nov-72022-pc-agenda
City of Walhalla · Oconee County · meeting of Nov 3, 2022 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Walhalla
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
“MAIN STREET to the MOUNTAINS”
Mr. Danny Edwards, Mayor
Mr. Danny Woodward, Mayor Pro Tem Mr. Grant Keehn, Councilman
Ms. Sarai Melendez, Councilwoman Mr. David Underwood, Councilman
Mr. Keith Pace, Councilman Mr. Michael Kozlarek, City Attorney
Mr. Tyler Jordan, Councilman Mr. Timothy B. Burton, City Administrator
206 N. Church Street (PO Box 1099), Walhalla SC 29691
864-638-4343 Phone
www.cityofwalhalla.com
Planning Commission Members:
Chris Grant, Chair; Kelvin Bryant; Gina Orr; Jessie Bunning;
William Tatum
AGENDA
WALHALLA CITY PLANNING COMMISSION
Nov 7, 2022
5:30 PM
Walhalla City Hall
206 N Church St, Walhalla, SC 29691
CALL TO ORDER & WELCOME Chris Grant, Chair
MOMENT OF SILENCE
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
APPROVAL OF AGENDA Planning Commission
APPROVAL OF MINUTES Planning Commission
STAFF REPORT Brandon Burton, City Administrator
MEMBER COMMENTS Planning Commission
PUBLIC INPUT (Public Comment is limited to 5 minutes per speaker)
ACTION/DISCUSSION ITEMS (to include Vote and/or Action on matters brought up for discussion, if
required)
1. Review of proposed ordinance- An ordinance to Establish Local Historic Property Designation
and Design Review.
ADJOURN
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
COUNTY OF OCONEE ) ORDINANCE 2022-X
CITY OF WALHALLA )
AN ORDINANCE TO ESTABLISH LOCAL HISTORIC PROPERTY DESIGNATION AND
DESIGN REVIEW
Whereas,
Whereas,
NOW THEREFORE: it is ordained and enacted that: by the Mayor and Council members
of the Municipality of Walhalla, in Council assembled, that the following ordinance, shall be
as follows:
SECTION 1. TITLE
The title of this ordinance shall be the City of Walhalla Historic Preservation Ordinance.
SECTION 2. PURPOSE
The purpose of this ordinance is:
I. to protect, preserve and enhance the distinctive architectural and cultural heritage of
City of Walhalla ;
II. to promote the educational, cultural, economic and general welfare of the people of
City of Walhalla ;
III. to foster civic pride;
IV. to encourage harmonious, orderly and efficient growth and development of City of Walhalla ;
V. to strengthen the local economy; and
VI. to improve property values.
It is the hope of the City of Walhalla that by encouraging a general harmony of style, form,
proportion and material between buildings of historic design and those of contemporary design,
the city’s historic buildings and historic districts will continue to be a distinctive aspect of the City
of Walhalla and will serve as visible reminders of the significant historical and cultural heritage of
the City of Walhalla and State of South Carolina.
This ordinance is part of the zoning ordinance of City of Walhalla and is enacted pursuant to the
South Carolina Code of Laws, Sections 6-29-710 and Section 6-29-870 et sequitur. (The
ordinance can also be referenced in the zoning ordinance and adopted as a separate ordinance.
If the general zoning ordinance is still operating under the authority of Title 5 it will be necessary to
include or substitute those citations; e.g. SCCL 6-29-710, 6-29-870 et sequitur or SCCL 5-23-
320.)
SECTION 3. DEFINITIONS
Alteration
A change in the external architectural features of any historic structure or in the interior of any such
structure if the interior feature is specifically included in the historic designation; a change in the
landscape features of any historic site or place; or work having an adverse effect upon designated
archaeological resources.
* Note: Items appearing in parentheses and underlined are for instructional purposes
Certificate of Appropriateness
Document issued by the Board of Architectural Review, following a prescribed review procedure,
certifying that the proposed actions by an applicant are found to be acceptable in terms of design
criteria relating to the individual property or the historic district.
