RecordWell Data

BOA-26-29, 7056 Camden Hwy. (County) - Staff Report

City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other

Open the original document More from City of Sumter

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Sumter City-County Board of Zoning Appeals September 9, 2026 BOA-26-29, 7056 Camden Hwy. (County) The Board of Zoning Appeals will consider a request from Harmoni Gateway Towers, LLC to establish a 279 ft. tall telecommunications tower on the property. The Zoning Administrator has referred this request to the Board of Zoning Appeals consistent with Article 5.b.4: Communication Towers and Antenne of the Sumter County Zoning & Development Standards Ordinance. The property is located at 7056 Camden Hwy., is zoned Agricultural Conservation (AC), and is identified as TMS# 088-00-03-028. 2 Sumter City-County Zoning Board of Appeals September 9, 2026 BOA-26-29, 7056 Camden Hwy. (County) I. THE REQUEST Applicant(s): Harmoni Gateway Towers, LLC Status of the Applicant: Authorized Agent (Leaseholder) Request: Request to establish a 279 ft. tall telecommunications tower on the property. County Council District: 1 Location: 7056 Camden Hwy. Zoning: Agricultural Conservation (AC) Tax Map Reference: 088-00-03-028 II. B ACKGROUND Communications towers and/or antenna may be treated as Conditional Uses in Sumter County without further review by the Sumter City- County Board of Zoning Appeals if the Zoning Administrator determines all applicable conditions in the Ordinance are met. The Zoning Administrator has referred the request by Harmoni Gateway Towers, LLC to construct a 279 ft. self-supported telecommunications tower at 7056 Camden Hwy. for decision by the Board of Zoning Appeals consisten t with Article 5.b.4: Communication Towers and Antennae. The property is zoned Agricultural Conservation (AC) and is located on Camden Hwy (US-521). 3 approximately 950 ft. south of the intersection of Camden Hwy and Dais Rd. The property is shown in red on the map on the previous page. Under the AC district zoning regulations which govern the property, telecommunications towers are evaluated in accordance with Article 1.h.4.c and Article 3.d.4 and in accordance with Article 5.b.4. of the Sumter County Zoning & Development Standards Ordinance. A copy of the overall property boundary with the proposed tower lease area identified, the proposed site development plan, and elevation drawing of the tower are included as Exhibits 1, 2, and 3, respectively Figure 1 - Property boundary with proposed tower lease area identified in the northwest corner 4 Figure 2 – Proposed site development plan Figure 3 – Proposed tower elevation drawing with Antenna Locations Identified 5 Figure 4 - Photo Simulation of Proposed Tower from Camden Hwy (US-521) Looking South Figure 5 - Photo Simulation of Proposed Tower from Camden Hwy (US-521) Looking North III. SPECIAL EXCEPTION REVIEW CRITERIA In the AC zoning district under Article 3, Exhibit 3 -5, telecommunications towers are special exception uses requiring the review and approval of the BZA, unless the Zoning Administrator determines all applicable conditions in the Ordinance are met. Special exception requests for 6 telecommunications towers are evaluated in accordance with Article 1.h.4.c. and Article 5.b.4. as contained in the Sumter County Zoning & Development Standards Ordinance. Article 1.h.4.c: Special Exceptions Permits for Special Exceptions shall be evaluated by the Board of Zoning Appeals on the basis of the following criteria: 1. That the Special Exception complies with all applicable development standards contained elsewhere in this Ordinance, including landscaping and bufferyards, off -street parking, and dimensional requirements; Case Facts: 1. Telecommunications tower development standards are discussed later in this report. There are no general Ordinance- specified development standards applicable to this site that have not been addressed. 2. That the special exception will be in substantial harmony with the area in which it is located; Case Facts: 1. The subject property and parcels immediately adjacent on all sides are zoned Agricultural Conservation (AC). 2. The parcel on which the tower is proposed is undeveloped and is currently an open field. 