RecordWell Data

Agenda

Town of Seabrook Island · Charleston County · Agendas

Open the original document More from Town of Seabrook Island

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TOWN OF SEABROOK ISLAND Town Council Work Session May 10, 2022 – 1:00PM Town Hall, Council Chambers 2001 Seabrook Island Road Seabrook Island, SC 29455 Watch Live Stream (YouTube) Virtual Participation: Individuals who wish to participate in the meeting via Zoom may call (843) 768-9121 or email kwatkins@townofseabrookisland.org for log-in information prior to the meeting. AGENDA 1. Call to Order – Roll Call – Freedom of Information 2. Mayor John Gregg • Update Concerning Main Road Corridor Segment C 3. Town Council Members: • Jeri Finke o Short-term Rental Ad Hoc Committee Report with Councilwoman Fox • Patricia Fox • Barry Goldstein • Dan Kortvelesy 4. Town Administrator Joe Cronin • DSO Public Hearing: May 17, 2022 (2:30 PM) • Action Items for May 24th Meeting o Ord. 2022-04: An ordinance to repeal and replace the Town of Seabrook Island Development Standards Ordinance (“DSO”); to repeal and replace the Town of Seabrook Island Zoning Map; and to repeal conflicting provisions from the Town Code for the Town of Seabrook Island 5. Adjourn Town of Seabrook Island Town Council Report of the Ad Hoc Committee on Short-Term Rentals Presented To Council By Jeri Finke, Councilwoman Pat Fox, Councilwoman In Consultation With Joe Cronin, Town Administrator Tyler Newman, Zoning Administrator/Chief Code Enforcement Officer May 10, 2022 1 Executive Summary This report reviews the purpose of the Ad Hoc Committee on Short-Term Rentals (2020-2022) and outlines how it responded to the direction given to it in October 2021 by Mayor John Gregg. The Mayor directed the Committee to review recent trends and developments in rental activity in the Town of Seabrook Island to address the claims and charges raised by the Preserve Seabrook group, in its petition filed with the Town Council in 2021, and its ongoing correspondence and public statements and actions since. To present a thorough perspective of the short-term rental (STR) issue, and respond in detail to the Preserve Seabrook group and its petition, this report includes an overview of the history and growth of the Seabrook Island development and the Town of Seabrook Island; reviews data provided by Seabrook Island Town staff, SIPOA (Seabrook Island Property Owners Association), and the Seabrook Island Club; references data sourced from trade groups and legal and business professionals; and summarizes findings from its interviews and meetings with local stakeholders. While the report’s intent is to present a data-driven review and discussion for recommendations to Council, it is necessary given the nature of the issue that anecdotal evidence be referenced. The Preserve Seabrook petition indicated there are a number of Seabrook Island property owners who believe there are too many people on the island, stressing its infrastructure and amenities, and they blame it on the presence of too many short-term renters. This report is intended to present a discussion that distinguishes between actual problems and the proliferation of anecdotal accounts that are not ongoing issues. The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic cannot be overstated, but it is also impossible at this time, for this report, to fully quantify for policy recommendations. It is clear that the pandemic disrupted the events and trends that have been used in the past to predict, plan, and accommodate the inevitable changes in the Seabrook Island community. Where the impact of the pandemic has been dismissed by some in discussing the STR issue, this report tries to put balance into the discussion. The report’s findings about the impact of STRs on the Town of Seabrook Island are not in agreement with the claims made by the Preserve Seabrook group and do not support the petition’s basis or proposal for rental permit caps. The report concludes by recommending to Town Council continued monitoring of the island’s rental market, robust enforcement of the current STR ordinance, and improved cooperation with SIPOA on addressing any problem rental properties. The report also includes recommendations to Council for immediate clarifying amendments to the Town’s current STR ordinance, as well as possible additional STR controls should future changes in rental activities in the Town prove them necessary. In finalizing this report, it became evident that the short-term rental issue has seemingly driven a wedge in the community, especially between residents and non-residents, all of whom are property owners with a significant investment in Seabrook Island. It is unfortunate that repeated, but unfounded claims, have convinced a group Seabrookers that every problem impacting their life on the island can be blamed on short-term renters, from a piece of litter to an unavailable tee time. Hopefully, this data-driven report will help move the community forward together. 2 THE STR AD HOC COMMITTEE REPORT TO COUNCIL Section Page 1. Ad Hoc Committee on Short-Term Rentals 2020-2022 .............................. 3 2. Preserve Seabrook Group and Petition ........................................................5 3. Referendum ..................................................................................................7 4. Development and Growth of Seabrook Island .............................................9 5. Age Demographics.....................................................................................13 6. Real Estate Life Cycle and Perspective .....................................................15 7. Residential Zoning, STRs by Zoning, Residency by Zoning ....................18 8. STR Nationwide Trends and Community Comparisons ...........................25 9. STRs by the Numbers on Seabrook Island ................................................28 10. Impact of Proposed Caps on STRs ............................................................32 11. Infrastructure and Amenities......................................................................35 12. Externalities and Local Contacts ...............................................................42 13. Operating a Business Behind the Gate.......................................................45 14. Conclusions ................................................................................................46 15. Recommendations ......................................................................................48 16. Addendums A. Petition and Introductory Letter - September 2021 ..........................51 B. Petition Signers .................................................................................54 C. Petition Opposition ...........................................................................58 D. Zoning Transition Chart ....................................................................59 E. Review of Papers Presented by Preserve Seabrook Group ...............60 F. STR Location Maps .........................................................................66 G. Policy Options Presented by Staff for Consideration .......................69 3 Section 1 The Ad Hoc Committee on Short-Term Rentals (STRs) 2020-2022 The Seabrook Island Town Council Ad Hoc Committee on STRs (hereafter in this report referred to as “the Committee”) was appointed by Mayor John Gregg in February 2020 (see the minutes of February 25, 2020, Town Council meeting). The Committee members are Councilwomen Jeri Finke and Pat Fox. The Mayor charged them with reviewing the rental activity within the Town of Seabrook Island through consultations with all stakeholders; researching how such activity was or was not regulated in other communities; and reporting to Council on whether there was any need or desire to address the issue in the Town’s Code of Ordinances. (At that time, there was nothing in the Town code that addressed rental activity beyond the requirement of the property owner obtaining a business license.) The Committee’s research and outreach in 2020 were hampered by COVID-19 restrictions on in- person group meetings and, as such, were limited to conference calls, webinars, online data collection, email correspondence, and meetings conducted via Zoom or other internet platforms. The result of the Committee’s work was the recommendation to Council that an ordinance be adopted that maintained the ability of property owners to rent their property, but to do so with rules that ensured basic safety protections for rental guests, minimized adverse impacts on neighboring properties and the public, complemented SIPOA and regime rules, and brought the Town of Seabrook Island in line with “best practices” in STR ordinances already enacted and successful in other communities. Council adopted Ord. No. 2020-14 on December 15, 2020. The new STR ordinance took effect on January 1, 2021. The Committee continued to work with Town staff to track and evaluate the implementation, impact, and enforcement of the new ordinance. In September 2021, the Town Council was notified of the formation of the Preserve Seabrook group and its petition effort regarding STRs based on the claim that rental activity was “out of control.” An email from one of the petition authors read: “Attached is a copy of the letter that is just beginning to be distributed to the entire Seabrook community that reflects concerns and a plan for action regarding short-term rentals.” (The referenced letter is attached to this report as Addendum A.) The petition that was formally filed with Town Council in October 2021 demanded a nonbinding ballot referendum on the November ballot to cap STR permits. When the petition’s referendum was denied (See Section 3), Mayor Gregg charged the Committee with resuming its research by assembling additional data on the trends and developments in rental activity within the Town (See minutes of the October 26, 2021, meeting of Town Council). To meet the Mayor’s charge, the Committee started a series of meetings in November 2021 with legal advisors, industry professionals, and trade groups; staff who track data and other information relevant to the issue; and with local stakeholders, including Seabrookers who have specific concerns and suggestions on how they wish to see STRs regulated, and/or capped, and/or prohibited; as well as Seabrook property owners who do rent or have rented their properties and/or who expressed an interest in participating in the discussion. The meetings included both those supportive of the petition and those opposed. 4 In stated and written correspondence, the Committee emphasized its intent to base its report to Town Council on solid data and not assumptions and misperceptions, and the Committee encouraged this perspective in each of its meetings and interviews. Each month the Committee gave a brief progress report to the Mayor during Council’s public meetings. In reporting on all the meetings and research in this report, for readability and ease of reference, the Committee uses Town of Seabrook Island, the community, the island, the Town, Seabrook, Seabrook Island interchangeably. It is of note, however, that the boundaries of the Town of Seabrook Island and the area under SIPOA’s jurisdiction are different, their authority and jurisdiction differ, and that the term “island” is used as a general term and does not refer to any actual geographically, legally defined island. The Committee’s references to “the Club” throughout this report refers to the “Seabrook Island Club,” which is a constituent of both the Town and SIPOA, but a separate entity that is privately funded and governed by its own articles of incorporation, bylaws, and rules and regulations. Throughout this report, the Committee did not include comments from anyone, whether pro or con the petition, who specifically asked to remain anonymous. Nor did the Committee include in any list, discussion, or reference in this report letters delivered that were not signed, believing that there was no way to verify the authors and put their comments into perspective. Town Administrator Joe Cronin and Zoning/Code Enforcement Administrator Tyler Newman attended the Committee’s meetings and were consulted regarding the contents, findings, and recommendations in this report. 5 Section 2 The Preserve Seabrook Group and Petition The founders of the Preserve Seabrook group and the authors of the Preserve Seabrook petition have conducted a steady public correspondence with the Seabrook Island Town Council, including presentations at Council meetings; correspondence with Seabrook property owners, focusing on full-time residents; and have maintained a regular presence in local social and print media. They were the first to be invited to meet with the Committee. Hereafter, this report refers to them as “the Petitioners.” While the Committee sought and received comments and information from all sides of the STR discussion, the Committee, admittedly, could not talk in person to every property owner and does not attempt to characterize every petition signer. It became clear in the Committee’s meetings and interviews that there are many nuanced views about STR activity on the island, and also about the material provided and publicized by the Petitioners. The petition (Addendum A) was formally presented to the Seabrook Island Town Council on October 4, 2021, with an update filed on October 25, 2021. Since that time, the Petitioners have informed Council that there are more than 400-500 signatures on an online petition. The Committee does not question that number as it has no way to verify the online signers; this report can only respond to the petition officially presented to Council. The official petition included 158 signatures, but after reviewing and removing duplicates and one invalid address, the official petition had 151 signatures representing 97 properties. (The list of signers, a public record, can be found in Addendum B.) The Committee notes that submission of the Preserve Seabrook petition in 2021 did not go unanswered by those opposed to its STR cap proposal. Town Council and/or the Committee received comments via emails or postings on the Town’s public comment portal representing more than 95 properties. While not an organized petition, 135+ property owners (after eliminating duplicates) took the time to write out their comments to express their views on the petition effort. (Those expressing their opposition to the petition, and not asking to remain anonymous, are listed in Addendum C.) 6 The Committee charted the addresses of the petition signers against active short-term rental addresses (as of March 2022) as but one metric to analyze if dissatisfaction over STR activity was related to location on the island. (To understand the zoning districts under the new DSO, and how the various residential classifications are applied to each neighborhood in the Town, see Addendum D.) Petition Signers Permitted STRs # % of Total # % of Total Single-Family Areas 133 88.1% 129 25.0% - Single-Family Large Lot (R-SF1) 0 0.0% 0 0.0% - Single-Family Medium Lot (R-SF2) 120 79.5% 101 19.6% - Single-Family Small Lot (R-SF3) 13 8.6% 28 5.4% Multi-Family Areas 18 11.9% 386 75.0% - Cluster Home (R-CL) 3 2.0% 83 16.1% - Townhome (R-TH) 9 6.0% 105 20.4% - Multi-Family/Condo (R-MF) 6 4.0% 198 38.4% Total 151 100.0% 515 100.0% • 88.1% of the petition signers (133) are located in one of the “single-family” zoning districts. By comparison, 25.0% of the permitted STRs are located in one of the “single- family” zoning districts. • 11.9% of the petition signers (18) are located in one of the “multi-family” zoning districts. By comparison, 75% of the permitted STRs are located in one of the “multi- family” districts. • To summarize, those who are most concerned about STRs by their signature on the formal petition are, statistically speaking, the least likely to live near one. Maps with the location of active (4/2022) and unique (2021) STR permits can be found in Addendum F. (active and unique defined on page 22) 7 Section 3 Referendum The Preserve Seabrook petition asked for a nonbinding referendum to be included on the November 2, 2021, general election ballot. The Committee notes that in correspondence about the petition, it was often asked for an explanation of why the referendum was not held. The referendum was denied with the following explanation (as per the October 26, 2021, Town Council meeting minutes): Mayor Gregg clarified that Council is not voting today on any ordinance or resolution concerning the proposed referendum of the petition received October 4 or the updated petition received October 25. Further, it is to be understood that were Council to determine that further regulation of short-term rentals by the Town be appropriate, the process to achieve that regulation would afford all interested parties an opportunity to be heard through outreach and/or public hearings. As for the petition, it is noted that State law requires that a referendum question be made available no later than forty-five days in advance of the relevant election. Notwithstanding that today’s agenda allowed both presentations and comments concerning the petition, the result of the untimeliness of submission of the petition is that the request for placing the proposed referendum on the ballot for the Town’s 2021 election is denied. Mayor Gregg noted to Council that he found the proposed referendum objectionable as pertaining to a legislative matter for Council while excluding participation by non-resident property owners who do not have the right to vote in a Town election. He added the petitioners were made aware that changes to zoning are not susceptible of address by referenda but have persisted in pursuing a non- binding referendum in an apparent attempt to induce Council to effect such changes. The Preserve Seabrook group later renewed its request for a nonbinding referendum to be held in a special election. The Town Council discussed the request at its November 26, 2021, meeting, and again the request