RecordWell Data

Public Works Committee November 2024 agenda

City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Nov 1, 2024 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Mauldin

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE MEETING MONDAY, NOVEMBER 4, 2024 | 6 PM 6th Committee Meeting The Committee will meet in Mauldin City Hall at 5 East Butler Road in the Council Chambers at 6 p.m. The meeting will be available remotely through Zoom. Please visit the City’s website at https://cityofmauldin.org/your-government/meeting-minutes-agendas/ to access the meeting via audio and videoconferencing. A quorum of Council will be present. 1 PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE MEETING NOVEMBER 4, 2024 6PM CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS 5 E. BUTLER ROAD C ommittee Members: Jason Kraeling (Chair), Michael Reynolds and Carol King 1. Call to Order 2. Public Comment 3. Reading and Approval of Minutes a. Public Works Committee- October 7, 2024 [Pages 3-4] 4. Reports or Communications from City Officers a. PW Director Matthew Fleahman Debris Pickup 5. Unfinished Business None 6. New Business a.Ordinance 1048- Sale of Property on East Butler Roa d [Pages 5-111] 7. Public Comment 8. Committee Concerns 9. Adjournment Chairperson Kraeling C hairperson Kraeling C hairperson Kraeling C hairperson Kraeling C hairperson Kraeling C hairperson Kraeling C hairperson Kraeling C hairperson Kraeling C hairperson Kraeling 2 PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE MEETING OCTOBER 7, 2024, 6PM CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS 5 E. BUTLER ROAD 2nd commitee mee�ng Commitee Members present: Jason Kraeling (Chair), Michael Reynolds and Carol King Others present: PW Director Mathew Fleahman and City Administrator Seth Duncan 1. Call to Order- Chairman Kraeling 2. Public Comment- None 3. Reading and Approval of Minutes a. Public Works Commitee- September 3, 2024 Mo�on: Councilwoman King made a mo�on to approve the minutes with Councilman Reynolds seconding. Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0). 4. Reports or Communica�ons from City Officers a. PW Director Mathew Fleahman Mr. Fleahman reported on the clean-up efforts a�er Hurricane Helene. 360 tons of brush and debris has been picked up by the department. Mr. Fleahman thanked the police and fire departments for their help with the storm clean-up. Chairman Kraeling thanked Mr. Fleahman. Everyone came together to help each other during this crisis. Councilwoman King echoed the comment and said the leadership from top to botom in the City was outstanding. Councilman Reynolds said he was proud of the City and employees for helping each other. Leadership was also helping employees outside of the workplace. He was happy to see the grace people have. Chairman Kraeling men�oned that businesses helped people as well. Ace Hardware was open to help people any way they could. Other businesses did the same. Mr. Fleahman agreed and said the Ace Hardware on Woodruff Road opened specifically to allow him to get supplies for the City. 5. Unfinished Business- None 3 6. New Business a. Ordinance 1046 - Sewer Ordinance Revisions The City Atorney has looked at this dra�. The language has been altered. The City will assume liability for the opera�on and maintenance of sewer laterals only a�er the replacement/repair is paid for by the property owner. No work will be done on private property. Mo�on: Councilman Reynolds made a mo�on to send this ordinance to Council with Councilwoman King seconding. Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0). 7. Public Comment- None 8. Commitee Concerns Chairman Kraeling said he has a picture of a 300-pound log being held up by one of the new City trash cans. They are sturdy. 9. Adjournment- Chairman Kraeling adjourned the mee�ng at 6:21 p.m. Respec�ully Submited, Cindy Miller Municipal Clerk 4 MAULDIN CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: November 4, 2024 AGENDA ITEM: 6a TO: Mauldin City Council FROM: Seth Duncan, City Administrator SUBJECT: Sale of Property E. Butler (Tract 1) DISCUSSION The Public Works Committee is being asked to make a positive recommendation to Council to approve the sale of certain property along E. Butler Road to SCDOT for the purpose of road improvements as part of the Butler Road Improvement Project AND to authorize additional temporary construction easement for the project. HISTORY/BACKGROUND In October, the City received the appraisal findings from ORC Real Estate Solutions for Infrastructure for the sale of land along E. Butler Road (Tract 1). The property is being purchased by SCDOT as part of the Butler Road Improvement Project which will see the improvement of E. Butler Road from Bridges Road to HWY 276. Improvements will include stormwater changes, inclusion of a 10- foot multi -use path , intersection changes, and other improvements. Additionally, SCDOT is requesting temporary Right -of- Way (ROW) on the parcel and is willing to compensate the City for its use. ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS The City owns a number of parcels along the project corridor and due to the nature of this project SCDOT is increasing its right-of-way throughout the project area. The parcel related to these appraisals at the corner of E. Butler Road and HWY 276 (Maverick Station). As described below, SCDOT is seeking to acquire a segment of City property for the project. The new right -of-way will have a significant impact on the property by reducing the number of parking spots at Maverick Station. As such, SCDOT’s offer is for fee simple title to land, temporary Right-of-Way and Cost to Cure activities . Cost to Cure activities include those previously described for Tracts 3- 8, but also the relocation of lost parking spaces at Maverick Station. In addition, the water vault for Maverick Station will have to be relocated as well as the sign. All of these improvements are inclu ded in the cost to cure. Each of the acquisitions are described below and illustrated in the referenced attached Exhibits. The City will utilize the funding provided to build additional parking spaces for public use and use of Maverick Station. Tract 1 – Maverick Station Compensation $ 26,856.00 fee simple title to 0.10 acre (4,476 SF) $ 34,693.00 Temporary ROW to 0.006 acre (264 SF) 5 $128,201.00 Cost to Cure $189,750.00 Total Staff have found the appraisal fair and cost to cure acceptable. FISCAL IMPACT The City will receive $189,750 for the sale of property to SCDOT and to provide temporary Right-of-Way. Staff suggest dedicating those funds to Cost to Cure activities as described in the appraisal. RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends City Council approve the sale of these properties to SCDOT as stated in the offers. ATTACHMENTS • Offer Letter Appraisal • Ordinance Butler Road ROW (Tract 1) • Title to Real Estate • Exhibit Tract 1 • Temporary ROW • Exhibit Tact 1 Temporary Right-of-Way (ROW) • Appraisal Tracts 1-8 (2 was combined with 1) 6 10/11/2024 Town Of Mauldin Attn: Seth Duncan Post Office Box 249 Mauldin, SC 29662 RE: P roject ID No. P030553 - Road S-107 (East Butler Road) - Greenville County - Tract 1 Dear M r. Duncan: Refer ence is made to the above captioned project, under which the South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) proposes to acquire a portion of your property for this improvement as has been discussed with you previously. The Department must pay just compensation for the property which is based on an appraisal made by a qualified real estate appraiser using comparable sales in the area. The apprais al, a copy of which is attached hereto, has been prepared, reviewed and approved, and I am now authorized to make you the following offer: $ 26,856 .00 for fee simple title to 0.10 acre (4,476 SF) of land and all improvements thereon, if any, in fee simple. $ 34,693 .00 Temporary Right of Way 0.006 acre (264 SF) $128,201.00 C ost to Cure $189,750 .00 Total Pleas e give this offer your prompt attention and let me know your decision as soon as possible. Retain this information to report your payment according to IRS rules in Publication 544. If I can be of any further assistance, do not hesitate to contact me. Sinc erely, Jennif er Jones Campbell O. R. Colan Associates, LLC Right of Way Agent ____10/11/24__________ Date Offer Made 7 MAULDIN ORDINANCE _______________-2024 AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE CONVEYANCE OF ANY AND ALL INTEREST IN CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY IN THE CITY OF MAULDIN AND GRANTING A TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT WHERE AS, the City of Mauldin (“City”) owns certain road right -of-way property lying and situate within the city limits of Mauldin, County of Greenville along East Butler Road identified as Tract 1 on the SCDOT Project ID P030553 and, WHEREAS, the South Carolina Department of Transportation (“the SCDOT”) desires for the City to convey its interest in the area of acquisition from Tract 1 to the SCDOT as part of the SCDOT’s Butler Road Improvements Project ( See www.buildingabetterbutler.com); and, WHEREAS, the SCDOT also desires for the City to convey a temporary Right-Of-Way (“ROW”) from Tract 1 identified as “Tract 1 Temp. R/W” to the SCDOT as part of the planned improvements; and WHEREAS, pursuant to S.C. Code § 5-7-40, a municipality may convey or dispose of property it owns by Ordinance; and, WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Council find that it is in the best interest of the City of Mauldin to convey the area of acquisition from Tract 1 as shown on Exhibit “B” to the SCDOT by quit-claim deed attached hereto as Exhibit “A” for the consideration stated in said deed and by Temporary Right Of Way Easement an area shown on Exhibit “ D” for the consideration stated in said easement on Exhibit “C”. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED, by the Mayor and Council of the City of Mauldi n, that the Mayor of the City is hereby authorized, empowered, and directed to execute, acknowledge and deliver the quit-claim deed attached hereto as Exhibit “A” and right-of-way easement attached hereto as Exhibit “C.” 8 This Ordinance shall be effective upon second reading approval thereof and no further authorization is required to execute and deliver all documents related to the conveyance contemplated by this Ordinance. Terry W. Merritt, Mayor ATTEST: Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk Intr oduced by: __________________________________ Firs t Reading: __________________________________ Second Reading: ________________________________ Approv ed as to form: _____________________________ Daniel R. Hughes 9 THE STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA TITLE TO REAL ESTATE COUNTY OF GREENVILLE Approximate Survey Stations 101+00 To 104+00 Lt S-107 East Butler Road To KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS , That I (or we) City of Mauldin, South Carolina - Post Office Box 249, Mauldin, South Carolina 29662 in consideration of the sum of One Hundred Fifty Five Thousand Fifty Seven and No/100 Dollars ($155,057.00) and other valuable consideration to me (or us) in hand paid at and before the sealing and delivering thereof, by the South Carolina Department of Transportation, Columbia, South Carolina, receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, have granted, bargained, so ld and released, and by these presents do grant, bargain, sell and release, unto the said South Carolina Department of Transportation, its successors and assigns, all that certain real property of the Grantor in fee simple absolute for Roadway Improvements on S-107 (East Butler Road) from US Route 276 (Laurens Road) to S-941 (Bridges Road), State and County aforesaid, as shown on plans prepared by Infrastructure Consulting & Engineering for the South Carolina Department of Transportation and dated April 6, 2023. SPECIAL PROVISIONS: The above consideration is for all that certain parcel of land containing 0.10 acres (4,476 square feet), more or less, damages and all improvements thereon, if any, owned by City of Mauldin, South Carolina, shown as the “Area of Acquisition” on Exhibit A, attached hereto and made a part hereof. Property herein conveyed is along a relocated centerline as shown on plans between approximate survey stations 99+99.61 and 111+08.83 Reloc.This being a portion of the property conveyed to City of Mauldin by the Deed of East Butler Investments, LLC, Hans Bolli, and June A. Bolli, dated and recorded June 9, 2021, in Deed Book 2626, at Page 2413; This being the same property conveyed to East Butler Investments, LLC, Han s Bolli and June A. Bolli, by Deed of Alex Kiriakides, III, Trustee, of Trust FBO Alex Kiriakides, III under Trust B of the Revocable Trust Agreement dated February 2, 2001, and MaryAnn Kiriakides, Trustee, of Trust FBO Mary Ann Kiriakides, under Trust B of the Revocable Trust Agreement dated February 2, 2001, and Michael William Kiriakides, Trustee, of Trust FBO Michael William Kiriakides under Trust B of the Revocable Trust Agreement dated February 2, 2001, and Cathy Cannon, Trustee, of Trust FBO Cathy Ca nnon under Trust B of the Revocable Trust Agreement dated February 2, 2001; dated and recorded May 13, 2021 in Book 2623 at Page 5877; This being the same property conveyed to Alex Kiriakides, III, Trustee, of Trust FBO Alex Kiriakides, III under Trust B of the Revocable Trust Agreement dated February 2, 2001, and MaryAnn Kiriakides, Trustee, of Trust FBO Mary Ann Kiriakides, under Trust B of the Revocable Trust Agreement dated February 2, 2001, and Michael William Kiriakides, Trustee, of Trust FBO Michael William Kiriakides under Trust B of the Revocable Trust Agreement dated February 2, 2001, and Cathy Cannon, Trustee, of Trust FBO Cathy Cannon under Trust B of the Revocable Trust Agreement dated February 2, 2001; by Quit Claim Deed of Alex Kiriakides, III, Trustee, Mary Ann Kiriakides, Trustee, Michael William Kiriakides, Trustee of Trust B under the Revocable Trust Agreement dated February 2, 2001 established by Alex S. Kiriakides, Jr., as Grantor; dated December 12, 2016 and recorded December 14, 2016 in Book 2502 at Page 2405. LESS AND EXCEPT: Quit Claim Deed recorded June 10, 2021 , in Book 2626 at Page 2674. in the Office of the Clerk of Court for Greenville County, South Carolina , and shown as Tax Map No. M003.01-02-014.00. Tie Equality STA. 351+75.76 US 276 (Laurens Road) = STA. 101+01.79 S-107 (East Butler Road). Road/Route Road S-107 (East Butler Road) Project ID No. P030553 Tract 001 Ordinance ____-2024 Exhibit A 10 Together with, all and singular, the rights, members, hereditaments and appurtenances thereunto belonging, or in any wise incident or appertaining. And I (or we) do hereby bind myself (or ourselves), and my (or our) successors, to warrant and forever defend all and singular said premises unto said South Carolina Department of Transportation, its successors and assigns, against myself (or ourselves) and our succ essors in interest and anyone claiming under us and against every person whomsoever lawfully claiming or to claim the same, or any part thereof. TO HAVE AND TO HOLD in fee simple, absolute and singular the said property and the rights hereinbefore granted, unto the said South Carolina Department of Transportation, its successors and assigns forever. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I (or we) have hereunto set my (or our) hand(s) and seal(s) this _______ day of _________________, in the year of our Lord, Two Thousand and . Signed, sealed and delivered in the presence of: City of Mauldin, South Carolina 1st Witness Grantor (L.S.) By Its: 2nd Witness Grantor (L.S.) NOTE: All right of way agreements must be in writing and are subject to rejection by the South Carolina Department of Transportation. THE STATE OF ) ) ACKNOWLEDGEMENT COUNTY OF ) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this ______ day of ___________________, 20________ by _______________________________ of City of Mauldin, South Carolina. Signature of Notary Public Printed Name of Notary Public NOTARY PUBLIC FOR THE STATE OF My Commission Expires: (Affix seal if outside SC) 11 N STA. 99+99.61 AND STA. 111+08.83 RELOCATE S-107 CENTERLINE BETWEEN NOTE: 01 Page 3 of 3 pages EXHIBIT "A" S-1 0 7 (B U T L E R R O A D ) STA . 1 0 1 + 5 0 .2 7 B EG IN C O N STR U C TIO N (0.10 AC.) TO TA L O B TA IN = 4,4 7 6 S F TRACT 1 01/09/2024 STA. 1 0 1 +0 1.7 9 S-1 0 7 (EAST BUT L E R ROA D ) STA. 3 5 1 +7 5.7 6 US 2 7 6 (LA U RENS ROA D ) TIE EQUA LITY 8 0 .3 2 ° S -1 0 7 (EA S T B U T L E R R O A D ) 1 0 3+2 6.4 9 PT = U.S. ROU T E 2 7 6 (LAU RENS ROAD ) 15 SCALE 0 FEET 30 PREPARED SCALE 0 FEET 30COUNTY DRAWING 809-105-00. STANDARD SCDOT WITH COMPLIANCE IN DEEDS OF REGISTER THE TO SUBMITTED BE SHALL PLAT WAY OF RIGHT RECORDABLE A CONSTRUCTION, OF COMPLETION UPON ADDITIONALLY, 29201. SC COLUMBIA, STREET, PARK 955 HEADQUARTERS; SCDOT FROM OBTAINED BE CAN WHICH OF COPY A PLANS, ENGINEERING TO REFERENCE DIRECT IN IS AND ACQUISITION" OF "AREA THE OF REPRESENTATION GRAPHIC A IS EXHIBIT THIS 15 GREENVILLE SOUTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION AREA OF ACQUISITION FROM TRACT PROJECT ID P030553 N EW 5 5 ' R /W N EW 5 0 ' R /W N EW 5 0 ' R /W 5 3 'C 3 5 'F 6 2 'C 3 1 'C 5 3 'C 3 1 'C 3 2 'C 4 5 'C 3 2 'F + 3 7 .2 3 9 0 .36 5 5 .0 0 + 8 0 .0 0 5 5 .0 0 + 2 6 .0 7 5 0 .0 0 + 2 7 .7 7 TRA N S. R/W N EW 3 2 'F 5 0 'C N EW 5 5 ' R /W 7 9 .2 8 + 4 9 .6 6 9 1 .31 + 5 7 .4 4 8 5 .4 4 + 6 4 .4 4 7 3 .3 0 + 5 6 .7 2 5 5 .0 0 + 5 5 .0 0 6 5 .0 0 + 5 5 .00 5 5 .0 0 + 4 0 .0 0 M EN T EASE- C O N ST. N EW T E M P. M EN T EA SE- C O N ST. N EW T E M P. 6 5 .0 0 + 5 0 .0 0 1 3 4 11 12 1 9 8 1 ( ICE) FIL E NO . 2 3.8 3 2 ON 3 3.5' R PRESENT R/W FIL E N O . 2 3 .832 1 9 81 ( IC E) PR ESEN T 3 7 .5' R /W FIL E N O . 2 3 .8 3 2 1 9 8 1 ( IC E) PR ESEN T 3 7 .5' R /W FILE N O . 23.83 2 198 1 ( IC E) PR ESEN T TR A N SITIO N R /W FIL E NO . 2 3.832 198 1 ( ICE) PRESENT 55' R/W FILE N O . 23.83 2 19 8 1 ( IC E) PR ESEN T 3 7 .5' R /W FIL E N O . 2 3 .8 3 2 1 9 8 1 ( IC E) PR ESEN T 3 8 .5' R /W FIL E NO . 2 3.8 3 2 1 9 8 1 ( ICE) PRESENT 5 5' R/W 5 6 .3 0 + 4 4 .3 5 4 3 .8 1 + 5 5 .4 33 6 .3 2 + 8 2 .9 6 8 4 .5 6 + 8 5 .0 9 3 9 .7 5 + 2 1 .8 4 3 9 .6 9 + 9 9 .0 4 3 8 .6 9 + 9 9 .0 3 3 6 .39 + 4 4 .0 8 3 6 .3 9 + 2 8 .6 2 8 0 .3 2 ° + 3 7 .2 3 9 0 .36 5 5 .0 0 + 8 0 .0 0 5 5 .0 0 + 2 6 .0 7 5 0 .0 0 + 2 7 .7 7 Ordinance ____-2024 Exhibit B 12 THE STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA TEMPORARY RIGHT OF WAY EASEMENT COUNTY OF GREENVILLE Approximate Survey Stations 101+00 To 102+00 Lt S-107 East Butler Road 102+00 To 103+00 Lt S-107 East Butler Road To KNO W ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS , That I (or we) City of Mauldin, South Carolina - Post Office Box 249, Mauldin, South Carolina 29662 in consideration of the sum of Thirty Four Thousand Six Hundred Ninety Three and No/100 Dollars ($34,693.00) , to me (or us) in hand paid, and other valuable consideration at and before the sealing and delivering thereof, by the South Carolina Department of Transportation, receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, have granted, bargained, sold and released, and by these presents do grant, give, bargain, sell and release, unto the said South Carolina Department of Transportation, its successors and assigns, an easement or right of way for the construction, improvement, operation and maintenance of a public road known as a State Highway for Roadway Improvements on S-107 (East Butler Road) from US Route 276 (Laurens Road) to S -941 (Bridges Road), State and County aforesaid, as shown on plans prepared by the South Carolina Department of Transportation, upon and across the land which I (or we) may own, in whole or in part, between the survey stations referenced above and as depicted and described on the above reference plans together with, all and singular, the rights, members, hereditaments, and appurtenances thereunto belonging, or in any way incident or appertaining. The grantor expressly recognize s the possibility that the property herein may be used in the future by public utility or others granted the statutory right to use the right of way. SPECIAL PROVISIONS: All that parcel or strip of land, to establish a temporary right of way, containing 264 square feet more or less, and all improvements, thereon, if any, owned by City of Mauldin, South Carolina , shown as the "Area of Temporary Right of Way" on Exhibit A, attached hereto and made a part hereof. Property herein conveyed is along a relocated centerline as shown on plans between approximate survey stations 99+99.61 and 111+08.83 Reloc. S-107. Temporary right of way herein condemned shall revert to the condemnee upon completion and acceptance of the project. Tax Map No. M003.01-02-014.00. Tie Equality STA. 351+75.76 US 276 (Laurens Road) = STA. 101+01.79 S-107 (East Butler Road). Road/Route Road S-107 (East Butler Road) Project ID No. P030553 Tract 001 Ordinance ____-2024 Exhibit C 13 TO HAVE AND TO HOLD, all and singular, the said easement or right of way and the rights hereinabove granted, unto the said South Carolina Department of Transportation, its successors and assigns forever for a public road, highway, other public transportation purposes or other public uses as are permitted within and in conjunction with highway rights of way and the grantors hereby dedicated their respective interest in said strip of land to public use for such purposes. It is agreed that buildings, fences, signs or other obstructions will not be erected by me (or us), my (or our) heirs, assigns or administrators within the limits of the right of way herein conveyed. