Agenda
City of Goose Creek · Berkeley County · meeting of Jan 7, 2020 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Goose Creek
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MARGUERITE BROWN MUNICIPAL CENTER
CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBERS
519 N. GOOSE CREEK BLVD.
GOOSE CREEK, SOUTH CAROLINA
MEMORANDUM
TO: MEMBERS OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION
FROM: LILI ORTIZ-LUDLUM
ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT
DATE: January 7, 2020
SUBJECT: NOTIFICATION OF
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
This is to remind everyone that the next meeting of the Planning
Commission is scheduled for Tuesday, January 7, 2020, at 6:30
p.m. at City Hall.
Should you have any questions or comments prior to Tuesday’s
meeting, please don’t hesitate to contact Brenda Moneer at
(x.1116) or Mark Brodeur, Planning Director (x.1118) at
843‐797‐6220.
In accordance with the freedom of information act, the electronic and print media were duly notified, along with a hard copy posted at city hall.
TUESDAY, JANUARY 7, 2020 AT 6:30PM
MARGUERITE BROWN MUNICIPAL CENTER
CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBERS
I. CALL TO ORDER – CHAIRMAN JOSH JOHNSON
II. AGENDA APPROVAL
III. REVIEW OF MINUTES: November 5, 2019
IV. PUBLIC HEARING – Rezoning Request from Conservation Open space(CO) to
Medium Density Residential(R2); for the parcel identified as a portion of
TMS#2440501032.
V. PUBLIC HEARING - Murals; specifically, regarding the language to provide
regulations and guidelines for murals within the City o f Goose Creek Zoning
Ordinance.
VI. COMMENTS FROM THE COMMISSION
VII. COMMENTS FROM STAFF
VIII. ADJOURNMENT
REVIEW OF MINUTES
Page 1 of 5
MINUTES
CITY OF GOOSE CREEK
PLANNING COMMISSION
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 5, 2019, 6:30 P.M.
GOOSE CREEK MUNICIPAL CENTER
519 N. GOOSE CREEK BLVD.
I. CALL TO ORDER – CHAIRMAN JOSH JOHNSON
Action: Chairman Johnson called the meeting to order at 6:30 p.m.
Present: Gary Berenyi; Heather Byrd; Paul Connerty; Judie Edwards; Josh
Johnson; Jeffrey Smith and John Starzyk
Absent: None
Staff Present: Planning Director Mark Brodeur; Planning Technician Brenda Moneer
Council Present: Councilmember McSwain
II. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Motion: A motion was made to accept the a genda as presented . Moved by
Commissioner Smith; Seconded by Commissioner Byrd.
Discussion: There was none.
Vote: All voted in favor. The motion carried (7-0).
III. REVIEW OF MINUTES - OCTOBER 1, 2019
Chairman Johnson stated there were two(2) typographical errors in the October 1, 2019 minutes.
Motion: A motion was made to approve the October 1, 2019 minutes with
corrections. Moved by Commissioner Edwards; Seconded by
Commissioner Smith.
Discussion: There was none.
Vote: All voted in favor. The motion carried (7-0).
IV. PUBLIC HEARING – REZONING REQUEST FOR PROPERTY LOCATED AT PARCEL IDENTIFIED
AS TMS# 235- 14-04-007; REQUEST TO REZONE FROM RESIDENTIAL MEDIUM DENSITY
(R2) TO RESIDENTIAL HIGH DENSITY (R3).
Chairman Johnson opened the public hearing. Mr. Brodeur presented staff report. He stated the
application is from D.R. Horton, Inc. They are requesting a rezoning of a property located on the
east side of Nello Drive. The Subject 18.13 -acre property is currently zoned R2. The rezone
proposal is to rezone the property to R3. The subject property is identified as TMS# 235- 14-04-
007. It is surrounded by residential properties and vacant parcels. The rezone proposal is
accompanied by a development plan for sixteen (16) two story buildings containing a total of
seventy-eight (78) residential units. The subject site is constrained by la rge expanses of
freshwater wetlands. To develop the property in a site sensitive way, relative to those wetlands,
Page 2 of 5
the applicant is proposing attached dwelling units in two (2) to five (5) units each on their own
small parcels. This is commonly referred to as cluster development. Cluster development is a
useful development tool when significant natural features exist on the property. Currently the City
of Goose Creek’s Zoning Map contains very little if any R3 zoned property. For the applicant to
build these attached units the project proposal must receive a recommendation from the Planning
Commission and a zone change amendment before City Council. It also must appear before the
Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) under the auspices of a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) before
moving forward. The proposed multi-family development will need to meet fourteen (14) distinct
conditions as part of the approval by the ZBA.
