RecordWell Data

BAR-L Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Jul 8, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – LARGE PUBLIC COMMENT JULY 8, 2026 A meeting of the Board of Architectural Review – Large (BAR -L) will be held on Wednesday, July 8, 2026 at 4:30 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street. The following written comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the meeting. The comments will also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/bar. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 B. APPLICATIONS 1. 35 Bee Street BAR2026-002699 | TMS #4601501043 | Medical Complex | Council District 6 New Construction | Height Districts 55/30S, 85/30, 85/125 | Old City District, Medical District Overlay Requesting Approval of a mockup panel. Owner: Medical University of South Carolina (MUSC) Applicant: Liollio Architecture NOTE: The Board will convene at this address on Tuesday, July 7, 2026, at 8:30 a.m. for a site visit. No Comments Submitted 2. 106 Coming Street BAR2026-002703 | TMS #4601603017 | Radcliffeborough | Council District 4 New Construction | Height Districts 4, 8 | Old City District Requesting Conceptual Approval of a student housing building. Owner: College of Charleston Applicant: Liollio Architecture 28 Comments Submitted: • Thomas Orth, Charleston Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • 27 Comments Submitted to Innovate Site See attached comments. Board of Architectural Review – Large Public Comment | July 8, 2026 Page 2 3. 989 Morrison Drive BAR2026-002706 | TMS #4590101001 | East Central | Council District 4 New Construction | Height District 4-12 | Historic Corridor District Requesting Conceptual Approval of a new multi-family building. Owner: Scott Fuller (representative) Applicant: Brad Brown 18 Comments Submitted: • 18 Comments Submitted to Innovate Site See attached comments. 4. 48 & 52 Line Street BAR2026-002700 | TMS #4590503136, 4590503139 Cannonborough/Elliottborough | Council District 8 | New Construction Height District 8 | Old and Historic District Requesting Revision to Conceptual Approval and Preliminary Approval of two (2) mixed- use buildings. Owner: LL East LLC Applicant: Kevin Smith (Robert A.M. Stern Architects) 7 Comments Submitted: • 7 Comments Submitted to Innovate Site See attached comments. 5. 251 King Street BAR2026-002690 | TMS #4570801052 | Downtown | Council District 4 Category 2 | c. 1880’s | Height Districts 3, 6 | Old and Historic District Requesting Conceptual Approval of exterior alterations and illuminated signage. Owner: Peter Demetre Applicant: Bill Marshall 4 Comments Submitted: • Chip Ervin, Grady Ervin & Co. Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Casey Lavin, Beemok Hospitality Collection Submitted to Staff by Bill Marshall See attached letter. • Historic Charleston Foundation Submitted to Staff by Bill Marshall See attached letter. • Preservation Society of Charleston Submitted to Staff by Bill Marshall See attached letter. Board of Architectural Review – Large Public Comment | July 8, 2026 Page 3 6. 134 Saint Philip Street BAR2026-002672 | TMS #4601202038 | Radcliffeborough | Council District 4 Category 3 | c. 1887 | Height Districts 2.5-3, 4 | Old City District Requesting Final Approval of an exterior lighting package. Owner: Father Johnbosco Ikemeh (St. Patrick Catholic Church) Applicant: David Hill (Innova Architecture) 1 Comment Submitted: • Preservation Society of Charleston Submitted to Staff See attached statement. 7. 200 Meeting Street BAR2026-002694 | TMS #4580503001 | Downtown | Council District 8 Not Rated | c. 1991 | Height Districts 3.5, 4 | Old and Historic District Requesting Final Approval of a signage package containing illuminated signage. Owner: Fourthline Capital Management LLC Applicant: Paul Dalesandro (Rise Above Signs & Graphics) No Comments Submitted Other Comments • Hallie Seibels, 34 Rutledge Avenue Submitted on Innovate Site July 6, 2026 6:14 PM Stop the development. I vote no CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – LARGE 106 Coming Street BAR2026-002703 | TMS #4601603017 | Radcliffeborough | Council District 4 New Construction | Height Districts 4, 8 | Old City District Requesting Conceptual Approval of a student housing building. Owner: College of Charleston Applicant: Liollio Architecture Wednesday, July 8, 2026 Public Comment BAR Application #2 106 Coming Street New Construction It's premature for the Board of Architectural Review to take any action on the proposed architectural aesthetics for the 106 Coming Street project site. There has been inadequate consideration and engagement with African and Indigenous Communities. There has been no information for the public about how immorally thousands of Negroes and Strangers are buried at this site. Thomas Orth B.S., M.Ed. Citizen of Charleston CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – LARGE 106 Coming Street 27 Comments Submitted 5 Comments in Support | 22 Comments Requesting Deferral or in Opposition First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted 5 Comments in Support Joe McGee 1 Magazine Street Dear Chair and members of the Board, I write in qualified support of the College of Charleston’s 106 Coming Street Commons proposal. Similar to the Radcliffeborough Neighborhood, our neighborhood understands the daily pressures created when student housing demand is absorbed by residential streets: parking competition, late-night behavior, absentee ownership, and the conversion of family housing into student rentals. For that reason, we support the College’s effort to house more students on campus and align with Radcliffeborough’s view that this project can improve neighborhood livability. At the same time, support should not be understood as unconditional approval of the design before you. This is an unusually sensitive site. The burial-ground history must be treated as central to the project, not as a secondary interpretive feature added after design decisions are made. The College should be expected to demonstrate that archaeological findings, commemoration, and community engagement have meaningfully shaped the plan. We also ask the BAR to require greater sensitivity to scale, massing, setbacks, and streetscape character along Coming and Vanderhorst. A student residence can serve an important public purpose and still fail if it overwhelms the adjoining neighborhood. The