Minutes (PDF)
Town of Sullivan's Island · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Sullivan's Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
Public Safety Committee: January 28, 2016 Minutes
TOWN OF SULLIVAN’S ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE OF COUNCIL
MEETING MINUTES
Thursday, January 28, 2016
A meeting of the Public Safety Committee of Council was held at 8:30 a.m., Thursday, January
28, 2016 at Town Hall, 2050-B Middle Street, all requirements of the Freedom of Information
Act having been satisfied. Present were Committee members, Chauncey Clark, Chair, Council
members Mayor Pat O’Neil and Sarah Church. Staff included Administrator Benke, Police
Chief Howard, Fire Chief Stith, Zoning Administrator Henderson and Asst. to Administrator
Darrow.
I. Call to Order. Chair Clark called the meeting to order, stated the press and
public were duly notified pursuant to state law and noted that all Committee members were
present. Approximately five residents and four media members (Island Eye News, Moultrie
News, Post & Courier News and Channel 5) were in attendance.
II. Coyotes
Committee members received a staff update from Administrator Benke and Police Chief Howard
regarding the coyote presence on the Island and the Town’s management activity:
No incidents to report of aggressive contact between coyotes and humans, to date.
A dog was attacked in a neighborhood recently. The Town cannot confirm it was a
coyote attack on the dog as there were no witnesses to the incident.
Police staff continues tracking and mapping reported coyote sightings over the past year.
The Town has, for approximately one year, set box traps on Town property identified
from the sighting analysis; however, no coyotes have been caught.
The Town of Sullivan’s Island has an established Plan, crafted with assistance from the SC
Department of Natural Resources (SCDNR), for co-existing with coyotes.
Soft-leg traps
The next step in the Plan, should Police Chief Howard deem it necessary, is the use of
soft-leg traps on Town-owned property.
This strategy would require the Town to obtain a depredation permit from SCDNR prior
to placement.
The Town would place soft-leg traps in more isolated/remote areas of the Island, not
heavily populated or trafficked sites. Appropriate safety signage would be installed to
warn people that trapping was underway.
Administrator Benke and Police Chief Howard have completed interviews with a short-
list of trapper vendors. The next step is to obtain depredation permits from SCDNR.
It was noted residents are allowed to use soft-leg traps on private property and many have
done so, using some of the same potential vendors the Town interviewed.
Committee Discussion:
Councilmember Church expressed her objection to the use of soft-leg traps. Her concerns
included:
Safety to children and pets who might be injured by the traps;
Approved at the February 1, 2016 Council Workshop
2
Public Safety Committee: January 28, 2016 Minutes
Other wildlife being injured from the traps;
The use of soft-leg traps now may be premature; noted that the coyote population
traditionally begins its annual retreat at this point;
This trapping method is inhumane to the coyote.
Committee Member inquiries:
Safety incidents with soft-leg traps on private property;
Frequency trappers would check traps, and, potential use of web-cameras
Chief Howard reported that the only incident of which he was aware involved a dog (Labrador)
trapped in a soft-leg trap. He was released and returned to his owner unharmed.
Administrator Benke noted that trappers would check the traps every 24 hours. Use of web-
cameras could be investigated, but the feasibility in using these devices would depend upon the
location of traps. He noted that trappers have advised against checking traps more than once
every 24 hours as every check leaves traces of human scent that deters coyotes from moving
toward the traps.
Committee members agreed that the primary concern was for the safety of children and family
pets. The majority of the Committee agreed the use of soft-leg traps was the appropriate next
step, noting Councilmember Church’s opposition.
Committee acknowledged that the Police Chief had the discretion and was authorized, under the
Town Plan, to move toward the use of soft-leg traps. This activity did not require an affirmative
vote from the Public Safety Committee or Town Council.
Chair Clark invited residents to offer comments; no comments made
III. Parking Plan Summer 2016
Chair Clark made introductory comments
The Town continues work toward a policy on an island-wide parking plan to include a
parking and traffic analysis conducted last year at Town Council’s direction.
Meanwhile, neighboring City of Isle of Palms announced it will execute its parking plan
this year, restricting visitor parking to its City.
Submitted it was important for Sullivan’s Island to keep pace with Isle of Palm’s parking
plan activity as the Town’s parking and traffic flow will certainly be impacted by Isle of
Palm’s parking changes.
