Minutes
City of Greenwood · Greenwood County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Greenwood
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
GREENWOOD CITY COUNCIL
January 22, 2024 – 5:32 p.m.
MINUTES
PRESENT
Council Members: Mayor Brandon Smith, Niki Hutto, Robert
Dean, Betty Boles, Johnathan Bass, and Ronnie Ables;
Assistant City Managers Ryan Thomas & Draper Carlile,
Clerk Tiffany L. Albert, Police Chief TJ Chaudoin, and
Attorney Tripp Padgett.
Councilor Matthew Miller was present by telephone.
City Manager Julia Wilkie was present remotely.
CALL TO ORDER Mayor Brandon Smith called the meeting to order at 5:32
p.m.
Bishop Oliver T. McCray gave the invocation.
STATEMENT AND
QUORUM
After the Pledge of Allegiance, Mayor Smith read the
following statement, “In accordance with the Freedom of
Information Act, Chapter 4, Title 30, Code of Laws of
South Carolina, 1976, an agenda has been posted on the
front door of City Hall and notification of this meeting
has been given to the news media.”
City Clerk Tiffany L. Albert, CAP-OM, confirmed a quorum
was present.
APPROVAL OF
CONSENT AGENDA
A motion to approve the consent agenda was made by Betty
Boles, seconded by Ronnie Ables.
There was no further discussion from Council.
The motion passed unanimously.
Assistant City Manager Draper Carlile asked Council to
amend the agenda to move New Business Item #2 before the
Public Hearing portion of their meeting.
Minutes - City Council -2- January 22, 2024 5:32 p.m.
A motion to amend the agenda to move New Business Item
#2 before the Public Hearing portion of the meeting was
made by Betty Boles, seconded by Robert Dean.
There was no discussion from Council.
The motion passed unanimously.
CONSIDER
Reappointment of
Annette Edwards,
Bishop Oliver
McCray, and
Marchelle
Tompkins-Bryant
to the
City/County
Board of Zoning
Appeals.
Assistant City Manager Carlile informed Council that
City/County Board of Zoning Appeals members Annette
Edwards (appointed in August 2019), Marchelle Tompkins-
Bryant (appointed in March 20 15), and Bishop McCray
(appointed in February 2023), had consented to serve
another term.
A motion to reappoint Annette Edwards, Bishop Oliver
McCray, and Marchelle Tompkins-Bryant to the City/County
Board of Zoning Appeals was made by Betty Boles, seconded
by Robert Dean.
There was no discussion from Council.
The motion passed unanimously.
After City Clerk Tiffany L. Albert, CAP-OM, administered
the Oath of Office to City/County Board of Zoning Appeals
members, Mayor Smith recused himself from the meeting
and exited Council Chambers at 5:42 p.m.
Mayor Pro Tempore Betty Boles presided over the next
agenda item.
Minutes - City Council -3- January 22, 2024 5:32 p.m.
CONSIDER
Ordinance No.
23-015 Amending
the City of
Greenwood’s
Official Zoning
Map (Ordinance
No. 04-020) by
Rezoning
Approximately
31.59 Acres of
Land Located at
227 Marshall
Road from R1
(Single Family
Residential-Low
Density) to MPR
(Master Plan
Residential).
(2
nd reading)
Under Public Hearings, Assistant City Manager Carlile
reviewed the proposed rezoning of 227 Marshall Road from
R1 to MPR. He opined Council should approve this request,
if they believed it met the Comprehensive Plan’s goals
& strategies and the MPR Ordinance, or vote to deny it
if they felt otherwise.
Those who spoke in opposition were:
Abney Wallace of 523 East Creswell Avenue who stated
that there were already too many high-density
development approvals in Greenwood and this proposed
development does not blend with area neighborhoods. He
asked Council to step back, slow down, do the right
thing, and vote no.
Tonya Foggie of 452 Wade Avenue agreed with what Mr.
Wallace stated and noted everything was cut down next to
her backyard. She stated that traffic was already backed
up and there was no need for another high-density area
near her neighborhood.
