Minutes (PDF)
Town of Sullivan's Island · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Sullivan's Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
Public Safety Committee: June 11, 2018 Minutes
TOWN OF SULLIVAN’S ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE OF COUNCIL
MEETING MINUTES
Monday, June 11, 2018
A meeting of the Public Safety Committee of Council was held at 8:30 a.m. on Monday, June 11,
2018 at Town Hall, 2056 Middle Street, all requirements of the Freedom of Information Act
having been satisfied. Present were Committee members, Chauncey Clark, Chair, Council
members Mayor Pat O’Neil and Sarah Church; staff included Administrator Benke, Fire Chief
Stith, Police Chief Griffin, Zoning Administrator Henderson and Asst. to Administrator Darrow.
I. Call to Order. Chair Clark called the meeting to order, stated the press and
public were duly notified pursuant to state law and noted that all Committee members were
present. Approximately twenty (20) residents (including Council members Howard, Langley &
Reese, as interested residents) and one media (Lynn Pierotti, Island Eye News) were in
attendance.
II. General Discussion: Parking Matters
A. Restriction of Middle Street Parking Outside of Commercial District and Public
Safety Concerns
• Station 20.5 Street to Station 18 Street
• Station 22.5 Street to Station 26 Street
Committee discussed proposal, as recommendation by Police and Fire Chiefs, to extend one-side
of street parking restriction on Middle Street from Station 20.5 – Station 18 Streets, and, from
Station 22.5 – Station 26 Streets. Parking change is being proposed for safety considerations,
specifically to allow for emergency vehicle apparatus access through Middle Street. This parking
change would reduce Middle Street parking inventory by 82 spaces.
Committee Comments
Chair Clark supports parking change for safety reasons and to allow for maximum emergency
response time.
Mayor O’Neil supports parking change to allow emergency vehicles to quickly respond to
emergency calls, and, navigate through the CCD and major intersection at Station 22.5 and
Middle Street. Parking change would allow for civilian vehicles to pull over for emergency
apparatus.
Council member Church echoed comments by other Committee members, noting that she defers
to recommendations made by the Fire Chief and Police Chief as to what support they need from
Council in order to maximize public safety. She supports increased safety over additional
parking spaces.
2
Public Safety Committee: June 11, 2018 Minutes
Public Comments
Bunky Wichmann (2211 I’On Avenue, SI) supports parking change for safety reasons but asks
for consideration for business district employee parking. Also recommends evaluating and
reducing speed limit island-wide for safety reasons.
Rusty Bennett (3124 Marshall Boulevard, SI) noted the 82 parking spaces that will be
removed with this parking change, primarily in/around the community commercial district
(CCD), will significantly impact the CCD businesses and, accordingly, asked for reconsideration
of this large number of reduced parking spaces. Noted, in his experience and research, he has
not found other municipalities that reduce valuable parking spaces to accommodate the potential
need for a public safety vehicle to navigate a road. He specifically noted that the section of
Middle Street from Stations 22.5 to 26 Streets was beyond the bottleneck area for fire apparatus
coming from Middle Street/Station 20.5 Street fire station trying navigate in/around Station 22.5
and Middle Street, the location where the majority of traffic attempt to turn to get on/off the
Island via Causeway.
Committee asked for Chiefs’ comments at this point:
Chief Griffin – noted that in traffic jams his staff routinely stack vehicles approaching Station
22.5/Middle Street from Isle of Palms direction (Station 26 – Station 22.5). This is done to allow
for vehicles along CCD to turn left to head off Island, the direction that creates the most traffic
congestion in the CCD, particularly when the Ben Sawyer Bridge is open.
Chief Stith – noted King Street in downtown City of Charleston has one-side of street parking
restrictions for the same reason as Sullivan’s Island: to allow for emergency vehicle access along
the road. Submitted that, in his opinion, vehicle congestion is equally problematic on either side
of Station 22.5/Middle Street when cars are blocking emergency apparatus. Submitted vehicles
need a place to pull over to allow emergency vehicles to quickly respond to, or transport off the
Island, injured residents and visitors, or, to respond to a fire call.
