11-21-2023 A-TAX COMMITTEE AGENDA AND PACKET
Town of Pawleys Island · Georgetown County · meeting of Nov 21, 2023 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from Town of Pawleys Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Pawleys Island
A-tax Advisory Committee Meeting
Tuesday, Nov. 21, 2023, 9:30 a.m.
PI Town Hall (or by Zoom, if needed)
Board Member Attendees:
Robert Levine (Chair) ____ Betsy Altman ____ Will Dieter ____ Sassy Henry ____
Mary Nash _____ Corinne Taylor ____ Eddie Wilder _____
Town of Pawleys Island Attendees:
Mayor Brian Henry ____ Daniel Newquist ____ Daniel O’Hara _____
Georgetown County Chamber of Commerce Attendees:
Beth Stedman _____ Mark Stevens _____ Clayton Stairs ______
Media/Public in
attendance:_____________________________________________________
AGENDA
I.Call to order
II.Statement of compliance with FOIA
III. Motion to approve agenda and minutes — ACTION
IV. Tourism Reports
a) Social Media Report (Pineapple PR)
b) Digital Report (Madden Media)
V.Funding Requests – Daniel O’Hara – ACTION, if needed
VI. Approve 2024 Marketing Budget — ACTION
VII. Financial Report – Beth Stedman
VIII. Old Business
IX. New Business
X. Adjournment
MINUTES
MINUTES
Town of Pawleys Island
Accommoda7ons Tax Advisory Commi=ee
September 19, 2023, at 9:30 a.m.
Pawleys Island Town Hall
In a=endance:
Pawleys Island A-tax Advisory Commi=ee members: Robert Levine (chair), Betsy Altman, Mary Nash,
Will Dieter, and Corrine Taylor (online)
Chamber staff: Director of Tourism Development Mark Stevens, Tourism Manager Clayton Stairs,
OperaFons & Member Engagement Manager Joanna Lombardozzi
Media: Charles Swenson (Coastal Observer)
Town of Pawleys Island a=endees: Town Administrator Daniel Newquist and Town Clerk Daniel O’Hara.
Presenters: Julianna Nadel and Savannah Coneys with Pineapple Public RelaFons, and Nicole McElroy
with Madden Media
The meeFng was called to order by Robert Levine at 9:30 a.m. A quorum was present. Levine made the
statement of FOIA compliance.
Will Dieter made a moFon to approve the agenda for this meeFng and the minutes from the last
meeFng in September 2023, with a change to reflect that Mayor Brian Henry and Mary Nash were not in
aYendance. Betsy Altman seconded the moFon. All in favor. MoFon passed.
Mark Stevens led the overview of tourism reports. Julianna Nadel and Savannah Coneys with Pineapple
Public RelaFons presented the Social Media Report. Coneys said from January to September 2023, the
Only Pawleys Facebook page was looking strong, with almost 40,000 fans. She said Instagram was also
improving, with a 26-percent increase in fans. She said the top posts on Facebook surpassed the goal by
2,000 clicks, which was much beYer than the industry average, and the Instagram page is on track to
reach its goal by December. Social media ad results showed a strong following, she said.
Nadel gave a report about the email markeFng overview. She said that the Only Pawleys newsleYer’s
design has been updated and they switched to a new company called Robly for design layout and
distribuFon. She said they switched to Robly because it is user-friendly and has more accurate analyFcs.
She said the open rates and the click through rates have gone up since the change and they are
projecFng that they will reach their followers goal for both Facebook and Instagram. Stevens said he has
really been impressed by the human-interest stories wriYen for the newsleYer and OnlyPawleys website
by Clayton Stairs.
Nicole McElroy with Madden Media presented the Digital MarkeFng Report. She said that there have
been 125,000 users year-to-date, and paid traffic has driven people to the website. For the campaign
overview, she said Google has been driving traffic to the website. The top key words people searched for
to find Only Pawleys were Pawleys Island, golf, and vacaFon rentals. She said Google display prospecFng
showed 3 million impressions, which exceeded the campaign goal by 1 million.
