02-09-26 Historic Preservation Commission Packet

HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION AGENDA Menomonie City Hall 800 Wilson Avenue Garden Level, Room 58 5:00pm Monday – February 9, 2026 Page 1 of 1 1. Roll Call 2. Approval of Minutes for January 12, 2026 3. Public Comments (agenda items only). 4. New Business a) Introduction to Murals in Menomonie P roject ( Various Locations ) – discussion only (no action). b) Approved Color Palettes – discussion and possible action. 5. Confirm Next Meeting Date – March 9, 2026 @ 5:00 pm 6. Adjourn “PUBLIC ACCESS” NOTE: Upon reasonable notice, efforts will be made to accommodate the needs of individuals with disabilities. For additional information or to request the service, contact the City Clerk or the City Administrator at 715-232-2221. HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES Chairman Ryland Erdman called the Historic Preservation Commission to order on January 12, 2026 at 5:00 pm in City Hall in Garden Level Room 58. Members present were Ryland Erdman, Melissa Kneeland, John Sobota, Joshua Kohnke, Carl Rudenborg, and Sylvia Gengenbach. Tim Dotseth was absent. Also present were Dave Kowieski, Becca Schoenborn, David Schofield, Robb Jensen, and John Goetz. Approval of Minutes: Motion to approve the minutes of the December 8, 2025 meeting by Kneeland, seconded by Gengenbach. Motion carried unanimously on a voice vote. Public Comments: none. Introduction to LumberJax Bakehouse and Café Project at 230 Main Street: Jensen and Goetz introduced themselves and their proposed project in the former Mood Boutique/Coffins Department Store. They discovered that an opera house previously stood upon the property. They plan to replace the storefront windows and doors. They plan to install new doors in line with the storefront and construct a new interior entry vestibule. They plan to repair the existing kneewall, pilasters, and parapet. They plan to repair the existing east wall (previously shared with 244 Main Street) and waterproof it with some sort of exterior scratchcoat. They plan to install new signage. Schofield asked if the exact location of the eastern property line had been surveyed, to which Jenson said it had not. Kohnke asked if they had discussions with the owner of the former Gin Mill about repairs to the west pilaster, to which Jenson indicated they had not. Kneeland noted that their effort to repair the existing building is appreciated. Erdman noted that he would like to see the reeded glass kept if possible but understood if it wasn’t feasible. Schofield asked how they planned to repair the kneewall, to which Jenson indicated that they would like to remove the steel and repair the brick or replace with cedar. Kohnke suggested that they include a justification for the front door modifications in their application. Kohnke suggested that they investigate how to cap the parapet. Kowieski noted that the City has an approved color palette. Goetz indicated that they had been in contact with Ray French and others about possible grants. Jenson and Goetz indicated that they would be working with their designers and would submit a Certificate of Appropriateness application in the near future. No action taken. Preliminary Draft of Guide Book for Applications for Certificate of Appropriateness: Kneeland presented the draft that she had prepared with Chris Johnson. Schofield indicated that Cedar Corp can update the Historic District Map. Gengenbach suggested eliminating acronyms, such as “COA” and simply spelling out “Certificate of Appropriateness”. Rudenborg suggested updating the spelling of “color”. Kneeland noted that the “Discover Dunn County” app includes historical photos that may be of assistance to potential applicants. Schofield noted that avaialble grant programs frequently change and it may be better to provide a contact that can assist with grant identification but not the current grant programs. Kneeland indicated that she would continue to work with Chris Johnson. No action taken. Next regular scheduled Historic Preservation Commission meeting will be held on Monday February, 2026 at 5:00pm at City Hall, Room 58. Adjourn: Motion to adjourn by Kohnke, seconded by Rudenborg. Motion carried unanimously on a voice vote. Minutes prepared by David Schofield, Director of Public Works MEMORANDUM David Schofield, Director of Public Works dschofield@menomonie-wi.gov 715-232-2221 Ext.1020 1 TO: Chairperson Erdman and Historic Preservation Commission FROM: David Schofield, Director of Public Works SUBJECT: Staff Comments DATE: February 9, 2029 Historical Preservation Commission Meeting Agenda Item #2 - January 12, 2026 Minutes Please find attached the proposed minutes for the January 12, 2026 Historical Preservation Commission Meeting. If the Commission concurs, the appropriate