RecordWell Data

BOA-26-33, 760 Bay Springs Rd. (County) - Staff Report

City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other

Open the original document More from City of Sumter

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Sumter City-County Board of Zoning Appeals October 14, 2026 BOA-26-33, 760 Bay Springs Dr. (County) The applicant (Carrie D. Tisdale) is appealing the Zoning Administrator’s determination that the structures used to keep chickens on the property are subject to the requirements of Article 3.x: Farming, including the stated setback requirements from residential property lines for barns, stables, pens, or other animal shelters. The applicant contends that the keeping of chickens on the property does not qualify as a farming activity/operation as defined in the Zoning Ordinance and therefore the setbacks provided for in Article 3.x: Farming are not applicable. The property is located at 760 Bay Springs Dr., is zoned Residential-15 (R-15), and is represented by TMS# 207-01-07-013. 2 Sumter City-County Zoning Board of Appeals October 14, 2026 BOA-26-33, 760 Bay Springs Dr. (County) I. THE REQUEST Applicant: Carrie D. Tisdale Status of the Applicant: Property Owner Request: The applicant is appealing the Zoning Official’s de termination that the structures used to keep chickens on the property are subject to the requirements of Article 3.x: Farming, including the stated setback requirements from residential property lines for barns, stables, pens, or other animal shelters. County Council District: District 4 Location: 760 Bay Springs Dr. Zoning: Residential-15 (R-15) Tax Map Reference: 207-01-07-013 II. B ACKGROUND The applicant, hereby referred to as the “appellant”, i s appeali ng the zoning official’s (Zoning Administrator) determination that the structures used to keep chickens on the property are subject to the requirements of Article 3.x: Farming of the Sumter County Zoning & Development Standards Ordinance (the “Zoning Ordinance”) . This provision mandates a 100- foot setback from nearest residential property lines for barns, stables, pens, or other animal shelters. The appellant contends that keeping personal 3 companion chickens does not qualify as a farming activity/operation under the Zoning Ordinance and that the Article 3.x.1 setback standards are therefore inapplicable. The property is located on the west side of Bay Springs Dr. within the Bay Springs Subdivision located off McCray’s Mill Rd. The property is shown in red on the location map on pg. 2 of this report and is located within the R-15 zoning district. The following exhibits are an integral component of this appeal case and are referenced throughout this report: Figure 1: 2026 Aerial Imagery Exhibit # Description 1 Appeal Application 2 Appellant Appeal Narrative & Site Plan 3 Zoning Official Determination 4 Written Correspondence W/ Appellant 5 Notice of Violation – 8-24-26 6 Notice of Violation – 9-9-26 7 Article 3.x.1: Farming 8 Article 10 – Agriculture Definition 9 Article 10 – Farm or Farmland Definition 4 The timeline of the events resulting in this appeal are summarized below: 1. Mid-July 2026 – A complaint from a resident concerning the subject property was received. The complaint concerned the number of chickens and number of structures housing said chickens on the property located at 760 Bay Springs Dr. 2. July 30, 2026 – Planning staff conducted aerial photographic analysis and performed a visual site inspection from the Bay Springs Drive public right-of-way. 3. August 24, 2026 – The Zoning Administrator issued a Notice of Violation (NOV) regarding the total number of accessory structures. The NOV also cited that the activity appeared to meet the definition of a commercial poultry house under Article 10, a use not permitted in R-15. See Exhibit 5. 4. August 31, 2026 – The appellant responded by email, proposing a consolidation plan for accessory structures and clarifying that the flock is maintained solely as personal hobby/rescue pets rather than a commercial operation. See Exhibit 4. Note: At this time, staff is not contesting that the keeping of chickens is non- commercial. 5. September 9, 2026 – The Zoning Administrator notified the appellant that Article 3.x.1 setbacks apply to animal shelters housing chickens, requiring a 100- foot setback from residential property lines, and issued an updated NOV outlining available options. See Exhibit 4 & Exhibit 6. 6. September 9, 2026 - The appellant replied inquiring into the formal administrative appeal process in lieu of requesting variance relief. See Exhibit 4. 7. September 10, 2026 – In response to staff inquiry, the appellant confirmed that approximately 50 chickens are housed on the property, noting that most are rescue animals, including ~20 recently acquired from a military family reassigned to Guam. See Exhibit 4. 