_01282026-1381
Town of Surfside Beach · Horry County · meeting of Jan 28, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Surfside Beach
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
Town of Surfside Beach
Planning, Building & Zoning Department
210 US Hwy. 17 South, Surfside Beach, SC 29575
(843)913-6341
PLANNING COMMISSION WORKSHOP MINUTES
TUESDAY, JANUARY 28, 2026 AT 5:00PM
1. CALL TO ORDER – Carolyn Pravlik, Chair – In attendance Mr. Von Buseck, Ms. Abrams, Mrs. Lane-
Laveglia, Mrs. Dubanoski, Mr. McKeen and Mr. Monson. Secretary Angie Poston and Director
Mark Brodeur. Code Enforcement - Mr. Vorrias was present.
2. INVOCATION – Ms. Abrams did the invocation.
3. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE – Ms. Abrams led the Pledge of Allegiance
4. WORKSHOP ITEMS:
a. TREE PRESERVATION ORDINANCE LANGUAGE WAS PRESENTED BY MR. BRODEUR
5. PUBLIC COMMENTS:
My name is Elizabeth Pellegrino. I think some of you knew my husband. I have issues with number four
and number nine. I'll start with nine, Can we get those back? Oh, all right. And I live at 419 Second
Avenue North. I have been a homeowner here for 20 years. I've lived here permanently for over 13.
Number nine is my first issue. If you guys add in palmetto trees, it doesn't change the problem that we
have right now because what they're doing is removing all the trees and only putting in palmettoes.
And I know I love palmettoes, but you should not be allowed to have only palmettoes in your yard.
They are a native tree, but they're an understory tree. I have them in my yard. They come up from
seed. I love a palmetto tree, but they cannot be the only tree in somebody's yard. And they're the
easiest tree for a builder to put in. They don't require much space. They don't take up room in the
yard. So this comes to number four. Number four, my issue there is that we're not allowing room for
trees so when you come in I've watched it to a lot across the street from my house one house out there
beautiful big oak trees chopped it all down put two giant McMansions that don't leave enough room
for trees. They have far too much driveway. They never use it. They're never there but it could park 12
cars and then they don't leave enough room for trees. They've got hardscaping. They’ve got pools. Up
the street from me, they put in this house that literally goes from every inch of the lot. And they took
down every tree and there isn't room for a tree left. The only place for a tree would be the right way.
Um, so I think number four needs to be the issue that needs to be taken care of because you guys have
made the setbacks too small. If we want trees, you got to get people ready for trees. Then number
nine, you just can’t group palmettos there because then we’re going to have a whole town filled with
palmettos. And, that’s that even though they are a native tree, they are not meant to be our only tree.
They are meant to be mixed in. So, we need to make sure we have a mixed amount of trees. We can
also cause by having too many trees, cause a parasite and wipe them all out. So, you've got to have a
2
mix of trees. This guy [pointing to Mark Brodeur] seems like he knows what he's talking about. So, I
think we need to listen to what he's saying. Thank you.
Name is Phil Murdock, 913A North Ocean Boulevard, Surfside Beach, South Carolina. I've partnered
with Danny Osland, Osland Custom Homes, retired attorney, mostly retired attorney homes. But uh
couple of things wanted to make a point of. The first is as a developer, I always have, and we get a lot
of feedback from people who are building. Surfside was not developed as a tree farm. It was
developed to build houses. And I am always cognizant of the fact, because I live here myself that trees
are important because I certainly do not want to walk or walk my dog in a track home community, you
know, that where everything was clear cut, that is not that that does destroy the character of this
town. So I absolutely agree with having a tree ordinance. But I also ask that we be cognizant for the
few lots that are left because most of our lots are already developed, you know, and for those people
who are paying four or five, $600 ,000 for a tear down, because that's where the market is at this point,
that we do allow them to build on those lots to the extent that that are that is allowed you and some of
what we're talking about here is going to be a challenge to allow.
