Salvatore's Tomato Pies
5511 MONONA DR, Monona, WI 53716 · Dane County
Establishment
- Type
- Restaurant (retail food serving meals) (Primarily Restaurant)
- Inspected by
- Public Health Madison & Dane County
- License / ID
- LICFDD-2020-00118
- Official record
- Public Health Madison & Dane County inspection reports
Year by year
| Year | Inspections | Violations | Serious |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 2 | 13 | 7 |
| 2025 | 2 | 14 | 8 |
| 2024 | 1 | 5 | 2 |
| 2023 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| 2020 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
Inspections
-
Oct 13, 2026 Re-Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Aug 14, 2026 Routine Inspection · Reinspection Required
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
CERTIFIED FOOD MANAGER
There is no certified food protection manager for the establishment.
Correction: Provide a certified food protection manager.
Code WFC 12-201.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Repeat
DATE MARK - EXCEEDED OR MISSING
Continental box cooler milk, True table top cooler Dynamite sauce, cooked mushrooms being cold held is not datemarked.or has a datemark. Walk in cooler Caesar dressing 8/07, Vegan sausage 7/26 exceed 7 days
Correction: Discard foods that are not datemarked, improperly datemarked, or held past the alloted 7 days.
Code WFC 3-501.18
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
EATING, DRINKING, OR TOBACCO
Employee was observed with beverage container in the kitchen food preparation area.
Correction: Provide an employee break room or designate an area away from food preparation for eating and tobacco use. Beverage containers must be closed and handled to prevent contamination of employee's hands, container, and exposed food, clean utensils, clean linens, and unwrapped single use items.
Code WFC 2-401.11
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
FOOD- THAWING ROP FISH
Frozen salmon in reduced oxygen packaging (ROP) is being improperly thawed.
Correction: Remove fish from ROP prior to thawing.
Code WFC 3-501.13(E)
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
FOOD - THAWING
Raw beef, and pasta improperly thawed at ambient air temperature in food preparation sink.
Correction: Adjust procedures or methods to properly thaw foods under refrigeration, submerged in running water, or in a microwave as part of a continuous cooking process.
Code WFC 3-501.13
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Repeat
LABEL - WORKING CONTAINER
Seasoning, flour, oils is stored in unlabeled container.
Correction: Store all foods that are removed from their original packages in containers labeled with the common name of the food or ingredient.
Code WFC 3-302.12
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
SANITIZER TEST KIT
A test kit for the sanitizer chlorine is not available in the bar.
Correction: Provide a test kit or other device for accurately measuring the concentration of sanitizing solutions.
Code WFC 4-302.14
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
TEMPERATURE - REHEATING
Meat balls was reheated to a temperature of 125-129 degree F.
Correction: Adjust procedures and methods to properly reheat food intended for hot holding to at least 165 degrees F within 2 hours.
Code WFC 3-403.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
TEMPERATURE - COLD HOLDING
Nduga sauce 48 F, pasta 46F, salmon 48F being held cool in grill top drawer cooler.
Correction: Maintain cold TCS foods at or below 41 degrees F.
Code WFC 3-501.16
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
THERMOMETER - MISSING INDICATING
Thermometer in Continental box cooler, and True table top cooler is missing or not properly located.
Correction: Provide or reposition thermometer so that it is located in the warmest part of the refrigeration unit and is easily visible.
Code WFC 4-204.112
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
TOXICS - PESTICIDE USE
Pesticide Home Defense used in food establishment is not being used in accordance with federal regulations. It is unapproved for food establishments.
Correction: Use and apply pesticides in accordance with federal regulations.
Code WFC 7-206.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
TOXICS - LABELING
Spray bottle of chlorine sanitizer is unlabeled.
Correction: Provide labels for toxic items used in the food establishment.
Code WFC 7-101.11; 7-102.11
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
WIPING CLOTHS
Wet wiping cloths improperly stored on table top.
Correction: Store wiping cloths in a container of sanitizer solution when not in use. Wet cloths used with raw animal foods shall be kept in a separate sanitizing solution.
Code WFC 3-304.14
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
-
Jul 10, 2025 Re-Inspection · No Reinspection Required
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Repeat
Corrected on site
SANITIZER TEST KIT - Not Corrected
A test kit for the sanitizer chlorine is not available in the bar.
Correction: Provide a test kit or other device for accurately measuring the concentration of sanitizing solutions.
Code WFC 4-302.14
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Repeat
Corrected on site
TOXICS - LABELING - Not Corrected
Spray bottle of chlorine sanitizer is unlabeled.
Correction: Provide labels for toxic items used in the food establishment.
Code WFC 7-101.11; 7-102.11
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Repeat
Corrected on site
-
Jun 13, 2025 Routine Inspection · Reinspection Required
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
AIR GAP - DRAIN
The ice bin in the bar does not have a proper air gap between the drain and the sewage system. It presently has a air break.
