City Council Work Session Meeting — Agenda Packet
City of Beaufort · Beaufort County · City Council · meeting of Jan 27, 2026 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Beaufort
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
Join from PC, Mac, iPad, or Android:
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/86141519967?pwd=YhQyasucHYbXbXC9dLHUIYSPcoXVj7.1
Passcode:524191 +16694449171 Webinar ID: 861 4151 9967
City of Beaufort
1911 Boundary Street
Beaufort Municipal Complex
Beaufort, South Carolina 29902
(843) 525-7070
City Council Worksession Meeting Agenda
January 27, 2026
Statement of Media Notification
"In accordance with South Carolina Code of Laws, 1976, Section 30-4-80(d), as amended, all
local media was duly notified of the time, date, place and agenda of this meeting."
Worksession Meeting - Planning Conference Room - 5:00 PM
Please note, this meeting will be broadcast via zoom and live-streamed on YouTube. You
can view the meeting at the City's page; City Beaufort SC
I. Call to Order - Philip Cromer, Mayor
II. Employee New Hire Recognition
A. Municipal Court - Paige Summers
B. Police Department - Ian Tiarks
III. Historic District Task Force Committee Interviews
A. Interviews to be conducted by Council for the Historic District Task Force
Committee
IV. Discussion
A. Fiscal Year 2025 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report
B. Discussion of establishing a Pilot Social District in Downtown Beaufort
C. Discussion on creating a Downtown Advisory Board
D. Noise Ordinance
E. Discussion of the Merits of Adopting a "No Comments" Policy on the City's
Facebook Page
V. Executive Session
A. Pursuant to Title 30, Chapter 4, Section (70) (a) (2) of the South Carolina Code of
Law: Receipt of legal advice and discussion of negotiations incident to proposed
contractual arrangements
VI. Adjourn
Page 1 of 80
2
Page 2 of 80
City of Beaufort
Department Request for City Council Agenda Item
To: City Council Date: 01/09/2026
From: Curt Freese, Community Development Director
Item Name: Interviews to be conducted by Council for the Historic District Task Force
Committee
Meeting Date: January 27, 2026
Department: Community Development Department
Background Information:
Introduction:
The following will be interviewing with the Council for possible consideration for this board:
Stacey Applegate
Bradford Fleming
Scott Gibbs
Jodie Miller
Martin Nash
Marius Payne
George Reynolds
Sue Sagui
Margaret Jerry Stocks
Marc Sviland
Fred Washington Jr
Background:
The Task Force will review policies, ordinances, and long-term strategies relating to the
preservation, cultural identity, and economic vitality of the Historic District. With a strong
emphasis on community representation, the committee will gather public input, evaluate
enhancement opportunities, and present recommendations to City Council.
Serving on the Historic District Task Force is a chance to meaningfully impact the future of
Beaufort’s most iconic and historically significant area. Members will help shape policies that
protect and enhance the district, ensure that community voices are represented in decision-
Page 3 of 80
making, and collaborate with diverse stakeholders to safeguard Beaufort’s cultural and
architectural legacy for the next generation. This is a unique opportunity to contribute to both
preservation and progress in one of America's oldest and most celebrated historic cities.
Who We’re Seeking
The City is accepting applications from Beaufort residents who live within the Historic District,
including:
o Three (3) full-time residents living inside the overall City Historic District
o Two (2) full-time residents living in the Northwest Quadrant of the Historic District
An additional four members will be appointed from existing boards and organizations, including
the Planning Commission, Historic Review Board, Historic Beaufort Foundation, and the
Freedman’s Arts District.
Eligibility & Expectations
Applicants must:
o Be full-time residents of the City of Beaufort
o Demonstrate an interest in historic preservation, community character, and/or thoughtful
development
Task Force members will collaborate with City staff, stakeholders, and fellow residents to ensure
the district continues to serve as a cultural, aesthetic, and economic anchor for Beaufort.
Legal Authority:
Staff Recommendation:
Placed on Agenda For:
Attachments:
1. Stacey Applegate - HDTFC - 12-7-25_Redacted
2. Bradford Fleming - HDTFC - 12-30-25_Redacted
3. Scott Gibbs - HDTFC - 12-20-25_Redacted
4. Jodie Miller - HDTFC- 11-16-25_Redacted
5. Martin Nash - HDTFC - 12-31-25_Redacted
6. Marius Payne - HDTFC - 12-29-25_Redacted
7. George Reynolds - HDTFC - 12-31-25_Redacted
8. Sue Sagui - HDTFC - 11-15-25_Redacted
9. Margaret Jerry Stokes - HDTFC - 11-17-25_Redacted
10. Marc Sviland - HDTFC - 11-05-25_Redacted
11. Fred Washington Jr - HDTFC - 11-10-25_Redacted
Page 4 of 80
Page 5 of 80
Page 6 of 80
Page 7 of 80
Page 8 of 80
Page 9 of 80
Page 10 of 80
Page 11 of 80
Page 12 of 80
Page 13 of 80
Page 14 of 80
Page 15 of 80
Page 16 of 80
Page 17 of 80
Page 18 of 80
Page 19 of 80
Page 20 of 80
Page 21 of 80
Page 22 of 80
Page 23 of 80
Page 24 of 80
Page 25 of 80
Page 26 of 80
Page 27 of 80
Page 28 of 80
Page 29 of 80
Page 30 of 80
Page 31 of 80
Page 32 of 80
Page 33 of 80
City of Beaufort
Department Request for City Council Agenda Item
To: City Council Date: 01/20/2026
From: Alan Eisenman, Finance Director
Item Name: Fiscal Year 2025 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report
Meeting Date: January 27, 2026
Department: Finance Department
Background Information:
Introduction:
David Irwin, Audit Partner with Mauldin & Jenkins, will present financial and compliance audit
from City of Beaufort's FY 2025 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report.