Historic District
An area, designated by the city council, upon the recommendation of the Board of Architectural
Review and pursuant to the provisions of this ordinance.
Historic Property
Any place (including an archaeological site or the location of a significant historical event),
building, structure, work of art, fixture or similar object that has been individually designated by
(city/county) council or designated as a contributing property within a historic district.
Public Space within a building
Spaces designed for use by the public, such as auditoriums, court rooms, lobbies, entrance halls,
etc. These spaces are usually gathering places as opposed to corridors for public use.
Substantial Hardship
Hardship, caused by unusual and compelling circumstances, based on one or more of the
following:
I. the property cannot reasonably be maintained in the manner dictated by the ordinance,
II. there are no other reasonable means of saving the property from deterioration, or collapse,
or
III. the property is owned by a nonprofit organization, and it is not feasible financially or
physically to achieve the charitable purposes of the organization while maintaining the
property appropriately.
SECTION 4. ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW BOARD ESTABLISHED
4.1 Creation
To implement the provisions of this ordinance, there is hereby established a Board of
Architectural Review, hereinafter referred to as the Board, for the City of Walhalla consisting of
(5,7,9) members. Members shall be appointed by the City of Walhalla council upon the
recommendation of the Board.
4.2 Composition and Qualifications.
All members of the board shall have a demonstrated interest in historic preservation. If available in
the community, the board should have at least one member who is qualified as:
1. a historian, knowledgeable in local history,
2. an architect or if an architect is not available to serve, someone knowledgeable in
building design and construction.
(Other designated members can be listed, such as, a lawyer, a real estate agent, engineer, and
representative of the historical society.)
No members shall hold any other (municipal/county) office. S.C. Code 6-29-870(C). (A
representative of the zoning commission could serve only as an ex-officio, non-voting member.)
Members shall assume their duties at the first regular meeting after their appointment. Members
shall serve without compensation except for reimbursement for authorized expenses attendant to
the performance of their duties. (Please include a reference to SC Code Section 6-29-1340 that
discusses the educational requirements of BAR Members.)
4.3 Terms of Office.
The term of office for each member shall be two years. Any person who has served as a member
of the Board for three consecutive terms shall not be eligible for reappointment for at least one
year. A term of less than one year shall not be counted in determining eligibility for reappointment.
Membership shall be identified by place numbers 1 through (5/7/9). Terms of office for members in
the odd-numbered places shall expire in odd numbered years; terms for even-numbered
members expire in even numbered years, provided, however, that each member shall serve until
his successor is appointed and installed.
4.4 Removal.
Any member of the Board may be removed by the city council, for repeated failure to attend
meetings of the Board or for any other cause deemed sufficient by the city council. Consider,
three (3) or more consecutive meetings or 50% of scheduled meetings in one year. (If the board
will not meet monthly/bi-monthly, then the 2nd part will not work.)
4.5 Appointment to Fill a Vacancy.
If any place on the Board becomes vacant due to resignation, removal, or for any reason, the city
council shall appoint a replacement within 60 days for the remainder of the unexpired term,
subject to confirmation by the city council.
4.6 Conflicts of Interest.
Any member of the board who has a personal or financial interest, either directly or indirectly, in
any property which is the subject of, or affected by, a decision of the Board shall be disqualified
from participating in the decision of the Board concerning the property.
4.7 Liability of Members.
Any member of the Board acting within powers granted by the ordinance shall be relieved from
personal liability for any damage and held harmless by the City of Walhalla. Any suit brought
against any member of the Board shall be defended by a legal representative furnished by the
city until the termination of the proceedings.
(Note: See appendix E of the Comprehensive Planning Guide for Local
Governments, "Board of Architectural Review Rules of Procedure" that sets forth
the officers and duties of each, a hearing procedure, an appeals procedure and
requirements for records. Appendix G of the same publication contains a sample
form for notice of a Board of Architectural Review Hearing. Appendix H has a
form for issuing a Stop Order to halt unapproved work.)
