Board of Zoning Appeals — Minutes
Lancaster County · Lancaster County · Board of Zoning Appeals · meeting of Aug 4, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Lancaster County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MEMBERS OF LANCASTER COUNTY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
CHARLES . K. DEESE
JAMES FAULKENBERRY
MARK BOLAND
AARON FENDER
JOSHUA PANGLE
1
MINUTES OF THE LANCASTER COUNTY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
REGULAR MEETING
August 4, 2026, at 6:00 PM
1. Roll Call/Call to Order
Board Members present: Quorum is present (3 Board Members)
Aaron Fender James Faulkenberry Joshua Pangle
Absent:
Charles Deese; Mark Boland
Staff: Shannon Catoe, Zoning Director
Dr. Kirsten Willis, Planner
Mika Garris, Zoning Technician
Alyssa Faile, Code Enforcement Officer
Mara Mata, Administrative Assistant
Staff were sworn in.
Members of the press were notified in advance but were not present. All adjacent property owners
were notified by mail. A notice of public hearing was published in the Lancaster News at least 15
days prior to the meeting. The agenda was posted on the County website and posted in the lobby
of the Administration Building one week prior to the meeting. A copy of the agenda is on file.
THE FOLLOWING IS A SUMMARY ONLY; IT IS NOT A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT.
Vice-Chairman Faulkenberry called the meeting to order at 6:01 p.m.
2. Approval of Agenda
J. Pangle moved to Approve the Agenda; Second by A. Fender.
Vote: 3:0. The motion was approved by unanimous consent.
2
3. Approval of Minutes
a. Minutes of 06/02/2026 Meeting.
Call for a motion. Motion to approve as written by A. Fender; Second by J. Pangle.
Vote: 3:0. Minutes are approved unanimously.
4. Public Hearing Items
Vice-Chairman Faulkenberry discussed Legal Notice, the Board of Zoning Appeal’s duties, and
general instructions for the meeting.
a. BZA-2026-0723 Legacy Pointe Indian Land, LLC
Application by Legacy Pointe Indian Land, LLC for a BZA variance for 5.99 acres at
Charlotte Hwy (TM #0013-00-011.01) to allow for a 95.32 sq ft sign. Permit ID #
107896.
Staff Presentation: Shannon Catoe presented the variance request.
Comment From Applicant(s):
Laura Temple (Mooresville) was sworn in. She shared that this request was for a 95.32 square foot
sign on a building that has limited visibility from the entrance on Charlotte Highway. The
applicants are requesting a sign that matches the scale of the building. She shared that the
property’s distance from Charlotte Highway and elevation should be considered as extraordinary
and exceptional circumstances . Text Amendments are not currently possible due to the UDO
rewrite, and they have received no objections from neighbors to a larger sign.
Public Hearing: (See attachments: Sign-in Sheets)
No members of the public signed up to speak.
Questions From Board:
Board Member Fender and the applicant discussed the location and placement of the proposed
sign.
Vice-Chairman Faulkenberry closed Public hearing and called for a motion on item BZA-2026-
0723 Legacy Pointe Indian Land, LLC.
Motion to bring to a vote by J. Pangle; 2nd by A. Fender.
3
ZONING VARIANCE CRITERIA
I. THAT THERE ARE EXTRAORDINARY AND EXCEPTIONAL CONDITIONS PERTAINING TO
THE PARTICULAR PROPERTY
Aaron Fender [DISAGREE]
Joshua Pangle [DISAGREE]
James Faulkenberry [DISAGREE]
II. THAT THESE CONDITIONS DO NOT GENERALLY APPLY TO OTHER PROPERTY IN THE
VICINITY
Aaron Fender [DISAGREE]
Joshua Pangle [DISAGREE]
James Faulkenberry [DISAGREE]
III. THAT BECAUSE OF THESE CONDITIONS, THE APPLICATION OF THE ORDINANCE TO THE
PARTICULAR PROPERTY WOULD EFFECTIVELY PROHIBIT OR UNREASONABLY RESTRICT
THE UTILIZATION OF THE PROPERTY
Aaron Fender [DISAGREE]
Joshua Pangle [DISAGREE]
James Faulkenberry [DISAGREE]
IV. THAT THE AUTHORIZATION OF A VARIANCE WILL NOT BE OF SUBSTANTIAL
DETRIMENT TO ADJACENT PROPERTY OR TO THE PUBLIC GOOD, AND THE CHARACTER
OF THE DISTRICT WILL NOT BE HARMED BY THE GRANTING OF THE VARIANCE
Aaron Fender [DISAGREE]
Joshua Pangle [DISAGREE]
James Faulkenberry [DISAGREE]
Variance application BZA-2026-0723 Legacy Pointe Indian Land, LLC is denied.