College of Charleston and Charleston’s historic neighborhoods are intertwined. The College benefits from the character of these neighborhoods, and it has a corresponding responsibility to strengthen, not diminish, that character. I urge the Board to shepherd this project forward only with clear conditions: a more sympathetic scale, a completed and credible burial-ground treatment plan, and a design that reflects the full historical significance of the site. Joe McGee, President, Harleston Village Association Jul 7 2026 11:42AM Elizabeth Soule Brainard Warren Street I am writing in support of the College of Charleston’s BAR proposal for the student housing at the 106 Coming/99 Vanderhorst Streets site, known as Jul 1 2026 11:32AM Board of Architectural Review – Large 106 Coming Street Page 2 Coming Street Commons. The College has kept Radcliffeborough Neighborhood Association (RNA) appraised of the project since at least April 2023. They have been forthright about the heights along Coming and Vanderhorst streets, and were supportive of our requests for setbacks and step ups to minimize mass closest to residential homes. RNA appreciates the need for additional student housing and our members have consistently supported the return of neighborhood housing stock to non-student occupants. RNA believes that Coming Street Commons will greatly advance this goal. Please do not hesitate to reach out should you need additional information. You may also learn more about us by visiting www.RadcliffeboroughSC.org. Patrick DeMarco 1430 Brian Rd, Charleston, SC 29407 I write in support of the College of Charleston's application and plans. This student housing is desperately needed, and will help alleviate housing demand (and hopefully costs) in the surrounding neighborhoods. In a fully-developed, thriving city, every new development poses trade-offs, and we must consider the most urgent problems at all times. While we all want to honor burial grounds and the deceased generations before us, I would argue that the living should be the focus. I am confident the college will do right with transfers of bodies and signage commemorating the site, and this project is far too important to languish in delays, reviews, etc. I encourage the board to approve this project without delay. Jul 2 2026 12:33PM Justin Moffitt 29403 I support this project. It is well designed. Jul 2 2026 3:33PM Zac Viscidi 59 Cypress St The College of Charleston is a storied institution that is older than our own nation. It will outlive all of us, and it possesses the ability to sensibly and sensitively develop this plot. There are significant concerns, but the College is more adequately prepared than most entities to address them. The city should be supportive of its largest and most important institutions. Encouraging a nice public space to honor those individuals who were buried in this plot is totally feasible and can be accomplished. Jul 3 2026 9:23PM Continued on Page 3 Board of Architectural Review – Large 106 Coming Street Page 3 22 Comments Requesting Deferral or in Opposition Stephen Ziff 8 Legare St This project is contrary to the BAR's commitment to protect Charleston's historic resources. Jul 2 2026 1:34PM Joseph R Faraguna 5 Gadsdenboro #306 Charleston SC 29401 Greetings thank you for the opportunity to put my “two cents” in. I’ll give you a little of my background for what it’s worth and to show where I’m coming from. Born in Queens and raised in Brooklyn and I live in Charleston, which is a small version of Brooklyn - waterfront, the ability to walk everywhere, history and culture. History! I graduated West Point and New York University and was a soldier and then an Army Lawyer. I am very much into America. I am fortunate that I was born here. I am fortunate that I live here. Like most I respect our history and our heritage. I find it hard to believe that we’re even having this discussion and that the College Of Charleston of all entities is seeking to interfere with a historic gravesite. Am I missing something? I think that mindset would takeoff and for example, my hometown of New York City has so many ancient graveyards on prime Real Estate. - well maybe we should start ondoing all the grave sites. More profitable $$$. It’s disappointing that some people are trying to “do this” and there’s this underlying attitude and approach toward parts of our culture. Parts that we should respect not denigrate. Leave this graveyard alone and apologize please! Bobby Joe Faraguna (631) 514-5547 Jul 2 2026 2:19PM Isabel Warner Wagner Terrace Reject the request based on the fact that the property would lay on top of a burial ground. Jul 2 2026 2:51PM Nicolas Pasanella 127 Westworth Street I live in a Charleston single on Wentworth and am proud of our neighborhood. This particular design completely and utterly overwhelms the neighborhood and is far too large and dense. I fully support C of C as a valued neighbor but absolutely object to this proposed building. Slowly the "feel" of Charleston is being bitten away bite by bite through enormous non contextual architecture. I am an architect and a developer but this is a bridge too far. I urge you to reject this proposed project Jul 2 2026 3:12PM Jennifer B. 55419 The presence of this burial ground is relevant to the Board’s duty to ensure that new construction is sympathetic to the historic features that characterize the site’s setting and context. The BAR should defer review unless and until it has a more complete understanding of site conditions. This process cannot be rushed given the site’s sanctity. Community-led commemorative projects — from the African Burial Ground in New York City to Contrabands & Freedmen Cemetery in Alexandria, Va. — demonstrate the time and engagement Jul 2 2026 12:53PM Board of Architectural Review – Large 106 Coming Street Page 4 required to do this work responsibly. Laura Isenstein 4 Beaufain St Unit 206 The presence of this burial ground is relevant to the Board’s duty to ensure that new construction is sympathetic to the historic features that characterize the site’s setting and context. The BAR should defer review unless and until it has a more complete understanding of site conditions. This process cannot be rushed given the site’s sanctity. Community-led commemorative projects — from the African Burial Ground in New York City to Contrabands & Freedmen Cemetery in Alexandria, Va. — demonstrate the time and