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I (or we) have hereunto set my (or our) hand(s) and seal(s) this day of , in the year of our Lord, Two Thousand and . Signed, sealed and delivered in the presence of: City of Mauldin, South Carolina 1st Witness Grantor (L.S.) By: Its 2nd Witness Grantor (L.S.) NOTE: All right of way agreements must be in writing and are subject to rejection by the South Carolina Department of Transportation. THE STATE OF ) ) ACKNOWLEDGEMENT COUNTY OF ) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this ______ day of ___________________, 20________ by _______________________________ of City of Mauldin, South Carolina. Signature of Notary Public Printed Name of Notary Public NOTARY PUBLIC FOR THE STATE OF My Commission Expires: (Affix seal if outside SC) 14 EXHIBIT "A" THIS EXHIBIT IS A GRAPHIC REPRESENTATION OF THE "AREA OF ACQUISITION" ANO IS IN DIRECT REFERENCE TO ENGINEERING PLANS, A COPY OF WHICH CAN BE OBTAINED FROM SCOOT HEADQUARTERS; 955 PARK STREET, COLUMBIA, SC 29201. ADDITIONALLY, UPON COMPLETION OF CONSTRUCTION, A RECORDABLE RIGHT OF WAY PLAT SHALL BE SUBMITTED TO THE REGISTER OF DEEDS IN COMPLIANCE WITH SCOOT STANDARD DRAWING 809-105-00. ESENT 37.5' 23.83 --= TRACT 1 TEMP. RW OBTAIN - 264 SF TEM 0 PRESENT 37 5, FILE NO. 23.832 1 NEW 0 NEW 50' ...;f;iW 36.39 35•r � RESENT 38.5' RW rlLE NO 23.832 1981 (ICE) / + 1 a;t � 39.75 1 ;,::�--- 3 ;�=�------332�'f=F 3 3Z2''FF _______ _ 11:; -- �� - 39 69 4 � ...._, �/��SENT 37.5' R-W --._ NO. 23.832 1981 (ICE) BEGIN CONSTRUCTIONSTA. 101+50 27S-107 (BUTLER ROAD) NOTE: RELOCATE S-107 CENTERLINE BETWEEN STA. 99 + 99.61 AND STA. 111+ 08.83 � , '<- 1:;·<oo· ��(}' <l 0 � I 001,S­� ® □ SOUTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION •• AREA OF TEMPORARY RIGHT OF WAY FROM TRACT 01 PROJECT ID P030553 e INC PREPARED 01/09/2024 15 0 SCALE�- 30 FEET COUNTY GREENVILLE (/) Q) gi C") 0 C") Q) gi Ordinance ____-2024 Exhibit D 15 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 1 of 96 Right of Way Section APPRAISAL REPORT Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 (1) Tract Location: Tr 1 – 100 E Butler Rd, Tr 3 – Vacant Land E Butler Rd, Tr 4 – 5 E Butler Rd, Tr. 5 – 5 E Butler Rd, Tr 6 – 9 E Butler Rd, Tr. 7 – 9 E Butler Rd, Tr 8 – Vacant Land, E Butler Road, all in Mauldin, SC 29663 Property Owner: Tr 1, 6, 7, 8 – City of Mauldin, Tr 3, 4 – Town of Mauldin, Tr 5 – Town of Mauldin a/k/a City of Mauldin, c/o Seth Duncan, City Administrator Address: PO Box 249, Mauldin, SC 29662 Areial View of Subject Property PREPARED FOR: South Carolina Department of Transportation (2) Prior to inspection the owner was contacted by letter and invited to be present during inspection of this property. The tract was inspected on 8/12/2023, October 3, 2023 and August 19, 2024. I was accompanied by Mr. Seth Duncan. Required by Sec. 24.102 (c) of Uniform Act. Mr. Duncan explained that the fire station will be decommissioned once a new building then under construction is completed, and he pointed out that memorial stones for K-9’s will be relocated. Mr. Duncan also expressed concern about loss of parking on Tract 1, which contains parking spaces and site improvements that support Maverick Station, a multi-tenant retail building. We had several subsequent conversations and Mr. Duncan provided documents. 16 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 2 of 96 Right of Way Section PREPARED BY: (3) Appraiser’s Name: Deborah L. Tripp, MAI, SRA 9CT11 S. C. Certified General Real Estate Appraiser 1132 Firm Name: Property Solutions, LLC APPRAISAL SUMMARY (4) Property Owner: Tr 1, 6, 7, 8 – City of Mauldin, Tr 3, 4 – Town of Mauldin, Tr 5 – Town of Mauldin a/k/a City of Mauldin Tract Location: Tr 1 – 100 E Butler Rd, Tr 3 – Vacant Land E Butler Rd, Tr 4 & 5 – 5 E Butler Rd, Tr 6 – 9 E Butler Rd, Tr. 7 – 9 E Butler Rd, Tr 8 – Vacant Land, E Butler Road, all in Mauldin, SC 29663 Date of Appraisal: 8/30/2024 Date of Value: 8/19/2024 (5) DESCRIPTION BEFORE AFTER Present Use: Retail and Government use Retail and Government use Number of Buildings: 4 4 Primary Improvement Size: (Stated in units of comparison) N/A N/A Building Setback (Feet) More than 35’ More than 35’ # of Feet Building is Above (+), at (0), or Below (-) Road Grade: 0’ 0’ # Parking Spaces: N/A N/A Corner Influence: Corner- Signal Corner- Signal Primary Frontage (Linear Feet): 630’+/- 630’ +/- Total Frontage(s) (Linear Feet): 872’+/- 872’ +/- Ingress/Egress: Primary Road Secondary Road(s) Full Access Full Access Full Access Full Access Zoning Conformity: Legal Conforming Legal Conforming (6) Site Size (SF): 240,713 231,076 Site Size (Ac.): 5.526 5.305 Present or Intended Use of Site: Retail & Gov’t Use Same Shape: Irregular Irregular Size of Acquisition: 0.221 Ac; 9,637 Sq. Ft. plus 264 SF TCE (7) HIGHEST AND BEST USE As Vacant: Commercial Development Commercial Development As Improved: Continue existing use Continue existing use (8) Annual Market Rent per SF: $N/A $N/A 17 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 3 of 96 Right of Way Section (9) VALUE INDICATIONS BEFORE AFTER Land Value $1,444,278 $1,386,456 Improvements $0 $0 Cost to Cure: $0 ($207,793) Temporary Right of Way $34,693 $0 Final Value Indications: $1,478,971 $1,178,663 (10) Value of Acquisition: $300,308 18 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 4 of 96 Right of Way Section APPRAISAL DETAILS AND REQUIREMENTS (11) PROPERTY RIGHTS APPRAISED: Fee Simple (12) PURPOSE OF THE APPRAISAL: To estimate the difference in the market value of this property caused by the acquisition of the right of way for the proposed construction of this project. (13) (13a) INTENDED USE: INTENDED USER: To assist the South Carolina Department of Transportation in negotiations with the property owner concerning an eminent domain acquisition. Market value is defined as “The most probable price, as of a specified date, in cash, or in terms equivalent to cash, or in other precisely revealed terms, for which the specified property rights should sell after reasonable exposure in a competitive market under all conditions requisite to a fair sale, with the buyer and seller each acting prudently, knowledgeably, and for self-interest, and assuming that neither is under undue duress. SOURCE: The Appraisal Institute, The Dictionary of Real Estate Appraisal, 4th Edition The South Carolina Department of Transportation, its Rights-of-Way Department, its Right-of-Way Consultants, its Legal Department and Associate Legal Counsel. (14) EXPOSURE TIME: 12 to 24 months (15) FIVE-YEAR SALE HISTORY: Date Sale Price Deed Reference Tract 1: 8/3/2017 $1,400,000 2518/2209 Tract 8: 11/11/2022 $525,000 2673/4183 All other tracts are 1975 or prior conveyances $ $ Comments: Tract 1 is now improved with Maverick Station – a quit claim deed was executed after the sale conveying a portion of this property. Tract 8 was conveyed at a market price in 2022. All other tracts were conveyed in 1975 or prior to 1975 and are not relevant to this analysis. (16) CURRENT LISTING: PENDING CONTRACT: N/A None (17) ASSESSMENT AND TAXES: Tax Parcel ID #: Tr. 1 – M003010201400, Tr. 3 - M003010201300, Tr. 4 - M003010201200, Tr. 5 - M003010201100, Tr. 6 - M003010201000, Tr. 7 - M003010200902, Tr. 8 - M003010200900 19 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 5 of 96 Right of Way Section Tax Year: 2023 Land Value: Improvement Value: Tax Appraised Market Value: $1,538,080 Total Real Estate Taxes: Tract 1 - $270 Tract 3: $162, Tract 4: $81, Tract 5: $135, Tract 6: $702, Tract 7: $162, Tract 8: $5,131.95. (18) CURRENT ZONING ANALYSIS: District: CRD – Central Redevelopment District Current Conformity: Conforming MININUM REQUIREMENTS: Front Setback: N/A Rear Setback: N/A Side Setback: N/A Building Height: N/A # Parking Spaces: Varies by Use Road Frontage: None noted Maximum Building Size: None noted 20 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 6 of 96 Right of Way Section SUBJECT LOCATION MAP 21 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 7 of 96 Right of Way Section SUBJECT TAX MAP Tax Map Number: Multiple 22 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 8 of 96 Right of Way Section SUBJECT ZONING MAP CRD 23 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 9 of 96 Right of Way Section FEMA FLOOD MAP Flood Panel: 45045C0416E Date: 8/18/2014 24 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 10 of 96 Right of Way Section SUBJECT PHOTOGRAPHS (1 - 3) Address/Location: N/S E. Butler Road Photos Taken By: Deborah Tripp Date of Photos: 8/12/2023 1) Acquisition looking east 2) Acquisition looking east 3) Acquisition looking west 25 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 11 of 96 Right of Way Section SUBJECT PHOTOGRAPHS (4 - 5) Address/Location: N/S E. Butler Road Photos Taken By: Deborah Tripp Date of Photos: 8/12/2023 4) Acquisition area 5) Acquisition area 26 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 12 of 96 Right of Way Section SUBJECT PHOTOGRAPHS (6 - 7) Address/Location: N/S E Butler Rd Photos Taken By: Deborah Tripp Date of Photos: 8/12/2023 6) Tract 1 Maverick Station 7) Tract 3 27 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 13 of 96 Right of Way Section SUBJECT PLAT / SKETCH 28 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 14 of 96 Right of Way Section SCDOT PLAN SHEET NOTE: Sketch above does not show the exclusion of the land area for Maverick Station that is not part of Tract 1. 