was denied, this time by vote of Council 3-0 with 1 abstention. Reasons for the second denial included: • The proposed referendum, even nonbinding, would disenfranchise two-thirds of Seabrook Island property owners and summarily dismiss their property rights, investments, and possible livelihoods. • The referendum would not resolve any issues arising out of problems at short-term rental properties. (The Mayor noted prior to the vote that “it does not appear there is a sufficient basis for assessing any benefit to be expected from conducting a special election or the timing of the same.”) • The proposed referendum would run counter to judicial precedent: In I’on v. Town of Mt. Pleasant, Op. No. 25048, Supreme Court of South Carolina (2000), the Court held that allowing zoning by initiative and referendum is not allowed under SC state law. While the Court dealt specifically with the petition and referendum process established under Title 5 of the SC Code of Laws (i.e. binding referendum), in I’On v. Town of 8 Mount Pleasant, the Court’s analysis was clear in the fact that zoning decisions should include participation by a broad range of interested parties: o “We disagree with appellants and conclude the Legislature could not have intended to allow zoning by referendum for two reasons. First, the conflict between the relatively free-ranging Title 5 initiative and referendum process and the elaborate, detailed zoning procedures contained in Title 6 are incompatible and hopelessly inconsistent. Second, allowing zoning by initiative and referendum potentially would nullify zoning and land use rules developed after extensive debate among a variety of interested persons.” o “The obvious incompatibility between the initiative and referendum process and the comprehensive Title 6 provisions indicates the Legislature did not intend to allow voters to enact more complex zoning measures by initiative and referendum.” o “[T]he comprehensive and detailed nature of the Title 6 provisions briefly outlined above reveals our Legislature's intent that zoning decisions should be made by a cross-section of unbiased officials after careful deliberation. Whether the zoning decisions involve the development of an overall zoning system or master plan, or the application of established rules in a particular case, Title 6 is designed to allow ample planning and ensure due process for all interested parties.” o “The Legislature has recognized by its enactment of detailed procedures in Title 6 that haphazard or thoughtless decisions are the antithesis of meaningful zoning. We agree with Developer that the Legislature has not condoned — and we should not approve — a process by which voters could circumvent this deliberative process by deciding zoning matters in an initiative and referendum process. Such a system ultimately could nullify a carefully established zoning system or master plan developed after debate among many interested persons and entities, resulting in arbitrary decisions and patchwork zoning with little rhyme or reason.” More generally, the Committee notes: • On its face, a non-binding or “advisory” referendum may not be illegal, per se. However, consistent with the court’s ruling in the I’On case, it would run counter to the provisions of Title 6, Chapter 29, of the SC Code of Laws, which require due process for all interested parties in zoning decisions. A referendum which is open only to registered voters would fail to meet that objective, as it would disenfranchise the majority of property owners within the Town of Seabrook Island. • The Petitioners want a cap on short-term rental permits, and that was evident with the official petition filed with Council; there was no need to hold a referendum to make that request any clearer. If 158, or 400, or some other number of individuals support a cap, that’s a real number that is noted in this report and has been acknowledged by Council. • If Council were to consider a cap on rental permits (or any other amendments to STR Ord. No. 2020-14), all interested parties would have an opportunity to participate in the process, as noted in the Mayor’s referendum explanation above, and as required by Title 6, Chapter 29, of the SC Code of Laws. This is consistent with the Court’s statements in the I’On case, and it is how the Town handled the STR ordinance in 2020 and any other zoning matter that has come before the Town. 9 Section 4 Development and Growth of Seabrook Island The Committee believes that assessing rental activity within the Town of Seabrook Island, and whether there is “uncontrolled growth of short-term rentals” as the Petitioners claim, cannot be done without first understanding the island’s history and growth. Resort Development The Charleston County Council approved the “resort community of Seabrook Island” in 1971 as the first Planned Development District (PDD) established in the county. Seabrook Island was initially developed and marketed as a resort, where villas (starting in 1974 with High Hammock Villas and Dune Crest Villas ) could be rented for short -term stays, and later were sold and contracts offered to buyers for the developer/beach club to manage and rent the properties for them. As the development progressed, soon both villas and single -family homes were being built and marketed for sale and as “resort rentals” and “beach vacation homes.” This would continue during the period of Seabrook Island’s history when the conference business also brought visitors (as renters) to the island. When the club (as it was organized and operated at the time) ended its rental and conference business, rental activity still remained a viable option for all property owners, as it is today. The Committee conclude s that it is accurate to say that Seabrook Island resort rental activity (now referenced as STRs) has always been a planned, constant, and significant economic and cultural element of the island. (See Section 10 regarding economic impact ; also page 41) Island Buildout When the Seabrook Island development was first approved by the County in 1971, the plan identified single family homesites in the range of 1200 -1600 with 1400-1600 multi-family residences. (As per the History of the Seabrook Island Club , the master development plan projected 1,236 single -family home sites and 1,415 multi -family residence s.) The development plan has been amended twice and updated once, but those numbers have changed little. In the Town’s 2019 comprehensive plan (required by state law), development behind the gate included 1,328 single-family homes and 1,690 multi -family residences (1,537 and 1,690 when adding in the PDDs for Jenkins Point and other areas. ) These numbers are compared in the following chart against a current review by Town staff at the end of the year 2021 (noting this count uses revisions in the new DSO – Addendum D – now pending before Council as this report is written) . Seabrook Island Planned Development The Town of Seabrook Island was incorporated in 19 87 SINGLE-FAMILY LOTS/UNITS MULTI-FAMILY/OTHER TOTAL HOMESITES/UNITS 1971 ORIGINAL PDD 1200-1600 1400-1600 2600-3200 2019 PDD AS PER COMPREHENSIVE PLAN 1537 1690 3227 2021 END OF YEAR ACTUAL 1523 1175 2698 +297 vacant lots remaining 10 Population Growth The Committee notes that US Census Data also bears out the Town’s growth. The Seabrook Island development is 50 years old ; this data looks at just the last 20 years: US Census Data – Town of Seabrook Island, SC CATEGORY 2000 2010 2020 % CHANGE 2000-2020 % CHANGE 2010-2020 POPULATION 1250 1714 2050 64% 19.6% HOUSING UNITS 1649 2203 2377 44% 7.9% OCCUPIED UNITS 660 917 1118 69.4% 21.9% VACANT HOUSING UNITS 989 1286 1259 27.3% -2.1% OCCUPANCY RATE* 40% 41.6% 47.0% 17.5% 13.0% *Occupancy rate is the number of occupied housing units as a percentage of total units. The Committee also looked at election data over the last ten years and found a significant increase in registered voters, which is another indicator of how the Town is growing: Seabrook Island Registered Voters 2011 -2021 Change Since 2011 Year Registered Voters # % Nov 2011 1,545 --- --- Nov 2013 1,712 167 10.8% Nov 2015 1,817 272 17.6% Nov 2017 2,031 486 31.5% Nov 2019 2,125 580 37.5% Nov 2021 2,386 841 54.4% The Committee includes the Census and election data in the preceding tables in response to the many comments made to Town Council and the Committee, referencing “the loss of our quiet island over the last 20 years,” or there are “too many people on the island.” The conclusion in 11 most of those comments is that “they must be renters” and, thus, there mu st be too many STR offerings. The Committee notes that the population of the Town of Seabrook Island has grown nearly 20% in just the last ten years; 64% in the last 20 years. C oncluding only renters contribute to the “too many people” fails to acknowledge the planned, inevitable, and documented growth of the Seabrook Island community . Those complaints also fail to accept that Seabrook Island is and always has been a beach community that experiences a seasonal population influx. For example, the Com mittee notes an excerpt from the Town’s 1999 Comprehensive Plan (as revised in March 2015): “As with other beach communities, the population increases dramatically in the summer when it includes residents, non-resident homeowners and short-term renters. During the summer of 2014, estimated peak population grew to 2,713 (as derived from gate passes). Source: Seabrook Island Property Owners Association (November 2014).” Pandemic Impact on Population The Committee notes that there is limited evidence to date that can quantify the two -year impact of the COVID -19 pandemic on the island’s population , but the Petitioners cannot just reference their concerns about the last two years without naming the pandemic and without giving its impact any consideration. The Committee found that putting the blame solely on renters for any “crowds” the island experienced over the last two years fails to account for travel behavior, nationwide and worldwide, that was influenced by the pandemic. Hotels, restaurants, and retail stores were closed, cruises were cancelled, international travel was not possible, and schools were shut down, so families looked for rental homes away from the cities and their devastating COV ID-19 case numbers and deaths to ride out the pandemic. In its interviews, the Committee found that f or Seabrook Island, pandemic -driven behavior resulted in: 1) Resident property owner s staying home and being present on the island , using SIPOA and Club amenities and the beach, when in previous years many traveled or returned north for the summer, thus were not a visible presence in normal years ; and 2) The more-than-normal presence of non-resident property owners with their families, riding out the pandemic in their vacation/future retire ment homes. During this time, the SI Club had to close certain amenities, including all inside dining; local restaurants were shut down or limited to carryout services; and the Freshfields Harris Teeter and other stores were imposing shopping restrictions that led to lines to shop that further increased tensions and exasperated perceptions about crowds on the island. The Committee, in trying to assess the COVID -19 impact, does not argue that people also “discovered” Seabrook Island during this time, and that added to the island’s pandemic population. The property managers reported there were waiting lists for rentals. But at the same time, the Committee acknowledges the anecdotal reports from the property management professionals that even then, many of their “guest occupied” nights were families of property 12 owners, who elected not to stay “with the grandparents” to protect against COVID -19 transmission “from the kids” or simply needed the extra room and /or privacy. The Committee notes that in response to SC Governor McMaster’s executive orders imposing travel restrictions on visiting SC, the Town closed the island to most short-term rentals in 2020 (March-May). The Governor also closed p ublic access to the state’s public beaches. Although the Seabrook Island beach is public, access to it is private behind the gate and via the SIPOA- owned boardwalks. The Committee could find no data that tracked if the ability to access the Seabrook Island beach during this time had any impact on rental activity in the Town. The Committee wanted to know how the pandemic played out by the numbe rs at STRs and looked at stats from various property managers. As an example, t he following chart is a look at properties managed by Coastal Getaways, which are consistent in their trending as other numbers presented to the Committee. Coastal Getaways Re ntal Activity YEAR DAYS GUEST OCCUPIED DAYS OWNER OCCUPIED TOTAL PROPERTY BOOKINGS MEMORIAL TO LABOR GUEST OCCUPIED MEMORIAL TO LABOR OWNER OCCUPIED TOTAL PROPERTIES BOOKED MEMORIAL TO LABOR CG TOTAL RENTAL PROPERTIES MEMORIAL TO LABOR 2019 22,135 12,642 2020 ***ISLAND CLOSED DUE TO COVID 3/17-5/15 27,241 33,702 14,496 17,324 3,101 12,424 3,678 1,865 162 2021 33,826 15,677 4,237 15,957 3,667 2,323 206 *** To make a year -to-year comparison, the totals in blue were arrived at by extrapolating from 2021 numbers for March to May (6,461 and 2,828) to adjust 2020 numbers to account for when the island was closed to most rentals. From this chart, t he pandemic clearly had an immediate impact. Owner -occupied nights were up 24% during the 2020 -21 period. Guest -occupied nights were up 52%. In the context of looking at the Town’s growth versus STR activity, and the impact of the pandemic, the Committee notes information from Coastal Getaways that it believes is significant to understanding summer “crowds.” July Fourth may be the busiest week on the island, true pre- and during the pandemic, but according to the management company’s owner: “I cannot emphasize this enough - rentals didn't change the entire month of July. What did change is that is the week more owners use their properties than any other week in the year. Thanksgiving is 2nd. So even though we had 201 rentals - over 40% of them were occupied by owners the week of July 4th. Plus other homeowners come here that week with their family and friends … ” 13 Section 5 Age Demographics The Committee acknowledges the many comments it received claiming that evidence of STRs being “out of control” mentioned the presence of so many unfamiliar faces and younger families on the island during both the peak and off-peak seasons. US Bureau of Census numbers indicate that the Town of Seabrook Island remains an “older” community with 62.1% of residents over the age of 65 (median age of 67.9). In comparison, that demographic for the country is 16.5%, for South Carolina 18.2%, and for Charleston County 17%. Considering the Census numbers, is it reasonable to assume only renters are younger? The Committee looked for a metric to review if the anecdotal observations about the younger, unfamiliar “crowds” of renters were valid or a misperception. Looking at data from the Seabrook Island Club suggests the latter: • With the turnover in real estate and a construction boom, the Club has added more than 500 new members, with a net gain of more than 200 members over the last two years. • Membership properties (as the end of March 2022) was 2,207. • Of the total memberships, 34% are resident members and 66% are nonresidents members. • Over the five-year span (2016-2021) there has been a 29% growth of members on the island fulltime. • The average age (56.7) of the new member is considerably younger than the average age (65) of the membership overall. • As of the close of 2021, 220 minor children were listed on the membership roster (previously the high was 75). Further responding to the claim that “unfamiliar faces” indicated renters overrunning the island, the Committee asked Town staff to analyze sales data from SIPOA during the two years pre- pandemic (2018-1019) and the two years of the pandemic (2020-2021). This look at property transfers is a revealing perspective: SIPOA Property Transfer Data Pre-Pandemic (2018-2019) and Pandemic (2020-2021) For additional context, roughly 18% of single-family homes and 28% of villas had a different owner at the end of 2021 than they did two years earlier. Pre-Pandemic Pandemic Change Property Type 2018 Transfers 2019 Transfers 2-Year Total 2020 Transfers 2021 Transfers 2-Year Total # % Single-Family Homes 78 77 155 119 100 219 64 41.3% Villas 119 110 229 176 153 329 100 43.7% Vacant Lots 35 18 53 67 102 169 116 218.9% Total 232 205 437 362 355 717 280 64.1% 14 With the boom in home construction and property sales, all resulting in a documented and significant number of new and younger Club members, the Committee notes that it is reasonable to feel frustrated with so many unfamiliar faces sharing the community but trying to directly link the presence of unfamiliar faces, perhaps also accompanied by children, as evidence that STR activity is out of control cannot be supported by the data. Pre-Pandemic 2018-2019 / Pandemic 2020-2021 Pre-Pandemic 2018-2019 Pandemic 2020-2021 Pandemic 2020-2021 15 Section 6 Real Estate Life Cycle and Perspective Life Cycle A common thread that surfaced during the Committee’s meetings and interviews, as well as in correspondence from real estate agents, property managers, and property owners who rent or have rented their properties, is the concept of the “real estate life cycle” of Seabrook Island. The Committee acknowledges that discussing the real estate life cycle is anecdotal, and the Committee did not spend time investigating if it is entirely unique to Seabrook Island. This topic is included in the report because it surfaced so very often throughout meetings and correspondence, often with a great deal of detail and passion. Again and again, the Committee was presented with the story of how a couple/family visited Seabrook Island as resort renters only to fall in love with it: They buy into the island and rent their property as they plan for eventual retirement; they spend more and more time at the property over the years (reducing the rental activity) and eventually move to the island permanently at which time they often sell the original Seabrook property to upsize or renovate and/or build. At the other end of the cycle, property owners age-out of the island, often moving to be closer to children and/or to live in a senior facility like Charleston’s Bishop Gadsden. This has created a real estate life cycle that for years, even during upturns and downturns of the market, has kept short-term rental activity a constant on the island, most often in the 25-30% range of total existing developed properties in recent years (determined by estimates from property managers, SIPOA, and the Club), while also refreshing the market and the community with new property owners. In many instances, the cycle spans two and three generations. As part of its review to understand the significance of this real estate cycle, the Committee reviewed a survey conducted by the Town in 2019, which was done prior to the preparation of the 2019 Comprehensive Plan for the Town of Seabrook Island (adopted by Ord. No. 2019-06 on July 23, 2019). Having a comprehensive plan in place is required by state law (S.C. Code of Laws, Sec. 6-29-310 et seq). The complete survey results are on the Town’s website (under the Services/Planning & Zoning drop down menu), but for this report, and this discussion about a real estate life cycle in particular, the Committee notes questions #11 and #12. Of those responding to the survey, 74.1% said they were full-time resident property owners. And those respondents indicated that nearly half, 46.8%, had visited the island at least once as a short-term renter before buying property. 