3. There is a single-family residence located +/- 500 ft. to the southwest of the proposed tower location and a single-family home located +/- 150 ft. the north across Camden Hwy. 4. The proposed 279 ft. self-support telecommunications tower is approximately 55 ft. from the edge of the existing public road right-of-way. 3. That the special exception will not discourage or negate the use of surrounding property for use(s) permitted by right. Case Facts: 1. The subject property and parcels immediately adjacent on all sides are zoned Agricultural Conservation (AC). 2. There is a single-family residence located +/- 500 ft. to the southwest of the proposed tower location and a single -family home located +/ - 150 ft. the north across Camden Hwy. 3. The proposed 279 ft. self -support telecommunications tower approximately 55 ft. from the edge of the existing public road right-of-way 7 Article 5.b.4. Communication Towers and Antennae: Application Requirements: The applicant for a permit for construction of a communications tower or the placement of a communications antenna on an existing structure other than a tower previously permitted must file with the Zoning Administrator an application accompanied by a fee of $500.00 and the following documents: 1. Specifications 2. Site Plan 3. Tower Location Map 4. Antenna Capacity – Wind Load 5. Antenna Owners 6. Owner Authorization 7. FCC License 8. Visual Impact Analysis 9. Removal Agreement Case Facts: • The applicant has submitted all aforementioned documents via Minor Site Plan #MSP-26-24. Conditions: Applicant must show that all of the following conditions are met: 1. Location and Visual Impact : The proposed tower, antenna or accessory structure will be placed on site in such a manner that it will minimize the visual impact on the surrounding properties; Case Facts: • The applicant is proposing to install a 279 ft. self-support telecommunications tower approximately 55 ft. from the edge of the existing public road right-of- way. • Figures #4 and #5 as submitted by the applicant represent photo simulation of the proposed tower as viewed from Camden Hwy. 2. Inability to locate on existing structures: The applicant must show that a proposed antenna and equipment cannot be accommodated and function as required by applicable regulations and the applicants’ technical design requirements without unreasonable modifications on any existing structure or tower under control of applicant, or to locate on an available and suitable nearby tower at reasonable costs (i.e., at or below local area rent average); Case Facts: • There are no known telecommunications towers within the immediate area of the site. 3. Necessity for location in residential district: The applicant must show that the portion of the county intended to receive coverage cannot be adequately served by a 8 communications tower or antenna placed in a non-residential district for valid technical reasons; Case Facts: • The proposed site is not in a residential zoning district. 4. Public property or other private property not suitable: Prior to consideration of a permit for location on private property which must be acquired, the applicant must show that available publicly owned sites, and available privately owned sites occupied by a compatible use, are unsuitable for operation of the facility under applicable communications regulations and the applicant’s technical design requirements; Case Facts: • There are no suitable publicly-owned sites within the vicinity of the proposed site. 5. Design for multiple use: Applicants must show that a new tower is designed to accommodate additional antennae equal to applicant’s present and future requirements; Case Facts: • The applicant’s design plans indicate three separate antenna arrays. The top array is identified for future Verizon antennas, and the two additional arrays are unspecified as to future users. 6. Safety Codes Met: Applicant must show that all applicable health, nuisance, fire, building, and life safety code requirements are met; Case Facts: • The project is subject to Sumter County building permit requirements. The Building Department has not completed review of the application to date, • All code requirements must be addressed by the applicant as a condition of any building permit issuance. 7. Paint and illumination: A communications tower must not be painted or illuminated unless otherwise required by state or federal regulations; Case Facts: • The tower is not proposed to be painted or illuminated, except for required safety beacons at the top and midpoint of the tower. 