Alan Eisenman, Finance Director, will present financial overview of FY 2025 Annual
Comprehensive Financial Report.
Background:
Legal Authority:
S.C. Code Ann. § 5-7-260; Title 5, Chapter 7
Staff Recommendation:
Placed on Agenda For:
Attachments:
1. Financial and Compliance Audit Presentation
2. Annual Comprehensive Financial Report Overview Presentation
Page 34 of 80
Financial & Compliance Audit – June 30, 2025
Presented by:
David Irwin, CPA
Partner
City of Beaufort, South Carolina
Page 35 of 80
Financial & Compliance Audit
June 30, 2025
Purpose of Today’s Presentation
Overview of:
• Independent Auditor’s Report
• Compliance Reports
• Financial Statements
Required Communications
Answer Any Questions
Page 36 of 80
Financial & Compliance Audit
June 30, 2025
Audit Opinion
City: responsible for financial statements.
M&J: to express opinions.
Auditing Standards = Generally Accepted Auditing
Standards and Governmental Auditing Standards
Financial Audit : Unmodified (Clean) Opinion
• Highest level of Assurance
• Financial Statements are fairly presented in all
material respects, in accordance with GAAP
Page 37 of 80
Financial & Compliance Audit
June 30, 2025
Compliance Reports
Financial Report contains two (2) Compliance Reports:
Single Audit Report
• Compliance audit
• Required > $750k in federal expenditures
• Unmodified (Clean) Opinion
Yellow Book Report
• Report on City’s Internal Controls and Compliance
• Not Intended to Provide an Opinion
• No Material Weaknesses or Significant Deficiencies
Noted During Our Audit
Page 38 of 80
Financial & Compliance Audit
June 30, 2025
Overview of Financial Statements
• City prepares an Annual Comprehensive Financial
Report (ACFR)
• ACFR goes above and beyond basic reporting
requirements
• Submitted annually to Government Finance
Officers Association (GFOA)
• City awarded ACFR Certificate for 18th year in a
row
Page 39 of 80
Financial & Compliance Audit
June 30, 2025
Overview of Financial Statements
Management’s Discussion & Analysis (MD&A)
• Written by Management
• Introduces and Summarizes Basic Financial Statements
• Comparative Information
City’s Financial Statements Include Three (3) Components
• Government-Wide Financial Statements
• Fund Level Financial Statements
• Notes to the Financial Statements
Page 40 of 80
Financial & Compliance Audit
June 30, 2025
Government-Wide Financial Statements
• $123.3 Million = total assets and deferred outflows
• $76.2 Million = capital assets, net of A/D
• $57.8 Million = total liabilities and deferred inflows
• $65.5 Million = net position (or equity)
• $40.9 Million = revenues ($40.2M in FY24)
• $32.7 Million = expenses ($33.6M in FY24)
• Increase in Net Position of $8.2M vs $6.6M increase in PY
Page 41 of 80
Financial & Compliance Audit
June 30, 2025
General Fund Revenues
10,309,148
2,407,025
80,238
7,777,981
3,891,676
2,023,401
821,472 120,887
Property taxes
Franchise fees
Fines and forfeitures
Licenses and permits
Intergovernmental
Charges for services
Investment earnings
Miscellaneous
Page 42 of 80
Financial & Compliance Audit
June 30, 2025
General Fund Expenditures
5,096,058
6,967,999
6,909,194
2,488,927
862,272
1,303,344
2,796,057
General government
Law enforcement
Fire and emergency
Public works
Streets
Community and development
Debt service
Page 43 of 80
Financial & Compliance Audit
June 30, 2025
General Fund - Fund Balance History
-
2,000,000
4,000,000
6,000,000
8,000,000
10,000,000
12,000,000
14,000,000
16,000,000
18,000,000
June 30, 2021 June 30, 2022 June 30, 2023 June 30, 2024 June 30, 2025
Page 44 of 80
Financial & Compliance Audit
June 30, 2025
Importance of Maintaining a Strong Fund Balance
• Cash flow through beginning of next fiscal year
• Significant emergencies and unanticipated
expenditures (i.e. weather-related costs)
• Flexibility for discretionary funding needs
• Potential for better interest rates on debt
issues
• Important in uncertain economic times
Page 45 of 80
Financial & Compliance Audit
June 30, 2025
Required Communications
• Clean Opinion and No Audit Findings
• We Received Full Cooperation from Management and Staff
• No Disagreements with Management
• No Significant Issues Discussed with Management
• No Uncorrected Misstatements
• We are Independent of the City as Required by Government
Auditing Standards
Page 46 of 80
Financial & Compliance Audit
June 30, 2025
Closing
We appreciate the opportunity to serve the City of Beaufort and look
forward to serving the City in the future.
Page 47 of 80
Annual Comprehensive
Financial Report Overview
Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 2025
January 27, 2026
Page 48 of 80
INTRODUCTION
As management of the City of Beaufort, SC, we offer readers of the City of Beaufort’s financial
statements this narrative overview and analysis of the financial activities of the City for the fiscal
year ended June 30, 2025. Management encourages readers to consider the information
presented within this discussion and analysis in conjunction with additional information presented
as part of this report. Readers are directed to the transmittal letter, financial statements, notes to
the financial statements and statistical information to enhance their understanding of the City’s
financial performance.
This report presents the financial highlights for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2025 and contains
other supplementary information.
Management Discussion and Analysis
Page 49 of 80
The following table presents a summary of the City’s Net Position as of June 30, 2025.
