RecordWell Data

Board of Zoning Appeals — Minutes

Lancaster County · Lancaster County · Board of Zoning Appeals · meeting of Jun 2, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Lancaster County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

MEMBERS OF LANCASTER COUNTY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS CHARLES . K. DEESE JAMES FAULKENBERRY MARK BOLAND AARON FENDER JOSHUA PANGLE 1 MINUTES OF THE LANCASTER COUNTY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS REGULAR MEETING June 2, 2026, at 6:00 PM 1. Roll Call/Call to Order Board Members present: Quorum is present (5 Board Members) Charles Deese Mark Boland Aaron Fender James Faulkenberry Joshua Pangle Staff: Shannon Catoe, Zoning Administrator Mika Garris, Zoning Technician Dr. Kirsten Willis, Planner Mara Mata, Administrative Assistant Staff were sworn in. Members of the press were notified in advance but were not present. All adjacent property owners were notified by mail. A notice of public hearing was published in the Lancaster News at least 15 days prior to the meeting. The agenda was posted on the County website and posted in the lobby of the Administration Building one week prior to the meeting. A copy of the agenda is on file. THE FOLLOWING IS A SUMMARY ONLY; IT IS NOT A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT. Chairman Deese called the meeting to order at 6:00 p.m. 2. Approval of Agenda J. Pangle moved to Approve the Agenda; Second by J. Faulkenberry. Vote: 5:0. The motion was approved by unanimous consent. 3. Public Hearing Items Chairman Deese discussed Legal Notice, the Board of Zoning Appeal’s duties, and general instructions for the meeting. 2 a. BZA-2026-0723 Extra Space Storage Application by Extra Space Storage and Legacy Pointe Indian Land, LLC to appeal action from Zoning Official for 5.99 acres at Charlotte Hwy (TM #0013-00-011.01) for denial of wall signage totaling 170.32 sq ft. Staff Presentation: Shannon Catoe presented the application consistent with the staff report; she shared that this applicant was approved as a self-storage facility and paid permit and impact fees based off that use. Staff Recommendations: Denial Comment from applicant(s): Jaime Rolowitz (Cornelius) and Laura Temple (Moorseville) were sworn in. They provided information regarding the site and the building and asked the board to recognize the facility as a large-scale retailer as defined in Section 10.3 of the UDO. The allowed wall signage is 75 square feet, and they are requesting 170 square feet of wall signage to increase visibility to Charlotte Highway. They also explained that the permit and impact fees were based off construction costs for their use, and that does include retail and they have a retail license. Questions to Applicant: Board Member Pangle and the applicant discussed the current zoning of the parcel and the possibility of a pplying for a text amendment. The applicants share d that Staff suggested they request a variance but did not feel they qualified. Chairman Deese and the applicants discussed the building’s distance from the road. The Board, Shannon Catoe, and the applicants discussed the possibility of having a sign closer to the road. Board Member Faulkenberry and the applicants discussed the square footage and whether this project qualifies for large scale retail. The applicants shared that they own 11 of these properties with signs that are scaled for the building. Public Hearing: (See attachments: Sign-in Sheets) No members of the public signed up to speak. Chairman Deese closed Public hearing and invited the applicants to speak if they wished. Applicant Rebuttal: The applicants declined to speak. Questions To Staff: Board Member Faulkenberry and Shannon Catoe discussed the difference between large- scale retail and self-storage regarding impact fees, permits, buffers, setbacks, and parking. 