BAR-S Meeting Results
City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Jul 9, 2026 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Charleston
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY OF CHARLESTON
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL
MEETING RESULTS
JULY 9, 2026 4:30 P.M. 2 GEORGE STREET
BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT: Bill Turner, Darryl Cobb, Kalen McNabb
STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT: Frankie Pinto, Daniel McKnight
A. Minutes
1. Review of Minutes from the July 9, 2026 Meeting
DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS
MOTION: Approve with Van Slambrook edits
MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0
B. Applications
1. 10 Clemson Street
BAR2026-002680 | TMS#4630702052 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6 |
Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1935 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Request approval for partial demolition of exterior elements visible from the public right-of-
way.
Owner: Amie Wolf & Kevin Kerragan
Applicant: Tyler A Smyth, Architect LLC
Site visit on 7/9/26 at 8:30 a.m.
DECISION: APPROVED
MOTION: Approval of demolition
MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• None
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Requesting demolition of siding, fenestration, and portions of roof.
2. Demolition area is highly visible due to structure’s location at a corner.
3. Area of request is at the rear, pulled in from the corners and down from the ridge,
per standard staff comments.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of demolition
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | July 9, 2026 Page 2
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• None
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• None
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Didn’t have any issues with request
2. 29 Pendleton Street
BAR2026-002683 | TMS#463-07-02-071 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6 |
Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1941 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Request OPT-IN REVIEW for demolition of existing exterior elements visible from the public
right-of-way AND conceptual approval for proposed addition.
Owner: Hanna Geiger & Nick Cann
Applicant: Hanna Geiger & Nick Cann
Previous site visit on 5/28/26.
DECISION: DEFERRED
MOTION: Deferral
MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: McNabb VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• None
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Encapsulation of portions of facades is the same as demolition as once it is
encapsulated, it is removed from purview
2. The chimney is a character defining feature, any demolition should be to the rear
of the chimney.
3. Drawings are very confusing. The elevations and renderings don’t seem to match,
and the plans are missing portions of the structure.
4. Proposal overwhelms the historic core of the house and is inappropriately scaled
for the context.
5. Any additions should be lower than the eave of the historic house.
6. Proposal is too heavy handed with additions creating a fortress like appearance.
STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL:
1. Staff encourage a more sensitive approach which will be better suited to the
context
2. Reduce the amount of added mass.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Denial as submitted
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• Addition on left has one story portion at front. Addition on right had garden courtyard
• Ceiling heights in existing house are around 8’3”, in addition around 8’
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• HCF
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | July 9, 2026 Page 3
o Appreciate opt-in review
o As proposed additions overwhelm historic structure, additions should be
subordinate
• PSC
o Appreciate opt-in review, comprehensive
o As proposed is an intense increase in massing
o Wagener Terrace ACA
o Site wall creates fortress like effect
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Appreciate neighborhood examples
• Agree that additions overwhelm main structure. As pedestrian on the street it may
create an overwhelming sensation
• Use of single story at front, two story at rear good tactics
• Nice design but a little aggressive, needs to be toned down
• Courtyard wall is adding to the mass
• Additions are competing with existing
• Like addition at the back, but the overall width loses the little house that is there
• Square footage not the issue, but attached to historic structure. Garage can be
attached
• Use of hyphen or tuck in from sides with addition to rear
• It’s not the size, it’s the amount of structure that is being attached to
• Understand not wanting to use more space in the rear but there is more space there
3. 8 Saint Margaret Street
BAR2026-002709 | TMS# 4631104010 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6 |
Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1939 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Request approval for partial demolition of exterior elements visible from the public right-of-
way.
Owner: SR Property Partners LLC
Applicant: S. Arch + Studio, LLC
Site visit on 7/9/26 at 8:50 a.m.
DECISION: APPROVED
MOTION: Approval of demolition
MADE BY: McNabb SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• None
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Area of request is pushed toward rear, pulled in from the eaves and down from
the ridge, per standard staff comments.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of demolition
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• None
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | July 9, 2026 Page 4
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• None
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Not an unreasonable amount
4. 680 King Street
BAR2026-002669 | TMS#4631603001 | Westside Neighborhood | Council District 4
Category 4 (Group2) | c. 1890 | Historic Corridor District
Request exterior alterations including removal of later addition, widened portion of the
piazza and exterior stair. Reframe the gable at the rear to remove the shed roof elements.