STAFF WILL PREPARE AN ORDER FORMALIZING THE DECISION, AND THE ORDER
WILL BE ISSUED TO THE INTERESTED PARTIES WITHIN 30 DAYS.
b. BZA-2026-1342 Allegiance Construction Group, LLC
Application by Allegiance Construction Group, LLC on behalf of Ryan & Britney
McCormick for a BZA variance for 1 acre at 4034 Flagstone Drive, Lancaster (TM
#0021-00-091.00) to permit an existing deck that was built without permits and to
allow construction of a roof on it. Permit ID #108938.
Staff Presentation by: Shannon Catoe presented the variance request.
Comment From Applicant(s):
Ryan and Britney McCormick ( Indian Land) were sworn in. They were unaware the previous
owners of their home built the deck unpermitted and within setbacks. They are requesting a
variance for the deck as they would like to build a porch with a roof on it. The applicants shared
4
that the topography makes moving the deck a hardship and provided photos of the yard. The
proposed porch with a roof will remain within the existing footprint of the deck and will not alter
the residential character of the neighborhood.
Public Hearing: (See attachments: Sign-in Sheets)
No members of the public signed up to speak.
Questions From Board:
Board Member Faulkenberry and the applicants discussed the deck’s distance into the setback and
when it was built by the previous owners of the home. They also discussed the proposed porch
with a roof . The applicant shared that they would like the existing deck to be inspected and
permitted to ensure it is structurally sound.
Board Member Fender and the applicants discussed the pool the applicants are also installing and
the setbacks.
Shannon Catoe shared that the variance is to allow the deck to stay as it is within setbacks. The
permit for the porch with a roof will be through the building department.
Board Member Pangle, Shannon Catoe, and the applicant discussed the variance request.
Vice-Chairman Faulkenberry closed Public hearing and called for a motion on item BZA-2026-
1342 Allegiance Construction Group, LLC.
Motion to grant the variance by A. Fender; 2nd by J. Pangle.
Vote: 3:0.
ZONING VARIANCE CRITERIA
V. THAT THERE ARE EXTRAORDINARY AND EXCEPTIONAL CONDITIONS PERTAINING TO
THE PARTICULAR PROPERTY
Aaron Fender [AGREE]
Joshua Pangle [AGREE]
James Faulkenberry [AGREE]
VI. THAT THESE CONDITIONS DO NOT GENERALLY APPLY TO OTHER PROPERTY IN THE
VICINITY
Aaron Fender [AGREE]
Joshua Pangle [AGREE]
James Faulkenberry [AGREE]
VII. THAT BECAUSE OF THESE CONDITIONS, THE APPLICATION OF THE ORDINANCE TO THE
PARTICULAR PROPERTY WOULD EFFECTIVELY PROHIBIT OR UNREASONABLY RESTRICT
THE UTILIZATION OF THE PROPERTY
5
Aaron Fender [AGREE]
Joshua Pangle [AGREE]
James Faulkenberry [AGREE]
VIII. THAT THE AUTHORIZATION OF A VARIANCE WILL NOT BE OF SUBSTANTIAL
DETRIMENT TO ADJACENT PROPERTY OR TO THE PUBLIC GOOD, AND THE CHARACTER
OF THE DISTRICT WILL NOT BE HARMED BY THE GRANTING OF THE VARIANCE
Aaron Fender [AGREE]
Joshua Pangle [AGREE]
James Faulkenberry [AGREE]
Variance application BZA-2026-1342 Allegiance Construction Group, LLC is approved.
STAFF WILL PREPARE AN ORDER FORMALIZING THE DECISION, AND THE ORDER
WILL BE ISSUED TO THE INTERESTED PARTIES WITHIN 30 DAYS.
5. Other
a. The Board and Staff discussed term expiration dates.
6. Adjournment:
With there being no further business, motion to adjourn by A. Fender; 2nd by J. Pangle.
Vote: 3:0. The motion was approved by unanimous consent. Adjourned at 6:36 PM.