Administrator Benke provided Staff report:
Background
Noted the Town began studying parking in 2008-2009, initially from a potential revenue
perspective.
o Town evaluations of staff expenses and general obligation fund expenditures
identified a significant percentage of Town monies were used to manage the
Approved at the February 1, 2016 Council Workshop
3
Public Safety Committee: January 28, 2016 Minutes
impact of visitor/tourist-related activity: traffic and parking, beach path repairs,
patrol presence, fire and rescue operations, sanitation/debris removal, etc.
o Conversely, the Town receives very little revenue associated with tourist/visitor
activity (i.e. Accommodations Tax), particularly compared to other beach
communities. The Town has no bed-breakfast or hotels, a very limited pool of
vacation rentals, a small commercial district with a handful of restaurants and
does not maintain paid municipal parking lots or other paid parking spaces.
The more important focus for the Town is providing good public safety services to
residents and the influx of Town visitors who frequent the Island through the
“tourist/high” season:
o Traffic control and law enforcement protection
o Search and rescue operations for water and beach incidents, in addition to medical
calls and fire suppression activity.
o Ability to navigate emergency vehicle through streets and on/off the Island
remains a critical concern for the public safety chiefs.
External pressures on the Town’s public safety and public works department operations
have increased over the decades as the tri-county area population has grown:
o 1972-1973:
It was common to see bumper-bumper cars from the Island down the Ben
Sawyer Causeway to Shem Creek bridge in Mt. Pleasant.
At that time Sullivan’s Island was the only way to access Isle of Palms
Mt. Pleasant’s population was approximately 6,200 people and Sullivan’s
Island had approximately 1,400 residents
o 1990’s:
Isle of Palms Connector opened to provide a direct route to Isle of Palms
beaches from Mt. Pleasant. This relieved some pressure on Sullivan’s
Island beach traffic.
o 2010:
Mt. Pleasant’s population tops 68,000 residents while Sullivan’s Island’s
population has grown to approximately 1,800 people. The only two places
for East Cooper residents to go to the beach continue to be Isle of Palms
and Sullivan’s Island.
Tri-county area continues to experience dramatic population increases as
well, adding to the pressure of weekend visitors to the Island.
Parking Plan Study:
First Step: evaluate the potential supply of Town parking spaces.
o Staff identified a maximum of 4,967 parking spaces:
Approximately 2,280 parking spaces are seaside of Middle Street
Approximately 2,229 parking spaces are marsh-side of Middle Street
458 spaces are on I’On Avenue
[NOTE: Some of those spaces have obstructions and other right-of-way conditions (i.e.
ditches) that would have to be addressed in order to reach this maximum parking number]
Approved at the February 1, 2016 Council Workshop
4
Public Safety Committee: January 28, 2016 Minutes
Second Step: evaluate traffic flow and quantify parking demand
o In 2015 the Town retained Stantec Consulting Services to conduct a
parking/traffic study of the Island. These are the same traffic engineers Isle of
Palms used for its traffic and parking study.
o Stantec’s 2015 study findings:
An average of 1,565 cars are parked on Sullivan’s Island in peak summer
afternoons
Bottle-neck intersections see degradation of service: Middle Street and
Hwy 703, Jasper Boulevard and Hwy 703)
Caveat: it was not possible to differentiate between resident and visitor
cars, and, difficult to evaluate through traffic travelling to Isle of Palms.
o Town staff estimate an average of three (3) people in each car, which brings 4,695
extra people on the Island. This influx increases the Town’s population
temporarily to almost 6,500 during the summer peak period.
Noted that the population increase from 1,800 to 6,500 significantly impacts public safety
The Town’s streets were designed and installed in the late 1940’s to accommodate post-
WWII traffic demands. The roads were not designed for, nor can they adequately
accommodate the impact of contemporary traffic volumes and vehicle configurations.
Parking and Traffic
What the Town cannot control that negatively impacts traffic flow and levels of service:
Traffic accidents occurring on the Island, Ben Sawyer Causeway, Isle of Palms, Isle of
Palms Connector or in Mount Pleasant on Coleman Boulevard;
Frequency of Ben Sawyer Bridge openings and closings.
What the Town can do:
Manage how cars are parked on the Island, to allow for a good flow for public safety
vehicles and resident vehicles;
Manage how many visitor cars can park on the Island
Mitigate the impact that the Isle of Palm’s 2016 parking plan, which reduces visitor
parking spaces, will have on Sullivan’s Island’s parking demands (could potentially
increase parking demands on the Town by approximately another 1,500 visitors)
Parking Plan Map
Administrator Benke and Zoning Administrator Henderson provided an overview of the parking
maps created through the Town’s GIS program.
Staff used the SCDOT parking restrictions as a baseline to build parking spaces on a
potential parking plan map.
Some parking spaces were marked for elimination due to right-of-way conditions that
made parking vehicles problematic.
Opportunities for golf cart parking were identified and mapped. Golf cart only parking
was identified along some of the most popular beach access paths to facilitate public
safety apparatus and personnel access to the beach for rescue/safety operations.