Owner: 680 King Management LLC
Applicant: Amber Aument LLC
Site visit on 7/9/26 at 9:10 a.m.
DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS
MOTION: Conceptual approval with Board and staff comments and preliminary / final by
staff
MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: McNabb VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• See comments
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Staff appreciate the removal of bump out and piazza stairs
2. Windows on addition seem off center
3. Clarify scope of work for existing windows
STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL:
1. Restudy Windows placement on addition
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with staff condition and preliminary /
final review by staff
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• Would like to adjust column spacing per conversation with Board at site
• If using aluminum clad window would be on entire structure
• Reusing siding if possible
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• PSC
o In support of project
• HCF
o In support of project
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Clarification of staff comment, is regarding windows on south east elevation
• Appreciate restoration of piazza
• Reuse existing columns and balusters
• If reusing siding, can differentiate on existing addition
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | July 9, 2026 Page 5
• Prefer wood on historic portion, clad on addition
• Recommend different lite cut window on addition
5. 37 Montagu Street
BAR2026-002676 | TMS# 4570304089 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 |
Category 4 | c. 1870 | Old and Historic District
Request approval for after-the-fact alterations.
Owner: Christopher and Molly Finn
Applicant: CHARLESTON REAL ESTATE REPAIRS
Site visit on 7/9/26 at 9:30 a.m.
DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS
MOTION: Approval of changes after the fact with Board condition
MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: McNabb VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• Remaining shutters at rear L can be removed
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Fenestration has changed from previous approval. The placement as constructed
does not match the Board conceptual approval and final review by staff.
2. Staff cannot approve the fenestration changes as it is a downgrade in design
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• None
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• HCF
o Not in support of after-the-fact without documentation that altered
windows were not historic openings
• PSC
o If change had been proposed to Board, would most likely not have been
approved
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Don’t have issue with steps being removed, more typical of original conditions
• Concern about the span between columns with new span, sagging issue. Looked better
with the missing columns
• No issue with removal of shutters on the L, the 2 remaining shutters should also be
removed
• Windows on east elevation, generally not that many windows on north/east
elevations. Don’t have issue with removal
• Since this is side hall house would expect a few more windows on this elevation
• Beautiful restoration
6. 110 Beaufain Street
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | July 9, 2026 Page 6
BAR2026-002660 | TMS# 4570304022 | Harleston Village | Council District 8|
Category 2 | c. 1838 | Old and Historic District
Request approval for alterations to existing iron fence and gate.
Owner: Jason Owen
Applicant: Ables Landscape Associates Inc. (Candace Young)
Site visit on 7/9/26 at 9:50 a.m.
DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS
MOTION: Approval with Board conditions and preliminary / final review by staff
MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: McNabb VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• Knee wall not to exceed 19”
• If possible retain and reuse existing brick
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Existing knee wall dates to 1935 per photos
2. Opposed to the alteration to historic knee wall
3. Change in fence height to meet neighbor fence at 108 Beaufain creates awkward
connection
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of changes to gate, denial of alteration to knee
wall
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• None
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• None
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Have more of an issue with widening of driveway, 10’ is typical width
• Knee wall is not original, brick with Portland cement
• Evolution of fence / wall could be part of history
• Appreciate the retention of the curve
• Cars are trending to get wider
• No on street parking on that side of street
• Possibility of reusing brick with Portland cement
• Approval due to turning radius
7. 10 Council Street
BAR2026-002673 | TMS# 4571104023 | Charlestowne | Council District
8|Category 4 | c. 1870 | Old and Historic District
Request approval to demolish existing garage, rear addition, portico and columns, fence
and gate. (clarification of request: alteration to gate)
Owner: Joshua Platt
Applicant: S. Arch + Studio, LLC
Site visit on 7/9/26 at 10:10 a.m.
