May 12, 2022 Historic Preservation and Design Study Group Meeting Minutes (PDF)
Town of Sullivan's Island · Charleston County · meeting of May 12, 2022 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Sullivan's Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP
MAY 12, 2022 1
Town of Sullivan’s Island, South Carolina
Historic Preservation and Design Study Group
A Subcommittee of the Land Use and Natural Resources Committee of Council
Thursday, May 12, 2022
Subcommittee met at 4:00pm, at Town Hall, 2056 Middle Street, all requirements of the
Freedom of Information Act having been met. Present were,
Subcommittee voting members: John Winchester (Chair), Aussie Geer (Vice Chair), Eddie
Fava, Elizabeth Tezza, Beverly Bohan, Michael Daly and Manda Poletti.
Staff: Joe Henderson, Deputy Administrator, Charles Drayton, Planning and Zoning
Administrator, and Pam Otto, Study Group staff member.
A. Call to Order. Chair Winchester called the meeting to order at 4:01pm, stating the press
and public were duly notified pursuant to state law.
Media: None present
Public: Thirteen (13) members present, including Land Use and Natural Resources (LUNR)
member Gary Visser, Design and Review Board (DRB) member Ron Coish, and Planning
Commission member Mark Howard.
B. Approval of Minutes from April 28, 2022 meeting.
Motion: A motion was made to approve the April 28, 2022, meeting minutes by Ms. Bohan;
seconded by Ms. Tezza, this motion passed unanimously with a 7-0 vote.
C. Items for Discussion.
Chair Winchester mentioned this was the sixth (6th) meeting of the Study Group. Ms. Coste
asked for more information about fractional ownership. Henderson said it was a new concept
that staff just became aware of recently. He said there is an umbrella company out of California
that offers shares in residential properties, there is one (1) fractionally owned property on the
island, this company is called Picasso. He said that Town Council and the legal team are aware
of this company and are working with other jurisdictions that have experienced the company as
well. He said that the Town is looking into state law, which pre-empts local jurisdictions, to see
if a law can be written and if anything can be done locally.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP
MAY 12, 2022 2
Chair Winchester then introduced Charles Drayton as the new Planning and Zoning
Administrator and welcomed him to the Study Group.
1. Historic Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) preservation incentive.
Chair Winchester said at the last meeting the group seemed to agree for good reasons to retain
the “rental option” for a restored ADU. While he saw the potential problems down the road for
“thirty (30) day rentals,” this had not been a problem so far and clearly the group wanted to
retain that as an incentive. He said that the group had discussed allowing DRB relief to allow
increased square footage but that so far, no percentage had been agreed upon. The desire, as
pointed out by Ms. Poletti, is to make the ADU option more attractive so it needs more
incentives. Chair Winchester pointed out that that when the historic cottage is twelve hundred
(1200) square feet (sf), it does not allow the construction of a home large enough to
accommodate families. It was stated from a member of the public that consideration should be
taken of families, with a caution that if building is made too restrictive it will be more difficult
for families to live on the island.
Motion: A motion was made by Ms. Geer to remove §21-20 C. (2) (j); which states that the
DRB may not grant discretionary increases in principal building coverage, impervious surface
coverage and square footage to properties with a second structure; and to replace that section
with one that grants the DRB discretionary authority to increase the principal building square
footage by up to fifteen percent (15%) as long as the historic ADU remains at 1200sf or less;
seconded by Ms. Bohan.
Discussion
Manda Poletti – feels that 15% does not seem like enough. The group has already voted to
grant twenty percent (20%) to attached additions, anything less is almost penalizing the ADU
incentive. If the goal is to keep the historic cottage unattached, then you have to allow a larger
percentage increase than the attached addition.
Michael Daly – Agrees with Ms. Poletti, the relief for the ADU should be greater than for the
attached addition, and the overall square footage being discussed is minimal.
Aussie Geer – Agrees they have a point and is happy to amend the motion.
Eddie Fava – Feels most people buy these structures because they want to fix them up and
won’t need an incentive to buy them. He asked about the maximum square footage allowed for a
new construction with no ADU.
