RecordWell Data

Plymouth Cafe

2211 EASTERN AVE, Plymouth, WI 53073 · Sheboygan County

29cited violations
11serious tier
7inspections

Establishment

Type
Restaurant (retail food serving meals) (Retail Food - Serving Meals)
Inspected by
Sheboygan County Health & Human Services
License / ID
NBOZ-CM9JX7
Status
Permitted
Phone
(920) 375-6664
Official record
Sheboygan County Health & Human Services inspection reports

Other public records for this business

Year by year

YearInspectionsViolationsSerious
2026153
20252106
2024172
2023370

Inspections

  1. Sep 2, 2026 Routine · 3 priority, 1 priority foundation, 1 core, 1 repeat
    • Serious Priority Corrected on site

      COOLING - 6-HOUR COOLING PARAMETER

      Sauted onions were observed in the Avantco 1 door cooler at 50F this item was prepped and sauted yesterday then placed in this unit. The item had not been used since.

      Correction: ACTION TAKEN ON SITE: Item was discarded FUTURE ACTION REQUIRED: Assure that all food is properly cooled in the following parameters: cooled from 135°F to 70°F within 2 hours and from 70°F to 41°F within 4 hours for a total 6 hour cooling period. Utilizing the walk in cooler instead of the prep cooler and shallow pans.

      Code 3-501.14 (A)

    • Serious Priority

      PLUMBING - BACKFLOW PREVENTION - AIR GAP

      No air gap provided on food prep sink.

      Correction: Provide an air gap on water supply side to protect water supply.

      Code 5-202.13

    • Serious Priority Corrected on site

      TOXIC SUBSTANCES - IDENTIFYING INFORMATION, PROMINENCE - ORIGINAL CONTAINER

      Pure bleach above the 3 compartment sink does not label.

      Correction: ACTION TAKEN ONSITE: Label was provided on this spray bottle FUTURE ACTION REQUIRED: assure that all chemicals are properly labeled

      Code 7-101.11

    • Not serious Priority Foundation Repeat

      CONSUMER ADVISORY - DISCLOSURE STATEMENT

      Consumer advisory is missing the disclosure statement.

      Correction: Properly identifiy those food items that require a consumer advisory.

      Code 3-603.11 (B)

    • Not serious Core

      IN-USE UTENSILS, BETWEEN USE STORAGE

      Ice cream scoops were observed to be held in room temperature water near the ice cream chest freezer.

      Correction: Store in-use utensils in the food item with handle extended, on a clean surface, running dipper well or in a container of water greater than 135°F.

      Code 3-304.12

  2. Oct 16, 2025 Routine · 4 priority, 2 priority foundation, 1 repeat
    • Serious Priority Repeat

      NO BARE HAND CONTACT WITH RTE-FOODS

      Employee on cookline observed touching buns and french toast with bare/ungloved hands.

      Correction: Discard contaminated food; employees shall use single-use gloves or other suitable utensils when handling ready-to-eat foods.

      Code 3-301.11 (B)

    • Serious Priority Corrected on site

      DATE MARKING - DISPOSITION

      Tuna salad in Avantco 3 door cooler was observed to have a date mark of 10/8/25.

      Correction: Discard ready-to-eat Time/Temperature Control for Safety Food requiring a date mark that has exceeded the discard date or has not been provided with a date mark. CORRECTED ONSITE: This item was discarded.

      Code 3-501.18 (A)

    • Serious Priority

      TOXIC SUBSTANCES - IDENTIFYING INFORMATION, PROMINENCE - ORIGINAL CONTAINER

      Spray bottles with Signet Sanitizer inside do not contain a label.

      Correction: Provide labels for poisonous or toxic materials used in the food establishment.

      Code 7-101.11

    • Serious Priority

      TOXIC SUBSTANCES - SANITIZER CRITERIA

      Bleach/Chlorine sanitizer in sanitizer bucket on Avantco 3 door prep cooler in waitsaff area of the kitchen was reading at >200 ppm chlorine concentration.

      Correction: Chlorine concentrations need to be at 50-100 ppm for sanitizing food contact surfaces.

      Code 7-204.11

    • Not serious Priority Foundation

      CONSUMER ADVISORY - DISCLOSURE STATEMENT

      Consumer advisory is missing the disclosure statement or "*" on the burgers which are cooked ot order.