Page 50 of 80
Government-Wide Financial Highlights
• The assets and deferred outflows of the City exceeded its liabilities and deferred inflows at the close of the most
recent fiscal year by $65,514,994 (net position). Unrestricted net position is reported as ($2,078,990) due to the
effects of reporting net pension liability in accordance with GASB Statement No. 68, Accounting and Financial
Reporting for Pensions – an amendment of GASB Statement No. 27, which is not an accurate representation of the
City’s financial position to meet the government’s ongoing obligations to citizens and creditors. Excluding net
pension liability ($18,390,355) from net position, results in $16,311,365 unrestricted net position available to meet
the City’s ongoing obligations to citizens and creditors.
• The City’s total cash position at June 30, 2025 was $39,629,758 compared to $40,438,725 at June 30, 2024, a
slight decrease primarily due to the City’s prudent spending along with the use of bond funds for capital projects.
• As of June 30, 2025, the City’s long-term indebtedness, including the liability for accrued vacation and net pension
liability, had decreased a net of $2,220,284 from June 30, 2024. The $1,320,184 for issuance of leases and
subscription arrangements contributed to the increase in debt along with $3,503,974 decrease from scheduled debt
payments led to the overall net decrease.
• The City’s bond rating from Standard & Poor’s is AA and an Aa2 rating from Moody’s Investors Services for general
obligation debt.
• Property taxes support 39% of the governmental services to citizens and the community
in fiscal year 2025.
Page 51 of 80
The following table presents a summary of the City’s Statement of Activities as of June 30, 2025.
Page 52 of 80
Government-Wide Revenue Highlights
Overall revenues increased $706,660 or 1.7% over the preceding year. Key elements of significant changes in
governmental activity revenues are as follows:
• Charges for service increased $698,801 or 4.1% primarily as a result of additional fire services support from
Town of Port Royal ($321,267), business development growth increasing fire impact fees ($212,802) and
building permits ($185,159).
• Operating grants and contributions decreased a net $910,952 or 22.3% which is mostly due from a federal
American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) grant revenue recognized during the fiscal year for an increase of $1,074,807
along with decrease of state grants of $1,975,559 from a cybersecurity and workforce initiative grant received
in the prior fiscal year.
• Capital grants and contributions increased by $1,094,637 or 115% primarily as result of capital grants for
infrastructure related to Allison Road Project that completed construction towards the end of fiscal year 2025
and Downtown Drainage Projects continued in the engineering and design phase.
• Taxes increased a net $465,651 or 2.9%. Property taxes increased $638,776 from growth in assessed property
values and accommodations taxes decreased $281,200 as tourism activity slowed down slightly from last year’s
record tourism year.
• Other General Revenues decreased $641,477 or 23.8%. The City recognized one-time insurance proceeds and
sale of property in the prior fiscal year.
Page 53 of 80
Government-Wide Expense Highlights
Overall expenses decreased $940,717 or 2.8% over the preceding year. Significant changes in expenses within
governmental activities are as follows:
• General government expenses decreased $2,096,919 or 23.5% predominately from grant-related
disbursements for cybersecurity and workforce initiatives recognized last year.
• Law enforcement expenses increased $641,362 or 8.8% predominately from a combination of personnel and
benefits increases of $235,239 along with recording amortization expenses related to the City’s
implementation of GASB 87 Leases.
• Street expenses increased $403,498 or 30.5% mostly due to depreciation for the recently completed Allison
Road project.
Page 54 of 80
The following is Statement of Revenues, Expenditures, and Changes in Fund Balance as of June 30, 2025.
Page 55 of 80
General Fund Revenue Highlights
General fund revenues increased $1,464,264 or 5% from the prior year. The significant changes are primarily
attributed to the following:
• Property taxes reported a 7.4% increase totaling $713,924. This increase is primarily related to a
growing tax base as the housing market reached unprecedented levels.
• A decrease of $1,637,620 or 29.6% is reported in intergovernmental revenue as the City received a
one-time $2,000,000 state grant for cybersecurity and workforce initiatives during the previous fiscal
year and a $321,267 increase from Town of Port Royal for shared costs related to fire services.
• Interest earnings revenue increased $118,211 or 16.8% as a result of a slightly higher interest rate
market on the City’s investments.
• Miscellaneous revenues decreased $827,092 or 87.2% due to one-time revenues from property sales
of $433,602 for land at Beaufort Commerce Park and $390,907 from insurance proceeds for a fire truck
repair recognized in the prior fiscal year.
Page 56 of 80
General Fund Expenditure Highlights
The General Fund expenditures decreased $413,114 or 1.5% over fiscal year ended June 30, 2025.
• General government decreased $1,398,458 or 21.5% as a one-time land purchase and expenditures
associated with a cybersecurity and workforce state grant were recognized in the prior fiscal year.
• Law enforcement saw a $663,609 or 10.5% increase over the prior year. Net increases in personnel
and benefits attributed to $285,662 of the overall increase and the police department added fourteen
leased vehicles upfitted with equipment to replace older vehicles for an additional $126,385.
• Public Works increased $116,374 or 4.9% as mostly due to an increase from an adjustment in the
contract for residential garbage collection.
Page 57 of 80
Other Major Funds Highlights
Tax Increment Financing District II Fund (TIF II)
The TIF II Fund expended $46,814 or $25,252 more than fiscal year 2024. This increase is associated with traffic signal
improvements on Boundary Street. Revenues of $171,067 were $14,821 lower than prior year due to a slightly lower
interest rate environment in investment earnings.
