RecordWell Data

Board of Architectural Review Regular Meeting Packet (PDF)

Town of Summerville · Berkeley County · meeting of Jan 6, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Town of Summerville

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Board of Architectural Review January 6th, 2026 Meeting at 6:00pm For additional information regarding this meeting please contact the Planning Department at 843.851.4214. All related documents for this meeting are available for review online and the meeting will be livestreamed via www.summervillesc.gov Approval of Minutes: 1. December 2,2025 Meeting PUBLIC HEARING Old Business: 1. 107 Joyce Lane-Addition New Business: 1. 620 W Carolina Ave-Demo of accessory structure 2. 139 Central Ave – Door/ Replacement Awnings 3. 112 W Carolina Ave- Construction of New Cottage Miscellaneous: 1. N/A Adjourn: Agenda Posted: Board of Architectural Review Minutes December 2nd, 2025 Members Present: David Price (Vice Chair) Beth Huggins Kimsey Hollifield Jane Knight Staff Present: Makeah Davis-Grant, Planning II Becca Zimmerman, Zoning Administrator Items on the agenda: Draft Minutes: Ms. Huggins made a motion to approve the December 2025 draft minutes as submitted. Ms. Knight seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. Old Business: 1) 410 Central Avenue – New construction of pool house Ms. Higgins expressed concern that the drawings and renderings did not match, stating that elements such as the band board and overall detailing should be consistent with the existing house. She also noted that the side of the house facing the street lacks sufficient ornamentation and commented that the design of that elevation is not appropriate and is visually unappealing. Following discussion, a motion was made by Mr. Price to approve the project with the condition that the design be revised to better match the house; the motion was seconded by Mr. Hollifield. Ms. Higgins voted against the motion, and the motion passed. New Business: 1) 119 W. 3rd South Street – Renovation to existing residential style structure for Meals on Wheels location Ms. Zimmerman provided an overview of the project, after which Mr. Lee explained the scope of work, noting that it includes new siding, windows, and shingles, with no changes to the overall design of the house and only the relocation of doors. Ms. Higgins asked whether the project would involve any change to the building footprint, and Mr. Lee confirmed that there would be no footprint change. Mr. Price commented that if window replacement is pursued, he does not believe historic windows should be required, stating that the house is very modern in design. Following discussion, Ms. Knight made a motion to approve the project as submitted, which was seconded by Mr. Hollifield, and the motion was approved. 2) 117 S. Cedar Street- Renovation to existing Victorian cottage for café/restaurant use/ adding wheelchair lift Mr. Komer, the business owner, and Mr. Karpus presented the project to the Board, with Mr. Karpus explaining the project details, including the proposed relocation of bushes, noting that the remaining landscaping would stay the same. In response to a question from Ms. Knight regarding whether the business would operate the wheelchair lift themselves, Mr. Karpus stated that some railing would be removed and confirmed that they would be able to operate the wheelchair lift independently. Following discussion, Mr. Hollifield made a motion to approve the project as submitted, which was seconded by Ms. Knight, and the motion was approved. 