The applicant was present but did not speak at this time.
Chairman Johnson inquired if the public wished to speak in favor of the rezoning. No one spoke in
favor. He inquired if the public would like to speak in opposition to the rezoning. Six (6)members
from the audience spoke.
Mr. Eric Mead of Nello Drive opposed the rezoning due to the proposed zoning being
uncharacteristic for the area. He also opposed due to the disruption of wildlife, traffic, drainage,
increase crime, and decrease in property values.
Mr. Joseph Hernandez of Water Oak Drive opposed due to traffic, decrease property values and
increase in crime.
Mr. Jake Taylor of Gianna Lane is opposed due to the extra traffic this will bring.
Ms. Uticia Rosda of Amy Drive opposed due to extra traffic, increased crime, and displacement of
wildlife.
Ms. Ana Dallas of Elrod Drive opposed due to drainage, traffic and concerned with schools as she
stated they are already full.
Mr. Phillip Obie II of Thurgood Road opposed due to the curb being dangerous to where this
development is being proposed. He also opposed due to drainage issues and speeding.
Chairman Johnson opened discussion between the Commission and applicant. Mr. David Williams
with Thomas and Hutton Engineering stated the property has been looked at a couple of times in
the past for single family residential. He stated he understood the concerns for wildlife and
believes a cluster development would be a better situation for wildlife. Concerning traffic, a traffic
study will be done. He stated in this case, we are providing two connections to the existing roads.
Regarding drainage concerns, a pipe drainage system will be installed. Mr. Williams stated we are
required by the state to reduce drainage and it must flow off the site. He stated he can not speak
to property value and crime concerns. Mr. Williams stated sidewalks and street trees will be
installed in the development.
Chairman John son inquired if the applicant has any idea as to the amount of traffic that is
generated by this size of development. The applicant stated about 760 trips in a day. Mr. Johnson
clarified for the public the requirements for drainage for this type of development. The applicant
stated drainage should always be better after development. Mr. Johnson inquired if the applicant
Page 3 of 5
would prepare a site distance exhibit that would show that the curb has enough visibility to the
intersection that is being proposed as this is a public concern. The applicant stated that can be
prepared. Mr. Johnson inquired what the property potentially would be developed into if the
zoning request remained R2. The applicant stated it would be single family and we will be entitled
to thirty (30) to thirty-two (32) homes to his knowledge.
Commissioner Byrd inquired if pad parking would be included. The applicant stated their would-
be individual garages with driveways. Commissioner Byrd inquired as to why guardrails have not
been installed if speeding and curbs have been an issue. Mr. Brodeur stated if this project
proceeded to the ZBA the applicant has indicated that they would do a traffic study. It would be
his recommendation that they look at any other mitigating devices to slow traffic and improve the
site distance at that intersection. He stated it would be up to a traffic and transportation engineer.
Commissioner Edwards inquired about on street parking. The applicant stated they will be
required to meet the parking requirement of the ordinance. Commissioner Berenyi stated the
property is restricted by wetland s and wetlands buffers. He stated only fifty (50) percent of the
property can be developed due to this and it makes logical sense to increase the density .
Commissioner Edwards inquired as to the location of the two (2) entrances. The applicant stated
Amy Drive and Farm Quarters Drive.
Chairman Johnson closed the public hearing and inquired if the Commission would like to act.
Motion: A motion was made to approv e the rezoning request for the property
235-14-04-007 from R2 to R3 with the recomm endation to the ZBA to
require a traffic study for speed and sight distance. Moved by
Commissioner Smith; Seconded by Commissioner Byrd.
Discussion: Commissioner Berenyi stated he would like to request that there be a
limit of 78 homes.
Amended Motion: A motion was made to approve the rezoning request for the property
235-14-04-007 from R2 to R3 with the recommendation to the ZBA to
require a traffic stu dy for speed and sight distance and to limit the
number of homes to 78. Moved by Commissioner Smith; Seconded by
Commissioner Byrd.
Vote: Commissioner Connerty; Commissioner Byrd, Commissioner Edwards,
Commissioner Smith and Commissioner Berenyi voted in favor.
