RecordWell Data

July 13, 2022 Minutes (PDF)

Town of Sullivan's Island · Charleston County · meeting of Jul 13, 2022 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Sullivan's Island

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

JULY 13, 2022 LAND USE AND NATURAL RESOURCES COMMITTEE MEETING 1 TOWN OF SULLIVAN’S ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA LAND USE AND NATURAL RESOURCES COMMITTEE OF COUNCIL Wednesday, July 13, 2022 Committee met at 8:45 a.m., Wednesday, July 13, 2022, at Town Hall (2056 Middle St.), all requirements of the Freedom of Information Act having been met. Present were; Committee members: Gary Visser (Chair) and Pat O’Neil Staff: Town Administrator Andy Benke, Building Official Max Wurthmann, Director of Planning and Zoning Charles Drayton, Deputy Administrator Joe Henderson and Committee staff member Pam Otto 1. Call to Order. Chair Visser called the meeting to order at 8:47 a.m., stating the press and public were duly notified pursuant to state law, and all Committee members were present. Media: None present Public: Fifteen (15) members present 2. Receive, and consider for approval, the final report from the Land Use and Natural Resources (LUNR) Subcommittee Sullivan’s Island Historic Preservation and Design Study Group. Chair Visser mentioned the Study Group had a diverse membership of Boards and Commissions members of the Town, residents, attorneys and architects. Their charge was to consider the historic preservation goals and new construction in the Town. The formation of the group was set forth in the 2018 Comprehensive Plan. Henderson gave a brief overview of the report, stating the recommendations that came from the group were of two (2) types, policy initiatives and text amendments. Policy initiatives can be approved by Town Council and involved a new historic survey and historic design guidelines. Text amendments are changes to the Zoning Ordinance and require being added to the Council agenda as action items, sent to the Planning Commission for a public hearing, review and approval, then back to Council. Henderson mentioned the final report would be posted on the Town website for public review. JULY 13, 2022 LAND USE AND NATURAL RESOURCES COMMITTEE MEETING 2 Motion: Mayor O’Neil made a motion to accept the Sullivan’s Island Historic Preservation and Design Study Group final report, with gratitude for those who produced it, and that the recommendations be forwarded to Town Council with a recommendation that the proposed text amendments be forwarded to and considered by the Planning Commission, and a recommendation that Council adopt the three policy changes in the report, which is the historical survey, the modifications to the Design Review Board (DRB) application, and the development of design guidelines, seconded by Chair Visser; this motion passed unanimously. 3. Receive public input and discussion on fractional ownership of properties and their use and impact on adjacent property owners. Chair Visser stated that the Committee would be taking no action on this item, it is information gathering only for the benefit of Town Council. He also said the time limit for public comments would be increased to five (5) minutes to give everyone adequate time. Public Comment Sarah Filosa (No address given) stated that she is the public affairs manager at Pacaso. She gave a brief background on Pacaso, saying that it is a solution for second home ownership in luxury homes. She stated all owners are financially invested in the home. Once Pacaso forms an LLC and aggregates a collection of homeowners, Pacaso does not retain any ownership of the property. Pacaso uses local property managers, and the owners must sign a code of conduct. All owners pass a criminal background check and are not allowed to rent the home, it is for owner’s use only. There is a local contact for all homes if neighbors need. She pointed out that twelve percent (12%) of homes on Sullivan’s Island are co-owned. She said a common question was, “What if an owner wants out?”, she said that owners must retain ownership for 12 months. After 12 months they can sell but must first offer it to the other owners, if they don’t want to purchase then they can use Pacaso to sell or their own real estate agent. Aussie Geer (2702 Goldbug Ave) stated she was a long time resident and former member of the Planning Commission. She said the purpose of the Planning Commission’s comprehensive study was to protect the single family, residential character of the Town in order to remain a predominantly low-density community. She said there are some homes that are owned by several family members, but it is still one family owning the property. That is very different than a group of people who don’t know each other owning a home. Sallie Pritchard (2830 Middle St) is against fractional ownership. She agrees with Ms. Geer. She stated her property was in an LLC as well, but for liability reasons, and is still family owned. Laurie Arthur (2850 Middle St) stated that fractional ownership has been an issue in California, with push back against the Pacaso model. She said that