3 Chairman Deese discussed the variance request. Board Member Pangle and Shannon Catoe discussed the large -scale retail text amendment . The applicants shared why they believe they qualify as a large-scale retailer. Chairman Deese called for a motion on item BZA-2026-0723 Extra Space Storage. Discussion: Chairman Deese shared examples of other businesses that were approved for larger signs. Per UDO 9.2.14.C, THE BOARD HAS CONDUCTED A FORMAL REVIEW, AND ACTION IS REQUIRED. BOARD MEMBERS, DO WE HAVE A MOTION TO: • Reverse the original decision or permit • Affirm the original decision or permit, wholly or in part • Modify the contested decision or permit • Continue to a later meeting Motion to affirm the original decision by M. Boland; 2nd by J. Pangle. Called vote: 5:0. Motion is approved unanimously. Mark Boland FOR Aaron Fener FOR James Faulkenberry FOR Joshua Pangle FOR Charles Deese FOR STAFF WILL PREPARE AN ORDER FORMALIZING THE DECISION, AND THE ORDER WILL BE ISSUED TO THE INTERESTED PARTIES WITHIN 30 DAYS. 4. Approval of Minutes a. Minutes of 05/05/2026 Meeting. Call for a motion. Motion to approve as written by A. Fender; Second by M. Boland. Vote: 4:0. Minutes are approved unanimously. J. Faulkenberry abstained. 5. Adjournment With there being no further business, motion to adjourn by A. Fender; 2nd by J. Faulkenberry. The motion was approved by unanimous consent. Adjourned at 6:46 PM. BEFORE THE LANCASTER COUNTY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS Appeal from Action of the Zoning Official Sign Permit Project No. 20260723 8479 Charlotte Highway, Indian Land, SC Parcel 0013-00-011.01 Applicant: Legacy Pointe Indian Land, LLC Operator: Extra Space Storage OUR REQUEST, UP FRONT What we are asking the Board to do REVERSE THE APRIL 9, 2026 DETERMINATION Recognize the facility as a “Retailer, Large-Scale” under UDO § 10.3, and approve the requested 170.32 sq ft wall sign. 1 WHY THE LAW SUPPORTS US The facility meets every element of the ordinance: a single use, in a single building, of at least 100,000 sq ft — and engages in on-site retail every day. 2 WHY FAIRNESS SUPPORTS US Council itself said large-scale buildings have more wall space and need bigger signs. Our building fits that finding exactly. 2 / 13 BACKGROUND The property at issue ADDRESS 8479 Charlotte Highway, Indian Land, SC NEW ADDRESS (PENDING) 8479 Legacy Pointe Place TAX PARCEL 0013-00-011.01 PROPERTY OWNER Legacy Pointe Indian Land, LLC OPERATOR Extra Space Storage BUILDING Single building — 100,000+ sq ft gross floor area FRONTAGE Charlotte Highway (state highway corridor) AT A GLANCE 100,000+ square feet of gross floor area 1 building • 1 operator • 1 continuous use Walk-in office. Public-facing. Open to the consuming public. 3 / 13 THE APRIL 9, 2026 “NOT APPROVED” LETTER What the Zoning Official decided “ Proposed wall signage exceeds the allowable maximum 75 sq ft message area by 95.32 sq ft. Applicant is requesting signage of 170.32 sq ft message area. The USE of storage facility does not meet the Large-Scale Retailer definition. — Julie Faile, Zoning Official, Lancaster County Development Services THE REAL ISSUE The 75 sq ft cap is only triggered because of the classification call. Reclassify correctly, and the sign is allowed. WHAT WE ARE APPEALING The single sentence: “The USE of storage facility does not meet the Large-Scale Retailer definition.” 4 / 13 THE CONTROLLING LANGUAGE Lancaster County Ordinance No. 2023-1855 Adopted July 17, 2023 • Amending UDO § 10.3, Use Type Definitions RETAILER, LARGE-SCALE “A single retail use located in a single building of at least 100,000 square feet of gross floor area.” — Ord. 2023-1855, Exhibit 1 (§ 10.3, Definitions, Use Type) TWO ELEMENTS — BOTH MUST BE MET (1) a single retail use • (2) in a single building of at least 100,000 sq ft APPLYING THE ORDINANCE We meet both elements of the definition ✓ ELEMENT 1 Single building, 100,000+ sq ft • One building — not a strip center, not multi-tenant. • One operator — Extra Space Storage occupies the entire building. • One continuous use — no subdivision, no shared anchors. • Gross floor area exceeds the 100,000 sq ft threshold. ✓ ELEMENT 2 A retail use • Consumer-facing, walk-in office open to the public. • Tangible retail goods sold over the counter. • Retail business license; SC sales tax collected. • Direct marketing to the general consuming public. The ordinance does not require the building to sell a particular kind of product — only that the use be retail and the building be large. 