RecordWell Data

Planning Commission Worksession — Minutes

City of Beaufort · Beaufort County · Planning Commission · meeting of Apr 6, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Beaufort

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 Planning Commission Work Session Minutes – April 6, 2026 CALL TO ORDER 2:47 A work session of the Planning Commission was called to order by Chairman Tomy and was held in-person in the Planning Conference Room on April 6, 2026 at 1:02 PM. The meeting was broadcasted via zoom and live- streamed on YouTube. You can view this meeting at the City’s page; City Beaufort SC. ATTENDEES Members in attendance: Mike Tomy, Chairman, Bill Bardenwerper, Vice-Chairman, Libby Anderson, Secretary, Clinton Hallman, Kim McFann, Benjie Morillo, and Bill Suter. Staff in attendance: Curt Freese, Community Development Department Director, and Nick Navia, Planner I. Chairman stated since Benjie Morillo would be late to today’s meeting, the Planning Commission would wait to discuss Lot Diversity until he arrives. PUBLIC COMMENT 3:30 Paul Trask, 610 Bladen Street, referred to the comment in the new provision proposal for carriage houses and other accessory structures which suggest that no accessories structures may be permitted prior to construction of the primary. He referred to the discussion he had with the Planning Commission (PC) about affordable housing and referred to his own son who just purchased a lot at the corner of Adventure and Washington Street and who couldn’t afford to build his primary dwelling first. Mr. Trask felt this would be a very substantial change in his son’s case. He asked that the Planning Commission (PC) take a little extra thought about something like this. Wallace Scarborough, 1207 Bay Street, handed out a document regarding the State Law and the points he would be speaking about today. He stated as a resident of Beaufort he respectfully opposes the proposed changes to Bed & Breakfasts standards, specifically in the amendment that would allow Bed & Breakfasts (B&B’s) to host outdoor events, to serve food and to include persons other than registered guests. To do this would be in direct conflict with the South Carolina Bed & Breakfast Act, South Carolina Code Title 45, Chapter 4. Mr. Scarborough read the State Law for Bed & Breakfasts (B&B’s). Outside events or serving non- guests changes the facility from a primary residential-based business and thus, would exclude them from the protections and exemptions that are listed in the Bed & Breakfast Act that the (B&B’s) are allowed to have. Such expansion probably would trigger the stricter International Building Code (IBC) requirements, full commercial food service regulations and increased insurance obligations. The impacts on the neighborhoods are not to be forgotten. Because of this, there will be increased noise, increased parking problems and increased traffic in the neighborhoods. If the City wishes to permit events, the proper approach would be to 2 require operators to seek to be either an Inn or an event facility. Mr. Scarborough stated he would not want the PC to broaden the definition beyond what the State Law allows. He referred to the SC Supreme Court case, “South Carolina State Authority versus Jasper County”. Mr. Scarborough respectfully requests that the PC recommend keeping the current language that limits meals and events to registered guests or the exemption that already exists in Section 3.6.2.C.1.E which is consistent with the South Carolina Bed & Breakfast Act. Any broader allowance would trigger a legal challenge. Graham Trask, 111 Bay Street, lives on the same block as the Cuthbert House and up the block from Mr. Tomy’s short-term rental (STR). Mr. Trask asked the Chairman if he participated in the Short-Term Rental discussion. Mr. Tomy said he did as a PC member. Mr. Trask argued that this is conflicting. He believes the current STR and B&B violates the IBC Chapter 3, Section 310, Group R1 Safety Ordinance. The Safety Ordinance suggests that with 10 occupants or more, you must have an automatic sprinkler system and ADA related features for public accommodations such as elevators and bathrooms. The B&B’s on his block are more than 10 people/occupants, and believes they are in violation. He referred to State Law Chapter 4 Bed & Breakfast Section 45420 definitions. Mr. Trask stated he felt the new suggestions actually expand what the City already has, which he feels are in violation of the State Law. Wallace Scarborough, said his wife was trying to comment online but couldn’t. His spoke on behalf of her and said, “she never approached any B&B about an event and never attended a (B&B) event and if somebody said she did, were lying. Public Comment closed. Chris Ramm, Bay Street said he and his wife and him are the owners of the Cuthbert House and feels this gentleman is trying to put them out of business. They just learned about these new changes today. The Cuthbert House has been operating since 1996 and has hosted select events along the way. Mr. Ramm stated that they had 10 guest rooms, and that they serve breakfast and only fulfill meal orders for their guests in the afternoon. Public Comment was closed. DISCUSSION – CHAPTERS 2, 3, AND 4 REVIEW 26:34 The Planning Commission and staff started with Chapter 3 since PC Member, Benjie Morillo, was not present yet. Chapter 3: 3.6.2 C – Bed and Breakfast Mr. Freese said the purpose of the meeting today is to finalize Lot Diversity, Bed & Breakfast, and the draft of Chapter 4. In future meetings we will finalize Chapters 2 and 3. Mr. Freese stated from the Planning Commission (PC), a lot of questions were asked about Bed & Breakfasts (B&B’s) and the PC was trying to understand what a Bed & Breakfast (B&B) is, so he provided some answers in a document that was included in the PC’s meeting packet. After speaking with the City attorney, Mr. Freese also included in their packet, the City attorney’s draft document. Mr. Freese went over the definitions that are currently in the City Codes for a Bed & Breakfast Inn (10 or fewer rooms), a