Public Comments (continued)
Pat Ilderton (2507 Atlantic Avenue, SI) noted three considerations:
• Current narrow driving experience for vehicles along Middle Street, due to vehicles
pulling in/out to park, makes drivers more inclined to drive slower along the road,
regardless of the posted speed limit. Creating a wide-open road, with improved
driver visibility, might encourage drivers to travel at the maximum speed limit, or
more. Suggested speed limit be reduced to 15mph in CCD.
• Questioned how many instances occurred over the past two years where life or
property has been compromised due to emergency vehicle access during bottleneck
traffic problems
• Recommended Town retain a traffic engineer consultant to get professional input on
the parking change proposal and increased safety
3
Public Safety Committee: June 11, 2018 Minutes
Chair Clark commented that the Town works closely, and has consulted, with SCDOT on its
managed parking plan, and, SCDOT has given approval for necessary safety-related parking
changes like the one proposed. He recalled that the Town has discussed for years the parking
situation in the CCD, noting the Town retained a consultant firm circa 2008/2009 who held
public charettes on CCD parking and traffic congestion.
Brian Hellman (2714 Atlantic Avenue, SI) remarked on the unintended consequences of
removing paved parking along Middle Street. He noted that residential streets that were not host
to beach parking in past years currently have beach visitor cars parked along the grassy rights-of-
way. He noted that reducing parking along Middle Street pushes the burden of beach parking
onto the residents, exacerbating congestion along the side streets, increasing difficulty for
resident guests to find street parking, tearing up grass in unpaved rights-of-way, etc. Submitted
Council’s decisions should focus on what is best for residents and taxpayers, not Island tourists.
He suggested establishing residential only parking areas like those on Isle of Palms.
Chair Clark noted that it would be difficult to copy Isle of Palm’s policy of residential only
parking districts as Sullivan’s Island is geographically narrower than Isle of Palms. He
commented that, since Mt. Pleasant is booming in population growth, all residents should expect
every street on Sullivan’s Island to fill up with beach traffic, whether the resident streets have
seen parking in the past or not. Unfortunately, every street and Island resident will continue to
share the pain of neighboring population growth and continually increasing beach traffic.
B. Commercial District Parking and Traffic Flow
Chair Clark presented a parking lot concept utilizing five (5) privately owned lots on Middle
Street to provide off-street parking for CCD businesses and patrons, specific lots being:
1. Jasper Boulevard facing rear of split zoned lot (residential portion) properties on Middle
Street addressed as 2214 A & B Middle Street, 2216 A& B Middle Street and 2210
Middle Street (behind Poe’s Tavern) (TMS # 529-05-00-031; 529-05-00-094; 529-05-00-
095; 529-05-00-090; 529-05-00-091; 529-05-00-032; and 529-05-00-033)
2. Portion facing Middle Street of split zoned lot property on 2202 Middle Street (TMS#
529-05-00-034)
3. Middle Street facing portion of split zoned lot (commercial portion) property at 2118
I’On Avenue/Middle Street (TMS# 529-09-00-022), at corner of Station 22 Street and
Middle Street
Also, potentially
4. Middle Street facing portion of split zoned lot (commercial portion) property at 2102
I’On Avenue/Middle Street (TMS# 529-09-00-019), at corner of Station 21 Street and
Middle Street
4
Public Safety Committee: June 11, 2018 Minutes
Illustrated below:
(Visual discussed during meeting)
Chair Clark and Staff noted between 40-50 parking spaces could be provided behind Poe’s
Tavern and adjacent properties (hashed space in illustration above), and, approximately 20-25
parking spaces on 2118 Middle Street lot.
Considerations would include (not exhaustive list):
• Perpetuity of parking access on private lots
• Participating businesses allowed to use parking lots
• Fencing, buffers and landscaping
• Noise considerations for neighboring residents
• Connectivity between different TMS lots
• Lighting
• Potential text amendment changes to Zoning Ordinance:
o §21-50C. (4): Short-term auto parking lot – currently allowed on the
commercial portion only of CCOD split zoned lots
o Section 21, Article III: RS District Special Exception for residentially zoned
portions of CCOD-1 Overlay
o Section 21, Article I: CCOD 1 Overlay Standards
o Section 21, Article XV: Parking Requirements on lots in CCOD-1 (Accessory
Structures)
Public Comments
Rusty Bennett (3124 Marshall Boulevard, SI) expressed support for off-street parking lot
concept noting this was “an idea whose time has come” and recalled previous traffic and parking
consultants suggesting the use of the split zoned lots as parking lots.
