Mcfarland House Cafe
5923 EXCHANGE ST, Mcfarland, WI 53558 · Dane County
Establishment
- Type
- Restaurant (retail food serving meals) (Primarily Restaurant)
- Inspected by
- Public Health Madison & Dane County
- License / ID
- LICFDD-2015-00222
- Official record
- Public Health Madison & Dane County inspection reports
Year by year
| Year | Inspections | Violations | Serious |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 2 | 17 | 3 |
| 2025 | 2 | 9 | 1 |
| 2023 | 2 | 11 | 4 |
| 2022 | 1 | 2 | 1 |
| 2019 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| 2018 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| 2017 | 3 | 0 | 0 |
| 2016 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| 2015 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
Inspections
-
Sep 24, 2026 Re-Inspection · No Reinspection Required
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
AIR GAP - DRAIN - Not Corrected
The ice machine in the ice cream shop does not have a proper air gap between the drain and the sewage system.
Correction: Provide a 2 inch air gap to the open site floor drain.
Code WFC 5-402.11
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
FOOD - CONTAMINATION DURING PREP - Not Corrected
Food products in kitchen prep cooler are subject to potential contamination by window AC unit above prep cooler when upper unit is open. AC unit vent observed with significant dust and debris build up and is blowing over prep cooler. Additionally, no screen is present on exterior of window, allowing potential pest contamination on food products when upper unit is open.
Correction: Remove food from this location or provide alternate methods to protect unpackaged food from contamination.
Code WFC 3-305.14
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
PEST - DOOR/WINDOW OPEN - Not Corrected
Kitchen window that contains window AC unit is open to outside, and may allow the entry of insects or rodents into establishment.
Correction: Keep door or window closed, install a screen or an air curtain to prevent the entry of insects or rodents.
Code WFC 6-202.15
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
PHYSICAL FACILITY - UNNECESSARY ITEMS - Not Corrected
Old single service articles, beverage boxes, and other micellaenous items stored in the food establishment basement and are unnecessary to its operation or maintenance.
Correction: Remove items that are unnecessary to the operation and maintenance of the food establishment. This includes food service equipment that is no longer used or nonfunctional.
Code WFC 6-501.114
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
-
Sep 14, 2026 Routine Inspection · Reinspection Required
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
AIR GAP - DRAIN
The ice machine in the ice cream shop does not have a proper air gap between the drain and the sewage system.
Correction: Provide a 2 inch air gap to the open site floor drain.
Code WFC 5-402.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
BARE HAND CONTACT
Employee observed handling lettuce out of kitchen prep cooler to prepare a wrap with bare hands.
Correction: Employees shall use single-use gloves, utensils, bakery papers or other approved means when handling ready-to-eat foods.
Code WFC 3-301.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
CLEAN - FREQUENCY/CONTAMINATION
Kitchen knives and scoops used with TCS food not cleaned at least every 4 hours or after use.
Correction: Wash, rinse, then sanitize food contact surfaces used with TCS food at least every 4 hours and any time contamination has occurred.
Code WFC 4-602.11
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
CLEAN - NON-FOOD SURFACES
Interior & exterior of kitchen prep cooler are soiled with grime and food debris. Exterior of baking ingredient containers are soiled with grime and are not clean. Wire racks in kitchen have build up and are in need of cleaning. Interior of basement glass door upright cooler has grime build up on wire racks.
Correction: Clean and remove dust, dirt, food residue, and other debris from all non-food contact surfaces of equipment.
Code WFC 4-601.11(C)
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
DATE MARK - EXCEEDED OR MISSING
House made sauces including pesto sauce being cold held in kitchen prep cooler has a datemark that exceeds 7 days. Greek yogurt and spinach cold held in front of house two door glass cooler not date marked.
Correction: Discard foods that are not datemarked, improperly datemarked, or held past the alloted 7 days.
Code WFC 3-501.18
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
EQUIPMENT - NSF/ANSI
Homestyle cooler/freezer does not meet ANSI standards for food service equipment, or has not received prior approval from the Department.
Correction: Replace with only ANSI accredited equipment in the facility, or submit to the Department for evaluation and approval of non-ANSI equipment.
Code WFC 4-205.11
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
FOOD - CONTAMINATION DURING PREP
Food products in kitchen prep cooler are subject to potential contamination by window AC unit above prep cooler when upper unit is open. AC unit vent observed with significant dust and debris build up and is blowing over prep cooler. Additionally, no screen is present on exterior of window, allowing potential pest contamination on food products when upper unit is open.
