Minutes June 12, 2012
City of Marion · Marion County · meeting of Jun 12, 2012 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Marion
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
MINUTES OF MARION CITY COUNCIL
PUBLIC HEARING 6:00 P.M.
REGULAR MEETING 6:30 P.M.
TUESDAY, JUNE 12, 2012
A Public Hearing was held by City Council on June 12, 2012 in the Council chambers at City
Hall at 6:00 p.m., over which Mayor Rodney Berry resided. Council members Michael Baker, Ronald
Atkinson, Bobby L. Davis, Ralph Atkinson, Betsy Atkinson and Odessa Gregg were in attendance. Also
present were Mr. Alan Ammons, Mrs. Patricia Brown, and Attorney Robert Lee.
Mayor Berry called the Public Hearing to order and opened the floor for questions
regarding Ordinance 12-04 - AN ORDINANCE TO SET MILLAGE FOR RAISING FUNDS
AND TO ADOPT THE BUDGET FOR THE CITY OF MARION, FISCAL YEAR ENDING
JUNE 30, 2013 and ORDINANCE 12-05 - AN ORDINANCE TO APPROPIATE LOCAL
HOSPITALITY REVENUES FOR THE CITY OF MARION FOR THE 2012 -2013 FISCAL
YEARS. Hearing no questions or comments regarding these ordinances, Mayor Pro -Tem Ronald
Atkinson made a motion to close the Public Hearing, seconded by Councilman Bobby Davis; motion
carried.
At 6:30 p.m. the regular meeting was called to order by Mayor Berry, with all Council members
in attendance. Councilwoman Gregg gave the opening prayer and Mr. Ammons led the Pledge of
Allegiance. Mayor Berry welcomed all guests and the press (Hometown TV and the Star/Enterprise).
Mayor Berry welcomed Duke Intern Priyang Shah who will be helping out around City Hall, the
Marion County Healthcare Foundation and the Marion County Economic Development office. He
will be here 10 weeks.
Before minutes were approved, Councilwoman Gregg asked for and had minor change made on
page 2 of the regular minutes.
Also before approving the minutes, Mayor Berry asked to make an amendment to the Agenda
(19.) to allow Ms. Rowell to speak on behalf of Ms. Davis. Motion made by Councilman Davis to
accept Agenda change, seconded by Councilwoman Atkinson; motion carried
Councilman Michael Baker made a motion to accept the minutes from the regular meeting on
May 8, 2012 and the special meeting on May 16, 2012, seconded by Councilwoman Betsy Atkinson;
motion carried.
Miss Ashley Williams was not present to accept her Proclamation.
2
Chip Scruggs, on behalf of Revelation Ministries, made a request to present a Christmas
Production for the City of Marion to celebrate the season and would like use of CD Joyner
Auditorium on December 7, 8 , 9 (with the 9th being a Sunday Matinee’ ) and also December 14, 15, 16
(with the 16th being a Sunday Matinee’). The production will be free to the public and fundrais ers will
be held to raise money needed for the production. Mayor Berry commented that practice dates would
need to be provided to Frank Page to make sure the auditorium would be available. Auditions are
planned for September 1, and no one will be turned away. October 1 will be set construction day and
the set will be pushed behind the curtains and out of the way until needed. Mayor Berry stated that
since the City will partner with this, we would advertise in all of our venues. Councilman Davis made
a motion to let Revelation Ministries use the CD Joyner Auditorium for their program, seconded by
Mayor Pro-Tem Atkinson; motion carried.
Regarding the request for Marion County Civil Court to be held in Council Cham bers the week
of July 16, 2012; Councilman Ronald Atkinson made a motion to accept the request, seconded by
Councilwoman Atkinson. The motion carried.