3) 107 Joyce Lane- Addition to existing cottage Mr. Price asked about the siding on the existing house. Mr. Evans responded that there is currently no Hardie plank; some areas have smooth wood siding, while other areas feature a mix of rough-sawn and smooth siding. Mr. Price noted that rough-sawn cypress is available from Southern Lumber and Berlin G. Myers, and Mr. Evans added that Hardie plank would be a better option with less maintenance. Mr. Price stated that the plan looks good and makes sense but suggested attempting to locate old rust-bone lumber to match the rest of the house where possible. Ms. Higgins inquired about the underpinning, and Mr. Evans explained that it will match the house but must be a separate unit since the rest of the house is on piers; it will be parged. Mr. P asked about the windows, and Mr. Evans confirmed they will have SDL (simulated divided lights) as well as sills and other details. Ms. Knight stated that the plan looks good and deferred to others on material choices. Ms. Higgins expressed appreciation for the effort to even out the building and create a balanced design. Mr. Evans confirmed that the original house measured 13x40. DP commented that rough-sawn cedar or cypress is preferred if available at a reasonable price, but smooth Hardie plank would also be acceptable. Ms. Higgins made a motion to approve the proposed addition as presented, with final siding details to return to the Board, including windows and all other elements as presented. Ms. Higgins seconded the motion, and all were in favor. 4) Proposal for Council to change December BAR meeting schedule Mr. Price presented proposed changes to the December meeting date. Ms. Higgins made a motion to request that the December BAR Board meeting be rescheduled so it does not conflict with the Town of Summerville Annual Tree Lighting Celebration, and Ms. Knight seconded the motion. The board discussed that the change was requested to allow members and community residents to participate in both the board meeting and the annual celebration, and the motion was approved. Adjourn: There being no further business to discuss, the meeting was adjourned by the Vice Chair at 7:20 p.m. Respectfully Submitted, Makeah Davis-Grant, Planner II STAFF REPORT BAR Meeting January 6th, 2026 To: Town of Summerville BAR From: Makeah Davis-Grant, Planner II Date: Applicant: Kenneth Evans Owner: EVANS JILL J & KENNETH G Requested Action: Final Review Existing Zoning/Land Use: GR-2/ Existing SF Residential Location: 107 Joyce Lane Building Rating: N/A, no rating Proposed Work: Request for residential addition Guideline Citation: 5.14 GUIDELINES FOR RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES Guideline 24. Additions Evaluation: The applicant is requesting approval to construct an addition to an existing home. The addition is intended to expand the usable living space while matching the current design and architectural style of the existing structure. The applicant’s request specifies that the new construction should align with the home’s existing materials, proportions, trim details, and overall appearance to ensure the addition blends seamlessly with the original building. STAFF REPORT BAR Meeting January 6th, 2026 To: Town of Summerville BAR From: Makeah Davis-Grant, Planner II Date: Applicant: Kelly Alfreds Owner: ALFREDS BRENT M & KELLY MARIE (TRUSTEES) Requested Action: Final Review Existing Zoning/Land Use: GR-2/ Existing SF Residential Location: 620 W Carolina Ave Building Rating: #2, Notable Proposed Work: Request to