engagement required to do this work responsibly. IT’s time for C OF C to STOP ENCROACHING UPON THE LIVIBILITY OF SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOODS! ENOUGH TOWN AND GOWN! The City MUST SEND A CLEAR MESSAGE NOW! Look for land to DEVELOP A SATELLITE CAMPUS OFF THE PENINSULA! NEXT FIGHT - WENTWORTH GARAGE PROPERTY! Jul 3 2026 9:56AM Ruth Miller 169 Manchester Road What you see is what you remember. What you don't see can be much more important. The past is literally buried by the present. Such is the situation in historic Charleston’s burial grounds. By 1710 the majority of people walking Broad St. were enslaved Africans or African-Americans. Into the 1960s the majority of people walking Calhoun Street were African- Americans. And how do we remember those of our 18th and 19th century city - exploring their graveyards. Charleston has more 18th century burial grounds than any city in America. Yet what is missing? No African-American is buried in any of them. In a city built by black hands with the wealth earned by plantation slaves, only white church members are buried in their cemeteries. Some congregations had more enslaved and free people of color in their balconies than sitting in the pew boxes below, yet nary a one was interred in the churchyard. There is documentation the site at 106 Coming St. holds the remains of thousands. Not just the enslaved, also the remains of the poor, the strangers, folks of any ethnicity, real people who were cast aside at their death by the living society because these people were not "important" enough or rich enough or white enough for our churchyards. The site at 106 Coming St. gives us, today, the opportunity to honor "We the people" who built America. The land should allow nothing but a park established by the living to honor the dead! Jul 3 2026 11:32AM MEREDITH HOFFORD 2 LAURENS ST, CHARLESTON 29401 PLEASE ACKNOWLEDGE, SOMEHOW, THOSE BURIED HERE. PLEASE IMPROVE THE AESTHETICS OF THE BUILDING. Jul 3 2026 12:58PM Board of Architectural Review – Large 106 Coming Street Page 5 Renee Webb 99 King St I respectfully oppose this project and urge the Board to deny conceptual approval. No development should disturb or excavate this historic burial ground. The College of Charleston should pursue an alternative locatio inn or design that preserves the site and honors those buried there. This project is also premature for design review. The archaeological investigation should be completed before any conceptual approval is considered so the site’s full historical significance can guide future decisions. Jul 4 2026 7:43PM James Newhard 8506 William Moultrie Drive, North Charleston, SC 29420 I write to request that the Board defer conceptual approval of the proposed student housing development at 106 Coming Street. I am a Registered Professional Archaeologist with more than 20 years’ professional experience, Vice President of the Charleston Society of the Archaeological Institute of America, Director of the Center for Historical Landscapes, former Director of the Archaeology Program at the College of Charleston, and a member of the College’s Community Engagement Council. I write solely in my individual capacity and not on behalf of the Council, the College, or any other organization. I am not asking BAR-L to assess archaeological methods, the treatment of human remains, or the broader question of whether development should occur on this property. I am asking the Board to exercise its own responsibility over new construction in Charleston’s historic urban fabric. The City’s Charleston Standards provide that new construction should be sympathetic to the historic features that characterize its setting and context and should respect the setting’s size, scale, proportions, and massing. The questions raised by this application – where the building is placed, how development is phased, what spatial hierarchy governs the block, and what physical weight is given to commemoration – therefore fall squarely within BAR-L’s review. The applicant’s own materials establish the extraordinary sensitivity of this setting. Liollio’s submission maps approximately 51,630 square feet of the 64,995-square-foot project site as overlapping the recorded limits of Charleston’s 1790s–1807 municipal burial ground. The applicant’s commissioned historical research further concludes that the Project Area may retain a higher degree of historic integrity than more heavily developed portions of the cemetery. This burial ground received people among the most marginalized by Charleston’s social order: enslaved people, free people of color, people of Indigenous ancestry, the poor, strangers, sailors, orphaned children, and others excluded from more privileged forms of Jul 5 2026 11:13AM Board of Architectural Review – Large 106 Coming Street Page 6 burial. The applicant’s own historical research goes further. BVL concludes that Africans who survived the Middle Passage but died after reaching Charleston – while confined aboard ships or in dockside facilities awaiting sale – were likely interred here. Some reached Charleston alive and died while awaiting sale. Its history, therefore, reaches beyond Charleston into the Atlantic world and the human consequences of the transatlantic slave trade. For a site carrying that history, conceptual approval should follow, not precede, meaningful public testing of the concept. The applicant’s submission points to public meetings in 2025, monthly CEC meetings, a May 2026 CEC presentation, and the June 2 design charrette. But a chronology of meetings is not evidence of substantive consultation on architectural design. Substantial portions of the 2025 meetings focused on whether this project should proceed at all. The architecture now before BAR-L was not their principal subject. Meetings debating on whether to build cannot later be counted as consultation on how to build. Opposition to the project is not design consultation. Nor are monthly CEC meetings equivalent to monthly architectural consultation. The CEC is an advisory body, not a proxy for the broader public or for descendant, tribal, and affiliated communities. At Liollio’s May 2026 presentation, I understood the firm to have treated engagement with the CEC as engagement with community representatives. That assumption is consequential: CEC members bring important knowledge and community relationships, but the Council cannot substitute for