5
Public Safety Committee: June 11, 2018 Minutes
He offered two additional suggestions:
(1) Create 2-hour parking on Middle Street in front of the tennis and basketball court areas at J.
Marshall Stith Park; and
(2) Enhance lighting on Middle Street in front of Stith Park, or within Stith Park, for restaurant
employees who park behind Town Hall in order for restaurant patrons to use vacant parking
spaces near CCD businesses
Tim Reese (305 Station 20, SI) suggested utilizing Town owned Battery Thompson, located on
I’On Avenue behind US Post Office and in front of Sullivan’s Island Elementary School
complex, for permit issued restaurant employee parking.
Bunky Wichmann (2211 I’On Avenue, SI) recommended Town promote summertime parking
on Sullivan’s Island Elementary School parking, a Town owned parking lot
Heidi Brown (405 Station 22, SI) did not support proposed off-street privately-owned parking
lot concept stating following objections:
1. Residential portion of split-zoned lots have not been offered for sale on the open market,
to her knowledge, so Town cannot determine if people would want to build on residential
section of CCOD-1 split zoned lots or not;
2. Safety considerations for vehicles entering/exiting these parking lots to the rear of
businesses such as Poe’s Tavern;
3. Town would, by allowing commercial parking activity on residentially zoned lots, shake
resident confidence in the veracity of Town Council decisions and ordinances. This issue
was extensively discussed years ago. The CCOD overlay districts within the Zoning
Ordinance were a result of that study-decision making process that incorporated resident
feedback/input;
4. The parking lots proposed would not be installed to benefit residents but, rather, tourists,
patrons and some business owners.
Pat Votava (2213 Jasper Boulevard, SI) echoed Ms. Brown’s comments noting
1. CCOD #1 & CCOD#2 study, deliberation and public feedback process resulted in the
establishment of the overlay districts that included the specific goal of providing for
residential construction on the properties along Jasper Boulevard.
2. Changing the use of these residential portions of the split zoned lots through special
exceptions breaks faith with residents on Jasper Boulevard, and, other residents on the
Island. If this change is allowed, is any residential lot safe if the Town feels like there is
a special need? Asked which residents wanted a parking lot in front of their homes.
3. Submitted neighbors on Jasper Boulevard, across from CCOD#1 overlay, deserve the
same quality of life, standards and protections as other residents on the Island.
Thereafter Ms. Votava read an email dated June 10, 2018 from Cynthia Kolb (2208 Jasper
Boulevard, SI) and Andy Kay (2202 Jasper Boulevard, SI), both who could not be present
today (Exhibit A)
Susan Middaugh (2420 Raven Drive, SI) also echoed comments made by Ms. Votava and Ms.
Brown, noting
6
Public Safety Committee: June 11, 2018 Minutes
1. The long process to establish the CCOD overlay districts was the best available
compromise solution to the issue.
2. Submitted the residential character for Jasper Boulevard would be compromised with
proposed change, specifically noting that noise barrier protections would be lost with a
parking lot installed across from the Jasper Boulevard residences
3. Suggested the Town look to commercially zoned lots in the CCOD for parking lots
solutions, and, noted the Poe Library/Battery Gadsden complex (1921 I’On Avenue) does
afford some parking options for restaurant workers.
Bunky Wichmann (2211 I’On Avenue, SI) reiterated that Town needs to evaluate speed across
the Island and take measures to proactively lower speed limits.
Committee Comments
Chair Clark noted SCDOT owns the roads and drainage on Sullivan’s Island so the Town would
have to work through a study and request process to change speed limits on the Island. He noted
that Town staff do communicate with SCDOT peers on traffic and other issues.
Councilmember Church supports lower speed limits Island-wide, noting that this topic is on the
Town’s radar for potential funding of a traffic study as funds allow
Mayor O’Neil suggested Town staff reach out to CCOD business owners to see if there is an
appetite to potentially engage in a privately-owned parking lot arrangement.
