RecordWell Data

Special Workshop of Council with the Waterfront Advisory Committee — Minutes

City of Beaufort · Beaufort County · General · meeting of Sep 24, 2025 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Beaufort

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

ALTERNATIVES FOR THE BEAUFORT WATERFRONT PLATFORM SEPTEMBER 24, 2025 PRESENTED TO: BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL / WATER COMMITTEE DEFINING RESILIENCE & SUSTAINABILITY In essence, resilience is the Capacity to Recover…how’bout…., “Resilient communities proactively build self-sufficiency for rapid recovery.” NOAA – “Coastal resilience means building the ability of a community to "bounce back" after hazardous events such as hurricanes, coastal storms, and flooding – rather than simply reacting to impact.” USACE - "the ability to anticipate, prepare for and adapt to changing conditions and withstand and recover from disruptions….[through] four principles - prepare, absorb, recover, and adapt.” NIST – “Resilience is the ability to adapt to changing conditions and prepare for, withstand, and rapidly recover from disruption caused by a hazard.” FEMA - “Instead of repeated damage and continual demands for federal disaster assistance, resilient communities proactively protect themselves against hazards, build self - sufficiency , and become more sustainable.” DEFINING RESILIENCE In essence, sustainability is the Capacity to Preserve…how’bout…., “Sustainable communities achieve long-term resilience goals socially, environmentally, and economically.” NOAA – “A vision of the future where ecosystems and societies are healthy and resilient in the face of change.” USACE - “The capacity to endure; i.e. the ability to sustain. When applied to a community infrastructure project, it refers to the ability to sustain not just itself, but its users, its community, and the ecology of its environment.” NIST – “To achieve sustainability, products, processes, and services should meet the challenges not only related to their functions and performance but also to environment, economy, and social issues.” FEMA - “Meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs…Social, economic, environmental, recreational, and other community goals can be achieved during recovery, resulting in a community that is a better place to live, work, and play than it was before the disaster.” DEFINING SUSTAINABILITY BACKGROUND DATA TIDE WATER LEVELS / DATUMS Beaufort, SC - Tide Datums & Water Level Observations (NOAA Station 8667999) Datum / Observation Elevation (feet, NAVD88) Description Max Tide 7.01 Highest Observed Tide (9/3/1979 12:00:00 AM) HAT 5.37 Highest Astronomical Tide (10/16/1993 1:00:00 PM) MHHW 3.55 Mean Higher-High Water MHW 3.17 Mean High Water NAVD88 0.00 North American Vertical Datum of 1988 MSL -0.11 Mean Sea Level MLW -4.22 Mean Low Water MLLW -4.43 Mean Lower-Low Water LAT -5.78 Lowest Astronomical Tide (2/8/1997 6:48:00 AM) Min Tide -6.80 Lowest Observed Tide (1/9/1978 12:00:00 AM) Ma Tide, . Ma Tide, . AT, . AT, . M , . M , . M , . M , . A , A , MS , . MS , . M , . M , . M , . M , . AT, . AT, . Min Tide, . Min Tide, . HISTORIC FLOODING Date Event Ranki ng Elevation (feet, MHHW) Total Storm Tide (feet) NOAA V-Datum Transformation at Beaufort, SC (feet, NAVD88) 10/8/2016 Hurricane Matthew 1 5.06 12.56 8.63 09/11/2017 Tropical Storm Irma 2 4.74 12.24 8.31 10/15/1947 Cape Sable Hurricane 3 3.36 10.86 6.93 11/07/2021 November 2021 King Tide 4 2.95 10.45 6.52 10/27/2015 October 2015 King Tide 5 2.93 10.43 6.50 11/10/2021 November 2021 King Tide 6 2.91 10.41 6.48 11/23/2018 November 2018 King Tide 8 2.75 10.25 6.32 06/04/2023 June 2023 King Tide 10 2.70 10.20 6.27 HURRICANE MATHEW , 2016 SEA LEVEL RISE PROJECTIONS Projections of Sea Level Heights for Fort Pulaski, GA (8670870) Year Low (feet) Int-Low (feet) Int (feet) Int-High (feet) High (feet) 2030 0.59 0.66 0.66 0.69 0.72 2040 0.82 0.89 0.95 1.05 1.12 2050 1.02 1.15 1.28 1.48 1.71 2060 1.21 1.41 1.64 2.03 2.40 2070 1.35 1.64 2.07 2.72 3.38 2080 1.48 1.90 2.56 3.51 4.53 2090 1.57 2.13 3.18 4.40 5.71 2100 1.77 2.40 3.90 5.35 6.99 FLOOD FREQUENCY ELEVATIONS (USACE) Return Period (N-year) SWL-SLC0 (feet, NAVD88) SWL-SLC1 (feet, NAVD88) SWL-SLC2 (feet, NAVD88) 0.5 5.18 7.85 12.41 1 6.52 9.25 13.85 2 7.48 10.15 14.71 5 8.59 11.17 15.66 10 9.25 11.76 16.21 20 9.76 12.23 