Minutes (PDF)
Town of Sullivan's Island · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Sullivan's Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
TOWN OF SULLIVAN’S ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE OF COUNCIL
MEETING MINUTES
Friday, May 1, 2015
A meeting of the Public Safety Committee of Council was held at 4:00 p.m., Friday, May 1,
2015 at Town Hall, 2050-B Middle Street, all requirements of the Freedom of Information Act
having been satisfied. Present were Committee members, Chauncey Clark, Chair, Council
members Pat O’Neil and Mary Jane Watson. Staff included Administrator Benke, Police Chief
Howard, Fire Chief Stith and Asst. to Administrator Darrow.
I. Call to Order. Chair Clark called the meeting to order, stated the press and
public were duly notified pursuant to state law and noted all members were present
(approximately 28 audience members and 1 media in attendance).
II. Parking Restrictions in Commercial District
Chair Clark stated the Committee’s goal today was to review the current traffic and parking
conditions in the Community Commercial District from a safety standpoint, and, provide for
public feedback on the same. He noted that last fall (November 13, 2014), the Committee
discussed the managed/paid parking concept; however, that topic was not included on this
meeting’s agenda. He asked residents to focus comments on general issues related to parking
and traffic in the CCD.
Chair Clark opened the floor for public comments (2 minutes each).
Public Comments:
Elizabeth Tezza, 2220 Atlantic Avenue, SI
Commented she lives at the corner of Atlantic and Station 22 ½
Observed the many safety considerations a driver must make at the corner of
Middle/Station 22 ½: pedestrian crossing both street intersections, multiple vehicle
options at the intersection (left/right turns, proceed straight), bicyclists riding through or
making similar turn choices as vehicles, vehicles entering/exiting the gas station at two
curb cuts immediately at the stop sign intersection, jay-walkers between the restaurants
and vehicles parking or leaving from parallel parking spots as well as perpendicular
parking spots, all in a very congested restaurant/commercial area.
Recommended the following (referenced her April 30, 2015 email to Mayor O’Neil):
o Re-install 4-way stop at Middle/Station 22 ½
o Close Station 22 ½ from Middle Street to I’On Avenue, reducing turn options at
Middle/Station 22 ½ intersection
o Allow for bicycle and golf cart parking only on the block of Station 22 ½ between
Middle Street and I’On Avenue
Michael Knoll, 1318 Middle Street, SI
Lives near the Fort Moultrie area and makes the right from Station 22 ½ to Middle Street
daily to get home, having to navigate the congestion in the CCD.
Approved at the May 4, 2015 Council Workshop
Public Safety Committee – May 1, 2015 Minutes
2
Has often observed vehicles stopping in the middle of the most heavily congested areas
of the CCD, close the Middle-Station 22 ½ intersection, to discharge passengers at a
restaurant before seeking a parking space. Noted this creates a bottleneck near the
intersection even in good traffic conditions.
Suggested eliminating some Middle Street parking spaces and creating valet parking
spaces, similar to what he has seen in South Beach, Florida, that would allow people to
drop off passengers and have vehicle parked away from the restaurant.
Wayne Stelljes, 3104 I’On Avenue, SI
Recommended giving safety chiefs wide latitude to manage a temporary closure of
Middle Street, based upon traffic flow.
Recommended removing parking on one side of Middle Street (Poe’s Tavern restaurant
side) from Station 22 ½ - 22 Streets and close one side of Middle Street from Station 21-
20 ½ Streets (Obstinate Daughter restaurant side).
Ann Osborne Kilpatrick, 1718 Middle Street, SI
Expressed appreciation that the Town is working to prepare for the impact of
Spring/Summer tourists on the Island.
Echoed traffic concerns about the CCD area as expressed by other residents.
Supports traffic and pedestrian safety measures along Middle Street in the CCD area.
Tim Reese, 305 Station 20 Street, SI
Recommended blocking parking from Station 22 ½ - 22 (Poe’s Tavern side) year-round.
