HP-25-20, 343 West Calhoun St. - Staff Report
City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
City of Sumter Design Review Board
October 23, 2025
HP-25-20-343 West Calhoun St (City)
I. THE REQUEST
Applicant: Mary Jean Dowling
Status of the Applicant: Property Owner
Request: Request for Design Review Approval to install a new
metal roof over the existing asphalt shingle roof.
District: Hampton Park Historic District
Location: 343 West Calhoun St.
Present Use/Zoning: Residential / Residential-9 (R-9)
Tax Map Reference: 228-06-02-018
Adjacent Property Land
Use and Zoning:
North – Residential / Residential (R-6)
South – Residential / Residential (R-6)
East – Residential / Residential (R-9)
West – Residential / Residential (R-9)
II. BACKGROUND
The applicant is requesting Design Review
Board approval t o install a new metal roof
system over the existing layer of asphalt
shingles. The applicant stated that there
was previously a metal roof on the house and
that there are remnants of that original roof
under the existing asphalt shingles.
The property located at 343 W. Calhoun St.,
was acquired by the applicant in 20 24 via
deed of distribution from the estate of her
late husband . The 0.25 lot currently
contains a residential structure that
measures 2,777 sq. ft.
2
ARCHITECTURAL/HISTORIC CONTEXT:
According to 1923 Sanborn Maps, the property contained a residential structure. The
Sumter County Assessor’s Office lists the construction date of the current structure as
1946.
The residence at 343 W. Calhoun Street is a 1½ story square-plan structure. It features
a front-facing gable roof that slopes toward the street, with a shed dormer extending
along the roofline. The dormer contains three horizontally oriented rectangular
windows. A porch spans the left and center portions of the front façade, provi ding a
balanced and inviting entrance to the home.
The building is a contributing structure to the fabric of the Hampton Park Historic
District based both on its age and architectural details.
There were no pervious design review approvals for this property.
Example of roof materials Proposed Color
PROPOSED SCOPE OF WORK:
The proposed project includes:
1. Install a MasterRib Panel roof system with ValsparXL paint finish
(Evergreen) over existing asphalt shingle roof.
3
DESIGN REVIEW:
Design review approval is required prior to the proposed work. The Design Review
Guidelines states:
4.1 Roofs
A. Preserve original roof form and pitch.
Do not raise residential roofs to add additional stories.
Place new dormers and skylights inconspicuously on rear and secondary elevations not
visible from the public right of way. Flush or flat skylights are more appropriate than raise
or bubbled.
B. Preserve original roof materials.
Retain original roof materials, such as standing-seam metal, slate, or clay tile whenever
possible.
Repair deteriorated sections of roofs with in-kind materials to match the original.
C. Retain original roof elements and ornamentation.
Preserve chimneys, dormers, exposed rafter tails, finials, and cresting.
Repair brick chimneys with brick and mortar to match the original.
Do not remove chimneys above the roofline, especially those on prominent elevations.
Stucco or paint a chimney only when its appearance detracts from the building.
Staff Analysis:
The applicant is proposing to install a new metal roof system manufactured by
Smith-Built, known as MasterRib, over the existing asphalt shingle roof . The
MasterRib roofing panels have trapezoidal major ribs spaced on 9-inch centers. The
panels are installed on top of 1x4 inch wood furring strips with material or insulated
layer under the panels. In this case, the existing layer of asphalt shingles will
remain under the panels. The panels and associated trim are secured with color
matched fasteners.
According to the manufacturer, the factory -installed Valspar WeatherXL paint
finish includes a 40-year warranty, and the MasterRib Panel life expectancy is well
beyond the 40-year warranty period.
Standing seam metal roofs were historically common in the district and are
consistent with the home’s character. While the proposed ribbed metal roof differs
slightly from traditional standing seam styles, which are no longer readily
available, it will rem ain visually compatible and complementary to the historic
appearance of the property.
4
III. STAFF RECOMMENDATION
If the Design Review Board makes the findings necessary to approve this request, Staff
recommends no additional conditions.
IV. DRAFT MOTION
1) I move the City of Sumter Design Review Board approve HP-25-20 in
accordance with the materials and construction details submitted.
2) I move the City of Sumter Design Review Board deny HP-25-20.
3) I move the City of Sumter Design Review Board enter an alternative motion.
V. HISTORIC PRESERVATION – October 23, 2025
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.