Stevens discussed a new Hammock Coast app that he has been working on, which will have three
walking tours – Pawleys Island Historic Homes, Georgetown Historic Homes, and African American
Heritage in Georgetown. Lee Brockington and Ron Daise provided voice-overs for the apps, he said, and
it will be operaFonal by the end of the year.
Stevens said City View, a well-known magazine in Knoxville, Tennessee, recently published a story about
Pawleys Island, which was totally earned media since it was not a paid piece and there were not even
any paid Only Pawleys ads in the publicaFon. He said Mayor Brian Henry donated a two-night stay at
Seaview Inn and the author also aYended a dedicaFon ceremony for the Weavers Shed at the Original
Hammock Shop in Pawleys and dined at Bistro 217.
Joanna Lombardozzi presented the financial report since Beth Stedman could not aYend the meeFng.
She said that markeFng had s a surplus to spend due to more-than-expected funds.
Daniel Newquist said that the monthly AccommodaFons Tax showed more than last year through July.
The total local Atax funds were around $825,000. Ajer a discussion, Will Dieter made a moFon to apply
$10,000 of the excess funds to Search Engine MarkeFng. The remaining would simply be moved over to
the next year. Altman seconded the moFon. All in Favor. MoFon passed unanimously.
Levine stated that the next meeFng will be on Nov. 21, 2023. The meeFng was adjourned at 10:39 a.m.
DIGITAL•WEBSITE
PAWLEYS ISLANDOctober 2023
Hammock Coast, SC / Monthly Board Report
Let’s take a peek at the performance. (numbers excite us!)
OCTOBER
PERFORMANCE
PAID
10,102
Users
12,015
Sessions
4,026
Engaged
Sessions
33.51%
Engagement
Rate
TOTAL
Sessions
TOTAL
Users
ORGANIC
1,006
Users
1,125
Sessions
768
Engaged
Sessions
66.27%
Engagement
Rate
Top Organic Pages
Homepage
History
Stay
Austin’s Cafe (listing)
Getting Here
Top Cities
Atlanta
Raleigh
Charlotte
New York
Columbus
FYTD
PERFORMANCE
TOTAL
Clicks
TOTAL
Impressions
Google SEM
Madden | Media Performance
Campaign launched on 1/1
OVERALL PERFORMANCE23,268 ClicksEXCEEDED CAMPAIGN GOAL FOR 14,813 CLICKS
1,931 Clicks
10.12% CTR
Top Ad Groups: Dine
Top Keywords:1. Pawleys Island
2. Things to do in Pawleys Island
3. Pawleys island rentals
4. Heritage golf club
5. Caledonia golf & fish club
6. Pawleys island golf courses
7. What to do in pawleys island
8. Seafood restaurants in pawleys island
9. Pawleys island realty
10. Pawleys island things to do
September and October Dine has remained the top ad group.
-Dine 608 clicks, 9.43% CTR
-Things to Do: 355 clicks, 16.44% CTR
-Rentals: 273 clicks, 12%
-Golf: 254 clicks, 9.30% CTR
-Events: 187 clicks, 11.21% CTR
-Visit: 186 clicks, 6.35%
BENCHMARK: 4.68%
116% ABOVE THE BENCHMARK
(OCTOBER)
Google RLSA
Madden | Media Performance
Campaign launched on 10/11
OVERALL PERFORMANCE1,364 Clicks
1,364 Clicks
5.95% CTR
Top Ad Groups: Explore
Top Keywords:1. South carolina cities and towns
2. Pawleys island
3. Pawleys island rentals
4. Pawleys island golf courses
5. South carolina destinations
6. Top things to do south carolina
7. Best golf courses in south
carolina
8. South carolina beaches
9. Homes for rent sc
10. Best beaches in sc
-90% of clicks take place on mobile devices
-Top In Market Audience Segments: Trips to the US, Trips to North
America, In Market Dog Food and Supplies
-Top DMAs: Charleston, Florence/Myrtle Beach, Columbia,
Greenville
BENCHMARK: 4.68%
27% ABOVE THE BENCHMARK
(OCTOBER)
Google Display - Prospecting Campaign launched on 1/9
OVERALL PERFORMANCE3.9M ImpressionsEXCEEDED GOAL OF 2.0M IMPRESSIONS
3,733 Clicks
0.81% CTR
462,031
Impressions Top Audiences:1. Hotels & Accommodations
2. Luxury Resorts
3. Travel
4. Trips to Myrtle Beach
5. Beachfront Hotels (highest
CTR)
Flight 2 will run August - November
Top Headline: Pawleys Island Beach Vacation
87% of impressions were delivered from the responsive ad.
