RecordWell Data

March 17, 2022 Historic Preservation and Design Study Group Meeting Minutes (PDF)

Town of Sullivan's Island · Charleston County · meeting of Mar 17, 2022 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Sullivan's Island

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

HI HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP MARCH 17, 2022 1 Town of Sullivan’s Island, South Carolina Historic Preservation and Design Study Group A Subcommittee of the Land Use and Natural Resources Committee of Council Thursday, March 17, 2022 Subcommittee met at 4:00pm, at Town Hall, 2056 Middle Street, all requirements of the Freedom of Information Act having been met. Present were, Subcommittee voting members: John Winchester (Chair), Aussie Geer (Vice Chair), Eddie Fava, Elizabeth Tezza, Beverly Bohan, Rita Langley, and Manda Poletti. Michael Daly arrived at 4:07pm. Staff: Joe Henderson, Planning and Zoning Administrator, Max Wurthmann, Building Official and Pamela Otto, Study Group Staff member 1. Call to Order. Chair Winchester called the meeting to order at 4:00pm, stating the press and public were duly notified pursuant to state law, and all voting members were present except for Christina Butler. Media: None present Public: Sixteen (16) members present, including Land Use and Natural Resources (LUNR) members Scott Millimet and Gary Visser, as well as Planning Commission member Mark Howard. 2. Approval of Minutes from March 3, 2022 meeting. Motion: A motion was made to approve the March 3, 2022 meeting minutes by Ms. Bohan, this motion passed unanimously with a 7-0 vote. 3. Items for Discussion. Chair Winchester stated the meetings would have agendas but said that the miscellaneous items that come up that are not on HI HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP MARCH 17, 2022 2 the agenda would be recorded by Vice Chair Geer to be possibly included on future agendas. A. Schneider historic preservation survey. Henderson was tasked to give an overview of the survey. He mentioned the presence of Kat Kenyon at today’s meeting, who was on Town staff when some of the survey work was done. Henderson said any time a historic preservation project was submitted to the Design Review Board (DRB), the survey is used to first determine if the property is historic and then what identifies the property as historic. The initial survey was done in 1987 by the Preservation Consultants of Charleston, with David Schneider as the lead surveyor. Initially there were three hundred sixty (360) resources identified, among those residential and non-residential. Today there are an estimated two hundred fifty (250) to two hundred seventy-five (275) residential structures, along with multiple archaeological and military structures. After the 1987 survey there was a post-Hurricane Hugo survey, to assess the damage to historic structures, of which many were wiped out. Thirteen percent (13%) of the historic structures were destroyed. In 2003, a survey was conducted where multiple properties were re- evaluated, and forty (40) properties were added to the previous surveys. In 2006, there was the National Register nomination, coinciding with the formation of the DRB in 2005. Thirty-six (36) properties were added at that time. In 2007, another supplemental review was made of all properties sixty (60) years and older. One hundred thirty-six were resurveyed, and many properties were added to the historic designation list. Henderson mentioned that the list is on the Town website at the request of some members of the DRB. He then showed an example of what the 1987 survey cards look like; they are typically four (4) to six (6) pages of information which details the name of the property, includes a photo, the HI HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP MARCH 17, 2022 3 construction date, the shape and form of the structure, the National Register status, the historical data, and the post-Hugo damage assessment. Henderson then gave an example of a traditional island resource, 2214 Middle St., explaining the difference between the traditional island resource and a Sullivan’s Island Landmark is the level of alterations over time. The property mentioned had some alterations, so it made it a traditional island resource, not a landmark. That means there is more flexibility with the DRB when allowing modifications to the property. Ms. Poletti asked if traditional island resource meant they are not on the National Register. Henderson said that is correct. There are two (2) different kinds of designations; one is the National Register which is a federal listing that offers no local protections, the other is the local designation, protection provided by the DRB and Town staff, which says a historical property is either a traditional island resource or a Sullivan’s Island landmark. Cindy Ewing asked how to judge the historical value of a property by the number system, one (1) to four (4), used in the study. Henderson said the code identifies what level of designation, “1” is a Sullivan’s Island landmark, “2” is a traditional island resource. Henderson stated that from a Town staff standpoint, a property is historic, and on the list as a “1” or “2” and must go to the DRB to for approval of any changes to the property, or it is not historic. Categories “3” or “4” have been given that designation because they have been altered or destroyed. Chair Winchester asked for Henderson’s opinion on whether there needs to be something done about the study list. Henderson said yes, it is time to review the study again. Public Input Chair Winchester mentioned correspondence the Study Group had received about the Schneider Study. Battery Gadsden sent a letter strongly supporting a new study (attached Exhibit A). Mike Walsh also sent a letter stating the Schneider Study is seriously flawed and in need of a review. Kat Kenyon agreed that the study is very flawed, with later reviews being not completely thorough. Mr. Millimet asked