Capital Projects Fund
The Capital Project Fund expended $7,341,782 or $3,082,027 more than fiscal year 2024. The increase is attributable
to more capital projects in construction phase, rather than in the design and engineering stage. Most of the current
year activity is a result of three projects: engineering and construction for Washington Street Park Phase I project for
$639,768, construction for Southside Park Phase I improvements for $2,334,339, and costs associated with large
stormwater drainage projects in The Point and surrounding areas of the City totaling $3,075,412. During fiscal year
2025, the City had thirteen (13) active capital projects that were underway and at various stages of completion.
Parks and Tourism Fund
The Parks & Tourism fund expended $5,342,573 in the current year which is $895,270 more than the prior year and
revenues of $5,719,730 were $231,630 more than FY 2024. The increase in revenues is mostly due to insurance
proceeds received for damages occurring during Hurricane Helene. The increase in expenditures is predominately a
result of $660,503 for budgeted initial principal and interest debt payments associated with the 2024 hospitality and
accommodations fee revenue bonds and $98,935 in repairs to the marina from Hurricane Helene.
Page 58 of 80
Other Major Funds Highlights
American Rescue Plan Act Fund
The American Rescue Plan Act fund expended $751,877 in the current year mostly related to purchase for playground
equipment at Pigeon Point Park and support to our local partners for affordable housing initiatives. Revenues were
$2,696,473 from federal grant along with interest and unearned revenues of $1,942,133 are shown as a liability on
the balance sheet as grant revenues are not considered earned until they have been expended. The other financing
uses comprises of $1,749,285 transfers out to the capital projects fund for road paving, boat landing and drainage
projects
Stormwater Fund
Stormwater operating revenue of $1,395,715 which is $12,122 less than fiscal year 2024 as revenues remain stable in
stormwater fees. Stormwater operating expenditures were $1,249,426 and included $515,755 for debt service
payments. The other financing uses comprises of $728,271 transfers out to the capital projects fund for drainage
projects throughout the City.
Page 59 of 80
Annual Comprehensive
Financial Report Overview
Questions/Comments
Page 60 of 80
City of Beaufort
Department Request for City Council Agenda Item
To: City Council Date: 01/22/2026
From: Linda Roper, Downtown Operations Director
Item Name: Discussion of establishing a Pilot Social District in Downtown Beaufort
Meeting Date: January 27, 2026
Department: Downtown Operations
Background Information:
Introduction:
City Council previously appointed the Tiger Team to identify strategies to strengthen downtown
vitality, support local businesses, and increase economic activity. Through research, stakeholder
input, and review of best practices from peer communities, the Tiger Team evaluated
opportunities to enhance the downtown experience and encourage longer dwell times.
As part of this work, the Tiger Team recommended exploring the establishment of a downtown
social district as one potential tool to increase foot traffic, support existing businesses, and create
a more active and connected downtown environment during designated days and times.
Background:
Many communities across South Carolina and the Southeast have implemented Social Districts
as a tool to enhance downtown vibrancy, encourage foot traffic, and support local businesses.
Social Districts create a defined public space where visitors can enjoy food, beverages, activities,
and programming in a safe, community-focused environment. Participating establishments may
also offer beer and wine for consumption within the district in accordance with local and state
regulations.
City Staff along with our community partners, Beaufort Area Hospitality Association, Beaufort
Regional Chamber of Commerce and Greater Beaufort-Port Royal CVB, are exploring the
possibility of establishing a pilot Social District in Downtown Beaufort. A pilot approach would
allow the City to define district boundaries, operating hours, participation requirements, and
safety measures while assessing community response and potential economic impact.
Legal Authority:
SC Code 5-7-10 Home Rule and General Powers
Page 61 of 80
Staff Recommendation:
Placed on Agenda For:
Attachments:
1. Social District Map semi final
Page 62 of 80
SOCIAL DISTRICT
Page 63 of 80
City of Beaufort
Department Request for City Council Agenda Item
To: City Council Date: 01/22/2026
From: Linda Roper, Downtown Operations Director
Item Name: Discussion on creating a Downtown Advisory Board
Meeting Date: January 27, 2026
Department: Downtown Operations
Background Information:
Introduction:
Beaufort City Council has recommended the formation of a Downtown Advisory Board to
provide advisory input on downtown-related policies, programs, and initiatives in support of the
City’s Strategic Plan. This discussion will determine the Board makeup and focus.
Background:
The Downtown Advisory Board will serve as a structured forum for engagement with downtown
businesses, property owners, residents, and key partners. The committee will provide
recommendations to City Council and staff on matters such as downtown infrastructure
improvements, tourism management, parking management, construction impacts, business
recruitment and retention, special events, and long-range planning initiatives. This advisory role
will strengthen coordination, improve transparency, and support proactive problem-solving.
Legal Authority:
SC Code Ann 5-7-10 Home Rule and General Powers
Staff Recommendation:
Placed on Agenda For:
Attachments:
1. Downtown Advisory Board - Suggested Board Make Up (2)
Page 64 of 80
Downtown Advisory Board
Suggested Board Makeup
The Board should be a good representation of the district with a variety of
professions and sectors. The Board should consist of 9-15 members to
provide diversity but small enough to remain effective.
Suggested members:
Downtown Business Owners & Operators – 3 seats
• Retail Store – 1
• Accommodations – 1
• Tour Operator -1
Downtown Property Owners/Developer – 2
Neighborhood Representatives – 3
• The Point – 1
• Old Commons – 1
• NWQ – 1
Historic Beaufort Foundation – 1
Beaufort-Port Royal Convention and Visitors Bureau – 1
Beaufort Regional Chamber of Commerce – 1
Beaufort County Black Chamber of Commerce – 1
Beaufort Area Hospitality Association – 1
Ex-Officio Members (non-voting)
Main Street Director
Tour and Event Coordinator
Planning Department Staff Liaison
Police Department Liaison
Fire Department Liaison
Page 65 of 80
City of Beaufort
Department Request for City Council Agenda Item
To: City Council Date: 01/09/2026
From: Stephenie Price, Police Chief
Item Name: Noise Ordinance
Meeting Date: January 27, 2026
Department: Police Department
Background Information:
Introduction:
The purpose of this agenda item is to request City Council’s consideration, review, and potential
revision of Beaufort’s noise ordinance to improve clarity, consistency, and alignment with
current community expectations. This review will also consider emerging noise sources, quality-
of-life concerns for residents, and the need to balance neighborhood impacts with business and
event activity.