11. As a Seabrook Islander, are you … 16 12. Did you rent (either as a short-term visitor or long-term renter) before purchasing property in Seabrook Island? Throughout this report, the Committee tries to gauge the impact of the pandemic. So noting that the survey was done pre-pandemic, it is of interest that when asked to describe the community/island in their own words, not a single respondent just two years ago called it overcrowded or overrun with short-term renters. Given the opportunity to add their own comments in response to a number of questions, out of nearly 450 comments that were submitted, less than 10 directly referenced any opposition to short-term rental activity and/or overcrowding because of renters, and even then most of those comments were concerned that renters do not follow rules on the island. Real Estate Perspective Over the two-plus years that the Committee has been working on the STR issue, several meetings and interviews have been held with real estate professionals to gain an understanding about the economic impact of the island’s rental market. The Petitioners have, on the other hand, indicated in their correspondence and presentations to Council and the Committee that they believe too much emphasis is placed on the value of STRs to the real estate market and the overall economy of the island. (See Section 10 to review the cost to the Town of the Petitioner’s proposed STR caps.) The Committee was repeatedly told by the local realtors that the ability to rent a property was crucial to sales and property values. One realtor reviewed her recent sales and said 80% of the buyers mentioned rental activity as a positive – and those buyers, sans only one at this time, were looking to eventually move to and/or retire to Seabrook Island. When asked, not one realtor could remember a buyer asking if a neighboring property was on the STR market – rather, of concern when house/villa shopping was whether a neighboring property was attractive and well maintained. While some realtors suggested that some further “control” of STRs might be helpful in easing tensions on the island, when presented with the chart that visually illustrates the impact of the petition’s proposed caps (See Section 10), they rejected the caps with such terms as “devastating, catastrophic, would crash property values, unnecessary, a clear violation of property rights.” The Committee notes that not all realtors were opposed to the Preserve Seabrook petition – the Committee is aware of two from its recent meetings: One realtor signed the official petition, but that realtor was very forthcoming in an interview with why, made helpful source suggestions for the Committee’s further research, and also had concerns about the petition’s proposed STR caps, including the impact on side-by-side regime properties. The Committee also acknowledges an interview with a second realtor who personally would like to see the elimination of any rentals in the long term but did not believe that possible considering the island’s resort-oriented history. 17 Island One In its meetings and interviews, starting with the Committee’s work back in 2020, the Island One initiative was often referenced by stakeholders, and done so as either a positive or negative influence on the island’s real estate market. The Committee took Island One into consideration for this report only in context of current real estate values and in response to claims that “investors” are driving the “uncontrolled growth” of STRs. The Town was not party to the 2004 Island One agreement between SIPOA and the Seabrook Island Club that included Section 40 of SIPOA’s covenants, which requires new property purchasers, unless grandfathered, to become members of the Club. The enactment of Island One was done by an island-wide vote of property owners (approved 2,293 to 762 in November 2004). Section 40 still remains controversial for some. The Town has no authority to amend that agreement, and the agreement cannot simply be abandoned without agreement between the Club and SIPOA and a vote of property owners. The Committee heard many times in its various STR stakeholder meetings that Island One particularly hurt villa sales (for which Club joining fees represent a much higher percentage of the sales price) and that it has taken 10-15 years for values to rebound, or to at least be on par with those on Kiawah Island. (The Committee only acknowledges receipt of these comments and did not research their accuracy or whether other issues, like market downturns and/or aging properties and maintenance issues, also hurt sales.) Realtors, however, told the Committee that Island One has not been a deterrent in the current market to buyers who want to make Seabrook Island a vacation destination and/or a future home. It does deter, however, outright investors who do not want to shoulder the carrying costs of joining fees and monthly dues when properties elsewhere can be purchased without that ongoing expense. When asked, realtors did not see any evidence that the current Seabrook market was being driven by investors simply looking to establish STR properties. The Committee took note in reviewing the impact of STR activity that the major property management firms operating on the island accept only clients where the property carries a Club membership, either by the Island One mandate or by choice for older or grandfathered properties. This fact is important in assessing use of the island’s amenities. (See Section 11.) The takeaway for the Committee on Island One and effect on the STR market: 1) Most of the rental owners who met with or contacted the Committee mentioned the additional costs associated with mandatory club membership as one of their primary reasons for renting their property; and 2) If villa prices were/are depressed because of Island One, it would further aggravate the financial impact if the Town arbitrarily then limited the ability of those property owners to recoup Club expenses by renting; and 3) Most realtors and property managers list the additional costs of mandatory membership, which is not a requirement in Seabrook’s neighboring communities, as a “firewall” to outright investors buying to establish STRs and who have no interest in ever living on the island. 18 Section 7 STRs: Residential Zoning Breakdown, Occupancy and Residency by Zoning Residential Zonin g In the language of its petition, the Preserve Seabrook group wants t he Town to “affirm the current Single Family Residential zoning protections in any future zoning changes.” The Committee believes the Town’s existing Development Standards Ordinance (DSO) addressed this issue, and that it is also adequately addressed in Section 5.1 in the revised DSO, approved by the Planning Commission in January 2022 and now pending before Town Council: “Section 5.1 Purpose. The purposes of the residential districts, in general, are to: provide for quiet, low-density residential neighborhoods; discourage unwarranted encroachment by regulating commercial and other uses which would interfere with the development or continuation of residential uses; minimize nonconformities; and discourage uses which would generate traffic on minor streets other than required to serve residences on those streets.” (Ord. 2022-04, an ordinance to repeal and replace the Town of Seabrook Island Development Standards Ordinance; to repeal and replace the Town’s Zoning Map; and to repeal conflicting provisions from the Town Code.) The Committee is concerned that the Petitioners do not consistently extend the “residential” description to the villas and townhomes within the Town. All developed properties behind the gate other than those owned by the Club or SIPOA are residential. The Committee reviewed rental activities as they impact ALL residential properties, not just single-family homes. (See Transition Zoning Chart in Addendum D.) Not only is the Committee concerned when correspondence from Preserve Seabrook supporters fails to apply the residential description to all properties, it is of concern when those comments suggest that full-time residents are single-family home residents who do not ever rent their properties, and they are the only property owners making full contributions to the community. Many stories related to this subject were relayed to the Committee. If and where someone volunteers and where someone spends and/or donates money are not subjects the Committee took time to track for hard numbers, if that would even be possible. The Committee notes, however, non-residents, both who rent and those who do not, relayed to the Committee their volunteer activities with SIPOA and Club committees and with local charities. They spend locally when on the island, as do their rental guests, perhaps even more so than residents because they are not prone to use Amazon and other online shopping when on vacation. 19 STR Activity in Single-Family Residential Zones The Petitioners have stated, and continue to state, that there has been “uncontrolled,” “explosive,” and “unfettered” growth in STRs, particularly in the single-family residential areas. While the data indicates an uptick in multi-family areas, including cluster home communities, townhomes and condos, the rate-of-growth between 2019 (the last pre-pandemic year) and 2021 was exactly 0.0%. The Committee notes the significance of the information in the following charts, some of the most important data in this report: • Between the 2019 and 2021 license years, the Committee notes the growth rate in “unique” single-family rental units has been exactly 0.0%. • Multi-family units have increased by 9.9% over the same time period. The total number of unique STR properties was up 7.3% town-wide by this metric. • Considering the Town has issued COs (certificate of occupancy) for several dozen new homes since 2019, the proportion of single-family homes that were rented in 2021 was actually less than in 2019. • The growth the Town has seen over the last few years has been distributed fairly equally among the condos (9.6%), cluster homes (10.1%), and townhomes (10.3%). Short-Term Rentals by Zoning District 20 21 Breakdown of STRs by Regime / Association (2019 to 2021) 22 In reviewing the previous charts (and those in following sections of this report and the maps in Addendum F), the Committee notes the terminology used: • ACTIVE STR: An "active” STR is a residential property which possesses a valid STR permit and business license from the Town at a given point in time. In this context, the term “active” does not necessarily mean that the property is actively being rented; rather, it means that a property may legally be rented (or advertised for rent) at that specific point in time. • UNIQUE STR: Over the course of the permit year, the number of “active” STR units will go up and down as new STR permits are issued and existing STR permits are cancelled or revoked. A “unique” STR is one which was “active” at any point during the permit year. • EXAMPLE: Owner “A” obtains a STR permit and business license prior to the April 30 deadline. As long as Owner “A” remains in good standing with the Town, the property will be considered an “active” STR and may be rented at any time during the license year (May 1 through April 30). In October of that year, Owner “A” sells the property to Owner “B” and Owner “A” notifies the Town that the property has been sold, thus the STR permit and business license are cancelled. Owner “B” intends to live at the property fulltime and does not obtain a new STR permit or business license. At that point, the property is no longer an “active” STR; however, the property will be included in the list of “unique” STR properties for that year because it was rented at some point during the year. Occupancy by Zoning The Committee notes that, on average, the maximum occupancy for condos, cluster homes and townhomes is significantly less (approximately 45% less) than for single-family homes: Residency by Zoning Permitted STRs were reviewed to determine how many of those properties are listed as a legal residence – 4.2% total according to the county’s tax records. Under state law, a legal residence can be rented up to 72 days and still retain the 4% property tax assessment (fair market value) for a primary residence. (6% fair market value for other real estate.) 23 Using data from the Town’s 2021 STR permits, the numbers for primary residences with an STR permit were comparatively low, as one would expect, while showing that there was a higher proportion of primary single-family homes that are rented over the course of the year (10 of 129 – 7.8% ) than multi-family units (12 of 389 – 3.1%). Using another metric, the Committee notes that more reliable data at this point would be to look at numbers based on residency status from county tax data (shown in the next chart). These numbers also indicate, as above, that there is a higher proportion of primary single-family homes that are rented over the course of the year (19 of 129 – 14.8%) than multi-family units (17 of 390 – 4.4%). The Committee looked at these residency metrics (4% v. 6% properties) related to STR properties in order to evaluate alternatives to limiting the impact of rental activity in zoning districts by some factor more refined than capping overall rental permit numbers. End of April 2022 24 25 Section 8 STR Nationwide/Statewide Trends and Community Comparisons The Committee notes that its research revealed that Seabrook Island is far from alone in experiencing an intense discussion about STRs – it is an issue town -to-town, state-to-state across the country. The Committee used webinars for some of its research ; those conducted by the Vacation Rental Managem ent Association and also by Granicus were particularly informative as to the national and state numbers: • The STR inventory nationwide increased 9.4% in 2021, and the pandemic is considered the driving force behind the increased popularity of short-term home rentals. • Although the travel industry had predicted that the pandemic impact would subside in 2022 (with more people again opting for cruises, large resorts, and overseas travel), the current forecast is that STR popularity will remain high as a COVID-nervous traveling public may still prefer home-centered vacations. • In 2021, 54% of short-term renters had never booked a vacation rental home before. • There are approximately 2 million STR listing in the US, representing 1.6 million rental units (with 1.22 listings on average in 2021 per rental unit across the US). There are numerous online platforms that owners can easily access to list a rental property, including Airbnb, VRBO, Booking.com, Marriott Bonvoys, Homeaway, etc. The ease of listing online and the proliferation of vacation-finding sites is a major development in the rental market over the last 5-10 years. State-to-State Comparison of Rentals and their Listings: From Granicus 2021 Although the STR numbers for Seabrook Island do not come close to the trending apparent in the industry’s national numbers, or even in South Carolina overall, the Committee believes it is important that Town Council be aware of the national trends as it continues to monitor STR activity in the Town. Acknowledging that Seabrook has always had a strong rental market (See Section 4), means that STRs are not an unexpected phenomenon as they have been when emerging in other communities (especially where the short-term rental market developed recently and was pandemic driven). 