motion would be Approve the January 12, 2026 Meeting Minutes (simple majority). Agenda Item #4A - Introduction to Murals in Menomonie Project Please find attached preliminary materials from Murals In Menomonie for their proposed murals. The murals would be painted directly on the wall of the building, or painted on panels that would be affixed to the building. The following proposed murals are located within the Historic District: • 616 3rd Street East • 400 4th Street East • 438 Main Street East I felt it prudent to invite Murals in Menomonie to introduce their proposed murals to the Historic Preservation Commission prior to submitting formal Certificate of Appropriateness applications so that the Commission could provide input on what exactly it would like to see in the applications. For example, is the description of the topic of the mural sufficient or would a mockup of the mural be preferred? Are exact colors to be used on the mural required? Murals in Menomonie will take feedback provided at this meeting and prepare their formal Certificate of Appropriateness applications for consideration at either the March or April meeting. No action is required on this topic at this time. MEMORANDUM David Schofield, Director of Public Works dschofield@menomonie-wi.gov 715-232-2221 Ext.1020 2 Agenda Item #4B – Approved Color Palettes The topic of approved color palettes has come up several times recently. Chris Johnson was kind enough to review minutes from meetings dating back to 1999. From this review, it appears that there are at least six (6) color palettes that have been approved, most recently in 2017. Unfortunately, the Commission records do not include copies of all of these approved color palettes. Some of the companies listed have gone out of business. It is my opinion that the Historic Preservation Commission should consider approving a single color palette, for which we have a physical copy in our possession. I would suggest the Benjamin Moore Historic Collection which is one of the previously approved color palettes. Other paint providers can match color samples. If the Commission concurs, the appropriate motion would be Approve the Benjamin Moore Historic Collection Color Palette for use in the Historic District and rescind all previous color palette approvals (simple majority). This motion would not impact previously approved Certificates of Appropriateness which listed specific colors. 7th Street East Closed from Wilson Avenue E. to 9th Avenue E. for Food Trucks and Artist Parking/Supplies Temporary Stands for Painting Panels (Typ.). Orientation to minimize conflict with view of bandshell. Exact number, size and location TBD. MURALS IN MENOMONIE SPECIAL EVENT WILSON PARK JUNE 24-28, 2026 N Kids & Community Tent Access to Private Property to be coordinated by Murals In Menomonie MURALS IN MENOMONIE SPECIAL EVENT 502 2ND STREET W. JUNE 24-28, 2026 Proposed Mural Topic: Ludington Guard Band N 6TH AVENUE WEST 5 Lot 7 Parking Stalls to be closed MURALS IN MENOMONIE SPECIAL EVENT 516 BROADWAY ST. S. JUNE 24-28, 2026 Proposed Panel Mural Topic: Menomonie Blue Caps Baseball BROADWAY ST. SOUTH N MURALS IN MENOMONIE SPECIAL EVENT 521 2ND STREET E. JUNE 24-28, 2026 Proposed Panel Mural Topic: Anderson Cigar Company 6TH AVENUE EAST N Access to Private Property to be coordinated by Murals In Menomonie *PENDING* 2 On-Street Parking Stalls to be closed MURALS IN MENOMONIE SPECIAL EVENT 617 BROADWAY ST. S. JUNE 24-28, 2026 Existing Sign Proposed to be Refreshed BROADWAY ST. SOUTH N Access to Private Property to be coordinated by Murals In Menomonie MURALS IN MENOMONIE SPECIAL EVENT 712 BROADWAY ST. S. JUNE 24-28, 2026 Proposed Mural Topic: University of Wisconsin-Stout N Access to Private Property to be coordinated by Murals In Menomonie 1 On-Street Parking Stall to be closed MURALS IN MENOMONIE SPECIAL EVENT 616 3RD STREET E. JUNE 24-28, 2026 Proposed Mural Topic: Charles Sanna 3RD STREET EAST N 4 On-Street Parking Stalls to be closed MURALS IN MENOMONIE SPECIAL EVENT 400 MAIN STREET E. JUNE 24-28, 2026 Proposed Panel Mural Topic: Lumberjacks 4TH STREET EAST N MURALS IN MENOMONIE SPECIAL EVENT 710 4TH STREET E. JUNE 24-28, 2026 Proposed Mural Topic: TBD 4TH STREET EAST N Access to Private Property to be coordinated by Murals In Menomonie *PENDING* MURALS IN MENOMONIE SPECIAL EVENT 710 4TH STREET E. JUNE 24-28, 2026 Proposed Mural Topic: Bolo Country Inn 4TH STREET EAST N Access to Private Property to be coordinated by Murals In Menomonie *PENDING* MURALS IN MENOMONIE SPECIAL EVENT 438 MAIN STREET E. JUNE 24-28, 2026 Proposed Mural Topic: Kraft State Bank Robbery 5TH STREET EAST (VACATED) N Access to Private Property to be coordinated by Murals In Menomonie MURALS IN MENOMONIE SPECIAL EVENT 614 MAIN STREET E. JUNE 24-28, 2026 Proposed Mural Topic: Wild