RecordWell Data

County Council Economic Development Workshop — Agenda Packet

Beaufort County · Beaufort County · County Council Meeting · meeting of May 12, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Beaufort County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

County Council Economic Development Workshop Beaufort County, SC Council Chambers, Administration Building Beaufort County Government Robert Smalls Complex 100 Ribaut Road, Beaufort Tuesday, May 12, 2026 9:00 AM AGENDA COUNCIL MEMBERS: Alice Howard, Chair David P. Bartholomew Logan Cunningham York Glover Lawrence McElynn Thomas Reitz Anna Maria Tabernik, Vice-Chair Paula Brown Gerald Dawson Mark Lawson Joseph Passiment 1. CALL TO ORDER: Alice Howard, Chair 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE: Alice Howard, Chair 3. STATEMENT OF COMPLIANCE WITH FOIA: Alice Howard, Chair 4. APPROVAL OF AGENDA 5. AGENDA ITEMS: a. History of Beaufort County Economic Development Corporation b. Economic Development 101 c. Questions/Open Discussion 6. BREAK 7. AGENDA ITEMS: a. BCEDC Strategic Plan Overview and Discussion b. Regional Partnerships- SC Delivery Method/Purpose History c. Southern Carolina Regional Alliance Overview d. Questions/Open Discussion 8. ADJOURNMENT Page 1 of 65 To watch committee or County Council meetings or for a complete list of agendas and backup packages, please visit: https://beaufortcountysc.gov/council/council-committee-meetings/index.html Page 2 of 65 Page 3 of 65 #2 REQUEST FOR PUBLIC COMMENTS eaufort County, SC Council Date:/ "' 5 /<9-, & N{me-Print: ?,A-1/'----ri.' �j_ ,, District: Z. --------------------- Topic: -�-b,<-----"--C_...E,�]:C. ______________ _ Email Address: (if you would like someone to reach out to you) /nMl. jM "2-� aJ-W\ Signature: = � #3 REQUEST FOR PUBLIC COMMENTS I Beaufort County, SC Council Date: S_ Id--(& Name-Print: Ur�j,,qljy\ lnz</( District: ........ # __ __._ ________________ _ J3CEDL Email Address: (if you would ike someone to reach out to you) Page 4 of 65 #4 REQUEST FOR PUBLIC COMMENTS Beaufort County, SC Council Date: 6'\ 1 2 -\c G Name-PrirJt: � Qoc �('.LI\ c\ -✓ <-J Email Address: (if you would like someone to reach out to you) Signature:"/ � }(_/_/I_ #5 REQUEST FOR PUBLIC COMMENTS Beaufort County, SC Council Date: ___ �--- Name-Print: _Q.,,_..,�'--l(_UA�D�·· __ ·��s-��· ---------­ {) District: ---------------------- Topic: Q�_.a,l0-l;1¼ Email Address: (if you would like someone to reach out to you) Signature: ____________________ _ Page 5 of 65 Page 6 of 65 Page 7 of 65 Page 8 of 65 Page 9 of 65 times more value for the taxpayer than the world's most The BCE DC in this 54 page presentation asserts emphatically YES we have! For example, on page 54 of your presentation, the BCEDC represents that it has taken $6.1 million and turned it into $765 million dollars of property value. This amounts to a 12,700% return and is a fantastical lie. Furthermore, increasing property values is not a stated mission of the BCEDC nor should it be. Let's look deeper at the ac l investments which the BCE DC has made to ascertain the BCEDC's actual performance s ou might make an educated decision on its effectiveness and results: Of the BCEDC's $6.1 million total incentives, $2.4 million was given to Glassworx. Glassworx went bankrupt prior to opening its doors in Beaufort! $2.4 million up in smoke with zero jobs created. The assessed value of Glassworx location is $7.7 million. The Glassworx property is currently listed for sale on the BCEDC's website for $7.1 million and includes an 83,000 square foot warehouse which is vacant and for sale. By the way, the BCEDC is as we speak trying to convince the City of Beaufort to give it $1 million so that it can then give it to a Bluffton developer to build another 80,000 square foot warehouse even though one is for sale by the BCEDC right down the street-but I digress. Of the remaining $3.7 million, $1.6 million was given to Norman International. Norman International created 67 jobs at an average hourly wage of $18/hour or $38,000/annum. For comparison, $38K is the same wage as a cook at McDonalds. The building in which Norman International rents a portion is valued at $7 .5 million. Another $SOOK was given to Materials Research and to Greenline respectively. Materials Research created 27 jobs paying $18/hour again $38K/annum. The Materials Research Property is valued at $1.9 million. Green line Industries created 25 jobs paying $26/hour or $55K/annum. Green line property is assessed at $1.2 million In total, the BCEDC has spent $9.2 million, including operating costs. The enterprises it has invested in have created only 146 jobs. That is $63,273 of taxpayer money spent on each job. The average wage of each of those jobs was $43,722. That means the BCE DC has spent $63K/job into enterprises which pay their employees on average $43K. Again, a $43K/annum job is the wage of a chef at McDonalds. $43K