26 Community Comparisons The Committee believes it should address the demand by the Petitioners that the Town of Seabrook Island impose an immediate cap on STRs because other communities are considering and/or imposing caps. The Committee asked a code/ordinance consultant, who works all around the country, if he was regularly seeing STR caps and other regulatory issues surface as a problem for other communities. The answer was helpful in putting the community comparison debate into perspective: The debate cannot be compared city to city because a community’s history, its zoning and character, its economics, and the reason STRs may be taking hold vary so widely. The Committee notes as an example for this report – Mt. Pleasant and Columbia have/are debating (as this report is being drafted) a cap on STRs, but a main driving force of the debate is the displacement of long-term rentals with a short-term market that is more expensive and thus displaces low-income workers by limiting affordable housing options. STRs in these communities also are in direct competition with hotels (as they are in the City of Charleston). Neither is an issue for Seabrook Island. More recently, the debate over limiting STRs came to the surface again in the Town of Folly Beach, and the Petitioners immediately made note that Town of Seabrook Island is not paying attention nor following a neighboring community’s lead. The Committee again notes the difficulty in making direct comparisons. Unlike Folly Beach, the majority of properties on Seabrook are behind a private gate; Folly Beach has an entirely different history and culture – surf and souvenir shops, retail bars and restaurants, a pier and municipal park. While the population of the two communities are similar, Folly Beach has more than twice the STRs, with the growth in STRs in Folly Beach during the period (2019-2021) at over 20%. STRs in Folly compete directly with LTRs, which is not an issue for Seabrook. From the press statement, STRs have “started to price out some owners of long-term rentals.” Town staff reviewed the data for long-term rental (LTR) licenses. While there are fewer LTRs than STRs, the pace of growth for LTRs has been significantly higher. The total growth in “unique” LTR properties was 12, or 43.5%, during the two-year period when STR growth was 7.3% by this metric (See Section 8). The Committee concludes that the LTR market, albeit limited on Seabrook Island, has not been displaced in recent years by STRs. TOTAL LONG-TERM RENTAL LICENSES Growth (2019-2021) 2019 2020 2021 # % Business Licenses Issued 23 27 33 10 43.5% Properties with Duplicate Licenses* 0 0 0 Unique Properties Licensed 23 27 33 10 43.5% Licenses Cancelled (Removed/Sold) 0 0 4 Total # Licensed at Year End 23 27 29 6 26.1% 27 If the Committee were to use an example, it recommends to Council that it look no further than Kiawah Island as that is the community closest resembling Seabrook’s history, situation, and active rental market. The Kiawah Town Council placed a 20% cap on short-term rentals in certain single-family residential zones while placing no cap in other residential zones. From the Town of Kiawah Island STR ordinance (Ord. No. 2020-07): Of note, the zoning districts in the Town of Kiawah Island do not correspond to those in the Town of Seabrook Island. Each municipality defines their own residential districts. 28 Section 9 STRs by the Numbers on Seabrook Island The Petitioners have based their arguments for capping rental permits on the “ uncontrolled growth of short-term rentals, especially on streets where there are many full -time and private residential properties.” Th is quote, including the bold emphasis, is from the opening paragraph of the letter introducing the petition effort. (Addendum A) The Committee reviewed the Petitioners’ proposed cap on STR permits and found that they had no baseline from which they were making their claim of “uncontrolled growth .” The Petitioners cited only 2021 rental permit number s they requested (and received) from Town Hall at various times during the year, as well as using anecdotal reports that many STRs “popped up over the last year or so.” The Petitioners’ information does not establish a baseline from which to claim a trend of uncontrolled growth. The Committee notes that there is just one -year of rental permit information. T he STR Ord. No. 2020-14 has been in effect only since January 1, 2021, and 2021 was the first year rental permits were required by the Town. The rental permit number fluctuates as properties are sold and/or owners elect to rent or not; permits are revoked upon a property sale, while new owners are required to file for a new permit. During the transition, there could be two rental permits on the books for one property. The Committee does not believe you can call a month -to-month fluctuation over just one year a trend for policy decisions. The Committee sought more and broader context for this report to Council. The Committee believes an important point is that obtaining a rental permit does not in any way indicate a property is an active rental every day/every month. A n STR permit is required if an owner plans to rent for even one night during the calendar year. Nor can the Committee or the Petitioners extrapolate from the occupancy limit on the rental permit that every rental property is always at full capacity when rented. It is also incorrect to gauge rental activity by going online and looking at “availability.” The Committee learned that the reservation systems available to view online by the public do not distinguish between a property being unavailable because the owner has blocked out the time for personal use or it is being actively rented. Tracking STRs via Business Licenses The Committee looked for several metrics to measure STR activity and trends in recent years ; one was to look at business licenses. Prior to enactment of Ord. No. 2020 -14, the only Town regulation of rental properties was the requirement that owners obtai n a business license before renting the proper ty. During its 2020 research leading up to the enactment of Ord. No. 2020 -14, the Committee found that the business license requirement was misunderstood and/or ignored by some property owners. Some owners si mply told the Committee that they were not aware of the need to have a business license (must less also file with the county and state to pay taxes) . They just managed and rented their own property , often via an online platform like VRBO. The Town began closer tracking of short -term rentals in 2019 by issuing separate business licenses for each short -term rental. P rior to 2019, management companies were able to cover all of their managed units with a single li cense. This skews the overall number prior to 2019 29 and prevents a meaningful “apples-to-apples” comparison for earlier years. For example, the license issued to Costal Getaways prior to 2019 covered well over 100 units each year, but the data base indicates only one license. The Town began using STR Helper (now Host Compliance by Granicus) in late 2018 and into 2019 to identify unlicensed rental units (and now also rental permit compliance). The software program tracks rental marketing across all online platforms for complian ce with local regulations. Town staff advises the Committee that once the software was implemented, noncomplying propert ies tracked, and property owners notified of violations, compliance increased significantly . Town staff expects compliance to approach 100% with follow-up tracking after this year’s (2022) license/permit cycle . The Committee believes that understanding the compliance issue helps find a reliable indicator of “growth” in the number of “unique” properties which have a rental license in any given year. This is essentially the “maximum” number of properties that were licensed to rent during a specific year and suggests what would be the “wors t case scenario” if all licensed units were actively rented at the same time. In reality, the Committee knows from the various metrics that the number of active rental units at any given point will ebb and flow as units are added or removed from the market for a variety of reasons, including personal use by the property owners. Using this metric, the Committee notes the total growth in “unique” rental properties between 2019 (pre-COVID-19) and 2021 to be 37, or 7.3%: TOTAL SHORT-TERM RENTAL LICENSES Growth (2019-2021) 2019 2020 2021 # % Business Licenses Issued 517 534 604 87 16.8% Properties with Duplicate Licenses* 8 18 58 Unique Properties Licensed 509 516 546 37 7.3% Licenses Cancelled (Removed/Sold) 0 11 28 Total # Licensed at Year End 509 505 518 9 1.8% *Duplicate licenses are issued when a prior owner has a license, the property is sold during the license year, and the subsequent owner also obtains a license during the same year. To fully understand the numbers in the chart above, the Committee makes two points: 1) The 2021 license year lasted 16 months rather than the usual 12 months due to state mandated changes in the Town’s license year. As a result, some “new” rentals that would have been captured in 2022 were instead captured in the 2021 license year. 2) Since the Preserve Seabrook petition was received in the fall 2021, the Town has had multiple owners, 8-10, who have stated that they were obtaining permits solely to protect their ability to rent in the event the Town imposes caps. These owners stated they currently have no immediate plans to rent. Tracking STRs via Data from SIPOA Next the Committee looked to data from SIPOA for another reference point. The January 6, 2015, minutes of the Seabro ok Island Gateway Task Force, assembled by SIPOA, indicates its research showed a total of 450 rental properties on the island. The trade/business groups who 30 currently offer software programs to scrub online for STR listings (such as Granicus Software Solutions) suggest that in 2015 before the software was perfected that this count could easily have been at least 5 -10% higher. The Gateway Task Force was confident in its number, but taking the recommended variable into consideration, the Committee conclude s that STR count on the island in 2015 was likely 477-495. If the rental permit count as of March 31, 2022, was 517, STR growth from 2015 to the writing of this report has been in the range of 4.4% to at worst 8.3%. The Committee poses to Council whether this can be considered “uncontrolled” STR growth considering over that same time period the number of housing units on the island has also been increasing by about the same percentage. Using the 2010 US Census number of housing units in the Town, then assuming on average 2 1 new houses per year as put fo rth in the Town’s 2019 Comprehensive Plan that relied on the American Community Survey Five -Year Estimates, the housing unit count in 2015 was approximately 2250 at year -end. At present, there are 2,366 developed housing units (with 35 under construction) in the Town. That is at least a 6.6% increase in housing units over seven years. (As per the 2020 Census results, housing units in the Town increased 7.9% from 2010 to 2020.) To compare, the Committee notes a housing unit increase of 6.6 -7.9% against a 4.4% to an at worst 8.3% increase in rental properties. 2015 2020 Census Current Percent Change Housing Units 2250 (estimate) 2377 2366 (+35 under construction) 6.6 – 7.9% STRs 477-495 na 518 4.4 – 8.3% Tracking STRs via Club Data The Committee also looked at how the Seabrook Island Club tracks rental activity. One metric is the number of amenity cards issued by the Club week to week. This is informative but not as straightforward since the Club includes in its rental count those membership addresses that request more than 10 amenity cards during the year , which may be just as likely to indicate several personal house guests rather than a rental property . 31 Seabrook Island Club Amenity Card Tracking 2015/2019 -2021 Year-to-year comparison in these numbers must also consider that the Club restricted credit card use in 2021, requiring payment only via the amenity card, thus increasing the number of amenity cards issued. The numbers also reflect the months in 2020 when the Town was closed to most rental activity . 32 Section 10 Impact of Preserve Seabrook’s Proposed Caps on STRs The Petitioners are calling on Town Council to cap the number of i ssued rental permits at 5% for single-family residential zoned districts and at 20% for other residential districts (multi -family, cluster homes, and townhomes) within the Town. Petitioners claim that they do not want to eliminate STRs or the ability of property owners who currently rent their properties from continuing to do so . The Petitioners propose that current rental permits be grandfathered, with conditions. The Committee notes that the proposed caps would in effect prevent any new rentals on the island for years. As one realtor reported to the Committee, this “would be catastrophic for home sales.” (See Section 6.) Here is a summary of the current breakdown of STR units as of March 31, 2022, plus the total reduction necessary (via attrition) to get down to the cap that was put forth in the petition: Current STR Permits Property Type # Permitted % of Developed Lots/Units Single-Family 129 10.8% Other Residential 388 33.0% Total 517 21.9% STR Cap (Petition) Property Type # Allowed % of Developed Lots/Units Single-Family 60 5.0% Other Residential 235 20.0% Total 295 Reduction Necessary to Get to STR Cap ** Property Type # Reduced % Reduction from Current Single-Family -69 -53.5% Other Residential -153 -39.4% Total -222 -42.9% ** As proposed in the petition, existing STR permits would be “grandfathered.” Therefore, the reduction in STR units would be accomplished over time by attrition (e.g. when the owner of a “grandfathered” STR unit fails to renew a permit on time or when a “grandfathered” STR unit is sold to a new owner). If the caps were to be imposed as stated in the petition, the Town would not issue a single new STR permit unless and until the number of STR units first drops below the 5% or 20% cap, as applicable. 33 Breakdown of Gross Income for STR Properties 2020 Business License Year (n=603) Here is the business license data for STRs for the 2021 license year: • The Town has issued a total of 603 business licenses over the course of the year to 546 “unique” addresses. Some addresses have multiple licenses due to a sale (i.e. a license was issued to the former owner, the property was later sold, and another license was subsequently issued to the new owner). • Due to revocations and cancellations over the course of the year (due to non-reported property transfers and owners who reported that they A “current” STR has an active business license and STR permit and can legally be rented; it does not necessarily mean that it is actively being rented. • Among the 603 licenses issued, the reported gross annual income ranged from a low of $0 to a high of $171,537. • The median gross income reported on all STR business licenses was $25,039; the average was $30,469. • The Town issued “base” licenses to 9 STR properties with $0 in reported or projected income. Most of these licenses have been processed since the petition was received in the fall. Anecdotally, most (if not all) of these came from people who have no current plans to rent but are fearful of losing the ability to do so if the petition’s cap proposal is successful. • Note: A business license is based on “gross” income and not “net” income. It does not account for the costs associated with operating/maintaining a rental property (such as a mortgage, interest, taxes, insurance, fees, management company expenses, maintenance/repairs, cleaning, depreciation, Club dues, etc.) 34 Summary of Average, Median and Total Gross Income for STR Units Including the Town’s Total Business License Collections (by property type) 2021 Property Type Gross Income AVERAGE Gross Income MEDIAN Gross Income TOTAL Business License Revenue R-SF1 (Single-Family/Large Lot) ----- ----- ----- ----- R-SF2 (Single-Family/Medium Lot) $48,374.54 $41,715.48 $5,563,071.74 $27,977.50 R-SF3 (Single-Family/Small Lot) $43,641.66 $45,319.32 $1,309,249.88 $6,799.50 R-CL (Cluster Home) $24,493.12 $24,791.00 $2,326,846.53 $15,128.40 R-TH (Townhome) $24,377.04 $21,559.15 $2,925,244.40 $19,148.00 R-MF (Multi-Family/Condo) $25,643.94 $23,906.50 $6,205,833.28 $39,705.50 Total (All Properties) $30,448.91 $25,025.05 $18,330,245.83 $108,758.90 As the number of STRs is decreased by attrition to get to the 5% and 20% caps proposed by the Petitioners, Town staff projects the direct revenue loss to the Town would be as follows: • $48,000 per year in business license revenue • $56,000 per year in STR permit revenue • $164,000 per year in State ATAX revenue • $33,000 per year in County ATAX revenue • A total of $301,000 in lost revenue per year, or about 16% of total general and restricted fund revenues. The Committee notes that the above projections do not take into account the following: • The significant reduction in rental properties will indirectly impact revenues for the Club, local restaurants, management companies, cleaning companies, and other businesses. These losses are difficult to project and are not accounted for in the numbers above. • While the Town’s revenues will take a significant hit, the Town’s enforcement demands will remain relatively unchanged. If more owners move to illegal rentals, enforcement costs may actually rise. (Based on what the Committee heard from property owners who rent and why they invested in their vacation/retirement home (Section 6), the Committee would not expect Seabrookers to follow the national trend, but according to Granicus research, without proper enforcement, nationwide less than 10% of STR owners voluntarily register and comply with local regulations.) • If the Town is faced with losing $300,000 per year, all evening and weekend code enforcement officers would need to be eliminated. And considering that the majority of the beach patrol budget is funded by revenues from accommodation taxes, the contracted beach patrol season and hours would have to be substantially reduced unless another source of funding could be found. Since the Town has no tax levy, there are limited sources of alternative revenue. 