6 / 13 ELEMENT 2 IN PRACTICE What our customers buy when they walk in Boxes & packing supplies Multiple sizes of moving boxes, tape, bubble wrap, packing paper, mattress and furniture covers, wardrobe boxes. Padlocks & disc locks Tangible goods sold over the counter; sales tax collected and remitted. Tenant protection plans Insurance-style coverage sold directly to consumers. Walk-in unit leasing Storage units leased in a standard, retail-style consumer transaction. On-site staff & customer service Public showroom hours; in-person assistance; the look and feel of a retailer. Every one of these is a transaction with a member of the general public — the textbook definition of retail. 7 / 13 ORD. 2023-1855, § 1(C) Council’s own findings apply to this building WHY COUNCIL CREATED THE LARGE-SCALE RETAILER CATEGORY “Large-scale retailers have different impacts to the community, can create more jobs, require more parking, and have more wall space on which to display signage.” 01 More jobs Extra Space Storage maintains on-site staff at this facility — ongoing local employment, just as Council described. 02 More parking Customers arrive daily by personal vehicle and by moving truck. The site is built around customer parking and circulation. 03 More wall space The building presents a large, continuous wall plane along Charlotte Hwy — the very condition Council said warrants a larger sign. 8 / 13 THE FAIRNESS PROBLEM Same building. Different rule? IF THIS WERE A FURNITURE STORE 100,000+ sq ft retailer • Same building footprint. • Same wall plane along Charlotte Hwy. • Same parking demand and customer traffic. • Same need for wayfinding from the highway. → Approved at the larger sign allowance. OUR BUILDING (DENIED) 100,000+ sq ft consumer- facing facility • Same building footprint. • Same wall plane along Charlotte Hwy. • Same parking demand and customer traffic. • Same need for wayfinding from the highway. → Denied — only because of what we sell inside. Nothing in the ordinance — and nothing in Council’s findings — supports that inconsistent outcome. 9 / 13 SIGN SIZE VS. BUILDING SCALE (FROM SIGNAGE INDUSTRIES DRAWINGS) The 75 sq ft sign doesn’t fit this building WHAT THE CURRENT 75 SQ FT CAP ALLOWS — 73.37 SQ FT SIGN (DRAWING 25526-D) 73.37 sq ft message area 31 ½" letter height ~27'-11" wide sign width ~15% of wall width WHAT WE’RE REQUESTING — 170.32 SQ FT SIGN (DRAWING 26150-D) 170.32 sq ft message area 48" letter height ~42'-7" wide sign width ~23% of wall width 10 / 13 WHAT IS ACTUALLY ON THE APPLICATION The sign we are requesting THE NUMBERS 170.32 square feet of wall-sign message area requested 75 sq ft cap currently being applied (generic) Permit Project No. 20260723 Why this size is appropriate • Proportionate to the building. A 100,000+ sq ft wall plane simply cannot be served by a 75 sq ft sign — the lettering would be illegible from Charlotte Hwy travel speeds. • Consistent with Council’s intent. The Large-Scale Retailer allowance exists precisely so buildings of this scale can be identified at highway speed. • Single tenant, single sign. We are not aggregating multiple tenants’ sign rights — this is one operator on one building. • Aesthetics and safety. Larger lettering improves wayfinding, reduces last- second lane changes, and serves public safety. 11 / 13 WHAT WE ASK THE BOARD TO ORDER Relief Requested 01 Reverse the April 9, 2026 determination that the use does not meet the Large-Scale Retailer definition. 02 Find that the facility is a “Retailer, Large-Scale” under UDO § 10.3 — single retail use, single building, 100,000+ sq ft. 03 Direct the Zoning Official to review Sign Permit Project No. 20260723 under the Large-Scale Retailer signage standards. 04 Approve the requested 170.32 sq ft wall-sign message area. Thank you We respectfully ask the Board to grant the appeal. QUESTIONS WELCOME Applicant: Legacy Pointe Indian Land, LLC Property: 8479 Charlotte Highway, Indian Land, SC — Parcel 0013-00-011.01 Operator: Extra Space Storage Permit: Sign Permit Project No. 20260723

Source: Lancaster County website. First collected Oct 26, 2026.