RecordWell Data

Planning Commission Regular Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Beaufort · Beaufort County · Planning Commission · meeting of Dec 15, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Beaufort

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

MEETING AGENDA The City of Beaufort PLANNING COMMISSION 1911 Boundary Street, Beaufort, SC 29902 Phone: 843-525-7011 ~ Fax: 843-986-5606 Monday, December 15, 2025, 5:00 P.M. City Hall, Council Chambers, 2nd Floor – 1911 Boundary Street, Beaufort, SC Please click the link below to join the webinar: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/81483285519?pwd=PozbejicwspV8kkZGGTjBdD8guVAlt.1 Password: 581624 Meeting ID: 814 8328 5519 Call in Phone #: 1+929-205-6099 STATEMENT OF MEDIA NOTIFICATION: "In accordance with South Carolina Code of Laws, 1976, Section 30-4-80(d), as amended, all local media were duly notified of the time, date, place and agenda of this meeting." Please note, this meeting will be broadcast via zoom and live-streamed on YouTube. You can view the meeting at the City's page; City Beaufort SC I. Call to Order II. Pledge of Allegiance III. Review of Commission Meeting Minutes: A. November 3, 2025 Worksession Minutes B. November 17, 2025 Regular Meeting Minutes IV. Questions Relating to Military Operations V. New Business: A. Sketch Plan Beaufort FSED & PCC – 396 Robert Smalls Parkway. The Applicant, Conor Blaney with Ward Edwards is proposing a commercial development to include a free-standing Emergency Department and a Primary Care Clinic. VI. Election of Historic District Task Force Representative VII. Board Meeting Schedule for 2026 VIII. Planning Worksession January 20206 Date IX. Election of Officers for 2026 X. Adjournment Note: If you have special needs due to a physical challenge, please call Julie Bachety at (843) 525-7011. Meeting Minutes PC Worksession – Nov. 3, 2025 1 Planning Commission Work Session Minutes – November 3, 2025 CALL TO ORDER 0:27 A work session of the Planning Commission was called to order by Chairman Mike Tomy and was held in- person in the Planning Conference Room on November 3, 2025 at 1:00 PM. The meeting was recorded and streamed on Facebook in accordance with City Policy. ATTENDEES Members who were in attendance: Mike Tomy, Chairman, Bill Bardenwerper, Vice-Chairman, Libby Anderson, Clinton Hallman, Benjie Morillo, and Bill Suter. Members Absent: Kim McFann Staff in attendance: Curt Freese, Community Development Department Director, Christopher Klement, Planner III and Nicolas Navia, Planner I. DISCUSSION 1:02 Before the discussion items occurred, Mr. Tomy went over a few things first. 1. Mr. Tomy asked Mr. Suter about the latest status of the Waterfront Park/Promenade rehabilitation project. Mr. Suter stated City Council will be reviewing this at their next work session on Tuesday, November 18. Meanwhile, a Questionnaire for better involvement and interaction with the citizens of the City of Beaufort was drafted to be disseminated. City Manager, Scott Marshall, will have it put on the City’s website and in the newspaper. There are 3 designs proposed and they will be presented after the first of the new year (2026). Citizen, Paul Trask, referred to the discussion of the marina lease in the Executive Session and said this is what got the City in trouble the first time, not revealing the details of a lease in public as it was being negotiated. 2. The new Historic District Task Force Committee that is being formed mentioned that Mr. Bardenwerper will be added to the task force as an ad-hoc position. Mr. Bardenwerper’s experience as a land attorney will be extremely helpful. There was a publication put out requesting people from the Northwest Quadrant community to get involved .There are five positions open and City Council will be appointing these. The deadline to apply is December 31, 2025. 2 Jeremy Tate consultant with Meadors Architecture went over some proposed changes. The Planning Commission (PC) started to review Chapter 4 Building Design and Infill Standards and agreed to discuss some of the major issues first. Mr. Tomy went over the Six General Design Principles: (1) Order, (2) Arrangement, (3) Symmetry, (4) Proportionalism, (5) Propriety and (6) Economy. After that the Commission members and staff delved into discussing potential revisions, starting with Chapter 4. The discussed changes are as follows:  Sec. 4.1.1.C – add “and bult environment” after the word natural and delete the wording neighboring development. Ms. Anderson spoke about the definition of Forecourt. It was agreed that the 12’ x 12’ might need to be edited. A good picture is also needed. Mr. Tate referred to Green Oaks Apartments as an example. PC agreed to keep the Forecourt but to change the language a bit. Mr. Tomy had an issue with slab on grade and also where the siding comes down to grade; its seen over and over and he referred to page 16 of the proposed code edits that were provided by Mr. Freese. It is also seen throughout other areas of the Code. Mr. Freese recommended adding following sentence: “Elevation - New construction shall be elevated” under Sec. 4.5.4.b.1. And adding the Elevation information from page 16 to page 17 as #9. PC agreed under Sec. 4.5.4 Single Family Detached House item B.2. to delete the sentence: “This height requirement does not apply outside of the Historic District.” Mr. Bardenwerper referred to section 4.5.7.B.1 that says, “Porches are not preferred, but may be used in buildings containing 12-units or less if they provide direct access to the unit from the street or sidewalk.” Also, add the word “porch” in front of the word “Stoop”. Ms. Anderson referred to Ashley Point. Mr. Bardenwerper referred to section 4.5.7.B.2 Parking on-site and the issues with parking on the street with apartment complex designs. Mr. Freese suggested removing the first