Um, when it comes to table 17.4.1, um, if we're going to do something like what you've got here, there
is a database that is, I think, very instructive for you guys, which is for the last 10 years, everything that
has been built in this town. There's been a lot of stuff built the last 10 years has got an as built survey
and that as built survey covers every tree, every pervious, impervious concrete, coverage, everything is
on that as built survey. I would highly recommend when it comes to finding an example, take these
categories if we're going to do this and take some of the as built that fits each one of these categories
and look at it from a practical standpoint and gauge that for your minimum, you know, your hardscape,
your softscape, your pool, you know, you need to look at that because if we create something that
suddenly you cannot build what everybody else has built for the last 10 years, then you are prejudicing
the people who are buying lots and buying teardowns at this point. So I think that you've got a
database of information that you can make use of by taking those as-builts and comparing them, you
take, take your, you know, your lot that's 3000 square foot. Look at that as-built and compare it to the
minimum lot landscape, the minimum front yard landscape and see how that measures up. See if you
can actually accomplish that build inside of the regulations that you're talking about. That's a great way
to cross check in my mind.
Jeanette Dubanoski: Based on your experience, do you have recommendations that you would want us
to consider?
Phil Murdock: Obviously, that would take a lot longer than five minutes, but certainly, again, I
compliment Mark and I compliment this committee for going back and looking through this stuff,
because we need direction, but at the same time, like I said, I do think that you guys really should take
a look at those as-builts and compare them just to see. Because then you could always go look at that
house and see what that looks like and if it looks like something hey that's kind of what I’m thinking
that I like you then you should be able to accomplish it within size you have 17.4.1. So the other thing I
was going to say when it comes to simplification and I think this might be a great example under 17.9
where you got the tree protection during construction I’m a big fan of military history I love George
Patton. You know, and he used to say never tell somebody else how to do something Tell them what
you want done and let them surprise you with their ingenuity. You know when it comes to all of this if
you tell them they got to keep the tree, let them figure out how to keep the tree. Because some of the
stuff that you got in here you're not going to be able to build the actual house and accomplish some of
the tree protection mechanisms that you're requiring here. And then you're gonna have for Nick out
there he's already got to deal with all the silt fence and everything else, but they're going to be running
3
around and measuring the drip underneath the tree and trying to put a fence around it. They got
knocked down every time the bulldozer went across it, trying to deliver materials. So like I said, maybe
just put in there a fine for the removal of that tree or that tree died because of something stupid that
happened, but let the contractor figure out to save the true, you know, as opposed to going through,
you know, half of the page of telling them what all they need to do. So that might be a great place
when it comes to simplification, just as an example. So, but again, thank you guys for looking at this.
This is very important, very important to us. It's impossible for us to design a house and tell somebody
what they can and can't do if we have no idea what we can and can't do. So thank y 'all.
Carolyn Pravlik: Reminded Commissioners that they cannot question the commenters.
Ruby Kreklau. 4
th South and Hollywood. Um, I just wanted to mention that also when you get a tree
permit and I believe that [unintelligible] can back me up on this you are actually supposed to display
that. I know a long time ago I had to get a permit for a tree and I was told you need to make sure that is
seen by anybody driving by. When was the last time anybody seen a permit when they drove by and
somebody was cutting something down. It is the same way with building. When you get a permit you
are supposed to display them. How many times have drove around and you see people working but
there is no permit? So I am not saying that is going to help anything, but at least it’s going help the
public – Oh, at least they have a permit. That is my two cents worth. Thank you.
My name is Dan Moskowitz. I don't live in Surfside. I live just outside of Surfside. The reason why I'm
here today is because I design houses for a living. I do a lot of work for Phil and other builders. I
probably design maybe about 25, 30 houses in Surfside. I know there's a lot of passions as far as the
trees go. Some people want to every single tree and, you know, some of the people I work for would
like to just wipe every tree off the map so they can build a house easier. All I care about is doing the
best job to, you know, navigate my clients through the permitting process to design within compliance.