29 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 15 of 96 Right of Way Section PARAGRAPH 19. SCOPE OF WORK: The scope of work is a written set of expectations that form an agreement or understanding of the appraisal assignment between the appraiser and SCDOT as to the specific requirements of the appraisal. The scope of work generally encompasses the following: (except where deviating from the norm is agreed upon with SCDOT (the client) and/or the appraiser; or in the case of instruction from the client as to the desired type of value requested or extent of the written report). The amount and type of information researched and the analysis applied in an assignment as required by the Uniform Act and SCDOT Appraisal Manual. Scope of work includes, but is not limited to, the following: The degree to which the property is inspected or identified; The extent of research into physical or economic factors that could affect the property; The extent of data research; and the type and extent of analysis applied to arrive at opinions or conclusions. Specific Scope of Work: The goal of the appraisal process is to conclude a credible appraisal based on the intended use and users, property characteristics, and type of value sought. This begins with general data collection, then narrows to the collection of neighborhood data followed by collection of data and analysis with regard to the site, and any improvements. The highest and best use of the property being appraised is then analyzed. Market data is collected in order to proceed with an appraisal analysis which forms a credible appraisal and reconciliation into a final value opinion using the appropriate approach(es) to value. The analysis is condensed to the preparation of an appraisal report. The project, known as the Butler Road Improvements Project, encompasses 1.7 miles from US 276 (N. Main Street) to Corn Road/Bridges Road, about one mile south of the I- 385 interchange. The purpose of the project is to provide additional capacity to address existing and future traffic congestion and to provide for improved bicycle access to the adjacent high school. It includes improvements to a bicycle-pedestrian/multiuse path on one side of the road, construction of curb and gutter and a sidewalk on the opposite side. Existing culverts with two bridges over Gilder Creek will be replaced, and intersection improvements will be added and modified on Old Mill Road and Bethel Drive, and intersection improvements at Murray Drive/Fairfield Drive. Project Influence: The appraiser has disregarded any decrease or increase in the market value of the real property caused by the project for which the property is to be acquired, or by the likelihood that the property would be acquired for the project, other than that due to physical deterioration within the reasonable control of the owner. 49 CFR 24.103 (b). 30 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 16 of 96 Right of Way Section A. Inspection of the subject This phase of the appraisal involves a physical inspection of the subject property, as specified by the SCDOT Appraisal Manual and Uniform Act. The subject was last inspected on 8/19/2024. B. Extent of research This involves the collection of data on national, state, regional and local trends, and an identification and analysis of the social, economic, environmental and governmental forces affecting the market value of the subject property. SCDOT provided plans and ownership information. The appraiser has relied on plans dated June 6, 2024. C. Extent of data research Data research involves the inspection of the subject property, the neighborhood and collecting and analyzing data from the market area that affects the value of the subject property. I have performed research of the sales comparables similar to the subject and confirmation of those sales comparables in the past five years. An extensive search of similar properties in Greenville County was undertaken. I also talked with real estate agents and appraisers familiar with area. D. Type and extent of analysis applied to arrive at opinion or conclusion This phase of the appraisal process involves analyzing all of the previously gathered data and determining the Highest and Best uses of the subject properties within the framework of the supply and demand, legal uses of the subject properties, and possible physical uses of the subject properties as if vacant, or as improved. The South Carolina Department of Transportation requires that the Sales Comparison Approach be demonstrated for all improved properties unless unusual circumstances preclude its development or the improvements are determined to be unaffected by the acquisition. The Cost Approach shall be considered when the impacted improvements are less than ten years old, a special-use property, or when sufficient comparable sale or lease information is not available. The SCDOT requires application of the Income Approach on all investment and income-producing properties where existing improvements might be impacted by the project. The conclusions have been reported in a SCDOT Standard format in accordance with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP), Uniform Act and SCDOT Appraisal Manual. The SCDOT Right of Way plans identify the subject (before size) as Tracts 1,3,4,5,6,7 & 8 containing 5.526 acres or 240,713 square feet of land. Adequate data was available to complete the analysis. The before value is subject to the extraordinary assumption that the new right of way does not exist and will not exist. The after value is subject to a hypothetical condition recognizing the value of the subject as if new right of way already existed. 31 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 17 of 96 Right of Way Section PARAGRAPH 20-A. DESCRIPTION OF REALTY (BEFORE) SITE DESCRIPTION Present Use Conforming governmental uses Site Size 5.526 acres or 240,713 square feet. It is recommended that a qualified surveyor inspect the subject for existing property lines and easements that are unable to be detected by the appraiser(s). Curb and Gutters Multiple curb cuts Sidewalk None # of Lanes Butler - Two, with center turn lane; U.S. 276 / N. Main Street – Four Traffic Level Good – 15,900 vehicles per day on E. Butler Road Good – 38,000 vehicles per day on N. Main Street Traffic Control Intersection, signalized for Tract 1 Shape Irregular Ingress/Egress The site is currently accessed by multiple curb cuts to Butler Road and one curb cut to N. Main Street. Access to the Improvements Butler Road and N. Main Street Frontage 630’ linear feet along E. Butler Road 210’ linear feet along N. Main Street 32’ at intersection Grade at Road Level At Grade Visibility/Exposure Good visibility and exposure Topography Generally level Drainage Adequate Flood Plain: Map Number 45045C0418E Date 8/18/2014 Zone X Landscaping Average Utilities Water Public Sewer Public Electricity Yes Natural Gas Yes Telephone Yes 32 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 18 of 96 Right of Way Section Zoning Designation CRD Uses Allowed Hotel, health care, library, public administration, public safety, social assistance, communication, dry cleaning, financial services, health and personal care services, offices, professional services, pet services, restaurant, retail sales, grocery, fitness, event center, stores, theaters, public parks Easements/ Encroachments Based upon my inspection and examination of the subject site, as well as my review of plats and deeds of the property, I did not detect adverse easements other than normal utility easements and rights of way. See Legal Constraints below. These are not believed to have a detrimental impact on property value. No adverse conditions were observed. It should be noted that I am not qualified to detect easements and encroachments, and legal counsel should be retained if there are any indications of title defects. Legal Constraints A Title Opinion shows the following Exceptions to Title. Note that these apply to Tract 1 only, which has parking and other site improvements that support the Maverick Station retail strip center, which is not included in this appraisal. The City of Mauldin is responsible for maintenance of the site improvements on Tract 1 that benefit the retail center. The Access and Parking Agreement referenced in the Title Opinion permits the owner of Maverick Station “full use of the City’s Parcel for ingress, egress, pedestrian traffic and a parking lot”. We conclude that the City must therefore provide adequate parking for the benefit of Maverick Station. It is apparent that patrons and/or employees of Maverick Station use the parking spaces immediately east and northeast of Tract that are located on the City’s Tract 3. 33 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 19 of 96 Right of Way Section Environmental I am not aware of potential environmental hazards on the property. None observed. Environmental aspects of the subject property are beyond my expertise. If necessary, I recommend a professional in environmental expertise be retained. Comments None Personal Property, FF&E, etc. (Included in the estimate of value) N/A Relocation Items (Not included in the estimate of value) N/A 34 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 20 of 96 Right of Way Section PARAGRAPH 20-B. DESCRIPTION OF REALTY (BEFORE): IMPROVEMENT DESCRIPTION The building improvements include the City of Mauldin City Hall, City of Mauldin Police and Fire Station. The improvements are not impacted by the acquisition and are not appraised. PARAGRAPH 21. HIGHEST AND BEST USE (BEFORE): Highest and Best Use is defined in The Appraisal of Real Estate – 13 th Edition as, “The reasonably probable and legal use of vacant land or an improved property, that is physically possible, legally permissible, appropriately supported, financially feasible, and that results in the highest value.” AS VACANT: Physically Possible: Before the acquisition, the subject site is 5.526 acres at the corner of Butler Road and N. Main Street. Traffic counts provide excellent exposure and the site has all utilities. A commercial improvement of about 48,000 square feet represents the ideal building size using a land to building ratio of five to one. Legally Permissible: The subject site is zoned Commercial Redevelopment, permitting hotel, restaurant, retail, grocery, event centers and other uses. If the site were vacant, it could be developed with many of the uses permitted by zoning including retail, hotel, or restaurant use. Financially Feasible: Surrounding uses include both office, institutional, service and retail uses. Population and income levels are strong. Any use that is capable of generating a positive return is feasible. Given the above, the most financially feasible use for the site is retail use Maximally Productive: The most maximally productive use of the site if vacant is for retail development. Therefore, based on the preceding discussion my opinion of the highest and best use of the property, as vacant and available for development, is for retail utilization. 