direct engagement with the communities connected to this site. The June 2 charrette did not cure that problem. At the June 4 CEC meeting, College representatives explained that notice had been sent to CEC members and to people who had already subscribed for project updates. According to that explanation, notice was not broadly distributed even across the College community. A design charrette promoted principally to an already self-selected audience is targeted outreach, not broad public notice. In my observation, attendance was correspondingly concentrated among people already deeply engaged in the controversy. Liollio’s substantive presentation of architectural and commemorative concepts to the CEC occurred in May 2026. The discussion surfaced unresolved questions about whether quiet contemplation is realistic beside undergraduate housing, whether commemorative space would remain meaningfully accessible to the public, how Board of Architectural Review – Large 106 Coming Street Page 7 Indigenous histories are represented, and whether commemoration can genuinely respond to community concerns when the building program itself is treated as fixed. This is the central process problem. The submission invokes “engagement” to validate design choices that the cited process did not consistently place before the broader public for meaningful consideration. Attendance is not consultation. An advisory council is not the public. Iterations of one preferred scheme are not alternatives. The proposed site planning and phasing raise an even more serious concern. The applicant’s own commissioned historical research documents that this was not an undifferentiated burial ground. An 1801 City ordinance required segregation. A northern section, not exceeding one acre, was reserved for free white persons, strangers, and foreigners; the remainder was assigned to enslaved people and people of color. BVL Historic Preservation Research appropriately identifies the reconstructed location of the partition fence as approximate. Yet BVL also states that the southern section of the property and Project Area served as the final resting place for a substantial number of enslaved individuals. Liollio’s own plans must be read against that history. The submitted site strategy places Phase I predominantly in the southern portion of the parcel while identifying land to the north for “Future Student Housing.” The same submission leaves approximately 13,365 square feet – about one-fifth of the project site – outside the mapped cemetery overlap. That is not proof of improper intent. It is a design choice requiring explanation. The Board need not determine the exact position of an eighteenth- century fence to ask a straightforward design question: what alternative massing and phasing schemes were tested to prioritize development outside the recorded cemetery footprint and reduce early construction pressure on the portion of the burial ground that the applicant’s own research associates with enslaved people, people of color, and African captives who died after reaching Charleston while awaiting sale? Uncertainty about the fence line is not a reason to disregard the cemetery’s documented racial geography. It is a reason to plan more cautiously. Before conceptual approval, the applicant should show what materially different phasing and massing options were evaluated, including options that shift development toward land outside the mapped cemetery overlap. It should explain why those alternatives were accepted or rejected and demonstrate when and how affected Board of Architectural Review – Large 106 Coming Street Page 8 communities were meaningfully engaged in evaluating them. Without that record, the current plan invites an obvious and damaging question: why does Phase I begin predominantly in the section reserved by ordinance for enslaved people and people of color while other land is deferred for future development? That question belongs before conceptual approval, not after it. The proposed commemorative strategy raises a related concern. The Phase I plan labels a principal cemetery-related element the “Ancestral Spine,” organized as a linear passage along the southern edge of the building, together with areas identified as “Healing + Reflection” and a “Mural Wall.” Elsewhere, the presentation invokes historic Charleston alleys as architectural precedents. But typological fit is not the same as commemorative adequacy. An alley can be historically Charlestonian and still be the wrong urban form for this site. This is not an incidental interpretive feature to be fitted around a 608-bed undergraduate residence hall. The burial ground links Charleston’s marginalized dead to the Atlantic slave trade and to a system of coerced labor that generated extraordinary wealth in this city and beyond. Its significance is local, national, and transatlantic. The architecture should give that history spatial weight. A narrow contemplative strip beside undergraduate housing risks turning commemoration into mitigation rather than an organizing principle of the public realm. The relevant question for BAR-L is whether the proposed public realm is proportionate to the historic meaning of the place and whether it provides adequate scale, dignity, public access, visibility, and solemnity. In my view, it does not. When the residence hall organizes the block and the burial ground’s commemoration is fitted around its edge, the spatial hierarchy is backward. I therefore respectfully request deferral until the applicant completes a genuinely design- focused public process, broadly noticed beyond an existing list of project subscribers. That process should test materially different site-planning alternatives, not successive iterations of a preferred scheme, and should document what feedback changed, what was rejected or retained, and why. The applicant should return with a master plan that: 1. meaningfully tests alternative phasing and massing, including options that prioritize land outside the mapped cemetery overlap, 2. accurately distinguishes the CEC’s advisory role from broader public and descendant engagement, and 3. provides commemorative space commensurate with the Board of Architectural Review – Large 106 Coming Street Page 9 magnitude of the site. Deferral would not decide the ultimate fate of the project. It would recognize that these questions are not details to be resolved after the concept is