Councilman Bobby Davis spoke on the numerous contributions Bethea Transport has made to
the whole of Marion County, including a tremendous number of bicycles, tricycles and many other
toys during the Christmas holidays. Councilman Davis is asking for Council to approve a Resolution
for Bethea Transport for their generosity in giving back to the community. Councilman Baker made a
motion to approve the Resolution for Bethea Transport, seconded by Councilman Ronald Atkinson;
motion carried. The Resolution will be presented at the July meeting.
Councilman Davis spoke on the many good things regarding the Miss Marion County Pageant
contestants and winners and asked that Council recognize them. He would like to recognize Miss
Marion County Jessica Coleman and Miss TEEN Marion County Tammy White with a Resolution and
would also ask that Council allow them to come and speak on their platform (Miss Coleman- Fighting
Cancer and Miss White – Empowerment) as they will be representing us around the County and
State. Councilman Davis would also like Letters of Recognition for all contestants. Councilman Baker
made a motion in accordance with Councilman Davis’s request, seconded by Councilwoman
Atkinson; motion carried. Councilman Davis would like to present these at the July meeting.
At this time, Mayor Berry recognized that Miss Ashley Williams was now present and called her
forward to accept a Proclamation in honor of her achievements and successes. On behalf of the
Mayor and City Council, the Proclamation was read by City Treasurer Patricia Brown. Upon
accepting, Miss Williams was met with much applause.
3
Councilwoman Gregg addressed some citizen concerns including the numerous flooding
problems in various areas, including the area on Bobby L. Davis Blvd that houses Ms. Renee’ Davis’ s
Daycare. When it flooded the children could not get in and out of the daycare and had there been an
accident in that home and they had to get out, some of the kids could have drowned in that water. If
Councilwoman Gregg had gotten out of the car, water would have been up to her knees . Mr. Ammons
told her this was being worked and she appreciates it. Councilwoman Gregg commented that she
attended the (Marion County Day) Job Fair and Health Fair and thought it was very well attended.
Councilwoman Gregg was introduced to Governor Haley and they shared some thoughts about
education and scarcity of jobs in Marion County. As Southern ladies usually do, they hugged and said
to each other “God Bless”. Councilwoman Gregg offered to give Mrs. Ellen Baldwin’s “school supplies
program” $200 of her $600 that each Council member is given for use in their district.
Councilwoman Gregg stated that for the last two meetings she has talked about cultural diversity and
people have genuine concern for the citizens of Marion. Councilwoman Gregg made a motion that
within the next 30 days, this City Council has some diversity training, se conded by Councilman Davis;
motion carried by 4-3 vote. Mayor Berry, Council members, Gregg, Davis and Baker voted yes;
Council members Ronald Atkinson, Ralph Atkinson and Betsy Atkinson voted no. Mayor Berry
commented that even though he cast the deciding vote to carry the motion, what we need to
understand is we all have differences of opinion and sometimes that is reflected in how we vote.
Mayor Berry further commented that he does not think anyone on Council is insensitive when it
comes to diversity.
Councilman Ralph Atkinson made a motion to give 2 nd Reading to Ordinance 12-04 -
AN ORDINANCE TO SET MILLAGE FOR RAISING FUNDS AND TO ADOPT THE
BUDGET FOR THE CITY OF MARION, FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 2013 ,
seconded by Councilwoman Atkinson. When asked if there was any discussion, Councilman Davis
mentioned, for the record, that he would vote in favor of the budget but wanted to make the
observation that “more thought should have been given into creating another position in the
Recreation Department, as that increased the budget; we are not paying the same that we would
have paid a person if we just filled a vacant position, so we are actually creating a position and I
have some concerns about that.” With no further discussion, the motion carried.