I can't do that if the next guy that comes in can read the same code and interpret it a slightly different
way or an entirely different way. So, I realize this is a work in progress with certain things like the
mitigation paragraph, which I think is 17-10, I was chatting with Mark before kind of talking about this,
and we talked about the inch-per-inch replacement, how that might be a big cumbersome especially if
you have big trees you have to take out when it’s in the footprint. And he said, oh no, well, you know,
if it's in the footprint, if it's within that 10 feet footprint or driveway or pool, no mitigation is required.
It doesn't indicate that to me anywhere in there the way that's written. Like I said, I know this is a work
in progress, but those are things I'll be looking for because he can leave in six months, another guy can
come and he can read that paragraph and says, no, all trees you remove, you have to replace inch by
inch. It doesn't matter if it was in the footprint, it doesn't say that. These are things that I'd to include
specific language and I know we're trying to simplify this is kind of from the opposite way but maybe
there's a way we could do that without any pages more like paragraphs that's about it that's all I have
to say I just want to make my job I want to be consistent when I can do my job and not get surprised
because lots of these things happen under the radar for me too you know you guys will have these
meetings I'll know nothing about it new guy will come in you guys will have a new code and I've already
spent six months dealing with a client, their dream home and all of a sudden. Nope, this stuff isn't
allowed anymore and it's a huge headache. So that's a lot to say, thank you.
LaVerne Kreklau: [unintelligible] Um, I would just like to say after listening to the developers one of our
problems I believe on the trees is that we do allow too much or not enough room. In other words, I
guess the builable lot size has went down since I’ve lived here, which has been 10 years. And a lot of
homes that are being torn down are being subdivided into two lots and there’s two places being built
4
where there used to only be one. And I think that if we went back to a bigger builable lot size that it
would be kind of a win-win except for you couldn’t squeeze in all the houses that you possibly can. Uh
across the street from my where I live, there was a house there a long time ago and now there’s two.
The person that lives next to me, he actually has two lots. It probably could end up being subdivided
into 3. And I think it's just that is kind of the root of the problem in my opinion. I think the lot size,
buildable lot size should be readdressed and because it’s going to continue to be a problem as the
smaller homes get tore down, the big ones get built, you don’t have enough room for trees. And like
they say, they don’t have the room for them and it is a problem. My two cents worth.
My name is Mark Watson and I live at 611 10th Avenue South Surfside Beach. I am probably here as
the voice of a quiet majority who really just want to be left the hell alone. Um, and the problem is
most of us want to be left alone so badly we’re not even here. But I’m passionate about being left
alone. Fundamentally to me, if it were up to me, there would be no tree ordinance regulating owners
of an existing residential property. To me, that's an oppressive thing that shouldn't even exist. Going
into my yard and counting how many diameter inches I have to have of a tree is just fundamentally
wrong. I understand that we have one and understand that this is a workshop to try to figure out how
to best do it. But to me, not only would we scrap this, but we'd have a pleasant conversation about
how to repeal taking 17-723.1 as far as going into my yard, my private yard, and telling me how many
diameter inches of trees and how many permits I have to have in order to cut a tree and this sort of
thing. But a tree is foliage. I happen to love trees, I really do. And in a Christlike way, I love people
who love trees. But it's fundamentally wrong to me to infringe on my property rights like that. I really
would hope you'd consider that. So every time we talk about going from going down to six inches, I
cringe. And every time we talk about making sure that we have a certain amount of inches in my yard, I
cringe, and I hope you would understand that there's a ton of people in this town that really just want
to be left alone. And I would encourage you to consider that. I'll leave you with this. In my mind,
municipal government has a purpose. Let's make sure that we've got a safe and clean beach. Maybe
we could reinforce the leash law that seems to just completely get ignored on the beach. Let's make
sure we've got streets there in good shape, sidewalks that are in good shape. Let’s make parks look
good. Let's make sure we've got strong fire and police time for all of that. But municipal government
should not be in the business at all of regulating how many diameter branches of tree I have in my
yard. It absolutely should not. And we shouldn't, because then we get in the business of having
neighbors rat on each other, which is what I've heard. And it just doesn't engender a society that really
is pleasant to me. So, I would hope y'all would consider that. I appreciate the work you do. I
appreciate all the work that you did. This is quite a work. I would love to see all that work scrapped,
but it doesn't change the fact that I think we can all agree to disagree. Thank you.