Suggested the Town should give consideration to the impact of resident patron parking
on Jasper Street, between Station 22 ½ - 22 (aka Short Jasper). Recommended restaurant
owners collaborate to explore available lots for patron parking.
Rusty Bennett, 3124 Marshall Boulevard, SI
Noted he was the only business owner from the CCD in attendance today; noted other
restaurant owners were currently working at their restaurants during this busy Friday
afternoon.
Stated that three dozen parking spaces have been reduced over the last two years, due to
temporary seasonal parking restrictions on Middle Street and/or “one-side only” parking
restrictions on I’On and Atlantic Avenues.
He spoke with Robert Clarke of SCDOT and relayed that Mr. Clarke advised he was
unaware of other SC municipalities who have blocked parking spaces to allow safety
vehicle access, as Sullivan’s Island has done in the past.
Submitted that whether parking spaces were removed from Middle Street near his
restaurant (Poe’s Tavern), emergency vehicles would still be delayed as tourist traffic,
bridge openings and other pressures contribute to delayed response times. He noted that
all municipalities have to deal with emergency vehicles navigating traffic and congestion.
It is a universal challenge for all communities.
Noted that removing parking spaces on Middle Street would push restaurant patrons to
resident streets. Such a change would move the patron traffic from the desired location
Approved at the May 4, 2015 Council Workshop
Public Safety Committee – May 1, 2015 Minutes
3
(restaurants) to undesired areas (residential streets), contrary to what resident have
wanted and which the Town has tried to avoid in the past.
Submitted traffic flow would not be enhanced by removing parking. On-street parking
has often been used as means to suppress traffic speeds.
Expressed support for a professional traffic engineer reviewing the traffic and parking
situation, and, providing the Town expert feedback.
Stated he did not want to see an emotion-based decision made on parking and traffic in
the CCD in lieu of a rational approach to the issue with decisions based upon sound
professional and scientific information.
Mark Tanenbaum. 406 Station 12, SI
Noted he has lived on the Island for 42 years and in the Station 12/13 area for 8 years.
During his years on Sullivan’s Island, the Charleston metropolitan area population has
grown over the past two decades from 50,000 to over 700,000 people. This sustained
population growth does, and will continue to, impact the Town and strain its resources.
Agreed with Mr. Bennett that a more congested CCD, with full parking spaces, slows
down traffic speeds. Recalled 15 years ago writing a letter to Council expressing his
concern about speeding vehicles racing along the CCD.
Stated the Town needs to recognize, when it makes decisions, that it is a suburb of the
Charleston area and will never be a small, stand-alone barrier Island community again.
Everett Presson, 1718 Otis Pickett Court, SI
Recommended Town remove the perpendicular parking along Middle Street (Dunleavy’s
Pub/Home Team BBQ side) and replace it with a sidewalk and parallel parking spaces.
Noted there are currently 25 parking spaces that back in/out onto Middle Street from the
perpendicular slanted parking spaces. These vehicles back out tail-first, often unable to
see vehicles and bicycles traveling along Middle Street in this heavily congested area.
These vehicles backing up often block both lanes of traffic and contribute to a bottleneck
near the Middle Street/Station 22 ½ intersection.
Recalled that the CCD Master Plan study (circa 2008/2009), for which the Town paid
close to $100,000, recommended removing the perpendicular parking spaces along
Middle Street for safety reasons.
Mark Howard, 1820 Central Avenue, SI
Recommended some inexpensive ideas for traffic on Middle Street:
o Place a crosswalk in front of Poe’s Tavern (many jaywalk across the street here);
o Maximize the number of light poles on the street and ensure they work;
o Consider a designated parking lot for CCD traffic, such as the Town lot at Battery
Jasper.
o Maximize parking on the municipal campus, as the Town moves toward new
Town Hall/Police Station construction, gate the parking lot and charge for
parking.
Alice Morrisey, 1652 Thompson, SI
Sang a David Matthew Band tune modifying the words to express her concern about parking and
traffic problems in the CCD and Island-wide.
