Mateo's Cafe And Restaurant
500 E WISCONSIN AVE, Appleton, WI 54911 · Outagamie County
Establishment
- Type
- Restaurant (retail food serving meals) (Retail Food - Serving Meals)
- Inspected by
- City of Appleton Health Department
- License / ID
- MROS-CE3LJR
- Status
- Permitted
- Phone
- (920) 209-2685
- Official record
- City of Appleton Health Department inspection reports
Year by year
| Year | Inspections | Violations | Serious |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 1 | 2 | 0 |
| 2025 | 1 | 3 | 1 |
| 2024 | 2 | 4 | 1 |
| 2023 | 1 | 7 | 2 |
Inspections
-
Apr 21, 2026 Routine · 1 priority foundation, 1 core
-
Not serious
Priority Foundation
Corrected on site
FOOD CONTACT SURFACES - SOILED
Inside surfaces of the ice maker is visibly soiled. Black mold accumulating on the inner surface of the machine where the ice falls out into the bin.
Correction: Maintain food contact surfaces in a clean condition. Clean and sanitize the inside of machine regularly to prevent dirt and mold build up.
Code 4-601.11 (A)
-
Not serious
Core
INSECTS AND RODENTS - OUTER OPENINGS - CLOSED AND TIGHT FITTING WINDOWS
The back door was open allowing the entry of insects or rodents. Door was open during inspection and did not appear to latch easily.
Correction: Keep this door closed, screened or provided with other approved methods to prevent the entry of insects or rodents. Door must be kept closed at all times. Repair is necesary.
Code 6-202.15 (A) (2)
-
Not serious
Priority Foundation
Corrected on site
-
May 1, 2025 Routine · 1 priority, 1 priority foundation, 1 core, 1 repeat
-
Serious
Priority
Corrected on site
TCS FOOD - HOT HOLDING
Hollandaise and sausage gravy in steam well is hot held at 109-120F
Correction: Maintain time/temperature control for safety food at or above 135°F. Both were reheated and at temp in inspector's presence.
Code 3-501.16 (A) (1)
-
Not serious
Priority Foundation
Repeat
CLEAN-UP OF VOMITING AND DIARRHEAL EVENTS
Food establishment does not have procedures that address responding to vomiting or diarrheal events.
Correction: Develop procedures for responding to vomiting and diarrheal events. Specifically actions that employees must take to minimize the spread of contamination. Will send flier with inspection report.
Code 2-501.11
-
Not serious
Core
INSECTS AND RODENTS - OUTER OPENINGS PROTECTED
The back door of the kitchen was open which could be the source for the entrance of insects or rodents. Owner indicates that they leave door cracked so vendors can bring in items.
Correction: Keep the back door closed so that entrance by insects or rodents into the food establishment is prevented.
Code 6-202.15 (A) (1)
-
Serious
Priority
Corrected on site
-
Jun 28, 2024 Re-inspection · 1 priority foundation, 1 repeat
-
Not serious
Priority Foundation
Repeat
CLEAN-UP OF VOMITING AND DIARRHEAL EVENTS
Food establishment does not have procedures that address responding to vomiting or diarrheal events.
Correction: Develop procedures for responding to vomiting and diarrheal events. Specifically actions that employees must take to minimize the spread of contamination. Will send info graphic with inspection report.
Code 2-501.11
-
Not serious
Priority Foundation
Repeat
-
Jun 20, 2024 Routine · 1 priority, 2 priority foundation
-
Serious
Priority
FOOD CONTACT SURFACES - WAREWASHING EQUIPMENT, CHEMICAL, TEMPERATURE, pH, CONCENTRATION AND HARDNESS
The quat sanitizer in dish machine is not being used according to EPA registered label use instructions and is at 0 PPM.
Correction: Provide training to employees on proper use and concentration of sanitizer or repair or adjust warewashing equipment to provide proper sanitizer concentration. Eco Lab has been called to repair equipment, will be sanitizing with bleach in the 3 comp sink until the dishmachine fixed.
Code 4-501.114 (A) - (E)
-
Not serious
Priority Foundation
CLEAN-UP OF VOMITING AND DIARRHEAL EVENTS
Food establishment does not have procedures that address responding to vomiting or diarrheal events.