Hi, I'm John Hyatt. I'm your liaison, but I'm not here as a liaison. I'm here as a private citizen. I’d like to
make just a few comments. Um, one is on the tree removal that is happening over the weekend. I was
kind of appalled this summer. I saw like nine in my little neighborhood and perhaps it would be easier
than have this gentleman take time on the weekends to just require the tree company to have a permit
in hand. And if they don't, then they can be cited by the police or whoever. That might be a simple
way to solve that. Also, I'm kind of a fan of lower penalties with escalation clauses for the people that
make mistakes. I don't like them to be hurt too bad, but the people that think they can just use their
money to buy exceptions, I think the tree ordinance should have escalations so that if they pay $15,000
for this tree, they pay 30 for the next and 45 for the next or something like that. I agree with what
people say about the size of lots. Big houses on small lots is not a friend of canopies. It's also not a
friend of children, and we're a fan of the beach. We have very little room for kids to play around their
houses, their new houses. We don't allow them to play in the streets by ordinance. You know, we don't
5
have a basketball court in our town for them. We want to be a family beach, but every time we see
decisions get made, it seems like we move away from being a family beach. I really like the idea of a
tree fund where people can mediate the removal of trees that might be prohibited or at least try to
protect it. And then if we do allow that money to be spent to give trees to the public, then the public's
planning those on their property and taking care of them. It doesn't mean that John Adair and his
other clerks department has to plant and take care of. I think that's a win-win for everyone. I really like
the idea that Mark suggested about worrying about the future canopy. You know, I love trees and I
love canopies and I've spent a long time in my life in the wilderness and I've never really considered, in
fact, the responsibility to build a canopy for the future, because the canopies we're looking at are going
to die at some point. And we've got to make sure that there's canopies in the future, and I really like
that idea, and I hope that you will incorporate that into whatever you choose to do. Another thing that
I'd like to point out is that sometimes people don't tell the truth about removing trees. They say, I want
to put a pool in, I want to put an addition on, they take on the tree and everybody, you know, says
that's fine. Well, maybe we should require that addition of that pool within 18 months or else treat it
as an illegal removal of the tree. I think that's it. Thanks for listening.
Bill Kinken 1312 N Dogwood. Mark, if you can make the thing four pages, please do. I was on council
last hour on planning last time we looked at it and it made my head spin trying to go through each
section by each section by each section. We shouldn't do that. Lot size is a better way to go. As far as
businesses, they have a business license. That license ought to restrict them to where that can work
unless they get an approval from planning and zoning to work on the weekend. They shouldn't be
allowed to work on the weekend. You know, it's just something we should look at. I mean, it's open a
bar all night long. We have restrictions on how long you can work. Why can't we do it? Because that is
what you see. They come out on the weekend, they cut a tree down, they're gone, nobody knows
about it. And the only way to stop it's fine. And once they pay a few fines, the more we get out. And
every tree they cut down is a landmark tree, because it's not there, it was a landmark tree. You just tell
them that it's going to be $15 ,000. There is a fair ordinance that kind of bothers me and that's the 10-
foot rule. I've had trees close to my house and I had to pay somebody to come in and trim the roots so
that the tree could stay there and not damage my house. It's not very expensive. In fact, it was
cheaper than getting our harvest to come write me a letter to cut a tree down. So, you know, it's
doable. Just somebody has to be willing to say, wait a minute, you can probably, just based on where it
is. Now, if it's right next to the house, you can't do that. But if it's sitting 10 feet away, those roots don't
go into that house, except in one area, and you just trim them. So, it's something to look at. Keep it
simple please because like I said my head spent when I was going through this first time and even the
second time and the third time so thank you all for what you're doing we need I think we need a strong
tree ordinance so that we don't get clear cut and Thank you.
