Minutes
City of Goose Creek · Berkeley County · meeting of Jan 7, 2020 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Goose Creek
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Page 1 of 4
MINUTES
CITY OF GOOSE CREEK
PLANNING COMMISSION
TUESDAY, JANUARY 7, 2020, 6:30 P.M.
GOOSE CREEK MUNICIPAL CENTER
519 N. GOOSE CREEK BLVD.
I. CALL TO ORDER – CHAIRMAN JOSH JOHNSON
Action: Chairman Johnson called the meeting to order at 6:30 p.m.
Present: Heather Byrd; Paul Connerty; Judie Edwards; Josh Johnson; Jeffrey
Smith; John Starzyk
Absent: Gary Berenyi
Staff Present: Planning Director Mark Brodeur; Planning Technician Brenda Moneer
Council Present: Councilmember McSwain
II. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Motion: A motion was made to accept the a genda as presented . Moved by
Commissioner Connerty; Seconded by Commissioner Edwards.
Discussion: There was none.
Vote: All voted in favor. The motion carried (6-0).
III. REVIEW OF MINUTES - NOVEMBER 5, 2019
Chairman Johnson stated the curb was used instead of curve.
Motion: A motion was made to approve the November 5, 2019 minutes with
corrections. Moved by Commissioner Connerty; Seconded by
Commissioner Byrd.
Discussion: There was none.
Vote: All voted in favor. The motion carried (6-0).
IV. PUBLIC HEARING – REZONING REQUEST FROM CONSERVATION OPEN SPACE(CO) TO
MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL(R2); FOR THE PARCEL IDENTIFIED AS A PORTION OF
TMS#2440501032.
Mrs. Moneer stated the applicant (the City of Goose Creek) would like to rezone this parcel to R2.
She stated the City previously requested and received a rezoning of R2 for a parcel located north
of th e p roperty being discussed tonight. She stated the northern property is currently
undeveloped and if TMS 244- 05-01-032 is rezoned , it would allow for the two properties to be
join by abandoning the property line and increase the joint property by ½ acre. This would allow
for the developer to work around the wetlands. Chairman Johnson confirmed that the City would
like to rezone the property before selling it to a potential buyer.
Page 2 of 4
Chairman Johnson inquired if anyone from the public would like to speak in favor of the rezoning.
Mr. Anthony Myers of Lindy Creek inquired what is going in the area. Chairman Johnson stated
the property is up for a potential rezoning to an R2 which is a medium density residential zoning.
Chairman Johnson inquired if anyone from the public would like to speak in opposition to the
rezoning. No one from the public wished to speak.
Chairman Johnson inquired if the Commission had any questions for the applicant. Commissioner
Byrd inquired if this is going to be a residential property. Mrs. Moneer stated it will be a small
residential development of six (6) lots. She stated due to the wetlands, it has forced the interested
developer to request a rezoning from a potential R1 use to an R2. Chairman Johnson closed the
public hearing. He stated the adjacent parcel did come before the Commission in April of 2019 and
the vote at that time to rezone to R2 was in favor three(3) to two (2). He stated he was one of the
dissenting votes because he felt is should remain R1, however he supports this request because it
is contiguous to the property that has already been rezoned.
Chairman Johnson inquired if the Commission would like to act.
Motion: A motion was made to approv e the rezoning request for the property
244-050-1032 from Conservation Open Space (CO) to Residential
Medium Density ( R2). Moved by Commissioner Smith; Seconded by
Commissioner Connerty.
Discussion: There was none
Vote: All voted in favor. The motion carried (6-0).
V. PUBLIC HEARING - MURALS; SPECIFICALLY, REGARDING THE LANGUAGE TO PROVIDE
REGULATIONS AND GUIDELINES FOR MURALS WITHIN THE CITY OF GOOSE CREEK
ZONING ORDINANCE.
Mr. Brodeur stated this topic came before the Commission two ( 2) times prior as a discussion
item. He stated following the last discussion, it was brought before the Cultural Arts Commission
for their input. He stated a modification the Cultural Arts Commission made was to designate the
subject areas of all murals to Creek Life or Goose Creek ’s natural beauty and environment.
Additional modifications the Cultural Arts Commission made were to have the applicant include a
maintenance plan and eliminate text from murals with the exception of the artist’s signature.
Chairman Johnson inquired if anyone from the public would like to speak in favor or in
opposition to the proposed change of the Zoning Ordinance.