SECTION 5. POWERS AND DUTIES
The responsibility of the Board is to promote the purposes and objectives of this ordinance, to
review and recommend to city council the designation of individual historic properties and historic
districts, and to review plans and applications, as hereinafter provided, for all construction within
historic districts and construction or demolition pertaining to or affecting duly designated historic
properties. The Board shall have the power to approve, approve with modifications or deny
approval for such applications in accordance with the prescribed procedures and guidelines.
SECTION 6. HISTORIC PROPERTY INVENTORY
The Board shall maintain a local inventory of buildings, structures, objects, and sites more than
fifty years old. These records shall be available to the public.
SECTION 7. DESIGNATION OF HISTORIC PROPERTIES
7.1 Criteria for Historic Designation.
The Board shall review the local inventory and make recommendations for historic
designation(s) to city council based on the following criteria.
A property may be designated historic if it:
1. has significant inherent character, interest, or value as part of the development or
heritage of the community, state, or nation; or
2. is the site of an event significant in history; or
3. is associated with a person or persons who contributed significantly to the culture and
development of the community, state, or nation; or
4. exemplifies the cultural, political, economic, social, ethnic, or historic heritage of the
community, state, or nation; or
5. individually, or as a collection of resources, embodies distinguishing characteristics of
a type, style, period, or specimen in architecture or engineering; or
6. is the work of a designer whose work has influenced significantly the development of
the community, state or nation; or
7. contains elements of design, detail, materials, or craftsmanship which represent a
significant innovation; or
8. is part of or related to a square or other distinctive element of community planning; or
9. represents an established and familiar visual feature of the neighborhood or
community; or
10. has yielded, or may be likely to yield, information important in pre-history or history.
(Note: These criteria are suggested, however, each community should review and revise them to
reflect the needs and comprehensive plan for their community.)
7.2 Owner Notification.
Owners of properties proposed to be designated historic shall be notified in writing thirty days
prior to consideration by city/county council. Owners may appear before the city council to voice
approval or opposition to such designation.
(Additionally, the planning commission shall provide its formal comment to the council on
ordinance adoption, amendment, and designation and may also serve as the entity conducting the
required public hearing if so authorized by council.)
7.3 Identification on Town Zoning Map.
All locally designated historic properties and historic districts shall be clearly shown on the
zoning map.
7.4 Opposition to Designation
Any property owner may object to the decision by the city council to designate his property as
historic by filing suit against the City of Walhalla before the Courts of the State of South
Carolina.
(Note: This suit must be based on procedural nonconformities in the designation process or on
the misapplication of the criteria for designation as specified in the city’s ordinance or under SCCL
6-29-870.0 not simply on the desire not to be included in the locally designated district. In the
case of individual landmarks, the basis for challenging designation is the same.)
SECTION 8. JURISDICTION OF THE BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW
The jurisdiction of the Board, in general, is the city limits. The jurisdiction of the Board for the
recommendation of properties to be designated historic is the City of Walhalla limits. The
jurisdiction of the Board for the review of proposed alteration to exteriors of buildings, new
construction, and demolition is the individual properties and areas that have been designated
by the City of Walhalla council as historic.
SECTION 9. NOMINATIONS TO THE NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
The Board may conduct first review and evaluation of all proposed nominations for the National
Register of Historic Places for properties that are within its jurisdiction, prior to consideration by
the State Board of Review. The Board may send their recommendations to the State Historic
Preservation Office for consideration at the meeting of the State Board of Review. The Board
shall not nominate properties directly to the National Register; only the State Board of Review
shall have this final review authority unless expressly authorized by federal statute.
SECTION 10. CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
A Certificate of Appropriateness is required before a building permit can be issued for the
demolition, new construction, exterior alteration, modification or addition to a designated historic
property. Any building permit not issued in conformity with this ordinance shall be considered
void.
Application for a Certificate of Appropriateness must be signed by the owner or his authorized
representative and the form must be signed by the chairman or vice-chairman of the Board
stating its approval, denial, or approval with conditions and the reasons for the decision.