8. Distance from existing tower: A permit for a proposed tower site within 1,000 ft. of an existing tower shall not be issued unless the applicant certifies that the existing tower does not meet the applicant’s structural specifications and design requirements, or that a co-location agreement could not be obtained; 9 Case Facts: • There is a Verizon Wireless tower located +/- 1,900 linear feet to the northwest of the site. There are no towers within 1,000 ft. of the proposed site. 9. Indemnity and claims resolution: The applicant must show by certification from a registered professional engineer that the proposed facility will contain only equipment meeting FCC rules, and must file with the Zoning Administrator a written indemnification of Sumter County and proof of liability insurance or financial ability to respond to claims up to $1,000,000.00 dollars in the aggregate which may arise from the operation of the facilities during its life, at no cost to the county and in a form approved by the County Attorney. Case Facts: • The applicant has submitted a written indemnification of Sumter County and proof of liability insurance. 10. Minimum Setback: Non-Residential Zoning: Towers located on non-residentially zoned properties must be set back from all lot lines by distances equal to the district setback requirement or the tower’s fall zone, whichever is greater. Fall zones less than the full height of the tower shall be determined by an engineer licensed in the state of South Carolina in a letter that includes the engineer’s signature and seal. Case Facts: • The applicant has submitted a fall radius letter signed and sealed by South Carolina-licensed professional engineer Adam N. Howe. In the letter, Mr. Howe states that the tower has been designed using 119 mph 3-second gust wind with no ice and a 30 mph 3-second wind gust with 1 inch of ice. • The engineer indicates in the letter that the most likely mode of failure is buckling of a tower section due to excessive wind loading. • With a caveat of condition dependency, the engineer notes that the top 60 ft. of the tower which contains 91% of the code-permitted design loading would likely fall within a 37.5 ft. fall radius. 11. Technical Assistance: Prior to issuing a permit, the Zoning Administrator may make use of professional technical services to determine if the standards in Article 5.b.4.d. are met; Case Facts: • The Zoning Administrator has not utilized any outside professional technical services in the consideration of this request. 10 12. Maintenance: The communications tower shall be maintained by common corrosion control procedures so it continuously maintains a minimum visual impact on surrounding properties Case Facts: • All code requirements must be addressed by the applicant as a condition of any building permit issuance. 11 Special Exception: A tower, pole, or antenna may be permitted by Special Exception together with the findings considered in Section 1.h.4.c. after a public hearing along with the following criteria: 1. All application requirements and conditions imposed by 5.b.4.d. and 5.b.4.e. are met except height limitations and setbacks; Case Facts: 1. All application materials required by Article 5.b.4.d. have been submitted by the applicant. 2. If additional tower height is required, the total tower height will not exceed one hundred-fifty (150%) percent of the maximum height permitted in the district. In unincorporated portions of Sumter County, radio and television towers are exempt at the Board of Appeals from tower height limits (this rule does not apply within the corporate limits of the City of Sumter); Case Facts: 1. N/A, No additional tower height is required beyond the maximum height permitted. 3. The applicant has demonstrated that additional height above that permitted by the regulations is necessary for service to occupants of an area within the City or County of Sumter; Case Facts: 1. N/A, No additional tower height is required beyond the maximum height permitted. 4. Setback requirements and additional conditions are established by the Zoning Board of Appeals as it deems necessary to remove dangers to public health and safety and to protect adjacent property; Case Facts: 1. 