Laura Sue Watson, I also live at 611 10th Avenue South in Surfside, and one of my big concerns in this is
you know to say, you say that it's not going to harm the individual that what you're really looking for is
the developer who's coming in and clear-cutting. The clear-cutting that you're worried about, the
clear-cutting that you're worried about, and yet you don't, yet your ordinance does still affect the
individual homeowner. We have a tree in our front yard that has a hole in it and I get concerned that
it's going to fall on somebody. We've got a round driveway if somebody comes and visits if that tree
goes over while the car is there or while we have, you know, children playing in the yard, I get
concerned about it. And because of the ordinance that's in place, I don't know if I can cut it or not. I
don't know what it's going to cost me, and that scares me. And then the second thing was, if you have.
A big sick tree that you take it down, and it's, you know, 40 caliber inches, and you have to replace it
with 40 caliber inches, are you not and putting too many trees in that space for them to grow and get
6
big and healthy because you've got to have enough space for the tree to get big in order for it to have
enough sunshine and have enough light to get big. So that may be overcrowding if you do it that way.
And then the last thing was I do love a canopy at times.
I'm also a gardener. I love fresh tomatoes. And if you have too many trees in your yard, you cannot
grow fresh tomatoes. It doesn't work. And so I would like also to have the ability to take a few trees
out of my yard so that I have space so that I can have a garden where the sun will hit it enough so that I
can put my tomatoes in my garden in my own yard. And these are things that this tree ordinance is
getting in the way of me doing in my own yard. And so it is affecting me as a personal person, single
individual homeowner. So maybe it's not, I'm not wanting to go in and clear cut everything. I've got
palmettoes, I've got magnolias that I absolutely want to leave there.
I've just got a couple of big trees. One of them looks sick to me. And one of them is real close to my
yard and real close to my house. And then I would just find just enough space put some tomatoes in
and I don't know if I can. Thank you.
Hi, my name is Ken Podraza.
I live on 616 10th Avenue North.
I'm also a member of the storm water committee.
First I'd like to say thank you for your kind comments about what the storm water committee has done
in the past in regard to this other chapter 18.
I'd also like to thank Mark for your kind comments also.
Appreciate that.
So each member of the stormwater committee will be speaking today.
We're going to focus on the draft revised chapter 17 regulation.
I'm not going to comment on it.
The members of the stormwater committee have worked on a separate proposed chapter 18
landscaping, tree protection, and canopy preservation tree regulations for several years.
During that time we had the help of various surfside beach employees, tree experts, arborists, regional
and state experts, examined similar regulations throughout South Carolina, neighboring states and
coastal areas along the East Coast.
It became very knowledgeable about the topic and bring that knowledge to bear in the comments that
will be made for today.
We request that you all use proposed chapter 18 tree ordinance as a source of information since it
directly addresses the town of Surfside Beach.
The proposed Chapter 18 regulation was presented to town council, the administration, and is available
on our stormwater committee website.
So today, we're going to highlight some of the most critical concerns about the Draft 17, Revised 17
tree regulation, comment on specific sections, and end with closing comments.
Storm water committee will provide our written comments to the town council, the planning
commission, the director, and posted on our storm water committee website and with the proposed
chapter 18 tree ordinance and that the tree canopy study was conducted in 2024 for the Surfside Beach
township.
You're also going to get that on the website to make sure that it's utilized.
