february-8-2024_bza_agenda-packet
City of Walhalla · Oconee County · meeting of Jul 10, 2024 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Walhalla
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
City of Walhalla
Board of Zoning Appeals
Frank Guldner, Vice-Chair Teara Barnwell, Chair
Dustin Raines Amy Welch
Thursday, February 8, 2024
Specially Called Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting
5:30 PM
206 North Church Street
Walhalla, South Carolina 29691
AGENDA
1. Call to Order
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Election of Officers
A. Chair
B. Vice Chair
4. Approval of Minutes – December 4, 2023
5. Meeting Dates for 2024
6. Public Hearings
a. Special Exception: Request for special exception to allow a double wide manufactured
home on a lot that is zoned General Residential (TMS 500-06-02-018)
b. Variance: Request for variance from roof pitch required under Section 199-2(C) (1) for
TMS 500-06-02-018
c. Variance: Request for variance from front porch size requirements under Section
199-2(C)(8)
7. Old Business
8. Public Comments, non-agenda items
9. Other Business
10. Adjournment
City of Walhalla • Community Development Department
206 N Church St. • P.O. Box 1099 • Walhalla, SC 29691 • (864) 638-4343 • Fax (864) 638-4357 • www.CityofWalhalla.com
City of Walhalla Board of Zoning Appeals
Monday, December 4, 2023 • 5:30 PM
Council Chambers • City Hall
Walhalla, South Carolina
Minutes
In accordance with the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act, Section 30 -4-10 et seq., South Carolina Code,
1976, the media was duly notified of the date, time, and place of the meeting.
Members Present: Teara Barnwell, Frank Guldner, Dustin Raines and Amy Welch
Members Absent: None
Staff Present: Mark Bloomer
Call to Order: Chairwoman Barnwell called the meeting to order at 5:30PM, with a quorum present to
conduct the meeting and welcomed all present to the meeting.
Approval of Agenda: Ms. Welch moved to approve the Agenda, seconded by Mr. Guldner. The
Agenda was unanimously approved.
Approval of Minutes – October 16, 2023: Ms. Welch moved to approve the October 16, 2023
Minutes, seconded by Mr. Guldner. The minutes were unanimously approved.
Introduction of New Planner: Chairwoman Barnwell introduced Mark Bloomer who is Walhalla’s new
Planner. Mr. Bloomer introduced himself and explained that he started the new position on
Halloween. He stated that he came to Walhalla from the Wilmington area, where he lived for
approximately two years. Prior to that Mr. Bloomer lived in the Charleston area for approximately
twenty years.
He stated that although beaches are beautiful, it is nice to be somewhere with hills and mountains. Mr.
Bloomer informed the board that he has approximately fourteen years of planning experience as well
as a law degree. He also stated that Walhalla is beautiful and he feels fortunate to be here. He also
stated that he looks forward to working with the board.
Date of January Meeting: Chairwoman Barnwell introduced this item. The regularly scheduled
meeting in January would fall on January 15, 2024, which is a holiday. The Committee decided to
have the meeting on January 22, 2024 instead. The motion was made by Mr. Guldner, seconded by
Mr. Raines.
Public Hearings
Variance: Request for variance from minimum setbacks on East Main Street (TMS 500 -
16-12-002) Chairwoman Barnwell introduced this item. Mr. Bloomer explained that the
applicant will be building a new house for the property owner on the subject lot. The
proposed house will face East Main Street. The applicant is Barry Culbertson from Culbertson
Construction LLC. Mr. Culbertson has requested a fifteen foot variance from the required forty
foot front setback that is required for the proposed house. He has requested this variance so
that two old growth pecan trees would not have to be cut down and so that the front of the
proposed house would be in line with the front of the existing house next door.
Mr. Bloomer stated that all though he understands the importance of preserving trees,
especially old growth trees, he does not feel that there is a hardship in this case that is peculiar
to this lot. Most of the vacant lots in the City have old growth trees and slope issues like the
subject property. Mr. Bloomer stated that he does not recommend approving the request for
a 15 foot Variance.
