HP-26-13, 109 Dugan St. - City - Staff Report
City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
City of Sumter Design Review Board
October 22, 2026
HP-26-13, 109 Dugan St. (City)
I. THE REQUEST
Applicant: Terrance Wells
Status of the Applicant: Property Owner
Request: Request for Design Review approval for replacement of
existing wood siding with fiber cement (Hardie Plank)
siding on the residential structure on the property.
District: Downtown Design District
Location: 109 Dugan St.
Present Use/Zoning: Single Family Residential / DTC
Tax Map Reference: 228-13-03-012
Adjacent Property Land
Use and Zoning:
North – Vacant lot / DTC
South – Resource Center / DTC
East – Single-Family Residence / DTC
West – Vacant lot / DTC
II. BACKGROUND
The applicant is requesting Design Review
Approval to replace the existing wood
siding on a residential structure with fiber
cement board siding (Hardie Plank). The
property subject to this request is located at
109 Dugan St.
The property currently contains a +/ -2,131
sq. ft. single-family residential dwelling on
a +/ -0.09-acre lot located within the
Downtown Core District.
Above: Site Picture – Dugan St. (Google Streetview Jan. 2025)
2
ARCHITECTURAL/HISTORIC CONTEXT:
The dwelling on the property is a two -story, wood-sided structure featuring a hipped
roof, two chimneys, and a covered porch. The home was built in the Colonial Vernacular
architectural style. Colonial Vernacular homes are identified by their simple ,
symmetrical design.
Sumter County Tax Assessor Records list the 2,131 sq. ft. single -family residence as
having been built in 1900.
The existing dwelling is a contributing structure to the fabric of the Downtown Design
District based both on age and architectural details . All proposed exterior changes
must be reviewed and approved by the Design Review Board.
SITE PHOTOS (as accessed via Google StreetView in January 2025):
Site Front (south-facing) as viewed from Dugan St. East-facing side of residence as viewed from Dugan St.
West-facing side of residence as viewed from Dugan St. Site rear (north-facing) as viewed from Liberty St.
3
PROPOSED SCOPE OF WORK:
The proposed project includes:
1. Removal of existing wood siding
Note: Wood siding was removed prior to application for Design Review
Approval and Building Permits. Notices of Violation for failure to obtain
building permits and Certificate of Appropriateness are in effect pending the
outcome of this Design Review Board application.
2. Installation of new fiber cement (Hardie Plank) siding
The proposed replacement material for the siding is James Hardie ColorPlus
Technology Hardie Plank Select CedarMill fiber cement siding in the color “Evening
Blue”. This form of siding is currently the most popular replacement siding product in
North America due to its curb appeal, durability, climate -specific engineering, and
warranty. Fiber cement planks are formed by combining wood pulp with Portland
cement. As a result, the planks or individual shingles do an effective job of mimicking
the look of traditional wood siding.
Fiber cement siding is installed in much the same way as traditional lapboard or wood
siding, as it is nailed directly to the exterior wall of the building.
Above Left: Rendering Provided by Applicant Above Right: James Hardie Hardie Plank ColorPlus
Technology Select Cedarmill in “Evening Blue”
DESIGN REVIEW:
Design review approval is required prior to the proposed work. The Design Review
Guidelines Manual states:
4
4.4 Exterior Walls: Siding
A. Preserve and Maintain Original Wood Siding and other Wood Features
Retain original wood siding and other wood features, such as decorative shingles, cornices,
and frieze boards, soffits, eaves, trim, and moldings.
Protect wood elements from water damage by repairing leaking roofs, gutters, downspouts
and flashing.
Keep wood surfaces primed and painted.
Splice in new materials of the same material, design, color, texture, and other visual qualities
of the original material, while retaining as much of the original material as possible.
C. Replace original wood siding and wood features in-kind.
Replace original wood siding and wood features only if beyond reasonable repair.
Match the original material in design, color, texture, and other visual qualities and, where
possible, material.
D. Preserve the visibility of exterior wood siding and wood features.
Consider removing non-historic materials that conceal original wood siding and features and
repair the underlying materials.
Do not cover wood siding with aluminum, steel, vinyl, brick and stone veneers, and other
artificial materials.
Do not cover soffits, eaves and porch ceilings with aluminum, steel, or vinyl siding.
Staff Analysis:
The Design Review Guidelines include a section on substitute siding materials that - while
focused on vinyl and aluminum siding is instructive for analysis of fiber cement siding as
an alternative siding material. The Ordinance allows replacement of siding if:
1. The existing siding is so deteriorated that it cannot be repaired; and
2. The substitute material can be installed without irreversibly damaging or obscuring
the architectural features and trim of the building
In cases such as that of 109 Dugan St ., removal of the existing wood siding and the
application of James Hardie ColorPlus Technology Hardie Plank Select CedarMill siding is
acceptable, as long as the two above-mentioned conditions are met. This is the case for the
109 Dugan St. residence.
III. STAFF RECOMMENDATION
Staff is supportive of this request.
The proposed replacement of the material with fiber cement siding alternative is
consistent with the design guidelines and will not detract from the Downtown Core
District.
IV. DRAFT MOTION
5
1) I move the City of Sumter Design Review Board approve HP-26-13 in
accordance with the materials and construction details submitted.
2) I move the City of Sumter Design Review Board deny HP-26-13.
3) I move the City of Sumter Design Review Board enter an alternative motion.
V. DESIGN REVIEW BOARD – October 22, 2026
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.