approved. The siting, massing, phasing, circulation, and spatial hierarchy are the concept. This is the moment when meaningful alternatives should be tested. At present, the architecture has moved ahead of the engagement process. On a site carrying this history, that sequence should be corrected before the Board grants conceptual approval. Harlan Greene 32 Chapel Street, Charleston, SC If goals of the BAR are to protect historic resources and to establish amenable design standards, this proposal should not be allowed to proceed in any manner. It is a well-known fact that this is a gravesite of national importance, and any building, no matter its excellence, would be a desecration; the current design is out of scale with its neighbors, and its use is incompatible with the neighborhood -- a quiet residential one, and one were thousands rest. The owner of the property can find other options to build a dormitory and even has a current dormitory site on Calhoun Street that it will demolish and not use as a dorm. While it is beyond the ken of the BAR, members should know that Federal Law about indigenous burials on the site may keep the site under litigation for years. As time passes and budgets expand, it is likely attempts to cost cut and deliver a less felicitous design (hard to imagine a worse one as the current) will develop. As for the design itself, putting a "grab and go" shop balanced between a celebration for the YWCA and a memorial for the dead hardly does service to either goal; and it becomes a crass hodgepodge of intentions, with no architectural merit. The public is highly engaged and incensed and while many do not want a building on the site at all, the real argument is that the current design makes no real concessions to the neighborhood or the site on which it wants to stand. Jul 6 2026 1:18PM Carol Jackson 1461 Patterson Ave Charleston 29412 Please do not approve the submissions you will rule on for any of these 3 scene changing projects--huge in scope, location and purpose. I know there will be plenty of commentators who have the expertise and experience I don't claim. My collective descriptions for each of these inappropriate projects and sites are dishonoring, disruptive and deconstructive to the longstanding architectural values and objectives your Board is pledged to uphold. Thank you. Jul 6 2026 3:50PM Michael Turner 1918 2nd Drive Dear Members of the Board of Architectural Review, I am submitting this formal public comment regarding the proposed student residence hall Jul 6 2026 4:44PM Board of Architectural Review – Large 106 Coming Street Page 10 project at 106 Coming Street, bounded by Calhoun, Coming, and Vanderhorst Streets. My perspective is informed by 23 years of institutional service at the College of Charleston, including serving as the Director of Facilities Planning for eight years. While understanding the institutional need for student housing, I urge the Board to defer conceptual design approval until comprehensive, independent archaeological investigations are finalized, and the site's complete physical and cultural conditions are fully understood. The presence of the 1794–1807 Strangers and Negroes Burial Ground is deeply relevant to this Board’s explicit duty to ensure that new construction is sympathetic to the historic features, setting, and sacred context characterizing a site. Granting early conceptual approval would severely inhibit the community’s ability to guide the interpretation and commemoration that must be the core focus of this property. The following critical factors require the Board’s immediate scrutiny prior to rendering any design decisions: 1. Incomplete Site Diagnostics vs. Spatial Realities Premature Review: Design concepts cannot be evaluated responsibly without completed ground-penetrating radar (GPR) and subsurface archaeological mappings. Subsurface Preservations: While 19th-century residential structures facing Coming and Vanderhorst Streets utilized shallow brick footings or piers extending only 1 to 3 feet deep (largely to avoid the peninsula's high water table), these footprints left the deeper, interior spaces of the block significantly undisturbed. The former backyard zones—now capped by surface parking lots—likely contain heavily intact, layered human remains from the 1794–1807 municipal cemetery. Reviewing structural massing or foundation footprints prior to mapping these intact sectors presents an extreme risk of site desecration. Topographical Disparities: Historical data indicates that the city's segregated municipal practices relegated the remains of enslaved and free people of African descent to the lower, topographically challenged, and marshy sections near the historic Coming’s Creek bed, while saving more stable ground for white "strangers." Designing a building footprint before mapping these distinct sectors compromises the context of the site. 2. Discrepancies in Institutional Planning and Unprecedented Financial Expenditures Record-Breaking Acquisition Costs for an "As-Is" Site: The College of Charleston’s as-is purchase of this approximately 1-acre unimproved parcel for nearly $28 million represents an unprecedented per-acre transaction for the City of Board of Architectural Review – Large 106 Coming Street Page 11 Charleston and the State of South Carolina. Committing a premium, record-setting sum for raw, unremediated real estate—without factoring in the massive development liabilities of an active burial ground—placed an immediate, structural strain on the project's financial validity. A Deviation from State Funding Norms and Taxpayer Subsidy: The revenue source for this property acquisition came from the State of South Carolina’s Capital Reserve Fund. Historically and conventionally, these state- appropriated funds—which are directly comprised of state revenues and fundamentally backed by South Carolina taxpayers—are typically reserved for Education and General (E&G) purposes, such as academic buildings, labs, and capital infrastructure that benefit the entire student body. By South Carolina statutory design, auxiliary operations (including housing, dining, athletics, and parking) are mandated to be self-supporting enterprises funded by their own generated revenues. While the specific wording of the budget proviso legally permitted this particular transaction, using general state capital funds to purchase a premium site means that South Carolina taxpayers