Mr. Bloomer explained that Mr. Culbertson is here and that he will provide more details on his
request for a variance. Mr. Culbertson showed the board a rendering of what the proposed
house will look like. It will be a large two story colonial. He also explained that he may not
even need fifteen feet of variance from the required setback. He may only need thirteen feet
of variance. Ms. Welch made a motion to approve Mr. Culbertson’s request for a fifteen foot
variance from the required forty foot front setback, seconded by Mr. Raines. All were in favor.
Variance: Request for variance from minimum setbacks on East Main Street (TMS 500-16-09-
004. Chairwoman Barnwell introduced this request for a variance. Mr. Bloomer explained that
this request for a variance is for the same gas station that the Board of Zoning Appeals
approved the variance for at their October 16, 2023 meeting. When installers for the
applicant (Kendall Robinson from Prince Signs) were checking conditions at the site after the
October 16, 2023 Board of Zoning Appeals meeting they realized that if they complied with
Walhalla’s 10 foot setback requirement from the right of way the new monument sign would
be in the parking lot.
This would cause a safety hazard to vehicles trying to enter or leave using the driveway. It
would also cause a safety hazard for vehicles trying to use the gas pumps closest to East Main
street. Additionally bollards would have to be installed on the new sign as a safety precaution.
This would add to the cost of the project. Mr. Bloomer stated the applicant has requested a
nine foot Variance from the ten foot setback that is required from the right of way. Mr.
Culbertson wants to place the new sign where the current sign is. Mr. Bloomer stated that
there is hardship here that doesn’t apply to other lots because of the size and layout of the lot.
For safety reasons we do not want a sign placed in the parking lot since it would create a
hazard for vehicular traffic. Since there is both hardship and a safety issue here, Mr.
Bloomer recommended approval of the request for a nine foot variance from the ten foot
setback that is required from the right of way. Mark Bloomer stated that Kendall Robinson
is here tonight, and he will further explain his request.
Mr. Robinson explained that placing the sign where Walhalla’s ordinances requires
would impede vehicular traffic flow on the lot. He agreed with what Mr. Bloomer had stated.
Chairman Blackwell made the motion to approve the request for a nine foot variance from the
ten foot setback that is required from the right of way, seconded by Ms. Welch. All were in
favor.
Old Business: None
Public Comments, non-Agenda items: None
Other Business: None
Hearing no further business, Chairwoman Barnwell adjourned the meeting at 5:49 pm.
Respectfully Submitted by Planning and Zoning Administrator Mark Bloomer
Chapter 199
Manufactured Homes
[HISTORY: Adopted by the City Council of the City of Walhalla 3-15-2016 by Ord. No. 2016-2.
Amendments noted where applicable.]
§ 199-1 Definitions.
As used in this chapter, the following terms shall have the meanings indicated:
MANUFACTURED HOME (MH)
A home built to the Federal Manufactured Home Construction and Safety Standards Act, also called the
"HUD Code." The HUD Code is a mandatory federal building code for MH, whereas site-built and
modular homes are built to a code adopted by the state. All manufactured homes bear a small red metal
tag called the "HUD tag" that identifies it as being built to the HUD Code.
MOBILE HOME
Generally used to refer to factory-built home built prior to 1976 (no mandatory building code for mobile
homes prior to 1976).
MODULAR HOME
A residential structure built to the latest edition of the International Residential Code as adopted by the
South Carolina Building Codes Council. The construction standards are exactly the same for site-built
homes as they are for modular homes. Modular homes in South Carolina bear a modular label issued by
the SC Building Codes Council. Under state law, modular homes are to be treated exactly the same as a
site-built structure.
§ 199-2 Construction standards.
A. No building permit shall be issued for any manufactured home originally brought into the City of
Walhalla or relocated within the City subsequent to the adoption of this chapter unless a certificate of
zoning compliance shall have been issued by the Zoning Administrator, to certify that the manufactured
home is in full compliance with this chapter.
