Minutes (PDF)
Town of Sullivan's Island · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Sullivan's Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
Public Safety Committee: August 15, 2018 Minutes
TOWN OF SULLIVAN’S ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE OF COUNCIL
MEETING MINUTES
Wednesday, August 15, 2018
The Public Safety Committee of Council met at 8:30 a.m., this date, at Town Hall, 2056 Middle
Street, all requirements of the Freedom of Information Act having been satisfied. Present were
Committee members, Chauncey Clark, Chair, Council members Mayor Pat O’Neil and Sarah
Church; staff included Administrator Benke, Fire Chief Stith, Police Chief Griffin, Deputy
Administrator/Comptroller Blanton and Asst. to Administrator Darrow.
I. Call to Order. Chair Clark called the meeting to order, stated the press and
public were duly notified pursuant to state law and noted that all Committee members were
present. Approximately eight (8) members in audience: two (2) residents and six (6) additional
staff members (5-member fire engine committee); no media.
II. General Discussion by Committee and Staff: 2019 Pumper Truck
Staff Overview (Fire Chief Stith):
Currently Town has two pumper trucks:
• Engine 1 (2001) – pumps 1250 gallons water/minute (Town’s primary pumper)
• Engine 2 (1996) – pumps 1000 gallons water/minute
Standard operating procedure is to run Engine 1 on all calls (fire or life/safety) as department
could receive a second call while responding to the first call. Chief Stith noted back-back calls
have become a trend this year.
ISO ratings allow credit for the aged 1996 Engine 1, but the vehicle does not meet NFPA codes
(NFPA is the industry standard). Should the Town authorize purchase of a 2019 pumper truck,
Engine 2 would remain with the fleet for general work, since the engine has no trade-in value.
Life expectancy of engines (per NFPA/ISO): 10-15 years active; then reserve until 20-25 years.
NFPA calls for retirement of engine after 20 years. Current Engine 2 is already a reserve vehicle
and has been in service beyond the prescribed replacement timeline.
Public Comments:
Wayne Guckenberger (2105 Pettigrew, SI) expressed support for purchasing another pumper
engine, noting he has previous insurance experience and appreciates the benefit of having
equipment that is operational for first responder staff in a catastrophe. Commented all residents
enjoy the Class I ISO Fire Station rating (highest available) in better homeowner’s and business
insurance premiums and overall safety. Submitted there is high value in supporting this request.
Chief Stith introduced Virgil Slagle of Safe Industries (distributor of E-One products) who
provided a presentation of the proposed 2019 E-One Engine. Proposal (Exhibit A)
highlights include:
Current concerns: obtaining parts for 1996 Engine 2 which is overdue for replacement and
consideration that, in a few years, Town will need to replace 2001 Engine 1.
2
Public Safety Committee: August 15, 2018 Minutes
Chief Stith and the Fire Engine Committee have planned the last 3-4 years for a replacement
engine, identifying department’s current and future needs, and volunteer training/engine use.
Recommendation is to utilize the same chassis as 2001 Engine 1 to provide similar cab
configuration for regular/volunteer staff.
Some of the 2019 Engine improvements/changes:
• Pumps 1500 gallons water/minute Hale pump
• Axis System – integrated communication system between E-One and end user. Similar to
On-Star technology, vehicle warning lights/alarms and software update notices will
upload to E-One through Verizon Wireless from vehicle to allow for faster
communication between parties and allow for quicker preventive/other maintenance. E-
One is the only manufacturer in the industry offering this technology. Axis System is
provided to the Town for free for the first five years.
• Re-designed electronic and venting system placement, in response to customer feedback,
to reduce/prevent engine shut-down when operating in higher water levels.
o Electrical panel – current engines have electrical under the engine/just above
frame. This causes engine to cut-off when vehicle is standing in approximately
24” water (driving/splashing water not included). 2019 E-One redesigned to
place electrical in cab behind firewall of console to avoid this issue.
o Cooling vents – current engines have vents placed low, near bottom of door
frames, causing water intake into the oil, transmission, etc. 2019 E-One
redesigned to place vents closer to top of door frames along the body to
reduce/eliminate this problem (driving/splashing water still a concern).
In response to Committee question, Mr. Slagle clarified that current vehicles see water related
problems when water rises to the bumper. New 2019 E-One should accommodate vehicle
working in standing water up to 36”. He noted that splashing water, caused by driving through
large standing water, could still cause water infiltration issues.
Other features include:
• Enhanced lighting to NFPA standards and beyond, customized to Town’s special needs;
• Vehicle dimensions modified to fit new technology and maximize tool storage.
• Relocation of ladders from vehicle side to rear, to allow for easier off-load/on-load and
increased space for tool storage.
• Ergonomic changes to create a safer climbing experience on/off truck, particularly in the
hose area.
• Hard cover material on the roof for hose bed, with motor to open/close cover, allowing
for firefighter to safely walk along the roof line to store hoses post-event.