Speaking to you today, it is important to recognize that the community of Surfside Beach gets to decide
on what we want our town to look like in the future.
These decisions will impact our community for many decades ahead, since large trees take decades to
centuries to mature.
7
We can preserve our unique community with our many mature and diverse trees that create beautiful
tree canopy where shade in the summer gives us cool temperatures, where the birds and wildlife
thrive, flooding is reduced, stormwater is filtered and diluted with pollutants that do enter the ocean,
and the air is made cleaner.
All that being provided by our trees.
Or we can be like many of our other coastal waterfront communities, where they have very few trees,
they this hot sun-baked homes, no wildlife, and constantly address flooding issues.
It's our choice.
So we will begin with overarching concerns with the draft revised chapter 18, tree and landscape
regulation.
So number one, using a lot size category over zone districts is a good idea.
However, why are there so many lot size categories?
The draft revised regulations are only changing requirements for the current R1 zone category.
Proposed Chapter 18 recommendations changing the R1 zone category into two lot size categories,
which would make it much easier for compliance and enforcement.
Number two, in the draft revised Chapter 17 regulation, the minimum number of trees will not change
for zone R1 and R3, excuse me, R2 and R3 categories.
Only R1 zone categories change with an increase in the number of trees.
Secondly, the draft revised Chapter 17 regulation reduced the minimum total diameter in all categories,
which will result in our largest trees most likely being lost.
We have to look both at number of trees and diameter to really get that balance correct.
We recommend keeping the current total cumulative diameter with a two inch increase with each
additional tree required for the lot size category.
Please see the proposed chapter 18 regulation ordinance for this requirement for more detailed
information.
Number three, the draft revised regulation has set a hierarchy for decision making to be crystal clear.
It starts with having the correct number of trees the total cumulative diameter for a specific lot size.
Both criteria are required, just as they are in the current Chapter 17 regulation today.
We suggest making a hierarchy list within this draft revised Chapter 17, starting with the correct
number of trees for cumulative diameter for a specific lot size.
Number four, the draft revised Chapter 17 regulation makes it simple having only two categories of
trees, protected trees and landmark trees designated by trunk size.
This has some issues.
First, normally there are only a few tree species designated as landmark trees because of their special
attributes such as being a native species and many other environmental benefits.
The live oak is a good example.
Please consider using the invocation of landmark trees with proposed chapter 18 words.
Number five, palm and palmetto should not be designated as protected in landmark trees.
These are really not technical trees. They're grasses. They grow as tall.
They grow tall in woody herbs.
They do not have a tree canopy or provide shade much even. Water absorption is low.
Roots are shallow and does not offer erosion resistance.
Doesn't shelter wild[life].
Designating palms and palmetto as trees in the draft revised chapter 17 tree regulation will enable the
majority of the town's urban trees to become mainly palm and palmetto trees.
Just to change our natural environment.
We suggest, as we did in the proposed chapter 18 words, to count a maximum of two palm or palmetto
trees, a total maximum of 12 inches in cumulative diameter with a lot size [unintelligible].
8
Homeowners may plant as many palmetto or palm trees as they would like to plant, as many like, but
only two plants count. [Time expired]
So pass it off now.
I'm Dixie Budd and I live at 411 Fifth Avenue, North.
So we're going to comment on the sections that you have tonight that we're looking at.
There's some redundancy, but you know.
Okay, section 17.2 of applicability.
These regulations should apply to all situations including development, redevelopment, et cetera, to
make the process crystal clear.
Should be questions.
Section 17.3, administrative authority.
We talk about town's development director.
I've never heard of this position in Surfside.
Whoever's accountable must be assigned by job position and title.
Number three, exemption for existing residential lots not engaged in tree activity.
The first sentence reads, no minimum tree coverage is required for existing home.
This is unclear because many residents may mistakenly assume that their existing homes will not have
to obtain any tree removal permit or follow any tree regulated regulations.
The sentence is not necessary and probably should be removed because of Yeah, figure it out.