Councilmember Church noted there is a need to have good parking options for businesses along
Middle Street, although not necessary along Middle Street. She expressed reservations in
converting privately owned CCOD split zoned residential lots for commercial use, noting
• There is an issue of fairness to residents who purchased, built or improved on their
homes along Jasper Boulevard with the expectation that the Town would keep the lots
across the street for residential use only;
• Questioned the unintended consequences of expanding commercial use within the
CCOD, specifically noting the split zoned lots along Jasper Boulevard, currently
being used for residential use. What if those property owners wanted to change their
property use and get a special exception for a parking lot or other commercial
activity?
Mayor O’Neil expressed support for the idea of 2-hour parking on Middle Street in front of the
tennis/basketball courts and J. Marshall Stith Park.
Member of public questioned how 2-hour parking would work. Administrator Benke answered
the Town could use a paid parking kiosk system with parking slips issued for up to 2-hour
increments.
Chair Clark suggested next steps would be to speak with residents in the Jasper Boulevard area
and speak with business owners in the CCOD area, plus the Graham family that owns 2118 and
2102 I’On Avenue/Middle Street properties.
7
Public Safety Committee: June 11, 2018 Minutes
Committee actions/recommendations:
As to amending parking plan (Agenda item 2(a))
MOTION: Mayor O’Neil recommended to Council to proceed with changes to
parking plan to create one-side only parking on Middle Street from Station 20.5 to
Station 18 Streets, and, Station 22.5 to Station 26 Streets; seconded by
Councilmember Church. MOTION UNANIMOUSLY PASSED.
As to privately-owned parking lot proposal, 2-hour parking only sections along Middle
Street and J. Marshall Stith Park/Middle Street lighting (discussed with Agenda item 2(b))
1. Committee will render report to Town Council regarding the privately-owned
parking lot proposal, deliberation and public feedback on same from this meeting.
This will allow the body of Council to express whether they wished for the Town to
further explore this option
2. Committee will render report to Town Council for discussion of potential 2-hour
parking along Middle Street in front of tennis/basketball courts within J. Marshall
Stith Park complex for Council feedback on further pursuing this possibility
3. Committee will render report to Town Council for discussion of potential enhanced
lighting along Middle Street and/or within J. Marshall Stith Park for safety
considerations for Council feedback on further pursuing this possibility
Committee moved to next agenda item
C. General Parking Flow and Enforcement
Chief Griffin offered a report on summertime traffic flow strategies and parking enforcement:
• Utilize cones within street near Station 22.5 and Middle Street intersection for right
turn onto Middle Street only on weekends. Process works well.
• In response to Mayor O’Neil’s suggestion for prominent stop signage, Chief Griffin
noted Staff could include a temporary eye-level “Stop Sign” in the road area/near
cones if desired or needed
• Department has increased parking patrols and doubled beach Kubota patrols as traffic
calming, enhanced parking enforcement and safety measures
Mayor O’Neil strongly recommended residents avail themselves of the official Town
communication platforms to learn of Town meetings, news and events instead of unofficial
social media sites, official Town sites being:
• Town website
• Town e-newsletter
• Nixle platform
• Twitter and Facebook accounts
• Administrator’s mass email address “book”
8
Public Safety Committee: June 11, 2018 Minutes
III. Adjourn
There being no further written or public comment, and there being no further business, the
meeting was adjourned (Mayor O’Neil motion; Councilmember Church seconded; unanimous
approval) at approximately 10:00a.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Chauncey Clark, Chair
Public Safety Committee
Approved at the June 19, 2018 Regular Council Meeting
1
Lisa Darrow
From: Votava, Patricia Ann <votava@musc.edu>
Sent: Tuesday, June 12, 2018 5:08 PM
To: Andy Benke; Lisa Darrow
Cc: Votava, Patricia Ann
Subject: RE: Town of Sullivan's Island Public Safety Committee Meeting June 11,2018
Attachments: SI Andy Kay letter re using residential lots for parking.docx
This message was sent securely by MUSC
HI Andy and Lisa,
Here is the copy of my neighbor Andy Kay’s letter that I mentioned at yesterday’s meeting and was asked to submit.
Please enter it in the record of the 6/11/18 Committee Meeting and distribute to Council.