Background:
Over the past years, the noise ordinance has served as guidance for addressing loud and
unseemly noise within the city. After discussion during the recent work session, City Council
requested that staff work collaboratively with the City Attorney to review the ordinance and
suggest potential revisions. The resulting review is intended to ensure the ordinance remains
effective, legally sound, and reflective of community expectations.
Legal Authority:
The City of Beaufort is authorized to adopt, amend, and enforce noise regulations pursuant to the
Home Rule powers granted to municipalities under South Carolina law. Section 5-7-30 of the
South Carolina Code of Laws authorizes municipalities to enact ordinances necessary for the
protection of public health, safety, and welfare, including the regulation of activities that may
constitute a public nuisance. Noise control ordinances fall within this general police power.
The City of Beaufort has the legal authority to review, revise, and enforce its noise ordinance to
address quality-of-life concerns and community standards within the city.
Staff Recommendation:
Page 66 of 80
Staff recommends that City Council adopt the draft noise ordinance as presented and reviewed
by the City Attorney. The proposed ordinance reflects direction provided by City Council,
incorporates legal review to ensure consistency with applicable state law, and is intended to
improve clarity, fairness, and enforceability. Adoption of the draft ordinance will provide clear
standards for residents, businesses, and enforcement personnel, while supporting quality of life
objectives and community expectations within the City of Beaufort.
Placed on Agenda For:
Attachments:
1. 1412.0209 Draft Noise Ordinance
2. Current Loud and Unseemly Noise Ordinance
3. 20260107153810876
Page 67 of 80
Sec. 9-1008. - Noise.
(a) Noises Prohibited. Any loud, obnoxious, unnecessary, or excessive noise which disturbs or interferes
with the comfortable enjoyment of persons of ordinary sensibilities occupying, owning or controlling
nearby properties, or persons making use of commercial or public properties for their intended
purposes, is prohibited. Prohibited noises include, without limitation, the following:
(1) Any sound made between the hours of 10:00 p.m. and 7:00 a.m. which exceeds 60 decibels,
measured using a digital sound meter;
(2) Any sound made between the hours of 7:00 a.m. and 10:00 p.m. which exceeds 80 decibels,
measured using a digital sound meter;
(3) The use of obscene language at a volume that is louder than that necessary for normal
conversation;
(4) The use of words which threaten or tend to threaten or incite physical violence, or which
endanger or tend to endanger the health and safety of others, which are stated for the
purpose of willfully disturbing any person or business;
(5) The use of a motor vehicle in a manner which emits loud and unseemly noise which disturbs
any residence, neighborhood, or business.
(b) Exceptions. This section shall not apply to the following:
(1) The use of a vehicular horn for the purpose of notifying those nearby of the presence of
another vehicle or a potential hazard;
(2) The sound produced by the use of equipment owned or operated by federal, state, or local
governments including, but not limited to emergency response vehicles, law enforcement
vehicles, EMS vehicles and fire district response vehicles;
(3) The sound produced by construction machinery, heavy duty equipment, and machines and
equipment used for construction, repair, cleaning, and maintenance of buildings, streets, or
public or private premises when operated between the hours of 7:00 a.m. and 7:00 p.m.;
(4) The sound produced by bells or chimes or other carillon instruments when used to signify the
passage of hour, half-hour or quarter-hour components, or to commemorate a wedding,
funeral or similar event, including regular religious services, provided the sounds do not
exceed five continuous minutes in duration in any one-hour period;
(5) Aircraft in flight or in operation at an airport;
(6) Railroad equipment in operation on railroad rights-of-way;
(7) The sound emanating from a ballpark, playing field, stadium, or comparable outdoor facility
designed and intended for recreational or sports activity when used for organized exhibitions
or participatory sports or recreational activities;
(8) Sounds produced by properly permitted parades, special events, or fireworks displays;
(9) Amplified music played at any bar, restaurant, theatre, or similar commercial establishment
located in an entertainment district (as designated by Sec. _____) between the hours of 5:00
p.m. and 1:00 a.m. that does not exceed 85 decibels when measured at the property line of
the establishment from which the music is being generated;
(10) The sound produced by an electrical generator when that generator is being used to provide
electricity to a dwelling unit or business to which electricity is temporarily not being provided
by a public utility as a result of inclement weather, natural disaster, or other emergency
situation beyond the control of the owner or occupant of the dwelling unit or business.
(c) Enforcement. Any person convicted of a violation of this section shall be deemed guilty of a
misdemeanor and, upon conviction, shall be subject to a fine not exceeding the maximum allowed
within the jurisdiction of the Municipal Court for the City of Beaufort, or imprisonment not exceeding
30 days, or both.
Page 68 of 80
• Sec. 9-1008. - Loud and unseemly noise.
(a) It shall be unlawful for any person to willfully disturb any neighborhood or business
in the City by making or continuing loud and unseemly noises, or by profanely cursing
and swearing, or using obscene language. It shall further be unlawful for any person
to willfully disturb any neighborhood or business within the city by the use of words
which threaten or tend to threaten or incite physical violence, or which endanger or
tend to endanger the health and safety of others within the city.