8. September 10, 2026 - The Zoning Administrator issued a formal written determination that Article 3.x.1 setbacks govern the shelters, accompanied by appeal submission instructions See Exhibit 2. 9. September 17, 2026 – The appellant emailed additional information concerning the nature of the chickens being kept on the property. See Exhibit 4. 10. September 21, 2026 – The appellant submitted a complete BOA Appeal Application (Forms 1 & 2), accompanied by an appeal narrative and proposed site plan. See Exhibit 1 & Exhibit 2. 5 Figure 2: Applicant Site Plan The Board of Zoning Appeals (BOA) BOA has the explicit authority to hear such appeals pursuant to Article 1.h.4. of the Zoning Ordinance. 1.h.4. Powers of the Board of Zoning Appeals: It is the intention of this Ordinance that all questions arising in connection with the enforcement of this Ordinance shall be presented first to the Zoning Administrator and that such questions shall be presented to the Board of Zoning Appeals only on appeal from the Zoning Administrator. The Board of Zoning Appeals shall have the following powers and duties: a. Appeals from administrative interpretation: To hear and decide appeals where it is alleged there is an error in an order, requirement, decision, or determination made by an administrative official of the Sumter City-County Planning Commission in the enforcement of the Zoning Ordinance… III. APPEAL Zoning Administrator Position The position of the Zoning Official is as follows: 6 1. Pursuant to written communication with the appellant, approximately 50 chickens are housed on the property in small structures located in the rear yard of the property. See Exhibit 4. 2. The keeping of approximately 50 chickens on the property constitutes agricultural activity, meeting the agriculture definition in Article 10 of the Zoning Ordinance. See Exhibit 8. This determination is based on the fact that an agricultural product (eggs) is produced from the chickens. While it is staff’s understanding that the eggs produced by the chickens on the property are given away, and not sold, there is still a product being produced. 3. Article 3.x.1. is applicable to general farming operations, including the keeping of approximately 50 chickens on a residential lot. 4. Article 3.x.1. of the Zoning Ordinance states that all accessory and principal buildings associated with said use shall meet the minimum yard and setback requirements for the district in which the farming use is lo cated, except that barns, stables, pens, or other animal shelter shall be located not closer than 100 ft. to the nearest residential property. These requirements are applicable to the buildings, structures, and/or enclosures serving the chickens on the property. 5. The language in Article 3.x.1 of the Zoning Ordinance states that farming operations can be of a personal nature and do not have to be commercial. 6. A definition of “farm” or “farmland” exists in Article 10 of the Zoning Ordinance. This definition includes a 35- acre minimum acreage requirement. Staff asserts that farming activity can take place on property that does not formally meet the definition of a farm. Appellant Position The appellant submitted the standard BOA application (Forms 1 & 2) for an appeal from action of a zoning official on September 21, 2026. The appellant is taking the following positions: 1. The action of the Zoning Official was erroneous because – The animals kept are personal pets whose value is companionship, not agricultural production or commercial value. The keeping of the animals on the property is not an agricultural enterprise, in that animals or eggs are not sold. Rather, the animals are kept, housed, and cared for pets. 2. Appellant is aggrieved by the action or decision in that – The determination classifies a private, non-commercial residential use as farming and subjects my property to setback requirements that the property cannot physically satisfy. The animals are maintained as personal pets and not for agricultural production or commercial purposes. A plan to 7 comply violations pertaining to the overall number of structures has been submitted and is believed to be acceptable means to achieve compliance. 3. Appellant contends that the correct interpretation of the Zoning Ordinance as applied to the property is – That private non- commercial keeping of companion animals on a residential property does not constitute a “farming use” subject to setback requirements in Article 3.x.1 of the Zoning Ordinance. Applying this standard would affect most property owners of personal flocks with the county. 