RecordWell Data

_10072026-594

City of North Myrtle Beach · Horry County · meeting of Oct 7, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of North Myrtle Beach

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 CITY OF NORTH MYRTLE BEACH, SOUTH CAROLINA NORTH MYRTLE BEACH CITY HALL PLANNING COMMISSION WORKSHOP Wednesday, October 7, 2026 1:30 PM MINUTES Silvio Cutuli, Chairman City Staff: Ty Bellamy Suzanne Pritchard, Asst. Director Harry Oehler Amber Elmadolar, Plan Reviewer/GIS Tech Joe Gosiewski Ed Horton, Absent for Roll Call only Ed Prince Emily Broome, Plan Reviewer/GIS Tech Chris Noury, City Attorney Allison Galbreath, City Clerk Callie Jean Wise Angela Westmoreland, Asst. City Clerk 1. CALL TO ORDER: Chairman Cutuli called the meeting to order at 1:30 PM and asked the Clerk to call the roll. Chairman Cutuli stated this was a workshop and went over ground rules . He stated that outbursts would not be tolerated. He explained that a workshop was basically a discussion among the Planning Commission and invited guests. He added there would be time for public comment. 2. DISCUSSION: MINOR PLANNED DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT AMENDMENT Z-26-22: City staff received an application for a minor amendment to the Parkway Group Planned Development District (PDD) for drone facilities at an existing fulfillment site. Jim Wood, Planning and Development Director, stated that workshops were educational opportunities for either City Council or the Planning Commission to learn more about an issue before they take formal votes on it. He added that no votes would be taken at the workshop. Director Wood noted the item would be back on the Planning Commission agenda on October 20, 2026, for a vote. He stated the purpose of today’s workshop was to provide information to the Planning Commission to inform their deliberations at the next meeting. Director Wood added members of the Horry County Airport Authority and Amazon were in attendance in person or via zoom. Tareq Wafarie, Amazon Economic Development Representative, shared a slide show and s tated that Amazon had started discussion with the FAA concerning drone delivery over a decade ago . He noted the entire process was controlled in-house and Amazon hired engineers, many of them former Boeing engineers or other airline engineers to design the drones. Mr. Wafarie stated it had taken a very long time to iterate and to prove to the FAA that Amazon had a drone that could operate safely across the entire network. Mr. Wafarie stated there were presently 16 active drone sites. He noted the drones had a 5-pound payload, could travel 7.5 miles from the facility, and gave off no exhaust . The package could be no larger than a shoebox. He explained that the drones were equipped with cameras for navigation but had no surveillance ability and that customer privacy was paramount. Discussion continued concerning no-fly zones, noise, delivery/landing zones, and FAA approval. Mr. Wafarie added that the FAA controlled airspace and an environment analysis through the National Environmental Policy Act and found no significant impact with commercial drone delivery. He shared that Amazon would host an information meet and greet for residents prior to the initial flight. 2 PER REQUEST, THIS BEGINS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE WORKSHOP. Commissioner Gosiewski: My first question is the drone has a seven -and-a-half-mile range. Is that established by the capability of the drone or is that set by the FAA? Tareq Wafarie: It's actually a combination of the two. The current drone, because of the way it's designed and through the testing that we've done with the FAA, is approved by the FAA at a seven-and-a-half-mile radius. Commissioner Gosiewski: A year from now, you could upgrade the drone and have a ten-and-a-half-mile radius with a larger drone? Tareq Wafarie: I'm not aware of plans to do that, but we are constantly designing. This is our second drone. Our current drone is 50 percent quieter than our last drone. We are always looking at ways to improve the current system, but I don't know what that would look like from a flight distance perspective as of today. Commissioner Gowiewski: You spoke of two altitudes, 400 feet and 100 feet. Why did you mention two altitudes? Tareq Wafarie: The 100 feet is where we vertically ascend and descend. We never do forward transition flight below 100 feet. We always go to at least 100 feet before we would even transition to forward flight to get at the 205 to 370 feet. The 400 foot above ground level is the absolute ceiling per the FAA. We cannot fly our drone higher than 400 feet above ground level. Commissioner Gosiewski: I think you've mentioned this or addressed this a little bit about trees and utility lines. How much space do you need to deliver a package? In other words, if you have a lot that is treed and you have above ground utility lines, are you looking at perhaps the driveway space to drop the package? Is that large enough? In other words, is it a 10 by 10 area or do you need a 20 by 20 area? What's the area that you need to actually deliver the package to go down 13 feet? Tareq Wafarie: We come down to 13 feet, but we need 18 feet diameter up to 100 feet. So, if you think of a cylinder that is 100 feet tall and 18 feet wide in diameter, that is the clearance that we need to be able to safely deliver by drone to your personal property . We don't fly it ourselves, but we purchased LiDAR that's flown down to the two-centimeter accuracy. And we've got good GPS data too. So even though you might say I'm interested in drone delivery, if you've got a stand of mature trees that just would not allow us to do it, you're not going to be eligible as a customer. Commissioner Gosiewski: Go back to the no -fly zone, please. Am I to understand that nothing in those red zones would be eligible for drone flights. No, no houses and there would be no delivery in those red areas Tareq Wafarie: Correct. None at all . Not only would you not be eligible for drone delivery, but we're not even going to fly through that area. That is a no-fly zone. So, by definition, we cannot fly there. Commission Gosiewski: And my last question, can you launch the drones without a pad? In other words, can you open up the back doors of the facility, roll the drone out, put a package in it and launch it from the parking lot? Tareq Wafarie: That's exactly what we'll be doing. So even though there's circles on the slide, that pad is merely painted circles on the existing parking area. Commissioner Gosiewski: I think you misunderstand. Instead of building a launch pad on the property, is it possible for you to open up the back doors of the facility, roll the drone out the back door, put a package in it and launch it? Tareq Wafarie: No, the way our system is designed today, we need that distance from our existing building to be able to take off and land, which is why those designated circles. Although I'm calling it a pad, it still is just the surface of the parking area. But no, we can't do that right out the back door of our building. Commission Horton: How close can you go to a neighboring property? Can you fly this thing within 18 feet of a neighbor’s property? Tareq Wafarie: Technically, yes, we could. If the neighbor, if the customer designated the delivery zone that had 18 feet clear and at that 18-foot line, if it was very close to a fence or a building or anything else, then you're probably not 3 going to pass that clearance through Amazon Prime Air. But you could get pretty close if that is your open area where you've designated delivery. Commissioner Prince: One of my questions about the 18 feet, say we have a lot of small lots, especially in the area of Cherry Grove where I live, and I don't know if there's 18-foot clearance in the front of the house without using the street. Is that how that works? Tareq Wafarie: Yeah, you're not going to be eligible for drone delivery. We don't count streets. This has to be on your personal property to be eligible for drone delivery. My house, for example, is not eligible for drone delivery for that very same reason. I don't have enough clearance. I'm in a very dense neighborhood with a big tree in the front yard and too small of a backyard for drone delivery, so I'm not eligible. Commissioner Prince: Did you do an analysis to see the lot sizes in our community and whether or not we have a lot that do qualify, or