Correction: Remove food from this location or provide alternate methods to protect unpackaged food from contamination.
Code WFC 3-305.14
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
PEST - DOOR/WINDOW OPEN
Kitchen window that contains window AC unit is open to outside, and may allow the entry of insects or rodents into establishment.
Correction: Keep door or window closed, install a screen or an air curtain to prevent the entry of insects or rodents.
Code WFC 6-202.15
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
PHYSICAL FACILITY - CLEAN
Floors & walls in the kitchen are in need of cleaning. Area underneath dish machine has heavy build up of grime and food debris.
Correction: Clean the physical facilities at a frequency necessary to keep them clean.
Code WFC 6-501.12
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
PHYSICAL FACILITY - UNNECESSARY ITEMS
Old single service articles, beverage boxes, and other micellaenous items stored in the food establishment basement and are unnecessary to its operation or maintenance.
Correction: Remove items that are unnecessary to the operation and maintenance of the food establishment. This includes food service equipment that is no longer used or nonfunctional.
Code WFC 6-501.114
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
SANITIZER TEST KIT
A test kit for the sanitizer quaternary ammonia is not available.
Correction: Provide a test kit or other device for accurately measuring the concentration of sanitizing solutions.
Code WFC 4-302.14
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
STORAGE - SEWER LINES
Several boxes of chips are stored under unprotected sewer lines in basement.
Correction: Relocate all foods away from the unprotected sewer lines or shield the sewer lines to prevent any leaks or drips onto the food items.
Code 3-305.12
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
STORAGE - IN-USE UTENSILS
Flour, sugar, and oat scoops in kitchen storage are immersed in product.
Correction: Store in-use utensils in the food item with handle extended, on a clean surface, running dipper well or in a container of water greater than 135 degrees F.
Code WFC 3-304.12
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
-
Aug 27, 2025 Re-Inspection · No Reinspection Required
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
PEST - OUTSIDE OPENINGS - Not Corrected
There are gaps at the two front doors and the back door of the building of the ice cream shop. There is a gap in the foundation in the basement near the ceiling where dry goods are stored in the basement.
Correction: Repair this hole or gap so that entrance by insects or rodents into the food establishment is prevented.
Code WFC 6-202.15
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
PEST - EVIDENCE - Not Corrected
Evidence of pests observed. There are mouse droppings on the floor under the fridge in the ice cream shop and along the wall behind the table with the syrups in the ice cream shop. There are also mouse droppings in the basement under shelves and mouse and possibly rat droppings in an unused sink in the basement.
Correction: Provide proper pest control by trapping or otherwise controlling pest problems on a continual basis. Clean up all pest activity evidence and increase control activities.
Code WFC 6-501.111
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
PEST - HARBORAGE - Not Corrected
The basement area contains stored decorations and other items which provide harborage conditions for insects and rodents.
Correction: Remove all unnecessary items from this area to minimize harborage for all pests.
Code WFC 6-501.111
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
-
Feb 26, 2025 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
CLEAN - NON-FOOD SURFACES
Non-food contact surfaces of a few items/areas are unclean: finger pulls of cooler doors, inside bottom of cooler, cooler door gasket, wire shelving in kitchen and a couple small areas of the kitchen walls have some accumulating grease.
Correction: Clean and remove dust, dirt, food residue, and other debris from all non-food contact surfaces of equipment.
Code WFC 4-601.11(C)
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
FOOD - CONTAMINATION DURING PREP
Food is subject to potential contamination by the practice of employee beverage being stored on the food prep table.
Correction: Remove food from this location or provide alternate methods to protect unpackaged food from contamination.
Code WFC 3-305.14
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
HANDSINK - SIGNAGE
No handwashing signage is provided at employee handwash sink behind the front counter.
Correction: Provide a sign or poster at each employee handwash sink that reminds food employees to wash their hands.
Code WFC 6-301.14
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
SANITIZER TEST KIT
A test kit for the chlorine sanitizer is expired (January 2025). Note - the quat test strips expire at the end of February.
Correction: Provide a test kit or other device for accurately measuring the concentration of sanitizing solutions.
Code WFC 4-302.14
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
THERMOMETER - MISSING INDICATING
Thermometer in Hoshizaki two door prep cooler is missing or not properly located.
Correction: Provide or reposition thermometer so that it is located in the warmest part of the refrigeration unit and is easily visible.