16.64 50 10.30 12.73 17.09 100 10.95 13.39 17.49 200 12.34 14.72 18.65 500 13.88 16.24 20.02 . . . . . . S S C feet, A S S C feet, A S S C feet, A DESIGN WATER LEVEL CONSIDERATIONS Return Period (N-year) USACE SLC0 Scenario USACE SLC1 Scenario USACE SLC2 Scenario Stillwate r Elevatio n (feet, NAVD88 ) Flood Depth at Platform (feet) Stillwater Elevation (feet, NAVD88) Flood Depth at Platform (feet) Stillwate r Elevatio n (feet, NAVD88 ) Flood Depth at Platfor m (feet) 0.5 5.18 0.00 7.85 1.85 12.41 6.41 1 6.52 0.52 9.25 3.25 13.85 7.85 2 7.48 1.48 10.15 4.15 14.71 8.71 5 8.59 2.59 11.17 5.17 15.66 9.66 10 9.25 3.25 11.76 5.76 16.21 10.21 20 9.76 3.76 12.23 6.23 16.64 10.64 50 10.30 4.30 12.73 6.73 17.09 11.09 100 10.95 4.95 13.39 7.39 17.49 11.49 200 12.34 6.34 14.72 8.72 18.65 12.65 500 13.88 7.88 16.24 10.24 20.02 14.02 FLOODING PATHWAYS DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS • Overtopping of the platform begins on the west end of the platform near Safe Harbor Marina at an elevation of approximately 6.00 feet, NAVD88 (see Figure 9, top left image). This will happen during extreme King Tide events as demonstrated in Table 4. For example, five of the eight extreme flood events that overtopped the platform since 2015 were due to King Tides. • A perimeter protection approach or future platform elevation approach could be feasible up to an elevation of approximately 9.05 feet, NAVD88 (see bottom left image of Figure 9) at which point increasing water levels would begin flanking the platform (and require additional measures to mitigate flanking). • At increasing levels of flooding above 9.05 feet, NAVD88, flanking of the platform area would occur via several roadway corridors on the east side such as Cartel Street and Scott Street and would require additional measures to mitigate this flanking (see bottom right image, Figure 9). • Regarding the footprint of areas to protect against future flooding such as for benefit-cost analyses of alternatives, considering the eventual enormity of flanking about the platform, the physical scope for feasible flood alternatives for the platform appears to be bound by the platform and upland to Bay Street. Attempts to mitigate flooding above levels of approximately 11 feet (NAVD88) may become infeasible given measures required to prevent flanking from The Point, connected roadway corridors, and widespread flooding of the City. • Above these extreme flood levels (11 feet, NAVD88), a much larger boundary beyond the platform for flood mitigation measures would be considered for alternatives. As an example, solutions for City-wide flood protection would be the type proposed in a USACE Coastal Storm Risk Management study involving a City-wide integrated flood defense system such as the proposed peninsula seawall system for the City of Charleston. Such a study for Beaufort, SC has been identified by the USACE in the SACS – South Carolina Engineering Appendix, which recommends a Beaufort Peninsula Coastal Storm/Flood Risk Management Study (3 x 3 x 3) funded by a USACE General Investigation (if appropriated). ALTERNATIVES CONSIDERED PHASE 2 – PRELIMINARY LIST OF ALTERNATIVES 1. DO NOTHING 2. REPAIR STRUCTURE 3. REPLACE THE BACKFILL WITH LIGHTER MATERIAL 4. REBUILD A SAME SIZE AND SHAPE PLATFORM • EVALUATE VARIOUS WATER LEVELS (D.A.P .P .) 5. REBUILD TO A SMALLER SIZE (WIDTH) 6. REPLACE WITH SEAWALL AND BACKFILL • EVALUATE VARIOUS WATER LEVELS (D.A.P .P .) 7. REPLACE WITH FLOATING STRUCTURES 8. HYBRID STRUCTURE • FIXED AND FLOATING STRUCTURES TO MAXIMIZE USE AND ACCESS 1. DO NOTHING 2. STRUCTURAL REPAIRS 3. REPLACE THE BACKFILL WITH LIGHTER MATERIAL 4. REBUILD A SAME SIZE AND SHAPE PLATFORM (VARY ELEVATIONS) +9 feet +8 feet +7 feet +6 feet 5. REBUILD TO A SMALLER SIZE (WIDTH) 6. REPLACE WITH SEAWALL AND BACKFILL 7. REPLACE WITH FLOATING STRUCTURES 8. HYBRID STRUCTURE - FIXED & FLOATING STRUCTURES UNION PIER WATERFRONTLOWER MANHATTAN RESILIENCE PLANNING APPROACHES Reduced Damages Damage Curve Shifted Low High MITIGATION DAMAGE Low $ High $$$ Cost of Ignoring Risks Cost of reducing Risk Low High INVESTMENTS IN MITIGATION COST Low $ High $$$ Total Cost of Mitigation You want to be here! Reactive Proactive Investing in Resilience • Phased Approach - decision process and points are iterative, • Plausible Scenarios - choice of bounding scenarios should be robust for the