BSA - 2026- 0723 · VARIANCE REQUEST
Sign Variance
Request
Section 10.3 — Lancaster County Unified Development Ordinance
as Amended by Ordinance 2023-1855
8479 Legacy Pointe Place, Indian Land, SC
Applicant: Legacy Pointe Indian Land, LLC | Operator: Extra Space Storage
Lancaster County Board of Zoning Appeals
Our Request
Variance from Section 10.3, Lancaster County UDO (as amended by Ordinance 2023- 1855)
WE ARE REQUESTING
95.32 sq ft
Requested sign message area
(variance above the 75 sq ft ordinance cap)
CURRENT ORDINANCE ALLOWS
75 sq ft
Maximum sign area under Section 10.3
(non-large-scale retailer classification)
Property at a Glance
Address
8479 Legacy Pointe Place, Indian Land, SC
Tax Parcel
0013-00-011.01
Property Owner
Legacy Pointe Indian Land, LLC
Operator
Extra Space Storage
Building
100,000+ sq ft · Single building, single use
Frontage
US Highway 521 (state highway corridor)
Distance to Hwy
Approximately 400 feet
THE VARIANCE CRITERIA
South Carolina law and the Lancaster County UDO require all four criteria to be met for variance approval
1 Extraordinary and Exceptional Conditions
2 Unique to This Property
3 Ordinance Restricts Utilization
4 No Substantial Detriment
FINDING 1 OF 4
Extraordinary and Exceptional Conditions
Distance from US Hwy 521
The property is nearly 400 feet from US Highway 521, making visibility significantly
more difficult than for properties adjacent to the highway.
Lower elevation
The property sits at a lower grade than the highway, further reducing the building's
visibility from the road.
Building scale vs. sign allowance
The building is the same size as large-scale retailers permitted larger signs. A 75 sq ft
sign would appear disproportionately small on this 100,000+ sq ft structure.
UDO amendment unavailable
Due to the pending new UDO, we cannot seek an ordinance amendment — as
Costco, Target, and other large-scale retailers received through the same process.
FINDING 2 OF 4
Unique to This Property
Only Property of this Type
We are the only multistory, climate-controlled self-storage facility in the area. No
other property in the vicinity shares our combination of building scale, distance from
the highway, elevation difference, and use type. The extraordinary conditions
identified in Finding 1 are specific to this property and do not generally apply to
surrounding properties.
0.6 miles from the Property
1.6 miles from the Property
3.8 miles from the Property
FINDING 3 OF 4
Ordinance Prohibits the Utilization
Buildings of Similar Size are Allowed Larger Signs
By allowing only a 75 sq ft sign, the ordinance gives this property far less highway visibility than
similarly-sized large-scale retailers located closer to the road. Our building stands nearly 400 feet
from US Hwy 521 — yet retailers at the roadside with identical or smaller buildings are permitted
much larger signs. This discrepancy effectively prohibits proportionate identification of our facility
from the highway, unreasonably restricting our ability to serve the public.
FINDING 4 OF 4
No Substantial Detriment to Adjacent Property or Public Good
Granting this variance will not harm neighboring properties or the character of the district:
Proportionate to the building.
A sign sized in proportion to this 100,000+ sq ft building
does not adversely impact neighboring properties.
No neighbor objections.
No neighbors have objected to our proposed signage.
Public benefit.
Better visibility from US Hwy 521 benefits adjacent owners
— reducing wrong turns and unnecessary traffic on local
roads.
Character preserved.
Another property we developed and own at 5320 E Independence Blvd, Charlotte
The sign is consistent with the commercial corridor
character of the highway frontage area.
RELIEF REQUESTED
We respectfully request the Board grant the following:
1 Grant the Variance
Grant a variance from Section 10.3 of the Lancaster County Unified Development Ordinance, as amended by Ordinance 2023- 1855, for Case BSA-2026-0723.
2 Authorize the Requested Sign Area
Authorize a wall sign message area of 95.32 sq ft for the property at 8479 Legacy Pointe Place, Indian Land, SC (Parcel 0013- 00-011.01), in excess of the 75 sq ft
ordinance limit.
3 Findings of Fact
Find that all four required variance criteria are satisfied as set forth in the evidence and arguments presented herein.
Thank You
We respectfully ask the Board to grant the variance.
QUESTIONS WELCOME
Case: BSA-2026-0723 — Variance Request, Section 10.3 Lancaster County UDO
Property: 8479 Legacy Pointe Place, Indian Land, SC · Parcel 0013-00-011.01
Applicant: Legacy Pointe Indian Land, LLC
Operator: Extra Space Storage
Source: Lancaster County website. First collected Oct 26, 2026.