Councilman Ronald Atkinson made a motion to give 2 nd Reading to Ordinance 12-05 –
AN ORDINANCE TO APPROPRIATE LOCAL HOSPITALITY REVENUES FOR THE
CITY OF MAIRON FOR THE 2012-2013 FISCAL YEAR, seconded by Councilman Ralph
Atkinson. When asked if there was any discussion, Councilman Baker had concerns about the
$30,000 allocated that Council has no say so as to how the money is spent and wish that there was
some way it could come before Council before it is spent. Mayor Berry stated that every dime spent
is set before Council, but at times decisions have to be made quickly and if the money is being spent
4
for its designated purpose of advertising and promotions to bring people into the City of Marion,
then no vote is needed. Councilman Davis agreed with Mr. Baker’s concern and stated that we do
not and have not known every time that money ($30,000 in Advertising and Promotions) was used
and what it was used for. Mayor Berry responded that the money cannot be used in any way; it has
to be used to draw tourism inside the city limits of Marion and has to be by way of Hospitality
guidelines. The guidelines are very specific and before we spend that money, we ordinarily get an
opinion from the Ethics Commission to make sure the money is being spent properly. Councilman
Baker is concerned that Council and the public are being informed of events, etc. at the same time
via marquees and billboards around town and feels that the Council should be made aware prior as
to be able to address questions the residents may have about events. Councilman Davis
commented that to prove Council doesn’t know what the money is spent for, they had no clue that
$4,500 was used for a Francis Marion film production. This Council did not approve it and had
absolutely no knowledge of it. We didn’t know about the money pulled out to be used for Thursday
Night Live until it was actually taking place and Mrs. Patricia knows that and everyone sitting on
this Council knows we never approved a film production and we have never approved any money
for Thursday Night Live. Councilman Davis further commented that it’s not a false statement, we
do not know where that money is being spent most of the time, until it’s spent, and we look at the
invoices. Mayor Berry responded that Thursday Night Live was paid for by sponsorships and the
City didn’t spend any money on that. The General Francis Marion film was bought by sponsorships.
None of that money, zero, the minutes and the budget will reflect that, no money was spent by the
City of Marion. Councilman Davis asked Mrs. Brown to tell them truthfully , when he came and
pulled the records from her, if she could account for every dime being spent by someone else’s
donation or did she tell him (Mr. Davis) that this was the balance the City spent. Mrs. Brown
responded that the City did spend a very small amount. Mayor Berry responded that he stood
corrected, the City spent $100 and worries about someone that wouldn’t support the arts in Marion.
Councilman Davis responded to Mayor Berry stating, “It’s not that we’re not supporting, it’s that
you need to tell the people the truth.” Mayor Berry stated, “That’s simply the truth.” With no
further discussion, the motion carried by a 6-1 vote, with Councilman Baker voting no.
Regarding the Audit Proposals, Mr. Ammons commented that Council had received copies
of two bids, one from Holt & Holt in Florence and one from Kenneth Cobb & Company in Mullins.
Councilman Davis made a motion to accept the low bid from Holt & Holt, seconded by Councilman
Baker; motion failed by a 3-4 vote with Councilman Davis, Councilman Baker and Councilwoman
Gregg voting yes and Mayor Rodney Berry, Councilman Ronald Atkinson, Councilman Ralph
Atkinson and Councilwoman Betsy Atkinson voting no. Councilman Ralph Atkinson commented
that when reviewing the bids, that it appears on the surface that Holt & Holt might have the low bid,
but when you factor in other things such as cost per hour for partner hours spent, that once the final
5
audit is done, then Kenneth Cobb might be the lower cost. Councilman Atkinson further
commented that Kenneth Cobb is located in Marion County, employs local people and are familiar
with the City as they have been doing the audit for over 15 years. Therefore Councilman Ralph
Atkinson makes a motion to accept Kenneth Cobb & Company’s bid, seconded by Mayor Pro -Tem
Atkinson. Councilman Baker asked for clarification on Councilman Atkinson’s comments regarding
the cost of partner hours and stated that staff hours should also be included. City Treasur er Patricia
Brown responded that Kenneth Cobb allowed for 29 more hours. Councilman Davis stated that if
Holt & Holt went over their hours, their staff charges would be $20 to $40/hour whereas Cobb &
Company is going to charge $70/hour. Councilman Davis further stated that we should be
completely open with the public and tell them what we’re talking about and “compare apples to
apples and oranges to oranges”, because we’re not doing that when we say “in the end it may be
less”. Councilman Baker inquired as to where Mr. Ammons had talked to MASC about their
recommendation, to which Mr. Ammons stated that he had not, but there was a copy of the article
by Eric Budz of MASC in their packets. Councilman Baker commented that it was their (MASC)
recommendation that we change auditors every few years. Councilman Davis also commented that
in the Institute of Government that USC and Clemson teach, they teach that auditors should be
changed every so often as to have a fresh set of eyes look at the City’s budget an d monies that are
being spent. Councilman Baker commented that everything we bring in from MASC is MASC’s
recommendation. With no further discussion, motion carried by a 4-3 vote with Mayor Berry,
Councilman Ronald Atkinson, Councilman Ralph Atkinson, Councilwoman Betsy Atkinson voting
yes and Councilman Bobby Davis, Councilman Michael Baker and Councilwoman Odessa Gregg
voting no.