demo accessory structure. Guideline Citation: 5.12 UNIVERSAL GUILDLINES FOR DEMOLITION Guideline 38. Guidelines for Demolition of Historic Properties Evaluation: The applicant is requesting approval to demolish an existing structure. While the exterior appearance of the building is visually appealing and appears to be in good condition, the interior condition of the structure is not habitable and cannot be reasonably renovated or made suitable for use. STAFF REPORT BAR Meeting January 6th, 2026 To: Town of Summerville BAR From: Makeah Davis-Grant, Planner II Date: Applicant: Stephen Walker Mueller Owner: MICKALIS PROPERTIES LLC Requested Action: Final Review Existing Zoning/Land Use: D-MX/Commercial Location: 139 Central Ave Building Rating: #1, Notable Proposed Work: Upfit to the exterior appearance to include door and windows replacement. Guideline Citation: 5.15 GUIDELINES FOR COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES Guideline 70 & 72. Replacement Windows for Commercial Properties/ Storefront Entrances Evaluation: Remove existing paired doors and install a new single wood door with glass. Modify and repair the door opening as needed for proper fit. Remove existing transom windows and replace them with new stained-glass windows, including necessary repairs to existing wood trim for installation. FINISH AND COLOR LEGEND ALL SIGNAGE INDICATED FOR ILLUSTRATIVEPURPOSES ONLY. LOCATION, SIZE, ETC. TO BEDETERMINED ON AN INDIVIDUAL PROJECTBASIS.MINIMUM 3/4" PLYWOOD BACKER BOARDREQUIRED AT SIGN LOCATIONS. AREA SHOULDCOVER ENTIRE LENGTH AND HEIGHT OFFASCIA OR SPACE AVAILABLE FOR SIGN.ELECTRICAL AND FINAL CONNECTION BYCONTRACTOR. ELECTRICAL REQUIREMENTSMAY BE OBTAINED FROM SIGN COMPANY.TYPICAL 120V REQUIREMENT.PARAPETS WHERE SIGNS ARE LOCATED TO BEPROVIDED BY CONTRACTOR. CONTRACTOR TOFURNISH AND CONNECT PRIMARY ELECTRICALSERVICE INSIDE PARAPET WALL.ON EXTERIOR WALLS MUST HAVE ELECTRICALPENETRATIONS AND/OR REMOTETRANSFORMERS COORDINATED AND/ORINSTALLED PRIOR TO CLOSING UP THE WALL.PENETRATION LAYOUT MAY BE OBTAINEDFROM SIGN COMPANY. 1.2.3.4.5. BUILDING SIGNAGE 1.SEE CIVIL DRAWINGS FOR LOCATIONS ANDCONTINUATION OF ALL SIDEWALKS ANDADA RAMPS FROM FACE OF BUILDING- TYP.GRADE- TYP.2.SEE CIVIL DRAWINGS FOR THE LOCATIONOF ALL PIPING FROM INTERNAL ROOFLEADERS, SUPPLY AND DRAIN LINECONNECTIONS- TYP.3.ALL HORIZONTAL PROJECTIONS TO HAVEPOSITIVE SLOPE ON TOP AND CONTINUOUSDRIP EDGE ON THE UNDERSIDE- TYP.4.ALL CONNECTIONS SHALL BE FLASHEDAND COUNTER FLASHED TO MAINTAINWATER & WEATHER TIGHT BLD.ARCHITECT TO BE NOTIFIED IN WRITINGOF ANY ON-SITE CONDITIONS THAT MAY BEIN QUESTIONS- TYP.5.PROVIDE 2X BLOCKING AS REQUIRED-(3) OPTIONS FOR BLOCKINGOPTION 1- P.T. WOOD FULLY WRAPPED INEPDM MEMBRANE OR TPO ROOFING MEMBRANE, TO PREVENT DIRECTCONTACT BETWEEN P.T. WOOD AND STEEL, STAINLESS STEEL, NAILS, BOLTS,WASHERS, & NUTS MUST BE USED- TYP.OPTION 2- USE CEDAR 2X BLOCKINGOPTION 3- USE "TIMBER SILL" BLOCKING6.ALL STRUCTURAL STEEL INCLUDINGCOLUMNS, STEEL BEAMS, JOISTS, GIRDERS,ROOF DECKING, AND MISCELLANEOUSMETALS SHALL BE DELIVERED TO THE SITEWITH A RUST INHIBITIVE GRAY PRIMERSHOP FINISH- TYP.7.ANY REQUIRED BOND BEAMS OR STEELPLATE HEADERS ARE TO EXTEND A MIN. OF8" EITHER SIDE OF MASONRY OPENING. SEESTRUCTURAL DWGS. ALSO- TYP. STRUCT.DWGS. IF DIFFER TAKE PRECEDENT.8.SEE ALSO G SERIES FOR LIFE SAFETY PLANAND INFORMATION- TYP.9.REVIEW ALL SIGHT LINES AROUNDPROPERTY BEFORE LOCATING ROOFTOPEQUIPMENT. VERIFY ALL EQUIPMENT ISADEQUATELY SCREENED- TYP. GENERAL NOTES: GENERAL TRELLIS/ AWNING NOTES:1.STRUCTURAL ATTACHMENTS AND LOADCALCULATIONS