Kathy Nave Felder of 606 Brooklane Drive read MPR
stipulations and noted this proposed development did not
meet any of them. Assistant City Managers Carlile and
Ryan Thomas noted that the criteria she read were
repealed from the Zoning Ordinance when it was modified
in September 2022.
Ken McCoy of 561 East Creswell Avenue stated the traffic
study should be null and void for this MPR development
because it was not done for the only point of access on
New Market Street. He noted that some Planning
Commission members were confused as to what they were
voting for, versus what was being said, during their
meetings. Mr. McCoy also stated the style of homes did
not fit the character of his neighborhood and the
manufacturer of those types of homes had been sued for
building defects.
Dewanda Sales of 212 Hardwood Loop stated that adding
more homes will not grow Greenwood but just bring more
people; however, she liked G reenwood because of the
slower pace.
Elizabeth Bowman of 400 East Creswell Avenue noted that
Wade Heights is a historic neighborhood, and 74 units on
20 acres is excessive.
Minutes - City Council -4- January 22, 2024 5:32 p.m.
Josh Bowser of 615 New Market Street showed a
presentation of how the MPR zoning did not include
affordable infill projects that are compatible with the
neighborhood’s character, nor did this proposed
development replicate front yard setbacks of existing
development areas.
Those who spoke in favor of the rezoning were:
Paul Harrison, with Blue Water Civil Design, represented
the developer. After distributing supporting handouts to
Council, he acknowledged there was a significant amount
of preserved tree canopy on the west side of the property
and some mature trees that were kept on the northern
border of the development. He noted the proposed MPR
density was 2.34 units per acre, which was less than the
R4 Medium Density that is adjacent to the site. Mr.
Harrison also noted that maximizing the most viable
properties will add value to residents in this and other
surrounding communities.
Jay Self of 3001 Scotts Fery Road in Troy, SC, who owns
the timber company that cleared the land, represented
the landowner. He informed Council of his intent to
replant trees, in the normal timber business cycle, if
this tract is not sold.
City/County Planning Director Carol Coleman clarified
the difference between gross and net density. She noted
that there were only two protected historic
neighborhoods in Greenwood right now and asked Wade
Heights residents to volunteer towards that designation
during the comprehensive plan rewrite next year. She
also noted that clustering would leave more open space
in the MPR zoning designation and, if approved, she would
recommend the buffer requirement to include 3-inch
diameter caliper trees.
Ms. Coleman added that no one on the Planning Commission
asked to see the site plan again, nor thought that
application should be returned for further
consideration; however, they could review the
application again, if Council deferred their vote to
send it back. Every single Comprehensive Plan, going
back from the 1990s, designated that area as High Density
Residential and all Planning Commission public hearings
were accessible and advertised.
Minutes - City Council -5- January 22, 2024 5:32 p.m.
She answered the following questions from Council:
Councilor Johnathan Bass: This development did meet the
revised MPR ordinance and Comprehensive Plan as a guide.
If this proposed MPR rezoning passes, a preliminary and
final plat that would include input from engineering,
public works, utilities, and the school district must be
approved by staff. The Marshall Road access was
eliminated, because of concern for Kirksey Forrest
entrances, and deferred access to New Market Street. A
second point of access was preferred, but the only other
access will be used for emergencies.
Councilor Niki Hutto: If there were any design
standards, she would have felt more comfortable
requiring border homes be primarily brick, or stone, to
make it more contiguous to existing neighborhoods. And,
as you get into the development, homes could transition
to a more affordable component with siding.
Councilor Betty Boles: If this development was approved,
only 22 of the 30 acres would be developed because of
drainage issues.
Assistant City Manager Carlile reminded Council that
they can either make the motion to approve, deny, or
send the zoning request back to the Planning Commission
since there were concerns about how this application was
reviewed. The traffic study could also be reconsidered
and updated before it returned to Council for their
consideration.