Hotel/Motel (25 or more rooms), an Inn (6 to 24 rooms), a Resort, Rooming and Boarding Facility. Mr. Freese referred to the International 3 Building Code (IBC), and International Residential Code (IRC) requirements. These Codes are adopted by the State. Public Comment Graham Trask, Real Estate Developer, commented that the PC shouldn’t ignore the IBC Chapter 3 – Section 3.10 Group 1. If there was a fire in the Cuthbert House and the PC allowed it, the City would have a lawsuit on their hands. Also, Mr. Trask commented on the proposed changes and referred to the current lawsuit against the Cuthbert House. He said the State Law is very clear about what defines a Bed and Breakfast. Wallace Scarborough said he served in the South Carolina General Assembly and it’s unique because a lot of times we looked at these Laws and thought, “what was the intent”? He knows the intent because he knows who the members were in the South Carolina General Assembly and they had discussions on this because Charleston SC was having issues with the B&B’s. Mr. Scarborough encouraged the PC to stay with the language that is currently in that Section. Public Comment was closed. Mr. Freese said the PC needs to decide what recommendation they want to give to City Council because this will come up with them, too. Mr. Tomy referred to Mr. Freese’s memorandum and recommended the following under Bed and Breakfast: o Eliminate the word “Inn” from the title “Bed & Breakfast Inn” because “Inn” is defined elsewhere. o Add the words and multiple residential after the word single so it reads, The use of a single and multiple residential structure”. Mr. Tomy referred to Mr. Freese’s memorandum and recommended the following under Short Term Rental: o In the first sentence, add an “s” to dwelling so it reads, three-family dwellings. Mr. Bardenwerper asked staff for a list of the names of the Bed and Breakfasts within the City. Ms. Anderson suggested putting this discussion of Bed and Breakfast on hold until the lawsuit is resolved. Mr. Bardenwerper said it’s important to stay compliant with the State Law. Public Comment Graham Trask commented that this was a great discussion. He said Mr. Bardenwerper’s comments were interesting because the Beaufort Inn has forty (40) rooms. Mr. Trask asked, “How could the Beaufort Inn claim to be non-conforming to a Zoning Law that has a maximum of ten rooms”. Mr. Bardenwerper replied and said, “the Law was dated 1988 prior to the State Statute or any local regulations or any regulations on Bed & Breakfast at all”. Wallace Scarborough stated a lot of these things are based on current zoning whether it’s T4-N or T4-HN; whether it’s in the commercial district, etc. He clarified that if this tried to exist today and was in T4-N or T4- HN, it would have had to go to City Council to get a Special Exception to exist, whereas the others like the Cuthbert House, which is grandfathered, would not have to get a special exception to exist. 4 Chapter 2: 2.5.9 – Lot Diversity 1:31:19 Mr. Morillo went over his proposed new section for Chapter 2: 2.5.9 – Lot Diversity that he emailed to the PC prior to the meeting. He said his chart shows all of his proposed amendments. Mr. Morillo said he is trying to address the problem of giant scale apartments that are scattered everywhere. Public Comment Paul Trask, 610 Bladen Street, would suggest a little bit larger limit for the “grocery store” for example. He thinks the Comprehensive Plan encourages infill as much as possible. He referred to the apartment complexes down Salem Road and on Highway 170, and said there is no interconnectivity and no pedestrian trail. He said it’s a good idea to try to encourage proximity to existing commercial development or require some degree of commercial or flex space. Mr. Trask thinks the proposal is trying to incorporate all these elements into one development, but they are already existing. The problem is that there is no connectivity to it; it requires people to get in their cars. We need to create connections to the Spanish Moss Trail for the existing ones, such as along Salem Road. Interconnectivity is the big problem. Public Comment closed. Chapter 4: 4.5.9 B.2 – Building Design and Infill Standards 2:31:19 Mr. Freese went over the proposed amendments and revisions for Chapter 4. PC agreed to put this chapter on the PC’s 4/20/26 Meeting agenda for approval. Mr. Freese suggested staff send any of their typos/corrections of the code to staff one week before the meeting. He said Chapters 2 and 3 will be presented to the PC at their regular meeting on May 18. Public Comment Paul Trask, resident, said he reviewed the clean copy of Chapter 4 and it looks good. Chapter 4 has to do with 2.6.3 in terms of providing an alternative to the two-story requirements. If this is still an issue when the PC reviews Chapter 2, it needs to be addressed. Public Comment closed. PC and staff agreed to reschedule their 5/4 PC worksession to 4/27 at 1:30 pm. The worksession will start at 1:30 pm at City Hall on to review the Chapters 2 & 3. Then the PC will leave at 3:00 to go on a site visit to the Pointe Grand and Garden Oaks Apartments. Ms. Anderson asked if the PC had addressed the issue of putting an accessory before the primary. If not, this issue might relate back to Chapter 2. Ms. Anderson referred to the situation at the corner of Bladen & Duke Street. Mr. Bardenwerper showed photos. This area is the Bladen Street Redevelopment District and there are special rules that projects follow and are approved of by staff and not by the Historic Review Board. Ms. Anderson suggested deleting this exemption from the Bladen Street and go back to having the Historic Review Board review them. PC and staff agreed to adding a simple footnote to all accessory structures in Section 3.11.2 stating “no accessory structure shall be built before the primary structure on any lot”. 5 ADJOURNMENT 2:56:00 Mr. Tomy made a motion to adjourn seconded by Mr. Hallman. The meeting ended at 3:56 pm.

Source: City of Beaufort website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.