35 Section 11 STR Impact on Infrastructure and Amenities Repeatedly mentioned in the Petitioners’ discussion about STRs is their claim that too many rental guests are stressing, overrunning, and abusing the island’s security, infrastructure, and amenities. The Committee sought to dig deeper than the prevailing anecdotal stories. Gate House The near constant complaint made to the Committee has been over the perception that illicit visitors are coming through the Gate (perhaps by the hundreds at times by some accounts told to the Committee) as guests of short-term renters who can call in an unlimited number of passes. The Committee notes that even property owners opposed to any STR cap would comment on the Gate House, suggesting that fixing problems there would address most of the dissatisfaction over rental activities. The Gate House is under SIPOA’s jurisdiction. The Town has no authority to dictate procedures for access through the Gate. The Committee believed, however, that talking to SIPOA about issues at the Gate – and the Committee did so several times – was necessary to its full understanding of how rental activities are impacting the island and to ensure that this report tries to address the whole spectrum of issues raised in its meetings with stakeholders. It is clear to the Committee that there have been problems with procedures at the Gate, including the handful of days that there have been long backups sometimes stretching up Seabrook Island Road. But at the same time, it is obvious that there are also widespread misperceptions about the degree to which Gate House problems contribute to parking problems, visitors on the beach, or any stress on the island’s amenities. The Committee knows from its meetings that SIPOA has been researching traffic numbers and patterns through the Gate, exploring solutions to legal issues and procedural hurdles, and developing plans for the near future. Those research numbers are SIPOAs to share and explain, and the changes SIPOA is planning to implement at the Gate are for SIPOA to announce. The Committee only wishes to acknowledge SIPOA’s work, its search for solutions, and its willingness to discuss the issues with the Committee. Infrastructure (Water and Sewer) Petitioners claim short-term rentals are stressing and overrunning the capacity of the Seabrook Island Utility Commission, using water and sewer for which they do not pay their fair share. The Committee asked the Chair of the Seabrook Island Utility Commission (SIUC) to comment on this claim. Her response was NO, short-term renters, do not have a significant impact on utility operations and the system’s capacity. And she noted that the owners of the rented properties pay for utilities like any other Seabrook property owner. If owners do not pass on those costs via their rental rates for the property, that is not a problem for the Town or SIUC to resolve. The capacity of SIUC to provide water and process sewage is gauged against the number of households and business structures both within the Town and provided via long-standing contracts outside the Town’s limits. It is not gauged against a population count at any point in time. In answer to the Committee’s question, the explanation was offered that if, hypothetically, you could completely empty the Town (households) by half or more and measure the demands 36 on the system and then add back in those empty households, there would be a difference seen in utilization. But on a week-to-week, month-to-month, basis, the number of people on the island, including rental visitors, is not the cause of any capacity issues. It is true that SIUC does need to upgrade and expand its operations, and there will be a significant cost associated with those improvements. Needed changes and expansions are directly related to the age of the utility, the planned build-out of the Town, and contractual obligations executed long before the Town acquired the utility plant in 1996. And it is also true that water and sewer rates have increased recently, but the Committee notes the reasons for the increase in the December 31, 2021, letter from the Utility Commission: “The water usage rate will increase in January from $4.37/1000 gallons to $5.00/1000 gallons. This increase includes a pass-through rate increase from St. Johns Water. In addition, the usage increase is driven by inflation related materials costs, employee costs and an acceleration of service line replacement projects. The water base fee, $24.55 per month, will not increase.” For background, and an understanding about the age of the utility and how longstanding obligations drive capacity issues, the Committee notes that construction of the island’s permanent water and sewage treatment plant began nearly 50 years ago, in 1974, by the resort developer. The plant was sold to Heater of Seabrook in 1988, which was a subsidiary of Minnesota Power and Light. A long, nasty legal battle between the Town and Heater was initiated in 1994 because of extraordinarily high-rate increases imposed by Heater; that legal battle lasted until an agreement was reached for the Town to acquire Heater of Seabrook's assets in 1996. Club and SIPOA Amenities The Committee notes that the Town has jurisdiction over the beach (from the high-water mark seaward), but does not control access via the boardwalks, nor does the Town provide for or fund any of the amenities (pools, golf courses, tennis courts, playground, restaurants, etc.). The Town has NO authority to dictate how the Seabrook Island Club governs memberships or allows access to its amenities. The Town also has NO authority over how SIPOA regulates access to the Lake House, manages the Oyster Catcher pool and building, or how it maintains the boardwalks and establishes beach parking. Nevertheless, the Committee sought to be as thorough as possible in its STR review and to understand how and to what degree rental guests, staying in Town permitted STRs, are impacting both the Club and SIPOA. The Committee looked at several metrics to measure renters’ activities and the impact those activities have on the ability of both resident and nonresident property owners to access those amenities. The Committee notes that a Town permitted STR does not arbitrarily allow access for its guests to the amenities at the Seabrook Island Club. Access is controlled by the Club, not conveyed by the Town rental permit, and the Club’s controls only give rental guests access to the Club if the rental property has a Club membership for which the joining fee was paid, and monthly dues are current. Rental guests must have an amenity card (for which there is a fee) and then “pay to play and eat” at guest rates that are higher than members’ rates. 37 As of the date of this report, there are approximately 2698 properties in the Town; the Club reported to the Committee that as of March 2022, there are 2207 properties on the island with memberships. The two companies managing the majority of rental properties on the island do not accept clients who do not have Club memberships in good standing. For those properties without a Club membership, STR guests may only access SIPOA’s Lakehouse with an amenity card and for which there is a fee. Perhaps some of the most telling statistics about rental guest use of amenities is looking at golf play. Despite comments that “you could not get on the course because of renters,” the Committee notes that rental guest play remained statistically constant, with the second year of the pandemic (2021) having some impact – consistent with the trending the rental management companies tracked. Member (non-STR) play increased during 2020-2021 with more members staying home on the island because of pandemic travel restrictions and more non-resident members being on the island to ride out the pandemic. (See Section 4) 38 The Club’s tennis stats from the same period offer a similar conclusion – members accounted for the vast majority of court usage against rental usage: Future capacity of the island’s amenities in light of the island’s growing population is an issue that must be addressed by SIPOA and the Club, not Town Council. Discussions about whether past governing boards and management of those organizations did not make correct long-range planning decisions is the proverbial “water under the bridge” and does not move the community forward. The Committee prefers to acknowledge that in researching the impact of STRs across the island, it was given the clear impression that both SIPOA and the Club are fully engaged, committed, and determined to maintain the Seabrook Island lifestyle by enhancing and expanding their amenities and exploring all options to meet the demands of a growing community. Seabrook Island’s Roads The Committee was often told that too many renters equate to the faster deterioration of Seabrook Island roads, for which only residents will eventually have to pay. There are 27.5 miles of roadway behind the gate that are owned and maintained by SIPOA. Once a car crosses the Land Fall Way intersection and drives through the gate, the Town has no jurisdiction over road maintenance. The Town also has no jurisdiction over how SIPOA assesses properties under its jurisdiction, but the Committee notes that all developed properties, whether having a Town- issued rental permit or not, are assessed the same and contribute to SIPOA’s operational budget. In its attempt to be thorough, the Committee turned to information from SIPOA’s GOMC (General Operations and Maintenance Committee) and found no evidence in its extensive reports (available on SIPOA’s website) that suggests passenger car traffic attributable to renters is adding any significant stress to the island’s roads. While vehicle traffic does add stress overtime, roads deteriorate for a 39 number of reasons – age, materials used, weather, maintenance, etc. The Committee did note in its review of the GOMC reports reference to the wear and tear generated by property owners: “It is estimated that around 40% of the vehicles on Seabrook are contractor vehicles, such as from landscaping or maintenance crews. This is a relatively high number for residential roads, which is significant because heavier vehicles cause more stress on asphalt than cars.” STR Accommodation Taxes (ATAX) The discussion about the impact of STR guests on island amenities must include the revenue flow STRs generate for the Town and how those revenues, although restricted in their use, benefit the community. Taxes required to be paid by STRs include a state accommodation tax (2%) and a county accommodation tax (2%) based on the gross receipts collected. (STRs are also required to pay a state sales tax of 8%.) Although state law allows for it, the Town of Seabrook Island does not currently collect an additional 1% accommodation tax. Of note to the Committee, the Town of Kiawah Island does. While the Town does not fund any of the physical amenities on the island, it does use its ATAX revenues to sponsor the July Fourth Fireworks display. This year, 2022, it will also use accommodation monies to bring the Charleston Symphony Orchestra to the island for an afternoon, outdoor concert. Accommodation taxes are also the majority source of funding for Beach Patrol. The Committee notes that better compliance with the business license/rental permit requirements (See compliance discussion in Section 9), means better compliance by property owners in collecting the required accommodation taxes, resulting in increased revenues for the Town. The Committee notes here , however, that compliance was not the only reason for the significant increase in accommodation tax revenues in 2021 – guest-occupied nights did increase (See Section 4), and also rental rates w ere raised several times in the last two years as per information from property managers. 40 ATAX revenues are considered “restricted” funds. SC state law is very specific about how cities and counties can spend state accommodations tax revenue. The first $25,000 must be deposited into the Town’s general fund, then 30 percent of the balance must be allocated to a qualifying fund for the exclusive use of tourism advertising. The Town makes that payment to the Charleston Area Convention & Visitors Bureau, a 501(c)(6) not-for-profit destination marketing organization (DMO) that meets the requirements of state law. The remaining balance of accommodations tax revenue must be used for tourism-related expenditures as defined in SC Code Section 6-1-530. 41 Overall Economic Impact The Petitioners have repeatedly argued that the economic impact of rental activity on the island is grossly overblown, overvalued, and not a point for discussion. The Committee notes the following from the Town’s 2019 Comprehensive Plan: Part 4.2: BACKGROUND AND INVENTORY OF EXISTING CONDITIONS In 2016, at the request of the Town, five MBA students from the Citadel Graduate School of Business prepared an Economic Impact Study for the Town. The study, prepared under the oversight of two MBA Program professors, utilized two previous economic impact studies as reference tools, and an “insightful tour of its many amenities, commercial centers, residential neighborhoods, and multiple staff teams that work for the island,” to document and further detail the value that Seabrook Island brings to the Charleston Area. The executive summary of this study concludes that “the economic impact of Seabrook Island, and their permanent and seasonal residents, is immeasurable and has increased significantly since the previous study was performed in 1996, with a combined economic impact of almost $344 million supporting over 4,800 jobs.” The Town believes these numbers to be conservative, as because of the time of year the study was put together, it understated the economic impact of the many summertime visitors who vacation on Seabrook Island. The economic activities associated with the Town of Seabrook Island are not only linked to the overall regional economy, they are also closely associated with the economic vitality of SIPOA, SIC, and SIUC. While each of these three Seabrook Island entities maintain revenue streams and incur costs that are exclusive of the Town, the overall economic success of the community is very much dependent upon the individual financial viability of all four entities. This relationship and financial dependence is recognized by each of the entities. For example, new Seabrook Island property owners become members, and are subject to the rules and regulations of the SIPOA, including the requirement that they also become members of SIC for a specific period of time. The dues associated with this requirement represent an important revenue stream for SIC. Similarly, one routine action identified in SIPOA’s Comprehensive Plan is to “continue to look for opportunities to reduce cost and redundancy with the Town and SIC by sharing operations.” 42 Section 12 The Externalities The term “externalities” is used to describe issues that a property could impose on its neighbors, be it a rental property or a property occupied by its owners. The Committee notes that these are the issues the Petitioners most often mention when making claims that STR activity is “ruining their quality of life” on Seabrook Island. Only some of these issues fall under the Town’s jurisdiction, but the Committee believes they are addressed by either Town ordinance and SIPOA’s rules and regulations. The point the Committee would like to make is that putting an immediate and strict cap on rental permits will not resolve any of these issues should they surface at any property. Beach Towels on Deck Railings This is not a Town issue or relevant to a property owner obtaining a rental permit. However, if this is an issue that someone finds disruptive of the island lifestyle, it is addressed in SIPOA’s rules and regulations, which “prohibit beach towels, bathing suits and other clothing from being draped over the exterior railings of homes and villas,” whether occupied by the owner, the owner’s guests, or renters. Beach Parking This is SIPOA’s issue. Perhaps it is a stretch to call beach parking an externality, but possibly it is if a property owner cannot find a beach parking spot during the island’s peak season. The Committee notes that it knows of no neighboring beach-front community, whether imposing STR limits or not, that does not have beach parking issues during peak season. Littering and Trash General littering on the island and individual properties is covered under SIPOA’s rules and regulations. If a property with a Town-issued rental permit has trash or debris littered about the property, the problem does fall under the general maintenance provisions of the Town’s STR ordinance. How trash receptacles are stored on a property and the rules for placing and removing the receptacles for trash pick-up are covered by SIPOA rules. Noise, Loud Music, Disruptive Behavior The Town does not have a noise ordinance; this is an issue addressed by SIPOA. Its rules and regulations prohibit the “playing of audio equipment … in a manner that disturbs the privacy or quiet enjoyment of occupants of neighboring residences.” Individual regimes are allowed to enact their own, stricter policies. SIPOA also has code-of-conduct rules: “Personal interactions among people within the SID must be conducted with proper decorum. If conduct deteriorates to the point of being belligerent, hostile, harassing, threatening, or combative in nature, such conduct shall constitute a violation of these Rules and Regulations subjecting the violator(s) to sanctions and assessments.” Overcrowding The Town imposed maximum occupancy limits (Ord. No. 2020-14) for properties obtaining a rental permit: Two per bedroom plus two for properties with less than 2500 square feet of living space; two per bedroom plus four for properties over 2500 square feet; both limits excluding children under two years of age in the occupancy count. Square footage and bedroom count are based on Charleston County property tax records. 