Approved at the May 4, 2015 Council Workshop
Public Safety Committee – May 1, 2015 Minutes
4
Committee Discussion:
Administrator Benke provided a brief background to this issue:
The police and fire chiefs raised safety concerns regarding the ability to move emergency
vehicles through the CCD area and off-Island via the CCD area, in response to on-Island,
and in support of off-Island, emergency calls.
The Town has communicated with SCDOT on this issue. Robert Clarke has given
SCDOT’s blessing for the Town to take whatever measures it feels is appropriate to
increase safety. The Town has been given wide latitude of discretion and options along
DOT streets when changes are made to increase safety.
In response to Mr. Howard’s suggestion, cross-walks are not allowed mid-block, per
SCDOT. As such, a crosswalk cannot be placed at Poe’s Tavern.
Noted that the parking and traffic design in the CCD area, particularly on Middle Street
between Stations 22 ½ - 20 are based upon a 1930’s traffic design. This design is ill
equipped for 2015 vehicle sizes and traffic counts.
He noted that Mt. Pleasant’s population is now at 68,000 people and increasing.
Traffic at Middle Street and Station 22 ½ have pedestrian crossings, bicycle maneuvering
and multiple traffic options at present, as mentioned by Ms. Tezza earlier.
Public Comments:
Sarah Church, 2215 I’On Avenue, SI
Suggested the Town could convert the parking area in front of Dunleavy’s – Taco
Mamacitas (currently perpendicular parking) to golf cart parking only, parallel parking.
Administrator Benke assured the audience and Committee that SCDOT would support
eliminating the current perpendicular parking spaces along Middle Street, should the Town want
to entertain this concept.
Karen Coste, 322 Station 19 Street, SI
Noted the concept of making I’On Avenue a one-way street and asked if the Town has
recently discussed this option.
Administrator Benke responded that approximately 15 years ago there was some discussion
about making I’On Avenue a one-way street and, during the CCD study in 2008/2009, resident
feedback was against making I’On Avenue one-way.
Chair Clark noted that two-way traffic on I’On Avenue encourages slower traffic speeds.
Mary Louise Ramsdale, 3122 I’On Avenue, SI
Stressed need for police to work harder on traffic enforcement. Noted Jasper Street
temporary summer traffic adjustments were not in force last weekend (turn only lane
signs).
Staff noted the Committee has included summer traffic control measures as the next agenda item.
Approved at the May 4, 2015 Council Workshop
Public Safety Committee – May 1, 2015 Minutes
5
Gary Visser, 2924 Middle Street, SI
Recalled that during the CCD study (circa 2008/2009) it was noted that parking in the
CCD contributing to deterring traffic speeds. Submitted that parking plans for the
restaurants need to be viewed and addressed as an annual activity.
Jerry Kaynard, 2501 Atlantic Avenue, SI
Noted the significant congestion that occurs in downtown Charleston, particularly the
tourist areas near Market Street and King/East Bay. Noted there is a lead public safety
vehicle (police or fire) in front of the emergency vehicles whose job is to clear the traffic.
Submitted that this idea could be part of the Town’s protocol, particularly for ambulance
assist.
The CCD study (circa 2008/2009) identified the perpendicular parking spaces, with cars
backing up onto one or both lanes of Middle Street, as major problems to traffic flow and
safety in the CCD.
Chief Stith noted that the fire department does usually escort inbound ambulances from the gas
station intersection to the call location.
Tim Reese, 305 Station 20 Street, SI
Supports eliminating perpendicular parking in favor of installing curbs, sidewalks and
parallel parking on Middle Street.
Believes the Town, in front of the restaurants on Middle Street with perpendicular
parking, should mimic the Town of Mt. Pleasant’s solution for Coleman Boulevard:
create “cut in” parking space alleys and/or park vehicles behind the restaurant.
Mark Tanenbaum. 406 Station 12, SI
Asked Staff if the perpendicular parking spaces were located on private parking.
Reiterated his opinion that parked cars slow traffic in the CCD.
Administrator Benke clarified that vehicles parking in the perpendicular spaces are located on
parking spaces that are 50/50 private and Town owned. Half of the vehicle is located on private
property and half the vehicle is parked on Town owned property.