35 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 21 of 96 Right of Way Section AS IMPROVED: Physically Possible: The site is currently improved with multiple governmental buildings which serve the community, The improvements are in good condition. The properties have a combined effective age of about 20 years and are located in the heart of Mauldin – an excellent location for the existing use. Legally Permissible: The current improvements are legally conforming uses. Financially Feasible: The improvements are in good condition and contribute positively to the value of the site. Maximally Productive: The most maximally productive use is to continue the existing use. Therefore, based on the preceding discussion my opinion of the highest and best use of the subject property, as improved, is for governmental and retail utilization. 36 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 22 of 96 Right of Way Section PARAGRAPH 22. VALUATION BEFORE THE ACQUISITION: LAND VALUATION (BEFORE): Land value is derived separately using the sales comparison approach and a minimum of three comparable sales. The South Carolina Department of Transportation requires that the Sales Comparison Approach be demonstrated for all improved properties unless unusual circumstances preclude its development or the improvements are determined to be unaffected by the acquisition. The Cost Approach shall be considered when the impacted improvements are less than ten years old, a special-use property, or when sufficient comparable sale or lease information is not available. The SCDOT requires application of the Income Approach on all investment and income-producing properties where existing improvements might be impacted by the project. The existing improvements are not impacted by the project so only the site valuation is applicable. 37 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 23 of 96 Right of Way Section Subject Sale 8 Sale 9 Sale 11 Sale 12 Land Type Governmental Commercial Commercial Commercial Commercial Name Maverick Yds. Maverick Yds. Oasis Animal Hosp. Medical Planned Street Address N/S E Butler Mauldin Jenkins Ct. at Jenkins St. Mauldin Jenkins Ct. Mauldin 900 W Butler, Mauldin 216-218 E Butler Sale Date 4/5/2023 4/5/2023 4/5/2023 2/1/2021 Size in Acres 5,526 2.625 2.76 2.02 10.793 Size in Square Feet 240,713 114,345 120,226 87,991 470,143 Sale Price $575,000 $575,000 $540,000 $1,300,000 Price per Acre $219,048 $208,333 $267,327 $120,448 Price per Square Foot $5.03 $4.78 $6.14 $2.77 Zoning CRD CRD CRD PD C-2 Topography Level Level Level Level Sloping Traffic Counts in VPD 14400 / 38,000 N/A - Internal siteN/A - Internal site 24,500 15,900 Planned Use Mixed Use Mixed Use Medical Medical Corner No N/A N/A No No Flood Zone No No No No Yes 17% Adjustments: Property Rights 0% 0% 0% 0% Adjusted Price $5.03 $4.78 $6.14 $2.77 Financing 0% 0% 0% 0% Adjusted Price $5.03 $4.78 $6.14 $2.77 Conditions of Sale 0% 0% 0% 0% Adjusted Price $5.03 $4.78 $6.14 $2.77 Market Conditions 8% 0% 0% 0% 28% Adjusted Price per Sq. Ft. $5.03 $4.78 $6.14 $3.55 Location/Exposure/Access 10% 10% 0% 0% Size/Utility -5% -5% -5% 10% Topography/Shape 0% 0% 0% 0% Zoning 0% 0% 0% 5% Utilities 0% 0% 0% 0% Corner 0% 0% 0% 0% Flood Zone 0% 0% 0% 35% Net Adjustment 5% 5% -5% 50% Indicated Value/Sq. Ft. $5.28 $5.02 $5.83 $5.33 38 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 24 of 96 Right of Way Section EXPLANATION OF ADJUSTMENTS: A market conditions/time adjustment is applied to all sales and is based on paired sales analysis, as discussed in the Sales Brochure. Adjustment for corner site is based on paired sales. Additionally, Sales 8 and 9 are also adjusted for Location/Exposure/Access as they are inferior interior sites, which is based on paired sales discussed in the Sales Brochure. Size adjustments are subjective in nature, based on the premise that larger quantities of goods sell for less per unit than smaller quantities. All sales are adjusted for not being located on corner sites, when compared to the subject’s corner location. Sale 12 is adjusted for having a portion of the site being in a flood hazard area. No other adjustments are warranted. The subject’s land value has been developed using the Sales Comparison Approach to value. Four comparable sales have been identified and analyzed on the adjustment grid(s) on the previous page. LAND VALUATION (BEFORE) CONCLUSION: Land sales used exhibit a range from $5.26 to $6.14 per square foot, with an average of $5.81 per square foot. A value of $6.00 per square foot for the land is concluded, giving greater weight to Sale11 as it has the least net adjustment. The indicated market value of the subject before the acquisition is therefore shown as follows: 240,713 X $6.00 per unit = $1,444,278 Site Improvements Acquired X = $ Rounded to: $1,444,278 39 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 25 of 96 Right of Way Section PARAGRAPH 22-A. SALES COMPARISON APPROACH TO VALUE (BEFORE) The following steps are applied in deriving a value via the Sales Comparison Approach: 1) Com parable data in the subject market and/or competing market(s) are researched. 2) Dat a is verified as accurate and representative of an arms-length transaction. 3) The proper unit(s) of comparison is determined. 4) Diffe rences between the subject and the comparables are identified and evaluated. 5) Adju stments are applied to the comparables for the relevant elements of comparison. 6) The resulting value indications are reconciled into a single value. As the improvements are primarily government related, this approach is omitted. PARAGRAPH 22-B. COST APPROACH TO VALUE (BEFORE): The following steps are applied in deriving a value via the Cost Approach: 1) Est imate the land value as though vacant. 2) Estimate the direct and indirect costs of the improvements new as of the date of appraisal. 3) Est imate an appropriate entrepreneurial profit. 4) Est imate the total accrued depreciation from physical deterioration, functional obsolescence, and external obsolescence. 5) Subtract total depreciation from the total cost new of the improvements. 6) Est imate the contributory value of any remaining site improvements 7) Add la nd value to the depreciated cost of the improvements. 8) Adju st the indicated value for any personal property or any intangible asset value that may be included in the cost estimate. As the improvements are primarily government related, this approach is omitted. 40 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 26 of 96 Right of Way Section PARAGRAPH 22-C INCOME CAPITALIZATION APPROACH TO VALUE (BEFORE) Under the Income Approach, value is created by the anticipation of future benefits to the owner in the form of cash flows and reversion. Anticipated benefits are converted to value using either direct capitalization or yield capitalization. Direct capitalization is normally used to appraise properties with stabilized income and expense patterns, while yield capitalization is used to value more complex properties and those with unstable income and expense patterns. This approach considers the property from the investor’s point of view. As the improvements are primarily government related, this approach is omitted. PARAGRAPH 23. RESOLUTION OF BEFORE VALUE AND VALUE ESTIMATE: Sales Comparison Approach – The Sales Comparison Approach for site valuation uses three recently closed sales to compare to the subject as vacant commercial land, according to its highest and best use. Adjustments are market driven, and this is the only applicable approach to value. Cost Approach – This approach is omitted. Income Approach – This approach is omitted. Reconciliation The Sales comparison Approach via Site Valuation is the only applicable approach to value. Therefore, based on the information contained in this report, the market value of the subject property as of the date of this report is estimated to be $1,444,278. PARAGRAPH 24. DESCRIPTION OF THE ACQUISITION: The acquisition includes 9,637 square feet or about 0.221 acre along both E Butler Road. The new right-of-way along Butler Road will be 40’, 45’ and 50’ wide compared to existing right-of-way ranging from 25’ in width to 37.5’ in width, with a triangular shaped transition right of way at the intersection of E Butler Road and Main St. PARAGRAPH 25. DESCRIPTION OF THE REMAINDER: The remainder contains 231,076 square feet or about 5.305 acres. Two separate Impact Assessment Reports were completed by International Forensic and Consulting Group, and both are shown in the Addenda. One report addresses Tracts 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8, while one addresses Tract 1 due to the separate uses of the properties. As for Tracts 3-8, pedestrian access is not impacted, but vehicular access impacts one of the four access driveways to E Butler Rd. The western driveway will be modified to right-in/right/out access only. A decorative circular landscaped island at the sidewalk to the front of the City of Mauldin City 41 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 27 of 96 Right of Way Section Hall is impacted by the new right-of-way. The circular island will be reconstructed and new landscaping installed outside the new right-of-way. A light pole will be impacted to allow for the reconstruction and adequate space remains for its relocation. A “No Thru Traffic” sign will be relocated, and a brick retaining wall will be demolished and reconstructed. Impacts to the irrigation system, a landscaped flagpole area, a Blue Star Memorial Highway monument sign, the canine police memorial must be reconstructed, and a City of Mauldin Police sign will be relocated within the required setback area. A stop sign will be relocated. The estimated cost to cure the impacts, to tracs 3 through 8 is $79,592 according to the report. The Impact Assessment Report for Tract 1 was also completed by International Forensic and Consulting Group as shown in the Addenda. On-site pedestrian and vehicular access is not impacted, and circulation is also not impacted. There are 11 parking spaces impacted by the new right-of-way and one space is temporarily impacted for the construction of a new drainage structure. A viable option is determined to recover 3 parallel parking spaces and a landscape area, but 8 spaces cannot be recovered on Tract 1. A monitoring well on site must be raised, and a lighted monument sign for Maverick Station will be reconstructed in a conforming manner. A water meter vault will be demolished and reconstructed and two light poles will be relocated. Landscaping and irrigation impacts will be impacted and will be reconstructed. The estimated cost to cure the impacts to Tract 1 is $128,201 according to the report. 