A motion to deny Ordinance 23-015 amending the City of
Greenwood’s official zoning map by rezoning
approximately 31.59 acres of land located at 227
Marshall Road from R1 (Single Family Residential-Low
Density) to MPR (Master Planned Residential) was made by
Niki Hutto, seconded by Ronnie Ables.
There was no further discussion from Council.
Those who voted in favor of denying the rezoning were
Mayor Pro Tempore Betty Boles, Niki Hutto, Robert Dean,
Matthew Miller, and Ronnie Ables. Johnathan Bass voted
against denial because he felt the application should
have gone back to the Planning Commission for further
review. Mayor Smith did not vote due to a conflict of
interest.
Minutes - City Council -6- January 22, 2024 5:32 p.m.
The motion to deny passed 5-1.
Mayor Smith re-entered Council Chambers at 6:49 p.m.
CONSIDER
Ordinance No.
24-001 Amending
the City of
Greenwood’s
Official Zoning
Map (Ordinance
No. 04-020) by
Rezoning
Approximately 5
Acres of Land
Located at 1400
Mathis Road from
R3 (Residential
Medium Density)
to R10
(Residential
High Density).
(2
nd reading)
Assistant City Manager Carlile reviewed the request to
rezone 1400 Mathis Road from residential medium density
(R3) to residential high density (R10) for the
construction of townhomes. He noted that surrounding
properties supported high density development and the
Planning staff recommended approval.
City/County Planning Director Coleman added that she did
not think it would be feasible to construct 50 units but
assured Councilor Hutto that the developer placed so
much effort into this development for it to anything but
townhomes. She informed Mayor Smith and Councilor Bass
that parking spaces were determined by the number of
bedrooms in higher density developments, and two parking
spaces per unit in general for a single-family unit. The
Homeowners Association will own thei r roads and can
dictate if residents can park on the street.
No one spoke for or against proposed Ordinance 24-001.
A motion to approve Ordinance No. 24-001 was made by
Matthew Miller, seconded by Betty Boles.
DISCUSSION:
Councilor Bass observed how empty Council Chambers was
during their consideration of this R10 development,
which is a higher density than the previous MPR, and
felt embarrassed and disappointed how the NIMBY (Not In
My Backyard) community only showed up to meetings when
it involved them.
There was no further discussion from Council.
The motion carried unanimously.
Councilor Matthew Miller exited the meeting at 7:18 p.m.
Minutes - City Council -7- January 22, 2024 5:32 p.m.
CONSIDER
Ordinance No. 24-
002 Amending
Ordinance No. 03-
010, Zoning
Ordinance, Chapter
2, Article 3,
Definitions:
Automobile
Wrecking, Junk and
Salvage Yards, and
Junk Yards; Table 3-
1 Zoning District
Use Chart; Amending
Sections: 3.2.5.2.
Additional
Conditional Uses
Allowed in RM3;
3.2.8.2. Additional
Conditional Uses
Allowed in RM7;
3.3.4.2. Additional
Conditional Uses
Allowed in GC;
3.4.1.1. Uses
Permitted in All
Industrial
Districts; 3.4.1.2.
Conditional Uses
Allowed in All
Industrial
Districts; Amending
Chapter 5, Design
and Performance
Standards, Article
7. Incentives for
Cluster
Development:
Section 5.7.4.3.
Open Space Defined,
Use of Preserved
Open Space; and
Table 6.1 Parking
Requirements.
(1st reading)
Under New Business, Assistant City Manager Carlile
informed Council of discrepancies in the Zoning
Ordinance that needed to be amended and informed
Councilor Hutto that the City’s Zoning Ordinance, with
the 2022 MPR Ordinance included, is now posted on the
City’s website. City/County Planning Director Coleman
noted that the clustering criteria for high density
developments will be posted after the 2
nd reading, if
approved.
A motion to approve Ordinance No. 24-002 was made by
Johnathan Bass, seconded by Niki Hutto.