Mark Tanenbaum. 406 Station 12, SI
Mr. Tanenbaum submitted that changing perpendicular parking to sidewalk and parallel parking
would likely not require adverse action against the private property owner (i.e. condemnation
under imminent domain action).
Ann Osborne Kilpatrick, 1718 Middle Street, SI
Questioned how an injured person would be currently transported off the Town should an
emergency vehicle note be able to get on or off the Island, due to traffic.
Chief Stith clarified that helicopters are used for transportation off the Island of serious injuries.
Approved at the May 4, 2015 Council Workshop
Public Safety Committee – May 1, 2015 Minutes
6
Jeff Hunter, Poe’s Tavern, SI
Submitted that the perpendicular parking spaces account for 99% of the issues and safety
problems in the CCD.
Staff Comment/Recommendation:
Administrator Benke:
Based upon a public safety standpoint, staff recommends to the Committee:
o Block parking on Middle Street from Station 22 ½ - Station 22 on the marsh-side
(gas station and Poe’s Tavern side): 23 parking spaces
o Block parking on Middle Street from Station 21 – Station 20 ½ on the seaward
side (Graham lot past Obstinate Daughter Restaurant to the Post Office): 20-24
parking spaces
Parking spaces would be blocked at the discretion of the Police and/or Fire Chief.
Town engage consultant services to provide engineering data and recommendations:
Conduct vehicle counts, identify traffic direction of travel and other traffic analysis to
identify long term strategy suggestions for Town Council.
Tim Reese, 305 Station 20 Street, SI
Suggested Town help fast track parking discussion with owners, with Council tasking the
Planning Commission to look at zoning changes, if needed to accomplish parking lots.
Ann Osborne Kilpatrick, 1718 Middle Street, SI
Suggested adding recommendation that the Town collaborate closely with Isle of Palms
to share resources (i.e. traffic consultant) and create mutual traffic/parking solutions.
Mayor O’Neil asked Administrator to clarify the nature and scope of consultant work Staff
recommends Council retain. Administrator Benke clarified that Staff recommends retaining a
traffic consultant to conduct traffic counts, perform traffic engineering and study traffic trends in
the area.
Committee Discussion:
Parking spaces along Middle Street between Station 22 ½ - 22 (Poe’s Tavern side)
Chair Clark: Removing parking spaces on this side of Middle Street has worked in past; pointed
to increased visibility of pedestrian crossing, for vehicles and pedestrians alike.
Councilwoman Watson: If Town plans to remove parking, she recommends doing this year-
round to condition Island visitors to the parking change.
Mayor O’Neil: Recommended a short term drop-off/pick-up or loading zone section, perhaps in
front of Poe’s Tavern.
Approved at the May 4, 2015 Council Workshop
Public Safety Committee – May 1, 2015 Minutes
7
MOTION: Councilwoman Watson recommended to Council that, for safety
reasons, parking along Middle Street be modified as follows: (a) year-round block
parking on Middle Street from Station 22 ½ - Station 22 adjacent to the westbound
lane (gas station and Poe’s Tavern side): 23 parking spaces; and (b) year-round
block parking on Middle Street from Station 21 – Station 20 ½ adjacent to the
eastbound lane (Graham lot past Obstinate Daughter Restaurant to the Post
Office): 20-24 parking spaces; (c) consideration for a drop off lane for patron
loading/unloading; seconded by Mayor O’Neil.
Discussion:
Fire Chief Stith: Noted that drop off should be restaurant patrons, not all delivery trucks on the
Island. His primary concern is emergency access through the street.
Mayor O’Neil: Recommended Staff include sufficient signage in the CCD encouraging and
directing visitors to the parking lot at Battery Thompson.
Residents offered suggestions that Town move forward on shared parking lots for restaurants,
removing perpendicular parking in favor of establishing a sidewalk and parallel parking.
Committee members noted that these concepts will be fully explored moving forward. At
present the Committee wants to recommend to Council a work-able, immediate option to
mitigate congestion and safety issues in the CCD, as outlined in the aforementioned motion.