43 The Committee notes that it heard complaints that the occupancy limits are too generous and do not apply during the day, leaving no regulatory mechanism to limit exceptionally large daytime gatherings or parties. (Ord. No. 2020-14 reads, “All short-term rental units shall be subject to maximum occupancy limit during the overnight hours.) The Committee believes amending the STR ordinance to define “overnight” may also prove helpful Parking A broad spectrum of parking issues is addressed by both the Town and SIPOA. The Committee spent a great deal of time in 2020 researching the parking rules included in the STR Ord. No. 2020- 14. Those rules are explained in the rental packet that must be, by ordinance, provided to all renters. (The complete rental packet is available to view on both the Town’s and SIPOA’s websites. SIPOA also requires distribution of information about its rules.) The parking provisions in Ord. No. 2020-14 were drafted to supplement and complement SIPOA’s parking regulations. The Town’s parking rules are clear and basic — don’t park in a no-parking area or against traffic; don’t block a fire hydrant; don’t block emergency vehicles; don’t block a neighboring driveway or intersection; don’t park on a lawn, sidewalk, or path. The Town’s STR ordinance only requires that a rental property have at least one off-street parking space available, but it places no restrictions on the number of cars that may be parked at an STR. The Committee notes that this is an area of aggravation when driveways at single-family homes look like a parking lot. While this situation can surface at both non-rental and rental properties, the Committee is concerned that it could be a more frequent occurrence at rental properties compared to those properties not rented. Research does indicate that clearly advertised occupancy limits (given time to take hold in the ad market) may limit the number of cars that are brought to a rental property and should SIPOA more strictly regulate gate passes for rental properties in the near future, this issue may resolve itself. The Committee concludes, however, that further controls on parking (i.e. # of cars) in the STR ordinance could be helpful. SIPOA, as well as some individual regimes, have additional parking rules in place, and those rules may be more restrictive than those imposed by the Town (they cannot, however, be less restrictive). SIPOA cannot enforce parking in areas it does not own, such as on private streets, cul-de-sacs, and parking lots. Also of note, there are areas of the Town outside the gate and SIPOA’s jurisdiction where the parking restrictions in Ord. No. 2020-14 are applicable. STR Management The Committee believes the Town’s STR ordinance put in place strong controls for managing an STR property, addressing the externalities, responding to maintenance emergencies, and ensuring the property owner and management company are held accountable for irresponsible renters. Key is the Town’s requirement that a property with a rental permit must have a local contact who resides within 50 miles of the property and is able to respond within 2 hours of receiving notice. In reviewing the implementation of this requirement, however, the Committee concludes that the ordinance could be amended to ensure even a higher level of responsiveness when problems arise at a rental property. 44 Designated 24-hour Contact for all Active STR Units Property Type Agent Owner Other # STR Single-Family (R-SF1, R-SF2, R-SF3) 112 2 15 129 Other Residential (R-CL, R-TH, R-MF) 280 28 81 389 Total (All Types) 392 30 96 518 Property Type Agent Owner Other Single-Family (R-SF1, R-SF2, R-SF3) 86.8% 1.6% 11.6% Other Residential (R-CL, R-TH, R-MF) 72.0% 7.2% 20.8% Total (All Types) 75.7% 5.8% 18.5% • An “agent” is generally a professional management company, such as Coastal Getaways, Seabrook Exclusives, Vacasa, etc. • The “owner” may serve as the local contact if they meet the residency criteria. For example, some owners may live full-time on Seabrook Island, or elsewhere in the Charleston region. • If the owner does not meet the residency criteria and does not us a management company, under the current ordinance, they may designate another person, such as a friend, family member, neighbor, etc. who does meet the residency criteria and authorize that “other” person to serve as their local contact. To summarize this data: • There are currently (April 15, 2022) 518 “active” STR units in the Town. o The term “active” only means that the unit has a STR permit and business license. It does not necessarily mean that it is actively being rented or offered for rent; only that it can be rented. • Three-quarters of all active STRs (75.7%) use a professional management company. o This number is higher for single-family homes (86.8%) and slightly less for multi- family homes (72.0%). o Condos are least likely to use a management company (67%). o Single-family homes within regimes and associations (the Village, Hidden Oaks, etc.) are most likely to use a management company (92.9%). 45 Section 13 Operating a “Business” Behind the Gate The Petitioners have repeatedly presented to the Committee and to Town Council their argument that an STR is a business not allowed by SIPOA’s governing documents, and that the Town is complicit in allowing the violations by issuing business licenses for rental properties. SIPOA’s regulations have no control over the Town’s zoning decisions, and STRs are permitted as a conditional use of property under the Town’s Development Standards Ordinance, §5.20.30. The Committee notes that any argument over the interpretation of SIPOA’s covenants, rules and regulations, or any other governing document of the association is not in any way a Town issue. However, the Committee believed that it was important to its thorough and complete review of the Petitioner’s concerns to meet with SIPOA regarding this issue. The Committee is confident in SIPOA’s explanation that STRs are not precluded by its documents, but are, in fact, acknowledged and/or implied throughout. To argue otherwise would fail to acknowledge 40 years of history where rentals have been allowed and recognized as a property right. The Committee sees no reason to further detail the argument, but to reference the statement from SIPOA’s outside counsel: "South Carolina law has specific rules that govern the interpretation of restrictive covenants, and neither zoning ordinances, IRS or SC department of revenue regulations, nor any other governmental rules are part of the legal analysis for covenant interpretation. From the standpoint of the [SIPOA] restrictive covenants, the rental of the properties on Seabrook Island is a use that is residential in nature. Additionally, SIPOA’s rules and regulations address the fact that property rentals are permitted on the island." The Committee concludes that should the Petitioners want to pursue this argument, they should do so with SIPOA, but the Committee believes this is not an issue on which to make any recommendation to Council. 46 Section 14 The Committee’s Conclusions After two years of working on the short -term rental issue, including spending the last five months focused on reviewing the claims raised by the Preserve Seabrook group, the STR Ad Hoc Committee concludes: 1) The COVID-19 pandemic had a significant impact on how property owners utilized their properties during 2020 -2021 and on the source and number of people on the island booking STRs. There is no method for determining if the last two years are the exemption or the new normal. It would be unwise to make po licy decisions on that uncertainty, especially decisions that may impact property rights, significant monetary investments, and the economic underpinnings of the Town. 2) Seabrook Island was planned and developed from the onset with a certain number of residential homesites (both multi-family and single -family), and it was inevitable that those homesites would eventually be built out with a resulting increase in the number of people on the island. US Census data confirms not only overall population growth, bu t an increase in the number of full -time residents, indicating that more people present on the island cannot be blamed solely on increased sh ort-term rental activity. 3) The Town took a significant step in 2020 with the enactment of an ordinance placing basic regulations on short -term rentals for the first time. With those regulations being in place for only one year, and the Town’s enforcement capabilities only now hitting full stride, there has not been sufficient time to gauge the effectiveness of that ord inance. The Town should have that information before acting to significantly expand regulations that would risk property values, disenfranchise some property owners while others continue to benefit from their rentals, and impact the economi es of the island. There are, however, changes to the ordinance that could be made now that would serve to clarify and enhance its original intent. 4) It is not the Town’s responsibility to identify, fund, or resolve any shortcomings in the amenities maintained by SIPOA or the Club, and even if the Town were to implement the immediate STR permit caps put forth by the Preserve Seabrook group, it would not end any current dissatisfaction over the utilization of those amenities. 5) The research does not support the Pr eserve Seabrook group’s claim that there is “uncontrolled growth of short -term rentals.” (See page 19) The number of properties offered for rent, both short- and long-term has increased but not at a pace statistically out of step with the growth of development on the island, and not inconsistent with the percentage of rentals present throughout the community’s history. 6) The research indicates that the Petitioners’ demand for an immediate 5% cap on rental permits for single-family zoned districts would be inappropriate considering the island’s history, growth, and development; would be unduly punitive and disruptive on real estate sales; and a possible violation of property rights. The proposed cap would require such a drastic reduction in allowed rental permits that even with a grandfathering clause, the cap proposal would close off even current long-term property owners from renting their property in the future if financial/health/family situations arise and necessitate the use of their property as a rental. 47 7) While data from recent years indicates that there has not been a disproportionate increase in the number of short-term rental units, especially in single-family areas, experience is not always indicative of future results. While concerns about property rights and values must still be weighed against any major policy shift, placing a realistic limitation on the growth of STRs may be in the best interest of the Town, its residents, and all Seabrook Island property owners. Additionally, as a result of the numerous discussions that were held with a variety of stakeholders, there are several amendments to the existing STR ordinance that should be considered in an effort to address some of the more common complaints. 48 Section 15 Recommendations to Town Council Notwithstanding all the data reviewed, the Committee is sensitive to the concerns of those Seabrookers who are unhappy with the growth and change they are witnessing on their island. Although short-term renters should not bear the blame for their dissatisfaction, and although much of the tension is being driven by misperceptions and misinformation, the Committee recognizes that the rental/resort element of the community does have an impact, especially during the peak summer season and, therefore, the Committee recommends to Council: 1) Imposing a 20% cap on short-term rental permits available to single-family residential zoned districts (R-SF1, R-SF2, R-SF3). This cap would be equivalent to that imposed by the Town of Kiawah Island. While trends in rental activity and increasing owner-occupancy rates in single-family areas indicate that this 20% cap likely will not be exceeded, the recommended cap will provide a backstop against any significant, unexpected changes to rental trends in the future. Enactment of the 20% cap should incorporate a “grandfather” provision to ensure that the rights of existing STR permit holders (as of the effective date of any cap) are not adversely impacted by the imposition of a cap, provided those properties renew on a timely basis and remain in good standing with the Town, with the exception that any permits that have been inactive for an entire year prior to the date of the cap’s enactment would lose renewal privileges. In noting the intent of the Town’s STR Ord. No. 2020-14, specifically those provisions for basic safety and minimizing impacts on neighboring properties, the Committee recommends immediate amendments to clarify and enhance those provisions by: 2) Requiring non-resident property owners to use a local rental management company if they do not live within 50 miles of their property. The Committee believes this would provide for a more timely and knowledgeable response if and when problems arise at a rental property. This would allow the Town’s code enforcement officers to be more familiar with a property’s management and remove some of the obstacles in dealing with properties only listed via online platforms. The provisions in the current ordinance allow the property owner to designate a local contact (neighbor, friend, house cleaner, etc.), but that has proven unworkable, with some designees not even knowing they have been made the local contact and/or not always available to respond to a call. 3) Limiting the number of vehicles which may be parked at a STR during the overnight hours (and define overnight as 11pm to 7am). 4) Implementing a maximum occupancy outside of the current overnight hours limit to provide an enforcement mechanism/tool in the event there are large groups or parties taking place within an STR, particularly during the day and early evening hours. 5) Requiring that renters must comply with evacuation orders. While actual complaints about rental properties – complaints made to both the Town and SIPOA -- over the last year have been few, the Committee supports the Town’s emphasis on enforcement and recommends: 49 6) Continuing to engage with SIPOA to establish a more coordinated system of responding to any complaint if and when a problem does surface at a rental property. 7) Establishing a complaint portal on the Town’s website to report violations of the STR ordinance. The Committee believes there are also administrative changes Town Council should adopt as soon as practical to help monitor rental activity ; manage the permitting, licensing, and record -keeping process; and provide another revenue stream to help respond to the seasonal population influx : 8) Increasing the Annual Short-Term Rental Permit Application Fee • The Town of Seabrook Island is currently at $250 per unit. • Kiawah charges $500 per unit. • Isle of Palm bases their fee on income; fees range from $350 to $925 per unit. • Folly Beach does not currently charge for a rental permit; the pending recommendation is to implement an annual fee of $1,000 for 4% properties and $2,000 for 6% properties. 9) Hiring a Short-Term Rental Compliance Manager • This would be a new position. • The primary duties will be to find and enforce unlicensed STRs and properties advertising in violation of Town ordinance, conduct STR inspections, provide day-to- day enforcement activities, process applications and record-keeping In listing the options that follow, the Committee points out that the y are but possibilities to discuss and further flush out with stakeholders, and they are made with no endorsement from the Committee at this time. The Committee belie ves that the Town’s STR ordinance , with robust enforcement, needs to be allowed more than one year to establish its impact before such major policy changes are undertaken . The Committee also believes that Council should take special care not to impose STR regulations that pit residents against non -residents without a very real and data driven need for that policy decision. a. Consider amending the maximum occupancy requirement to place a hard cap on the overall number of people who can be present overnight at a rental property, no matter the number of bedrooms or square footage of the property. b. Considering limiting the number of vehicles which may be parked at a rental unit (e.g. one per bedroom with the guarantee that at least two vehicles be allowed per unit). c. Consider limiting how many days per week or weeks per year a property may be rented. d. Rather than having one type of STR permit, consider establishing multiple “classes” of permits, each with different requirements on when and how often the property could be rented during the year (e.g. peak versus non-peak). Each class would carry different requirements and application fees. e. Consider imposing a minimum length-of-stay, especially in cluster homes, townhomes, and condo properties to reduce the turnover frequency of rental guests. f. Consider implementing an additional 1% Local Accommodations Tax. Although not related to the STR cap issue per se, it would provide an additional revenue stream to offset costs related to serving “visitors” during peak season when both renters and non-residents are adding to the island’s population. 