if the DRB can issue fines. Henderson stated that Town staff would write the citations. Mr. Millimet feels that enforcement is critical. Ms. Clark asked if the updates, the ones removing some items from the list, were done by the same company or in house. Henderson stated David Schneider was part of Preservation Consultants of Charleston and worked on the study in 1987 and 1990. HI HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP MARCH 17, 2022 4 Schneider then left and continued to work for Sullivan’s Island for the subsequent reviews. Ms. Langley said there are a lot of good things about the Schneider Study, but also some things that need work. Ms. Coste how a 1987 survey can tell how many of the remaining, post-Hugo properties are still worthy of being on the list or should be removed. Henderson agreed, stating that after Hurricane Hugo there was no DRB and no staff to oversee much of what went on with renovations or demolitions. Ms. Coste mentioned a lot of properties were just sold after Hurricane Hugo so there is no way to know how many historic structures were lost. Henderson said that is why there is a need reassess the historic properties and consolidate all of the surveys into one resource. It was asked if there is an approximate date that defines something as historic. Henderson said sixty (60) years or older is the typical benchmark. Ms. Poletti specified that it must have significance as well. Chair Winchester asked if the Study Group thought the Schneider study needed to be redone or can it be used as it is. Ms. Tezza stated that the study should not be thrown out but updated and reviewed. Chair Winchester agreed the study is useful but it is flawed and people lack confidence in it. Mr. Visser pointed out any motion made should include improvements to categorization. Ms. Ewing felt any study should start with the most historic structures and work through the rest next. Ms. Coste asked how many structures were on the original study, Henderson said three hundred sixty (360) properties were identified as historic in 1987. Ms. Coste then asked how many properties are listed today. Henderson said it is estimated to be at two hundred seventy-five (275) “1” and “2” rated residential properties. He also said this is why the list needs to be re-evaluated and consolidated into a master list. Such a list would be a great help to Town staff. Motion: A motion was made by Ms. Tezza to recommend a review and update of the Schneider study, including a review of all structures listed as “1” and “2” to start and also review the criteria for historic designation, but the recommendation is not limited to these items; seconded by Ms. Langley. Discussion Ms. Poletti feels the Schneider study is not as detailed as is needed, and incorrect in some areas, but it is a good starting point. She also stated that the South Carolina Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) website has a list of recommended consultants they prefer people use for historic projects and that might be useful as HI HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP MARCH 17, 2022 5 well. Mr. Daly said that the DRB saved many structures but the feel of the historic cottages was ruined by Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) flood regulations requiring the raising of homes. The DRB is the strongest protection the Town for historic homes. Ms. Geer agreed and said now is the right time for another survey. Ms. Bohan said a designation needs to be added to historic homes to educate the public and prohibit the people from thinking they could hide a historic house within a larger structure. Mr. Fava supports a revision of the Schneider study as it does not reflect the current state of historic properties and the updates were probably not thorough. Ms. Tezza asked if the motion should be amended to include a designation. Ms. Poletti asked what the designation would look like. Ms. Bohan said similar to the Charleston Carolopolis award, attached to the home and put up by the Town. Motion: A motion was made by Ms. Tezza to recommend a review and update of the Schneider study, including a review of all structures listed as “1” and “2” to start, a review of the criteria for historic designation, and the motion was amended to include a suggestion to pursue some type of historic designation for certain properties identified as historic as a “1” and “2”; seconded by Ms. Langley. This motion passed unanimously, 8-0. B. Historic review process and standards. Chair Winchester asked Ms. Bohan and Henderson to provide their expertise and describe the process and standards of historic renovations or restorations. The goal is to see if the standards or process needs to be improved. Henderson summarized how staff and the DRB have been working on the process over the past 5 years by increasing training for DRB members, making changes to the application, and also changing the permitting procedure, including enforcement. The DRB application has gone from four (4) pages to ten (10). All initial requests to the DRB automatically require a conceptual review. This is important because it is at the discretion of the Board to grant final approval. Now all projects are required to have a conceptual review with staff as well in a pre- application meeting. If this staff review is not done, Henderson will inform the Board that the project is not informed by the regulations. There are two (2) main projects that come before the Board, non-historic and historic. If it is a non-historic, the project is before the Board to request increases in the zoning standards. The project is required to justify that request. Historic projects are required to identify how it meets the historic HI HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP MARCH 17, 2022 6 preservation standards, that come directly from the Secretary of Interior standards. On the application is a space where the project manager or architect can tell how they meet these standards. Another