Top States: Ohio, North Carolina, Georgia, Virginia, Pennsylvania
BENCHMARK: 0.30%
170% ABOVE THE BENCHMARK
Madden | Media Performance
(OCTOBER)
Google Display - Remarketing Campaign launched on 1/9
OVERALL PERFORMANCE3.0M ImpressionsEXCEEDED GOAL OF 1.2M IMPRESSIONS
2,446 Clicks
0.94% CTR
259,342
Impressions
There was a 59% increase in CTR this period. Recommend
pausing the family beaches creative and full optimizing budget
towards to family outdoors creative since that is performing
more efficiently with a higher CTR and lower CPC.
Top Geos: Chicago, Dallas (highest CTR), New York, Atlanta, Los
Angeles, Washington DC, Knoxville, Seattle, Phoenix, Nashville
BENCHMARK: 0.30%
213% ABOVE THE BENCHMARK
Madden | Media Performance
(OCTOBER)
Meta - Prospecting Campaign launched on 1/9
OVERALL PERFORMANCE33,555 ClicksEXCEEDED GOAL OF 12,243 CLICKS
4,132 Link Clicks
3.59% Link CTR
223
Ad Engagements
115,097 Impressions
Top Geos:1. Greenville
2. Charlotte
3. Atlanta (increase from Sept)
4. Greensboro
5. Raleigh Durham
6. Knoxville
7. Columbia
8. Tri Cities TN-VA (highest CTR)
9. Nashville
10. Philadelphia
The book on porch creative continues to drive
performance delivering 3,918 clicks.
Paused the kids waving and swing creative due to low
performance.
BENCHMARK: 0.90%
298% ABOVE THE BENCHMARK
Madden | Media Performance
3.81% CTR
(OCTOBER)
1.87% CTR
Hammock Coast, SC / Monthly Board Report
THANK YOU
SOCIAL MEDIA
Social Media and Email
Marketing Report
Only Pawleys
October 2023
Social Media Marketing
Social Media Overview
Organic Social
●Continued to gather content, scheduled posts
across platforms and monitored Pawleys Island’s
social pages
Only Pawleys
Social & Email
Report PINEAPPLE PUBLIC RELATIONS
Y oY Organic Social Media
PINEAPPLE PUBLIC RELATIONS
Facebook
● Total Likes: 40.186 vs. 7,714 +9%
● Amplification Rate: 0.9% v. 1% -11%
● Applause Rate: 20% v. 25% -20%
● Engagement Rate: 5.4% v. 5.7% -5%
● Total Engagements: 16,115 v. 24,894 -35%
● Total Impressions: 296,478 v. 434,600 -31%
● Total Clicks: 4.221 v. 4,780 -11%
Instagram
** Instagram disconnected from Facebook and cannot pull last year’s numbers, will
update once it is reconnected.
We saw a dip in engagement and impressions this October compared to last year. This was
due to the top three posts in October 2022 performing at a slightly higher rate than this
years. With the content visit in November coming up we should be able to correct this in
November and December.