sentence, “On-site parking must be located behind the building and accessed off a rear alley.” Mr. Freese stated there was a change under Sec. 4.5.9.B.3 under Height that the minimum height for Liner Building is now 16 feet and 2 stories instead of 1 story. Public Comment Paul Trask referred to the Take 5 Oil Change building on Robert Smalls Parkway, and a Liner Building addition that was placed on it so it would meet the Code requirement and it is still vacant today. He felt it would remain vacant for a long time. Mr. Tate referred to the Mavis Tire building on Lady’s Island. Mr. Trask also referred to the Chipotle and South Atlantic Bank building regarding drive-thrus. Public Comment Closed. The PC took a break at this time. 1:59:08 The PC reconvened at this time. The PC agreed to go over Chapter 4, page by page, 2:13:30 and proposed changes to following Sections: 3 4.1.1.B – remove the word “high” and change the word “street to streetscape”. 4.1.1.C – add the words “and built environment” and delete the words “surroundings and neighboring development.” 4.1.1.D – remove. 4.3.1.B – Under Intent, the word “climate”, needed to be added to the overall definition section. 4.3.1.C – change the wording to read “architecture vernacular.” 4.3.1.C – after shaped by local, add “design.” Add a period after craftsmanship and delete the rest of the sentence. 4.3.1.C – delete the second paragraph. 4.3.2.B – delete the sentence starting with “Relationship to the Street.” 4.3.2. D.1 – change “rectangular” to “complimentary”. 4.3.2.D.2 – add the words “when possible” after the word resemble and add “local businesses” after the word barns. 4.3.2.F.a – add the words “using historical proportions” after the word “wide”. Page 5 item b under Raised foundations – add the word “proportional” after the words “incorporate a” and change “foundation” to “foundation(s)” and change “waterlines” to “water table”. Page 5 item d under Low-pitched roofs delete the words “to reduce the amount of heat trapped in the building.” Need to add a definition for “pitch” to the overall definition page. Page 6 item iii – add “but must be properly actuated.” Page 6 item iv.1 – remove. Page 6 item v.1 – remove the sentence “Material options: Typically made from painted steel or galvalume” and add “With a long term or permanent color finish.” Page 6 item v.2 – remove the words “and are typically required to be dark gray or black.” Page 6 item vii.2 – add at the end of the sentence (Consider UV rating). Page 6 item vii.1 – remove sentence. Page 7 item viii – change “should” to “shall”. Page 8 item P.a – remove the word “gasoline”. 4 Page 8 item Q – remove the sentence “however, the Planning Commission or staff may work with applicants to incorporate limited signature design elements.” 4.5.1.C General – this is a repeat. Refer to the previous section that this also speaks about. Page 17 item h – remove the word “one” and replace it with “two”. Page 17 item 8.c – change rocks to “stone”. Page 18 item B.3 – add T3-S to the Location, Specific title and remove T3-N. The Planning Commission was unable to finish revising Chapter 4. Public Comment: Paul Trask asked if the rest of the changes will be brought up at a regular meeting or another worksession. Public Comment closed. The Planning Commission will discuss the rest of the Code amendments at their next Work Session on Monday, Dec. 1 st, 2025 at 1:00PM. 3:14:06 The Worksession ended at 4:41 pm. Meeting Minutes PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING Nov. 17, 2025 New Business - 396 ROBERT SMALLS PARKWAY Sketch Plan approval for development of a Free-Standing Emergency Department (FSED) & Patient-Care Center (PCC) by Novant Health STAFF REPORT: PLANNING COMMISSION (PC) – SKETCH PLAN 396 ROBERT SMALLS PARKWAY DATE: December 15, 2025 1 GENERAL INFORMATION Applicant: Conor Blaney with Ward Edwards (Engineer) for Novant Health Site Address / Tax PIN: 396 Robert Smalls Pkwy.; PIN: R120 028 000 1248 0000 Applicant's Request: Applicant is requesting Sketch Plan approval for new construction of a new medical complex, consisting of a 11,620 sq. ft. Free-Standing Emergency Department (FSED) and a 5,750 sq. ft. Primary Care Clinic (PCC). The proposed development will encompass approx. a third of the overall 14.4-ac. tract. Current Zoning: INSTITUTIONAL & CAMPUS DISTRICT (IC) Current Land Use: Undeveloped Flood Zone/Base Flood: Flood Zone: X, Elevation: > 13 ft. (Base-Flood Elevation) Existing Landmark/Specimen Trees: Following number of Specimen/Landmark trees are affected by this request: a. Laurel Oaks: 2x b. Live Oaks: 9x c. Loblolly pines: 19x d. Red Maples: 3x e. Southern Magnolias: 12x f. Sweetgum: 1x ZONING DISTRICT INFORMATION INSTITUTIONAL & CAMPUS DISTRICT (IC) Minimum Lot Width: 50 ft. min Minimum Lot Size: 5,000 sq. ft. min Max Impervious Lot Coverage: 65% Front Setback 10 ft. min. / Max. setback shall not exceed average max setback on same side of block; Side Setback Corner/Alley: 5 ft min Interior: 10 ft min (25 ft. when abutting T3-districts) Rear Setback 25 ft min. Building Height: 4 stories max SURROUNDING ZONING, LAND USE AND REQUIRED BUFFERS Adjacent Zoning Adjacent Land Uses Required Buffer type(s) - see Sec. 5.4.1; 5.4.2; 5.4.3) North: County Robert Smalls Leadership Academy (Beaufort County School) N/A South: IC Undeveloped remainder tract adjacent to “Beaufort Station” Front Buffer Requirement along Robert Smalls Pkwy.: “Type E” East: County Unincorporated section assoc. with Robert Smalls Academy / W.K. Alston Drive N/A West: IC 4000 Margaret - Multi-family residential Buffer Type “D” 2 Background: The applicant is requesting Sketch Plan approval pursuant to Code Section 7.5.3 for construction of a new medical & healthcare complex by Novant Health, consisting of a 11,620 sq. ft. Free -Standing Emergency Department (FSED) and a 5,750 sq. ft. Primary Care Clinic (PCC). The proposed development encompass es approx. 