is that just going to be figured out as you go? Tareq Wafarie: Great question. I appreciate you asking me. We do a fair amount of analysis before we ever start any outreach within the community, and that is not only from a customer reach perspective where we know we have a significant number of Prime customers in North Myrtle Beach, which we do, but also will the airspace and will the ground space really allow us to reach a lot of those customers, and if the answer is no, we move on to somewhere else. Commissioner Prince: If you were not located inside the city of North Myrtle Beach, would we even be hearing about you considering delivering into our area? In other words, if you were in the county, would we even get a say in this? There's just FAA would have to be where we would file a complaint or comments. Tareq Wafarie: I don't want to lie to you. If you're not in the host community, and I won't, and so if you're not in the host community, in this case North Myrtle Beach, there is no say on the local land use piece of this because we're on the ground at our fulfillment center. The FAA controls all of the airspace, so does that mean you won't have a say. I wouldn't couch it as that because we're going to do community outreach and that's going to include all communities in the service area, so we want to take the feedback, but if the question is can we stop drones from flying overhead, that is a matter of the FAA, not me. Commissioner Prince: So, you're looking at serving an area that's not inside the city of North Myrtle Beach. Those folks just don't have a say. Tareq Wafarie: They don't have to be a customer, but you're exactly right. If it's we don't want drones flying in this community, that is a decision from the FAA. Chairman Cutuli: You earlier mentioned that you need FAA flight approval yet. Do you know when you are anticipating getting that approval? Tareq Wafarie: Yeah, I think we're still a ways out. I don't have a definitive time frame because there's some Class C airspace within the circle. You can see it in the purple there. We're going to have to be issued a Certificate Of Authorization, and I think that paperwork may have been filed recently, but that takes a while for them to approve it, and so in a perfect world, we would line up the local land use approvals, the community engagement piece, and the FAA approvals to occur hopefully within the same month. I don't know if we're going to be able to achieve that here Chairman Cutulli: How do you qualify a customer's property for delivery? In other words, do you send somebody out and do an on-scene analysis or do you just do it over? Tareq Wafarie: It happens in a couple of different ways. Much like when we first initiated same-day delivery, you would go onto the app like you currently do, and when you went to click on an item, we're going to tell you, hey, this is eligible for drone delivery. Are you interested, yes or no? Once you say yes that triggers a process for consent by the customer. At that point, our airspace team reviews the LIDAR to see would this even work at this particular customer's home? If the answer is yes, based on the LIDAR and based on the customer's consent, and you're able to establish a delivery zone, that should complete the process, and we will attempt to make that delivery. If it’s the first flight, we end up seeing a trampoline that's happened in a couple of cases, then that'll be a reach- 4 out to the customer to say, look, you said you had a zone there. It's not free and clear, so we can't deliver until you resolve the matter. In a very rare and extreme instance, would we go out and do a customer survey where there's a discrepancy from what we might see on LIDAR and what you might be telling us on the customer end? And so, we could send a team out to review the site and take the necessary measurements before we would make any delivery there. Chairman Cutuli: On the seven-and-a-half-mile operating area map that you've got on the screen, the purple area is a questionable area or what is that area again? Tareq Wafarie: It's Class C airspace defined by the FAA, and so because of the traffic involved there, we just need to get certificate of authorization. Part of that, I'm not the FAA expert, but I have a team that is, part of that is making sure that our traffic management system for unmanned vehicles coordinates well with other users of that Class C airspace. So, it's a higher level of scrutiny within the purple than it is in the other areas that do not have Class C airspace. Councilman Horton: You indicated that you can only deliver to individual single -family residences. You cannot deliver to any condominium projects or any apartment projects, correct? Tareq Wafarie: As of today, that is correct. That has been a challenge for us. We have attempted that in some other markets. It is very challenging just needing common open space and consent from multiple owners and landlords to approve where deliveries could be made. So right now, no commercial property deliveries, only single-family residential. Commissioner Oehler: A couple questions for you. We'll go to the bad side. How many accidents have you had or experienced with Amazon with these drones? Tareq Wafarie: Yes, so we thank you for the question. I don't mind answering that at all. We have had two incidents. And so one was we hit a crane in Tolleson, Arizona. I've already mentioned that. That was very early. That was one of our first sites to launch. That crane should have been registered with the FAA. It was not. Our drone made contact with it. We've adjusted the scanners on the drone to accommodate even an unregistered crane of that specific type so that that doesn't happen again. We learned from it. We lost the drone that day. It was not good. Nobody was injured. The second incident we had was out of Richardson, Texas. We made contact with the eve of an apartment complex where we were attempting multifamily delivery. We had 18 feet clear. But on the ascent after making delivery, the edge of our drone clipped the soffit of the top of that building and made landing on the ground unexpectedly. And so, again, those are the two unfortunate incidents. In both of those, we complied with NTSB and the local emergency responders. Commissioner Oehler: How often do you need to reapply to the FAA? So, currently, you’re at seven and a half miles. You're always looking for new technology to expand out. When you need to reapply to the FAA, say, hey, we want to expand our circle to ten miles as opposed to seven and a half, what are the parameters behind that? Tareq Wafarie: Yes, is the answer, the short answer. And it's beyond that. If we were to ask for further distance, there would be more reviews and testing involved for us to go beyond seven and a half miles. If we were to change the physical makeup of the drone itself, that would require another round of FAA approvals. And thirdly, if we were to relocate where we are operating takeoff and landing from within our fulfillment center parking area, that would also require approval and additional review from the FAA. And that is because these are autonomous drones. And so, if you're a drone pilot that can joystick it and fly it either from an iPad or some other control system, you don't have the same scrutiny that we have with the FAA. These are autonomous. And so, the exact location of where we take off and land is really important to that approval process. So, if we were to change that in any way, we're coming back to the city, we're coming back to the FAA. Commissioner Oehler: I see on one of the areas that you guys are operating in , Ruskin, Florida, would that happen to be a beach community? Tareq Wafarie: Yeah. Commissioner Oehler: What kind of feedback or pushback did you get from the residents in Ruskin prior to your operation beginning there? 