The statement on the on about the fifth line starting with this exemption applies only to routine
maintenance and does not exist with property owners.
What is routine maintenance? Routine maintenance is unclear because it's not defined.
The paragraph is inconsistent with section 17.3, item one. Section 17.3, item one, coming up.
Permit is not required, exempt.
The first paragraph, first sentence says, tree removal, et cetera, provided all tree removal work is
reviewed by the town staff first.
Well, this whole section can't be an exemption if you need someone to review the information.
You are required to submit the tree work. A tree removal permit should be required for any tree work
that requires review by the authorized staff at Surfside.
Additionally, use of the wording like town staff does not specifically identify the appropriate job title or
person who is an accountable.
An accountable job title person must be identified to ensure compliance is documented.
Number one, dead, dying, or hazardous trees.
Most residents are not qualified to adequately determine if a tree is dead or is in significant decline.
Often town staff are not tree experts, So this paragraph is confusing.
Again, the town's development director, who makes hazard determinations is not known or a known
staff position, and we don't know how this person is qualified to determine hazards.
If the director denies the determination, what is the appeal process?
The town may require post removal, photograph or verification.
Seems arbitrary and not enforceable by suggesting leaving the sentence.
So you're getting down to those four pages.
Small and unprotected trees.
Number two, small and unprotected trees under six inches DBH.
Measurement of the tree diameter DBH, which is four and a half feet from the ground may result in a
reduction of the residents current total cumulative diameter.
The current chapter 17 regulation has the measurement being made at two feet from the ground has
this been technically addressed.
9
The first bullet must state that the lot size category requirements of both the tree number total
cumulative diameter requirements must be satisfied.
The second bullet, designated for invasive or nuisance species should be eliminated since all trees have
some value.
If invasive or nuisance species section is not removed, it's just another level of complexity that most in
the town are not experts in this knowledge and it would be difficult to enforce.
Property owners must notify the town, this is number three within five business days after emergency
removal, who is this person or position that they must notify?
Is this exemption for all town council declared emergencies or any emergency a homeowner may
encounter?
Seems like a problem during major emergencies and what is this supposed to accomplish? The
problem removal will still occur unless pictures are required.
Number four, routine pruning and maintenance.
The first bullet, normal pruning every 12 months.
Seems like a loophole to allow for more pruning every year.
It's not advisable.
Section 17A lists exemptions for pruning or trimming branches at less than six inches in diameter, so
therefore this is unnecessary continuing.
Second bullet, removal of dead wood under four inches in diameter.
It's inconsistent with the rest of the draft revised regulation for trees or limbs, which is stated as under
six inches.
Residential yard maintenance, the paragraph is unclear.
The exemption cannot be both removal of unprotected nuisance trees any size and then no exemption
if identified as protected for landmark tree.
How can this be enforced?
Trees in specific locations.
The 10 foot buffer rule should be eliminated since our setbacks in some easement areas and many
driveways have trees 10 feet or less from these specified locations.
The draft revised regulation allows all trees to be potentially cut down without a tree permit.
[Time expired]
Scott Von Buseck: Point of Order made regarding pre-planned comments by the Stormwater
Committee.
Carolyn Pravlik: Allowed the comments by the members of the Stormwater Committee.
Hi, it's Yvette Hellier, 7th Avenue North, and I'm also a member of the stormwater committee. Thank
you for your time. I know this is not the most fun thing to be doing.
I wanted to pick up where my previous colleague left off on that paragraph six, be located in a specified
location.
It should modify to require actual visual structural problems that occurred and then require a permit.
The tree branches over a driveway pruning a tree 15 to 20 feet eliminates the problem with the
driveway and saves the mature tree.
A section 17-3.2 tree permit required, the section is confusing with there being a section 17-5 permit
requirements.
Why are there two permit required sections? It didn't quite make sense to us.
Pruning or trimming beyond routine maintenance.