Regarding bids for the bush hog side cutter, Mr. Ammons stated that we received only 2
bids; Sparrow-Kennedy submitted a proposal of $9,966 , Mullins Truck and Tractor $10,399 and
Altman Tractor no bid. Councilman Ronald Atkinson made a motion to accept the bid by Sparrow-
Kennedy for $9,966, seconded by Councilman Ralph Atkinson; motion carried.
ADMINISTRATOR’S REPORT
Mr. Ammons gave an update on the Capital Sales Tax Projects, stating that we came out
with a little over $2.3 million for projects in the City of Marion. It has been sent to County Council
who has already given 1st Reading, with 2nd Reading being held this morning. They will have a 3rd
Reading and then it will be ready for the ballot.
We are back on track with Fox Watch, with a meeting scheduled for Tuesday, June 26 at
5:30 p.m. at MPD to reorganize and have the committee members meet with our Police Dep artment
in order to formulate a better working relationship.
6
The Voucher Committee met and approved the applications that citizens will use to apply
for assistance. We had several applications from USDA to use as guidelines to formulate our
application. The e Voucher Committee will meet again on June 26 at 6:00 p.m. in the Conference
Room at City Hall. The Chairman of the committee will be elected at that time.
Mr. Ammons asked to skip the CDBG – Storm water at this time and will come back to it.
Attorney Lee commented that upon reviewing the Redistricting Plan, (the Benchmark Plan
is the current District map) it was discovered that the Proposed Plan 1 had drawn Councilman Davis
out of his District 4 and into District 5, even though correct addresses had been provided to the
State. We would like for Council make a motion to send this back and have it redrawn to put
everyone in their proper districts. Once the new plan comes back, the Mayor will call for a
workshop to have you look it over and make any changes. After a brief discussion on the how the
population numbers for the districts was determined, Councilman Baker made a motion to send the
map back with a comment that whenever this is received back, please send it to the Council
members because this was received on May 15 and we are just getting it tonight, even if you have to
make notes of any errors on the map. Mr. Ammons commented that she (Ms. Jones) had already
contacted them about the problem and was trying to get a new map before the C ouncil meeting.
Councilman Baker stated that was fine, but at least let them know as they had been waiting for 8
months. Councilman Davis seconded the motion; motion carried.
Mr. Ammons stated that he had worked with Mr. Davis and Mrs. Gregg over the p ast few
weeks on the storm water problems. We have been working to clean out the ditches and other
areas. For some time now, we have requested help from other agencies that this belongs to, but we
are doing it ourselves and it has already made a tremendous difference. The Mayor has been able to
obtain C-fund money to do the culvert across Bobby L Davis to the outflow ditch that goes to
Catfish. That project is currently being advertised and we will have the bids for your approval at the
next meeting. That project will take about 2 weeks. Mr. Ammons stated that he appreciates Mrs.