indirectly footed the bill for a housing project, bypassing standard fiscal boundaries and shielding the project from the true financial scrutiny a self-supporting auxiliary should face. A Failure of Due Diligence and Negotiation: College administrators have publicly admitted they were fully aware that a centuries-old burial ground surrounded and occupied this site before they finalized the purchase. This raises a critical question for the public record: knowing the extreme historical sensitivities, the massive legal obligations, and the strict requirement that housing projects eventually sustain themselves, why did the college fail to leverage this knowledge during negotiations? No concessions appear to have been made with the developer to perform advance subsurface testing, build in deep cost discounts, or structure site development safeguards into the contract before committing millions in atypical state funds. Unaddressed Operational and Economic Feasibility: Because the land was bought as an unimproved, "as-is" site at a premium market rate, the underlying financial model for the actual housing operation is inherently fragile. A project of this magnitude requires a multi-year, highly complex forensic excavation, advanced bioarchaeological mapping, potential DNA analysis, and individual reinterments. By failing to structure these massive, infrastructure-level archaeological liabilities into the initial purchase model, it remains Board of Architectural Review – Large 106 Coming Street Page 12 completely unverified how the housing auxiliary can legally remain self-supporting while still fulfilling its state-mandated goal of providing affordable student housing. Abrupt Abandonment of the Vetted Capital Roadmap: The College of Charleston's 2023 Campus Framework Plan previously prioritized the development of three smaller, less historically complicated student housing locations: the Lightsey Center Annex, the College Lodge, and the Wentworth Street parking garage. These projects were actively on the design boards, with some already undergoing the formal state approval process. Crucially, the Lightsey Center Annex and College Lodge dormitory projects were situated on existing campus property that was already owned and paid for by the college. Developing these sites would have yielded a vastly superior financial outcome for the institution— delivering a lower per-bed cost overall and maximizing long-term taxpayer and university value, even with a smaller total bed count. The sudden, administrative directive to halt these cost-effective projects to force all effort and capital into a high-risk, premium-priced purchase at 106 Coming Street points to institutional haste rather than sound fiscal or spatial design. 3. Ethical and Socio-Cultural Context Adherence to Commissioned Findings: The College of Charleston’s own commissioned historic reports note a distinct possibility that this potter's field contains the remains of captive individuals brought through Gadsden's Wharf to be sold into slavery. Moving forward with building footprints before these ancestral remains are fully accounted for risks replicating historical patterns of exploiting marginalized populations for administrative or institutional convenience. Impact on the Student Body: Erecting a massive modern facility on an active, sacred burial ground ignores the social and psychological impact on the prospective residents, particularly non-white students who may feel deep discomfort living atop an inadequately preserved ancestral site. A Staring Double Standard in Institutional Precedent: The current rush to clear and develop the Coming Street cemetery stands in direct, unbalanced contrast to the philosophy expressed by the college just two years ago. On October 21, 2024, during a soil collection ceremony at Rivers Green to honor three former African American cemeteries, College of Charleston President Andrew T. Hsu explicitly stated: "Throughout human history, the soil near gravesites and in burial grounds holds deep cultural, spiritual and historical significance... The soil connects us and, quite literally, provides us all Board of Architectural Review – Large 106 Coming Street Page 13 common ground." If the administration genuinely believes that burial soil holds this deep cultural and spiritual significance, that standard must be applied equally here. It creates an unacceptable double standard to perform symbolic ceremonies of reverence on one part of campus while rushing a massive concrete foundation over an active, unmapped burial ground on another. The sanctity of this burial ground demands that we do not rush the process. I respectfully ask that the BAR defer review of this project until the complete scope of the underground remains is scientifically established, ensuring that the final design is shaped by historical reality rather than institutional haste. Respectfully submitted, Michael J. Turner Former Director of Facilities Planning, College of Charleston Charleston, SC Hallie Seibels 34 Rutledge Avenue Do not build a huge dorm on top of a graveyard. I vote no Jul 6 2026 6:16PM Melody Miller 98 Logan St, Charleston, SC 29401 I urge the BAR not to rush to design approval for this project. This is an 18th-century burial ground and should be treated with respect; time should be allowed for archaeological review. Jul 6 2026 8:16AM Larry Musetti 98 Logan St, Charleston Please do not approve. CofC is not a good Charleston citizen. They only have their interests at heart. Worse, CofC is fuzzing the facts, not totally honest or trustworthy. Your approval now would make harder our ability to shape interpretation and commemoration of this historic burial ground. Jul 6 2026 8:37AM Lynn Hanlin 67 Meeting, Charleston SC 29401 It’s premature to act on this request as the archaeologists report is not complete. Such report will aggect the design of new construction .reject the CofC request at this time Jul 6 2026 9:55PM Ellen Waller 1056 Wharf Indigo Place, Mt. Pleasant, SC The CoC does not appear to be a good steward of Charleston. Ignoring the public burial ground on the proposed site in addition to apparently ignoring or disregarding the surrounding neighborhood speaks volumes. Disappointing. Jul 6 2026 10:04PM Jerome Harris 528 Cecilia Cove Dr, Charleston, SC 29412 The proposed Coming Street Commons new construction project is controversial and has stirred strong emotions in