recent change by the Board is that a project must justify how the design is more compatible with the surrounding neighborhood. They must prove that they deserve the increases they are requesting. The application process is very intense but if done correctly, the Board is very informed about the project in question. There have also been several changes in the permitting procedure, the contractor is required to provide a narrative to the DRB of how everything will be built on site. Mr. Howard asked where these changes were initiated. Henderson stated they have been learned from some DRB approved projects that went badly. Ms. Poletti asked why the application lists ten (10) preservation standards in part D1 of the application, when only the first eight (8) are preservation standards and the last two (2) are rehabilitation standards. Henderson stated that in the zoning ordinance gives the Department of Interior rehabilitation standards because if it comes before the DRB, it is a rehabilitation. A straight preservation project does not need to come to the DRB. There are four (4) treatment strategies outlined in the Secretary of Interior guidelines; preservation, rehabilitation, restoration, and reconstruction. Ms. Bohan stated that all projects involving historic structures will involve at least one of the strategies. She said that the DRB meets on site at these historic properties to ascertain how and what changes will be made before they consider approval. Ms. Bohan said that Craig Bennett, of Bennett Preservation Engineering PC, was hired to be a consultant to advise the Board. She also said that it was difficult to make an informed decision until the applicant gives their presentation at the DRB meeting. Mr. Howard asked when an addition becomes historic, using the example of a 1920 addition onto a home built in 1890. Henderson said the DRB makes the determination of what is significant or not and, as Ms. Bohan stated, a historic rehabilitation project can evolve from its approval due to age of the structure and the harsh barrier island environment. The example given was the Fort Moultrie auto garage, an eighty (80) year old addition was removed in order to help with the restoration of the original structure. Ms. Ewing is not sure if members of the DRB are the right people to make the distinction of what is historic. Henderson stated that several things are used to determine what can be done HI HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP MARCH 17, 2022 7 to a historic structure. The architect must give their justification of photos, evaluations of building material but the Board also goes out on site. For example, the Junior Officers Quarters has well documented alterations. They originally had single story porches, but in the 1930s a second story porch was added. Those second story porches would not be removed because they are a prominent, well-defined historic characteristic of these structures; however, at the same time lean-to structures were added to the back of these buildings. The DRB has allowed the removal of these lean-tos because they weren’t very prominent, and it allows a give and take with the DRB. Chair Winchester believes that the process that has evolved over the last ten (10) years is a good process, but wants to know if there are things that can be done to improve it. Mr. Millimet wants a historical preservation expert as a resource to the DRB, relieving the pressure on the DRB. Ms. Bohan says they have hired someone, Craig Bennett, because the Board wanted more information. They approached Mayor Pat O’Neil to request the funding to hire him and he was found by Henderson. He has been advising the Board for the past nine (9) months and is at their disposal at any time. He writes reports and walks properties with the Board. Ms. Bohan assured everyone that the DRB was doing everything they could do to preserve historic structures. Ms. Ewing feels the DRB just approves all requests coming to them. Chair Winchester wants to know where the process failed, at the decision process or the ordinance itself. Ms. Coste feels that the DRB has become political. Chair Winchester concluded that the process and standards are there but there might be problems with the execution. Ms. Tezza said the members of Boards and Commissions are very well trained, by Joe and annual training requirements. She felt some just might not agree with the decisions that are made. Ms. Poletti said she has been through the DRB process and feels they were more restrictive in some instances that SHPO. She feels that the DRB does the best possible job that can be done and that they are why the historic properties have been preserved. 4. General Public Input. Chair Winchester mentioned letters received from Mike Walsh (Exhibit B), Battery Gadsden (Exhibit A), and Joy Morris (Exhibit C). He also mentioned a letter from Chris Kronzer referencing rear setbacks and swimming pools (Exhibit D). Chair Winchester said he is available after the meeting if anyone has anything to discuss with him. HI HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP MARCH 17, 2022 8 5. Discussion of next meeting’s agenda items. Chair Winchester mentioned that the first agenda item for the next meeting will be the third item on the agenda for today’s meeting that was not discussed; size, mass, and scale of historic resources. He also suggested that the next item be incentives. Mr. Howard stated that he had been asked by the Battery Gadsden Board Director to read the letter submitted by Battery Gadsden. He then read the attached letter, Exhibit A, out loud to the assembly. 6. Adjourn. There being no further public discussion and no new business, the meeting adjourned at approximately 5:43pm. Motion: A motion to adjourn was made by Ms. Tezza; seconded by Vice Chair Geer. This motion passed unanimously, 8-0. Respectfully submitted, Pamela Otto

Source: Town of Sullivan's Island website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.