SHALL BE FURNISHED BYTRELLIS / AWNING OR CANOPYMANUFACTURER/ SYSTEM DESIGNER OFRECORD. SUPPLIER'S DESIGNER OFRECORD SHALL DESIGN PER PREVAILINGAND APPLICABLE CODES.2.WHERE APPLICABLE SYSTEM SHALL ALLOWFOR MOVEMENT AT EXPANSION JOINTSAND FOR MOVEMENT OF EXTERIOR WALLSYSTEM ON WHICH THE TRELLIS, AWNING,OR CANOPY IS MOUNTED.3.MANUFACTURER SHALL PROVIDEINSTALLER WITH WRITTEN INSTALLATIONINSTRUCTIONS. MANUFACTURER SHALLDESIGN TRELLIS, AWNING, OR CANOPY INACCORDANCE WITH THE WALL SYSTEMAND PROVIDE BLOCKING AS NEEDED ORINDICATED IN THE CONSTRUCTIONDOCUMENTS.4.INSTALLER SHALL NOTIFY THE TRELLIS,AWNING, OR CANOPY DESIGNER OFRECORD, G.C., AND ARCHITECT OF ANYDEFICIENCIES THAT WOULD NOT ALLOWFOR THE PROPER INSTALLATION . TRELLIS,AWNING, OR CANOPY SHALL NOT BEINSTALLED PRIOR TO ANY DEFICIENCIESHAVE BEEN CORRECTED IN ACCORDANCEWITH THE CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTSAND THE MANUFACTURER'SINSTALLATION INSTRUCTIONS. B1BRICK SIDING-COLORS1S2CEMINTITIOUS LAPSIDING-COLORCEMINTITIOUS BOARDAND BATON-COLORS3CEMINTITIOUSPANEL-COLOR PREP EXISTING WALLFOR NEW DECORATIVEMOLDING AND PAINT-TYP. REMOVE DOOR,REPAIR DAMAGEDWOOD, AND PREP FORNEW DOOR AND WALL-TYP. PREP EXISTING WALLFOR NEW DECORATIVEMOLDING AND PAINT-TYP. REMOVE AWNING ANDPREP FOR NEW- TYP.REMOVE SIGN ANDPREP FOR NEW- TYP.PREP FOR NEW PAINTSCHEME- TYP. NEW DECORATIVEMOLDING AND PAINT-TYP. NEW SINGLE DOOR,REPAIR DAMAGEDWOOD, AND NEWINFILL WALL W/MOLDING- TYP. NEW DECORATIVEMOLDING AND PAINT-TYP. NEW AWNINGS- TYP.NEW SIGN- TYP.NEW PAINT SCHEME-TYP. Issue Date:Project No:Sheet Title: Sheet Number: ALL DESIGNS, DRAWINGS AND SPECIFICATIONS DEPICTED ON THIS SHEET ARE THE PROPERTY OF KW Designs, llc. ANY UNAUTHORIZED USE OR REPRODUCTION IS SUBJECT TO LEGAL PROSECUTION. POSSESSION IN ANY FORM CONSTITUTES ACCEPTANCE OF THESE CONDITIONS. COPYRIGHT 2020 12.08.25KWD25-123 Revision:Date: These drawings are an instrument ofservice provided by KW Designs© Copyright 2025 by KW Designs llc, 831 W. Main St.Laurens, SC 29360. Drawings, specifications and otherdocuments, including those in electronic form, prepared by theArchitect and the Architect's consultants are the Architect'sInstruments of Service for use solely with respect to thisProject. The Architect and the Architects's consultants shall bedeemed the authors and owners of their respective instrumentsof service and shall retain all common law, statutory and otherrights including copyrights. No portion of these documents mybe reproduced without permission of KW Designs llc, nor mayany part of these documents be reproduced, stored in aretrieval system, or copied by mechanical photocopying,recording, or other means, known or hereafter invented, or byall means, methods, and processes known and hereafterinvented, without permission of KW Designs llc. Project: Owner / Client: Summerville Pub 831 W. Main St.Laurens, S.C. 29360PHONE: 843.990.1923EMAIL: kwoudstra@kwdesigns.net Architecure Master Planning Phased development planing Summerville, SC See G-003 General Note "Permit ReviewerUnauthorized Use Notification Protocol Note"Relative to Illegal use of drawings. If G-003 or thisnote is not part of receive package contact viaemail kwoudstra@kwdesigns.net immediately asyou have received an unauthorized and illegal setof drawings. A-200Existing Elevations 3/8" = 1'-0"Existing Elevation (Front)13/8" = 1'-0"Demo Elevation (Front)2 3/8" = 1'-0"Proposed Elevation (Front)3 NEW STAIN GLASS WINDOW REMOVE WINDOW AND PREP FOR NEW- TYP. STAFF REPORT BAR Meeting January 6th, 2026 To: Town of Summerville BAR From: Makeah