Commissioner Johnson and Commissioner Starzyk opposed. The
motion carried (5-2).
V. DISCUSSION – ORDINANCE LANGUAGE AND REQUIREMENTS FOR MURALS
Mr. Brodeur presented a draft ordinance to the Commission for murals. He stated specific ways
that murals can be beneficial is that they create a public art scene; p lacemaking and e conomic
development. He stated if you create a great place, people want to live, work and socialize there.
Murals add a creative esthetic to the environment which energizes neglected and sometime
blighted neighborhoods. They also enhance districts where new developments are taking place
by creating a sense of destination. The P lanning Commission is being asked to review this draft
before it is set for public hearing in December. He stated that City Council believes that the Cultural
Arts Commission should be the body responsible for murals.
Page 4 of 5
Commissioner Berenyi believes incorporating murals in the community is a good idea.
Commissioner Edwards stated she likes the idea of including history but there are some points of
history she believes should not be included in a mural. Mr. Brodeur stated this is an opportunity
to define what we want to see on murals. Chairman Johnson inquired as to why the Cultural Arts
Commission come up with the topic that would be acceptable and inquired if it needed to be
codified in the ordinance or can the ordinance reference a guideline. Mr. Br odeur stated it can
reference a companion document and he can also relay to the Cultural Arts Commission that they
are the deciding body . Commissioner Edwards stated when murals were added to a City she
previously lived in, it eliminated graffiti. Discussion regarding the preservation and maintenance
of murals ensued. It was stated it would be the building owner’s responsibility to ensure it is
maintained. He stated the building owner owns the art, but the artist retains the ability to modify
and update the art. Commissioner Byrd stated there needs to be parameters set if the building has
a change of ownership. Mr. Brodeur stated the mural runs with the property not the owner.
Discussion about mural s protruding six inches ensued. It was stated that will be researched.
Commissioner Byrd inquired if there were any incentives for business owners to incorporate
murals. Mr. Brodeur stated no. The Commission agreed that the Cultural Arts Commission should
be responsible for murals. Chairman Johnson suggested having the ARB approve the location of
the mural and the Cultural Arts Commission approve the design. Mr. Brodeur stated he will think
about this.
VI. END OF YEAR BUSINESS
a) Election of Chairman
Motion: A motion was made to Nominate Mr. Josh Johnson for Chairman.
Moved by Commissioner Connerty; Seconded by Commissioner
Edwards.
Discussion: There was none.
Vote: All voted in favor. The motion carried (7-0).
b) Election of Vice Chairman
Motion: A motion was made to nominate Mr. Jeff Smith for Vice Chair. Moved
by Commissioner Connerty; Seconded by Commissioner Berenyi.
Discussion: There was none.
Vote: All voted in favor. The motion carried (7-0).
Motion: A motion was made to close nominations. Moved by Commissioner
Edwards; Seconded by Commissioner Connerty.
Discussion: There was none.
Vote: All voted in favor. The motion carried (7-0).
c) Commission Member Terms
Page 5 of 5
Mrs. Moneer stated next year Commissioner Byrd, Commissioner Smith and Chairman Johnson
will make their determination.
d) 2020 Calendar Approval
It was stated that January 2nd should be Tuesday not Wednesday on the 2020 Calendar.
Motion: A motion was made to accept the calendar with corrections. Moved by
Commissioner Berenyi; Seconded by Commissioner Connerty.
Discussion: There was none.
Vote: All voted in favor. The motion carried (7-0).
VII. COMMENTS FROM THE COMMISSION
Commissioner Edwards inquired as to when they will be starting the Comprehensive Plan. Mr.
Brodeur stated early 2020.
VIII. COMMENTS FROM STAFF
Mrs. Moneer stated on December 5, 2019 , there will be an end of year Boards and Commission’s
party.
IX. ADJOURNMENT
Commissioner Smith made a motion to adjourn, Commissioner Berenyi seconded. All voted in
favor (7-0). The meeting adjourned at approximately 8:06pm.
________________________________________ Date: ___________________
Mr. Josh Johnson, Chairman
PUBLIC HEARING
Rezoning Request from Conservation Open space(CO) to Medium
Density Residential(R2); for the parcel identified as a portion of
TMS#2440501032.
