March 3, 2022 Historic Preservation and Design Study Group Meeting Minutes (PDF)
Town of Sullivan's Island · Charleston County · meeting of Mar 3, 2022 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Sullivan's Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP
MARCH 3, 2022 1
Town of Sullivan’s Island, South Carolina
Historic Preservation and Design Study Group
A Subcommittee of Land Use and Natural Resources Committee of Council
Thursday, March 3, 2022
Subcommittee met at 4:00pm, at Town Hall, 2056 Middle Street, all requirements
of the Freedom of Information Act having been met. Present were,
Subcommittee voting members: John Winchester (Chair), Aussie Geer (Vice
Chair), Eddie Fava, Elizabeth Tezza, Beverly Bohan, Rita Langley, Michael Daly,
and Manda Poletti
Staff: Joe Henderson, Planning and Zoning Administrator, Max Wurthmann,
Building Official and Pamela Otto, Study Group staff member
1. Call to Order. Chair Winchester called the meeting to order at 4:00pm,
stating the press and public were duly notified pursuant to state law, and all
voting members were present except for Christina Butler.
Media: None present
Public: Fourteen (14) members present, including Land Use and Natural
Resource (LUNR) members Gary Visser, Scott Millimet and Pat O’Neil, as
well as Planning Commission Member Mark Howard.
2. Introduction of Study Group members. Chair Winchester introduced the
subcommittee voting members, mentioning that Christina Butler could not
be present. The criteria of voting members were a member each from the
Boards and Commissions (excluding Tree Commission), a builder, an
architect, an historian, and residents who are familiar with renovating
historic homes. He also mentioned the non-voting members who will add to
the discussion. The non-voting members are Joe Henderson, Max
Wurthmann, Pat O’Neil, Gary Visser, Roy Williams, Mike Walsh, Linda
Perkis, Carlsen Huey, Mark Howard, Karen Coste, Kathy Heller, Hal Currey
and Cheryl Clark. Chair Winchester then went through the Study Group
HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP
MARCH 3, 2022 2
handouts, mentioning that they are available on the Town website on the
Study Group page.
3. Orientation and evaluation of existing conditions. Chair Winchester
spoke briefly about the conduct of the meetings, saying that public input is
welcome, and communications can be emailed to Town staff. The agenda
will be made available in advance to the public. The houses being discussed
are to be discussed by address, not name. There will be a time for public
input in the meetings and email correspondence will be put on the record.
However, when it comes to motions and voting, discussion will be kept
between voting members. Before the meetings are adjourned, there will be a
discussion of the next meeting’s agenda. It was asked if historic
preservation in other communities will be studied, Chair Winchester said he
felt it more important to see what Sullivan’s Island wants. Ms. Tezza
pointed out that Sullivan’s Island is unique from other historic communities
as it is bound by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), the
South Carolina Department of Health and Environmental Control
(SCDHEC) and critical lines. Henderson stated that it would be good for all
members, voting and non-voting, to have ideas about where they feel the
zoning ordinances are doing well and where they are not doing well.
Henderson then showed how to navigate to the Study Group page on the
website and where to find all the documents, maps, and resources. Mr.
Millimet asked how the Group would approach their mission, as historic
preservation and new build design are very different topics. Chair
Winchester stated that historic preservation will be the first priority and then
new builds will be addressed.
A. Study Group Process. Henderson gave an overview of the text
amendment process for an ordinance. He stated the goal of the Study
Group is to study the existing conditions, mainly since 2005, of new
construction on residential properties and also historic restoration
projects. The Study group will develop a list of recommendations to
send to Town Council via the LUNR committee. Town Council will
then discuss them at meetings and workshops, and then send them to
the Planning Commission, who will draft the language after study of
the issues. Planning Commission will also hold a public hearing to
allow public input, then send it back to Town Council for 3 readings.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP
MARCH 3, 2022 3
B. Comprehensive Plan Objectives. The Comprehensive Plan (in Land
Use policy 6, Land Use objective 6.1) recommends the formation of a
task force to review Zoning Ordinance regulations to ensure that
future construction is respectful of the Island’s traditional mass-height
scale proportional to lot size, neighborhood compatibility and historic
resources. Land use objective 6.2 recommends taking a look at design
guidelines and other accessory usage. Henderson then went through
the regulatory framework used to process building permits. Any
permit must have 3 factors considered before issue, those are historic
districts, Zoning maps and FEMA flood maps.