Only Pawleys
Social & Email
Report
Social Wins + Top Posts
PINEAPPLE PUBLIC RELATIONS
Social Media Wins
●Engagement Rate
○Facebook engagements rate of 5.4%
surpassed the industry avg. of 0.27%
○Instagram’s engagement rate of 9.5%
surpassed industry avg. of 0.98%
●Engagement
○Top post on FB reached more than
2.1K engagements and IG’s top post
reached nearly 2.3K engagements.
Only Pawleys
Social & Email
Report
MoM Organic Social Media
PINEAPPLE PUBLIC RELATIONS
Facebook
● Total Likes: +01%
● Shares: -23%
● Likes: -23%
● Total Engagements: -29%
● Total Impressions: -25%
● Total Clicks: -13%
Instagram
● Total Followers: +0.2%
● Likes Received: -21%
● Comments Received: -23%
● Total Engagements: -22%
● Total Impressions: -17%
Only Pawleys
Social & Email
Report
Organic Social Demographics
PINEAPPLE PUBLIC RELATIONS
Facebook Demographics
Instagram Demographics
Only Pawleys
Social & Email
Report
**unable to collect demographics due to Instagram being disconnected from Sprout
Organic Social Media: YTD
Facebook
●Total Likes: 40,186
●Engagement Rate: 5.1%
●Total Engagements: 249,118
●Total Impressions: 4,878,696
●Total Clicks: 47,415
Instagram**
●Total Followers: 17,657
**Until Sprout connection is restored, we cannot collect YTD data on Instagram as
Instagram’s own insights only go back 90 days at a time
Only Pawleys
Social & Email
Report PINEAPPLE PUBLIC RELATIONS
Paid Social Media
For the month of October, Pawleys Island conducted 2 boosted post
campaigns across Facebook and Instagram. All ads performed well
above industry standards.
Facebook & Instagram
●Total Campaigns: 2
●Total Engagements: 3,986
○Avg. Cost-Per-Engagement: $0.03 (Industry Avg.
$0.63)
●Total Paid Impressions: 21,316
Only Pawleys
Social & Email
Report PINEAPPLE PUBLIC RELATIONS
Social Key Takeaways
Moving Forward●With Facebook and Instagram’s changing
algorithms, which favor video, we will continue to
search for more video content to add into our post
rotation in the coming months to see if this boost
engagements and impressions.
●We will also focus on adding in more images of bird
watching, local restaurants, shops on the mainland
(specifically the Island Shops), and add more
carousel (multi-picture) posts.
Only Pawleys
Social & Email
Report PINEAPPLE PUBLIC RELATIONS
Email Marketing
Email Overview
PINEAPPLE PUBLIC RELATIONS
Strategy●Wrote and deployed October newsletter in Robly
●Updated subscriber list based on AAA and Guest Quest email
leads
●Prepared monthly report
Monthly Themes●Mobi-Mat on Pawleys
●Pup-friendly vacation
●30th Turtle Strut Run
●Peace Vacations rental home
●24/7 Beach cam
Only Pawleys
Social & Email
Report
Campaign Results
PINEAPPLE PUBLIC RELATIONS
(Month over Month Comparison (September v October)
●Open Rate: 15.98% v 13.5% -15,5%
●Avg. Delivery: 98.96% v 98.60% -0.36%
●Click Rate: 6.65% v 5.7% -14.2%
●Opt-Outs: 28 v 23 -17%
●Avg. Bounce Rate: 0.08% -27.7%
○Hard Bounces: 29
■Hard bounces - The email was undeliverable because the
sender blocked receiving emails or the email does not exist
○Soft Bounces: 431
■Soft bounces - The email was undeliverable because the
user’s inbox was full, there was an outage or other
temporary reasons
●Subscriber Increase: +1 new subscriber in October, the same as
September. Going forward, we will receive Guest Quest leads which will
increase our subscribers.