is 50% of Beaufort County median income. $43K is a low paying job. 146 jobs over 6 years is only 24 jobs/year-that is nothing. Again, 24 jobs/year is a rounding error in the annual jobs created by the private sector. Why waste taxpayer money for rounding errors! Page 10 of 65 The BCEDC on page 55 of its' presentation asserts its return on its $6.1 million is $765 million of "discounted taxable property" resulting in a 12,700 return. The true assessed value of the land and buildings to which the BCEDC has contributed total $19.6 million. How does the BCE DC arrive at $765 million which is 39 times more - the are lying to you? Bottom line, the truth is that the BCE DC has been an abject failure. The BCE DC will tell you it has been a resounding success and expects you to believe it. The BCEDC's investments have created no measurable impact in economic development in Beaufort County. Its investments have created relatively few jobs each year. The wage rates of the jobs in the companies in which it has invested are equivalent to a MacDonalds employee. It's investments are nothing more than gifts which crowds out and competes with private investors and actually does the opposite of what it is intended to do. My research revealed to my surprise that the BCEDC contributed and guaranteed to the developer of and the tenants occupying the the 1st spec building in the commerce park a monumental $4 million - $2 million guarantee and subsidy to the developer and a total of $2 million to the tenants. The developer made a profit of $2 million on the deal which was largely from the taxpayer giving the developer $2 million. The only people benefiting from the BCE DC are the CEO and its staff who are being paid a princely sum total of $GOOK/year. The organization needs to be defunded; the staff need to find different jobs. Beaufort County can then re-evaluate if it should be spending taxpayer money, at all, on small time projects which themselves are rounding errors compared to what the private sector is doing on its own without taxpayer funded largesse. Page 11 of 65 Page 12 of 65 Many counties pursue economic diversification because: • they are losing population, • suffering industrial collapse, • or facing chronic unemployment. Beaufort County is the opposite. We have proven and sustained: • strong in-migration, • rising property values, • affluent demographics, • expanding retail, • tourism demand, • and substantial private investment. In many respects, Beaufort County's "problem" is actually: • managing growth, not • creating growth. • Beaufort County doesn't lack growth. It lacks accountability for how public money is being used in the name of economic development After years of funding, what substantial economic transformation has BCEDC produced that would not otherwise have occurred through ordinary private-market growth? Paul Trask Page 13 of 65 BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNTY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY ITEM TITLE: HISTORY OF BEAUFORT COUNTY ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION MEETING NAME AND DATE: County Council May 12, 2026 STAFF RECOMMENDATION / COUNCIL OPTIONS: PRESENTER INFORMATION: ITEM BACKGROUND: FISCAL IMPACT: APPROVAL HISTORY: Page 14 of 65 History of Beaufort County Economic Development Corporation Page 15 of 65 About the BCEDC OUR VISION To be the collaborative driver for leading economic development efforts in the communities we serve. OUR MISSION We engage key stakeholders to diversify the county's economy, attract investments, and create well-paying jobs, while respecting the natural environment. Page 16 of 65 John O’Toole EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR Brian Warner ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT SPECIALIST Kelli Brunson SENIOR PROJECT MANAGER EXHILARATING ENVIRONMENT READY & SKILLED WORKFORCE UNPARALLELLED SUPPORT Page 17 of 65 Our Board of Directors Page 18 of 65 November 29, 2015 Page 19 of 65 BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNTY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY ITEM TITLE: ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 101 MEETING NAME AND DATE: County Council May 12, 2026 STAFF RECOMMENDATION / COUNCIL OPTIONS: PRESENTER INFORMATION: ITEM BACKGROUND: FISCAL IMPACT: APPROVAL HISTORY: Page 20 of 65 Economic Development 101 Page 21 of 65 What is Economic Development? Economic development is the process through which per capita income, tax revenue, and wealth are increased in a community by attracting investments and creating jobs. Successful economic development improves the quality of life in a community. It’s not just about business. It’s about people. Source: South Carolina Department of Commerce Page 22 of 65 Economic Development Activities The three main economic development activities: • Developing new product • Recruiting new industry • Business Retention & Expansion (BR&E) Page 