      Correction: Properly identifiy those food items that require a consumer advisory.

      Code 3-603.11 (B)

    • Not serious Priority Foundation

      WAREWASHING - SANITIZING SOLUTION - TESTING DEVICES

      A Quat test kit is not available for checking sanitizer concentrations for the spray bottles with Signet mixture (found near mop sink) inside.

      Correction: Provide a test kit or other device for measuring the concentration of sanitizing solutions.

      Code 4-302.14

  3. Jan 27, 2025 Routine · 2 priority, 2 priority foundation, 3 repeat
    • Serious Priority Corrected on site

      NO BARE HAND CONTACT WITH RTE-FOODS

      Employee observed handling ready-to eat foods with their bare hands. Waitstaff observed handling ready-to-eat toast with bare hands. When employees informed of the need to wear gloves when handling ready to eat products, staff was observed reusing gloves and handling order notepad with gloves.

      Correction: Gloves provided to waitstation for wait staff. Discard contaminated food; employees shall use single-use gloves or other suitable utensils when handling ready-to-eat foods. Wash hands and put on new gloves between tasks.

      Code 3-301.11 (B)

    • Serious Priority Repeat Corrected on site

      TCS FOOD - COLD HOLDING

      Milk in waitstation Avantco 2 door cooler is cold held at 44°F.

      Correction: TCS food items moved to different refrigeration unit. Maintain cold time/temperature control for safety food at or below 41°F. Discard unsafe food items.

      Code 3-501.16 (A) (2) AND (B)

    • Not serious Priority Foundation Repeat

      RTE/TCS FOOD - PROPER DATE MARKING

      Previously frozen food items such as lasagna not marked with date of thaw. Food items intended to be held longer than 24 hours such as sliced ham and cooked rice are not all datemarked.

      Correction: Adjust method or procedures so that all ready-to-eat time/temperature control for safety food, if required, are provided with date marking or an effective method of identifying when a food item has exceeded 7 days. Discard improperly date marked food or food that has past the 7 day shelf life.

      Code 3-501.17 (A)

    • Not serious Priority Foundation Repeat

      ADEQUATE EQUIPMENT FOR TEMPERATURE CONTROL

      Avantco 2 door cooler in waitstation is not sufficient in capacity to hold foods at 41 degrees.

      Correction: Adjust temperature control of cooler. Provide equipment in sufficient capacity to hold food at proper temperature. Reduce food inventory or provide additional approved equipment.

      Code 4-301.11

  4. Mar 13, 2024 Routine · 2 priority, 5 priority foundation
    • Serious Priority Corrected on site

      TCS FOOD - COLD HOLDING

      A. Products inside of Avantco 2 door cooler (milk, whiped cream) reading at 45/46°F. B. Shelled eggs on counter 4 cartons high reading at 77F. CORRECTED: A.TCS products removed from cooler and placed in a working cooler. B. Eggs placed in refrigeration. It was agreed that a smaller quantity would be left out during the rush.

      Correction: Maintain cold time/temperature control for safety food at or below 41°F. Discard unsafe food items.

      Code 3-501.16 (A) (2) AND (B)

    • Serious Priority Corrected on site

      TOXIC SUBSTANCES - SANITIZER CRITERIA

      Chlorine sanitizer used in sanitizing bucket was measured >200ppm. CORRECTED: Sanitizing bucket was diluted and was measuring at 100 ppm.

      Correction: Sanitizer shall meet the requirements under 40 CFR 180.940 or 40 CFR 180.2020.

      Code 7-204.11

    • Not serious Priority Foundation Corrected on site

      PROPER COOLING METHODS - CRITERIA

      Improper cooling methods are observed for chicken dumpling soup. The product was in a large 10 gallon bucket surrounded by little ice and was only going down by about 8F every 30 minutes. CORRECTED: Methods changed. Product was placed in the walk in freezer

      Correction: Adjust methods or procedures to facilitate cooling as described in 3-501.15.

      Code 3-501.15 (A)

    • Not serious Priority Foundation

      RTE/TCS FOOD - PROPER DATE MARKING

      Several items in different coolers did not contain a date mark. Including precooked meatloaf, ribs, cut ham, and other premade products.

      Correction: Adjust method or procedures so that all ready-to-eat time/temperature control for safety food, if required, are provided with date marking or an effective method of identifying when a food item has exceeded 7 days. Discard improperly date marked food or food that has past the 7 day shelf life.