50 g. Consider amending the nuisance provisions of the Town code to regulate noise, trash, bikes, beach equipment, etc. If adopted this would not be an STR regulation, but a general ordinance of the Town that would apply uniformly to all properties. (This option would come with a substantial enforcement cost.) h. Consider, as an alternative to the 20% cap recommended in #1 above, implementing a more refined cap based on the occupancy status of various property classes (e.g. legal residences versus nonlegal residences). See Addendum G for examples of various alternatives for capping the number of STRs in the Town. 51 Section 16 Addendum A The Preserve Seabrook Letter and Petition As Presented to Town Council Dear Neighbors, We are a growing group of neighbors who see Seabrook Island changing and desire to preserve the quality of life that this unique island offers us. While some change is inevitable and necessary to survive and grow, this change is a threat to what makes "our home" a distinctive place to live. Our concerns center on the uncontrolled growth of short-term rentals, especially on streets where there are many full-time and private residential properties. We aim to retain a reasonable offering of properties that can be rented by guests who love to visit and vacation on our beautiful island, while ensuring Seabrook does not gradually morph into a resort community. Data provided by the Town of Seabrook Island shows there are nearly 500 resort properties on Seabrook, with 20% in residential neighborhoods. Many of these have popped up over the last year or so. These properties plus those in regimes are permitted by the Town to have almost 3500 occupants per week, not including small children. In residential areas, the average resort property is approved for 11 occupants, plus underage children. These short-term rentals constitute 31% of all the resort guests. In areas governed by regimes, the average max capacity is 6, plus underaged children. As a means of comparison, according to census estimates, there are about 1900 residents who call Seabrook their home, and there are roughly 2100 members of the Seabrook Island Club. While we realize not all rental properties run at 100% occupancy all the time, we are experiencing an influx of resort guests not only during peak seasons but during off-seasons as well, as exposure of our special island increases through word of mouth, entertainment streaming, and social media. The Town’s new Short-Term Rental (STR) ordinance that took effect this year requires rental properties must be under permit from the Town and also requires adherence to occupancy limits and the advertising of such limits. Today resort properties range in capacity from 4 to 16 guests, plus underage children, depending on bedrooms and building size. We believe adding a cap on the number of resort properties on Seabrook would protect the unique qualities of our island while allowing revenue generated through rental properties to continue to flow back to the Town through state and county accommodation taxes that the renters pay. (Neighboring Kiawah Island adopted a similar ordinance in 2019, which went into effect in 2020, and applied limitations to short-term rental businesses.) We are concerned that the Town’s short-term rental ordinance also undermines the current protections we have in Seabrook’s Zoning Ordinance for Single Family Residential (SFR) Zone which states: 1. To provide for quiet, low-density neighborhoods; 2. To discourage unwarranted encroachment by prohibiting commercial uses and to prohibit other uses which would interfere with the development or continuation of single-family uses; 3. To discourage nonconforming uses; and 4. To discourage uses which would generate traffic on minor streets other than required to serve residences on those streets. 52 We might add, these protections are also at risk by the Town considering eliminating these provisions in the recently proposed changes to the zoning ordinances. To respond to these concerns, a citizen’s petition is gathering signatures that asks the Town to place a single question on the November 2, 2021 ballot. Do voters support: • Affirming the current Single Family Residential zoning protections in any future zoning changes; • Establishing a cap on the maximum number of short-term rental licenses to 5% of developed properties within the residential areas as defined below; however, on the streets in these residential areas having greater than 20 developed properties, there shall be a cap of 5% of all developed properties on each street (included in this area are properties currently zoned Single Family Residential and the following regimes - Hidden Oaks, Marsh Creek, North Beach Village, St. Christopher Oaks, and the Village at Seabrook); • Establishing a maximum 20% licensing cap on the total number of developed lots/properties for the rest of the Town; • Permitting any applicable properties holding a valid short-term rental license to be grandfathered and included in the licensing cap, unless the short-term rental property owner fails to renew his/ her license by the required date or ceases to operate in an area of where the number of short term rentals exceed the caps; • Not issuing new permits in those instances where the licensing cap is exceeded because of grandfathered properties, or for any other reason that keeps the number of short-term rental properties above the cap; • Prohibiting the transfer of short-term rental licenses to the subsequent owner(s) of the property, with the exception that intra-family property transfers can include the transfer of the short-term rental license for that property, provided it is not a sale of the property; and • Affirming neighborhoods, governed by regime covenants, having the authority to establish more restrictive caps or to prohibit short-term rentals in their regimes (the current regimes in this category include Haulover Point and Marsh Point)? These proposals, if approved by voters and implemented by the town, would impose NO ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS on owners of short-term rentals. Furthermore, 20% of the properties in Seabrook are currently short-term rentals, and 20% will remain so if the Town Council approves the cap. We are simply asking to halt the growth of short-term rentals in your neighborhood and across Seabrook, and restore the balance between those of us who reside in our homes and those who operate a business by renting their properties over a period of years. Dissenting voices will claim that a cap on short-term rentals will cause property values to fall and will hurt the finances of the Town, the Club, and SIPOA. Besides having no evidence to support these claims, simply consider the areas of Kiawah, Mt. Pleasant, Isle of Palms, and many other communities which have enacted caps and are seeing record real estate sales and rising values AFTER enactment. Put another way, if the future value of our homes or the financial viability of the Town, The Club, and SIPOA hinges on having more short-term rental properties next to our homes, we are at risk of seeing our community forever changed. We need your help NOW! There are three things you can do to help preserve the uniqueness of Seabrook Island: 1. If you are a Seabrook Island property owner, sign the petition asking the Town to put the matter on the ballot and search "Preserve Seabrook: It’s Our Home" to locate the online petition. 2. Attend the Town Council meeting on September 28th on Zoom and express your support for the request. 3. When this proposal gains the approval of the Mayor and Council and is placed on the November ballot, registered voters should vote in FAVOR advising the Mayor and Council what we want them to do for Seabrook. 53 If you have any questions or suggestions, please send an email to preserveseabrook@gmail.com. We promise a quick and thoughtful response. Thank you in advance for your support of this ballot initiative. Sincerely, Paul & Susan McLaughlin Lisa Duckworth Vince & Sharon Schiavoni Joe Berttucci Deb Lehman Ted Flerlage Terry Little And many others.... 54 Addendum B Preserve Seabrook Petition Signers Once the petition was officially submitted to Council, these names became part of the public record: Name Address Marianna J. Price 1009 Embassy Row Way Derek Fyfe 1014 Embassy Row Way Dean Goodwin 1110 Heather Island Lane Sherri Goodwin 1110 Heather Island Lane Elizabeth R. Zahrn 1116 Summerwind Lane Debra K. Lehman 1127 Summerwind Lane Jay I. Lehman Jr. 1127 Summerwind Lane Patricia Knowles 1140 Turtle Watch Lane Susan Ferland 1188 Oyster Catcher Court Helene DeCandia 1242 Creek Watch Villas Stephen DeCandia 1242 Creek Watch Villas James R. Sporn 1404 Nancy Island Drive Monique B. Sporn 1404 Nancy Island Drive Donna Lefevre 1408 Nancy Island Drive Robert Lefevre 1408 Nancy Island Drive Robin Aaron 1500 Lady Anna Court Ian Millar 1508 Lady Anna Lane Joy Millar 1508 Lady Anna Lane Cindy Mulligan 1735 Live Oak Park Donna J. Miller 1736 Live Oak Park Linda Ligenza 1809 Landfall Way J.G. Saver 2032 Sterling Marsh Lane Constantine Constandis 2060 Sterling Marsh Dr Anne Upton-Constandis 2060 Sterling Marsh Lane Brian Kirchoff 2107 Landfall Way Tracey Kirchoff 2107 Landfall Way Douglas Hurd 2116 Loblolly Lane Lee Hurd 2116 Loblolly Lane Gary Kunkelman 2116 Royal Pine Drive Katherine Kunkelman 2116 Royal Pine Drive Tiffany Lyn Thompson 2121 Royal Pine Drive Robert Oltmanns 2135 Landfall Way LTR Spencer Clary 2138 Landfall Way Caroline Leonard 2139 Landfall Way Holly Loving 2259 Seabrook Island Road James Mark Loving 2259 Seabrook Island Road 55 Roger Steel 2290 Marsh Hen Drive Vivian Steel 2290 Marsh Hen Drive Linda Benyo 2339 Andell Way Alan Bernstein 2340 Marsh Hen Drive Jeffrey Pompe 2348 Andell Way Kathleen Pompe 2348 Andell Way Dee Colquitt 2356 Andell Way Julian Colquitt 2356 Andell Way Delbert R. Kahn 2375 Seabrook Island Road Kathleen A. Kahn 2375 Seabrook Island Road Joseph Berttucci 2381 Golf Oak Park Ronnell T. Berttucci 2381 Golf Oak Park Lynne Richards 2400 Cat Tail Pond Ernest L. Johnson 2415 Andell Way Joan Johnson 2415 Andell Way Kristine Wilson 2418 Racquet Club Drive Glen Cox 2420 Cat Tail Pond Karin King 2420 Cat Tail Pond Linwood Metts 2435 Bateau Trace Lure Lea Metts 2435 Bateau Trace Joanne Lewis 2440 Cat Tail Pond Road Ann Demetruk 2460 The Haul Over David Demetruk 2460 The Haul Over Carol Price 2500 Clear Marsh Road Michael Price 2500 Clear Marsh Road Dieter H. Lantin 2535 Seabrook Island Road Heidi Lantin 2535 Seabrook Island Road Martha Penkhus 2556 Clear Marsh Road Stephen Penkhus 2556 Clear Marsh Road Elizabeth A. Lagana 2605 Jenkins Point Road John E. Lagana 2605 Jenkins Point Road Jeffrey Fenton 2637 Persimmon Pond Ct Patricia Linton 2637 Persimmon Pond Ct Betty Maher 2670 Gnarled Pine John Maher 2670 Gnarled Pine Judith Bennett 2711 Old Forest Drive Midge Fleming 2787 Little Creek Road Melissa Shawver 2792 Little Creek Road Charles K. Septer 2811 Old Drake Drive Rose C. Septer 2811 Old Drake Drive Mary Ellen Kyle 2836 Old Drake Drive 56 Thomas Rogers Kyle 2836 Old Drake Drive Cathy McWilliams 2841 Captain Sams Road Thomas McWilliams 2841 Captain Sams Road Diane Woychick 2864 Captain Sams Road Aldrich L. Boss 2868 Captain Sams Road Ann-Stewart C. Boss 2868 Captain Sams Road John Dewey 2923 Baywood Drive LTR Sarah Dewey 2923 Baywood Drive LTR Mark Andrews 2929 Baywood Drive Melissa Andrews 2929 Baywood Drive Joan Kearney 2938 Deer Point Drive Andrew Ogden 2941 Seabrook Island Road Johanna B. Tuleikis 2941 Seabrook Island Road Laurey H. Harrell 2946 Seabrook Island Road Wade E. Harrell 2946 Seabrook Island Road Steven Sutton 2948 Seabrook Island Road Susan Tory Kindley 2958 Seabrook Island Road Lawrence Holditch 2959 Baywood Drive Rebecca Holditch 2959 Baywood Drive Brenda L. White 2962 Captain Sams Road Herb White 2962 Captain Sams Road Ron Welch 2975 Seabrook Island Road Barry Hand 2993 Seabrook Island Road Clarkson McLean 3009 Rascal Run Court Richard Agresta 3021 Hidden Oak Drive Victoria E. Agresta 3021 Hidden Oak Drive Nancy Sanchez 3024 Seabrook Village Drive Ray Sanchez 3024 Seabrook Village Drive John Ellsworth 3025 Seabrook Village Drive Kelly Ellsworth 3025 Seabrook Village Drive John F. Bisceglia 3028 Seabrook Village Drive Patricia Bisceglia 3028 Seabrook Village Drive Christopher Ryan 3032 High Hammock Road Sherry Vincent 3032 Marsh Haven Lee L. Weber 3036 Marsh Haven Thomas Stanek 3043 Marsh Gate Drive Margie Ann Jones 3051 Marsh Gate Drive Paul D. McLaughlin 3061 Baywood Drive Susan R. McLaughlin 3061 Baywood Drive Elizabeth M. Flerlage 3062 Baywood Drive Theodore Martin Flerlage Jr. 3062 Baywood Drive 57 James Dobson 3064 Marsh Gate Drive Karen Ann Rowland 3068 Baywood Drive Michael Rowland 3068 Baywood Drive Cindy Guyton 3071 Seabrook Island Road Donald B. Guyton 3071 Seabrook Island Road Denise Kotva 3092 Baywood Drive Gary Kotva 3092 Baywood Drive Holly Berry 3108 Marsh Gate Drive Steven Berry 3108 Marsh Gate Drive Margaret Wildermann 3138 Privateer Creek Road Richard Wildermann 3138 Privateer Creek Road Diane Harvey 3143 Baywood Drive Barbara Montagu-Pollock 3150 Privateer Creek Road Stephen Montagu-Pollock 3150 Privateer Creek Road Pat Robbins 3168 Privateer Creek Road Joel Kirk Pondelik 3190 Pine Needle Lane Nancy Lynn Pondelik 3190 Pine Needle Lane Amber Berry 3201 Privateer Creek Road Beth Ann Wright 3210 Privateer Creek Road Bryan P. Wright 3210 Privateer Creek Road Ruth Ann Henderer 3221 Privateer Creek Road Willard E. Henderer 3221 Privateer Creek Road Deborah A. Rice 3227 Middle Dam Court Debbie Mott 3238 Middle Dam Court Karen Stout 3238 Middle Dam Court Jo Merril 3306 The Lookout Gordon Weis 3365 Coon Hollow Drive James W. Newton 3552 Seaview Drive Sally Newton 3552 Seaview Drive Alan Weiss 3635 Pompano Court Diane Weiss 3635 Pompano Court Conrad Kottak 3742 Amberjack Court Isabel Kottak 3742 Amberjack Court Joseph Berttucci 2381 Golf Oak Park *Duplicate Ronnell T. Berttucci 2381 Golf Oak Park *Duplicate Elizabeth Lagana 2605 Jenkins Point Road *Duplicate John Lagana 2605 Jenkins Point Road *Duplicate Sharon Mack 3053 Seabrook Island Road *Invalid Address Beth Ann Wright 3210 Privateer Creek Road *Duplicate Brian Paul Wright 3210 Privateer Creek Road *Duplicate 58 Addendum C Petition Opposition Once a comment is posted to the Town’s website comment portal or emails are sent to Town Council, they become part of the public record. As mentioned in Section 1, the Committee did not include (or count) comments from anyone asking to remain anonymous. Patrick Aiello Anne and Cal Aycock Joseph C. Baril Tim Beatty Peter Bogert Jill and Bill Boissonnault Vicki and Andy Boukydis Liza Boyajian Kristen and Paul Brennan Nancy and Randy Buck Rachel Burt and Daniel Loventhal Mary Cardello Sarah and Paul Cassidy Heather and Joe Compton Linda and Barney Cornaby Jim Cowan Mari Kay Dobbins Wendy Donaghue Kyle Dufresne Terri and James Edmiston Kathleen and Chris Ennis Peggy Small Fox Steffen Frey Jill and Marc Friedfertig Kathy Fulton and Bill Coppell Laura Goepfert Helen and Peter Golden Teresa Grace Mary Gwyn Virginia Hayes Maureen Healy Kristi and Steve Hesse Patricia and Phil Hite Gwen and Chris Imprey Mary Jacques Jeanna and Frank Kaulakis Jill and Dennis Karem Terri and Eric Kempthorn James Lagos Terrence L. Little Mary Ann Lloyd Paola and Casey Long Amber Lynch Gerald L. Lynch John Lyons Jennifer and Rod Macdonald Karen and Rob McPherson Andy Malinofsky Gale Marsiglia Dr. and Mrs. William Marsteller Andrea and Dan Milgate Deanna Mendenhall-Miller and Norman Miller Cherry and Scott McGovern Randy Montgomery Carole Moore Terri Murphy Francine Meyer Pam Nelson and Milum Livesay Derek Oatway Mollie O’Connor Kem O’Sullivan Kerry Palmer David Paschkes Dorothy and John Pensabene Mark Razzano John Regan Lucy and Azim Sarka Janey and Steve Sarniak William Sax Mandy Schlender Michelle Scollins Max Sherman Wendy and Kris Sirchio Jackie and Paul Smith Julie and Michael Sowa Ann and Mike Staed Melanie and Morry Steinbach Robyn and Rick Stickles David Sweet Jay Tannon Jack Teitsma Cherie Tibbetts Lisa G. Trimberger Joy and Kyle Tucci Greta Vaughan Erin Verneris Lisa Vellieux and Steve Karp Salvador and Lupe Villanueva Diane and Roy T. Widdus Brian Wood Catherine and Jay Yeomans David Zimmerman 59 Addendum D Residential Zoning In addition to the chart below, it may be helpful to view the map of the Town with the zoning districts marked. That map (pending final approval under the new Development Standards Ordinance now before Council) can be viewed on the Town’s website. Zoning Transition Chart 60 Addendum E Papers Presented to the Committee by the Petitioners The Petitioners presented the Committee with two studies that they promote as “facts” validating their claims that short-term rentals are ruining the nature of Seabrook Island, lowering property values, and destroying quality of life. Contrary to the charges made publicly and repeatedly by the Petitioners about the Committee, these reports were not simply dismissed. To the contrary, they have been read and reread, an author contacted, and their applicability to the Town of Seabrook Island studied and discussed. While the Petitioners have pulled sentences out of these reports to “make their case,” the Committee looked at the reports in whole and chose not to pull sentences or phrases out of context. Paper I The economic costs and benefits of Airbnb No reason for local policymakers to let Airbnb bypass tax or regulatory obligations Report by Josh Bivens, January 30, 2019 Economic Policy Institute, Washington, DC Summary: Analysis shows that the costs of Airbnb expansion to renters and local jurisdictions likely exceed the benefits to travelers and property owners. Thus there is no reason policymakers should reverse long-standing regulatory decisions simply to accommodate the rise of a single company. First, the Committee notes that this paper was published pre-COVID-19 and, thus, includes no analysis of whether the significant disruption the pandemic caused in economies would change its theories and conclusions. Dr. Bivens’ paper is introduced with a reference to internet-based service firms (IBSFs) and the heated debate on whether they are good for the overall economy. His paper aims to add to the debate by testing theories about their costs and benefits. “Specifically, it assesses the potential economic costs and benefits of the expansion of one of the most well-known of the IBSFs: the rental business Airbnb.” The paper discusses the displacement of hotel jobs (job quantity and quality suffer), as a cost of Airbnbs. But other than the boutique hotel (Andell Inn at Freshfields), the nearest hotel (Sanctuary Resort) is nearly 20 miles away. Seabrook Island STRs actually create jobs and sustain a local rental management industry, including Coastal Getaways, whose owners live within the Town and invest in the community. Further, the paper considers whether the presence of Airbnb STRs raises housing costs, particularly by displacing long-term rentals for lower-wage workers, but that is not an issue applicable to Seabrook Island. The Committee was offered no evidence of any long-term rentals on the island being displaced directly by the short-term market. Right or wrong, the long-term rental price point on the island historically has not been conducive to attract hourly and lower- wage workers. There are no apartment buildings against which Airbnb STRs compete (and 61 apartment buildings and