Ms. Bohan said she would like to know that as well. Henderson stated that the maximum
allowed square footage depended on the size of the lot. The most allowed is fifty-six hundred
(5600) sf. Henderson went through the formula used to determine allowed principal building
square footage (PB sf). The starting point is twenty-four hundred (2400) sf, you are then allowed
to increase by ten (10) sf for every one hundred (100) sf your lot is over 2400sf.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP
MAY 12, 2022 3
Mr. Fava said with that in mind, he is in favor of a larger percentage increase allowed for
properties with ADUs in order to give them an incentive. He also said that a 5600sf house does
not happen very often due to other checks and balances involving set backs and impervious
coverage, it is an anomaly that something reaches that maximum limit.
Beverly Bohan – Asked if the purpose was still to reduce mass and scale of homes. She pointed
out that on a standard half (.5) acre lot with a 1200sf cottage, given twenty-five percent (25%) by
the DRB could have a new house constructed to three thousand eight hundred ninety-seven
(3897)sf for a total of almost fifty one hundred (5100) sf. She strongly recommends that the
incentive be kept to no more than 20%. There is incentive toward attached because the fifty
percent incentive was taken away from the attached addition. She said to allow too much of an
increase to the new house with an ADU creates a scene similar to a “tugboat pulling the Queen
Mary.”
Ms. Poletti said the two amounts for the incentives depend upon each other and if the route
chosen is to give ADUs 20%, then the attached addition percentage might need to be revisited.
That will make the ADU to appear to have more of an incentive. Ms. Bohan asked what was
more important, to have ADUs over attached additions, or to reduce the overall mass, size and
scale of homes. She said that the homeowners can’t be restricted on their vision for their
properties but that the Town doesn’t have to give away or gift allowances, if it does it will end up
exactly how it is now, with homes that are too extravagant.
Elizabeth Tezza – Agrees with Ms. Poletti that whatever is decided needs to be more due to
perception of an incentive, the ADUs incentive should appear higher than the attached addition.
Chair Winchester said it is more at 15% or 20%, but that 25% is too much. He also said it
should be understood that most of the cottages being dealt with are not 1200sf, they are smaller,
around eight hundred (800) sf. Chair Winchester said that with a cottage at 800sf, then the new
house being built can be significantly bigger with just the DRB relief of 15%. He feels like the
ADU option is a situation that is more desirable to most people even with a lower percentage
incentive, plus the rental option is a big incentive. Ms. Poletti asked if the ADU is more
desirable, why are so many being lost to the attached. Chair Winchester said it was due to the
fifty percent (50%) exemption incentive and the relief that incentive is able to request, essentially
“double dipping” into two (2) opportunities for additional square footage. Henderson agreed,
saying the 50% exemption allowed for considerably more square footage.
Chair Winchester asked if Ms. Geer modified her motion from 15% to 20%, would there be a
consensus. Ms. Poletti said she is amenable to 20% but thinks the percentage allowed for
attached should be lowered to be under that percentage. Ms. Bohan asked what the difference
would be between 20% and 25% relief, Henderson said it would come out to about two hundred
(200) sf. Ms. Poletti said she would prefer to see ADUs over attached and to do that thinks that
ADUs should appear to have a higher incentive.
Motion: Ms. Geer amended her original motion, to recommend removal of §21-20 C. (2) (j);
which states that the DRB may not grant discretionary increases in principal building coverage,
HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP
MAY 12, 2022 4
impervious surface coverage and square footage to properties with a second structure; and to
replace that section with one that grants the DRB discretionary authority to increase the principal
building square footage by up to 20% as long as the historic ADU remains at 1200sf or less;
seconded by Ms. Bohan. This motion passed unanimously, 7-0.
Public Comment
Ms. Heller said she believes that the group should go with the largest number, as any property
would come before the DRB and they would have the option to turn it down. Chair Winchester
said the group has done that, adding a possible 800sf to a house with an ADU on a half-acre lot.
He said if that is not enough for a property owner, then the proposed property might not be the
right one for them.
2. New Construction: General discussion of the mass, size and scale of the new single-
family homes and additions.
Chair Winchester asked the group what they were feeling about new construction, knowing what
has already been discussed. Mr. Visser said that Town Council is curious where the group is
going but that the group can cover and discuss any aspect of the built environment on the island.
Discussion
Mr. Coish feels that there are some new homes on the island that seem very big. Ms. Perkis said
that there is no need to incentivize people to move here so there is no need for all of these
increases, what is the purpose of allowing them to be bigger. She said that if there is a half-acre
lot, there is a size you can build to and that should be it. Mr. Howard is interested in preserving
the island character, maybe by encouraging porches and larger yards. All variance procedures
should be reviewed. Chair Winchester pointed out that if a home is not seeking increases, they
do not need to go to the DRB. Ms. Heller feels that newer corner lot homes are being built
facing the wrong direction, longways, with no street presence. Ms. Perkis said that the Town
consulted with a design group, Cooper Consulting, who contributed to the design guidelines.