CALL FOR THE QUESTION: MOTION UNANIMOUSLY PASSED.
[Committee re-affirmed its earlier discussion and recommendation to Council that the
Town retain a traffic engineering consultant to conduct traffic counts and provide
transportation analysis data for the Town.]
III. Summer Traffic Control Measures
Administrator Benke reviewed traffic control measures the Town can take:
1. Coordinate with Town of Mt. Pleasant on the timing of lights at the intersections of
McCants/Rifle Range Road, Ben Sawyer Boulevard/Rifle Range Road, and Chuck
Dawley/Coleman Boulevard (Royall Hardware area). Action already being taken.
2. Hire additional deputies from Charleston County. Action already being taken –
number of deputies available from Charleston County varies each weekend.
3. Establish signs to alert drivers that to a “no left turn” onto Middle Street from Jasper
Boulevard during high travel season. Action will begin this weekend.
4. Coordinate with Isle of Palms for traffic control measures when there are accidents on
Sullivan’s Island and, in turn, Isle of Palms. Action already being taken – note there
Approved at the May 4, 2015 Council Workshop
Public Safety Committee – May 1, 2015 Minutes
8
are limited options for Staff when accidents create traffic jams on either Island or
bridges.
5. Ben Sawyer Bridge coordination. Action that can be taken is already being taken.
During an accident or emergency, the Town can and does “lock down” the bridge
for emergency vehicle access. Ben Sawyer Bridge is one of 140 bridges along the
ICW from Norfolk, Virginia to Miamia Florida. The bridge summer open/close
schedule is the most favorable of the times available. Administrator noted the
bridge must, as a rule, open on demand for watercraft, allowing for free travel along
the ICW.
6. Coordinate with Mt. Pleasant Traffic Division Supervisor for Mt. Pleasant officers to
work traffic detail on the Ben Sawyer/Coleman Boulevard lights when Sullivan’s Island
has an accident. Action/coordination starts this weekend.
Chuck Gallis, 1817 Back Street, SI
Commented that stepped up enforcement of alcohol on the beach would also impact
traffic, noting that beachgoers seeking to drink and perhaps drive are generators of traffic
problems.
Chief Howard noted that the Beach Services Officers begin patrolling the beach this weekend.
Wayne Stelljes, 3104 I’On Avenue, SI
Recommended Town think hard about commercial loading zones, noting these vehicles
obstruct traffic flow through the busy CCD area.
Thanked the Administrator and Staff for facilitating SCDOT quick remedy to vehicles
entering the wrong way into Thomson Park at Breach Inlet, creating a safety hazard.
Administrator Benke noted that Committee proposed consideration of a drop-off area for
patrons, not a loading zone. He submitted a “no parking sign” in the drop-off area should suffice
to prevent parked commercial delivery trucks.
IV. Pedestrian Safety Education
Mayor O’Neil:
Observed the CCD blocks, particularly around the restaurant core, are treated like a
pedestrian mall with people drifting across the street to restaurants and bars.
He acknowledged this is a universal problem held by many neighborhood commercial
and/or tourist driven locations. Asked what the Town could do to promote pedestrian
safety education.
Chief Howard: Noted that there is no law that states a person may not cross in the middle of a
street block.
Councilwoman Watson: Suggested the Town solicit businesses to assist with spreading
pedestrian safety.
Approved at the May 4, 2015 Council Workshop
Public Safety Committee – May 1, 2015 Minutes
9
Mayor O’Neil: Noted that, for now, the police force could step up dialogue with people not
using the crosswalks, warning them of safety dangers and encouraging them to use the
crosswalks.
IV. Adjourn
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned (Councilmember O’Neil motion;
Councilmember Watson seconded; unanimous approval) at approximately 5:35p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Chauncey Clark, Chair
Public Safety Committee
Approved at the May 4, 2015 Council Workshop
Approved at the May 4, 2015 Council Workshop
Source: Town of Sullivan's Island website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.