(b) On Bay Street and its sidewalks, bounded by Carteret and Charles Streets, noise
generated by the unamplified human voice at a decibel level in excess of seventy (70)
[decibels], measured by a Realistic® sound level decimeter, or its equivalent, (adjusted
to "A" for weighing voice recordings and response selector on "slow") located fifty (50)
feet from the source, between the hours of 10:00 a.m. and 6:00 p.m., Monday through
Saturday, and between the hours of 12:00 noon and 6:00 p.m. on Sunday, shall be
prima facie loud and unseemly noise (momentary peaks shall not exceed seventy-five
(75) decibels). Upon determination that the volume of such unamplified human voice
exceeds this decibel level, a police official shall first warn the offending individual(s) of
the violation of his/her conduct. Continued measurement of the level of noise by the
offending individual(s) exceeding this decibel level after such warning shall constitute
prima facie evidence of willful violation of subsection (a).
(c) Except as within the Nighttime Music District as defined in subsection (d) below and
on any lot zoned Industrial Park District, the use of horns, radios, phonographs, loud
speakers, whistles, exhausts, pile drivers, blowers, or other devices not numerated
here, but which cause loud or irritating noises, between the hours of 9:00 p.m. and
8:00 a.m., which are plainly audible from a distance of fifty (50) feet from its source,
shall be considered prima facie evidence of a violation of subsection (a), unless such
device was used as a danger warning or in some similar emergency or a permit has
been granted by the city manager or city council for same. As to properties located
within the Nighttime Music District, as defined in subsection (d) below, the following
shall apply:(1) the use of horns, radios, phonographs, amplifiers, loudspeakers,
whistles, exhausts, pile drivers, blowers, or other devices not numerated here, but
which cause loud or irritating noises, between the hours of 10:00 p.m. and 1:00 a.m.
on Sunday through Thursday nights only, which are plainly audible from a distance of
fifty (50) feet from its source, shall be considered prima facie evidence of violation of
subsection (a); and (2) the use of horns, radios, phonographs, amplifiers,
loudspeakers, whistles, exhausts, pile drivers, blowers, or other devices not
numerated here, but which cause loud or irritating noises, between the hours of 1:00
a.m. and 7:00 a.m., which are plainly audible outside the exterior walls of the building
containing its source, shall be considered prima facie evidence of a violation of
subsection (a). Notwithstanding any time periods or other provisions of this section,
sound (from any of the sources specified herein) which exceeds eighty-five (85)
decibels (dB(C)) measured at any time at the property line of the establishment from
Page 69 of 80
which the music is being generated shall be considered prima facie evidence of a
violation of subsection (a).
(d) Nighttime Music District. A Nighttime Music District is hereby established and shall
include those parcels and properties and portions of those parcels and properties
contained within the following boundaries: all those parcels of land encompassed by
the tract bounded on the north by the southern right of way of Bay Street, on the west
and the south by the highwater mark of the Beaufort River, and on the east by the
western right-of-way of Carteret Street.
The Nighttime Music District is also delineated on the map which is incorporated in
this chapter and shown on the next page.
(e) The loud playing of radios, phonographs, tape decks, amplifiers, and loudspeakers,
and other sound devices in any public park, outdoor public place, or privately owned
or controlled courtyards or outdoor areas, including from vehicles, the sound and/or
noise which is substantially audible to the distance of fifty (50) feet or more, shall be
prima facie evidence of a violation of subsection (a). Notwithstanding any time periods
or other provisions of this section, sound (from any of the sources specified herein)
which exceeds eighty-five (85) decibels (dB(C)) measured at any time at the property
line of the establishment from which the music is being generated shall be considered
prima facie evidence of a violation of subsection (a).
(f) There shall be no violation under subsections (c) or (e) of this section for special
events provided a permit is first obtained from the city.
(g) It shall be unlawful for any person to drive, propel or otherwise operate a
motorized vehicle in a manner which emits loud and unseemly noise, which willfully
disturbs any residence, neighborhood or business in the city. The prohibition of this
subsection shall include operating a motorized vehicle by rapid throttle advancing
(revving) of an internal combustion engine resulting in increased noise from the
engine.
(1962 Code, § 22-1; Ord. No. O-12-81, 7-28-81; Ord. No. O-15-91, 4-23-91; Ord. No. O-
30-91, 10-22-91; Ord. No. O-23-94, 11-22-94; Ord. No. O-01-00, 1-11-00; Ord. No. O-06-
00, 2-8-00; Ord. No. O-09-09, § 1, 3-24-09; Ord. No. O-14-12, §§ 1, 2, 7-10-12; Ord. No.
O-5-19, § 6, 6-11-19)
Cross reference— Noise by sidewalk vendors, § 7-9008(13).
Page 70 of 80
Page 71 of 80
City of Beaufort
Department Request for City Council Agenda Item
To: City Council Date: 01/18/2026
From: Scott Marshall, City Manager
Item Name: Discussion of the Merits of Adopting a "No Comments" Policy on the City's
Facebook Page
Meeting Date: January 27, 2026
Department: City Managers Office
Background Information:
Introduction:
The purpose of this discussion is to provide City Council with an overview of the considerations
associated with disabling public commenting on the City of Beaufort’s official Facebook page.
The discussion is intended to assist Council in determining whether they would be in support of
formal adoption of such a policy.
Background:
The City uses its official Facebook page primarily as a means of distributing timely information
to residents, businesses, and visitors. When a municipality allows comments on an official social
media page, the interactive portion of that page is generally considered a limited public forum,
which requires viewpoint-neutral moderation and consistent enforcement of content rules.