10.1 Required Procedure.
An application for a Certificate of Appropriateness shall be obtained from Community
Development Department, and when completed, filed with the appropriate administrative official
as designated by the Board.
10.2 Time Limits.
Applications for a Certificate of Appropriateness shall be considered by the Board at its next
regular meeting, provided they have been filed at least seven (7) calendar days before the
regularly scheduled meeting of Board. If the Board fails to take action upon any application within
45 days after the complete application is received, the application shall be considered approved,
except in cases where the Board has postponed an application to demolish a structure under the
provisions contained in this ordinance.
10.3 Board Action on Application.
The Board shall review the application, using the design guidelines appearing in Section 11 of this
ordinance to make findings of fact to decide whether or not the applicant's plans are appropriate.
The decision of the Board, along with the reasons for each decision, will be recorded in the
minutes and will be available upon request as a public reference for preservation procedures.
10.4 Contents of Application.
The Board shall, in its Rules of Procedure, require data as are reasonable and necessary to
determine the nature of the application. An application shall not be considered complete until all
the required data have been submitted.
10.5 Notification of Affected Property Owners.
Prior to the issuance of an approval or denial of a Certificate of Appropriateness, the Board shall
inform the owners of any property likely to be materially affected by the application, and shall give
the applicant and such owners an opportunity to be heard. (Would the City/Council prefer a set
radius of notification? Such as, adjacent property owners, set number of feet radius, posting the
property… I assume the opportunity to be heard would be a public hearing or public comment
section at the scheduled meeting.)
10.6 Submission of a New Application.
If the Board determines that a Certificate of Appropriateness should be denied, a new application
affecting the same property may be submitted only if substantial change is made in the plans for
the proposed work. (Consider a waiting period or substantial change – a new application
affecting the same property may not be submitted for one (1) year from the date of denial, unless
the request contains substantial changes that address the Board’s stated reasons in the originally
denied application.)
10.7 Maintenance, Repair, and Interior Projects.
Nothing in this document shall be construed to prevent the ordinary maintenance or repair of any
exterior architectural feature of structures designated as historic when that repair does not involve
a change in design, material, color, or outer appearance of the structure. The Board shall not
consider the interior arrangements or alterations to the interior of a building unless the interior of a
public building or the public space of a private building is specifically described and designated as
historic. The Board may authorize a staff member to approve minor projects involving repairs and
ordinary maintenance that do not alter design, materials, color or the outer appearance of a
structure or interior projects not subject to design review.
10.8 Fines and Penalties.
The system of fines applied by the City of Walhalla for violation of the building code will apply to
violations of this ordinance.
10.9 Substantial Hardship.
In the event a Certificate of Appropriateness is denied, the property owner may apply for an
exemption based on the substantial hardship of maintaining the property according to the design
guidelines for historic properties. Substantial hardship is to be considered by the Commission
where one or more of the following unusual and compelling circumstances exists:
a. the property cannot reasonably be maintained in the manner dictated by the
ordinance,
b. there are no other reasonable means of saving the property from deterioration, or
collapse, or
c. the property is owned by a nonprofit organization and it is not feasible financially or
physically to achieve the charitable purposes of the organization while maintaining the property
appropriately.* (Planning Commission, BAR Board or Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA)? Often
these go to the BZA as the applicant is appealing the zoning ordinance’s requirements.)
* While the Courts have consistently upheld designating and enforcing ordinance requirements
on properties owned or operated by religious institutions and not-for-profit organizations, it is
sometimes in the overall interest of community preservation efforts to specifically recognize that
such institutions and organizations, in addition to private individuals, are subject to economic
hardship issues.