5 Tareq Wafarie: Yeah. Ruskin was one of our real success stories. I wouldn't say it was easy. We did have the same line of questions that you're giving me today, but we have had no issues with that and overwhelmingly positive results in that community. Commissioner Oehler: Next, going to the map, the way your operating area is, is it beneficial for you guys to come out, go over the ocean to get that little piece that's within the circle? Would you guys consider doing that to service that area? Tareq Wafarie: I will have to check in with my airspace team again on this definitively, but our plans right now are not to be over the beach or the water to access any customers in North Myrtle Beach. Commissioner Oehler: Just to reiterate what you said earlier, a customer has to opt in to get drone service, correct? There has to be at least 100 feet and an 18-foot circle. That's clear for you guys to hover over, drop the package, and then leave, correct? Tareq Wafarie: That is correct. Commissioner Wise: You said jobs, new employees. If you're starting with 12 drones, how many employees or jobs does that create? Tareq Wafarie: I would imagine we'll create 6 to 10 net new jobs out of this program. I'll work with Mike Lindberg, who's actually controlling this particular project, and I know he's done a lot of work with your regional economic development team on exactly what that might look like, but it's not going to be below that number. Commissioner Wise: Does this eliminate any jobs of the independent contractors that are currently used to make deliveries? Tareq Wafarie: No, it does not. This does not eliminate any jobs. This is a supplemental service with a completely different program. All of those delivery drivers will still be making same -day deliveries. Some of those that might be eligible for drone delivery now would go there within the hour, which our delivery drivers just can't do, because the main difference there is a delivery driver might have 40 to 50 packages in their vehicle, and they're going out throughout the entire community and dropping those packages sam e day. The drone has one single item for one single customer and then returns to the station. Very different programs. It's not going to impact those existing jobs by personal vehicle. Commissioner Wise: Thank you, sir. The drone demonstration/open house that you spoke about, you said one month to six weeks. How will you let the public know when that's available? Tareq Wafarie: We have a community engagement team that focuses on lots of different channels. One will be through North Myrtle Beach, like how your communication team likes to get word out to your constituents. Beyond that, we do a lot of social media. Facebook has been extremely successful for us, where we're usually able to generate hundreds of RSVPs to those events. Oftentimes, we'll do a press release as well, try to do media release, even live camera media release where we talk about those upcoming meetings. So, we don't just have one method. We broadly use multiple methods to get the word out for that meeting. Commissioner Wise: Regarding the decibel level, whenever you say you're leaving the warehouse, you go up 100 feet. What is the decibel level of the drone at 100 feet before you make forward flight? Tareq Wafarie: Yeah, it'll be between 45 and 60 as it's a 100 feet up, but usually closer to the 45 level, much like it would be that forward flight as it's flying through the community. Commissioner Wise: Once it's at 13 feet in someone's yard, what is that decibel level? Tareq Wafarie: Yeah, closer to 65. We have seen it. We've done an independent sound study and we sent people out, not only in our studio that we built to conduct that study, but also in a yard, a test yard in Arizona. We find it to be on average at about 65. Sometimes it has crept up closer to what it is at takeoff at 68 decibels. And sorry, I want to mention on that because I failed to during the presentation, the process from when it descends to a customer's yard, drops the package and re-ascends and begins forward flight back to the station is about 25 to 30 seconds. Commissioner Wise: The people that are loading the drones, are they required to wear hearing protection? 6 Tareq Wafarie: Yes, they are. And they're specially trained. You can't be a warehouse associate who is typically filling boxes and all of a sudden decide to walk out to the primary drone delivery center that requires special training. Commissioner Wise: How many properties that are in your 7.5 area do you guys know are currently, will be eligible based off your LIDAR for the drone delivery? Tareq Wafarie: I don't have an answer to that today. I can search for that. Oftentimes we're not going to divulge that proprietary information. I can see what I can divulge and get that answer for you. Commissioner Wise: Even if it's a percentage wise of the, what we call R1 zoning, which is single family residential, that would be very good to know. And in 2025, have you had any public injuries due to drone flights provided by you guys? Tareq Wafarie: No, we have not. Not in 2025 or 2026 or ever. Commissioner Bellamy: I just have a one follow up question. So the blue circle we're looking at in the operating area map right now, it looks like for the most part, nothing east of the waterway is going to be serviceable except for the little sliver potentially where it says N orth Myrtle Beach on the map. And that would have to go out into the ocean and back. Is that correct? Tareq Wafarie: No, we have no plans to go out into the ocean and back in to reach customers anywhere in the service area. Commissioner Wise: So, the only way it would be able to go is north and then cut between the helicopter pad and the flight zone? Commissioner Bellamy: The service area is the unfilled circle, correct? Commissioner Wise: So, they wouldn't even be able to go across that flight pattern. Tareq Wafarie: They're not going east of the waterway. So, I'm not certain that we would be able to deliver to those customers in that wedge, to be honest. Commissioner Oehler: And beyond that circle right now, that's still part of the city, you do not have the approval because it's outside the 7.5 mile radius, correct? Tareq Wafarie: Exactly. This line is the seven and a half miles. This wedge, although falls within it, would require us going out over the ocean and around the no-fly zone to reach it. I want to be careful here because I'm not the FAA guy. I am the Economic Development Manager for Prime Air. And I don't want to give you the wrong answer, but this to me looks like an area we would not be able to serve for those reasons. Commissioner Bellamy: Remind me again what the blue shaded area is. Tareq Wafarie: That's a different class of airspace but not restricted like Class C airspace is restricted. It's based on the type of airport and runway. Commissioner Wise: Based off of what Commissioner Gosiewski said earlier, right now, without the land use approval, could you currently use the parking spaces that are there to launch your drones? Tareq Wafarie: No, we cannot. We would be breaking your local land use rules if we did that. Just like we wouldn't launch a new fulfillment center without local land use approval. Commissioner Oehler: You said you had an FAA environmental analysis done. Where is it available that we could look at or read it? The overall programmatic analysis is available online. Tareq Wafarie: I think it's dated June or July of this year. It's called the Programmatic Environmental Assessment through the FAA for commercial drone delivery. That is available now. The Environmental Assessment at the local level, I 7 think they're still working through that. I know that we already have this NFZ defined over the wildlife preserve, but I don't think that official EA has been fully signed off on yet. And they reach out to state agencies to get feedback. And that's really what provides the FAA what they need to conduct that. Each region, much like North Myrtle Beach, has a regional FAA. They're called the FSDO, the district office of the FAA. That's where you would be able to access that information. And I can make sure as an additional follower that you know who that local FSDO contact is. Commissioner Gosiewski: Time of day, you have civil twilight hours, sunrise to sunset. Is that set by the FAA? Tareq Wafarie: Yes, it is. That is another one of our limitations under the FAA. Okay, it's one of your limitations under the FAA. Commissioner Gosiewski: Do local governments have the authority to supersede that and say hours of delivery between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m., let's say, for example? Or is it like airspace, sunrise to sunset, period, end of story? Tareq Wafarie: Yeah, we have to comply with the FAA requirements for airspace. The ability of the local authority to wade in the waters of the FAA's control, you would have to work with the FAA on that. Director Wood: You mentioned that the FAA has to approve your flight program for this offering. A lot of