Design Review Board Meeting — Minutes
Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · Design Review Board · meeting of Oct 28, 2025 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board
Meeting Minutes
10/28/2025 Page | 1
Town of Hilton Head Island
DESIGN REVIEW BOARD MEETING
Tuesday, October 28, 2025, 1:30 PM
Minutes
1. Call to Order
Chair Carstens called the meeting to order at 1:30pm.
In attendance: Judd Carstens, Annette Lippert, Tom Parker, Todd Theodore, Megan
Fitzpatrick, Patricia Pastor, Cathy Foss.
2. Adoption of the Agenda
Melissa Paul-Leto, Principal Planner, proposed changes to the published agenda order. The
change moved St. James Baptist Church to the second item in Unfinished Business, and
moved Black Marlin Outdoor Bar to the first item in New Business.
Mr. Parker made a motion to adopt the agenda with the changes. Ms. Pastor seconded, which
passed unanimously.
3. Approval of the Minutes
a. Regular Meeting Minutes of October 14, 2025
Ms. Fitzpatrick made a motion to approve the meeting minutes of October 14, 2025. Mr.
Theodore seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
4. Unfinished Business
a. DRB-001013-2025 - Patterson Family Park - Final
Chair Carstens recused himself, passed the gavel to Vice Chair Lippert, and left the dias.
Ms. Paul-Leto introduced the Patterson Family Park for Final review. The applicant
answered questions from the Board. Mr. Parker motioned to approve with the following
conditions: the roof color will change to be non-reflective; all conduit will be hidden to the
greatest extent possible. Ms. Pastor seconded. Vice-Chair Lippert denied the motion
which passed by a vote of 5 to 1.
b. DRB-001018-2025 - Union Cemetery Road — St. James Baptist Church — Final
Vice Chair Lippert passed the gavel to Chair Carstens who returned to the dias. Mr.
Parker recused himself and left the dias. Ms. Paul-Leto presented the St. James Baptist
Church for final review. The applicant answered questions from the Board. Vice Chair
Lippert motioned to approve under the following conditions: confirmation of the school
building as part of the scope and ramp details; drawings of the heights of the various
Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board
Meeting Minutes
10/28/2025 Page | 2
building elements; the can light cut sheet will be submitted; the louver colors will match
the building siding; the stained glass will be included in the resubmittal to staff; the brick
crossings should not be painted but instead a contrasting brick; the gutters and
downspouts will match the roof color. Ms. Pastor seconded. The motion passed
unanimously.
5. New Business
a. DRB-001002-2025 - 86 Helmsman Way - Black Marlin Outdoor Bar - Conceptual
Mr. Parker recused himself and remained away from the dias. Ms. Paul-Leto presented
the Black Marlin Outdoor Bar for conceptual review. The applicant answered questions
from the Board. Vice Chair Lippert motioned to approve under the following conditions:
study the roof extent as it relates to the Carolina Crab Company nearby so that those
corners do not connect in plan but are more like the right side elevation; clarify how the
pavement will be repaired to match existing; provide countertop materials, roof materials,
tv's, fans, lights, colors of the garage doors, including the slats on the side; confirm that all
the bar equipment is below the countertop height; provide heights for anything within the
center portion of the structure like various equipment, heaters, etc. that get mounted. Ms.
Foss seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
b. DRB-000964-2025 - 124 Arrow Road - Monument Sign
Mr. Parker returned to the dias while Mr. Theodore recused himself and left. Ms. Paul-
Leto presented the Monument Sign for review. The applicant answered questions from
the Board. The Board suggested that a hierarchy on the sign would make it look less like
a directory, a stucco base should be added, the cap color should not be white, the sign's
relative size and location to the building almost make the sign moot and lighting should be
considered. Chair Carstens motioned for the applicant to implement input from the Board
and resubmit the project to staff and the Chair and Vice Chair for review. Mr. Parker
seconded. The motion was approved unanimously.
6. Public Comment - Non Agenda Items
Mr. Theodore returned to the dias. Citizen Taiwan Scott spoke in reference to cultural
expression through design colors and asked that the Board consider colors that reflect the
Gullah Geechee community in addition to the Town color scheme as we introduce more parks
to the area and update the LMO.
7. Board Business
The Board discussed Beach Properties of Hilton Head and requested that staff review what
was approved regarding the primer and roof color. An update on construction near Crazy Crab
was requested. Staff proposed that 2026 meetings take place on Wednesdays which would
require Board approval and an amendment to the Rules of Procedure.
8. Staff Reports
9. Adjournment
Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board
Meeting Minutes
10/28/2025 Page | 3
The meeting adjourned at 3:38pm.
APPROVED: 11-12-25
Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Oct 26, 2026.