The owner may be required to submit documents to show that he cannot comply with the design
guidelines and earn a reasonable rate of return on his investment in the property. Information
required may include:
1. costs of the proposed development with and without modification needed to comply
with the design guidelines as determined by the Board,
2. structural report and/or a feasibility report,
3. market value of the property in its present condition and after completion of the
proposed project,
4. cost of the property, date purchased, relationship, if any, between seller and buyer,
terms of financing,
5. for the past two years, annual gross income from the property with operating and
maintenance expenses, depreciation, and annual cash flow before and after debt service during
that time, and
6. other information considered necessary by the Board to determine whether or not the
property may yield a reasonable return.
10.10 Demolition.
If the Board denies, or postpones for 180 days, a request to demolish a historic building, the
Board shall work closely with the owner to find an appropriate use for the property, to help find a
buyer or to obtain funding for rehabilitation, including low interest loans or grants. The Board shall
inform the community concerning the threat to the building, its value as part of the fabric of the
community and, through publicity and contacts with civic groups, seek to provide assistance in
preserving the property.
SECTION 11. DESIGN GUIDELINES
11.1 Intent.
It is the intent of this ordinance to ensure, insofar as possible, that properties designated as historic
shall be in harmony with the architectural and historical character of the City of Walhalla . In
granting a Certificate of Appropriateness, the Board shall take into account
the architectural and historical significance of the structure under consideration and the exterior
form and appearance of any proposed additions or modifications to that structure as well as the
effect of such change or additions upon other structures in the vicinity.*
* (The Board can issue specific design guidelines for separately designated areas containing
different categories of resources. Usually these guidelines are adopted by council.)
11.2 The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation.
When considering an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for new construction,
alteration, repair, or restoration, the Commission shall use the Secretary of the Interior's
Standards for Rehabilitation as guidelines in making its decisions. In addition, the Board may
adopt more specific guidelines for local historic districts and local historic buildings. These
guidelines serve as the basis for determining the approval, approval with modifications, or denial of
an application. (Planning Commission or BAR Board?)
The Secretary's Standards for Rehabilitation are:
1. A property will be used as it was historically or be given a new use that requires
minimal change to its distinctive materials, features, spaces, and spatial relationships.
2. The historic character of a property shall be retained and preserved. The removal of
distinctive materials or alteration of features, spaces, and spatial relationships that characterize
a property will be avoided.
3. Each property will be recognized as a physical record of its time, place, and use.
Changes that create a false sense of historical development, such as adding conjectural features
or elements from other buildings, will not be undertaken.
4. Changes to a property that have acquired historic significance in their own right will be
retained and preserved.
5. Distinctive materials, features, finishes, and construction techniques or examples of
craftsmanship that characterize a property will be preserved.
6. Deteriorated historic features will be repaired rather than replaced. Where the
severity of deterioration requires replacement of a distinctive feature, the new feature will match
the old in design, color, texture, and, where possible, materials. Replacement of missing features
will be substantiated by documentary and physical evidence.
7. Chemical or physical treatments, if appropriate, will be undertaken using the gentlest
means possible. Treatments that cause damage to historic materials will not be used.
8. Archeological resources will be protected and preserved in place. If such resources
must be disturbed, mitigation measures will be undertaken.
9. New additions, exterior alterations, or related new construction will not destroy historic
materials, features, and spatial relationships that characterize the property. The new work will be
differentiated from the old and will be compatible with the historic materials, features, size, scale,
and proportion, and massing to protect the integrity of the property and its environment.
10. New additions and adjacent or related new construction will be undertaken in such a
manner that, if removed in the future, the essential form and integrity of the historic property and
its environment would be unimpaired.
SECTION 12. APPEALS
Any person may appeal a decision of the Board to the Courts of South Carolina pursuant to the
South Carolina Code of Laws, Section 6-29-900 et sequitur. (May wish to add that the BAR can
review written appeals of City staff’s decisions.)
AND IS DONE AND RATIFIED in Council Duly assembled this ______Day of ________ 2022.
______________________________
Danny Edwards, Mayor
(seal)
ATTEST:
___________________________
Timothy B. Burton, City Administrator
Introduced By: ______________________________
First Reading: ______________________________
Public Hearing,
Second Reading
And Adoption: ______________________________
Source: City of Walhalla website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.