federal programs have public comment periods. They have an opportunity for the public to view the request and to make comments. You know, sometimes they publish those notices in the Federal Register and not everybody gets to see them. But to your knowledge, does your application to the FAA, does that have a public comment opportunity for folks who may want to submit comments to the FAA about your application? Tareq Wafarie: I don't believe it does. I just want to be right up front with you. Because we received a programmatic environmental assessment for network -wide across the region, or across the country, rather, that PEA, or P, they call it, was the opportunity for environmental assessment. I don't believe there's a public comment period associated with each unique delivery operation zone. In some states, they do initiate a public comment period, depending on your state divisions of environment or fish and wildlife. But per the FAA, I do not believe that they have a public comment period on what they would review for our Certificate Of Authorization. Chairman Cutuli: Is there any way that you could provide a more detailed map of your operating area so we have a clearer picture of city limits? Tareq Wafarie: Probably. And one thing that is really helpful for a lot of us, and I hear your question, and if I can get a better map that's more clear, you're going to want to zoom in on it, and this map is preliminary, and so I wouldn't use it as law. When we do our community outreach meetings, yes, we have the drone there. We don't demonstrate the drone, so it doesn't fly. We're not even allowed to tu rn it on. But we also have big screens that you can interact with, and you can zoom in on the actual map and say, am I within or am I not within these boundaries? So, I want to make sure that you have access to that. You don't have to wait for that community meeting, but I can get you a clearer map. Chairman Cutuli thanked Mr. Warfarie and asked the Horry County Department of Airports Representative to come to the podium. Ryan Boettcher: My name is Ryan Boettcher. I'm with the Department of Airports, the Horry County Department of Airports. We are a division of the Horry County Government, and we are responsible for the airports within the county system, which includes Grand Strand Airport. So, I was asked today to come just get the airport's position on this drone delivery service. We were consulted maybe a couple months ago with preliminary information about it. Just to make it kind of very clear, the airport's position is really just centered around protecting the airspace and activities that are going to happen at the county airport system. So, anything that's going to be happening at Grand Strand Airport, we want to make sure that we're not going to be impacting the approaches, impa cting safety or operations that's going to originate or terminate at the airport. Grand Strand is a unique airport. We have a lot of different types of activity, whether it's general aviation, flight training, corporate, we get a lot of military, we have banner tows, helicopters. So that's kind of our big position is we just want to make sure the airspace around that airport is protected. Based on the preliminary information that we've received, we do not have a position that necessarily makes us opposed to this type of operation. The exhibit that you saw earlier, we received that a couple days ago, kind of showing the initial restricted flight area, which seems fairly consistent with what we expected. Obviously, anything within that, we would just prefer that there's not going to be a lot 8 of activity. It was talked quite a bit during the presentation by the individual from Amazon about who has the ultimate responsibility and authority over that, and that is the FAA. The airports were consulted if it's going to be something that might impact our airports, but beyond that is really an FAA determination. We really don't have a lot of say in that. What's unique about this type of aeronautical activity is that it doesn't originate or terminate at the a irport, and this is another case where we have even further limited say in what's going to happen. But that's really what I just kind of want to come present is this is ultimately an FAA type determination. We would be consulted if it was going to be something that would really impact our approaches for departures at one of our airports. And I'm happy to answer any questions if you have them. Commissioner Gosiewski: Can you tell me if there's a difference between no-fly and restricted airspace? Mr. Boettcher: Not entirely sure if there's a difference. I believe the term that he was using as far as the restricted or what I said restricted, I believe that he's implying that there's absolutely no kind of aircraft or no drone movements within that area. So when we were initially talking with them, that was a concern that we made very clear that there's a lot of homes between the airport and the beach area that there couldn't be any kind of crossing over the airfield with drones just because of the aircraft activity that's going to be happening around there. I believe they're used interchangeably in this case. Commission Gosiewski: Well, I believe that I heard, which is a scary thing to say, that when the police department was looking at drones, there was or is a drone available that could be used in the no -fly zone that we're in, but the cost is hugely prohibitive. So, if the police department can buy drones that can be used within that red area, the no - fly zone, then can others send the drones through that no-fly zone? Mr. Boettcher: I'm not an expert on drone activity, but what I do know about drones is we do have drones that will occasionally operate. They're usually going to be manually operated. It has to get approval from the FAA before they're able to do that. Even when we have projects at the airport and we want to get an aerial kind of drone imagery, we have to get FAA approval specifically for that operation. So, they are going to be regulated. I would assume it's a different type of regulation and also because they're going to be manually operated and there's individuals that would have to be trained for that operation, but the FAA and the tower would have to be notified as part of that process. I don't necessarily know if they are, I don't believe they're the same or one of the same just because they're different types of operations. Commissioner Bellamy: You may not know the answer to this and this may not be a question for you, but you brought up something pretty important, like a banner plane flies at a very low altitude. The tower is going to know where that plane is. How are drones going to know where that plane is? Mr. Boettcher: I believe this would be part of the FAA review process. From my understanding, the reason that restricted area around the airport is so expansive is to protect operations that are going to be originating or departing from the airport. So, banner tows is obviously a concern. They are also regulated in where they need to operate or the elevations, especially along the beach. Helicopters are a little bit different. They're not quite regulated in the same way, but really, it's those departures and arrivals to and from the airport. So, I believe the FAA's intent is that the restricted area that they kind of showed or that no-fly area really should encompass the majority of the areas where there might be lower type activities occurring. And the FAA is aware of anything that happens on the beach property. Obviously, we talked about this quite a bit down in Myrtle Beach as well with MYR, but any kind of banner tows, parasailing, helicopter tours, they're all kind of regulated in how they operate there. So that would likely be a more sensitive area, but the FAA would b e aware of that and they do also control that space as well. Suzanne Pritchard, Planning and Development Assistant Director: You have a copy of this presentation in front of you. And before I start, I just also wanted to say you also have copies in front of you of emails and things that we've received over the past few days, week, about this drone issue. There's 32 different people in the emails. Most of them identify themselves as Barefoot residents, but their general concerns are repetitive noise and overflights, neighborhood quality of life, flight frequency, future expansion, uncertainty about enforceable local