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | July 9, 2026 Page 7
DECISION: APPROVED
MOTION: Approval demolition as submitted
MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: McNabb VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• none
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Garage was constructed between 1957 and 1971 per aerials
2. Piazza was originally 2 story
3. Staff is not opposed to the removal of the existing rear addition
4. (clarification of request by applicant during presentation: gate being altered, not
demolished)
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of demolition
BOARD COMMENTS:
• (See combined public comment and Board discussion in #8)
8. 10 Council Street
BAR2026-002677 | TMS# 4571104023 | Charlestowne | Council District
8|Category 4 | c. 1870 | Old and Historic District
Request approval for new addition, piazza, and detached garage.
Owner: Joshua Platt
Applicant: S. Arch + Studio, LLC
DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS
MOTION: Conceptual approval with Board conditions and preliminary / final by staff
MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: McNabb VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• Encourage study piazza screen wall and balustrade
• Require round columns
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Returning piazza to original configuration
2. Columns and railing are speculative and appear to mimic previous changes, should
replicate what would have been on the two-story piazza traditionally or have
basis for design. Round columns and turn balustrade on similar houses adjacent
3. Proposed rear addition is subordinate and differentiated
4. Garage is subordinate and compatible
STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL:
1. Restudy proposed columns and balustrade
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with Board and staff conditions and
preliminary / final by staff
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• None
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | July 9, 2026 Page 8
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• PSC
o If restored, piazza should be more authentic configuration
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Don’t think can require a piazza screen, can require restudy of columns
• Encourage piazza screen wall and balustrade
• Change lite cut to be more differentiated
• 1961 newspaper article for changes being removed
9. 15 Longitude Lane
BAR2026-002679 | TMS#458-13-01-061 | Charlestowne | Council District 8| Not
rated | c. 1950| Old and Historic District
Request approval for demolition of existing 1 story garage, boiler room, garage hyphen,
portions of wall on west and south elevations for new openings, front door and transom and
brick front stairs.
Owner: Charles McIlvaine and Ann Kelly
Applicant: Beau Clowney Architects (Nicole Lee)
Previous site visit on 5/14/26.
DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS
MOTION: Approval of demolition with Board condition
MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: McNabb VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• Wrought iron railing reused if possible, can be altered
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Front stair and portions of west wall and roof were previously denied demolition
2. Amount of west wall and roof requested to be demolished has been reduced.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Denial per previous Board motion
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• Any thought to reincorporate iron into new design
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• PSC
o Appreciate edits
o Board previously denied removal of front stair, should be retained
BOARD COMMENTS:
• (See combined Board discussion in #10)
10. 15 Longitude Lane
BAR2026-002691 | TMS#458-13-01-061| Charlestowne | Council District 8| Not
rated | c. 1950| Old and Historic District
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | July 9, 2026 Page 9
Request conceptual approval for a new two-story garage, hyphen, and additional exterior
alterations.
Owner: Charles McIlvaine and Ann Kelly
Applicant: Beau Clowney Architects (Kate Campbell)
DECISION: APPROVED
MOTION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final by staff
MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: McNabb VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• 1
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. The following Board comments have been addressed:
a. Roof pitch has been lowered.
b. Bay that extends from garage has been reduced
c. East façade has been pulled back and original corners have been retained
d. Parge coat has been changed to a lime wash
2. The following Board comments have not been addressed:
a. The eave height has remained the same as the existing house.
b. Does not follow the typical diagram of stepped in from historic structure or
adding a hyphen to create more of a transition
c. The proposed addition is still wider than main house
d. Dormer on west elevation has been restudied, but is still larger than the 3
individual dormers on the east elevation.
3. Proposed dormers have different roof materials. (drawing issue?)
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Deferral per previous Board motion
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• Roof of existing house is shingle
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• HCF
o Garage on front, though atypical, is appropriate for location
o Appreciate changes from previous submittal
o Encourage reducing overall footprint and massing
• PSC
o As proposed virtually doubles mass
o Should step in from plane of historic form
BOARD COMMENTS:
• A lot of positive changes since last submittal
• Pushing in bay from Lane elevation
• West elevation dormers much better
• Don’t have issue with one story additions on neighbors’ side
• Railings should be reused
• Very unusual context, Lane would typically be back side. Predominate characteristic of
Lane is garages
• Does garage element need to be narrower
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | July 9, 2026 Page 10
• Well articulated mass from street
• In different context, would feel more strongly about some of these features
• Odd setting on narrow lane
• Revised proposal for front door much better
• Mass of garage broken up
• Can’t lower eave height any further
11. 15 Bedons Aly
BAR2026-002666 | TMS#458-0-90-3087 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 |
Not Surveyed | New Construction | Old & Historic District
Request approval for revisions to previous Board approval.
