Johnny's Italian Steakhouse
8390 MARKET ST, Middleton, WI 53562 · Dane County
Establishment
- Type
- Restaurant (retail food serving meals) (Primarily Restaurant)
- Inspected by
- Public Health Madison & Dane County
- License / ID
- 73576-81837
- Official record
- Public Health Madison & Dane County inspection reports
Year by year
| Year | Inspections | Violations | Serious |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 2 | 14 | 14 |
| 2023 | 1 | 5 | 2 |
| 2022 | 2 | 12 | 8 |
| 2019 | 3 | 0 | 0 |
| 2018 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| 2017 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| 2016 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| 2015 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| 2014 | 4 | 0 | 0 |
| 2013 | 4 | 0 | 0 |
| 2012 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
Inspections
-
Oct 20, 2026 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
CLEAN - FOOD CONTACT SURFACES
Slicer and slicer wheels are visibly soiled. Metal stem thermometer was not cleaned prior to inserting into food.
Correction: Maintain food contact surfaces in a clean condition.
Code WFC 4-601.11(A)
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
CROSS CONTAMINATION
Food is not protected from cross contamination. Raw sausage stored over raw scallops in grill cooler drawers.
Correction: During storage, preparation, holding, and display, keep raw animal foods separate from each other and from ready-to-eat foods so that cross contamination is prevented. Unwashed fruits and vegetables have to be separated from raw animal ready-to-eat foods and washed produce. If there is question of possible contamination, discard ready-to-eat foods.
Code WFC 3-302.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
EATING, DRINKING, OR TOBACCO
Opened employee beverage container in the kitchen area.
Correction: Provide an employee break room or designate an area away from food preparation for eating and tobacco use. Beverage containers must be closed and handled to prevent contamination of employee's hands, container, and exposed food, clean utensils, clean linens, and unwrapped single use items.
Code WFC 2-401.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
TEMPERATURE - COOKING
Salmon was cooked to a temperature of 92F.
Correction: Cook raw animal foods to the appropriate time and temperature. Adjust procedures and methods.
Code WFC 3-401.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
TEMPERATURE - COLD HOLDING
In house prepared dressing at 45F in prep cooler.
Correction: Maintain cold TCS foods at or below 41 degrees F.
Code WFC 3-501.16
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
TOXICS - LABELING
Sanitizer bucket is unlabeled.
Correction: Provide labels for toxic items used in the food establishment.
Code WFC 7-101.11; 7-102.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
TOXICS - SEPARATION
Chemical spray bottle stored above ice machine.
Correction: Rearrange area so that toxic materials are stored below or away from food, equipment and single service items.
Code WFC 7-201.11; 7-301.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
-
Jan 13, 2026 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
CLEAN - FOOD CONTACT SURFACES
Meat slicer is visibly soiled.
Correction: Maintain food contact surfaces in a clean condition.
Code WFC 4-601.11(A)
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
DATE MARK - EXCEEDED OR MISSING
Bolognese, opened milk, and cream sauce being cold held is not datemarked or has a datemark that exceeds 7 days.
Correction: Discard foods that are not datemarked, improperly datemarked, or held past the allotted 7 days.
Code WFC 3-501.18
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
EATING, DRINKING, OR TOBACCO
Employee was observed eating in the kitchen area.
Correction: Provide an employee break room or designate an area away from food preparation for eating and tobacco use. Beverage containers must be closed and handled to prevent contamination of employee's hands, container, and exposed food, clean utensils, clean linens, and unwrapped single use items.
Code WFC 2-401.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
HANDSINK - ACCESSIBLE/CONVENIENT
Bar hand sink is not stocked with soap and towels.
Correction: Provide an accessible hand sink properly stocked to facilitate handwashing by food employees.
Code WFC 5-203.11; 5-204.11; 5-205.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
PARASITE PREVENTION/DESTRUCTION
There are no records for parasite prevention or destruction in raw or partially cooked fish (halibut) used in a ready-to-eat form.
Correction: Provide records to prove that fish has been frozen to destroy parasites or fish has been aquacultured to prevent parasite growth. Fish may not be served in a raw ready-to-eat form and shall be cooked to proper temperature before service or discarded.
Code WFC 3-402.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
TEMPERATURE - COLD HOLDING
(1) Melted butter and cooked prosciutto on counter at room temperature. (2) Sour cream in prep cooler at 54F (less than 2 hours)
Correction: Maintain cold TCS foods at or below 41 degrees F.
Code WFC 3-501.16
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
TOXICS - SEPARATION
Butane torch is stored with food on rack.
Correction: Rearrange area so that toxic materials are stored below or away from food, equipment and single service items.
Code WFC 7-201.11; 7-301.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
-
Dec 11, 2023 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
AIR GAP - DRAIN
The soda ice bin does not have a proper air gap between the drain and the sewage system.
Correction: Provide a 2 inch air gap to the open site floor drain.
Code WFC 5-402.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
CONSUMER ADVISORY
Consumer advisory on menu is missing petite tenderloin from holiday menu.
Correction: Provide a consumer advisory with required disclosure and reminder components for animal foods served in a raw or undercooked condition.
Code WFC 3-603.11
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
HANDSINK - SIGNAGE
No handwashing signage is provided at restroom hand sinks.