DISCUSSION:
City/County Planning Director Coleman informed Mayor
Smith that nonactive junkyards in the City would not
have a business license, but she would check with Finance
Director Sara O’Dell to confirm if there were any
junkyards functioning in the City.
There was no further discussion from Council.
Those who voted in favor were Mayor Smith, Niki Hutto,
Robert Dean, Betty Boles, Johnathan Bass, and Ronnie
Ables. Matthew Miller exited the meeting and did not
vote.
The motion passed 6-0.
Minutes - City Council -8- March 27, 2020 10:59 a.m.
CONSIDER
Donation of Body
and In-Car
Cameras to
Greenwood County
and the Town of
Ninety Six.
Assistant City Manager Carlile informed Council that the
Police Department was no longer using 56 Body and 29 In-
Car Cameras that were now obsolete. He suggested the
City could get more value from donating them and the
goodwill that came with it.
A motion to donate body and in-car cameras to Greenwood
County and the Town of Ninety Six was made by Niki Hutto,
seconded by Johnathan Bass.
Police Chief TJ Chaudoin confirmed that the Greenwood
County Sheriff’s Office and Ninety Six Police Department
were still operating on the former system that had not
been updated yet.
There was no further discussion from Council.
The motion passed 6-0.
CITY MANAGER
COMMENTS
Before City Manager Comments, Mayor Smith recognized
Greenwood Metro District Engineer Tony Williamson who
asked Council to apply for a Community Development Block
Grant for the Matthew Mill Village Phase III project on
their behalf. Brittany Holman from the Upper Savannah
Council of Governments informed Council that a signed,
urgent & compelling need waiver must be submitted for
the City to apply for a 4
th CDBG application within that
year. Mayor Smith will make it a priority to provide
Council’s decision at their February meeting.
Before reviewing upcoming events, Assistant Managers
Carlile and Thomas informed Council of four City CPST
project applications. Mayor Smith would like to meet
with Davis & Floyd to discuss Toros Field perimeters.
CITY COUNCIL
WARD REPORTS
Councilor Ronnie Ables (Ward 6) reported concerns
regarding sanitation equipment/trucks with various
issues that cannot be fixed internally. Councilor Bass
noted Council is getting more information through emails
that are being relayed to constituents. Mayor Smith
noted that 14 bags of trash from Mathis Road was picked
up.
Minutes - City Council -9- January 22, 2024 5:34 p.m.
Councilor Miller (Ward 5: Councilor Bass and Mayor Smith
reported a large amount of trash that was picked up in
Ward 5 on Martin Luthur King, Jr. Day.
Councilor Bass (Ward 4): Assistant City Manager Carlile
confirmed that grandfathered, nonconforming businesses
in the Uptown Overlay cannot get another business
license if no application was submitted after 180 days.
Betty Boles (Ward 3) reported constituents’ usual
roadside pickup complaints and agreed with Councilor
Ronnie Ables that the City needed more reliable
equipment, and staff, to operate them. Assistant City
Manager Ryan Thomas reported that the typical curbside
cycle is now 35 days. He also noted that City Manager
Wilkie and staff will be presenting a revised solid waste
ordinance to Council in the next couple of months.
Councilor Robert Dean (Ward 2) reported that he will be
meeting with developers to address some concerns with
the development behind Jerry’s Produce.
Councilor Niki Hutto (Ward 1) would like to get real
numbers on what the City can handle when it comes to new
construction and stated that she did not want to prohibit
growth, but the City needed to keep its uniqueness with
the preservation of historic architecture.
Mayor Smith: City/County Planning Director Coleman
confirmed that the Comprehensive Plan for the County
will be updated in 2025 and noted the availability of
utilities must be addressed.
ADJOURNMENT A motion to adjourn the meeting was made by Betty Boles,
seconded by Robert Dean.
There was no discussion from Council.
The motion passed unanimously.
Mayor Smith adjourned the meeting at 7:57 p.m.
_________________________
Brandon Smith, Mayor
ATTEST:
_____________________________
Tiffany L. Albert, City Clerk
Source: City of Greenwood website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.