B. All manufactured homes brought into the City of Walhalla, or relocated within the City of Walhalla
after the adoption of this chapter, shall be required to be in compliance with each of the following
requirements.
C. All manufactured homes subject to this chapter shall meet or exceed the most current construction
standards promulgated by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, as well as the
South Carolina Manufactured Housing Board, including:
(1) A gable roof having a pitch with a minimum vertical rise of 4.5 feet for each 12 feet of horizontal run.
(2) A roof finished with shingles, with a fire rating of Class C or better, and that are commonly used in
standard residential construction.
(3) A minimum width of 24 feet and a minimum length of 40 feet.
(4) A roof structure that provides an eave projection of no less than 12 inches, which may include a gutter.
(5) Exterior sliding, comparable in composition, appearance and durability to the exterior siding commonly
used in standard residential constructions, consisting of one or more of the following:
(a) Vinyl siding whose reflectivity does not exceed that of flat white paint;
(b) Cedar or other wood siding;
(c) Wood grain;
(d) Stucco siding; or
(e) Brick or stone siding.
(6) Skirting must be installed and maintained so that it encloses the area under the manufactured multi-
section homes and modular porches, decks or other additions to ground level. The foundation skirting or
curtain wall may be of brick, masonry or stone materials designed for permanent outdoor instillation.
(7) A permanent landing and steps with handrails are required for each outside doorway, excluding the front
door. The structure must include steps which lead to ground level. The landing, handrails and steps must
meet the following requirements:
(a) A minimum four-by-four landing shall be required outside each exit door.
(b) The landing shall not be more than 8.5 inches below the threshold.
(c) Steps shall be 8 1/4 inches maximum in height. Treads shall be a minimum of nine inches wide.
(d) All wood components in contact with the ground must be treated and approved for ground contact.
(e) If steps are 30 inches or greater in height, permanent handrails are to be installed.
(8) A front porch shall be erected and be at least eight feet by 10 feet.
(9) Units shall be placed on permanent foundation supports of concrete or other suitable material adequate
for the load.
(10) All visible mobile features shall be removed.
(11) If the proposed unit will be replacing another dwelling unit (mobile home, manufactured home, stick-
built) or be built within an existing neighborhood, the home must be constructed to blend into the street
and/or neighborhood. It should have the aesthetic qualities of other dwelling units in the area.
(12) Decorated windows, bay windows, columns and fancier exterior trim are encouraged.
(13) Each manufactured home shall be anchored according to the HUD regulations of the National
Manufactured Housing Construction and Safety Standards Act or the manufacturer's installation manual.
§ 199-3 Zoning requirements.
A. As per the Walhalla Zoning Ordinance (Chapter 330, Part 1, of the City Code), manufactured home
placement will be allowed in the General Residential Zoning District, but will require a special
exception approval by the Board of Zoning Appeals.
B. A site plan must be submitted for the placement of the manufactured home on the lot. This plan must
include measurements, distances, access points and property lines; and may include pictures of the
proposed home to be placed on the property.
C. A zoning application must be completed, with a request for a special exception hearing as outlined in
the Zoning Ordinance.
D. The Board of Zoning Appeals must both hear and approve this special exception.
§ 199-4 Structural and use standards.
A. Each manufactured home shall be used as a permanent single-family residence only.
B. The manufactured home shall have permanent utility hookups, metered at the mobile home, which,
except for electrical connections, shall be concealed from view.
C. No more than one manufactured home shall occupy one lot, except in a mobile home park.
D. No manufactured home shall be placed or parked upon any premises within the corporate limits for use
for sleeping or dwelling purposes within 25 feet of the nearest mobile home or permanent building,
except for carports.
E. All manufactured homes shall be served by an all-weather parking area with a surface of sufficient
dimensions to accommodate parking for at least two vehicles and connected to a street or driveway. The
surface may be of concrete, brick, asphalt, gravel or similar material, but not grass or dirt.
F. All manufactured homes hereafter set up within the City of Walhalla shall bear a label or seal of
compliance with federal mobile home construction and safety standards promulgated by the Department
of Housing and Urban Development.
