Salvatore's Tomato Pies
121 E MAIN ST, Sun Prairie, WI 53590 · Dane County
Establishment
- Type
- Restaurant (retail food serving meals) (Primarily Restaurant)
- Inspected by
- Public Health Madison & Dane County
- License / ID
- LICFDD-2016-00350
- Official record
- Public Health Madison & Dane County inspection reports
Year by year
| Year | Inspections | Violations | Serious |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 1 | 4 | 2 |
| 2025 | 2 | 6 | 4 |
| 2024 | 1 | 5 | 1 |
| 2022 | 1 | 5 | 4 |
| 2019 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| 2018 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| 2017 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| 2016 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
Inspections
-
Oct 2, 2026 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
CONSUMER ADVISORY
Consumer advisory on menu is missing asterisk for burgers that customers can order under cooked.
Correction: Provide a consumer advisory with required disclosure and reminder components for animal foods served in a raw or undercooked condition.
Code WFC 3-603.11
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
FOOD- THAWING ROP FISH
Frozen fish (salmon) in reduced oxygen packaging (ROP) is being improperly thawed under refrigeration in the drawer cooler without opening the ROP bag.
Correction: Remove fish from ROP prior to thawing.
Code WFC 3-501.13(E)
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
SANITIZATION - CHEMICAL
The sanitizer concentration for Chloine in the WareForce low temp dishwasher in the Bar is at 0 ppm.
Correction: Use test strips to measure proper sanitizer concentration and adjust the concentration accordingly. Provide training to employees on proper use and concentration of sanitizer.
Code WFC 4-501.114
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
SANITIZER TEST KIT
A test kit for the sanitizer (i.e. quaternary ammonia) is expired/damaged.
Correction: Provide a test kit or other device for accurately measuring the concentration of sanitizing solutions.
Code WFC 4-302.14
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
-
Jun 26, 2025 Re-Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Jun 17, 2025 Routine Inspection · Reinspection Required
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
CONSUMER ADVISORY
Consumer advisory on menu is missing disclosure asterisk (*), or another unique mark on menu items offered raw or undercooked.
Correction: Provide a consumer advisory with required disclosure and reminder components for animal foods served in a raw or undercooked condition.
Code WFC 3-603.11
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
HANDSINK - SIGNAGE
No handwashing signage is provided at employee handwash sink at the lower level and also one of the restrooms hand sink.
Correction: Provide a sign or poster at each employee handwash sink that reminds food employees to wash their hands.
Code WFC 6-301.14
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
HANDWASHING - SOAP
Soap not available at food employee handwash sink at the lower level prep area.
Correction: Provide hand soap at handsink to facilitate proper handwashing.
Code WFC 6-301.11
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
HANDWASHING - DRYING
No single-use toweling or approved hand drying device available at handsink for hand drying.
Correction: Provide single-use toweling or an approved hand drying device at handsink at the lower level prep area to facilitate proper handwashing.
Code WFC 6-301.12
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
LABEL - WORKING CONTAINER
Oil is stored in unlabeled container. 2. Semolina and sugar stored in unlabeled containers.
Correction: Store all foods that are removed from their original packages in containers labeled with the common name of the food or ingredient.
Code WFC 3-302.12
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
TEMPERATURE - COLD HOLDING
Different food items in prep coolers being cold held at above 41 degrees F. 1. Blue cheese 45 F in the top Atosa prep cooler. 2. Raw shrimps 45 F, Raw Patties 45 F in the drawer cooler under the grill for less than 2 hours. 3. Fresh mushrooms 49 F, Precooked sausage 50 F and Blue cheese 50 F in the top and mid rail of the Liquitec Pizza prep cooler for less than 2 hours.
Correction: Maintain cold TCS foods at or below 41 degrees F.
Code WFC 3-501.16
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
-
Mar 26, 2024 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
CLEANABLE - NONFOOD SURFACE
Floor in the Food walk-in cooler at the lower level that is exposed to splash, spillage, or other food soiling is no longer easily cleanable.
Correction: Provide non-food contact surfaces that are constructed of corrosion resistant, nonabsorbent, and smooth materials.
Code WFC 4-101.19
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
HANDSINK - SIGNAGE
No handwashing signage is provided at employee handwash sink in the Kitchen on the cookline and in the dish washing area.
Correction: Provide a sign or poster at each employee handwash sink that reminds food employees to wash their hands.
Code WFC 6-301.14
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
LABEL - WORKING CONTAINER
Semolina is stored in unlabeled container in the basement.
Correction: Store all foods that are removed from their original packages in containers labeled with the common name of the food or ingredient.
Code WFC 3-302.12
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
SANITIZER TEST KIT
A test kit for the sanitizer (i.e. chlorine) is not available or is expired/damaged.
Correction: Provide a test kit or other device for accurately measuring the concentration of sanitizing solutions.
Code WFC 4-302.14
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
TEMPERATURE - HOT HOLDING
Bacon bits in metal pan on the grill being hot held at 123 degrees F.
Correction: Maintain hot TCS foods at or above 135 degrees F.
Code WFC 3-501.16
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
-
Feb 25, 2022 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
DATE MARK - SYSTEM
A date marking system is not in place for ready-to-eat TCS foods removed from frozen to cooler.
Correction: Implement procedures so that all ready-to-eat TCS foods are date marked with a date not to exceed 7 days.
Code WFC 3-501.17
-
Not serious
Good Retail Practice
Corrected on site
HANDSINK - SIGNAGE
No handwashing signage is provided at employee handwash sink in basement and pizza make table area.
Correction: Provide a sign or poster at each employee handwash sink that reminds food employees to wash their hands.
Code WFC 6-301.14
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
SHELLSTOCK MAINTAINING IDENTIFICATION
Shellstock tags not keep in chronological order with last date of sale/ serving recorded.
Correction: Shellstock shall be held in original container until emptied and not commingled with other shellstock. Shellstock tags shall be held at food establishment for a minimum of 90 days after the shellstock container is emptied. Tags shall be kept in chronological order with last date of sale/serving recorded on tag. Discard shellstock where tags are not available.
Code WFC 3-202.18; 3-203.12
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
TEMPERATURE - HOT HOLDING
Cheese Sauce in steam table being hot held at 115 degrees F.
Correction: Maintain hot TCS foods at or above 135 degrees F.
Code WFC 3-501.16
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
TEMPERATURE - COLD HOLDING
Chop pork in pizza make table cooler being cold held at 54 degrees F.
Correction: Maintain cold TCS foods at or below 41 degrees F.
Code WFC 3-501.16
-
Serious
Priority (CDC risk factor)
Corrected on site
-
Oct 10, 2019 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Feb 27, 2018 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Feb 7, 2017 Routine Inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
-
Nov 21, 2016 Pre-inspection · No Reinspection Required
No violations cited.
Source: Public Health Madison & Dane County. History last read Nov 3, 2026. Violation text is the inspector's wording. “Serious” is the source's own top tier. About this data.