23 of 65 New Product Page 24 of 65 Product: Magnus Speculative Building $5.1 Million Investment in Building Page 25 of 65 Product: 14.77 Acres on Parker Drive • Purchased April 2025 • Palmetto Sites Certification through SC Department of Commerce - March 2025 • Received grant funding for Phase II completion of Palmetto Sites - $13,800 - from the Department of Commerce Page 26 of 65 Product: 117-Acres Envirotract Page 27 of 65 Recruiting New Industry Page 28 of 65 Existing Business Page 29 of 65 Existing Business Page 30 of 65 Business Retention & Expansion 90 Visits Per Year Page 31 of 65 Incentives STATE INCENTIVES • Statutory Income Tax Credits • Sales Tax Exemptions • Single Factor Apportionment • Discretionary Grants • Job Development Credits • Workforce Training LOCAL INCENTIVES • Fee In Lieu of Taxes (FILOT Agreements) • Property Tax Abatements • Special Source Revenue Credits (SSRC) • Multi-County Industrial Park Destinations (MCIP Agreements) • Other Discretionary Incentives Page 32 of 65 • Provide necessary resources to support local economic development organizations • Invest in infrastructure • Instill a Pro-Business Climate in the community • Maintain confidentiality prior to investment announcements The Role of Elected Officials in Economic Development Page 33 of 65 OUR PARTNERS Page 34 of 65 BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNTY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY ITEM TITLE: QUESTIONS/OPEN DISCUSSION MEETING NAME AND DATE: County Council May 12, 2026 STAFF RECOMMENDATION / COUNCIL OPTIONS: PRESENTER INFORMATION: ITEM BACKGROUND: FISCAL IMPACT: APPROVAL HISTORY: Page 35 of 65 BCEDC Strategic Plan Page 36 of 65 Cumulative Scorecard $909 Million in Capital Investment $32.1 million in incentives and site development grants 3,338 jobs created and retained SINCE INCEPTION 2017 Page 37 of 65 Page 38 of 65 Jobs & Wages Page 39 of 65 Economic Development Organization Models County-Run Economic Development Model A county department model is where the county government directly operates economic development functions (like in many counties across the U.S.). • Public accountability and policy alignment • Stable public funding • Clear authority over public resources • Direct integration with public planning Page 40 of 65 Economic Development Organization Models Private (non-profit) Economic Development Model A private (non-profit) model is where a nonprofit corporation is the lead economic development entity, with strategic support from county council committees, local government partners, and regional alliances. • Competitive, flexible, and fast • Ability to pursue grants, philanthropic contributions, sponsorships, regional partnerships, and collaborative funding • Broader stakeholder engagement from business, civic, and community leaders • Agility in program development • Professionally credentialed staff Page 41 of 65 Economic Development Organization Models County-Run Economic Development Model • Charleston County Economic Development • Horry County Economic Development • Lexington County Economic Development • Berkeley County Economic Development • York County Economic Development Private (non-profit) Economic Development Model • Columbia Area Development Partnership • Greenville Area Development Corporation • Anderson County Economic Development • OneSpartanburg Inc. • Beaufort County Economic Development Hybrid • Dorchester County Economic Development • McCormick County Economic Development Page 42 of 65 A Holistic Approach to Economic Development Page 43 of 65 Forces Shaping Beaufort County • Conservation • Housing Development • Commercial/Retail Development • Economic Development Page 44 of 65 BCEDC Strategic Plan Purpose This document outlines the strategic planning framework for the Beaufort County Economic Development Corporation (BCEDC). It is designed to align industry targeting, workforce development, infrastructure investment, and partnerships to drive sustainable economic growth. Page 45 of 65 Strategic Focus Areas BCEDC focuses on five primary industry sectors: • Healthcare • Life Sciences • Aerospace & Defense • Headquarters & Back Office • Light Manufacturing Supporting program of work strategies include: • Workforce • Infrastructure • Funding for BCEDC • Entrepreneurship • Business Retention & Expansion • Business Recruitment BCEDC Strategic Plan Page 46 of 65 Measurement Success will be measured through key indicators including job creation, capital investment, workforce outcomes, site readiness, and community impact. BCEDC Strategic Plan Page 47 of 65 Aerospace and Defense  Objective: Retain and expand industry  Strategies: Military pipeline, BRE support, site optimization  Metrics: Job creation, capital investment, partnerships Economic Sectors in Beaufort County BCEDC Strategic Plan Page 48 of 65 Supply Chain for Hospitality and Tourism • Objective: Strengthen and support the supply chain