Correction: Provide a 2 inch air gap to the open site floor drain.
Code WFC 5-402.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
DATE MARK - EXCEEDED OR MISSING
Container of Pesto being held cold dated 6/05 that exceeds 7 days. Grill chicken in table top cooler is not datemark.
Correction: Discard foods that are not datemarked, improperly datemarked, or held past the alloted 7 days.
Code WFC 3-501.18
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
EMPLOYEE HEALTH REPORTING
Employees have not been informed they must report symptoms, lesions containing pus, diagnosis of foodborne illness, and situations of exposure to foodborne illness to the person in charge.
Correction: Person in charge shall inform or retrain food employees on required reporting of symptoms, lesions containing pus, diagnosis of foodborne illness and situations of exposure to foodborne illness.
Code WFC 2-201.11
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
FOOD - UNCOVERED
Grilled chicken in the Grill line table top cooler were observed to be unwrapped or uncovered.
Correction: All foods that are not part of a cooling process shall be covered at all times to prevent cross-contamination. If cross-contamination is evident, discard suspected foods
Code WFC 3-302.11(4)
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
HANDWASHING - DRYING
No single-use toweling or approved hand drying device available at handsink for hand drying at bar sink.
Correction: Provide single-use toweling or an approved hand drying device at handsink to facilitate proper handwashing.
Code WFC 6-301.12
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
LABEL - WORKING CONTAINER
Spices are stored in unlabeled container.
Correction: Store all foods that are removed from their original packages in containers labeled with the common name of the food or ingredient.
Code WFC 3-302.12
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
PERSON IN CHARGE - DUTIES
The Person in Charge (PIC) is not performing the following duties: Employee eating cheese curds in pizza make table food preparation area instead of designated area. Unawareness of common food allergens Unawareness of Reporting Foodborne illness to health department and having documentation onsite
Correction: The person in charge shall ensure or provide training so that employees are trained on common food allergens, employee illness health reporting, where to eat outside of food preparation area.
Code WFC 2-103.11
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
REFUSE - OUTSIDE RECEPTACLES
The covers for the outdoor waste receptacles are open.
Correction: Provide tight fitting lids, doors and covers for the receptacles and waste handling units used for refuse, recyclables and returnables.
Code WFC 5-501.15
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
SANITIZER TEST KIT
A test kit for the sanitizer chlorine is not available in the bar.
Correction: Provide a test kit or other device for accurately measuring the concentration of sanitizing solutions.
Code WFC 4-302.14
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
TEMPERATURE - COLD HOLDING
Garlic Parmesan cheese salad dressing in Continental table top cooler being cold held at 58 -54 degrees F, and Strawberry dressing as well as Goddess dressing 58F in top shelf of grill line table top cooler.
Correction: Maintain cold TCS foods at or below 41 degrees F.
Code WFC 3-501.16
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
TEMPERATURE - COOLING
Tomato sauce 60 F in walk-in cooler and Italian sausage 48-49 F in walk-in cooler after more than 24 hrs.
Correction: Rapidly cool cooked food from 135 degrees F to 41 degrees F or less within six hours, provided the food cools from 135 degrees F to 70 degrees F within two hours. TCS food prepared from ambient temperature ingredients shall be cooled within four hours to 41 degrees F or less.
Code WFC 3-501.14
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
TOXICS - LABELING
Spray bottle of window cleaner, and spray bottle of unknown red solution is unlabeled.
Correction: Provide labels for toxic items used in the food establishment.
Code WFC 7-101.11; 7-102.11
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
-
Feb 28, 2024 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
BACKFLOW PREVENTOR
Backflow preventer is above the two shut off valves on the faucet above the mop sink.
Correction: Provide a State of Wisconsin approved backflow prevention device.
Code WFC 5-202.14
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
DATE MARK - EXCEEDED OR MISSING
Cole Slaw sauce being cold held is datemarked 02/08 exceeds 7 days.
Correction: Discard foods that are not datemarked, improperly datemarked, or held past the alloted 7 days.
Code WFC 3-501.18
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
HANDSINK - SIGNAGE
No handwashing signage is provided at employee handwash sink at bar.
Correction: Provide a sign or poster at each employee handwash sink that reminds food employees to wash their hands.
Code WFC 6-301.14
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
SANITIZATION - FOOD SURFACES
Thermometer not being sanitized.
Correction: After cleaning, rinse and sanitize equipment and utensils.
Code WFC 4-702.11
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
SANITIZER TEST KIT
A test kit for the sanitizer chlorine is not available or is expired/damaged.
Correction: Provide a test kit or other device for accurately measuring the concentration of sanitizing solutions.
Code WFC 4-302.14
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
-
Mar 22, 2023 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
May 8, 2020 Pre-Inspection · Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
Source: Public Health Madison & Dane County. History last read Nov 3, 2026. Violation text is the inspector's wording. “Serious” is the source's own top tier. About this data.