mobile homes as referenced in the paper have never been allowed within the security gate under the Town’s zoning ordinance so are not going to drop into an island neighborhood now). As for STRs lowering property values, the boom in real estate sales over the last two years, with prices nearly doubling in some of the most heavily STR populated regimes, indicates any actual or perceived rental activity is not driving down sales or property values. And the paper’s concern about special tax and zoning treatment being extended to Airbnbs is not applicable. No STR, no matter through what means or platform the rental is arranged, has been or is allowed to avoid the Town’s zoning laws, disregard the business license and rental permit requirements, or avoid paying the county and state sales and accommodation taxes. The Committee reviewed the cost-benefit findings from the paper’s analysis and found only one that could be applicable to rental activity in the Town of Seabrook Island. The highlighted sentence is that used by the Petitioners, and it is printed here in the context of the entire paragraph. A further potential cost is the externalities that property rentals (of all kinds) impose on neighbors, for example, noise and/or use of building facilities. Since hosts are often not on-site with their renters, they do not bear the costs of these externalities and hence may not factor them into rental decisions. Of course, one could argue that such externalities are also incurred with long-term rentals not arranged through Airbnb. But if the expansion of Airbnb increases total short- and long-term rental activity, or if short-term rentals impose larger externalities than long-term rentals, then Airbnb expansion can increase these externalities. The Committee notes that this reference to “externalities” are addressed in both the Town’s STR ordinance and SIPOA’s rules. It is another discussion about whether, how, and to what extent rules are being effectively enforced, but the Committee found intent from both the Town and SIPOA to reduce impacts on neighboring properties of any problem rentals/renters. It is acknowledged that there have been (and could be) at times problems at rental properties, but if the reporting records are at all telling, those problems have been few and associated with a limited number of rental properties. And contrary to the assumption from the Dr. Bivens’ paper, owners do “bear the costs” of “externalities” as under the Town’s ordinance they are liable. (Ord. No. 2020-14) And finally, the Committee notes that only using Airbnb as a standard for evaluating the impact of rental activity on Seabrook Island as the Petitioners do by citing this paper (and also by claiming via posts in social media that Airbnb record profits indicate out-of-control STRs in Seabrook), ignores how our local properties are managed and rented. Owners who have elected to put their property on the short-term rental market (even for one night during the year) do so through various companies, both online and local, and some list on multiple sites. And, unlike any reference in Dr. Bivens’ paper, all rentals on the island, even those booked through Airbnb, must have a local contact, be it the property owner or a designated person or 62 agent, who must reside within fifty (50) miles of the rental property and be available to respond within two (2) hours of receiving notification of an emergency, alleged violation, or inspection request. The chart that follows is the end-of-year 2021 snapshot of the “Designated Agents” and number of properties managed (out of 521 total licenses). Four companies were managing a total of 369 STRs in the town. This represents 70.8% of all permitted STRs, and 93.2% of STRs with a Management Co. Many of those properties were advertised on Airbnb, but the IBSF was not dominating or controlling the rental activity. Year-end 2021 review of property management: Name # % Akers Ellis Rentals 1 0.2% Bhani Maker Simon 2 0.4% Coastal Getaways 214 41.1% Dunescrest Properties LLC 1 0.2% ESPM Vacation Rentals 1 0.2% Gamble Home Services 2 0.4% Heather Byrd 1 0.2% iTrip Vacations Charleston 1 0.2% Kiawah by Owner 1 0.2% MS Services 1 0.2% Reliable Property Managers 1 0.2% Sandpiper Management 7 1.3% Sea Oats Vacation Property Management 2 0.4% Seabrook Exclusives 79 15.2% Seabrook Property Managers 3 0.6% Sweetgrass Properties 18 3.5% TurnKey Vacation Rentals 3 0.6% Vacasa South Carolina LLC 58 11.1% No Agent 125 24.0% Total 521 100.0% And finally, while tte Petitioners have cited this article on multiple occasions to show a conclusive negative relationship between short-term rentals and local real estate values. The committee notes that several of the studies referenced in this article found the exact opposite to be true: • Merante and Horn (2016): ‘…each 12 Airbnb listings per census tract leads to an increase in asking rents of 0.4 percent.’ • Barron, Kung, and Proserpio (2018): ‘…a 10 percent increase in Airbnb listings in a ZIP code leads to a 0.42 percent increase in ZIP code rental prices and a 0.76 percent increase in house prices.’ 63 • Sheppard and Udell (2018): ‘…a doubling of Airbnb activity within a tight geographic zone surrounding a home sale is associated with a 6 to 11 percent increase in sales prices.’ • Wachsmuth et al. (2018): ‘…a 1.4 percent increase in NYC rents from 2015 to 2017 due to Airbnb’s expansion in that city.’ 64 Paper II Submitted to the Committee by the Petitioners: Not In My Neighborhood: The Effects of Residential Rentals on Single-Family Home Values Keith Ihlanfeldt Department of Economics and Devoe Morre Center Florida State University May 2019 Abstract: Single-family homeowners have long expressed a distaste for residential rentals in their neighborhood based on a belief that rentals will adversely affect neighborhood quality and lower house values. Prior study on this issue is thin and has not been able to establish causality from correlation. In this paper, I utilize a twelve-year panel of neighborhoods from the Miami, Florida metropolitan area to study the impacts that four different types of rentals have on the values of single-family homes. Causality is more firmly established in comparison to previous research by estimating house value models that include time and neighborhood fixed effects and that treat the rentals as endogenous variables. My results show that, regardless of the type of rental, adding an additional rental unit to the neighborhood or increasing its neighborhood share at the expense of single-family owner-occupied homes, lowers home values, especially if the rental unit is of lower quality. Once again for this report to Council, the Committee notes that this study was published in May 2019, pre-COVID19, and thus takes no account of the economic impact of the pandemic in the paper’s equations, indexes, logarithms, housing variables, etc. used to evaluate rental impacts on home values (referenced as the Housing Price Index or HPI in the study). The Petitioners presented the study with highlighted sentences (as they did with the first study), so again the Committee must point out that these sentences are used in their STR discussion out of context of the overall study. For example, the highlighted sentence (as per the Petitioners’ submission) below included in context, references a study done in Texas in 1984-86, for which the Committee questions the applicability to Seabrook Island 30-plus years later. Wang et. al. (199) provided the first evidence on the impact of the SF rentals on the value of SF home values. Their sales transactions came from SF home subdivisions in San Antonio, Texas, covering the years 1984-1986. They measured proximity to SF rentals as the percentage of rentals among the closest five and eight homes They found that if a house is surrounded by two rental properties out of the closest five houses or three rentals out of the closes eights houses the selling price would decrease by 2 percent, ceteris paribus. Further the Committee notes this study focused on limited tracts/neighborhoods in the Miami metropolitan area, using Florida property tax reports, home-sales data, and other base variables that date back to 2002 and before. The Committee found no correlation in the neighborhoods described in Miami to Seabrook Island nor to 2020-2022 real estate sales and rental activity on the island. The study looks at rentals in general, including properties that are classified as apartments, condominiums, mobile homes, or single-family. That is the reference in the abstract (regardless of the type of rental). It is not a study of short-term rentals. The study discusses the impact those different types of rental properties have when encroaching on single-family neighborhoods. 65 Since the Town’s zoning does not allow such encroachment, the study fails to correlate to rental activity on the island and property values. The study includes a strong focus on the impact rentals may have on crime, and in turn property values, but crime is not an issue in this context on Seabrook Island. And the study suggests that indicators show that maintenance (and lower quality properties) are influencing property values not necessarily the presence of rentals. So again, the Committee did not find the study applicable to its review of issues on Seabrook Island. Notwithstanding that overall the Committee found the information in this study to be extraneous to its research, nor does the Committee want to repeat the error of lifting sentences out of context, the Committee does note these sentences in the conclusions that the Petitioners did not highlight or share: The hope is to find the source of the negative spillover effects produced by rental housing and reduce or eliminate them with appropriate interventions that do not exclude rentals from SF neighborhoods. In previous research we have found that rentals help integrate neighborhoods both racially and socially; hence they should remain a housing option within most neighborhoods. 66 Addendum F STR Maps The Active STR Permits (April 30, 2022) map on the next page shows all the active STR permits as of April 30, 2022, which was the end of the 2021 permitting year. Each property that had an active permit on that date is indicated with a green dot. The second map, Unique STR Permits (2021), shows all the unique properties that had an STR permit at some point during the 2021 license year. Each property is color coded based on its status as of April 30, 2022. If the property had an active permit as of that date, it will have a green dot. If the permit was cancelled prior to then and was no longer active, it will have an orange dot. If the permit was revoked prior to then and was no longer active, it will have a red dot. (See definitions of the above terminology on page 22.) These maps indicate that the STRs were highly concentrated town-wide in the multi-family areas. In the single-family districts and most STRs were located in close proximity to the beach. 67 68 69 Addendum G Policy Options for Possible Future Consideration by Council Presented to the Committee by Town Staff STR Policy Option #1: No Cap as per the current STR ordinance Zoning District General Provisions Single-Family Residential (R-SF1, R-SF2 & R-SF3) No cap: no limit on number of days the unit may be rented; legal residence may retain 4% assessment if the unit is rented no more than 72 days per year per S.C. Law Other Residential (R-CL, R-TH, R-MF & MU) No cap: no limit on number of days the unit may be rented; legal residence may retain 4% assessment if the unit is rented no more than 72 days per year per S.C. Law Maximum STRs Allowed Per Policy Zoning District Total (All Types) Single-Family Residential (R-SF1, R-SF2 & R-SF3) 1,151 (100.0%) Other Residential (R-CL, R-TH, R-MF & MU) 1,171 (100.0%) Total (All Districts) 2,322 (100.0%) Actual STRs Permitted (2021) Zoning District Total (All Types) Single-Family Residential (R-SF1, R-SF2 & R-SF3) 129 (11.2%) Other Residential (R-CL, R-TH, R-MF & MU) 390 (33.3%) Total (All Districts) 519 (22.4%) 70 Policy Option #2: As Proposed by the Preserve Seabrook Petition Cap All Single-Family at 5% & Multi- Family Units at 20% Zoning District General Provisions Single-Family Residential (R-SF1, R-SF2 & R-SF3) Capped at 5% of developed lots; no limit on number of days the unit may be rented; legal residence may retain 4% assessment if the unit is rented no more than 72 days per year per S.C. Law Other Residential (R-CL, R-TH, R-MF & MU) Capped at 20% of developed lots; no limit on number of days the unit may be rented; legal residence may retain 4% assessment if the unit is rented no more than 72 days per year per S.C. Law Maximum STRs Allowed Per Policy Zoning District Total (All Types) Single-Family Residential (R-SF1, R-SF2 & R-SF3) 1,151 (100.0%) 57 (5.0%) Other Residential (R-CL, R-TH, R-MF & MU) 1,171 (100.0%) 234 (20.0%) Total (All Districts) 2,322 (100.0%) 291 (12.5%) Actual STRs Permitted (2021) Zoning District Total (All Types) Single-Family Residential (R-SF1, R-SF2 & R-SF3) 129 (11.2%) Other Residential (R-CL, R-TH, R-MF & MU) 390 (33.3%) Total (All Districts) 519 (22.4%) 71 Policy Option #3: As recommended by the Committee (Section 15), Cap all single-family units at 20% (as does the Town of Kiawah Island) Zoning District General Provisions Single-Family Residential (R-SF1, R-SF2 & R-SF3) Capped at 20% of developed lots; no limit on number of days the unit may be rented; legal residence may retain 4% assessment if the unit is rented no more than 72 days per year per S.C. Law Other Residential (R-CL, R-TH, R-MF & MU) No cap, no limit on number of days the unit may be rented; legal residence may retain 4% assessment if the unit is rented no more than 72 days per year per S.C. Law Maximum STRs Allowed Per Policy Zoning District Total (All Types) Single-Family Residential (R-SF1, R-SF2 & R-SF3) 1,151 (100.0%) 230 (20.0%) Other Residential (R-CL, R-TH, R-MF & MU) 1,171 (100.0%) Total (All Districts) 2,322 (100.0%) 1,401 (60.3%) Actual STRs Permitted (2021) Zoning District Total (All Types) Single-Family Residential (R-SF1, R-SF2 & R-SF3) 129 (11.2%) Other Residential (R-CL, R-TH, R-MF & MU) 390 (33.3%) Total (All Districts) 519 (22.4%) 72 Policy Option #4: Cap Non-Legal Residence Single-Family Units at 30% Zoning District Legal Residence (4%) Non-Legal Residence (6%) Single-Family Residential (R-SF1, R-SF2 & R-SF3) No cap, units may not be rented more than 72 days per year Capped at 30% of developed lots; no limit on number of days the unit may be rented Other Residential (R-CL, R-TH, R-MF & MU) No cap, units may not be rented more than 72 days per year No cap, no limit on number of days the unit may be rented Maximum STRs Allowed Per Policy Zoning District Legal Residence (4%) Non-Legal Residence (6%) Total (All Types) Single-Family Residential (R-SF1, R-SF2 & R-SF3) 635 (100.0%) *Max. 72 days 516 (100.0%) 154 (30.0%) 1,151 (100%) 789 (68.5%) Other Residential (R-CL, R-TH, R-MF & MU) 256 (100.0%) *Max. 72 days 915 (100.0%) 1,171 (100.0%) Total Residential (All Districts) 891 (100.0%) *Max. 72 days 1,431 (100.0%) 1,069 (74.7%) 2,322 (100%) 1,960 (84.4%) Actual STRs Permitted (2021) Zoning District Legal Residence (4%) Non-Legal Residence (6%) Total (All Types) Single-Family Residential (R-SF1, R-SF2 & R-SF3) 19 (3.0%) 110 (21.3%) 129 (11.2%) Other Residential (R-CL, R-TH, R-MF & MU) 17 (6.6%) 373 (40.8%) 390 (33.3%) Total Residential (All Districts) 36 (4.0%) 483 (33.8%) 519 (22.4%) 73 Policy Option #5: Cap Non-Resident Single-Family Units at 30% and Non-Resident Multi-Family Units at 50% Zoning District Legal Residence (4%) Non-Legal Residence (6%) Single-Family Residential (R-SF1, R-SF2 & R-SF3) No cap, units may not be rented more than 72 days per year Capped at 30% of developed lots; no limit on number of days the unit may be rented Other Residential (R-CL, R-TH, R-MF & MU) No cap, units may not be rented more than 72 days per year Capped at 50% of developed units; no limit on number of days the unit may be rented Maximum Allowed Per Policy Zoning District Legal Residence (4%) Non-Legal Residence (6%) Total (All Types) Single-Family Residential (R-SF1, R-SF2 & R-SF3) 635 (100.0%) *Max. 72 days 516 (100.0%) 154 (30.0%) 1,151 (100%) 789 (68.5%) Other Residential (R-CL, R-TH, R-MF & MU) 256 (100.0%) *Max. 72 days 915 (100.0%) 457 (50.0%) 1,171 (100.0%) 713 (60.9%) Total Residential (All Districts) 891 (100.0%) *Max. 72 days 1,431 (100.0%) 611 (42.7%) 2,322 (100%) 1,502 (64.7%) Actual Permitted (2021) Zoning District Legal Residence (4%) Non-Legal Residence (6%) Total (All Types) Single-Family Residential (R-SF1, R-SF2 & R-SF3) 19 (3.0%) 110 (21.3%) 129 (11.2%) Other Residential (R-CL, R-TH, R-MF & MU) 17 (6.6%) 373 (40.8%) 390 (33.3%) Total Residential (All Districts) 36 (4.0%) 483 (33.8%) 519 (22.4%) 74 Policy Options #5 & #6 Unlike a “hard cap” on residential units, tying the number of allowable STRs to the number of properties that are non-legal residences (6%) allows the cap to move up or down each year based on existing conditions. For example, if the percentage of legal residences increases over time, the maximum number of allowable STR permits would decrease proportionate to the decrease in the number of non-legal residences (subject to grandfathering provisions for existing STRs in excess of the cap). In short, if single-family areas transition to more full-time residences, the number of allowable STRs would go down. If the number of full-time residences goes down, the number of allowable STRs would go up. Current  Legal Residency Rate 45% 46% 47% 48% 49% 50% 51% 52% 53% 54% 55% 56% 57% 58% 59% 60% 61% 62% 63% 64% 65% Legal Residences (4%) 518 530 541 553 564 576 588 599 611 622 635 645 657 668 680 691 703 714 726 737 749 Non-Legal Residences (6%) 633 621 610 598 587 575 563 552 540 529 516 506 494 483 471 460 448 437 425 414 402 30% Cap on 6% Properties 189 186 183 179 176 172 168 165 162 158 154 151 148 144 141 138 134 131 127 124 120

Source: Town of Seabrook Island website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.