Correction: Develop procedures for responding to vomiting and diarrheal events. Specifically actions that employees must take to minimize the spread of contamination. Will send info graphic with inspection report.
Code 2-501.11
-
Not serious
Priority Foundation
WAREWASHING - SANITIZING SOLUTION - TESTING DEVICES
A quat and chlorine test kits are not available for checking sanitizer concentrations.
Correction: Provide a test kit or other device for measuring the concentration of sanitizing solutions. Get test strips for both quat and chlorine to test the buckets and dishmachine.
Code 4-302.14
-
Serious
Priority
-
Jun 2, 2023 Routine · 2 priority, 2 priority foundation, 3 core
-
Serious
Priority
Corrected on site
PACKAGED AND UNPACKAGED FOOD - RAW OVER RTE-FOODS
Approximately 45 trays of eggs were observed to be stored above boxes of produce (pineapple, melons, leafy greens) in the walk in cooler.
Correction: Reorganize food storage so that ready-to-eat foods are stored above raw animal food and raw vegetables. Discard ready-to-eat foods that show evidence of contamination. Walk in cooler was immediately reorganized and the eggs were placed on the bottom shelves and the produce boxes were moved to the upper shelves
Code 3-302.11 (A) (1)
-
Serious
Priority
Corrected on site
TCS FOOD - HOT HOLDING
Gyro cone on spit is hot held at 100°F. Also the biscuit & gravy mix was hot held in the hot holding unit at 126 degrees Fahrenheit.
Correction: Maintain time/temperature control for safety food at or above 135°F. Discard unsafe food items. Gryo spit was turned up and within 15min the gyro cone was at 155 degrees Fahrenheit. The biscuit & gravy mix was rechecked and at 135 degrees Fahrenheit.
Code 3-501.16 (A) (1)
-
Not serious
Priority Foundation
Corrected on site
RTE/TCS FOOD - PROPER DATE MARKING
Several items (sauces, food containers) in the salad/sauce prep cooler and kitchen cooler were improperly date marked with no date mark provided.
Correction: Adjust method or procedures so that all ready-to-eat time/temperature control for safety food, if required, are provided with date marking or an effective method of identifying when a food item has exceeded 7 days. Discard improperly date marked food or food that has past the 7 day shelf life. The food containers and sauces were labeled right away.
Code 3-501.17 (A)
-
Not serious
Priority Foundation
Corrected on site
FOOD CONTACT SURFACES - SOILED
The bottom part of the white water tank is visibly soiled with a light brown mold slime.
Correction: Maintain food contact surfaces in a clean condition. Owner cleaned ice machine right away.
Code 4-601.11 (A)
-
Not serious
Core
Corrected on site
PACKAGED AND UNPACKAGED FOOD - COVERED CONTAINERS OR WRAPPING
Multiple food items stored on the bottom shelf in the kitchen prep cooler were observed to be uncovered.
Correction: All foods that are not part of a cooling process shall be covered at all times to prevent cross-contamination. Food shall be discarded if suspected of cross-contamination. The food items were provided with a cover during inspection.
Code 3-302.11 (A) (4)
-
Not serious
Core
Corrected on site
LABELING - FOOD STORAGE CONTAINERS LABELED WITH COMMON NAME
Multiple food items throughout the cold holding units are stored in unlabeled containers.
Correction: Store all foods that are removed from their original packages in containers labeled with the common name of the food or ingredient. The unlabeled containers were pointed out to the owner and employees and were labeled on the spot.
Code 3-302.12
-
Not serious
Core
Corrected on site
NON-FOOD CONTACT SURFACES - CLEANING FREQUENCY
The ventilation unit and fan covers in the walk in cooler is not cleaned on a frequent basis to prevent mold growth. Mold was observed on the fan covers and on the ventilation unit itself.
Correction: Clean all equipment on a routine basis to prevent accumulation of soil residues. Employees working on cleaning and sanitizing the ventilation unit and fan covers during inspection.
Code 4-602.13
-
Serious
Priority
Corrected on site
Source: City of Appleton Health Department. History last read Oct 1, 2026. Violation text is the inspector's wording. “Serious” is the source's own top tier. About this data.