RecordWell Data

Planning Commission Regular Meeting — Minutes

City of Beaufort · Beaufort County · Planning Commission · meeting of Sep 21, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Beaufort

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 Planning Commission Regular Meeting Minutes – September 21, 2026 CALL TO ORDER 3:57 A regular meeting of the Planning Commission was called to order by Chairman Mike Tomy and was held in-person in the Council Chambers on September 21, 2026 at 5:00 PM. The meeting was broadcasted via live-streamed on YouTube. You can view this meeting at the City’s page; City Beaufort Government. ATTENDEES Members in attendance: Mike Tomy, Chairman, Bill Bardenwerper, Vice-Chairman, Libby Anderson, Secretary, Clinton Hallman, Michael Holle, and Benjie Morillo. Member Absent: Kim McFann. Staff in attendance: Curt Freese, Community Development Department Director, Christopher Klement, Planner III, and Nick Navia, Planner II. REVIEW OF MINUTES 4:47 A. June 15, 2026 Regular Meeting Minutes Ms. Anderson noted on the 1st page under the motion, to change Ms. Wilson to Ms. McFann. Motion: Mr. Hallman made a motion to accept the minutes with the modification made by Ms. Anderson. Mr. Bardenwerper seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. B. August 17, 2026 Regular Meeting Minutes Mr. Bardenwerper asked that it be noted on 1 st page that he did attend the meeting but it was virtually. Mr. Hallman noted on the last page, his name is incorrect. Motion: Mr. Bardenwerper made a motion to approve the minutes with the noted changes. Mr. Hallman seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. C. August 31, 2026 Worksession Minutes Mr. Hallman noted on the 2 nd page, the word initiative needs to be initiatives. Ms. Anderson noted on page 3 that Mr. Tomy’s name is misspelled. 2 Motion: Mr. Bardenwerper made a motion to approve the minutes with the noted changes. Ms. Anderson seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. QUESTIONS RELATING TO MILITARY OPERATIONS 8:50 None. PUBLIC COMMENT 9:20 Paul Trask, 620 Bladen Street, stated he had comments but they were not related to the project on the agenda and that he can wait. Public comment closed. APPLICATION 10:28 A. Public Hearing: Site Plan - Beaufort Free-Standing Emergency Department (FSED) – 396 Robert Smalls Parkway. The Applicant, Conor Blaney with Ward Edwards is proposing a commercial development to include a free-standing Emergency Department. The property is further identified as R120 028 000 1248 0000. Curt Freese presented his staff report. Public Comment: None. Public comment was closed. Motion: Mr. Bardenwerper made a motion to recommend approval based on the public hearing that was held on August 17, 2026, and its continuation tonight, as well as the information provided by the applicant in the submittals and in response to questions. The motion also incorporated the staff-recommended findings of fact on page five of the staff report, which the Planning Commission adopted in full, along with the 10 conditions recommended by staff. Staff recommends Site Plan approval with the conditions, in that it satisfies 7.5.7 of the Development Code (see below), specifically 7.5.7 D. 3 (found in this Staff Report) with the conditions. a. The plan is consistent with the City of Beaufort Comprehensive Plan and Civic Master Plan. Staff finds it consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. b. The plan complies with all applicable requirements of this Code. Staff believes the proposed Architectural Changes and conditions serve to fulfill this finding. c. There exists adequate infrastructure (transportation and utilities) to support the plan as 3 proposed. The applicant has completed a TIA, and made the necessary changes to the entrance, trail and sidewalk and obtaining an easement for Access to W.K. Alston, to fulfill this requirement. d. The plan conforms to the character of the neighborhood, considering the location, type and height of buildings or structures and the type and extent of landscaping on the site. Staff believes the proposed Architectural Changes and conditions serve to fulfill this finding. Conditions: Approval is conditioned upon the following materials and changes to be provided to Staff to be approved administratively: Administrative Approval Architectural Details 1. Entry tower height and proportion The entry gable has returned to a taller configuration despite the Planning Commission’s direction to reduce its visual height. The applicant should reduce the tower to the previously presented lower option or provide a comparative elevation demonstrating how the current height responds to the Commission’s concern and remains proportional to the one-story building. 2. Materials and colors Provide a complete exterior material and color schedule identifying brick, mortar, fiber- cement siding and trim, standing-seam roofing, coping, fascia, soffits, gutters, downspouts, storefront systems, louvers, doors, canopies, and equipment screening. Submit physical samples and a brick-and-mortar sample panel for staff review before installation. 3. Material transitions and detailing Provide enlarged details showing transitions between brick, fiber-cement siding, storefront systems, canopy roofs, parapets, and the entry tower. Details should include corner boards, bases, head and sill conditions, flashing, trim dimensions, expansion joints, and terminations. Avoid unresolved changes of material at outside corners or within a single architectural volume. 4. Fenestration Provide typical window and storefront head, jamb, sill, mullion, and trim details. Windows within masonry should have an appropriate recess and coordinated brick head and sill treatment. Openings within fiber-cement walls should have consistently proportioned casing and projecting sill details. Confirm that the drawings and renderings show the same window sizes and subdivisions. 5. Canopy detailing Provide final details for the entrance and secondary canopies, including roof slope, standing-seam profile, fascia, soffit, supports, attachment to the building, drainage, and 4 gutter/downspout locations. The secondary canopies should remain subordinate to the principal entrance canopy and use the same architectural vocabulary. 6. Rooftop equipment screening Provide rooftop sightline studies from adjoining streets and parking areas. Confirm that mechanical equipment will be fully screened and that the screen walls, parapets, and entry tower are coordinated as a unified roofline rather than a series of unrelated horizontal elements. 7. Service and equipment areas Provide elevations and details of generator, fuel-tank, dumpster, and other service enclosures, including wall and gate materials, height, opacity, ventilation, and landscaping. These areas should read as subordinate site-screening elements and should be compatible with the principal building. 