6 acres of the overall 14.4-acre tract (~40%). This entails 3.61 ac. in developed area and 1.11 ac. in civic/open space. The applicant has been to two (2) TRC Meetings before, i.e. July 1, 2025 & August 26, 2025. Tree Removal / Mitigation / Canopy Coverage Proposed: A total of 55 potential Landmark and Specimen trees have been identified to be affected by a Level 2 Assessment according to International Society of Arboriculture (ISA) standards. Eight (8) of these have structural, or health issues and thus should not be considered to their full value. The remaining 47 trees identified can be regarded to their full value in regards to structural and health integrity, with one of the trees (Mulberry) not being covered by Code Section 5.3.1 as a preservable Landmark/Specime n tree species. This leaves 46 identified Specimen/Landmark trees to be protected. However, the proposed Tree Canopy Coverage Assessment Table shows that a total of 55.72% of the disturbed area will be preserved with mature tree coverage and/or be provided in proposed complementary tree planting (street trees, buffers, open space). The minimum tree canopy coverage requirement in accordance with Code Sec. 5.3.2 for Commercial Developments is: 30%. Required elements of a Sketch Plan to be reviewed and discussed at a public meeting in accordance with Code Sec. 7.5.3.B: 1. Street Plan – The applicant shall provide a preliminary traffic plan that addresses the following elements: a. The proposed street network and connectivity to the existing Street network, including all proposed access points. Staff analysis: ➢ Street access / network connectivity: The proposed FSED & PCC will be accessible by a direct ingress/egress from S.C. Hwy. 170 (Right-in, right-out only - RIRO) and also will be accessible from a newly created spine road on the north-side of the property that will connect between W.K. Alston Drive and the “4000 Margaret” multi-family neighborhood. By proposing a connection to W. K. Alston Dr. by the new spine road, applicant needs to show that an encroachment permit from the Beaufort County School District, who owns the land in between, exists first!* ➢ Pedestrian / bicycle accessibility & connectivity: The newly built spine road on the north-side of the property will also incorporate a sidewalk on the north side to create a pedestrian connection between “4000 Margaret”, the Novant Health complex and W.K. Alston Dr. / Robert Smalls Leadership Academy. b. The location and layout of all arterial and collector roads within the development. Staff analysis: 3 ➢ The FSED & PCC will be directly accessible from S.C. Hwy. 170 (Robert Smalls Pkwy.) as well as from “4000 Margaret” and W.K. Alston Dr. through a new spine road connection. * ➢ In accordance with Sec. 7.2.3 – Lot Access Standards, the minimum prescribed separation between curb- cuts is 500 ft.; this is separation is just met between W.K. Alston Drive and the proposed RIRO- ingress/egress. c. The scope of a traffic impact study prepared by a S.C. licensed traffic engineer which evaluates proposed access points, the existing street system, and any need for any road improvements (including off-site improvements) created by the proposed development. Staff analysis: ➢ The Executive Summary of the TIA comes to the following conclusion: “Based on the results of the traffic analysis, the proposed Beaufort FSED Development is anticipated to have minimal impact on the surrounding road network. No mitigation due to the impacts is recommended as part of this TIA.” 2. Community Open Space Plan - The Applicant shall provide a preliminary open space plan that depicts compliance with Section 7.4 of this Code, with the following elements: a. Proposed Community open space distribution and location, including percentage of open space. Staff analysis: ➢ In accordance with Sec. 5.3.2 – Tree Coverage Requirements, the minimum tree canopy percentage of 30% for commercial projects is by far exceeded as the proposed development will be providing a canopy coverage percentage of 55.72%. ➢ In accordance with Sec. 7.4.2 – Community Green Space and Community Open Space Requirement, the provided Open Space with this development proposal (disturbed area: ~ 6 ac. of overall 14 ac. site) is 1.11 ac., which comes out to 18.5% of the disturbed area. Hence, the required 15% for property sizes of 3 – 10 ac. in the “IC district” is exceeded. ➢ In accordance with Sec. 7.4.3 – Community Green Space and Community Open Space Types, the overall medial complex development, and particularly in conjunction with future development of the remainder of the parcel, would largely benefit from more community-oriented and active types, such as a “Community Park”, “Greenway”, “Square/Green”, and/or “Plaza(s)”. b. Compliance with Section 7.4.2, Community Green Space and Community Open Space Requirement. Yes, complies. c. Required buffer areas in accordance with Section 5.5.1. Staff analysis: ➢ In accordance with Sec. 5.4.2 – Front Buffer Requirements along Major Corridors, the applicable location along Robert Smalls Pkwy. (S.C. 170) from Parris Island Gateway to the Broad River Bridge, 4 mandates Buffer Type E. The applicant has stated that Option 1 of Buffer Type E will be applied (see chart below). d. Wetland areas and setbacks as determined by SCDES-BCM, if applicable. Staff analysis: ➢ A small existing isolated wetland area (~0.049 ac.) on the north of the overall property will be protected by a 10 ft. wetland buffer and also will not be impacted as the proposed new spine road has been designed to go around it. e. Proposed park locations, acreage, and types of parks in accordance with Section 7.4. Staff analysis: ➢ Together with the aforementioned isolated wetland area, there is a ~16,053 sq. ft. (0.36 ac.) open space area to be preserved at the northwest corner of the overall property adjacent to “4000 Margaret”. Moreover, the provided open space area provided includes the immediate areas around the FSED & PCC buildings. Lastly, street trees and landscaping will be planted along the proposed spine road, the parking lot and internal streets as well as along the front buffer towards Robert Smalls Pkwy. 3. Pedestrian Network Staff analysis: ➢ As per developer, there will be a sidewalk provided along the north side of the new spine road to create a pedestrian network connection between “4000 Margaret”, W.K. Alston Dr. and the FSED & PCC facilities. ➢ There is no mention if the proposed sidewalk will be laid out to also provide for joint bicycle usage, or if there will any other bicycle network connections. ➢ No sidewalk / bike trail will be built along S.C. Hwy. 170 (Robert Smalls Pkwy.); this needs to be re- examined, as the Civic Master Plan clearly recommends “the installation of an off-street multi-use path with a wide landscaped separation from vehicular travel lanes in order to provide a comfortable, safe and beautiful option for pedestrian and cyclists.” (see page 6 below) 4. Zoning/Design Staff analysis: 5 ➢ In accordance with Sec. 2.3.3, the “IC district” is designed to support institutional uses, such as for hospitals, universities, research facilities, and offices in a campus-like setting. The proposal clearly aligns with this zoning-specific designation. 5. Overall Utility Plan Staff analysis: ➢ A street lighting plan which details street and site illumination of the new spine road and the parking lots, and other areas around the immediate FSED & PCC locations, has been included in the submittal package. ➢ An electricity supply plan which shows how the electricity network connections will be provided for underground, is forthcoming ➢ The applicant has submitted a confirmation email from “Beaufort Jasper Water & Sewer Authority – BJWSA” confirming that capacity for both water supply and sewer discharge, through a newly built gravity sewer pump station (SP-75) by the new 4000 Margaret complex, exist for this FSED & PCC proposal. Sketch Plan Review Criteria in accordance with Code Sec. 7.5.3.F: 1. The land use mix within the project conforms to Beaufort’s Zoning District Map and Comprehensive Plan Preferred / Future Land Use Map and furthers the goals and policies of the Comprehensive Plan: Staff analysis: ➢ As per below Future Land Use Map, the current Beaufort Comprehensive Plan identifies the location of the proposed Novant Health complex, consisting of a FSED & PCC, as both “Institutional” and part of an “Urban Center”. The current zoning district designation as “IC” are compliant with the goals for future land use development in this particular location along the Robert Smalls Parkway corridor. 6 2. The Sketch Plan is consistent with the rationale and criteria set forth in this Chapter, the City's Comprehensive Plan, and the Civic Master Plan as amended: Staff analysis: ➢ In Chapter 8.3 of the Civic Master Plan, Robert Smalls Parkway is identified as a “mixed-use corridor of vibrant activity”. In regards to streetscape improvements, the Civic Plan recommends “the installation of an off-street multi-use path with a wide landscaped separation from vehicular travel lanes in order to 7 provide a comfortable, safe and beautiful option for pedestrian and cyclists.” (page 172 et. seq.) – see chart below. 3. The preliminary traffic, open space, park, utility, and pedestrian design is adequate and functional given the existing and planned capacities of each system, and meets the standards found in this Code: Staff analysis: ➢ The vehicular access to the proposed FSED & PCC seem to be adequate. The proposed spine road connection between “4000 Margaret”, the Novant Health site and W.K. Alston Drive (Robert Smalls Leadership Academy) provides an adequate and absolutely necessary street network connection and access alternative away from the busy Robert Smalls Parkway corridor. ➢ However, better pedestrian & cyclist network connections between the residential (“4000 Margaret”), school (Robert Smalls Leadership Academy) and the new medical facilities could be provided. Also, further connections to the neighboring Walmart, Cross Creek Shopping Complex and other commercial, and residential neighborhoods could be provided for. Access and infrastructure connectivity for pedestrians & cyclists do not meet expectations. ➢ The proposed open space is landscaped very well, with a decent number of existing specimen and landmark trees preserved and integrated, however, the intent of Community Green Space and Community Open Space, as stated in Sec. 7.4.1 which “are intended for the use and enjoyment of a development’s residents, employees, or users”, do not seem to provide for enough active usage options. Provided Community Green / Open Space does not provide for active / integrative usage. 4. The conceptual design and massing proposed is consistent with the requirements of the Development Code: Staff analysis: ➢ The height of the proposed FSED & PCC buildings will be no more than 1 story. That underutilizes the permissible building height of 4 stories max. ➢ Design and massing of the buildings, particularly the building design, frontage and fenestration leaves room for improvement. Overall, the buildings architecturally are not reflective of the preferred Lowcountry vernacular! This includes such elements as “Bahama shutters”, “reeds”-textured Parklex rainscreen panels, brown and gray colors on the exterior. as well as too large window frames, faux windows, and the application of pre-fabricated cementitious building wall segments. Building elevations that face the street shall have at least 40% of the first-floor wall area consist of windows and/or doors, and 15% of upper floors. ➢ Sec. 4.6.4 – Specific to Conventional Districts – F. Additional Guidelines Specific to IC District: All buildings constructed as part of a campus may be subject to the guidelines for civic building outlined in Section 4.5.10, or shall be held to standards similar to the requirements in the surrounding context. ➢ Sec. 5.6.7 – Parking Lot Design – B. Pedestrian Corridors in Parking Lots: Parking lots with 40 spaces or greater shall be designed to separate pedestrian travel from vehicles. They shall include designated pedestrian walkways to provide safe access to building entries for pedestrians: 8 1. Perimeter sidewalks — typically located on public rights-of-way— and/or interior parking lot pedestrian corridors may be utilized to provide the required pedestrian access. 