Correction: Provide a sign or poster at each employee hand wash sink that reminds food employees to wash their hands.
Code WFC 6-301.14
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
STORAGE - IN-USE UTENSILS
In-use utensil stored in sanitizer bucket.
Correction: Store in-use utensils in the food item with handle extended, on a clean surface, running dipper well or in a container of water greater than 135 degrees F.
Code WFC 3-304.12
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
TOXICS - SEPARATION
Soap in squirt bottle unlabeled. Chemical spray bottle unlabeled.
Correction: Rearrange area so that toxic materials are stored below or away from food, equipment and single service items.
Code WFC 7-201.11; 7-301.11
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
-
Apr 28, 2022 Re-Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Apr 18, 2022 Routine Inspection · Reinspection Required
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
CLEAN - FOOD CONTACT SURFACES
Slicer is dirty as is interior contraption in ice machine.
Correction: Maintain food contact surfaces in a clean condition.
Code WFC 4-601.11(A)
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
CONSUMER ADVISORY
Consumer advisory on menu is missing disclosure mark next to steak risotto and beef wellington.
Correction: Provide a consumer advisory with required disclosure and reminder components for animal foods served in a raw or undercooked condition.
Code WFC 3-603.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
CROSS CONTAMINATION
Raw meatballs stored on top of cooked noodles and raw seafood in walk in cooler.
Correction: During storage, preparation, holding, and display, keep raw animal foods separate from each other and from ready-to-eat foods so that cross contamination is prevented. Unwashed fruits and vegetables have to be separated from raw animal ready-to-eat foods and washed produce. If there is question of possible contamination, discard ready-to-eat foods.
Code WFC 3-302.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
DATE MARK - EXCEEDED OR MISSING
Cheesecake mix datemarked 4/10, remoulade marked 4/6, and red sauce datemarked 4/10 in walk in cooler still in use. Ham incorrectly datemarked 4/5 in prep cooler, actual date was 4/15
Correction: Discard foods that are not datemarked, improperly datemarked, or held past the alloted 7 days.
Code WFC 3-501.18
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
FOOD - UNCOVERED
Multiple foods in the walk in cooler were observed to be unwrapped or uncovered.
Correction: All foods that are not part of a cooling process shall be covered at all times to prevent cross-contamination. If cross-contamination is evident, discard suspected foods
Code WFC 3-302.11(4)
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
FOOD - CONTAMINATION
Pans of seasoned uncooked potatoes are stored on top of each without barrier.
Correction: Change methods or procedures to protect foods from contamination.
Code WFC 3-307.11
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
GOOD REPAIR - PLUMBING
Faucet for sanitized basin of three compartment sink is dripping also, operator states that hot water can only be turned on with valve under the sink.
Correction: Repair the plumbing system to conform to the State Uniform Plumbing Code.
Code WFC 5-205.15
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
HANDSINK - NON-HAND FAUCETS
The handsink located in the bar of this facility is not equipped with a non-hand operated faucet. Faucet handle for hot water is blocked from opearting by dishwashing unit.
Correction: Provide a functional non-hand operated faucet at all hand sinks in the facility. Alternatively, switch hand sink and dump sink in bar as current dump sink has full clearance to be used as non hand operated.
Code WFC 5-202.12(C)
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
HANDSINK - ACCESSIBLE/CONVENIENT
Handsink in bar is not accessible; access blocked by dump tray and glassware in tray plus sink is not supplied with soap or towels. While bar was not open at time of inspection, staff were present in location polishing glassware.
Correction: Provide an accessible handsink to facilitate handwashing by food employees.
Code WFC 5-203.11; 5-204.11; 5-205.11; WFC 6-301.12; WFC 6-301.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
SANITIZATION - CHEMICAL
The sanitizer concentration for chlorine in the dishmachine is at 0ppm. Quat in kitchen three compartment sink at 0-150ppm. Wiping cloth sanitizer buket at 0ppm.
Correction: Use test strips to measure proper sanitizer concentration and adjust the concentration accordingly. Provide training to employees on proper use and concentration of sanitizer.
Code WFC 4-501.114
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
TEMPERATURE - HOT HOLDING
Tabletop steam well had marinara at 123F
Correction: Maintain hot TCS foods at or above 135 degrees F.
Code WFC 3-501.16
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
TEMPERATURE - COLD HOLDING
Beer batter used with raw seafood help on countertop at 55F. Housemade ranch dressing help on ice at 60F. In soup small prep cooler cooked noodles kept on lid of container at 55F
Correction: Maintain cold TCS foods at or below 41 degrees F.
Code WFC 3-501.16
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
-
Jun 14, 2019 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Jun 14, 2019 Re-Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Jun 14, 2019 Re-Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Mar 16, 2018 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
May 22, 2017 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Jun 1, 2016 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Jun 1, 2015 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Jun 5, 2014 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
May 12, 2014 Re-Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Feb 13, 2014 Re-Inspection · Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Feb 6, 2014 Routine Inspection · Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Jul 9, 2013 Re-Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Jun 26, 2013 Re-Inspection · Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Jun 24, 2013 Re-Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Jun 19, 2013 Routine Inspection · Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Feb 27, 2012 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
Source: Public Health Madison & Dane County. History last read Nov 2, 2026. Violation text is the inspector's wording. “Serious” is the source's own top tier. About this data.