Approved at the February 1, 2016 Council Workshop
5
Public Safety Committee: January 28, 2016 Minutes
Town evaluated spaces with the understanding that all four-wheels of a vehicle would be
off the pavement and on the right-of-way.
Sullivan’s Island Elementary School parking was not included in the parking inventory,
but could be included if desired.
Chief Stith:
Recommended restricting parking (vehicle and golf carts) to one-side of the road, only,
on all roads where visitor parking is allowed. This would provide the opportunity for
cars to pull off the road onto rights-of-way when emergency vehicles have to navigate
streets for an emergency call.
Committee Discussion:
Suggested Middle Street (North) should be opened to parking spaces, to help encourage
disbursement of visitor parking throughout the Island. Currently Middle Street (South)
bears the brunt of visitor parking demands on Middle Street.
Discussed value of removing parking along I’On Street as the ditches and narrow roads
make on-street visitor parking a problem.
Encourage golf-cart parking spaces near the beach accesses.
Endorse municipal ordinance to require four-wheels off the pavement/road for parked
vehicles on public rights-of-way.
Requested analysis of available parking space quantity for the following scenarios:
o Open parking to Middle Street (North);
o Restrict parking to one-side of street island-wide;
o Remove parking option from the staff identified restricted areas where right-of-
way conditions make parking problematic;
o Retain golf cart spaces, running parking numbers for one-side of street only golf
cart parking.
Identify any additional problem areas for parking. One example might be residences
where property owners rely upon on-street parking due to lot configuration and house
access. The Town may have to develop some limited resident-only parking sticker plan
for residents in this situation.
Noted that, while SCDOT has to approve any changes to a Town Parking Plan, the Town
has the flexibility to modify the Plan as needed, based upon assessments made during the
implementation phase.
Committee acknowledged that an island-wide Parking Plan would be an approach that is
fair to the visitors of Sullivan’s Island, flexible enough for Council to evaluate its
efficacy and modify if necessary, and ensure public safety services can be properly and
efficiently provided to residents and visitors during the busy summer season.
Staff clarified the Parking Plan would be in effect for the entire year, not just the summer season.
Next Steps:
Staff indicated they would have the mapping modified and reanalyze parking space quantity
based upon the aforementioned scenarios. This information and proposed ordinance language (to
require four-wheels off the road/pavement) would be ready for the February Council Workshop
meeting next week (Monday, February 1, 2016).
Approved at the February 1, 2016 Council Workshop
6
Public Safety Committee: January 28, 2016 Minutes
It was estimated approximately 2,000 parking spaces might be available given the
aforementioned scenario changes; however, a better estimate would be available at the February
1, 2016 Council Workshop.
Committee discussed advertising a final proposed parking plan to the public to give residents the
opportunity to review it and provide feedback. Staff will work with Stantec to have the
consultant modify the proposed Parking Plan Map. This will give the Town current information
to provide to the public and SCDOT. It was noted SCDOT will have to approve a Town Parking
Plan before Town implementation.
Chair Clark invited residents to offer comments.
Public Comments
Mike Walsh, 2530 I’On Avenue
Noted he re-sent an email to Council that he emailed approximately one year ago [he did
not circulate copies of the email or provide a copy to the recording secretary for
inclusion with these minutes]
o His letter centered on the blatant parking violations, debris and the general
negative impact of visitors during the Polar Bear Plunge 2015.
Enforcement: advocated for strong enforcement of this Parking Plan when implemented.
Submitted enforcement will be the single most significant factor in the success or failure
of this Plan.
Economic Component: questioned why Town Council will not pursue the potential for
revenue from the parking plan (charge for parking at least in some sections). Noted that
in northeastern states, municipalities push visitors to park near the beach in municipal lots
and charge $25/car. Submitted the Town should attempt to mitigate the cost of visitors
on the Island.
Endorses one-side of street only parking: noted he lives at the corner of Station 26 &
I’On Avenue. Currently his yard from corner to corner is full of beach visitor cars on
warm weekends. He and his wife choose to keep their lawn free of fencing and should
not be mandated to install fencing to prevent people from moving cars onto their lawns.
Currently he places garbage cans at the end of his driveway to prevent cars from blocking
ingress/egress.
No other public comments offered
Staff will provide a presentation to Council at its February 1, 2016 Workshop, and,
continue work with Stantec on the proposed Parking Plan Map modifications.
IV. Adjourn
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned (Mayor O’Neil motion;
Councilmember Church seconded; unanimous approval) at approximately 9:45a.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Chauncey Clark, Chair
Public Safety Committee
For review/approval at the February 1, 2016 Council Workshop
Approved at the February 1, 2016 Council Workshop
Source: Town of Sullivan's Island website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.