2. Pedestrian pathways (if provided) shall be a minimum 5 feet in width. 3. Where parking is located between a public entrance and the fronting sidewalk, a pedestrian pathway shall be provided, following the shortest practical route across the parking lot between at least 1 such entrance on each side of the building facing a public street. 4. Pedestrian pathways shall be clearly delineated with striping. This may also be accomplished with the use of paving materials that differ from that of vehicular areas, striping or other similar methods. ➢ Outline/plan for future development on remainder of property, including specifications on street network, future land uses, community green/open space locations and interconnectivity with surrounding neighborhood(s). ➢ Scaling, massing and building designs do not meet Comprehensive Plan, Civic Master Plan or Beaufort Development Code expectations for this location. FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS Findings: see Staff Analyses above Staff Recommendation: Table Sketch Plan approval at regular Planning Commission on 12-15-2025, until following staff comments and eventual PC comments have been addressed: ❖ Demonstrate how the remainder of the parcel will be developed and made accessible, including street connectivity; pedestrian / bike trail connections; type and placement of specific uses, and/or the concept of how the overall property development will fit into the surrounding development pattern and community along the Robert Smalls Parkway corridor; refer to all Sketch Plan elements in accordance with Code Sec. 7.5.3.B, which are: 1. Street Plan / Proposed street network, inter-connectivity (see staff analysis, page 2); 2. Open Space Plan to show which type of (active) community green / open spaces are provided for and where (see staff analysis, page 3); 3. Pedestrian Network, including better provision of inter-connectivity of sidewalks and trails for both pedestrians and cyclists (see staff analysis, page 4); and Sketch Plan Review Criteria pursuant to Code Sec. 7.5.3.F: The conceptual design and massing proposed (see staff analysis, page 7). ❖ The proposed new “spine road” on the north side of the entire property is absolutely necessary and a prerequisite for providing interconnectivity and a secondary ingress/egress point. However, a necessary encroachment permit for the traversing of Beaufort County Schools property along W. K. Alston Drive is missing. (refer to Sketch Plan element: 1 . Street Plan / Proposed street network, inter- connectivity in accordance with Code Sec. 7.5.3.B, see staff analysis, page 2); ❖ Inadequate pedestrian, and especially bicycle connections provided within and onto proposed development site (refer to Sketch Plan element: 1 . Street Plan / Proposed street network, inter-connectivity in accordance with Code Sec. 7.5.3.B, see staff analysis, page 2); and refer to Sketch Plan review criteria: 3. The preliminary traffic, open space, park, utility, and pedestrian design is adequate and functional given the existing and planned capacities of each system, and meets the standards found in this Code pursuant to Code Sec. 7.5.3.F; see page 7); ❖ More community-oriented and active community green and open spaces should be provided in overall development scheme, especially in connection with development of remainder of property 9 (refer to Sketch Plan element: 3. Community Open Space Plan in accordance with Code Sec. 7.5.3.B, see staff analysis, page 3); General remark: Development concept fails to adequately demonstrate the creation of an interconnected-connected, well accessible and integrative urban development that is both easily accessible from within and neighboring communities, and attractive to live and work in for residents and visitors alike. 10 Appendix: Staff Review Comments from Oct. 27, 2025 – [with applicant responses in blue; Nov. 14, 2025] A. Erosion and Sediment Control (provided by Jason Hetrick, PE, CFM) 1. Provide erosion and sediment control bmps to protect the swale within this area adjacent to Robert Smalls Park Way. Comment addressed. Additional silt fence, sediment tubes, temporary and permanent seeding, and riprap have been added to provide erosion and sediment control. See sheet C202 / C802 2. Depict a temporary culvert under the construction entrance in Phase 1 so that it can span the existing ditch. Comment addressed, see on Sheet C202. B. Stormwater Management (provided by Jason Hetrick, PE, CFM) 1. Main bioretention basin has a bottom of bank elevation of 16.5’ but the inflow pipe has an invert elevation of 16.0 feet. Please clarify. Comment addressed, the inflow pipe has since been revised to an invert elevation of 16.5 ft. 2. Confirm that the main bioretention basin has adequate separation from ground water, as the wet pond is shown with a water level of 14.0 feet. It appears that the wet pond will also stage at an elevation above the bioretention facility thus impacting/saturating the bioretention facility as well since they are connected. The seasonal high groundwater is found to be 4 ft. below ground surface. The surface elevation is around 19 ft., putting the groundwater to be at an elevation of 15 ft. The bottom of the Bioretention is at an elevation of 16.5 ft., giving 1.5 ft. of separation between the groundwater and bottom of the basin. The bioretention overflows to the adjacent wet pond via an emergency weir at an elevation of 18.75 ft. The wet pond stages to a maximum elevation of 18.58 ft., which is below the emergency weir elevation; therefore, it will not backflow into or saturate the bioretention media. Flow is directed from the bioretention basin to the pond, and then from the pond to the outlet control structure. 