      Code 3-501.17 (A)

    • Not serious Priority Foundation

      CONSUMER ADVISORY - DISCLOSURE STATEMENT

      Consumer advisory is missing the disclosure statement.

      Correction: Properly identifiy those food items that require a consumer advisory.

      Code 3-603.11 (B)

    • Not serious Priority Foundation

      ADEQUATE EQUIPMENT FOR TEMPERATURE CONTROL

      Avantco 2 door cooler in the waitress area is not cold holding properly. Ambient air temperature of the cooler is at 45F

      Correction: Provide equipment in sufficient capacity to hold food at proper temperature. Reduce food inventory or provide additional approved equipment.

      Code 4-301.11

    • Not serious Priority Foundation

      USING A HANDWASHING SINK - HANDWASHING ONLY

      Handwashing in the kitchen near the food prep sink was observed to have different sponges and other items inside of the well.

      Correction: Keep handwashing sink free of obstructions at all times to allow for frequent handwashing.

      Code 5-205.11 (B)

  5. Jul 26, 2023 Follow Up · 1 core, 1 repeat
    • Not serious Core Repeat

      CERTIFIED FOOD MANAGER – REQUIREMENT - FOOD ESTABLISHMENTS

      There is no approved or current certified food manager for this establishment.

      Correction: Provide an approved certified food protection manager in the food establishment within 30 days.

      Code 12-201.11 (A) (1)

  6. Jun 16, 2023 Follow Up · 1 core, 1 repeat
    • Not serious Core Repeat

      CERTIFIED FOOD MANAGER – REQUIREMENT - FOOD ESTABLISHMENTS

      There is no approved or current certified food manager for this establishment.

      Correction: Provide an approved certified food protection manager in the food establishment within 30 days.

      Code 12-201.11 (A) (1)

  7. Jun 7, 2023 Routine · 1 priority foundation, 4 core
    • Not serious Priority Foundation

      HANDWASHING SINKS, INSTALLATION - WATER TEMPERATURE

      Hot water temperature at the kitchen handwashing sinks is less than 85°F.

      Correction: Water temperature at a handwashing sink shall be at least 85°F and no more than 110°F. Competitive Plumbing services will be arriving first thing tomorrow morning to repair the faucet actuators. Recommend wrist paddles be installed to facilitate hands-free operation.

      Code 5-202.12 (A)

    • Not serious Core

      CERTIFIED FOOD MANAGER – REQUIREMENT - FOOD ESTABLISHMENTS

      There is no approved or current certified food manager for this establishment.

      Correction: Provide an approved certified food protection manager in the food establishment within 30 days.

      Code 12-201.11 (A) (1)

    • Not serious Core

      IN-USE UTENSILS, BETWEEN USE STORAGE

      Rice and sugar containers had bowls for dispensing product in lieu of scoups with handles.

      Correction: Store in-use utensils in the food item with handle extended, on a clean surface, running dipper well or in a container of water greater than 135°F.

      Code 3-304.12

    • Not serious Core Corrected on site

      PROPER COOLING METHODS - IN EQUIPMENT

      Chicken dumpling soup was noted in a 3-4 gallon container covered in the walk-in cooler. The food product was noted at 80 F and was cooked 2-3 hours previously.

      Correction: The soup product was re-cooked to 204 degrees F. Provide containers that facilitate heat transfer, such as metal pans, and loosely cover food items during the cooling process so that heat is allowed to escape. The use of ice baths, ice wands, and frequent stirring are methods that should be used for facilitating rapid cooling of larger volumes of food.

      Code 3-501.15 (B)

    • Not serious Core

      KITCHENWARE, TABLEWARE AND SINGLE-USE ARTICLES - HANDLED TO PREVENT CONTAMINATION

      It was observed that eating utensils are stored in the waitstaff area with the food/lip contact surfaces and handles intermingled where the food or lip contact surface could be contaminated.

      Correction: Store utensils in a manner to avoid contamination to the food and lip contact surface by arranging utensils in a container with the handles orientated uniformly.

      Code 4-904.11 (A)

Source: Sheboygan County Health & Human Services. History last read Oct 17, 2026. Violation text is the inspector's wording. “Serious” is the source's own top tier. About this data.