42 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 28 of 96 Right of Way Section PARAGRAPH 26. HIGHEST AND BEST USE (AFTER): AS VACANT: Therefore, based on the preceding discussion, my opinion of the highest and best use of the subject property, as vacant and available for development, after the proposed road construction is the same as before the acquisition. AS IMPROVED: Therefore, based on the preceding discussion, my opinion of the highest and best use of the subject property, as improved, after the proposed road construction is for the existing use. PARAGRAPH 27. VALUE AFTER THE ACQUISITION: “After” values and conclusions are based upon plans provided by the SCDOT and the completion of the proposed road construction. Consideration has been given to relevant aspects of the property affected by the acquisition for analysis and comparison to the subject’s “before” condition and the comparable data. LAND VALUATION (AFTER): EXPLANATION OF ADJUSTMENTS: The site after the acquisition has the same value as before the acquisition at $6.00 per square foot. LAND VALUATION (AFTER) CONCLUSION: The subject’s land value after the acquisition has been developed using the Sales Comparison Approach to value. Four comparable sales have been identified and analyzed. Adjustments are the same as Before the Acquisition. The site after the acquisition has the same value as before the acquisition at $6.00 per square foot. The indicated market value of the subject site is shown as follows: 231,076 sq. ft. X $6.00 per unit = $ 1,386,456 X $ per unit = $ 0.00 Rounded to: $1,386,456 43 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 29 of 96 Right of Way Section PARAGRAPH 27-A. SALES COMPARISON APPROACH TO VALUE (AFTER): EXPLANATION OF ADJUSTMENTS: Adjustments are the same as before the acquisition. SALES COMPARISON APPROACH (AFTER) CONCLUSION: This approach is omitted. PARAGRAPH 27-B. COST APPROACH TO VALUE (AFTER): This approach is omitted. PARAGRAPH 27-C. INCOME CAPITALIZATION APPROACH TO VALUE (AFTER) This approach is omitted. PARAGRAPH 28. RESOLUTION OF AFTER VALUE AND VALUE ESTIMATE: Sales Comparison Approach – The Sales Comparison Approach for site valuation is the only applicable approach to value after the acquisition due to the highest and best use of the site. Therefore, based on the information contained in this report, the market value of the subject property after the acquisition is estimated to be $1,386,456. The difference in land value before and after the acquisition is therefore calculated as follows: COST TO CURE Raulston Travis, PE, Senior Forensic Consultant, provided an Impact Assessment Report dated October 16, 2023 and March 14, 2024, as shown in the Addenda. Please refer to the consultant’s report attached for detailed information. Reported impacts have previously been discussed. The estimated cost to cure the impacts to the subject property is $79,592 + $128,201 for a total of according to the report, for a total of $207,793. Before $6.00 240,713 Sq. Ft. $1,444,278 After $6.00 231,076 Sq. Ft. $1,386,456 Difference 9,637 Sq. Ft. $57,822 44 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 30 of 96 Right of Way Section PARAGRAPH 29. UNECONOMIC REMAINDER: UNECONOMIC REMNANT – A parcel of real property in which the owner is left with an interest after the partial acquisition of the owner’s property, and which the acquiring agency has determined has little or no value or utility to the owner. NOTE: An uneconomic remnant may have substantial “market” value and still have little or no value or utility to the owner. (Appraisal Guide; Federal Highway Administration). There is no uneconomic remainder. Temporary Construction Easement: A property’s loss in market value in the case of a temporary easement is the value of the encumbered property for the period it is to be held by the Condemnor. The most common measure is the “rental” value of the property due to the owner’s loss of its use and occupancy during possession by the Condemnor. After construction of the public improvement is completed, the construction easement is extinguished and the unencumbered fee interest in the land reverts back to the owner. The value of the land in fee simple equates to $6.00 per square foot. If held in fee simple, the value of the TCE land would be $57,822 Calculating a return on investment of 10% for 1 year equates to $5,782 annually. The length of the TCE encumbrance is 6 years, therefore the value of the temporary easement area is $34,693. Calculations follow. Land - Fee Fee Value/Sq. Ft.Fee Value $6.00 Value of Site Improvements Acquired Fee Value of Temporary Easement 9637 $6.00 $57,822 Fee Value of TCE $57,822 Return on Investment 10% Subtotal 1 Year Return on Investment $5,782 # Years Easement Encumbrance 6 Value of Temporary Easement Area Acquired $34,693 CALCULATIONS OF VALUE OF TEMPORARY EASEMENT AREA 45 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 31 of 96 Right of Way Section DISTRIBUTION OF VALUES (30) Value Components: Before (Paragraph 22) After (Paragraph 27) Difference Land Value: $1,444,278 $1,386,456 ($57,822) Improvements: $0 $0 $ 0 Cost to Cure $0 $(207,793) ($207,793) Temporary Right of Way $34,693 $0 ($34,693) TOTAL: $1,478,971 $1,178,663 $300,308 (31) Value Components of the Acquisition: Right of Way Acquired: Land: 9,637 sf @: $6.00 $ 57,822 Cost to Cure $207,793 Value of Site Improvements within the Acquisition Area: $0 Temporary Right-of-Way $34,693 Total for the Acquisition: $300,308 plus Damages (if any to the remainder) $0 less Benefits (if any to the remainder) $0 Total for the Acquisition (Right of Way, plus damages, less benefits): $300,308 (32) Final Statement of Value: a) Having considered all applicable approaches, it is my opinion that the indicated value of the whole property before the acquisition is : $1,478,971 b) Having considered all applicable approaches, it is my opinion that the indicated value of the whole property after the acquisition is: $1,178,663 c) The difference between the indicated value of the property before the acquisition, and the indicated value of the remainder, after the acquisition is: $300,308 (33) Based on this report, the fair market rental for this property is: $ n/a per month. The appraisal is made as of: Date of Appraisal: 8/19/2024 Date of Report: 8/30/2024 S. C. Certified General Real Estate Appraiser CG 1132 46 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 32 of 96 Right of Way Section GENERAL ASSUMPTIONS AND LIMITING CONDITIONS General Assumptions - This appraisal has been completed and the appraisal report prepared with the following general assumptions: 1. No responsibility is assumed for the legal description or for matters including legal or title considerations. The titles to the property are assumed to be good and marketable unless otherwise stated. Any plats, maps, or photographs in this appraisal are used merely to help the reader visualize the property and its surroundings and are not certified to be accurate. 2. Any liens or encumbrances (except for any lease encumbrance that might be referred to in the appraisal) which may exist have been disregarded, and the property has been appraised as though no delinquency in the payment of general taxes or special assessment exists and as though free of indebtedness. 3. It is assumed that the utilization of the land and improvements are within the boundaries of the lines of the property described and that there is no encroachment or trespass unless noted in the report. No survey of the subject property was made or caused to be made by us, and no responsibility is assumed for the occurrence of such matters. 4. A visual inspection of the subject site was made and all engineering is assumed to be correct. The plot plan and illustrative materials in this report are included only to assist the reader in visualizing the property and to show the reader the relationship of its boundaries. The appraiser is not a construction engineer and is not responsible for structural or cosmetic inadequacies associated with any of the improvements unless otherwise noted in the report. 5. It is assumed that there are no hidden or unapparent conditions of the property, subsoil, or structures that render it more or less valuable. No responsibility is assumed for such conditions or for arranging for engineering studies that may be required to discover them. The soil for the area under appraisal appears to be firm and solid, unless otherwise stated. Subsidence in the area is unknown or uncommon, and the appraiser(s) does not warrant against this condition or occurrence. 6. Subsurface rights (minerals and oil) were not considered in this appraisal unless otherwise stated. In addition, no potential timber value was considered. 47 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 33 of 96 Right of Way Section 7. It is assumed that there is full compliance with all applicable federal, state, and local environmental regulations and laws unless noncompliance is stated, defined, and considered in the appraisal report. Unless otherwise stated in this report, the appraiser did not observe the existence of hazardous materials or gases, which may or may not be present on the property. The appraiser has no knowledge of the existence of such materials on or in the property. The appraiser, however, is not qualified to detect such substances. The presence of substances such as asbestos, urea-formaldehyde foam insulation, or other potentially hazardous materials may affect the value of the property. The value estimate is predicated on the assumption that there are no such materials on or in the property, which would cause a loss in value. No responsibility is assumed for any such conditions or for any expertise or engineering knowledge required to discover them. The client is urged to retain an expert in this field, if desired. 