Ms. Coste feels that most new construction is out of compatibility with the island and that is an
issue that needs to be addressed. It was asked if the purpose of the DRB was to preserve the
character of the island., why are they approving these homes. Chair Winchester reiterated that
not all homes come before the DRB. He also said that there needs to be better standards for the
DRB to be able to enforce. Henderson said the purpose of the variances is to entice people who
want increases to have to go before the DRB, triggering negotiations for better design. A
property owner can build whatever they want, but if they want more square footage they need to
go to the DRB where certain standards need to be demonstrated.
Ms. Wilson said that when she has people ask her for home plans now, all they want is more
square footage, they are thinking about resale value. She is under a pressure to ask for the most
allowed square footage. The rules need to be more restrictive so she can tell people that she
can’t design a house that big. She feels the DRB is very important and that a place without one
has no control over the houses being built. It is hard for her to tell a client no if the neighboring
HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP
MAY 12, 2022 5
house has received variances. She feels there need to be more restrictive rules. The architect
should be able to prove their case and to do the work to get these variances. If a town does not
support their Boards and make their rules stronger, there is the potential for the character of a
town to be ruined. Henderson said that an attempt has been made by adding pages to the DRB
application to request the applicant to justify the relief. He asked if it was feasible for architects
to do more, a streetscape for example. Ms. Wilson said it used to be required. Mr. Winchester
said that is an administrative task that can be done now and does not need to be brought to
Council. Mr. Visser said if the application is not completed, it should be denied. That way the
Board can have all of the necessary information to make an informed decision. Mr. Howard
feels that neighborhood compatibility should always be considered, even if a project is not going
before the DRB. Ms. Bohan said that it still has to go to staff to make sure it follows the
guidelines. Henderson agreed, if a house is not going before the DRB, it still has to meet certain
architectural standards.
Eddie Fava – Supports fewer and simpler rules. The application should not be so confusing. He
also feels every new construction should go before the DRB and there should be an architect or
design specialist on staff to oversee this. He also feels that there is too much on the DRB and
that the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) should be more involved. He supports more openness
of design, not restricted by more guidelines.
Me. Winchester asked if he was saying there should be no relief by the DRB for new
construction. Mr. Fava said yes, no relief keeps it simple. Ms. Campbell said Sullivan’s Island
setbacks are more restrictive that others, and even now there are so many non-conforming
properties on the island. Mr. Fava said yes the ordinances here are more restrictive and that it
was intentional. It was done with the knowledge that if you were able to demonstrate a good
design or there was some pre-existing condition, then DRB could give some relief. However, if
there was someway to modify setbacks or other zoning issues so that if there is a hardship or a
need then the property owner could go before the BZA, that would take some of the pressure off
of the DRB. Henderson said there is a challenge in sending design issues to the BZA, their
standards are restricted by size, shape and physical topography of a property. If a property
owner is coming to the BZA, they are saying they can’t use the property for its intended use due
to the regulation and they are requesting a variance.
Elizabeth Tezza – feels the island is very eclectic and she believes strongly in personal property
rights. People building sideways seem to be building to the lot they are on, the more rectangular
lots, or are putting their porches on the side to have more privacy. The Town is not a planned
community, and she does not think it should look like one. She said many new homes seem very
large, but they are not coming to the BZA for variances, they are getting all of the relief the DRB
can give them. She would be fine with not allowing any relief for new construction, most lots
are large and can accommodate a good-sized house.
Beverly Bohan – Hopes to create new construction guidelines, placed on the website, so there is
less paperwork involved. She appreciated Ms. Wilson’s honesty about size, mass and scale of
HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP
MAY 12, 2022 6
new homes, and people asking to build bigger homes. She thinks if the guidelines were stricter,
saying nothing over five thousand (5000) sf for example, it is a better way to scale down homes.
Henderson said that is the issue, what number should be used to define too big. Mr. Fava said
staff and the Board can say a home is just too large, there is no need to use the percentages.