protections, additional concerns, crashes, battery fires, privacy, property values, wildlife, and coastal character. And their main requests are to postpone approval 16 to 90 days, obtain flight volume, route, hours, noise, and setback information, obtain a city attorney opinion. Most of them use substantially identical language saying they are not opposed to delivery itself, they just are looking for complete information. But I just wanted to make sure everyone knew that those would be part of the record of the workshop. There's some overlap of what the Amazon representative already went over. This site plan shows the existing fulfillment center. Water Tower Road is to the top of the picture. The warehouse access paved areas 9 here, they're already in place. And then we have the proposed changes. They're looking to add in this top area a battery vault. And then we have the lower paddock, 13,600 square feet. They're removing 24 parking spaces, no additional building, no changes to right -of-way access on Water Tower Road, which is the only place they have right-of-way access, no changes to impervious area. Again, these are just the physical changes for review. Those site changes do not protect the operational effects of the operation. Public works, the fire marshal, planning, and zoning have identified no issues that would preclude approval at this level. There's more construction level review that would come with the permit, but the initial level review, there's no staff issues. This aerial view shows the Amazon facility in the Palmetto Coast Industrial Park with Highway 31. You can see the closest future residential is about 1,200 feet away from the area where they would be launching drones. The existing residential use is about 2,200 feet away. In terms of these decisions here, it's the city. We can authorize changes to the approved site plan, the fencing, the equipment, parking, et cetera. The FAA provides the authorization to conduct the drone flights. City approval of this amendment doesn't authorize flight, and then denial would reject the amendment, but it would not establish citywide drone ban or protections. There may even be opportuni ties for them to come back with a different amendment for site. Configuration. As an analogy, if the same distribution center was switching to motorcycle -only delivery, the city would also be reviewing the changes to parking, the loading areas, and the other site features. In terms of the federal law that we're looking at here, the federal law places aviation safety and the efficient use of airspace within control of the FAA. The state and local rules that we have can be preempted, even if they address legitimate concerns. There's a case, 1973, City of Burbank versus Lockheed Air Terminal, and the Supreme Court invalidated Burbank's nighttime jet takeoff restrictions. This was an important case regarding the ability of communities to set flight curfews and noise limits. Jets aren't drones, so why is this relevant? There's a data sheet, a fact sheet, that was put out July 14, 2023, on state and local regulation of unmanned aircraft systems. I just want to read a few lines, word for word, because that wording matters. The FAA has the exclusive authority to regulate aviation safety and the efficient use of airspace by aircraft. Attempts by state and local governments to regulate in those fields are preempted. It goes on to say, despite important differences between manned aircraft and unmanned aircraft systems, the basic preemption framework described above is fully applicable to UAS, the unmanned aircraft systems. The fact sheet goes on to say a ban on drone operations over an entire city would very likely be preempted because it would completely prohibit drones from using or traversing the airspace above the city and impede the FAA and Congress's ability to safely and effectively integrate drones into the national airspace. In contrast, a privacy- related restriction applied to lower altitudes over facilities where people could have an expectation of privacy, such as parks or schools, would more likely be permissible because of its lesser impact. Lastly, it goes on to say it is well established that states have a valid interest in choosing where aircraft may operate on the ground, and it gives ground sighting issues as an example of the type of rule that would not likely be subject to preemption. And moving on to the state law, South Carolina passed the South Carolina Drone Regulation and Public Safety Act, which takes effect on January 1st. I believe that was passed in May of this year, or 26, yes. That act restricts unauthorized drone operations above or within 1,500 feet of military installations and correctional or detention facilities. It establishes criminal penalties and confiscation provisions for violations, delivery of contraband, unlawful surveillance of protected facilities, and weaponized or harmful drone use. That's just some of the things the law does, but in addition, it requi res compliance with applicable FAA requirements, it preserves federal authority over airspace, and it prohibits conflicting local ordinances. The law still recognizes reasonable restrictions on takeoff and landing sites and operation on or above public property. Moving to the local level, you've seen this similar diagram. These are the U.S. locations listed by Amazon where they were operating as of October 6th, showing North Myrtle Beach just for context. We've looked at a lot of the control that these local places use. There's a mix of state restrictions. Arizona, Florida, Michigan all have state limits on local drone regulation. Some use ordinary requirements, some have created drone ordinances specifically, but there's a large variety of controls. The possible city controls. We can create city standards concerning where a facility may be located, how its site is developed. We can create fencing and buffer requirements, parking, access, drainage, and screening. We can regulate the noise from cooling equipment, generators, compressors, and other ground equipment, but any limits on aircraft noise or operation hours would need separate review on those federal preemption grounds. As a community, we should be clear about which protections we can lawfully adopt and enforce through legal review. The FAA recognizes local authority to designate takeoff and landing locations, but the same guidance says local laws can be preempted if they impair reasonable use of the airspace. 10 Authority to regulate locations is not unlimited authority to eliminate the service. Moving on to what's next, we have Planning Commission, October 20th, where you can approve conditions, deny or postpone the minor amendment. There's another option. City Council can consider whether to initiate zoning standards through the required text amendment process, but these are kind of really what we have before us as options now. Commissioner Prince: The way I'm currently understanding this, if they were just to go right outside of the city limits, would the FAA approve in North Myrtle Beach? Assistant Director Pritchard: They would need Horry County approval for whatever site regulation or site changes they made, but their operations, land use controls can deal with where things land or take off from, but they can't regulate where they fly, and because the drones don't land anywhere, there's really no restrictions you can place on those kind of barriers, other than the no-fly zones that the FAA already puts in place. Commissioner Horton: Just further to his point, is this, looking at this map, if they are doing the operation leaving from the city of North Myrtle Beach, they can fly into all the Wampee area out there that's in the county, and the county can't have any input. They can fly into the areas of Myrtle Beach that adjoin us, and they can fly into all those areas without anybody saying anything. Assistant Director Pritchard: As long as they're not landing, yes. Commissioner Horton: So really and truly, there are a lot, there are more people outside of our community that will really be impacted. Assistant Director Pritchard: From that map, it appears to be so. There's some Barefoot, a little bit of Park Point, the Parkway Group residential would be available for deliveries, but most of the rest of North Myrtle Beach is a no-fly zone. Commissioner Horton: It looks like about maybe 30% of the Barefoot, and then a lot of the Parkway area