4. Appellant requests the following relief – Reverse staff’s determination that the property constitutes a farming use and interpret the Zoning Ordinance based upon the actual and stated purpose for which the animals are kept, as privately owned pets and companion animals, not for commercial or agricultural production and determine that the setbacks requirements in Article 3.x.1 of the Zoning Ordinance are not applicable to this situation. The above is a summary of the statements made within the formal appeal application. The appellant provided additional information and appeal arguments in the summary and site plan attached as Exhibit 2. IV. BOARD INFORMATION Per Article 1.h.4.a of the Zoning Ordinance, the BOA must decide if there is an error in the order, requirement, decision, or determination of the Zoning Administrator pertaining to the position that the keeping of 50 chickens on the property constitutes general farming operations subject to the requirements of Article 3.x.1 of the Zoning Ordinance. If the BOA makes the decision to affirm the Zoning Administrator’s determination, the appellant will need to come into compliance with the Zoning Ordinance. This process could include seeking a variance from the BOA concerning Article 3.x.1 setback requirements. If the BOA makes the decision to reverse the Zoning Administrator’s determination, then Article 3.x.1 setbacks will not be applicable to this situation and the appellant can move forward with plans to resolve compliance issues concerning the number of accessory structures on the property by consolidating all chicken keeping activity to structures compliant with Article 4.g: Accessory Buildings & Uses of the Zoning Ordinance. IV. DRAFT MOTIONS FOR BOA-26-33 A. I move that the Zoning Board of Appeals Affirm the Zoning Official’s determination that the requirements of Article 3.x.1 of the Zoning Ordinance are applicable to the keeping and sheltering of chickens on the property, subject to the findings of fact and conclusions developed by the BZA and so stated: B. I move that the Zoning Board of Appeals Reverse the Zoning Official’s determination that the requirements of Article 3.x.1 of the Zoning Ordinance are applicable to the 8 keeping and sheltering of chickens on the property, subject to the findings of fact and conclusions developed by the BZA and so stated: C. I move that the Zoning Board of Appeals enter an alternative motion for BOA-26-33. V. BOARD OF APPEALS – October 14, 2026 Exhibit 1 Exhibit 2 Exhibit 3 Exhibit 4 Exhibit 5 Sumter City-County Planning Department DERON L. MCCORMICK HELEN M. ROODMAN GARY M. MIXON CITY MANAGER PLANNING DIRECTOR COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR 12 W. LIBERTY STREET • PO BOX 1449 • SUMTER, SC 29151 OFFICE: (803) 774-1660 • FAX (803) 774-1687 August 24, 2026 Carrie D. Tisdale Property Owner of Record (760 Bay Springs Dr.) 760 Bay Springs Dr. Sumter, SC 29154 RE: Zoning Violation Notice 760 Bay Springs Dr. TMS# 207-01-07-013 Dear Property Owner: This letter serves as a formal notice of zoning violation for property located at 760 Bay Springs Dr. and further identified as TMS# 207-01-07-013 (the “Property”) on Sumter County tax parcel maps as of the date of this letter. The property is zoned Residential-15 (R-15). Based on observations and available information, current land uses on the Property appear to violate the Sumter County Zoning & Development Standards Ordinance (the “Zoning Ordinance”). Specifically, agricultural activity including the keeping of fowl/poultry is occurring on the property. While limited poultry keeping is permitted within a residential zoning district , the activity observed appears to meet the definition of a commercial poultry house as stated in Article 10.b1: Definitions of the Zoning Ordinance. Commercial poultry houses are not permitted in residential zoning districts. Definition - Poultry House, Commercial (Article 10.b.1): A building or structure where chickens, turkeys, ducks, or other domestic birds are raised exclusively for commercial use, and where the structure(s)in which they are housed is not less than 200 sq. ft. in aggregate. Additionally, the Property appears to contain more accessory structures associated with poultry keeping than permitted in residential zoning districts. Although the accessory structures do not appear to exceed 120 sq. ft. in size, the number of structures exceeds the ma ximum allowed. See below. Article 4.g.2.a.3. – Any accessory building 120 sq. ft. in size or smaller (i.e. play houses, well pump houses, and other similar uses) will not be counted as accessory structures. However, they must comply with accessory structure 5 ft. minimum setbacks and shall be limited to 2 per parcel. Please be aware that other violations may exist. Should additional issues be identified, they will be communicated promptly for resolution. VIOLATION: Evidence indicates violations of the following Zoning Ordinance provisions: ➢ Article 3, Exhibit 5: Permitted Uses in All Zoning Districts ➢ Article 4.g.2.a.3: Residential Accessory Structures (Conditions & Exceptions) REQUIRED CORRECTIVE ACTION(S): 1. Contact the Zoning Administrator to schedule a meeting regarding this matter on or prior to September 9, 2026. 