C. Historic Districts. Sullivan’s Island has three (3) local historic
districts and four (4) National Register historic districts. A National
Register historic district is adopted on a federal level. The local
historic districts, Moultrieville, Sullivan’s Island, and Atlanticville,
gives the Town the authority to protect structures within these
districts. National Register historic districts do not give any authority
for protection of structures. The Design Review Board (DRB) uses
these districts to determine where they can be more flexible with
massing, scale, and contemporary design. There is also a historic
structure overlay that identifies historic structures outside of the
districts.
D. Zoning map. This also regulates development on Sullivan’s Island.
Most of the island is zoned Residential but there is also a commercial
district with split zoned lots and a Public Facilities zoning district.
Henderson also discussed the new FEMA flood maps issued in 2019
and the drastic change it can make to the Island’s built environment.
No longer do homes have to be built eight to ten (8-10) feet from
grade, they can now be built two (2) feet from grade. This makes
neighborhood compatibility a very important concern for the elevation
of homes as well.
4. Establishment of Mission Statement. Chair Winchester stated the task of
the Study Group is not to review the ordinances, but to review the built
environment and the success or failure to protect historic structures. The
implied task is to solicit public input and make recommendations that
HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP
MARCH 3, 2022 4
address and support the vision of the Comprehensive Plan. The Study
Group should also make recommendations for changes that will ensure the
protection of historic structures and address the new FEMA guidelines.
5. Discussion of next meeting’s business. Chair Winchester asked for
comments for the next meeting’s agenda as he wanted a rough idea of what
to include. Mr. Howard wants to include how flood maps change the
approach to historic structures and how high they can be built. Mr. Millimet
asked the percentage improvement to require adherence to FEMA
guidelines. Henderson answered that it was fifty percent (50%). Ms. Coste
asked if the mission statement included fencing. Chair Winchester stated
that they could very well be covered.
Mr. Visser stated that some current incentives to protect historic structures
might not be doing the job. Ms. Tezza supports the current incentives but
was not sure if certain homes could still be considered historic. Ms. Heller
asked if lowering the building limits has resulted in an increase in the
construction of garages. Henderson stated that allowing a garage was an
incentive to build lower. Ms. Poletti agreed, saying it was an issue when this
came before the Planning Commission, that if you let people build lower
there will be an increase in separate garages.
Ms. Poletti asked if the next agenda could include a discussion of the
Department of Interior standards for historic preservation. Ms. Bohan said
any who come before the DRB should be using these guidelines as they are
very specific. Ms. Coste asked if the Study Group will emphasize to the
members of the Boards and Commission what their purpose is and make
sure they are properly trained. Chair Winchester hopes the Study Group will
be able to enact changes in the ordinances that better guide the Boards and
Commissions. Ms. Tezza said the members are trained and are restricted by
the ordinances.
Mr. Millimet asked what qualifies a structure as historic. He also wants to
know what can be done to tighten up the existing regulations so there is no
room for broad interpretation, size and mass are an issue. Mr. Fava feels
that the incentive that allows a property owner to build a larger structure if
attached to the historic structure has the opposite effect that it intended, it
encourages larger mass.
Chair Winchester wants to broach the Schneider Study and discuss it. The
next agenda is to cover the Schneider Study, Town standards and processes
HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND DESIGN STUDY GROUP
MARCH 3, 2022 5
for a restoration project to include Board training, the height-mass-scale of
historic properties (including the special exception) and accessory structures.
Henderson wants to touch on two (2) sections of the ordinance that effect
historic projects in his opening to the next meeting, one is the historic
special exception, and the other is the fifty percent exemption. He will show
some off island examples and then discuss the incentives on island.
Mr. Walsh said there was more than one study. Henderson said Schneider
came to update his study multiple times, initially in the mid-1980s, again in
1988 and in 2005. During those updates, properties were removed and
added. Mr. O’Neil was glad to see the value placed on historic preservation
and thanked the Study Group for their time and effort.
6. Adjourn. There being no further public discussion and no new business, the
meeting adjourned at approximately 5:21pm.
Motion: A motion was made to adjourn by Ms. Langley, seconded by Ms.
Tezza; motion passed unanimously.
Respectfully submitted,
Pamela Otto
Source: Town of Sullivan's Island website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.