out there, and then, if it's single-family residential, has 18 feet in circumference and 100 feet clear, so it's going to be very limited based off of what we've developed. Very limited inside our city limit, but you get out. You get into those neighborhoods outside of the City. This is just unfortunate. It's unfortunate that everybody doesn't get input. Assistant Director Pritchard: The county has larger lots, so there might be more in the county. Commissioner Oehler: So, if the Commission chose to deny it, when could they reapply? Assistant Director Pritchard: There is a process by which they could apply for a major amendment that would go to Council. That would be available to them immediately. Commissioner Oehler: All right. The law that's going to go into effect on January 1st, 2027, how does it adversely affect us? Nothing, from what I'm understanding. Our options are controlling the land, and that's it, correct? Assistant Director Pritchard: It just reinforces those options, yes. Commissioner Oehler: Was there any consideration, and is there any type of ordinance that we could create to either control the sound or anything like that? Assistant Director Pritchard: Yes. You could preclude certain zoning districts from having drone launch, maybe no residential areas or distances from residential areas, buffering of those things, fences. All of those things are available. The things that you would use to buffer a traditional kind of noisy or commercial operation are available for this as well. Chairman Cutuli: Dealing specifically with the minor amendment, the staff stated that it has no issue with it. My question is, is that because there are no ordinances or regulations covering drones in particular, or drone operations, drone operation land? Assistant Director Pritchard: We don't have any ordinances about that, but yes. The fences and parking are very minor changes to a site plan. They're not visible from a right-of-way, just from the land use perspective, that's where it comes from. 11 Commissioner Oehler: Just to reiterate, when they're going to look to enhance their technology, I just want to make sure that they, you guys are required to come back to say, hey, we're expanding it out to 10 miles now, we're expanding it up. The equipment's able to go 15 miles round trip. You guys would have to reapply for certain requirements with the FAA only? Not with the local authority? Tareq Wafarie: Yeah, I want to be very clear on that point. Yes, we would have to reapply with the FAA. Depending on if we make changes to our existing site plan, we would also have to make official application with you. But put all of that aside, if we make changes, let's go ahead and commit to our existing relationship with North Myrtle Beach. We want to let you know, we don't want you to be caught off guard from those things. We're doing more than just delivering by drone in North Myrtle Beach. We want to continue that relationship forward. So if we're making changes in the future, you're going to know about it. Chairman Cutuli: If there's no further questions by the Commission, I'd like to open it up to the public. The rules of engagement with the public is that we're going to limit you to three minutes. No repetitive themes or issues. We've heard a lot today. We've heard a lot previous to today. We've done a lot of research; there's a lot of papers. I got a stack of papers an inch thick dealing with this stuff. So, if you think we've already heard it, save your breath and let's move on to stuff we have not heard. Unique issues, new issues, anything that we have not thought of. This is what we're looking for. So, if you've signed up to speak, please come up to the podium, give us your name, address, and speak clearly into the microphone. We'd appreciate that. Lisa Watts, 3189 Bells Lake Circle, Longs: When I bought my property four years ago, one of the attractive things that I noticed was all the pine trees and the evergreens and the nature trail and the North Myrtle Beach sports complex. It was all beautiful. But now I'm looking, when I heard about the drones coming, I think I'm two miles away. And I was wondering, when the drone drops a package from 18 feet, does it immediately go back up to 300 feet before it goes two miles back to the launch pad? Or is it just going to stay at 18 feet because you're right on Water Tower Road? Tareq Wafarie: We drop from 13 feet, not 18 feet. And we immediately go back to at least 100 feet in the earth before we transition back to altitude between 205 and 370 feet. Lisa Watts: The last thing I have is, I was doing research about real estate assessment. Experts are already preparing frameworks for homeowners to appeal their property taxes. They argue that persistent low altitude buzzing diminishes the quality of life and fair mar ket appeal, creating a tangible case for property devaluations. So, I just wanted to remind you all that you've built over 1,000 houses within a mile. Not even, a half a mile from the Amazon. So, there's a potential they're all going to not want to pay their taxes at the current level, just to warn you about it, including me. Dana Brown, 2314 Vera Way, Longs: My first question would be on your map, the area in yellow. Is that the P DD that you guys were talking about, the Parkway Group? My house? Yes, there was a little section down there at the preserve that was outlined in yellow. Okay, so they're allowed to fly in there . How many drones can go in one neighborhood at a time? Will we have 10 in there? 1 in there? How many can go in there at a time? Tareq Wafarie: There are no limitations to number of drones in a specific geographic area. Our limitation is by number of flights per day, which is 1,000 flights per day. So, if you have a lot more people in your particular subdivision ordering by drone, you're going to see more drones than in maybe a different subdivision. Dana Brown: Okay, and since there's not many neighborhoods except mine that can really get it, I guess we get a lot. The other thing is, how many drones right now are you operating in South Carolina? Tareq Wafarie: I don't believe we have an operation in South Carolina. This would be the first. Dana Brown: Terrific. Okay, and then to piggyback off on e of Mr. Oehler's question, I didn't quite hear you. When you get your FAA approval, if you do, how often do you have to renew when you're not getting something new and different? Tareq Wafarie: We don't have to renew our FAA approval, only if there are changes. Dana Brown: 12 Okay, and when you get your FAA approval, does this mean you don't need to go back to the FAA to expand out in other areas, or you do? I mean, once you've got like your Class C, I think you called it? Tareq Wafarie: Any changes to where we are flying would require approval by the FAA. Dana Brown: Okay, and let's see. The other question is, how come you've spent so much money on this project already and started hiring and you haven't received approval? Tareq Wafarie: Timing is really important for us, and so I mentioned earlier tonight, the amount of money we've spent, I don't know the exact number of that, but there's a three -legged stool here for each project where we're trying to launch Amazon drone delivery. We hav e to get local approval. We have to get FAA approval, and we do community engagement, and until we've done all three of those things successfully, we do not begin operations. Dana Brown: Okay, I had some job announcements and everything, and I know you've been applying for these licenses. My last question would be, when were drones first discussed in North Myrtle Beach? Was that just this summer, or was it when you originally started building here? When did you first dream of having a drone program here? Tareq Wafarie: I apologize. I just don't have the answer to that because I'm filling in for my colleague. Dana Brown: Well, I'm glad Ms. Pritchard's helping you out with your marketing and getting the drone in here. Pamela Gibson, 2700 Ocean Boulevard, North Myrtle Beach: One of my questions is, you have a 7.5 area miles of fly zone here in North Myrtle Beach. Can you go to Myrtle Beach then and ask them if you could have a 7.5 area in Myrtle Beach also? Tareq Wafarie: Technically, we could. So the way our system operates is on a hub-and-spoke model. Right now, that's not the plan to have any overlap. Rather, we are targeting substantial metropolitan statistic areas and making sure that