that sustains Beaufort County’s tourism economy • Strategies: Workforce development and access, workforce housing expansion, transportation and infrastructure improvements, policy alignment to support quality of life • Metrics: Workforce placement and retention rates, number of workforce housing units, transportation usage and access improvements, infrastructure investments supporting tourism-related operations Economic Sectors in Beaufort County BCEDC Strategic Plan Page 49 of 65 Life Sciences  Objective: Emerging cluster development  Strategies: Target subsectors, research partnerships, lab-ready infrastructure  Metrics: New research companies, facilities built, trained workforce Economic Sectors in Beaufort County BCEDC Strategic Plan Page 50 of 65 Healthcare  Objective: Regional healthcare hub  Strategies: Consortium, workforce expansion, market positioning  Key metrics: RN/technical placement, capital investment, job creation Economic Sectors in Beaufort County BCEDC Strategic Plan Page 51 of 65 Light Manufacturing  Objective: Build long-term capacity  Strategies: Apprenticeships, site prep, success storytelling  Metrics: Shovel-ready sites, trained workforce, project wins Economic Sectors in Beaufort County BCEDC Strategic Plan Page 52 of 65 Headquarters and Back Office  Objective: Attract small/mid HQ operations  Strategies: Talent pipeline, lifestyle marketing, infill development  Metrics: New business recruitment, workforce retention Economic Sectors in Beaufort County BCEDC Strategic Plan Page 53 of 65 Business Recruitment  Define and target key industries  Advance site readiness  Leverage incentives and landing pads BCEDC Program of Work Initiatives BCEDC Strategic Plan Page 54 of 65 Business Retention & Expansion • Strengthen business relationships • Enhance business intelligence • Tell the story of existing industry BCEDC Program of Work Initiatives BCEDC Strategic Plan Page 55 of 65 Entrepreneurship While this is an important aspect of economic development, it is primarily handled by the two entrepreneurship organizations in the county. BCEDC is supportive of these organizations.  Assist existing organizations in expanding education and mentorship programs  Strengthen entrepreneur support networks  Identify opportunities for access to capital and incentives BCEDC Program of Work Initiatives BCEDC Strategic Plan Page 56 of 65 Workforce Development  Expand apprenticeships  Improve transportation access  Support workforce housing BCEDC Program of Work Initiatives BCEDC Strategic Plan Page 57 of 65 Infrastructure  Coordinate transportation planning  Expand utilities  Develop shovel-ready sites BCEDC Program of Work Initiatives BCEDC Strategic Plan Page 58 of 65 Funding & Sustainability  Diversify funding  Increase private sector support  Improve return on investment transparency BCEDC Program of Work Initiatives BCEDC Strategic Plan Page 59 of 65 Granting Organization Amount Purpose Santee Cooper $10,000 Marketing / Lead Generation Campaign SC Department of Commerce $13,800 Palmetto Sites Phase II - Parker Drive Site (50% of cost) SC Department of Commerce $204,000 Pad Site - Beaufort Commerce Park SC Department of Agriculture $13,500 International Recruitment of Fisheries Private Sector Fundraising $34,625 Programmatic Expenses (Annual Events: Converge / Prosperity in Practice) South Carolina Economic Developers Association $6,000 Scholarship - Professional Development Southern Economic Development Council $750 Scholarship - Professional Development Page 60 of 65 2030 What Success Looks Like • Business Recruitment & Existing Industry Projects / Workforce • More targeted investment in targeted sectors – ie; life sciences, aerospace • More emphasis on projects – coordinate with degrees to emphasize workforce strengths • BCEDC gets greater support for smaller projects • Signature/Impact projects proceeding – Value added infill projects HHI, BLF, PR, BCP, Cloud, Lobeco Page 61 of 65 2030 What Success Looks Like • Business Recruitment & Existing Industry Projects / Workforce • Retain – lower non-military average ages • Increase infrastructure to keep money in area. Less leakage on supply chain. Page 62 of 65 2030 What Success Looks Like • Community Partnerships • Enjoys greater collaboration between all education partners • Increased partnership with SCA • BCEDC is aligned with County Council, Towns and City Page 63 of 65 2030 What success Looks Like • Administration / Funding • CEDC staff is accredited as Certified Economic Developers (CEcD) • BCEDC is an Accredited Economic Development Organization • Grants in support of its mission $2,000,000 • Private Sector support grows by 110% Page 64 of 65 Return on Investment - BCEDC • County’s Net Contribution to BCEDC $6,106,483 • Discounted Taxable Property ~ $765,000,000 • Annual Tax Income at 6% ~ 13,577,220 Rate of Return > 125% Page 65 of 65

Source: Beaufort County website. First collected Oct 24, 2026.