Odessa keeping him informed so he will know what the trouble spots are. As of today, there is 200
feet of pipe being laid on Phillips Street and should be completed in 3 or 4 days. The area from
North Main to Withlacoochee Park with the 48” pipe where we have had trouble for some time, is
also on bid and we should have all figures available for next month. Councilman Davis asked about
another section of Phillips Street and Mr. Ammons stated that everything on that end of the street
was working, but the problem is further down and that is where we’re working now. In answering
Councilman Davis’s question regarding the ditch behind the house on Bobby L. Davis Blvd, Mr.
Ammons stated that the City was right now in the process of cleaning it out. Councilman Davis also
inquired about the raw sewage on North Hampton and Lipscomb Street. Councilman Ronald
7
Atkinson commented that there was a problem on Northside in front of Dennis Mickey’s house. Mr.
Ammons responded that the problem on Northside was a sewer infiltration problem, not a storm
drain problem. Councilman Davis stated that as City leaders, regardless as to whose problem it is ,
we should be addressing these problems as they are health hazards. Mr. Ammons explained that we
have several areas that have had those problems for years when we did water and sewer ourselves.
It is the infiltration of ground water that goes into the sewer pipes and comes out in the least poin t
of resistance which are the manholes. Mayor Pro-Tem Atkinson commented that in the past we
have brought the big blue truck to try and pump some of that out and clean up. Mr. Ammons
commented that Grand Strand went the next day and cleaned everything u p. Councilman Ralph
Atkinson inquired as to whether or not we should make more use of the blue truck to which Mr.
Ammons responded that the blue truck was being used every day with 2 employees. Councilwoman
Gregg commented that if we don’t address it and do something about it, it will be extremely
embarrassing if it’s reported to DHEC and we have not talked about it and gotten it corrected. Mr.
Ammons commented that we do have some infra-structure problems and sludge problems and we
have to get some type of maintenance program. We also have an on-going problem with litter
which contributes to the drains being filled with cans, bottles, and a various assortment of trash,
with which we need to get the public’s help. Mr. Ammons stated that we need to identify problem
areas and apply for some CDBG money. We received approval for a storm water master plan which
we can narrow down to a storm water study and take the areas that Council has identified. The
study will be approximately $10,000 - $15,000 and once the study is complete we can apply for
CDBG monies for the areas that qualify. Councilman Davis inquired as to what was being done
about Pine Street. Mr. Ammons responded that DOT had come in and replaced pipes at the north
end and at the south end and that Pine Street will be one of the streets that will be replaced the
entire distance because of the trees growing into the pipes. Mayor Berry encouraged Council to
identify their locations and get them to Mr. Ammons quickly.
Lt. Thomas Graves of the Marion Police Department was named May Employee of the
Month and was given a gift certificate.
CITY ATTORNEY’S LEGAL UPDATE
Attorney Lee asked to add one item to the Executive Session regarding the County and at
this time has no update for Open Session.
DEPARTMENTAL REPORTS
Mayor Berry stated that the Departmental Reports were in the Council’s packets. Also, due
to a request at last month’s meeting regarding the crime report, there is a copy displayed for those
who are interested.
8
ACCOUNTABILITY OF CITY OFFICIALS/COMMENTS FROM CITY COUNCIL AND
MAYOR
Councilman Baker had no comment at this time.
Mayor Pro-Tem Atkinson had no comment at this time.
Councilman Davis offered congratulations to Miss Ashley Williams on her
accomplishments. Councilman Davis commented that he enjoyed having the opportunity to assist
Governor Haley’s Health Fair and Job Fair and thought it was very good for our county.
Councilman Davis’s only negative was that our grass (along 76) wasn’t cut in time for our potential
employers to see how beautiful Marion really is.
Councilman Atkinson had no comment at this time.
Councilwoman Atkinson had no comment at this time.
Councilwoman Gregg had no comment at this time.
Mayor Berry announced that the City of Marion had once again b een named as Tree City.