• Future planning for potentially larger hoses, tools and technology needs
Warranty features (included in price):
Separate 5-year warranties on transmission and pumps, lifetime warranty on the booster tank.
Other items have a 2-year bumper/bumper warranty with annual pump testing for 2 years. Safe
Industries and E-One, with a manufacturing plant in Sumter, SC, work with Town to minimize
vehicle being off-Island for repair/warranty work.
3
Public Safety Committee: August 15, 2018 Minutes
Committee Comments
Chair Clark noted cab configuration and enhanced tool compartments should increase efficiency
for volunteer training/use of vehicle. Additionally, he noted the volunteer fire/rescue squad fund
a majority of the department’s equipment already, namely jet-skis, boats, etc.
Chief Stith noted the new engine’s color-coded water level indicator for the pumper would allow
for firefighter to work the scene, if needed, instead of standing by the indicator to monitor the
pumper’s water levels, as required on current pump engines.
Councilmember Church asked fire engine committee for their thoughts on the proposed new
engine.
Firefighter Stephen Poole stated the 2019 E-One engine would provide for current and future
safety needs, noting the similar cab configuration will provide for faster staff/volunteer training
and operational efficiency.
Chief Stith noted the new engine would be equipped with an EMT compartment for life/safety
calls, reiterating that the primary pumper truck responds to all calls.
Committee then discussed financial considerations (Proposal Exhibit A)
Chair Clark noted the Town had set aside funds years ago for the replacement of Engine 2.
Comptroller Blanton reviewed the financing versus cash payment option, noting quotes on debt
interest at 3.3% would add costs of between $55,000 - $76,000 - $113,00 to the price of the
vehicle (5-7-10 year financing schedule respectively).
Mayor O’Neil noted that the Town had residual funds from the sale of Town lots, some of which
had been set aside for this capital improvement. Comptroller Blanton clarified Town had $2.6-
$2.7 million in reserve from the sale of lots.
Comptroller Blanton clarified, for Councilmember Church, that the Town has an additional
contingency reserve of a little over $1.0 million and did not see a cash-payment for the engine
materially reducing the Town’s credit standing.
Committee noted E-One offers a discount for advance cash payment (approximately $15,000), a
reduced discount for cash-payment with performance bond, and no discount for COD/financed
payments. There is an approximately $2,000 difference between cash payment with performance
bond and no performance bond.
Comptroller Blanton recommended the Town pay for the new engine as a one-time cash payment
as the money is currently in-hand and interest on it is well under the 3.3% finance charge, should
the engine be financed.
Administrator Benke clarified for Committee that remaining $2.6 million long-term capital
project reserve will include minor items for Town Hall (i.e. audio/visual system) with balance
held aside for other long-range capital projects.
4
Public Safety Committee: August 15, 2018 Minutes
MOTION: Chair Clark recommended Town Council purchase the 2019 E-One
Pumper Truck Engine as specified in Exhibit A, financed as a lump payment, with
performance bond as an option; seconded by Mayor O’Neil. MOTION
UNANIMOUSLY PASSED.
III. Old Business: Update Middle Street Parking Plan Amendments
Staff Update (Administrator Benke)
• Middle Street commercial area parking restrictions, approved by Council in June, have
been implemented and signage installed. Parking is restricted to one-side of street only
from Station 22 ½ - Station 26 (east) and Station 20 ½ - Station 18 (west).
• He has not fielded any complaints from businesses; working with one resident in the
Station 25 area on concern about losing street parking in front of his residence.
Chief Stith stated he has received compliments from residents about the ease in maneuvering
through the streets and overall increased safety. As to the fire department, the change has been a
significant improvement when responding to emergency calls.
Administrator Benke offered additional update on current SCDOT road/infrastructure work
currently underway on the Island. Bulk of work will occur at Station 26 ½ and Atlantic Avenue
to Station 28-29 and Jasper Boulevard areas. He noted the one (1) SCDOT jet vac for the entire
state is here on the Island.
Committee asked if SCDOT has received additional funding as its maintenance presence has
increased on the Island in past couple of years. Administrator Benke noted that SCDOT’s
schedule calls for maintenance work on Sullivan’s Island once every six years. Last year
SCDOT was on the Island performing work due to FEMA monies from a storm event. He noted
that SCDOT is working hard to utilize funds/resources it has available but, to his knowledge, the
General Assembly has not increased the agency’s (maintenance) funding.
Administrator Benke noted that, pursuant to the 2014 ice storm, the Town received a $1.5
million FEMA grant award for pump/pipe replacement at Stations 18-19 and Stations 29-30/
I’On.
IV. Adjourn
There being no further written or public comment, and there being no further business, the
meeting was adjourned (Mayor O’Neil motion; Councilmember Church seconded; unanimous
approval) at approximately 10:00a.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Chauncey Clark, Chair
Public Safety Committee
Approved at the August 21, 2018 Regular Council Meeting
Exhibit A
August 15, 2018 Public Safety Committee
Source: Town of Sullivan's Island website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.