LLC’s exist on Sullivan’s Island for liability reasons only. She stated her agreement with previous speakers about the importance of single-family home ownership. She had concerns that Pacaso could increase the number of shareholders on properties. JULY 13, 2022 LAND USE AND NATURAL RESOURCES COMMITTEE MEETING 3 Barbara Spell (1702 Atlantic Ave) is also opposed to fractional ownership. She feels what was described by Ms. Filosa is a commercial business. She said the residents don’t want short term rentals. John Carroll (partner in Burr and Forman LLP) stated that he represents Pacaso in public affairs. He offered his help if Council had any questions, as he has been working in many coastal towns with Pacaso. He stated that Pacaso was anti-rental and they would be willing to work with any initiative to prevent rentals on Pacaso properties. He said Pacaso was very different from a time share, there is only one owner, the LLC. He would be willing to work with the Town on mutually beneficial regulations. Karen Byko (2862 Middle St) is strongly opposed to Pacaso and other LLC time share schemes. She said that the properties operate like a hotel, VRBO (Vacation Rental By Owner), and time share. She discussed the policies of Pacaso and how it was different from a family-owned LLC. She reiterated that Pacaso is a business, with their properties having a never-ending rotation of people checking in for 2 to fourteen (14) days. She stated that other residents had asked her to speak on their behalf. Mr. O’Neil asked if he could pose some questions to the Pacaso representatives. Chair Visser agreed, as long as that would be afforded to the attendees as well. Ms. Filosa came to the podium to answer questions. Mr. O’Neil asked if the owners of the Pacaso properties would remain private, as LLCs can remain private. Ms. Filosa said the owners would be listed in the LLC. Mr. O’Neil asked if that would be made available to the public. Ms. Filosa said it would depend on the state law. Mr. O’Neil said that if in South Carolina it is not required to be made public, then would it be. Ms. Filosa replied it would not. Mr. O’Neil asked why eight was the number of shares used. Ms. Filosa said that was the product of market research. Ms. Langley asked why the company would come to a Town that does not want them here. Ms. Filosa said that there was significant demand among their buyers for Sullivan’s Island. She said they are more than willing to work with the Town. Ms. Coste asked how this company came in and purchased a home. Henderson stated that Town government is not made aware of transfers of ownership. Henderson asked how Pacaso handled the fee structure, how are maintenance and management fees received. Ms. Filosa stated that when owners purchase their homes there is a 12% fee to facilitate the LLC structure. After that, there is a ninety-nine dollar ($99) monthly maintenance fee. She stated that the 12% is a one-time initial fee. Henderson said there is revenue being generated by Pacaso. JULY 13, 2022 LAND USE AND NATURAL RESOURCES COMMITTEE MEETING 4 It was asked if time shares were allowed on Sullivan’s Island. Henderson said there was case law that said the Town could not prohibit time shares. Benke said it was Baker vs Sullivan’s Island. Mr. O’Neil asked if that qualified as a short-term rental. Henderson stated that short- term rentals could be regulated but a time share involves ownership being divided and the town can’t regulate that. Mr. Carroll went through a brief description of the difference between time share and an LLC. Time shares involve the recording of a deed for sales and transfers. With an LLC, the owners do not change, the LLC changes. He stated that Pacaso works with local property managers, and he would assume the property managers would have a business license for the Town of Sullivan’s Island. It was asked if there had been some attempts to regulate the process in California. Mr. Carroll stated there would be some challenge to that regulation because of personal property rights. He reminded the Committee that the LLC structure has been around for decades and he would caution against attempting to regulate it. Ms. Filosa said she was available to answer questions at any time and that Pacaso supported personal property rights. Chair Visser wanted to assure everyone that their comments would be part of the public, and that all the correspondence sent to the Committee would be added to the minutes to become part of the record. Mr. O’Neil said the Town was looking into this issue. He said the Town is committed to single family residential neighborhoods; the Town chose quality of life over financial gain to support that. He personally is very committed to it. 4. Adjourn. There being no further public discussion or new business, the meeting adjourned at approximately 9:30 a.m. Motion: A motion was made to adjourn by Mr. O’Neil, seconded by Chair Visser; this motion passed unanimously. Respectfully Submitted Pamela Otto Approved at the August 16, 2022 Council Meeting

Source: Town of Sullivan's Island website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.