STAFF REPORT FOR THE
CITY OF GOOSE CREEK PLANNING COMMISSION
For reference, the City of Goose Creek Code of Ordinances are available
online at https://www.cityofgoosecreek.com/government/code‐
ordinances
Agenda Item
Applicant: City of Goose Creek
Location/Address: Off Lindy Creek Rd.
Request: Rezone from Conservation Open Space (CO) to
Medium Density Residential (R2)
Subject Parcel
Property Owner: City of Goose Creek
Tax Map Number: TMS#2440501032
Approximate Acreage: .46
Plat Book & Page: A677 – 84
Comprehensive Plan Future Land
Use Map Designation:
Low Density Residential (R1)
Property Zoning to the Property Uses to the
North: R2 Medium Density Residential/City North: Undeveloped
South: R2 Berkeley County South: County Residential
East: R2 Berkeley County East: County Residential
West: GC Berkeley County West: County Commercial
Anticipated Rezoning Meeting Schedule
Body Meeting Date Action
Planning Commission January 7, 2020 Public Hearing‐Rezone Request
City Council Meeting January 14, 2020 First Reading (TBD)
City Council Meeting February 11, 2020 Final Reading (TBD)
City Council Meeting subject to change. Please check the website for up‐to‐date information.
Zoning Map showing TMS 244‐05‐01‐032. Located off of Lindy Creek Rd.
COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE MAP LEGEND
PUBLIC HEARING
Murals; specifically, regarding the language to provide
regulations and guidelines for murals within the City of Goose
Creek Zoning Ordinance.
Department of
Planning and Zoning
Mark Brodeur
DIRECTOR
519 N. GOOS E CREEK BOUL EVARD
P.O DRAWER 1768
GOOS E CREEK , SC 29445- 1768
TEL (843 ) 797- 6220 EXT. 1118
FAX (843) 863- 5208
Memorandum
TO: Members of the Planning Commission
FROM: Mark Brodeur, Planning and Zoning
Director
DATE: January 7, 2020
SUBJECT: Public Hearing to consider the merits of a Mural
Ordinance
Proposal:
Conduct a Public Hearing to consider the merits of an ordinance to permit
murals on commercial property in the City of Goose Creek.
Background:
In most cases murals are a positive element in the cityscape. A growing
body of research has positively identified murals with social, cultural, and
economic benefits as well as positive mental health. Murals have the
added benefit of “Intersectionality”, meaning they promote these
characteristics simultaneously, in a synergistic way. Some specific ways in
which murals are beneficial include:
Public Art
Placemaking
Economic Development.
Murals add a creative aesthetic to the built environment, which energizes
neglected or blighted neighborhoods, and enhances districts where new
development is taking place by creating a sense of destination. W hen
linked to cultural preservation efforts, murals can also highlight diversity
and resilience initiatives.
The purpose of public art is not only to enrich the community and improve
our quality of life through its ability to enrich an environment, but also to
ignite the imagination, encourage thought and to prompt discourse.
Discussion:
The City Council requested that staff prepare an ordinance to allow murals
throughout the City. The Planning Commission is asked to conduct a Public
Hearing to review the attached Mural Ordinance.
The staff of the Planning and Zoning Department met with the Planning
Commission and Cultural Arts Commission to refine the elements of the
draft ordinance into the version you have before you today,
Recommendation:
Open the Public Hearing, invite any and all public comments and discuss
the merits of the draft ordinance for murals. Close the Public Hearing and
make a recommendation to the City Council.
151.089 Murals on Private Property
(A) Purpose. This Chapter is intended to enact a process and procedures for the installation of
original art murals on private property and further the public interest by: (i) encouraging artistic
expression; (ii) fostering a sense of pride; (iii) preventing vandalism at mural sites through the installation
of murals that vandals are reluctant to disturb; and (iv) visually activating dormant walls on commercial
enterprises.
(B) No Commercial Advertising Murals. The City may consider the installation of murals and, at
the same time, wishes to prevent the proliferation of off-site commercial signs. Therefore, the City’s
mural regulations do not allow commercial advertising.
(C) Objectives of Mural Ordinance. Mural regulations also promote public safety and welfare by
ensuring the following objectives are achieved:
(1) The design, construction, installation, repair, and maintenance of such displays will not
interfere with traffic safety or otherwise endanger public safety.
(2) Regulation will provide reasonable protection to the visual environment by controlling the
size, height, spacing, and locations of such displays.