Davis-Grant, Planner II Date: Applicant: Michael Taylor Owner: HOLLIFIELD KIMSEY A Requested Action: Final Review Existing Zoning/Land Use: GR-2/Existing SF Residential Location: 112 W Carolina Ave Building Rating: #5, Notable Proposed Work: Request for construction of new cottage. Guideline Citation: 5.10 UNIVERSAL GUIDELINE FOR NEW STANDALONE CONSTRUCTION Guideline 29. New Construction Evaluation: The applicant is requesting approval to construct a new cottage home to be situated behind the existing single-family residence in a manner consistent with surrounding development. Owner Approval Letter 112 West Carolina Summerville SC 29483 Date: 12/15/2025 I Kimsey Hollifield am allowing Mike Taylor / Taylor Coastal to apply for BAR application - new detaced ADU Owner: Kimsey Hollifield QUEEN BATH LAUNDRY / STORAGE CLOSET 9'-6" X 9'-3" KITCHENETTE 10'-1" X 9'-9" LIVING 10'-1" X 9'-9" SLEEPING 7'-6" X 16'-0" PERGOLA PATIO 17'-0" X 5'-0" COVERED PORCH SHELVES SHELVES STACK W/D 26' - 1" 28' - 7" This document is an instrument of service and shall remain the property of Haas Design & Consulting, LLC, who retains all common law, statutory and other reserved rights, including the copyright thereto. These plans are protected by Federal Copyright Laws. The original purchaser is authorized to construct one, and only one, home using these plans. Modification or Re-use, without prior written consent of designer, is prohibited. 560 W. Butternut Road Summerville, SC 29483 (843) 609-9189 design@modernvellum.com modern vellum residential design 11.13.25 25-018 HOLLIFIELD COTTAGE 112 W. CAROLINA AVE. SUMMERVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA 29483 LIGHT GRAY HATCH DENOTES UNHEATED SQUARE FOOTAGE DARK GRAY HATCH DENOTES HEATED SQUARE FOOTAGE NOTE: SQUARE FOOTAGE CALCULATION IS TAKEN FROM OUTSIDE FACE OF EXTERIOR STUD WALL. FINISHED SQUARE FOOTAGE CALCULATIONS FOR THIS HOUSE WERE MADE BASED ON PLAN DIMENSIONS ONLY AND MAY VARY FROM THE FINISHED SQUARE FOOTAGE OF THE HOUSE AS BUILT Square Footage FIRST FLOOR HEATED 407 SF TOTAL HEATED 407 SF COVERED PORCH 93 SF TOTAL UNHEATED 93 SF TOTAL UNDER ROOF 500 SF QUEEN BATH LAUNDRY / STORAGE CLOSET 9'-6" X 9'-3" KITCHENETTE 10'-1" X 9'-9" LIVING 10'-1" X 9'-9" SLEEPING 7'-6" X 16'-0" PERGOLA PATIO 17'-0" X 5'-0" COVERED PORCH SHELVES SHELVES STACK W/D 26' - 1" 28' - 7" This document is an instrument of service and shall remain the property of Haas Design & Consulting, LLC, who retains all common law, statutory and other reserved rights, including the copyright thereto. These plans are protected by Federal Copyright Laws. The original purchaser is authorized to construct one, and only one, home using these plans. Modification or Re-use, without prior written consent of designer, is prohibited. 560 W. Butternut Road Summerville, SC 29483 (843) 609-9189 design@modernvellum.com modern vellum residential design 11.13.25 25-018 HOLLIFIELD COTTAGE 112 W. CAROLINA AVE. SUMMERVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA 29483 LIGHT GRAY HATCH DENOTES UNHEATED SQUARE FOOTAGE DARK GRAY HATCH DENOTES HEATED SQUARE FOOTAGE NOTE: SQUARE FOOTAGE CALCULATION IS TAKEN FROM OUTSIDE FACE OF EXTERIOR STUD WALL. FINISHED SQUARE FOOTAGE CALCULATIONS FOR THIS HOUSE WERE MADE BASED ON PLAN DIMENSIONS ONLY AND MAY VARY FROM THE FINISHED SQUARE FOOTAGE OF THE HOUSE AS BUILT Square Footage FIRST FLOOR HEATED 407 SF TOTAL HEATED 407 SF COVERED PORCH 93 SF TOTAL UNHEATED 93 SF TOTAL UNDER ROOF 500 SF

Source: Town of Summerville website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.