3. If trees are being planted or preserved within the limit of disturbance, additional stormwater credit can be claimed on the SoLoCo spreadsheet. Comment noted. 4. Provide a profile of the stormwater pond and depict the permanent pool elevations, storm elevations and top of bank as well as the control structure. Comment addressed, refer to sheet C604 for the Stormwater Pond and Outlet Control Structure details. 5. Please update the stormwater computations to use the peaking factor required by SoLoCo for post conditions, of 400, not 323, Section 3.7.2. Comment addressed, the stormwater computations and SWPPP have been updated. C. Planning & Zoning Design Standards: 1. Size, mass and scale: the proposed FSED & PCC are no more than one story in height; this is below surrounding developments, such as “4000 Margaret”, which contains 3-story high multi-family buildings 11 and two-story townhomes as well as the “Beaufort Walmart Supercenter”, which is one-story and the commercial lots at “Beaufort Station”, which are mostly 1 - 1.5 stories in height. Thus, the proposed massing underperforms surrounding uses, nonetheless, it resultingly creates a favorable transition between developed and undeveloped parcels along that corridor. Comment noted. 2. Building materials and details: in accordance with Sec. 4.6.4 – C. Windows and Doors, “building elevations that face the street shall have at least 40% of the first-floor wall area consist of windows and/or doors,(…)”. Comment noted, the architect is working directly with staff accordingly. 3. Additional Guidelines Specific to IC District: “All buildings constructed as part of a campus may be subject to the guidelines for civic building outlined in Section 4.5.10. or shall be held to standards similar to the requirements in the surrounding context.” Comment noted, the architect is working directly with staff accordingly. o Large Footprint Building (>20,000 sq. ft.) – N/A Final landscape and open space plan: 1. Community Green Space and Open Space (Sec. 7.4): Disturbed land area = 322,764 sq. ft. (~7.41 ac.); in accordance with the table in Sec. 7.4.2 – 15% of the area shall be provided for community green/open space (equals approx. 1.11 ac.); civic/open space types that may be provided are listed in table under Sec. 7.4.3, e.g. greenway, square/green, plaza, park. Comment noted, please see the landscape plan included in the submittal package. Traffic Impact Analysis (TIA): 1. In accordance with Sec. 7.3.2 – “shall be required for any development that is shown to generate more than 50 trips during peak hour on adjacent streets as per the most recent Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE) Trip Generation Manual.” o Sec. 7.3.2.C. – Traffic Impact Analysis Plan Preparation: “To review the TIA, the Planning Commission and TRC will require current trip generation information, available information on land use, travel patterns, and traffic conditions, and shall consult with the SCDOT.” o See Sec. 7.3.2.D. – Table on required plan contents for TIA See excerpt of draft Traffic Impact Analysis (TIA; prepared by Kimley-Horn). Curt Freese, Community Development Director: 1. It appears this would be the first development of a new commercial subdivision, with corresponding infrastructure, street, stormwater, etc. The proper path would be sketch plan, preliminary and final plat, as infrastructure would be shared. A Site Plan is not appropriate at this time, and a Sketch Plan under 7.5.3 is the next step. This would only require a preliminary TIA which does not require a full review, so it could be scheduled for December. Please refile the application. Comment noted. 2. As per #1, does a regional wet pond to serve the commercial subdivision make more sense than an individual pond on-site? Due to the site’s existing topography, one portion naturally drains to the southwest while the other drains to the northeast. Given the location of the proposed development, it is most appropriate for our project to utilize a stormwater pond that discharges to the northeast. The remaining portion of the property will require a separate pond designed to accommodate the drainage flowing to the southwest. 3. Again, the street being built seems appropriate for an entire subdivision and must go through the major subdivision process. Comment noted. 4. A TIA will be required and should likely be required for potential uses of the entire site, zoned IC. Please see the TIA Report included in the submittal package. 12 5. Should the entrance into the site, be centered in the middle of the site, to serve all of the potential lots to reduce access points? The future use and development timing for the remainder of the property are not yet determined. The access point must also be aligned to provide direct and efficient entry for emergency vehicles, and the proposed location has been coordinated with SCDOT to ensure it meets their requirements. For these reasons, the access is positioned to best serve the needs of the FSED and PCC. 6. Applicant must provide an exhibit documenting compliance with existing Tree Canopy standards 5.3.2.1, of 30% for non-residential. Please see the landscape plan included in the submittal package. 7. Is there an access easement from the School District for access to W.K. Alston? Coordination with the school district is ongoing, and efforts to obtain it are currently underway. 