G. All manufactured homes shall be registered with Oconee County and bear the required seal of the
county.
§ 199-5 Nonconforming mobile or manufactured homes.
To avoid undue hardship, the lawful use of any mobile home or manufactured home at the time of the
enactment of this chapter may be continued, except that such mobile or manufactured home shall not be
changed, replaced or altered in any way which does not conform to the provisions of this chapter.
§ 199-6 Enforcement; violations and penalties.
A. It shall be unlawful for any person to place or park any mobile home or manufactured home upon any
premises within the corporate limits, except as provided by this chapter and any amendments thereto;
and in the event of any violation of these provisions, such shall be sufficient grounds for the City of
Walhalla to discontinue all municipal services to such mobile or manufactured home.
B. Any person or persons violating any portion of this chapter shall be punishable by a fine not exceeding
$500 per violation or 30 days in jail. Each twenty-four-hour period of noncompliance shall constitute a
separate offense.
Background on roof pitch requirements:
A steeper roof of 4/12 or more will make a manufactured home look much more
like a conventional home. Many manufactured homes come with a 3/12 roof pitch,
but some can be upgraded to a 4/12, 5/12 or greater. Usually pitches of 5/12 are
limited to modular homes with hinged roofs, so they can be transported within
height limits.
In addition to aesthetics, it is believed a roof with a 4/12 pitch may also be better
for shingles than a standard 3/12 pitched roof, assuming a shingled roof vs metal.
Below is an image showing the angle of various roof pitches.
The following Code does not display images or complicated formatting. Codes should be viewed online. This
tool is only meant for editing.
Chapter 199
Manufactured Homes
[HISTORY: Adopted by the City Council of the City of Walhalla 3-15-2016 by Ord. No. 2016-2.
Amendments noted where applicable.]
§ 199-1 Definitions.
As used in this chapter, the following terms shall have the meanings indicated:
MANUFACTURED HOME (MH)
A home built to the Federal Manufactured Home Construction and Safety Standards Act, also called the
"HUD Code." The HUD Code is a mandatory federal building code for MH, whereas site-built and
modular homes are built to a code adopted by the state. All manufactured homes bear a small red metal
tag called the "HUD tag" that identifies it as being built to the HUD Code.
MOBILE HOME
Generally used to refer to factory-built home built prior to 1976 (no mandatory building code for mobile
homes prior to 1976).
MODULAR HOME
A residential structure built to the latest edition of the International Residential Code as adopted by the
South Carolina Building Codes Council. The construction standards are exactly the same for site-built
homes as they are for modular homes. Modular homes in South Carolina bear a modular label issued by
the SC Building Codes Council. Under state law, modular homes are to be treated exactly the same as a
site-built structure.
§ 199-2 Construction standards.
A. No building permit shall be issued for any manufactured home originally brought into the City of
Walhalla or relocated within the City subsequent to the adoption of this chapter unless a certificate of
zoning compliance shall have been issued by the Zoning Administrator, to certify that the manufactured
home is in full compliance with this chapter.
B. All manufactured homes brought into the City of Walhalla, or relocated within the City of Walhalla
after the adoption of this chapter, shall be required to be in compliance with each of the following
requirements.
C. All manufactured homes subject to this chapter shall meet or exceed the most current construction
standards promulgated by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, as well as the
South Carolina Manufactured Housing Board, including:
(1) A gable roof having a pitch with a minimum vertical rise of 4.5 feet for each 12 feet of horizontal run.
(2) A roof finished with shingles, with a fire rating of Class C or better, and that are commonly used in
standard residential construction.
(3) A minimum width of 24 feet and a minimum length of 40 feet.
(4) A roof structure that provides an eave projection of no less than 12 inches, which may include a gutter.
(5) Exterior sliding, comparable in composition, appearance and durability to the exterior siding commonly
used in standard residential constructions, consisting of one or more of the following:
(a) Vinyl siding whose reflectivity does not exceed that of flat white paint;
(b) Cedar or other wood siding;
(c) Wood grain;
(d) Stucco siding; or
(e) Brick or stone siding.