Owner: Elizabeth Simmons
Applicant: Sebastian Von Marschall Architect, LLC
DECISION: APPROVED
MOTION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final by staff
MADE BY: McNabb SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• None
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Previously approved by BAR-S: 2/12/2026
2. Staff have no additional comments
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final by staff
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• None
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• HCF
o Requests Board uphold previously approved ground floor fenestration
BOARD COMMENTS:
• No issues with any of the proposed changes
12. 25 Sans Souci Street
BAR2026-002667 | TMS#463-08-02-034 | North Central | Council District 4
c. 1955 (date incorrect) 2010| Historic Corridor District
Request conceptual approval for new rear porch addition and alterations to front porch.
Owner: Mark Dubrouillet
Applicant: Smart Renovations
DECISION: APPROVED
MOTION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final by staff
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | July 9, 2026 Page 11
MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: McNabb VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• None
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Proposed front porch has awkward connection with existing façade.
STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL:
1. Reduce width of new front porch roof.
2. Recommend removing the expressed corner boards from porch infill
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with Board and staff conditions and
preliminary / final by staff
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• Existing material cementous siding
• Drainage issue at front porch
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• None
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Don’t have issue with front porch roof
13. 12 Council Street
BAR2026-002674 | TMS#457-11-04-022 | Charlestowne | Council District 8
Category 4 | c. 1870 | Old and Historic District
Request conceptual approval for a one-story sunroom addition to south façade.
Owner: Barzilla SC LLC
Applicant: AMERICAN VERNACULAR, INC
DECISION: APPROVED
MOTION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final by staff
MADE BY: McNabb SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• None
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Existing house already has unusual form due to the unique lot condition.
2. Proposal is subordinate and differentiated.
3. Due to placement on site, the addition will not be seen at the same time as the
existing front facade
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final by staff
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• None
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• None
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | July 9, 2026 Page 12
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Don’t have any issues
14. 6 Limehouse Street
BAR2026-002685 | TMS#457-11-04-053 | Charlestowne | Council District 8
Not rated | c. 1913 | Old and Historic District
Request conceptual approval for roof replacement with Versaloc roof.
Owner: Matthew Scherder
Applicant: Sea Island Residential, LLC
DECISION: DEFERRED
MOTION: Deferred by applicant prior to meeting
15. 5 Cumberland Street
BAR2026-002664 | TMS#458-09-02-032 | French Quarter | Council District 8
|Category 4| c. 1830 | Old and Historic District
Requesting approval to install skylights along existing ridge.
Owner: Cumberland Kitsune, LLC
Applicant: Stumphouse, LLC
DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS
MOTION: Conceptual approval Board condition with preliminary / final by staff
MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: McNabb VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• Study copper flashing throughout for consistency
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Submittal shows precedent for the addition of skylights.
2. The faux skylight and clerestory windows portion is inappropriate.
3. Skylights should be located on rear roof slopes to lessen visibility.
4. The current design proposes popped up skylights, staff would prefer a flat option
STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL:
1. If approved there should be no faux skylight / clerestory window portion
2. Any approved skylights should be placed on rear slope
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Deferral for restudy with Board and staff conditions
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• Same product used in City Market
• Frame color to match existing roof color
• Kitchen area won’t have skylights
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• None
BOARD COMMENTS:
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | July 9, 2026 Page 13
• Clarification of staff comment, “rear slope” Cone Street side
• Continuous skylight in City Market
• Not cutting into old roof
• Monitor design as compared to skylight
• Faux skylight would be framed the same, wrapped with copper roof material
• Could skylight be flashed in copper
• Low profile, will hardly notice
• Faux skylight issue, wouldn’t look lopsided without
PUBLIC MEETING ACCOMMODATIONS:
In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, people who need alternative formats, ASL
(American Sign Language) Interpretation, or other accommodation, should please contact Janet
Schumacher at 843-577-1389 or schumacherj@charleston-sc.gov three business days prior to the
meeting.
Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.