Ms. Bohan says the Board tries to push the percentages back and homeowners just keep
resisting. She is asking if it is possible to just set limits, based on the lot size, that are firm. Then
if there is an issue, they would have to go to the BZA for a variance. Henderson said it would be
easy to change the formula currently being used to determine maximum heated square footage
based on lot size, then you could allow the 20% from the DRB. Chair Winchester asked why it
was simpler to address it from that aspect, that it would be more difficult to negotiate backwards
from a set size. Mr. Howard said that the house is not the only filling the lot, porches, garages
and swimming pools don’t count.
Chair Winchester asked where this discussion was going. The group has looked at the ADU
incentive and decided to allow DRB relief for property owners going this route. He sees no
purpose in changing the formula and not using the DRB relief. Ms. Bohan said if that is the case,
then she would propose lowering the possible DRB relief for new construction to 20% across the
board.
Aussie Geer – Thinks new construction is too large. If a homeowner wants the extra 25%, they
will insist upon it from their architect and contractor. They will also not understand why they
can’t have it if a neighbor did get it. She feels that it can be reigned in by having a set amount
allowed, then if you have a hardship you can go to the BZA.
Michael Daly – Agreed, if there is a maximum allowed, most people will ask for it and expect it.
He thinks an option is to provide more relief to a single-story house, when they are lower to the
ground it controls the appearance of size.
Manda Poletti – Described the house next to hers, which is similar in size to hers by square
footage but is built up and seems much larger. She asked if it was possible to make it where you
can only get the additional square footage for new construction if you leave the house low.
D. Discussion of next meeting’s agenda items.
Chair Winchester said at the next meeting the 25% relief the DRB can offer on new construction
will be discussed. He said the DRB needs this as a means to get houses lower. He does not feel
it has worked so far. He asked the group to consider that if it necessary to reduce the
discretionary authority of the DRB and maybe tying it to keeping the houses lower. A property
owner could only get the relief if they stay within 2 feet of the Base Flood Elevation (BFE) is an
idea worth considering. Ms. Perkis said that it is not practical if a hurricane comes through, not
to mention that if they are that low, they can build a garage. Chair Winchester said all of the
historic properties are low and that is the goal. The zoning standards for new construction will
also be discussed at the next meeting.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP
MAY 12, 2022 7
E. Adjourn
There being no further public discussion and no new business, the meeting adjourned at
approximately 5:47pm.
Respectfully submitted,
Pamela Otto,
Historic Preservation and Design Study Group staff member
*Correspondence sent to Study Group attached
5/2/2022Dear Historic Preservation And Design Study Group members,
My name is Rick Graham and Ilive at 2102 Ion Avenue. Ideeply appreciate historic
preservation and its relationship to the quality of life on Sullivan’s Island. The appropriate
balance between new realities and historic preservation is dif ficult to maintain so your work is
very important.
While you’re addressing the balance, I’d like to call your attention to amajor violation of our
current historic preservation ordinances. The parking lot at Battery Thomson is aviolation and
there’s no justification for it. This is certainly an example of the Town doing whatever it wants
and it diminishes the importance of historic preservation .Town Council doesn’t care about the
Battery Thomson eyesore but I’m sure it’s present condition isn’t what previous Town Council
members had in mind when aconsultant was hired to get Battery Thomson on the National
Historic Register. Apicture is included.The relationship between the site and the structure of
Battery Thomson is definitely not being maintained as called for by federal guidelines.
Sullivan’s Island is becoming more popular and crowded every year so parking will always be a
concern. Theres been plenty of worthless meetings and studies about parking which didn’t
accomplish anything although we did finally make some progress with the opening of the new
parking lot on Middle Street. With areal commitment to solving problems there are plenty of
ways to address parking issues without destroying historic properties and the new parking lot
is only one example. What ashame it would be to continue degrading Battery Thomson while
also weakening the argument for historic preservation by allowing the illegal parking lot to
continue. You can’t preserve history by destroying it.
Irequest the Historic Preservation Study Group address the Battery Thomson parking lot. The
town will likely claim past uses to justify it. Those brief infrequent uses were never as intense as
the current parking lot and probably not legal either. Although this letter is being submitted late
in the process Ibelieve there is time for the study group to form astatement concerning the
appropriateness of using Battery Thomson for parking and the importance of the Town
following its own zoning code. Please ask town of ficials at the next meeting to explain the
creation and use of the Battery Thomson parking lot.
Respectfully,
Richard Gr^am
fwvt'
2102 Ion Ave.
Source: Town of Sullivan's Island website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.