279 ft. self-support telecommunications tower is proposed to be placed 55 ft. from the edge of the existing public road right-of-way. 5. Prior to approving a permit by Special Exception or on appeal from the Zoning Administrator, the Board may make use of professional technical services to determine that the standards in 5.b.4.d and 5.b.4.e. are met. 12 IV. STAFF RECOMMENDATION The proposed tower’s placement close to Camden Hwy (US -521) carries significant risk to the Sumter community. Camden Hwy. is a principal arterial roadway, and functions as a critical link within Sumter County and between Sumter and areas to the north. Introducing a facility which, in the event of failure, would potentially block this critical corridor is a hazard mitigation risk. While engineers can design telecommunications towers to buckle or fold over on themselves, the proposed fall zone represents only 13.4% of the tower's total height. Expecting a freestanding structure of this size to collapse so perfectly that no part of it lands beyond that distance is highly unrealistic and outside standard engineering safety margins . W here manufacturers provide certified "fall zone letters" utilizing advanced hinge -point calculations, the legal and physical minimum limit typically stops at 33% to 50% of the total height. V. DRAFT MOTIONS FOR BOA-26-29 A. I move the Zoning Board of Appeals approve BOA-26-29, subject to the findings of fact and conclusions developed by the BZA and so stated: [reference specific findings as developed based on facts presented in the staff report, exhibits, and/or during the public hearing.] B. I move the Zoning Board of Appeals deny BOA-26-29, subject to the following findings of fact and conclusions developed by the BZA and so stated: [reference specific findings as developed based on facts presented in the staff report, exhibits, and/or during the public hearing.] C. I move the Zoning Board of Appeals enter an alternative motion for BOA-26-29. VII. BOARD OF APPEALS – September 9, 2026 N 40°53'32" W 672.80' N 34°30'28" E 297.83' S 51°16'32" E 443.97' S 08°54'28" W 482.11' 65.35' N 40°51'32" W 118.42' 607.45' VESTED IN: KENNETH TAYLOR Document 1190, Page 1626 APN: 088-00-03-028 Now or Formerly: GEORGE NATHANIEL TAYLOR & YVONNE B. TAYLOR, Trustees Document 1302-1594 088-00-02-021 Now or Formerly: WILLIAM J. KENDRICK Document 1306-4535 088-00-03-050 Now or Formerly: ORA SPANN Document 1006-671 088-00-03-013 Lease Premises Access Easement 6.27' 475.84' Camden Highway Sheet No.2of2 Date Signed: NORTH Transforming the Industry Land Surveys Zoning Compliance Environmental Consulting Property Condition Assessment Seismic Risk Analysis Appraisal Millman Surveying, Inc. d.b.a CBRE Land Surveying Corporate Headquarters 950 Main Avenue, Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 800-520-1010 Fax: 330-342-0834 www.millmanland.com landsurveyors@cbre.com Surveyor's Seal GRAPHIC SCALE MSI Project No. 61711 Harmonin Tower ID#SC009812 Camden Highway Parcel 088-00-03-028 City of Rembert County of Sumter State of South Carolina PM:Drafter: CALCAL PC: TRM SPECIAL PURPOSE SURVEY PREPARED FOR: HARMONI TOWERS, LLC 11-21-2025 ~Grass~ Camden Highway 75' Wide - Public - Asphalt Pavement 14 12.5' Right-of-Way Book 1319, Page 2276 COPYRIGHT 2025 T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES, LLCC CAMDEN HIGHWAY REMBERT, SC 29128 Z-2 THESE DOCUMENTS ARE CONFIDENTIAL AND ARE THE SOLE PROPERTY OF HARMONI TOWERS AND MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED, DISSEMINATED OR REDISTRIBUTED WITHOUT THE EXPRESS WRITTEN CONSENT OF HARMONI TOWERS. HARMONI SITE NAME: BORDEN NEW 279' SELF-SUPPORT TOWER 11.16.26 TM 08.25.25ISSUED FOR REVIEW JDK 0 68160 HARMONI TOWER ID # : SC0009812 VZW FUZE PROJECT #: 17333601 HERMITAGE, PA 16148 www.t-sqrd.com 2501 SHENANGO VALLEY FREEWAY, SUITE 3 T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES HERMITAGE, PA 16148 www.t-sqrd.com T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES 2501 SHENANGO VALLEY FREEWAY, SUITE 3 724.308.7855724.308.7855 6210 ARDREY KELL ROAD SUITE 375 CHARLOTTE, NC 28277 HARMONI TOWERS FINAL ZDS COPYRIGHT 2025 T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES, LLCC CAMDEN HIGHWAY REMBERT, SC 29128 Z-3 THESE DOCUMENTS ARE CONFIDENTIAL AND ARE THE SOLE PROPERTY OF HARMONI TOWERS AND MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED, DISSEMINATED OR REDISTRIBUTED WITHOUT THE EXPRESS WRITTEN CONSENT OF HARMONI TOWERS. HARMONI SITE NAME: BORDEN NEW 279' SELF-SUPPORT TOWER 11.16.26 TM 08.25.25ISSUED FOR REVIEW JDK 0 68160 HARMONI TOWER ID # : SC0009812 VZW FUZE PROJECT #: 17333601 HERMITAGE, PA 16148 www.t-sqrd.com 2501 SHENANGO VALLEY FREEWAY, SUITE 3 T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES HERMITAGE, PA 16148 www.t-sqrd.com T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES 2501 SHENANGO VALLEY FREEWAY, SUITE 3 724.308.7855724.308.7855 6210 ARDREY KELL ROAD SUITE 375 CHARLOTTE, NC 28277 HARMONI TOWERS FINAL ZDS

Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.