He also announced that David Bennett, former head coach at Coastal Carolina, would be putting on
a free 3-day football clinic, sponsored by Anderson Brothers Bank. It is for kids ages 8 -14 and as of
now we have 100 kids signed up, from Marion and Marion County, as well as surrounding areas.
Coaches from all high schools in the county will also be helping out. Mayor Berry offered his thanks
to City Clerk Pam Jones for being the “go to” person for the Governor’s Marion County Day. The
Governor’s Original 6 Foundation sent a list of persons they wished to invite to the round table
discussion held 3 months ago. The Governor attended the meeting at the Opera House and heard
our concerns for Marion County. Marion County Day was a big success with approximately 600 in
attendance, including the Governor who was very pleased with the event. Councilwoman Gregg did
not know the Governor was here (in March) and wanted to know why Council wasn’t made aware of
the meeting. Mayor Berry responded that the Governor’s Foundation sent a list of who was to be
invited, which did not include any Council members. Councilwoman Gregg and Councilman Davis
expressed their displeasure at not being informed that the Governor would be in Marion to which
Mayor Berry explained that this was at the request of the Governor’s office that no one be informed,
mainly due to security reasons. When asked by Councilman Davis how “those people just out of the
streets in Marion who attended that particular meeting were invited and we’re elected people
representing the citizens of Marion and we knew nothing about it”. Mayor Berry responded that the
list was designed by the Governor and it was leaders throughout the community. They do things a
little outside the box and were looking for new information from a very diverse group.
PUBLIC COMMENTS
Due to an earlier amendment to the agenda, Annie Mae Rowell spoke on behalf of Renee’
Davis, owner of Tender Loving Care on Bobby L. Davis Blvd. Ms. Rowell addressed the issue of the
flooding and drainage problems at that location and also along other areas of Bobby L. Davis Blvd.
9
There is a problem with trash, including liquor bottles, beer cans, pine straw and other debris being
washed from the field and into the grates and ditch and Ms. Rowell has paid people to come out and
clean out the ditch behind her house. It is not safe for children to have to wade through this nasty
water to get to their houses. Mayor Berry commented that he thinks it is probably the worst part i n
the City and we will have to give it constant attention. Mayor Berry thanked Ms. Rowell for her
comments.
EXECUTIVE SESSION
Councilwoman Betsy Atkinson made a motion to enter Executive Session to discuss
Contractual Matters regarding a Potential Lease Agreement, URS-Landfill, and Contractual Matter
with the County, seconded by Councilman Ronald Atkinson; motion carried.
Upon returning from Executive Session, Mayor Berry stated that no action had been taken.
Councilwoman Atkinson made a motion to return to Open Session, seconded by Councilman Ralph
Atkinson; motion carried.
Due to the generosity of Dr. William Cheezem’s generous donation of property to the City of
Marion, Mayor Berry asked that Mr. Ammons have a plaque in Dr. Cheezems’s honor placed in the
building. Councilman Baker made a motion to approve the lease agreement with the stipulation
that Mr. Ammons does a background check and if that is found favorable, we move forward. The
motion was seconded by Councilwoman Atkinson, motion carried.
Regarding the Proposal from URS for JF Contractors to close the landfill for $11,684,
Councilman Ronald Atkinson made a motion to approve their invoice and therefore the landfill will
be closed, seconded by Councilwoman Atkinson. Councilman Baker requ ested adding an
addendum to the motion to state “in the amount of $11, 684” because the original amount was
$48,000. Motion carried. Councilwoman Atkinson made a motion to allow Patricia to pay this
from Capital Projects, seconded by Councilman Atkinson; motion carried.
ADJOURNMENT
Having no further business, Councilwoman Betsy Atkinson made a motion to adjourn,
seconded by Councilman Ronald Atkinson; motion carried.
____________________________ _____________________________
Mayor Rodney Berry City Clerk Pam Jones
Taped: June 12, 2012
Source: City of Marion website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.