Rice, Bricks and Lumber MAIN STREET EAST N Access to Private Property to be coordinated by Murals In Menomonie MURALS IN MENOMONIE SPECIAL EVENT 709 MAIN STREET E. JUNE 24-28, 2026 Proposed Mural Topic: Harry Miller Golden Submarine Race Car MAIN STREET EAST N Access to Private Property to be coordinated by Murals In Menomonie MURALS IN MENOMONIE SPECIAL EVENT DUNN COUNTY FAIRGROUNDS JUNE 24-28, 2026 Proposed Mural Topic: Dunn County Fair 17TH STREET EAST N Access to Private Property to be coordinated by Murals In Menomonie MURALS IN MENOMONIE SPECIAL EVENT DUNN COUNTY FAIRGROUNDS JUNE 24-28, 2026 Proposed Panel Mural Topic: TBD N Access to Private Property to be coordinated by Murals In Menomonie *PENDING* David Schofield <dschofield@menomonie-wi.gov> HPC Approved Paint Palettes Chris Johnson <cjohnson@menomonie-wi.gov> Fri, Jan 30, 2026 at 10:54 AM To: David Schofield <dschofield@menomonie-wi.gov> Hello David, Having looked into the past minutes from HPC going back to 1999 I was able to find a few approved paint palettes from the past, a missing list, as well as now an open ended question from Kim as I asked Ben to reach out to her for me with this question. The currently approved colours that I have on record are as follows; Pittsburgh Paints - Historic Interior and Exterior, Pittsburgh Paints - Exterior Color Statements (See above), Mautz Paint - Historic Colors of America Collection (see below image and further explanation), *Mautz was subsumed into Sherwin-Williams and they claim to still sell Mautz paints so their Historic Collection may include some of these colours* Ace - Historic, T. J. Ronan, Also approved was "Stout Blue", and the Benjamin Moore Historic Collection. It would appear as if the Commission also approved the conditional use of other paints at the digression of the Commission on a case by case basis. (See attached minutes from April 1999). I also found reference to a list of additional approved colours from Feb 2017, with the helpful phrase "see attached" to which I could find no attachment. I have also attached the minutes from that meeting as well. Lastly I had Ben reach out to Kim Gerth on my behalf with this question, and she pointed me back to the Benjamin Moore Colour Pallet Fan as well as mentioned that she thought the Commission approved the use of any colour pallet with the word "Historic" in it, but to that end I was able to find no such motion. I also reached out to Melissa Kneeland to see if she had any insight on the matter, but have yet to receive a response. Hope that helps! Let me know if you have further questions in this regard. Cheers, Chris Johnson Deputy Clerk 800 Wilson Ave Menomonie, WI 54751 715.232.2221 Ext: 1016 2 attachments HPC Minutes 4.1999.pdf 68K HPCommMinutesFebruary2017.docx 17K Historic Preservation Commission MinutesThe Historic Preservation Commission held its February meeting on February 13, 2017 at 5:00 p.m. at City Hall. Members present: Ryland Erdman, Tim Dotseth, Peggy Terry and Josh Risler. Also present: Darrek Orwig (Main Street of Menomonie), Kim Gerth (City of Menomonie) The minutes from the January 9, 2017 meeting of the Historic Preservation Commission were approved as presented. (Ryland Erdman motion, Josh Risler 2nd and all in favor) Public Comments: There were no public comments. Old Business: Darrek Orwig will keep the commission updated as to the progress of the Certified Local Government (CLG) sub-grant for an Architectural and Historical Intensive Survey of the City of Menomonie. Historic Plaques: Monte Burstad has the only plaque installed, although two other property owners have planned to purchase plaques. Training for Historic Preservation Commission will be February 28, 2017 from 3pm to 5pm. Commission members and City Staff will be invited. Review of Certificate of Appropriateness: There were (2) Certificate of Appropriateness/Sign Approvals submitted. One was for Menomonie Visitors Center at 342 Main Street. The Commission approved the Certificate of Appropriateness/Sign Approval for the wall sign on the East wall. See Attached.The second was for Triangle Antiques at 333 Main Street. The Commission approved the Certificate of Appropriateness/Sign Approval for painting trim on the Main St and Crescent Street facades. Paint color will be an approved color; Benjamin Moore’s Georgian Brick HC-50. See attached. Darrek Orwig compiled a list of new colors for addition to the Historic color pallet. Ryland Erdman made a motion to accept; Tim Dotseth 2nd; all in favor. National Preservation Day is May 18, 2017. Historic Commission may partner with Main Street and offer “walking tours” to the public. Ryland Erdman made a Motion to adjourn; Peggy Terry 2nd ; all in favor. The next Historic Preservation Commission meeting will be held on March 13, 2017 at City Hall at 5:00 p.m.