10
Routine maintenance, again, it's not defined.
Every 12 months for trimming or pruning means that 25 percent of the tree could be eliminated every
year, which is not a healthy tree practice.
Structural pruning, topping, and cutting, damages trees, but the paragraph in the regulation allows for
it to be made by permit.
In the definition section, topping is a prohibitive practice, so this seems to be a contradiction.
We would recommend, instead of tree topping, add tree dead wooding, because that dead wooding is
a practice that is in abriculture that allows for the health of the tree to be enhanced.
Construction or land disturbance impacts really needs to talk about the critical root zone. It's not
defined, it doesn't speak about the survivability that trees need to have when their roots are impacted.
And construction sites and development sites, the number one reason we lose trees is because the
roots are not taken care of and protected.
Replacement or mitigation plan approval, this is really a tough one for us because any activity that
triggers removal of a protected landscape tree over six inches dbh must include either or, replacement
or mitigation plan.
It's really dependent on, we think, the correct number of trees and the total cumulative diameter. For
the specific lot category, if this is meant to be a requirement, the regulations must make it clear.
Definition sections I could go into a long detail about.
All I really want to get, you'll get our written comments.
So what I really want to get down to is take advantage of the chapter 18 proposed tree ordinance that
we put together because if you're going to have a tree ordinance, you should have tree definitions to
make it clearer.
Folks really don't know, and that's a good way to educate.
And the hand out option works recommended, we highly recommend that too.
Any which way you can provide outreach and education information to the public, make them aware.
This town for 30 years had people who lived here and knew what it meant to save their trees, to keep
their legacy going.
And we're getting an influx of a lot of people coming from a lot of places that want to not live in that
kind of thought, but yet this is the trees are the reason why people come here. So we really do have to
find a balance. One of them is, I will repeat, palms are not trees. I love them.
They enhance a property, they give us the tropical vibe, but they don't produce the benefits that trees
do.
So go ahead, plant as many palm trees as you like, which you should only be able to count two, and up
to 12 inches.
And then that way we can structure a balance to be ensuring that our tree canopy continues to be
sustained. Are we done?
So thank you, we will send you our written comments because we do have a lot of detail. We will look
forward to your next edition.
I would really like to see that one-page ordinance. Fascinated by that.
And if you have any questions, you need any help, please contact us because we would like very much
to see the right decisions be made.
And we are a 37 page ordinance that had everything comprehensive for the town of Surfside Beach.
We completely understood that it would not become the ordinance.
So thank you very much.
Chris Stamey. 715 Cedar Drive. I'm not here to represent Stormwater, I here to represent myself. Well,
uh, it's hard work, y 'all. And I appreciate it from a citizen of this town. I, and I believe me, I went
11
through with stormwater committee for three years. It is hard. And I hope that the time we get
something to council, that it will be something that council can live with, the citizens of this town can
live with -- that one page would be great. You know, if more than if you feel less is better, the better it
is. But you've got to have something if it takes 15 pages got to have something that people can enforce.
People can read and understand what they're reading and looking at. So with that, thank you all and
the people that worked for you.
Keith Ashby. 13th Avenue North. I am not on the stormwater committee. I just want to say, Mark,
please get it down to four pages. And in fact, I challenge you to get it to one page. Because the way it
is now, I don't think a majority of citizens are even going to look at it. Anybody wants to do tree work,
they're going to look at that and they're going to say, I'm going to do what I want to do. Or they're
going to call you guys to say, can I do what I want to do? Or neighbors want to call you guys and say,
Hey, my neighbors do on this.
And so, you know, we got to get it down. You know, it reminds me of the of the resume rule, right?
One page resume because if it's longer than that, nobody's going to read it. So one page, please.
Thank you.
6. ADJOURNMENT: Ms. Abrams made the motion to adjourn. Mr. Monson second. Everyone was in
favor.
Source: Town of Surfside Beach website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.