8. Visible building systems Coordinate wall-mounted utilities, conduits, meters, disconnects, vents, louvers, gutters, downspouts, and exterior lighting. Locate these elements away from principal façades where practical and finish them to match or complement the adjacent wall material. 9. Lighting and signage Provide final exterior lighting and signage information. Fixtures should be simple, shielded, and coordinated with the building. Signage should not compete with the entry gable or become the dominant architectural feature. 10. Drawing consistency Revise the plans, elevations, renderings, material designations, and orientation labels so they are fully coordinated. Where renderings are illustrative, the approved architectural elevations and material schedule should govern. Mr. Morillo seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. PUBLIC COMMENT 51:22 Paul Trask, 620 Bladen Street, referred to the Landscape Ordinance that City Council acted upon in an emergency situation and adopted the recommendations. He referred to Beaufort County’s plan for the multi-use path all the way down on the east side of Salem Road. Mr. Trask referred to the County’s document. Mr. Trask feels the county’s document does not comply with some of the requirements in the Tree Ordinance. He referred to the Preservation of character defining features such as Live Oak canopies, the connectivity linked by practical multi-model network in the Landscape Ordinance. Mr. Trask presented a short video that illustrates his points. He is in favor of the path but he just wants the County to do it properly. He requests that the Planning Commission writes a letter to City Council requesting that they liaison and make certain that the County abides by the City’s Tree Ordinance. 5 Beaufort County is having a meeting next week on this with Beaufort County Council. Mr. Trask will send a digital copy to Mr. Freese for his file. (Mr. Trask written comments are attached) Motion: Mr. Bardenwerper made a motion to request staff to prepare a letter for the Chairman’s consideration taking into account the concerns raised by Mr. Trask at tonight’s meeting about the location of the County’s plans for a multi-use path that the Planning Commission is in support of. Mr. Hallman seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. Paul Trask, 610 Bladen Street, referred to Waterfront Park Advisory meeting last week that went into Executive Session to discuss lease matters pertaining to Safe Harbor. Mr. Trask stated he doesn’t feel the Waterfront Park Advisory has the authority to negotiate with Safe Habor but does have authority to make recommendations to the deposition of the park and marina. Mr. Trask has gone to City Council along with many others to call attention to the overuse and misuse of Executive Session to discuss matters which should be discussed in public. Mr. Trask requests the Planning Commission have a second letter drafted to City Council recommending immediately that they Commission the study that he brought to them a few months ago that identified three communities in the Island of Palms, North Carolina, and a community on a lake in Wisconsin. He feels this is a priority issue and that a proper consultant needs to be hired. (Mr. Trask written comments are attached) Public Comment closed. MISCELLANEOUS DISCUSSION 1:33:38 Chairman Tomy went over a few issues that were not listed on the agenda. Chairman Tomy referred to the copy of the letter that he wrote and sent out to the Mayor and Beaufort County asking their Planning Commission for the comments. The letter, expresses the Planning Commission’s desire for consultation between the two Planning Commissions with respect to Seak Farms. Motion: Mr. Bardenwerper made a motion that the Planning Commission endorse the letter of September 29, 2026 sent out to the City of Beaufort Mayor, the City Manager, and the head of the Beaufort County Planning Commission, expressing the Planning Commission’s development known as Seabrook Farms. Given the fact that the PC is updating the Comprehensive Plan, the City of Beaufort Planning Commission would like consultation with the Beaufort County Planning Commission with respects to the plan. Mr. Hallman seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. Chairman Tomy referred to the Moratorium on apartments that the Town of Port Royal has adopted and which may affect the City of Beaufort and Beaufort County. Mr. Freese further outlined that this current State Statute allows the tax exemption to apartment complexes who are (partially) owned by a nonprofit and who offer at least 75% of their rental units to residents who qualify of earning no more than 80% of area median income, or 20% of the units to residents who qualify as very low income that’s less than 50% of AMI, or 40% of the units occupied by residents whose incomes do not exceed 120% of the area’s very low income which is 60% of AMI. Mr. Hallman referred to Mr. Freese’s agenda packet for tomorrow’s City Council worksession and 6 suggested the PC look at the presentation on page 182 that Mr. Freese put together. Chairman Tomy asked Mr. Freese to mention to Council that the PC had a discussion on the subject and has concerns. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN 1:58:48 Mr. Freese suggested if the PC has extra items they can send them to staff and staff can have them prepared for the worksession on October 5. The PC agreed to sending their items to staff. Chairman Tomy stated we need to have invitations sent out to other groups that we want to get input from as soon as possible. Chairman Tomy referred to the schedule for the Comprehensive Plan that staff put together and suggested the PC take another look at it and see where we’re at since City Council wants to know. Mr. Freese said staff can do a chart of an update of what is planned and what has actually been complete and present it at both the worksession and the regular meeting. Mr. Bardenwerper complimented Mr. Freese on his initial draft of the Place Principles. Staff and the PC further discussed the Place Principles. Mr. Hallman stated that before the kick off of the Trails and Parks Committee, he and Mr. Holle need to have a specific charge and mission statement. Chairman Tomy said this can be done at our next worksession. Mr. Freese notified the PC that City Council has sent the Joint Worksession for October 8 at 5:30 pm in the Planning Conference Room. Mr. Tomy will be in Charleston for a hospital visit at 1:00 pm and will get back as soon as he can. Ms. Anderson will be out of town. ADJOURNMENT 2:07:37 Mr. Hallman made a motion to adjourn seconded by Mr. Holle. The meeting ended at 7:07 pm.

Source: City of Beaufort website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.