(3) The public will enjoy the aesthetic benefits of being able to view such displays in numbers
and sizes that are reasonably and appropriately regulated.
(4) To impose permit requirements and regulations for murals.
(5) The design of such murals will relate to one of two subject areas, including but not limited
to “Creek Life” and what it means to live in this town or Goose Creek’s natural beauty and
environment.
(D) Definition. A “mural” means a painting or artwork temporarily or permanently affixed to an
exterior commercial building wall, which can be seen from the public right-of-way, and is distinguished
from signage in that it does not advertise a business, commercial endeavor, or product sold or offered on
the site or off-site.
(E) Permit required.
(1) It is unlawful for any person, firm, or corporation to authorize, erect, construct, maintain,
move, alter, change, place, suspend, or attach any mural within the City without first obtaining the
necessary permits.
(2) An application for a mural shall be submitted to the City’s Planning and Zoning
Department to be assessed by City staff for compliance with this Code. The application shall include a
maintenance plan be submitted for review and approval.
(3) Applications for short-term, “event specific” murals may also be approved, with a time
duration as established by City staff. All fees, permits, procedures, and requirements as otherwise
specified in this Chapter shall apply to short-term event specific murals.
(F) Procedure.
(1) The Planning and Zoning Department shall submit the application to the Cultural Arts
Commission (CAC) who shall review the proposal, solicit public comment, and decide to approve,
approve with conditions or deny the application.
(G) Requirements.
(1) Upon a change of ownership of the property to which a mural is installed, the new owner
may, at the owner’s election and without the need for permission from the City, terminate the covenant
and remove the mural, subject to the provisions of this Chapter.
(H) Regulations. An approved mural shall comply with all the provisions of this Section:
(1) Any alteration to an approved mural shall require approval in accordance with the
procedures listed above. An “alteration” includes any change to a permitted mural, including, but not
limited to, any change to the image(s), materials, colors, or size of the permitted mural. “Alteration” does
not include naturally occurring changes to the mural caused by exposure to the elements or the passage of
time or that result from the maintenance or repair of the mural. Such minor changes may include slight
and unintended deviations from the original image, colors, or materials that occur when the permitted
mural is repaired due to the passage of time or as a result of vandalism.
(2) No part of a mural shall exceed the height of the structure to which it is tiled, painted, or
affixed.
(3) No part of a mural shall extend more than six (6) inches from the plane of the wall upon
which it is tiled, painted, or affixed.
(4) Unless otherwise authorized by the Cultural Arts Commission upon making findings of no
resulting impacts, no mural may consist of, or contain, electrical or mechanical components, or changing
images (moving structural elements, flashing or sequential lights, lighting elements, or other automated
methods that result in movement, the appearance of movement, or change of mural image, not including
static illumination turned off and back on not more than once every 24 hours).
(5) No mural shall be placed on a residentially zoned lot.
(6) No mural shall be arranged and illuminated in a manner that will produce light intensity of
greater than three-foot candles above ambient lighting, as measured at the property line of the nearest
residentially zoned property.
(7) Digitally printed image film murals will not be permitted.
(8) No part of a mural shall contain words or letters except for the artist’s signature.
(9) A mural shall not be created without the final authorization of the Goose Creek Cultural
Arts Commission.
(I) Violations.
(1) Nuisance. Any mural created and installed without City approval pursuant to this Chapter,
or any mural that is not maintained in accordance with the approved maintenance plan, is and shall be
deemed “graffiti” and is a public nuisance pursuant to Section 137.01 (B), subject to abatement pursuant
to Chapter 137.22 and the specific penalties and remedies enumerated herein, including without limitation
collection by lien or special assessment.
(2) Administrative Penalty. Any person who creates, allows to be created, causes or otherwise
maintains any mural identified as a public nuisance pursuant to this Chapter is guilty of a violation of this
Subsection, and is subject to an issuance of administrative citation as follows. Prior to the issuance of a
citation hereunder, the City shall issue notice to any person that violates this Subsection (b), giving that
person thirty (30) days from the issuance of the notice to remove the mural created and installed without
City approval. If the mural is timely removed in compliance with the City notice issued, no citation shall
issue. If the mural is not timely removed, an administrative citation shall issue with a fine in the amount
of five hundred dollars ($500.00)
Source: City of Goose Creek website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.