(6) Skirting must be installed and maintained so that it encloses the area under the manufactured multi-
section homes and modular porches, decks or other additions to ground level. The foundation skirting or
curtain wall may be of brick, masonry or stone materials designed for permanent outdoor instillation.
(7) A permanent landing and steps with handrails are required for each outside doorway, excluding the front
door. The structure must include steps which lead to ground level. The landing, handrails and steps must
meet the following requirements:
(a) A minimum four-by-four landing shall be required outside each exit door.
(b) The landing shall not be more than 8.5 inches below the threshold.
(c) Steps shall be 8 1/4 inches maximum in height. Treads shall be a minimum of nine inches wide.
(d) All wood components in contact with the ground must be treated and approved for ground contact.
(e) If steps are 30 inches or greater in height, permanent handrails are to be installed.
(8) A front porch shall be erected and be at least eight feet by 10 feet.
(9) Units shall be placed on permanent foundation supports of concrete or other suitable material adequate
for the load.
(10) All visible mobile features shall be removed.
(11) If the proposed unit will be replacing another dwelling unit (mobile home, manufactured home, stick-
built) or be built within an existing neighborhood, the home must be constructed to blend into the street
and/or neighborhood. It should have the aesthetic qualities of other dwelling units in the area.
(12) Decorated windows, bay windows, columns and fancier exterior trim are encouraged.
(13) Each manufactured home shall be anchored according to the HUD regulations of the National
Manufactured Housing Construction and Safety Standards Act or the manufacturer's installation manual.
§ 199-3 Zoning requirements.
A. As per the Walhalla Zoning Ordinance (Chapter 330, Part 1, of the City Code), manufactured home
placement will be allowed in the General Residential Zoning District, but will require a special
exception approval by the Board of Zoning Appeals.
B. A site plan must be submitted for the placement of the manufactured home on the lot. This plan must
include measurements, distances, access points and property lines; and may include pictures of the
proposed home to be placed on the property.
C. A zoning application must be completed, with a request for a special exception hearing as outlined in
the Zoning Ordinance.
D. The Board of Zoning Appeals must both hear and approve this special exception.
§ 199-4 Structural and use standards.
A. Each manufactured home shall be used as a permanent single-family residence only.
B. The manufactured home shall have permanent utility hookups, metered at the mobile home, which,
except for electrical connections, shall be concealed from view.
C. No more than one manufactured home shall occupy one lot, except in a mobile home park.
D. No manufactured home shall be placed or parked upon any premises within the corporate limits for use
for sleeping or dwelling purposes within 25 feet of the nearest mobile home or permanent building,
except for carports.
E. All manufactured homes shall be served by an all-weather parking area with a surface of sufficient
dimensions to accommodate parking for at least two vehicles and connected to a street or driveway. The
surface may be of concrete, brick, asphalt, gravel or similar material, but not grass or dirt.
F. All manufactured homes hereafter set up within the City of Walhalla shall bear a label or seal of
compliance with federal mobile home construction and safety standards promulgated by the Department
of Housing and Urban Development.
G. All manufactured homes shall be registered with Oconee County and bear the required seal of the
county.
§ 199-5 Nonconforming mobile or manufactured homes.
To avoid undue hardship, the lawful use of any mobile home or manufactured home at the time of the
enactment of this chapter may be continued, except that such mobile or manufactured home shall not be
changed, replaced or altered in any way which does not conform to the provisions of this chapter.
§ 199-6 Enforcement; violations and penalties.
A. It shall be unlawful for any person to place or park any mobile home or manufactured home upon any
premises within the corporate limits, except as provided by this chapter and any amendments thereto;
and in the event of any violation of these provisions, such shall be sufficient grounds for the City of
Walhalla to discontinue all municipal services to such mobile or manufactured home.
B. Any person or persons violating any portion of this chapter shall be punishable by a fine not exceeding
$500 per violation or 30 days in jail. Each twenty-four-hour period of noncompliance shall constitute a
separate offense.
Source: City of Walhalla website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.