Only Pawleys
Social & Email
Report
Campaign Results
PINEAPPLE PUBLIC RELATIONS
Only Pawleys
Social & Email
Report
These statistics are from the first deployment (send) of the Only
Pawleys newsletter. RoblyAI, a tool that staggers the send of the
newsletter over a 24 hour window to ensure optimal engagement,
was active for this send. It increased newsletter open rates by
1.77%. It can only be used the first time you send an email.
Campaign Results: Second Send
PINEAPPLE PUBLIC RELATIONS
Only Pawleys
Social & Email
Report
These statistics are from the second deployment of the OnlyPawleys newsletter.
This second send targeted people who did not open the newsletter the first time,
utilizing a tool called OpenGen.
Email Key Takeaways
PINEAPPLE PUBLIC RELATIONS
Moving Forward
●Pineapple PR is working on new Welcome Email
experience
Only Pawleys
Social & Email
Report
THANK YOU!5238 Peachtree Road, Suite 150
Chamblee, GA 30341
404-237-3761
pineapple-pr.com
PineapplePublicRelations@pineapple_pr
BUDGET
2024 Budget 2023 Budget
INCOME
30% Tax Estimate 95,000.00$ 102,366.00$
SCPRT Grants 35,000.00$ 37,000.00$
Carry-over from FY 2023* 50,000.00$ 30,000.00$
Total Projected Income 180,000.00$ 169,366.00$
EXPENSE 2024 2023
Print + Digital Components 53,500.00$ 43,500.00$
Digital (Social, Email, Website, SEM, Display, SCPRT) 84,100.00$ 85,166.00$
Creative & Production 3,000.00$ 3,000.00$
Administrative, Acct., Audit 9,400.00$ 7,700.00$
Total Marketing/Admin Expense 150,000.00$ 139,366.00$
Carry Forward 30,000.00$ 30,000.00$
TOTAL EXPENSE 180,000.00$ 169,366.00$
EXPENSE 2024 2023
Print (+ Digital Components)
Atlanta Magazine 13,000.00$ 13,000.00$
SCPRT Vacation Guide, all SC Welcome Centers 8,000.00$ 7,500.00$
Our State (NC) 20,000.00$
AAA Magazine No Longer Printing -$ 13,000.00$
City View (Knoxville) 12,500.00$ 10,000.00$
TOTAL PRINT (+ DIGITAL COMPONENTS) 53,500.00$ 43,500.00$
Digital
Email Marketing 12,600.00$ 12,000.00$
Social Media Marketing 21,000.00$ 20,000.00$
Website (includes SEO, maintenance & hosting) 12,200.00$ 8,000.00$
SEM & Digital Display 38,300.00$ 30,000.00$
Our State Paid Content -$ 5,000.00$
City View (Knoxville) -$ 4,000.00$
SCPRT Co-op Digital -$ 6,166.00$
Varies annually, presented in May 2024
TOTAL DIGITAL 84,100.00$ 85,166.00$
OTHER
Creative & Production 3,000.00$ 3,000.00$
TOTAL OTHER 3,000.00$ 3,000.00$
Town of Pawleys Island Tourism Marketing
DRAFT Budget January - December 2024
ADMINISTRATIVE
Chamber 7,500.00$ 6,600.00$
Accounting 400.00$ 350.00$
Audit 1,500.00$ 750.00$
TOTAL ADMINISTRATIVE 9,400.00$ 7,700.00$
Carryover to 2025 30,000.00$ 30,000.00$
TOTAL 180,000.00$ 169,366.00$
NOTES:
-30% ATAX income is estimatedbased on past five (5) years' performance.
-Media buys are subject to change. If income does not meet projections, media will be cut from the plan.
-*"Carryover" to FY2024 is not reflected in percentage breakouts of expenses in pie chart.
Print:35.7%
Digital:56.0%
Admin:6.3%
Creative:2%
FINANCIALS
Source: Town of Pawleys Island website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.