Code WFC 4-204.112
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
TIME AS A PUBLIC HEALTH CONTROL
Operator has no written plan for using time as a public health control (for self service creamer near the front register; in ktichen - shell eggs and cooked bacon).
Correction: Create a written plan for time as a public health control and maintain the documentation onsite.
Code WFC 3-501.19
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
-
Jun 12, 2023 Re-Inspection · No Reinspection Required
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
PHYSICAL FACILITY - DESIGN - Not Corrected
The design of the wall behind the food prep table is not cleanable. The wall is bare drywall.
Correction: Provide floors, walls, and ceilings that are designed, constructed, and installed so they are smooth and easily cleanable.
Code WFC 6-201.11
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
-
Jun 5, 2023 Routine Inspection · Reinspection Required
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
CLEAN - FOOD CONTACT SURFACES
The soda gun in the ice cream shop is visibly soiled.
Correction: Maintain food contact surfaces in a clean condition.
Code WFC 4-601.11(A)
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
LABEL - WORKING CONTAINER
Containers of sugar, flour, and waffle mix are not labeled.
Correction: Store all foods that are removed from their original packages in containers labeled with the common name of the food or ingredient.
Code WFC 3-302.12
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
LABEL - PACKAGED FOOD
Packaged cookie ice cream sandwiches in the ice cream shop are missing ingredient and allergen information.
Correction: Properly label packaged food items with: common name; an ingredient list, including all subingredients in descending order of predominance, including; a weight or count; the name and address of the manufacturer, packer, or distributor; allergen content disclosure.
Code WFC 3-602.11
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
LABEL - BULK FOOD
Ingredient and allergen information is unavailable for bulk bakery items at the coffee counter.
Correction: Provide ingredient and allergen information for bulk bakery items.
Code WFC 3-602.11
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
PHYSICAL FACILITY - DESIGN
The design of the wall behind the food prep table is not cleanable. The wall is bare drywall.
Correction: Provide floors, walls, and ceilings that are designed, constructed, and installed so they are smooth and easily cleanable.
Code WFC 6-201.11
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
SANITIZER TEST KIT
A test kit for the sanitizer quaternary ammonia is not available.
Correction: Provide a quat test kit for accurately measuring the concentration of sanitizing solutions.
Code WFC 4-302.14
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
STORAGE - IN-USE UTENSILS
In-use utensil improperly stored. The ice bucket in the ice cream shop is stored upright.
Correction: Store in-use utensils in the food item with handle extended, on a clean surface, running dipper well or in a container of water greater than 135 degrees F. Store the ice bucket inverted.
Code WFC 3-304.12
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
TEMPERATURE - COLD HOLDING
The short 1 door cooler is holding half and half at 48F and an opened container of almond milk at 50F
Correction: Maintain cold TCS foods at or below 41 degrees F.
Code WFC 3-501.16
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
TIME AS A PUBLIC HEALTH CONTROL
Operator has no written plan for using time as a public health control for the cream in the self-serve carafe.
Correction: Create a written plan for time as a public health control and maintain the documentation onsite.
Code WFC 3-501.19
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
TOXICS - USE CONDITIONS
Clean Quick quat sanitizer is not being used according to manufacturer`s use directions. The solution tested over 500 ppm and the effective concentration is 150-400 ppm active quat.
Correction: Change procedures and provide training to employees on proper use of toxic chemicals. Use toxic chemical according to manufacturer's use directions.
Code WFC 7-202.12
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
-
Apr 5, 2022 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
PHYSICAL FACILITY - DESIGN
The bare drywall behind food prep table and behind the one-door upright True freezer is not painted, and not cleanable.
Correction: Provide floors, walls, and ceilings that are designed, constructed, and installed so they are smooth and easily cleanable.
Code WFC 6-201.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
SANITIZATION - CHEMICAL
The sanitizer concentration for low temp dish machine is at 10 ppm.
Correction: Use test strips to measure proper sanitizer concentration and adjust the concentration accordingly. Provide training to employees on proper use and concentration of sanitizer.
Code WFC 4-501.114
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
-
Mar 4, 2019 Re-Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Feb 20, 2019 Routine Inspection · Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Feb 15, 2018 Re-Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Feb 6, 2018 Routine Inspection · Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Feb 13, 2017 Re-Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Feb 10, 2017 Re-Inspection · Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Jan 31, 2017 Routine Inspection · Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Mar 22, 2016 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Aug 31, 2015 Pre-inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
Source: Public Health Madison & Dane County. History last read Nov 2, 2026. Violation text is the inspector's wording. “Serious” is the source's own top tier. About this data.