Thanks so much
Pat Votava
From: Votava, Patricia Ann
Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 4:45 PM
To: 'Andy Benke'; 'ldarrow@sullivansisland-sc.com'
Cc: Votava, Patricia Ann
Subject: FW: Town of Sullivan's Island Public Safety Committee Meeting June 11,2018
Hi Andy and Lisa,
Here is the copy of my neighbor Cynthia Kolb’s letter that I read at the meeting this morning.
Please enter it in the record and distribute it to Council.
Thanks so much
Pat Votava
From: Cynthia Kolb [mailto:kolb.cynthia.md@gmail.com]
Sent: Sunday, June 10, 2018 12:45 PM
To: Votava, Patricia Ann
Subject: Town of Sullivan's Island Public Safety Committee Meeting June 11,2018
Dear members of the public safety committee and other interested parties,
I am writing to you as a resident of 2208 Jasper Boulevard to oppose the use of residential lots on this street for
business district parking. The look and feel of our neighborhood would suffer tremendously both from the
aesthetic and noise level points of view. I have already noticed, as the summer season heats up, that parking is
increased on our street, including where no parking signs already exist. Establishing parking lots would increase
traffic to the street and encourage street parking. Removing the barrier that these residential lots provide would
also increase noise and foot traffic. More car and foot traffic would create more litter further damaging the
appeal and decreasing property values.
In an effort to continue to honor the charming nature of our small island, I would respectifully request a solution
that continues to provide that barrier and keep the appeal of our residential street. I have visited Sullivan's Island
since childhood for its beautiful beaches surrounded by quaint residential streets. I studied on these beaches for
June 11, 2018 Public Safety Committee
Exhibit A
2
medical school exams. I always dreamed of returing to the island and I was finally able to buy a small slice of
this heaven for myself and family in 2009.
As described so eloquently by Dorothea Benton Frankin in her novels, Sullivans Island is enchanting with its
unique pluff mud beaches, Palmetto trees and colorful local lore. My neighbors and myself would like to
continue to walk around the neighborhood or sit on our porches and enjoy the views.
Thank you for hearing my input. I apologize that I was not able to come in person to provide my opinion, but
work keeps me away. Please let me know if I can be of further assistance.
Best regards,
Cynthia Kolb
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
This message was secured via TLS by MUSC.
June 11, 2018 Public Safety Committee
Exhibit A
Two Areas of Consideration
Public Safety
Zoning & Quality of Life
Assumptions
Request is for additional parking in the residential zoned areas assumed to include access from Jasper Blvd
S u mma r y
Residents desire to maintain the residential character per the original rezoning discussions; anything detrimental to
that is suspect. The original rezoning discussion emphasized maintaining a residential character for the area; using
residentially zoned property along Jasper for commercial purposes runs counter to that original discussion and
agreement
The majority of traffic on the 2200 block of Jasper arrives or leaves via Myrtle Ave and Station 22 and thus impacts
more than 2200 block of Jasper
A significant amount of the current traffic thru the neighborhood travels at excessive speeds and without stopping at
intersections in order to beat congestion at Station 22 1/2 and Middle or because they are late for work or because
they are in a hurry to get off the island. This is in conflict with the residential use of the area and should be
diminished rather than increased.
The neighborhood sees substantial low speed traffic: kids, bikes, joggers, golf carts, etc. All travel the area to avoid
the congestion on 22 1/2 and/or Middle. They come from the causeway or from the other side of 22 1/2. They are
headed towards the playground, beach, library, school, post office, etc. They are children, seniors, residents and
visitors. This low speed route of travel needs to be enhanced not diminished; no other good routes exist for this low
speed traffic. A wider sidewalk along the playground would be a plus in this regard.
About a dozen kids live on and play in these streets. Its terrifying to see them on skateboards, scooters, bikes, etc.
during weekend or weekday peak traffic periods.
While the number of major accidents in the neighborhood has been minimal; the number near misses is
phenomenal. I myself was recently rear ended while stopped, waiting for traffic to pass, so I could pull into my
drive. The other driver was coming onto the island and trying to beat the congestion at 22 /12 & Middle
This concession has not been given full and complete thought and may not stand following further consideration and discussion.
ANDY KAY
2202 JASPER
June 11, 2018 Public Safety Committee
Exhibit A
Source: Town of Sullivan's Island website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.