8. There are no sidewalks proposed for either 170 or the internal street. Section 7.1.3 requires sidewalks for all streets. Comment noted. However, an issue exists along Hwy. 170 due to the roadside ditch, which would require significant streetscape improvements and involvement with SCDOT. It should also be noted that the adjacent apartment complex does not include a sidewalk along Hwy. 170 either. 9. Section 7.1.3 requires curb and gutter. Curb and gutter are provided along each side of the road. 10. Street Trees for new streets are required as per Section 7.1.3 and 7.2.5. Please refer to the landscape plan included in the submittal package. 11. Street Lights for new streets are required as per Section 7.1.3. The submittal package includes the site lighting plan, which incorporates the proposed street lighting. 12. Section 7.4.2 A requires 15% park/open space , this has not been delineated or provided on the plan. Please see Open Space exhibit included in the submittal package. 13. Staff cannot determine if the buffer area complies with Section 5.4.2. Our intent is to comply with Option 1 for Buffer Type E. 14. There is no landscaping plan as required per Section 5.4-5.5. Please see landscape plan included in the submittal package. 15. There is no lighting plan as required per Section 5.7. Please find the site lighting plan included in the submittal package. 16. It appears the electric is underground as per Section 7.1.3, however, it does not appear how the site will be served on the utility plans. Electric is underground and an electrical plan is forthcoming and will be provided upon receipt. D. Building Department comments (by Mr. Bruce Skipper): 1. Accessible sidewalks from the public transportation stop to within the site have not been provided. See IBC 1104.1 (from Robert Smalls Parkway to the buildings). An internal sidewalk connection has been added from W.K. Alston Drive through the site, providing direct pedestrian access to the adjacent multifamily development. Installing a sidewalk along Robert Smalls Pkwy. would require significant hardscape improvements due to the existing roadside ditch and would necessitate coordination and involvement with SCDOT. It appears that the adjacent multifamily development was not required to construct a sidewalk along Hwy. 170. 2. At least one accessible route shall connect accessible buildings, accessible facilities, accessible elements, and accessible spaces that are on the same site. See IBC 1104.2 (Between Buildings). Comment addressed, accessible sidewalks have been added between buildings. 3. Where a building or portion of a building is required to be accessible, at least one accessible route shall be provided to each portion of the building, to accessible building entrances, connecting accessible pedestrian walkways and to the public way. IBC 1104.3 (sidewalks at each building). Ramps shall comply with section 13 IBC 1012. Slope 1012.2, Handrails 1012.8, edge protection 1012.10, and curb 1012.10.1 (sidewalk ramps). Comment addressed. E. Fire Marshal (by Mr. John Badgett): 1. Fire sprinkler plans must be approved by the SC Fire Marshal’s Office prior to installation. IFC 901.2. The architect is working directly with staff accordingly. 2. A Fire Sprinkler System Specification Sheet (FSSSS) must be provided prior to the building permit being issued. IFC 901.2. The architect is working directly with staff accordingly. 3. This office will witness all fire protection system acceptance testing to include emergency responder radio communications IFC 901.5. Comment noted. 4. Ambulatory Care Facilities shall comply with section 422 of the IBC. IFC sec 202. Comment noted. 5. Site access/apparatus road capable of supporting fire apparatus in all weather conditions shall be established prior to bringing combustible materials on site in accordance with IFC sec.3313. Comment addressed. 6. Fire apparatus access roads shall have an unobstructed width of not less than 20 feet exclusive of shoulders and an unobstructed vertical clearance of 13 feet 6 inches. IFC 503.2.1. Comment addressed. 7. Fire Department Connection (FDC) shall labeled, protected, and remain clear and accessible. IFC 912.4. Comment addressed. 8. KNOX FDC caps shall be provided on fire department connection. IFC 912.4.1. Comment noted. 9. All control valves including PIV and Backflow Preventer must be electrically supervised. Comment noted. 10. This office will witness the underground pressure test of the fire protection main from PIV into building and FDC line. All joints will be exposed for testing. NFPA 10.10.2.2.1. Comment noted. 11. This office will witness the underground flushing of the fire protection main from PIV into building and FDC line. NFPA 10.10.2.1.1. Comment noted. 12. A Knox Box shall be provided for fire department access. IFC 506.1. Comment noted. 13. Address identification characters shall be contrasting to background, and each character shall be no less than 4 inches high with a minimum width stroke of no less than ½ inch. IFC 505.1. Comment noted. 