desired timeframe, • Decision Points - should support future response options, and • Lead Times - facilitate the appropriate timing of the next decision. Adaptive Risk Design/Management for Resilience Defining What Matters Most o High Risk Tolerance: • Use lower scenarios (low-moderate proj’ns). • Projects with a short lifespan. • Planning areas with flexibility to make alternative choices within the near-term. • Low criticality (e.g., a recreational field) o Low Risk Tolerance: • Use higher scenarios (moderate-high proj’ns). • Projects or assets with a long lifespan, in which losses would be catastrophic. • Planning areas with limited flexibility to adapt in the near or long term. • Assets that serve critical functions (e.g., ports, roads, bridges, hospitals and associated infrastructure). Dynamic Adaptive Policy Pathway (DAPP) RESILIENCE SOLUTIONS TOOLBOX Green to Grey • Site Specific – offshore vs inshore (geology, winds, waves, water levels vary). • Regulatory – state/federal permits, building codes, municipal ordinances. • Cost Drivers – a function of risks, funding, and timelines. • Resilience & Sustainability – material adequacy, operation, & maintenance. Nonstructural Examples Elevation/Relocation Flood Warning System Hybrid Nature-based Examples Hybrid Engineering with Nature Hard Engineered Examples Seawall w/Wave Deflector Mixed Active/Passive LOW BATTERY SEAWALL PROJECT NowThen Historical Background - 1909 Picture from the Evening Post • 30-70 foot long wooden pile supporting timber deck foundation. • Cobble stones, oyster shells, and granite rubble laid at toe of the wall. • Started construction 1909. • Approximately 667,000 cubic yards of dredged fill to create 47 acres of developable land 8.5 feet above MLW Historical Background - 1911 • Ashley River Water Front Corporation sold 191 residential building lots by end of 1911. • Promenade was built along with oyster shell roadways; the southern peninsula was tied to White Point Gardens and the East Battery Boulevard stopped at White Point Garden Rutledge St Limehouse St Tradd St Chisolm’s Mill Raising the seawall to combat rising sea levels Low Battery Seawall Height 7 ft Existing US Army Corp Study 12 ft Preferred Alternative Nov 2013 - July 2014 / $2.6 Million / 121 LF ow did the ow Battery Seawall project develop….”The Turn”? ~ 6 ft per month / $22,500/foot asted longer than intended… LOW BATTERY – CONDITION • Deterioration behind concrete veil (seaward wall) • Timber support piles subjected to marine borers • Timber beams and platform have collapsed in places • Supporting hardware is severely corroded • Platform and support beams were saturated (landside wall) Challenges • Cracking • Spaulding • Voids • Settlement • Public Health & Safety • Frequent Wave Runup & Overtopping (King Tides) The Solution Micropile Design • 1,620 piles • 75 to 90 ft long / 6 to 10 inches in diameter • 5% of piles load tested (compression or tension) Micropiles Glass Fiber Reinforced Polymer (GFRP) One Section at a Time Shotcrete Seawall Repair 9.50 ft Raising the Low Battery Seawall Adaptive Capacity Resiliency Sustainability Capacity to Recover Capacity to Preserve Resiliency is the ability to anticipate, prepare for, and adapt to changing conditions and withstand, respond to, and recover rapidly from disruptions Sustainability involves developing infrastructure with consideration to economic, social and environmental implications Sustainable Outcomes Adapt to Future Sea Level Rise Built-in Capacity for ” igher all Social Endurance Connecting People with Water Material Longevity Here Today.... Here Tomorrow Adaptable Reuse & Innovation Retain & Repurpose "Leave No Waste Behind" Reduce Flooding Risk Resilient Outcomes Social Impact Material Resilience Hold the Line Nov 2013 - July 2014 / $2.6 Million / 121 LF ~ 6 ft per month / $22,500/foot 2020 - 2024 / $65M Million / 1 mile ~ 110 ft per month / $12,300/foot Resilient & Sustainable - People-Planet-Profit QUESTIONS & ANSWERS “The ow Battery Seawall’s innovative built - in adaptive capacity is audacious! It sets the resilience bar for Charleston that is dynamically prepared for future flood risks such as sea level rise!” Chris Mack, P .E., D.CE Director of Climate Resilience & Coastal Solutions, JMT Scan to learn more!

Source: City of Beaufort website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.