In recent months, the volume, tone, and complexity of comment activity has increased, requiring
greater staff monitoring, higher potential for allegations of selective moderation, and an elevated
risk that misinformation or personal attacks will appear directly beneath official City posts.
Several municipalities have addressed these concerns by adopting a “no comments” policy that
preserves the informational function of the platform while reducing legal and operational
burdens.
Legal Authority:
Municipal social media activity is governed by First Amendment principles regarding public
forums. Allowing comments typically creates a limited public forum that obligates the City to
apply content-neutral moderation standards and exposes the City to potential claims of viewpoint
Page 72 of 80
discrimination if comments are removed inconsistently.
Disabling comments entirely is considered a content-neutral restriction when applied uniformly.
While it does not eliminate all legal considerations, it significantly reduces exposure associated
with selective comment removal, the need for detailed moderation protocols, and disputes arising
from inconsistent enforcement. Adoption of a written social media policy by Council would
provide clear authority and guidance for staff implementation.
Staff Recommendation:
Staff presents this report for Council discussion and direction. Should Council decide to support
a “no comments” policy for the City’s official Facebook page, staff recommends the following:
Formal Adoption by Resolution: Approve a written social media policy specifying that the
official Facebook page is used for informational purposes only and that commenting is
disabled across all posts.
Public Communication: Issue a clear announcement explaining the purpose of the change and
directing residents to alternative ways to provide feedback.
Strengthen Engagement Channels: Promote existing communication pathways—including
website forms, departmental email contacts, public meetings, and community listening
sessions—to ensure continued accessibility for all residents.
Next Steps:
If policy is supported, then staff will bring a Resolution for consideration to memoeiralize the
decision.
If policy is not supported, staff will include an additional FTE in the proposed FY27
consolidated budget to establish a Social Media Manager position to manage the City's social
media presence, to include monitoring social media platform comments to ensure compliance
with local policies and public law.
Placed on Agenda For:
Attachments:
1. Background Paper
Page 73 of 80
BACKGROUND PAPER ON ADOPTING A “NO
COMMENTS” POLICY FOR THE CITY’S OFFICIAL
FACEBOOK PAGE
Policy Concept:
The city’s official Facebook page remains visible and active for one-way communication (posts,
photos, videos, links), but all public commenting is turned off (either on all posts, or on most
posts as a default). Residents can still react (“likes,” etc.) and may still message the page, email,
call, or attend meetings, but they cannot publicly reply under posts.
This is different from moderating comments (removing a subset under a policy) and different
from an elected official’s personal page—courts now treat those differently after the U.S.
Supreme Court’s 2024 decision in Lindke v. Freed, which clarified when a public official’s
social media activity counts as state action subject to the First Amendment.
Potential merits (reasons a city might adopt “no comments”)
1. Reduced legal risk and simpler First Amendment posture
If you allow comments, you are very likely creating at least a limited public forum in the
“interactive” portion of the page, which triggers First Amendment constraints on how you
moderate. That principle was at the core of Davison v. Randall in the Fourth Circuit (which
includes South Carolina). The court held that the interactive portion of an official page was a
public forum and that blocking a critic there for his views violated the First Amendment.
Once you open that door, you must:
• Develop and apply viewpoint-neutral moderation rules
• Train staff to moderate consistently
• Risk litigation or complaints if someone believes they were blocked or deleted because
they were critical
By contrast, never enabling comments arguably avoids creating that forum in the first place.
That can:
• Reduce risk of viewpoint discrimination claims about selective deletion of comments
• Reduce the need for detailed moderation logs and documentation
• Simplify the city’s legal posture: the page is informational, not a discussion forum
Page 74 of 80
Important caveat: there’s no absolute guarantee a court would bless any particular setup, but the
risk profile is materially different from an open-comment page you curate case-by-case.
2. Staff capacity, workload, and mental health
Where comments are open, someone has to:
• Monitor for defamation, threats, harassment, obscenity, spam, scams, etc.
• Respond (or at least triage) genuine service requests and complaints
• Capture and retain comments as public records, depending on state/local practice
That can consume a lot of time and emotional bandwidth, especially in periods of controversy
(development disputes, police incidents, tax increases, etc.). Municipal best-practice guidance
increasingly notes that comment moderation can be a “second job” for communications staff and
that unmanaged spaces can quickly devolve into “toxic” forums.
Turning off comments:
• Makes workload predictable and bounded
• Reduces after-hours monitoring pressure (nights, weekends, holidays)
• Limits staff exposure to abusive, personal attacks that can lead to burnout
3. Limiting misinformation and harassment in city-branded spaces
Open comment threads can easily host:
• Misinformation about projects, safety, or policies
• Personal attacks on staff, elected officials, and residents
• Discriminatory or hateful speech that, while potentially protected, is reputationally
damaging if it appears on an official page
A no-comments policy:
• Prevents the city’s official channels from becoming a platform for harmful or misleading
content directly attached to the city’s own posts
• Keeps the visual experience cleaner for residents who are just looking for information
(e.g., “Is King Street closed today?”)
People will still talk—on neighborhood groups, local pages, etc.—but the city isn’t hosting or
curating that discourse under its own masthead.
4. Clarity and consistency vs. case-by-case censorship accusations
Page 75 of 80
Courts and advocacy groups warn that deleting negative comments while leaving positive ones is
classic viewpoint discrimination.
A blanket policy of “we don’t host comments on this page at all” can be seen as:
• Content-neutral (no one gets to comment, pro or con)
• More defensible than a pattern of deleting only certain viewpoints
• Easier to explain than explaining why some critical comments stay and others go
5. Channeling engagement into more manageable, formal pathways
Some municipalities and officials who disable comments emphasize that they’re not refusing
feedback; they’re redirecting it. For example, a mayor in Australia justified turning off
comments on her own account by pointing residents to moderated council channels and
traditional contact methods instead.