14. Buildings equipped with automatic sprinkler systems shall have a fire hydrant located within 100 feet of the FDC SCIFC 507.5.1.1. Comment noted. F. Architecture/Building Design (provided by Meadors Architecture, LLC): 1. PCC a. Staff noted that all of the windows on the north elevation have a wall constructed directly behind them and therefore are not transparent windows. Per Section 4.6.4.C.1, “Building elevations that face the street shall have at least 40% of the first-floor wall areas consist of windows and/or doors, and 15% of upper floors.” Staff interprets this code section to mean building fenestration that allows visible light to transfer to the interior during the day and light sources from inside to activate the otherwise dark facades at night. Staff recommends the interior wall be removed so that these windows can provide true transparency. b. The applicant could use interior window treatments such as blackout blinds on tracks to provide privacy. c. The renderings show a black brick base with joints that align with the panels above, but the 2D elevations do not show brick. Applicant to clarify – staff is supportive of the brick base. d. Generally, staff does not believe this building is indicative of traditional Lowcountry vernacular architecture and offers the following comments: 14 i. Staff is not supportive of the textured Parklex cementitious rainscreen panel, especially in the “reeds” texture. This is not a common cladding material in Beaufort. Note: Section 4.6.4.A.1.b states “fiber cement board siding, smooth finish.” The textured finish “reeds” is not compliant with this section of the code. ii. Bahama shutters are not common in Beaufort and appear more tropical/coastal. Staff recommends they are removed from the project. iii. The window head casings appear to extend past the jamb casings, which is atypical. The sills are not visible in 2D drawings or renderings. These windows should have traditional head and jamb casings with a projecting sill. iv. Staff recommends making the colors lighter, as both the brown and gray appear dark. Staff would be in support of a white or off-white color instead of the gray. v. There are large frame elements (brown) around some of the windows, but not all. Their placement appears arbitrary. Staff believes the intent of these is to break up the façades but believe these may be more successful if designed as actual bays rather than frames applied to the wall. vi. Some of the joints in the panels appear to sit on the outside edges of the windows, while other joints are set a few inches away from the windows. e. The mechanical screen on top of the roof appears tall in relationship to the rest of the building. To remedy this and to provide better screening, staff recommends converting the flat roof to a sloped roof to conceal the mechanical areas. Staff believes a sloped roof would also create a more Lowcountry approach to this building, as hip/gable roofs are common throughout the area. 2. FSER a. It is unclear if any of the windows with Bahama shutters have windows behind them, or if this is a faux window detail. The renderings do not appear to show any windows. Per Section 4.6.4.C.1, “Building elevations that face the street shall have at least 40% of the first-floor wall areas consist of windows and/or doors, and 15% of upper floors.” Staff interprets this code section to mean building fenestration that allows visible light to transfer to the interior during the day and light sources from inside to activate the otherwise dark facades at night. Applicant to add windows to meet code compliance. Any instances of faux windows should be removed. b. As it is designed, the building’s primary façade and entrance face into an internal parking area, while the rear façade and mechanical yard face Robert Smalls Parkway. This rear façade does not appear to meet the 40% fenestration requirement to meet code compliance, and staff believes that placing the mechanical yard on this façade will make it difficult to meet this requirement. Staff believes the building orientation may need to change to better relate to the primary frontage rather than internal, head-in parking. Staff understands the need for quick access from the parking lot to the building entrance, and recommends the applicant study the addition of a second entrance. A potential solution may be to swap the FSER with the PCC on the site plan where the FSER would maintain its current orientation but front to the north access road and the PCC will mirror in plan to front to Robert Smalls Parkway. c. Applicant to refer to all applicable comments under item 1.d in the PCC section. d. The use of the protruding brown frames around some of the windows is different from the PCC, but staff still believes its placement is arbitrary. Some of these protrusions also appear to cut off the brick base. This base should continue around the building without interruption, except at the entrances. 15 e. The ambulance drive-through bay does not appear to relate or connect well to the rest of the building. If it is possible, staff recommends lowering the roof to align with the main building’s roof. f. The mechanical screen on top of the roof appears almost as tall as the exterior walls of the building (staff measured the screen wall digitally as approximately 10’-0” tall). To remedy this and to provide better screening, staff recommends converting the flat roof to a sloped roof to conceal the mechanical areas. Staff believes a sloped roof would also create a more Lowcountry approach to this building, as hip/gable roofs are common throughout the area. BOARD MEETING SCHEDULE FOR 2026 PC – Planning Commission: 2026 Schedule (Draft) Meetings are held at City Hall in Council Chambers on the 2nd floor at 5:00 p.m. Only digital submittal of all documents is accepted now. You may also view the meeting schedule in document form. Note: Deadline for applications for next month’s meeting are due by noon of the current month’s meeting. Written comments for any project before the board must be submitted by noon (12:00 pm) on the business day before the meeting. Meeting Schedule Deadline Date (Interoffice) Wednesday, January 21, 2026 December 15, 2025 Wednesday, February 18, 2026 January 20, 2026 Monday, March 16, 2026 February 17, 2026 Monday, April 20, 2026 March 16, 2026 Monday, May 18, 2026 April 20, 2026 Monday, June 15, 2026 May 18, 2026 Monday, July 20, 2026 June 15, 2026 Monday, August 17, 2026 July 20, 2026 Monday, September 21, 2026 August 17, 2026 Monday, October 19, 2026 September 21, 2026 Monday, November 16, 2026 October 19, 2026 Monday, December 14, 2026 November 16, 2026

Source: City of Beaufort website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.