8. It is assumed that all applicable zoning and use regulations and restrictions have been complied with, unless a nonconforming use has been stated, defined, and considered in the appraisal report. 9. It is assumed that all required licenses, certifications of occupancy, consents, or other legislative or administrative authority from any local, state, or national government or private entity or organization have been or can be obtained or renewed for any use on which the value estimate contained in this report is based. 10. This appraisal assumes water and sewer services will always be provided for the subject. 11. Responsible ownership and competent property management are assumed. 12. The Americans with Disabilities Act (“ADA”) became effective January 26, 1992. I (we) have not made a specific compliance survey and an analysis of this property to determine whether or not it is in conformity with the various detailed requirements of the ADA. It is possible that a compliance survey of the property, together with a detailed analysis of the requirements of the ADA, could reveal that the property is not in compliance with one or more of the requirements of the Act. If so, this fact could have a negative impact on the value of the property. Since I (we) have no direct evidence relating to this issue, I (we) did not consider 48 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 34 of 96 Right of Way Section General Assumptions Continued non-compliance with the requirements of ADA in estimating the value of the property. 13. There is currently a good deal of discussion regarding the potential hazards of Electro-Magnetic Fields and the possible health risk of being located near high voltage transmission lines. I (we) have not made a specific compliance survey and analysis of this property to determine whether or not there are potentially hazardous effects from EMF’s. It is possible that a compliance survey of the property together with a detailed analysis could reveal that there is EMF levels, which are above a safe level. If so, this fact could have a negative impact on the value of the subject property. Since I (we) have no direct evidence relating to this issue, I (we) did not consider EMF levels in estimating the value for the property. General Limiting Conditions – This appraisal has been completed and the appraisal report has been prepared with the following general limiting conditions. 1. The distribution, if any, of the total valuation in this report between land and improvements applies only under the stated program of utilization. The separate allocations for land and buildings must not be used in conjunction with any other appraisal and are invalid if so used. The value estimates provided in the report apply to the entire property, and any proration or division of the total into fractional interests will invalidate the value estimate, unless such proration or division or interests has been set forth in this report. 2. Nei ther possession of this appraisal or copy thereof carries with it the right to publication, nor may it be used for any purpose by anyone but the applicant without previous consent of the appraiser(s). 3. The appraiser, by reason of this appraisal, is not required to give further consultation, testimony, or be in attendance in court with reference to the property in question unless arrangements have been previously made. 4. Nei ther all nor part of the contents of this report (especially as to value, the identity of the appraiser, or the firm with which the appraiser is associated) shall be disseminated to the public through advertising, public relations, news, sales, or other media without the prior written consent and approval of the appraiser. 49 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 35 of 96 Right of Way Section General Limiting Conditions Continued 1. Inf ormation, estimates, and opinions contained in this report are obtained from sources considered reliable, however the appraiser assumes no liability for such sources. 2. The information supplied to the appraiser is considered to be accurate. The information supplied by the client has been accepted without further verification as correctly reflecting the property’s current condition unless otherwise noted. 3. The various estimates of value presented in this report apply to this appraisal only and may not be used out of the context presented herein. This appraisal is valid only for the appraisal date or dates specified herein and only for the appraisal purpose specified herein. 50 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 36 of 96 Right of Way Section CERTIFICATE OF APPRAISER I hereby certify: That I have personally inspected the property herein and that I have also made a personal field inspection of the comparable sales relied upon in making this appraisal. The subject and the comparable sales relied upon in making the appraisal were as represented in the comparable data brochure which supplements this appraisal. That to the best of my knowledge and belief the statements contained in the appraisal herein set forth are true, and information upon which the opinions expressed therein are based is correct: subject to the limiting conditions therein set forth. That I understand that such appraisal may be used in connection with acquisition of right of way for a highway to be constructed by the State of South Carolina with the assistance of Federal-aid highway funds, or other Federal Funds. That such appraisal has been made in conformity with the appropriate State and Federal laws regulations, policies and procedures applicable to that appraisal of right of way for such purposes; and that to the best of my knowledge, no portion of the value assigned to such property consists of items, which are non-compensable under the established law of South Carolina. That neither my employment nor my compensation for preparing this appraisal report is in any way contingent upon the values reported herein. That I have no direct or indirect present or contemplated future personal interest in such property or in any benefit from the acquisition of such property appraised. That I have not revealed the findings and results of such appraisal to anyone other than the proper officials of the South Carolina Department of Transportation or officials of the Federal Highway Administration and I will not do so until so authorized by the State officials or until I am required to do so by due process of law, or until I am released from this obligation by having publicly testified as to such findings. That the owner or his designated representative was given the opportunity to accompany me during my inspection of the property. That I have not provided any services regarding the subject property within the prior three years, as an appraiser or in any other capacity. That any decrease or increase in the fair market value of the real property prior to the date of valuation caused by the public improvement for which such property is being acquired, or by the likelihood that the property would be acquired for such improvement, other than that due to the physical deterioration with in the reasonable control of the owner, has been disregarded in determining the compensation for the property. That my opinion of the fair market value of the acquisition as of 8/19/2024 is $$300,308 based upon my independent appraisal and the exercise of my professional judgment. As of the date of this report, I have completed the requirements for continuing education as set forth by the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice. Date: 8/30/2024 State Certified General Real Estate Appraiser CG1132 . Date: Click or tap to enter a date. 51 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 37 of 96 Right of Way Section ADDENDA 52 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 38 of 96 Right of Way Section 53 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 39 of 96 Right of Way Section 54 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 40 of 96 Right of Way Section 55 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 41 of 96 Right of Way Section 56 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 42 of 96 Right of Way Section 57 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 43 of 96 Right of Way Section 58 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 44 of 96 Right of Way Section 59 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 45 of 96 Right of Way Section 60 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 46 of 96 Right of Way Section 61 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 47 of 96 Right of Way Section 62 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 48 of 96 Right of Way Section 63 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 49 of 96 Right of Way Section 64 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 50 of 96 Right of Way Section 65 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 51 of 96 Right of Way Section 66 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 52 of 96 Right of Way Section 67 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 53 of 96 Right of Way Section 68 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 54 of 96 Right of Way Section 69 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 55 of 96 Right of Way Section 70 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 56 of 96 Right of Way Section 71 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 57 of 96 Right of Way Section 72 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 58 of 96 Right of Way Section 73 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 59 of 96 Right of Way Section 74 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 60 of 96 Right of Way Section 75 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 61 of 96 Right of Way Section 76 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 62 of 96 Right of Way Section 77 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 63 of 96 Right of Way Section 78 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 64 of 96 Right of Way Section 79 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 65 of 96 Right of Way Section 80 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 66 of 96 Right of Way Section 81 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 67 of 96 Right