we're getting into those markets at a single location. Oftentimes, we have multiple like we do in Houston right now. But the plans right now do not show that we would be going into that community right now. But yes, technically, we could. There could be overlapping delivery service radiuses of 7.5 miles each. Pamela Gibson: Okay. Thank you for that. Also, you had stated, tell me again, how many drones that you want to have at this Amazon facility? I know you're going to initially start with 12, but it can grow to what potentially? Tareq Wafarie: We're not limited to the number of drones that we could have on site. We're limited by flights per day. So again, we're going to start with a smaller number. We're going to see what the demand is. If we're doing a few hundred flights per day and we can do that successfully with the number of drones we'll have on site, then that number would stay. If we need more to be able to meet the demand, we would bring in more. Pamela Gibson: Have you gotten any feedback or any complaints about, let's say, an area that's getting 100 drone deliveries at a time at the noise level? Have you received any complaints in regard to the noise level of multiple drones flying? Tareq Wafarie: Yes, we have. Most of those complaints have not been about the noise. It's just been about the number of flights. It's a very small percentage of the complaints that we've received today that are actually about noise, less than 5%. It's more about the overflight. In those instances, there's been that instance in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, as well as Richardson, Texas, which I'm sure you've seen in the news. In those cases, we do an investigation of our flight paths and look for opportunities where we can adjust flight paths. I also want to be very clear on that. It is a rare event where we ad just flight paths or establish additional no -flight zones based on particular feedback. It would have to be a real problem with the current flight path arrangement for us to make that adjustment, but in some cases, we have. Pamela Gibson: And I know that you said that there would be people actually operating. My time's up. Sorry. Next meeting. Thank you. Tareq Wafarie: While you're sitting down, I'll say that people are not operating the drones. These are autonomously flown. Our human in the loop flight monitors can only tell the drone to go back to station or land. John Duresky, 1720 Little Leaf Loop, North Myrtle Beach: 13 First of all, and this might be for a lot of people who might not want to come up and ask a question. Is there any way that people in the audience could submit written questions for Amazon to answer, if you couldn't ask them, for the board to answer? And also get a go od minutes of everything that all these questions that have been answered right now, because I don't know about y'all, but I'm getting kind of old, and I can't remember all this stuff. And we've been fire-hosed with a lot of information. 1,000 flights a day, 13 drones, 18-foot cylinder that goes up 100 feet, 100 feet, 205 to 375. Have I got them all yet? So, if I can't remember that, we need, as a community, to be able to have all that information for us. And y'all need that, too. Because I know y'all, same age as I am, you can remember all that. I know you can't. And the other thing I want to ask is, could HOAs restrict landing in their neighborhoods? HOAs restrict a lot of things. Could an HOA, by this, restrict landings in their neighborhood? Amazon? FAA? Anybody? And why isn't FAA here? That is a total lack of disrespect to the city of North Myrtle Beach, that FAA didn't have the cojones to get up here and answer some of these questions. Anybody? Anybody that has, anybody comment on that? Commissioner Cutuli: Good question. We don't have that information. John Duresky: Do you feel disrespected that FAA is not here today to answer questions? I do. And ya’ll should too. Okay, that's right. And we should. And this, this is a very, very complex situation. And I think so many people, maybe the City Council over there, didn't start to look into this until this last City Council meeting, maybe, where there were people saying this kind of stuff. So, anybody that said they can truly have looked at this in the past week, two weeks, they're not telling the truth. And I don't like people who don't tell the truth. I know not y'all do either. So, I think, I think that's it. Submit written questions and have them answered and published. And if we don't have HOA restricting, they would restrict that. I think that's really important, too. Chairman Cutuli: Good idea and we will seek out that question. Tareq Wafarie: I'd love to respond if I could. And unpack. There were several things to unpack there. First is on the HOA piece. We're not landing in any neighborhoods. And so, we're completely controlled by the FAA. So, if an HOA said you can't land in our subdivision, great, you could do that. But you could not say we can't fly within that HOA region because that is solely the responsibility of the federal government. Regarding a place to submit comments, I love that. And it was on my last slide on community engagement. If you go to amazon.com and click Customer Service, you can use that standard line. That will go to our primary department, who is able to track all of that feedback. We have a phone number, 1-888-280-4331, that will also connect you with customer service. And again, I'm old too. I can't remember all this information either. So, we will make sure that you have a copy of the slide deck that was presented today. I will work with the staff to make sure that that is publicly available. And we'll send that off in PDF format later today so that that can be published. So again, we don't want you to feel that you don't have your questions answered. It's the opposite. And we are going to come back and do community engagement. And so, I highly recommend showing up to that event too, where you can interact directly with the team. There'll be a survey where you can provide written feedback that would be given out at that meeting. And all of those feedback loops are important to us. So, thank you for your questions. • Additional Amazon contact information at the end of the minutes. Debbie Harkey, 318 25th Avenue North, North Myrtle Beach: Could you share with us why Amazon withdrew the drone thing from New Haven, Connecticut? What were the environmental and noise issues? Tareq Wafarie: Okay. We have not withdrawn anything from New Haven. We have not withdrawn an application. Our application is active with the town of New Haven. In fact, we've been approved by the Planning Commission as of May. We are currently looking at potentially redesigning the location of where we're going to operate our drones from that facility. And so that delay has been on our end. There is an open comment period with their Department of Environmental Protection. And so, they have received about a thousand comments to date on the activity. But we have not withdrawn anything. And we fully expect to continue forward with our application in New Haven. Debbie Harkey: Okay. Well, you need to update Google. Tareq Wafarie: We're not in charge of Google, unfortunately. I wish we were because there's a lot of misinformation out there in the media. 