2. Comply with requests for additional information pertaining to the Property. 3. Comply with the terms of any agreement established to resolve zoning violations on the property. The Sumter City-County Planning Department’s goal is to work cooperatively with property owners and tenants to achieve voluntary compliance with the Zoning Ordinance. Failure to complete the corrective actions listed above may result in further enforcement measures, which could include issuance of a formal citation/court summons or other civil remedies available to Sumter County. Please contact me at 803-774-1611 or jderwort@sumtersc.gov to discuss your plans for bringing the property into compliance. I have enclosed documents of the ordinance referred to above for your records. I look forward to working with you to address this issue. Sincerely, Jeff Derwort, AICP Zoning Administrator cc: Helen Roodman, Planning Director Exhibit 6 Sumter City-County Planning Department DERON L. MCCORMICK HELEN M. ROODMAN GARY M. MIXON CITY MANAGER PLANNING DIRECTOR COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR 12 W. LIBERTY STREET • PO BOX 1449 • SUMTER, SC 29151 OFFICE: (803) 774-1660 • FAX (803) 774-1687 September 9, 2026 Carrie D. Tisdale Property Owner of Record (760 Bay Springs Dr.) 760 Bay Springs Dr. Sumter, SC 29154 RE: Zoning Violation Notice 760 Bay Springs Dr. TMS# 207-01-07-013 Dear Property Owner: This letter serves as a formal notice of zoning violation for property located at 760 Bay Springs Dr. and further identified as TMS# 207-01-07-013 (the “Property”) on Sumter County tax parcel maps as of the date of this letter. The property is zoned Residential-15 (R-15). Based on observations and available information, current land uses on the Property appear to violate the Sumter County Zoning & Development Standards Ordinance (the “Zoning Ordinance”). Specifically, agricultural activity including the keeping of fowl /poultry is occurring on the property. While limited poultry keeping is permitted within a residential zoning district , the activity observed appears to meet the definition of a commercial poultry house as stated in Article 10.b1: Definitions of the Zoning Ordinance. Commercial poultry houses are not permitted in residential zoning districts. Definition - Poultry House, Commercial (Article 10.b.1): A building or structure where chickens, turkeys, ducks, or other domestic birds are raised exclusively for commercial use, and where the structure(s)in which they are housed is not less than 200 sq. ft. in aggregate. The Property appears to contain more accessory structures associated with poultry keeping than permitted in residential zoning districts. Although the accessory structures do not appear to exceed 120 sq. ft. in size, the number of structures exceeds the maximum allowed. See below. Article 4.g.2.a.3. – Any accessory building 120 sq. ft. in size or smaller (i.e. play houses, well pump houses, and other similar uses) will not be counted as accessory structures. However, they must comply with accessory structure 5 ft. minimum setbacks and shall be limited to 2 per parcel. Additionally, the structures on the property used for chicken keeping violate the setback requirements listed for minimum yard and setback requirements for barns, stables, pens, animal shelters pertaining to livestock. Please be aware that other violations may exist. Should additional issues be identified, they will be communicated promptly for resolution. VIOLATION: Evidence indicates violations of the following Zoning Ordinance provisions: ➢ Article 3, Exhibit 5: Permitted Uses in All Zoning Districts ➢ Article 3.x.1. ➢ Article 4.g.2.a.3: Residential Accessory Structures (Conditions & Exceptions) REQUIRED CORRECTIVE ACTION(S): 1. Contact the Zoning Administrator regarding this matter on or prior to September 16, 2026, and identify plans for compliance based on information provided in my email to you dated September 9, 2026. 2. Comply with requests for additional information pertaining to the Property. 3. Comply with the terms of any agreement established to resolve zoning violations on the property. The Sumter City-County Planning Department’s goal is to work cooperatively with property owners and tenants to achieve voluntary compliance with the Zoning Ordinance. Failure to complete the corrective actions listed above may result in further enforcement measures, which could include issuance of a formal citation/court summons or other civil remedies available to Sumter County. Please contact me at 803-774-1611 or jderwort@sumtersc.gov to discuss your plans for bringing the property into compliance. I have enclosed documents of the ordinance referred to above for your records. I look forward to working with you to address this issue. Sincerely, Jeff Derwort, AICP Zoning Administrator cc: Helen Roodman, Planning Director Exhibit 7 Exhibit 8 Exhibit 9

Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.