of Way Section 82 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 68 of 96 Right of Way Section 83 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 69 of 96 Right of Way Section 84 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 70 of 96 Right of Way Section 85 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 71 of 96 Right of Way Section 86 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 72 of 96 Right of Way Section 87 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 73 of 96 Right of Way Section 88 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 74 of 96 Right of Way Section 89 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 75 of 96 Right of Way Section 90 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 76 of 96 Right of Way Section 91 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 77 of 96 Right of Way Section 92 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 78 of 96 Right of Way Section 93 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 79 of 96 Right of Way Section 94 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 80 of 96 Right of Way Section 95 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 81 of 96 Right of Way Section 96 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 82 of 96 Right of Way Section 97 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 83 of 96 Right of Way Section 98 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 84 of 96 Right of Way Section 99 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 85 of 96 Right of Way Section 100 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 86 of 96 Right of Way Section 101 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 87 of 96 Right of Way Section 102 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 88 of 96 Right of Way Section 103 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 89 of 96 Right of Way Section 104 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 90 of 96 Right of Way Section 105 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 91 of 96 Right of Way Section 106 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 92 of 96 Right of Way Section 107 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 93 of 96 Right of Way Section QUALIFICATIONS OF THE APPRAISER DEBORAH L. TRIPP, MAI, SRA PROPERTY SOLUTIONS, LLC 5721 BUSH RIVER ROAD COLUMBIA, SC 29212 803.407.3000 PROFESSIONAL DESIGNATIONS AND AFFILIATIONS ¨ MAI - Member of the Appraisal Institute, 1996, Member #11,163 ¨ SRA - Senior Residential Appraiser Member of the Appraisal Institute, 1990 ¨ State Certified General Real Estate Appraiser - State of South Carolina, GG1132 ¨ State Certified General Real Estate Appraiser – State of North Carolina, A5379 ¨ State Certified General Real Property Appraiser – State of Georgia, 5364 ¨ Broker certified, South Carolina Real Estate Commission, 1988 – 380218832 ¨ Broker-in-Charge, South Carolina Real Estate Commission License REL.29249.BIC TECHNICAL TRAINING Courses Society of Real Estate Appraisers Courses Completed: Course 101, “An Introduction to Real Property Appraising”, 1984 Course 102, “Applied Residential Property Appraising”, 1985 Appraisal Institute Courses Completed: Course 201, “Principles of Income Property Appraising”, 1991 Course 202, “Applied Income Property Valuation”, 1991 Course 410, “Standards of Professional Practice, Part A”, 1996 Course 420, “Standards of Professional Practice, Part B”, 1996 Course 430, “Standards of Professional Practice, Part C”, 2005 “Seven Hour National USPAP Update Course”, 2024-2025 Edition, 2023 Course 833, “Fundamentals of Separating Real Property, Personal Property and Intangible Assets”, 2012 Recent Seminars and Professional Development Programs “Eminent Domain Continuing Education Class”, SCDOT, 2024 “The Validation Frontier – Theory & Applications in Stress Testing & Value Relationships for the ‘Unvaluation’”, Appraisal Institute, 2024 “Corridor Valuations, Appraisal Institute, 2024 “15 Takeaways Legal“, Appraisal Institute, 2023 “State of SC Economic Summit”, Appraisal Institute, 2023 “Appraising Environmentally Contaminated Properties, Appraisal Institute, 2023 “Valuation of Conservation Easements”, Completed Curriculum and Passed Examination”, Appraisal Institute, 2023 “Conservation Transactions: Legal and Appraisal Matters”, SC Conservation Bank, 2022 “State of South Carolina Economic Summit 2022” Appraisal Institute, 2022 “Conservation Easements, 2021 Updates on Legal, Appraisal, Accounting and Ethical Issues”, The Alabama/Mississippi chapter of the Appraisal Institute & The Georgia-Alabama Land Trust, 2021 “Six Recent Appraiser Lawsuits and the Lessons from Each”, Appraisal Institute, 2021 “State of SC Economic Summit, Parts 1 and 2”, Appraisal Institute, 2021 “Aerial Inspections for Real Estate”, Appraisal Institute, 2021 “What’s up with Technology for Real Estate Appraisers”, Appraisal Institute, 2020 “Artificial Intelligence, AVMs & Blockchain – Implications for Valuation”, Appraisal Institute, 2020 “Appraising for the Department of Interior (AVSO) & Other Federal Agencies”, Appraisal Institute, 2019 “Uniform Standards for Federal Land Acquisition”, - Appraisal Institute, 2018 108 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 94 of 96 Right of Way Section QUALIFICATIONS OF DEBORAH L. TRIPP, MAI, SRA - (Continued) PROFESSIONAL CONTRIBUTIONS Author: ¨ “Practical Applications: The Cost Approach and Accrued Depreciation” Seminar sponsored by SC Chapter of the Appraisal Institute and approved by the SC Real Estate Appraisers Board, 1993 ¨ “Appraiser Independence Redefined: The Empowerment of a Profession”, Appraisal Institute, Valuation Insights and Perspectives, Volume 1, # 4, Fall, 1996. ¨ "Proposals and Engagements – Preparing for Marriage with your Client", Appraisal Institute, Valuation Insights and Perspectives, Volume 4, #3, Third Quarter, 1999. ¨ Various appraisal seminars and workshops, 1988 to 2007 Advisor: ¨ Valuation Insights and Perspectives, professional periodical, published quarterly by the Appraisal Institute, Chicago, Illinois, through 1999. Reviewer: ¨ “Senior Housing - Looking Toward the Third Millennium” , Arthur E. Gimmy, MAI, Appraisal Institute, Chicago, Illinois, 1998. ¨ “Fannie Mae Desktop Underwriter Quantitative Analysis Appraisal Report Form 2055 & Qualitative Analysis Appraisal Report Form 2065”, Joseph L. Minnich, III, SRPA, SRA, Appraisal Institute, Chicago, Illinois, 1997. Other: Past President and Cofounder, CREW Midlands South Carolina, 2014 (Commercial Real Estate Women) President, CREW Midlands South Carolina, 2013 President Elect, CREW Midlands SC, 2012 Director, CREW Midlands SC, 2010-2011 Past President and Co-Founder: SC Professional Appraisers Coalition, 2009 Board of Directors, SC Chapter Appraisal Institute, 2004-2006 Government Relations Committee, SC Chapter Appraisal Institute, 2003, 2014-2016 Associate Guidance Committee Chair, SC Chapter Appraisal Institute, 2003 Member, Government Relations Committee, Appraisal Institute, 1996-2002 Vice-Chair, Government Relations Committee, Appraisal Institute, 1999 Member, Public Affairs Committee, Appraisal Institute, 1999 Member, Publications Review Subcommittee, Appraisal Institute, 1996-1999 Member, Communications Committee, Appraisal Institute, 1999 SC State Chair, Government Relations Subcommittee, Appraisal Institute, 1994-1998 EXPERIENCE ¨ Property Solutions, LLC, Owner/President, Analyst, Appraiser, Consultant, 1998 to present. ¨ Administrator/Subcontract Senior Commercial Appraiser, Executive Vice President and/or owner, various appraisal firms since 1981. ¨ Experience in real estate industry as Broker-in-Charge or licensed agent since 1977. 109 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 95 of 96 Right of Way Section QUALIFICATIONS OF DEBORAH L. TRIPP, MAI, SRA - (Continued) SCOPE OF PROPERTY ANALYSIS COMPLETED Real Estate Analysis Prepared For US Department of Justice Southern First Bank University of South Carolina Wal-Mart City of Columbia SouthState Bank Internal Revenue Service Wells Fargo Bank Security Federal Bank SC Law Enforcement Division South Carolina Department of Transportation Richland County South Carolina Department of Parks, First Citizens Bank & Trust Recreation & Tourism Truist Blue Cross & Blue Shield of South Carolina Lexington Medical Center Department of Housing & Urban Development Attorneys First Horizon South Carolina National Guard South Carolina State Housing Authority South Carolina Budget & Control Board Columbia Housing Authority South Carolina Bar Association General Services Administration State Farm Insurance Company University of South Carolina US Army Corps of Engineers Real Estate Analysis and Consulting Extensive experience in numerous property types including: Health Care Enterprises Hospitals Senior Care Facilities Conservation Easements Market Analysis Life Care Communities Independent Living Facilities Apartments HUD Programs Complex Properties Tax Credit Review Appraisals Litigation Appraisals Litigation Consulting Partial Acquisition Partial Interests Environmentally Impaired Shopping Centers Retail Buildings Offices Office Parks Restaurants Historic Properties Single Family Residences Development Land Mixed Use Developments Plantations Subdivisions Feasibility Studies Market Analysis Rental Studies Air Rights Marinas Qualified as Expert Appraisal Witness on Real Estate Analysis and Valuation in : US Bankruptcy Court, District of South Carolina; Lexington County Family Court, Eleventh Judicial Circuit; Aiken County Civil Court, Second Judicial Circuit, Administrative Law Judge Division, State of SC. Consultant in real estate mediation deliberations and depositions. Community Service Co-Founder, Commercial Real Estate Women – Midlands Chapter Co-Founder, South Carolina Professional Appraisers Coalition President, Southwell Subdivision Homeowner’s Association Board of Directors, 2011 Chair and Organizer, Central South Carolina Habitat for Humanity First Ladies Build, the first Women-built Habitat House in South Carolina, First Lady Rachel Hodges, Honorary Chair Nominated for South Carolina "Woman of Achievement" Award, Governor's Commission on Women, 2001 110 Project ID No. P030553 P03553 – Road S-107 County Greenville Tract(s) 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8 SCDOT R/W Form 110-A (01-2023) Page 96 of 96 Right of Way Section 111

Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.