14 Debbie Lombardino, 309 49th Avenue North, North Myrtle Beach: I'd just like to offer food for thought for the Commission. When commercial drones were introduced into the National Airspace System, the FAA did not simply assume they were an ordinary extension of existing aviation activity. And by the employees submitting this to you as a minor PDD, they're asking you to consider drone operation as an extension of a fulfillment distribution center. And you should not allow that to happen. This should be a major amendment. Wayne Stansel, 1420 Fox Hollow Way, North Myrtle Beach: Just a simple question for clarification. Is it seven and a half nautical/air miles or seven and a half ground miles? There’s a difference. Tareq Wafarie: Seven and a half ground miles. It's six point something nautical miles. Lori White, Palmetto Shores, North Myrtle Beach: I would like to know what site-specific independent bird and wildlife impact studies Amazon has conducted for our very unique North Myrtle Beach ecosystem. Tareq Wafarie: Thank you for that question. So, we have not done an independent study of your local wildlife. We depend on the FAA to collect that information from state agencies. It's important for us to rely on those state agencies. In Arizona, as an example, it was the state agency who notified the FAA that there was a nesting bald eagle habitat that created a huge no -fly zone at the southern edge of our delivery zone. And so, we have to rely on the experts state by state to get that information to the FAA. Lori White: Because it appeared back in July you issued a no significant impact report regarding the environmental assessment. Tareq Wafarie: Correct. Lori White: Yeah. Well, that seems pretty sweeping considering the area we live in. Tareq Wafarie: We still need local approvals. That was finding of no significant impact countrywide of us doing commercial drone delivery with our current drone. It does not mean we've cleared local environmental. Diane Carter, 702 Thomas Avenue, North Myrtle Beach: I've got a couple questions for you. You made it really clear that the seven-and-a-half-mile radius could go higher. You also made it very clear that as of today, there is no condo, hotels, or commercial building deliveries. Is it already in the works to expand? Tareq Wafarie: Right now, our current expansion plan is to be able to service 500 communities or more through new operations of drone delivery. That is for residential properties only. We have no plans to deliver to commercial properties at this time. And honestly, I would know about it if there was. I wouldn't be the first to know, but eventually I would know. And I'm giving you an honest answer today. That is not part of our plan right now. Diane Carter: Right now. But January 1, it might all change. And doubling the drones and doubling the mileages. Tareq Wafarie: Sure. Five years ago, we were delivering two-day packages, had no idea that COVID would happen and change the entire way we do our business. I don't get it wrong. So, we're always innovating. Diane Carter: You know, I'm Prime Amazon all the way. I love Amazon. But at the same time, I don't want them flying all over North Myrtle Beach. God forbid if one of them fell down out of the sky and hit Highway 17 July 4th weekend. You know, what's to stop that? Also, one last thought. Once this commission okays Amazon coming in with the drones, is that can of worms open forevermore? They could never put a lid on it or control the mileages, the radius that you guys deliver to, or the number of drones flying over some of their own houses. Yeah, I thought so. Please don't open this can of worms. Please don't. Wayne Hinkel, 1300 Thomas Avenue, North Myrtle Beach: One of the questions is regarding, we've talked about short -term rentals is a big concern. There's more and more properties turned over to short -term rentals. As the short -term rental people come in, those Amazon 15 deliveries, if they're only delivering one item at a time, could be pretty regular over top of a customer's home. And if you see the flight paths that are set up currently right now, it's going to be like a highway over top of those houses. I think luckily, I'll be in one of the restricted zones, but it's for short-term rentals. When we look at the residents who live here continuously, with the amount of short -term rentals, you're going to see an increase in people ordering directly to them. And then Amazon, it's hard enough these days to determine property lines. When you're looking at your 18-foot cylinder by 100 feet, how are the property lines determined without proper survey, because we can't do that currently. Tareq Wafarie: Great question. We have to rely on the consent form of our customers to know what the property lines are. Wayne Hinkle: A consent from a neighbor to my property, I don't know how they can regulate that, because you said you'll look at the drop zone. But if you don't know the property lines or anything else, it could be very close to it or actually drop in the wrong area or on the wrong property. And you also mentioned if you had to ground them, you could do it immediately. If you're not allowed to la nd in City property or personal property, if you had to ground them right away, where would they land? It’s 12 now. Tareq Wafarie: We would find the nearest open grassy area to immediately land a drone. Wayne Hinkle: So that brings up if they are actually landing, is it on City property, personal property? Tareq Wafarie: It could be. It could be. It would be a safe contingent landing, which is authorized under the FAA. We cannot continue to fly if it would not be safe to do so. And so we could perform a safe contingent landing with the nearest grassy area that would not cause damage or personal harm. Wayne Hinkle: Which could be any body of property or the city property. I think that ought to be looked into as far as if they have to ground them. One other question, like I said, it's single packages, single items or single packages the size of a shoebox? Tareq Wafarie: Yes, so anything five pounds or less and the size of a shoebox. So, if you had two packs of batteries less than five pounds, that would be multiple items in that case Wayne Hinkle: So if you had two packs of batteries less than five pounds, that would be multiple items in that case. It's not just a single delivery item. It's whatever will fit in a box. Tareq Wafarie: Yes, single customer is a better description of it. Fred Coyne, 1600 James Island Avenue, North Myrtle Beach: This is a question from somebody in the audience; I thought it was a very good question. In the event that you do have an emergency and it sounds like it's a very rare, more of an anomaly than anything, that who would be paying for the damages if they were caused? Tareq Wafarie: Amazon would absolutely make it right every single time, just like we would today. If a delivery van backed into a mailbox, we're going to make that right immediately. Pamela Gibson: About wind, how is the wind going to affect this, like surface to altitude, wind limitations? How is that going to affect delivery? Tareq Wafarie: It's going to affect it immensely. And so, I'm actually working on a project in Syracuse right now too, which is a different weather problem we're going to have to solve for. But anything other than very light wind, we're not able to fly. And so, we have to wait for that weather pattern to calm before we can continue flights for the day. So, it's temperature based. We can go up to about 113 degrees Fahrenheit. You're not going to hit the low end of North Myrtle Beach at 13 degrees. But then light winds and light precipitation, beyond that, the whole fleet would be grounded until we're clear to fly again. Pamela Gibson: What would be your wind limitations before you even flew? I mean, what would stop you from flying as far as the wind speed? Tareq Wafarie: 16 I don't know the exact technical details, but I know a guy who does. And so hopefully we can put that information out there in the public as well. And I'll be sure to have that information and one of those teammates available when we do the community outreach piece as well. Pamela Gibson: Did you do any research about the wind? Because we do have substantial winds in this area because of the ocean, living oceanfront or being near the ocean. Did you do any reporting, any research, anything about the wind levels here? Tareq Wafarie: Absolutely. So there are a lot of checkpoints at the beginning before we waste anybody's time. Weather patterns and climate is certainly one of those initial checkpoints. Chairman Cutuli: I'd like to thank everyone for attending the workshop. I think you can see we are dealing with an immense amount of information. And we need time to digest it. You know, we're dealing not only with the larger picture is, how does it affect the city overall? So, give us time to digest all this information and see where it goes from there. 7. ADJOURNMENTAREQ WAFARIE: Chairman Cutuli adjourned the workshop at 3:25 PM. Respectfully submitted, Angela C. Westmoreland Assistant City Clerk From Tareq Wafarie, Amazon Economic Development Representative: How to provide feedback to Amazon: • www.primeair.amazon • Amazon.com/Customer Service • 1-888-280-4331 • During community engagement meetings, date/time TBD NOTE: BE ADVISED THAT THESE MINUTES REPRESENT A SUMMARY OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION WORKSHOP AND ARE NOT INTENDED TO REPRESENT A FULL TRANSCRIPT OF THE MEETING.

Source: City of North Myrtle Beach website. First collected Oct 27, 2026.