A city might do the same:
• Use Facebook as a notice board (agenda links, alerts, press releases)
• Direct questions to:
o 311 or customer service systems
o Web forms
o Email addresses by department
o Public meetings and hearings
This can:
• Move conversations into channels where staff can track, route, and close the loop
• Reduce the risk of important service issues getting buried in comment threads
Potential drawbacks (costs and risks of “no comments”)
1. Perception of reduced transparency and accessibility
Residents increasingly assume that if the city posts on Facebook, they can respond right there.
Turning off comments risks:
• Perception that the city is “afraid of criticism,” is “silencing dissent,” or doesn’t want to
listen
Page 76 of 80
• Frustration from people who primarily use Facebook and may not seek out email or other
channels
Even if listening is happening through other means, the optics of “comments off” can be
politically and reputationally challenging.
2. Lost opportunity for real-time engagement and rumor control
Comment threads, when managed well, can give staff:
• Early visibility into confusion, rumors, or anxiety in the community
• Opportunities to correct misinformation (“No, this does not affect your tax bill this year”)
in front of many readers at once
• A chance to show responsiveness and empathy in public
Without comments:
• Many of those conversations move to third-party groups where the city is absent or less
visible
• It’s harder to see what’s circulating and respond at scale
3. Equity and digital inclusion concerns
For some residents, especially:
• People with limited time or flexibility to attend meetings
• Residents who are more comfortable communicating in writing
• Younger or more online populations
Facebook comments may feel like the most accessible way to engage. Turning them off can:
• Skew participation toward people with the time and capacity to use more formal channels
• Undercut efforts around inclusive engagement and “meeting people where they are”
4. Potential public records and FOIA perception issues
If residents are used to commenting substantive concerns (e.g., drainage complaints, traffic
safety hazards) on posts, and the city then disables comments:
• Some may worry their input is now less documented or less likely to be preserved
• It can raise questions about whether the change is driven by avoidance of FOIA
exposure, even if that’s not the intent
Page 77 of 80
In reality, other channels (e.g., email, online forms) generally create more structured and
searchable records. But the optics can still be touchy if the policy rollout isn’t carefully
explained.
5. Relationship with elected officials’ own pages
The law now draws finer lines between official and personal/ campaign pages after Lindke v.
Freed and related commentary. If the city page disables comments, but:
• Individual elected officials keep comments open on their own pages, or
• Officials are perceived as discussing city business on personal channels
You can end up with:
• Confusion over where the “real” forum is
• Legal and practical risk shifting away from the municipal page and onto individual
officials who may be less equipped to manage it
Middle-ground approaches (if you don’t want a complete shutdown)
If the question is “should we ever allow comments?” rather than “do we allow comments right
now?” there are several compromise models:
1. Limited public forum with strict, viewpoint-neutral rules
Keep comments on, but adopt a clear written policy that:
• States the purpose of the page (e.g., to discuss city services and programs)
• Prohibits specific categories of content (true threats, incitement, obscenity, doxxing,
spam, commercial solicitations, discriminatory slurs, off-topic posts, etc.)
• Is applied equally to supportive and critical comments
This requires more work but preserves the interactive benefits while reducing some risks.
2. Comments on only some content types
For example:
• Comments on: general engagement posts (community events, “question of the day,” etc.)
• Comments off: quasi-adjudicatory posts (hearings, quasi-judicial land-use items), highly
polarizing topics, emergency alerts where clarity is paramount
Page 78 of 80
This lets you maintain a dialogue in lower-risk spaces while keeping especially sensitive posts as
one-way communication.
3. Time-limited comment windows
Enable comments for a defined period (e.g., 48–72 hours after posting), then close them. That
can:
• Capture initial feedback and allow for some dialogue
• Limit the long-tail of unmonitored comments weeks or months later
4. Separate “engagement channel”
Some governments treat:
• Website + email + meetings as official record channels
• Facebook as a supplementary outreach channel, with comments limited to specific,
structured engagement efforts (e.g., a time-bound survey or Q&A)
Practical considerations if adopting a no-comments policy
If a municipality decides to go with “no comments,” a more defensible and community-friendly
approach usually includes:
1. Written policy & legal review
o Adopt a formal social media policy approved by the governing body and vetted
by counsel.
o Clearly state that the city’s Facebook page is for information dissemination only
and list alternative participation channels.
2. Consistent application
o Turn off comments across the board, not selectively per viewpoint.
o Apply the same rule to all departments operating under the city’s umbrella, absent
a clear rationale for differences.
3. Communication with the public
o Announce the change with a pinned post and website note explaining:
▪ Why the change is being made (capacity, consistency, safety, legal clarity)
▪ Where and how residents can now comment or raise concerns
o Emphasize that feedback is still wanted, just through other mechanisms.
4. Strengthening alternative engagement
Page 79 of 80
o Ensure other channels are easy to find and responsive:
▪ Online forms, 311, dedicated email, town halls, listening sessions, etc.
o Consider periodic virtual Q&As or other formats that allow dialogue but on
clearer terms.
Bottom line
• Merits: Lower First Amendment risk around selective moderation, reduced staff and
mental-health burden, less misinformation and harassment hosted on official channels,
and clearer, more neutral rules (“nobody comments here”) rather than case-by-case
censorship accusations.
• Drawbacks: Real and perceived loss of transparency and accessibility, missed
opportunities for public dialogue and rumor control, equity concerns, and potential
political fallout from residents who see it as “closing the comments.”
Page 80 of 80
Source: City of Beaufort website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.