Mr. Louis Hassell of Loganberry Circle spoke in favor of murals and agreed that text should be
eliminated.
Ms. Sharina Haynes of the Cultural Arts Commission came to show her support for the murals.
Commissioner Edwards inquired about the guidelines that the Cultural Arts Commission used
when they requested artwork for the traffic boxes. She also inquire d how murals compared. A
Page 3 of 4
representative of the Cultural Arts Commission stated they had to make sure they were in
compliance with the South Carolina Department of Transportation ( SCDOT). S he stated the
artwork was not allowed to have text and must represent Goose Creek’s natural beauty.
Commissioner Byrd stated she was disappointed to see that text on murals will not be allowed
according to the proposed ordinance. She stated this is precluding the City from marketing its own
brand of #creekrising . Commissioner Byrd asked for clarification regarding digital ly printed
murals. Mr. Brodeur stated a digitally printed mural would be made of vinyl as opposed to a
traditional painted mural. Commissioner Byrd stated not allowing digitally printed murals is
limiting art. A Commissioner shared his opposition for not allowing businesses to advertise . He
stated there are certain businesses that are synonymous with the City such as Ye Old Fashion Ice
Cream and Publix.
Commissioner Edwards asked for clarification regarding Section H3: No part of a mural shall
extend more than six (6) inches from the plane of the wall. Mr. Brodeur stated we are not look ing
for three-dimensional murals. He stated the Cultural Arts Commission will be the body to decide
what is acceptable.
Chairperson Johnson stated the only comment he has regarding the text of the ordinance is under
Section C5 : The design of such murals will relate to one of two subject areas, including but not
limited to “Creek Life” and what it means to live in this town or Goose Creek’s natural beauty and
environment. He stated it conflicts itself when it states, “relate to one of two subject areas” and then
states, “including but not limited to .” It was decided to rewrite Section C5 to read “the design of
such murals will relate to the subject areas creek life, what it means to live in Goose Creek, and it’s
natural beauty and environment.”
Commissioner Byrd recommended a change in Section H7 and H8. She stated those two (2) items
limit what the City is able to capitalize on from an artistic perspect ive. She stated from an artist
perspective, it limits their ability to use a material and m aintain the artwork in a cost -conscious
way.
The Chairman of the Cultural Arts Commission, Marsha Hassel , stated an artist will decide the
medium that they would use based upon the canvas they are trying to create. The Commission
agreed to strik e Section H7 (Digitally printed image film murals will not be permitted ) from the
proposed ordinance. The Commission agreed to strike Section H8 (No part of a mural shall contain
words or letters except for the artist’s signature) from the proposed ordinance stating the City will
be limiting its scope and brand recognition which is valuable.
Discussion occurred regarding Section I2. Commissioner Starzyk stated the last two (2) sentences
do not make sense. (If the mural is timely removed in compliance with the City notice issued, no
citation shall issue. If the m ural is not timely removed, an administrative citation shall issue with a
fine in the amount of five hundred dollars ($500.00)). The Commission agreed to rewrite the text to
read “If the mural is removed in compliance with the City notice issued, no citation shall be issued.
If the mural is not removed, an administrative citation shall issue with a fine in the amount of five
hundred dollars ($500.00).”
Page 4 of 4
Mr. Brodeur stated he would like to send the revised proposed ordinance to the City’s Attorney
before it is presented to City Council. The Commission agreed.
Commissioner Byrd stated regarding Section B (No Commercial Advertising), she does not want
to limit commercial advertising. Chairperson Johnson stated he would like to leave the text as it is
written. He feels citizens are flooded with advertising. A Cultural Arts Commissioner stated the
idea for the murals is for beautification not advertising. Chairman Johnson closed the public
hearing.
Motion: A motion was made to amend the proposed ordinance with the edits in
accordance with the City Attorney from the last paragraph , to move
forward with Ordinance 151.089 Murals on Private Property to be put
before City Council at their next meeting. Moved by Commissioner
Byrd; Seconded by Commissioner Connerty.
Discussion: There was none
Vote: All voted in favor. The motion carried (6-0)
VII. COMMENTS FROM THE COMMISSION
There was none.
VIII. COMMENTS FROM STAFF
There was none.
IX. ADJOURNMENT
Commissioner Smith made a motion to adjourn, Commissioner Edwards seconded. All voted in
favor (6-0). The meeting adjourned at approximately 7:40pm.
________________________________________ Date: ___________________
Mr. Josh Johnson, Chairman
Source: City of Goose Creek website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.