broad segments of the community. The approach to secure regulatory approvals for the project without meaningful engagement of descendants and other impacted stakeholders is disturbing to me both as a member of the Protect and Respect the Bodies Coalition and the Community Engagement Council. The community engagement efforts undertaken to date have been more performative than substantive in my opinion. Much remains to be done by the applicant and the owner before conceptual approval is granted by BAR Jul 7 2026 8:38AM Board of Architectural Review – Large 106 Coming Street Page 14 L on the architectural aesthetic elements of this project to answer the question how the design appeals to human senses and how the proposed elements combine to define the structure's visual character, cultural meaning and spatial experience given the history of the site. Prior to granting conceptual approval BAR L should require the applicant and owner to: 1) secure from the City of Charleston approval to remove the site as an abandoned cemetery as requires by SC Code Section 27-43-40 2) secure approval of a Cemetery and Commemoration Plan for the Potter's Field/ Second Official Cemetery reflecting engagement with the descendant community and consultation with SC DES<SHPO<the City of Charleston, stakeholders and other interested parties. I urge BARL to defer this application Amanda Metze 321 Sumter St 106 Coming Street is the final resting place for an estimated 4,600-12,000 immigrants, orphans, and enslaved people that were forcibly brought into the City of Charleston through Gadsden’s Wharf. The purchase of this property and discovery of this burial ground places immense international responsibility in the hands of College of Charleston, the City of Charleston, and the State of South Carolina. I urge the City of Charleston and College of Charleston to rigorously study precedents, such as the New York African Burial Ground, as an appropriate consideration for this site. As public entities, The City and College of Charleston are obligated to consider the magnitude of this project, and to remember the opportunity that they have to offer dignity and memorialization to those buried at 106 Coming Street. Jul 7 2026 11:37AM Emilie Crossan Summerville I respectfully urge the BAR to defer and reconsider the proposed design for 106 Coming Street. The existing one-story mid-century modern structure on this site has significant historical value in its own right, as the location of the first Black YWCA in Charleston and a crucial gathering place for those involved in the Civil Rights Movement. The College should do its due diligence to ensure that all those buried in the cemetery are properly accounted for — not only freed and enslaved Black and Indigenous people, but also the poor, the unknown or “Strangers,” and the orphans from the orphanage across the street, on whose site the College has also built a dorm. The last enslaved Africans to enter the city through its ports, before the end of the Transatlantic Slave Trade in 1807, were likely buried here. Beyond the broader ethical concerns, the proposed work on the site does not sufficiently Jul 7 2026 11:42AM Board of Architectural Review – Large 106 Coming Street Page 15 honor the estimated 4,000 to 12,000 people buried in the cemetery. If the disturbance of the burial ground cannot be reversed, I urge the BAR to do everything in its power to require the College to develop a design that meaningfully reflects and honors the historic and sacred nature of this site, drawing on precedents such as the African Burial Ground National Monument in New York City. Brittany Lsvelle Tulla 231 King Street, Charleston, SC 29401 It is imperative that the BAR defer this request until we have fully archeologically evaluated this burial ground. This site is of international importance, and this project requires utmost professional and civic due diligence. Jul 7 2026 11:55AM CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – LARGE 989 Morrison Drive BAR2026-002706 | TMS #4590101001 | East Central | Council District 4 New Construction | Height District 4-12 | Historic Corridor District Requesting Conceptual Approval of a new multi-family building. Owner: Scott Fuller (representative) Applicant: Brad Brown CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – LARGE 989 Morrison Drive 18 Comments Submitted 3 in Support | 15 in Opposition First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted 3 Comments in Support Justin Moffitt 29403 This is a well designed building that fits the intent of its zoning district (Upper Peninsula). The city specifically selected this area of the peninsula to have higher density. This fits the area and is significantly better than what is on the parcel now. Jul 2 2026 3:30PM Pat DeMarco 1430 Brian Road, Charleston, SC 29407 Upon review of the overall trade-offs of this project, I believe it to be a net positive for the city and should be approved as-is and without delay. - Thanks to this project's relatively isolated site, the height shouldn't cause any problems for immediate neighbors. - This also is not a historic or low-density area, and there are similar-size projects very close to the site. - It would be ideal to have ground-level retail and pedestrian activity. Perhaps this project could have retail/restaurant amenities available on an elevated floor via stairs/ramp. But this is less important than 1) providing urgently-needed rental housing, and 2) ensuring that the site is flood- resilient. - Yes, the tidal and environmental concerns are important. We should ensure this project provides adequate buffers for wetlands, and that its landscaping includes native vegetation, pollinator plants, and wetlands-appropriate grounds that drain well and can support marsh-dwelling creatures. We as a city have two paths forward: continue to freeze the peninsula into a museum for wealthy people and tourists, or allow it to be a dynamic city that works for all demographics. It would be great if nothing had to change, but that isn't possible. This overall is a worthy project for the city. Jul 2 2026 12:43PM Jessica Smith 5106 West Dolphin St. North Charleston, SC 29405 I'm writing today to voice my support for the proposed building at 989 Morrison Drive. Unlike the previous design, this design does not impact Newmarket Creek. It also satisfies multiple incentives from the Upper Peninsula District, including: workforce housing, decreasing stormwater runoff and impervious surfaces, exceptional bicycle parking and facilities, and the obtainment of a green building certification. This building would be a win for the city of Charleston and I hope you will support it! Jul 6 2026 10:42AM Board of Architectural Review – Large 989 Morrison Drive Page 2 15 Comments in Opposition Stephen Ziff 8 Legare St The proposed height and scale is overwhelming. Jul 2 2026 1:38PM Constance Baldwin 1 Bishop Gadsden Way, Apt. 211; Charleston, SC 29412 The proposed building at 12 stories is too tall and much too large for the site. In addition. the dark color and strange "screening" which overlays the windows bears no reference to Charleston architecture of any period. What is the most puzzling is that PS3P is a local firm and should have produced a much smaller, significantly better design for that location and for our city. Jul 2 2026 2:34PM Isabel Warner Wagener Terrace Deny request due to continues building of these large scale projects that end io having multiple structural issues and mold issues. These issues go unanswered at other buildings. We don't need more. Jul 2 2026 2:52PM Lesa Watts 947 White Point Court A 12-story apartment building In a flood zone and built on a tidal creek- No, please don’t approve this proposal. The scale and size of this project are so far off the mark for what Charleston residents want to see being constructed here. The size of this building alone is so out of character for our city. Not to mention the additional cars and traffic potentially added to an already very high traffic area. Jul 2 2026 4:54PM Howard Taylor 979 Lakeview Dr. Too large a footprint, too tall, too much. Jul 2 2026 12:40PM Anna Brigid Creason 10 9th avenue Charleston, sc 29403 YIKES, the scale alone of this project overwhelms the area. Not to mention having to raise the ground floor due to the tidal creek it would sit on. This will end up being a pain for residents of the building and the community. Have we learned nothing from Atlantic on Romney? The only benefit is to the developers bank account. Jul 2 2026 12:48PM Jennifer B. 55419 The proposed height, scale, and mass overwhelm the site and its context. 12 stories significantly exceeds nearby building heights, and the footprint fills the site with insufficient articulation to reduce perceived mass. The architectural expression — particularly window scale and patterning — is unnecessarily complicated. Jul 2 2026 12:54PM MEREDITH HOFFORD 2 LAURENS ST, CHARLESTON, 29401 How is it that ANY development was approved for this site?! much less something of this scale. Please preserve the Newmarket Creek as much as possible. The population density of this area of the Peninsula is TOO MUCH. This building is too large and too high. Jul 3 2026 1:06PM Renee Webb 99 King St The proposed building’s height, scale, and overall mass are out of proportion with the surrounding area and overwhelm both the site and its context. 2. At 12 stories, the building is substantially taller than neighboring structures, and its expansive footprint occupies most of the site with too little architectural Jul 4 2026 7:30PM Board of Architectural Review – Large 989 Morrison Drive Page 3 articulation to lessen its visual bulk. Harlan Greene 32 Chapel Street, Charleston, SC While the architectural design seems massive for the site and with flood levels restricting use of the ground level, this plan, as presented, seems to negate the spirit of this neighborhood, and seems to continue the idea of creating towers that disconnect residents from their neighborhoods, require more cars, and appeal to non residents ... This then seems to defy local attempts to curb tourism and to deal with possible flooding. Destroying on the last tidal creeks in the area, and piling more people into a vulnerable spot does not seem to be a wise move for our city. Jul 6 2026 1:27PM Joe McGee 1 Magazine Street The proposed height, scale, and mass overwhelm the site and its context. 12 stories significantly exceeds nearby building heights, and the footprint fills the site with insufficient articulation to reduce perceived mass. The architectural expression is very unappealing, not sympathetic to nearby properties. The appropriate denial of ground floor waiver, complicated by flood zone and FEMA requirements seem to not favor of this scale of development. Cannot the future of the neck be more appropriately designed and human-scale? Jul 6 2026 5:15PM Blake Scott 211 Gordon St. Dear Board Members, Please protect the historical, cultural, and environmental heritage of the peninsula of Charleston and deny this current request at 989 Morrison. The property is historically part of Newmarket Creek, and is highly flood prone. The builders should give more space - a wider vegetative buffer - for what remains of the marsh. They are trying to maximize profit, via building square footage, at the expense of the rest of us, downstream. Have your building, but give some space back to the marsh and nature. In the long run, it will add value to all of our properties and the community can still experience a healthy tidal creek and greenspace downtown. Jul 6 2026 6:58PM Larry Musetti 98 Logan St, Charleston FEMA’s requirements will restrict pedestrian activity at this massive complex. It violates everything I view as Charleston. The proposed height, scale, and mass overwhelm the site and its context. Jul 6 2026 8:50AM Lynn Hanlin 67 Meeting, Charleston SC 29401 The scale, mass, height overwhelm the surrounding buildings. Additionally, the property is located in a flood zone which should take priority over whatever is built. Jul 6 2026 10:05PM Carol Jackson 1461 Patterson Ave Charleston 29412 Please do not approve the submissions you will rule on for any of these 3 scene changing projects--huge in scope, location and purpose. I know there will be plenty of commentators who have the expertise and experience I don't claim. My collective descriptions Jul 6 2026 3:50PM Board of Architectural Review – Large 989 Morrison Drive Page 4 for each of these inappropriate projects and sites are dishonoring, disruptive and deconstructive to the longstanding architectural values and objectives your Board is pledged to uphold. Thank you. CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – LARGE 48 & 52 Line Street BAR2026-002700 | TMS #4590503136, 4590503139 Cannonborough/Elliottborough | Council District 8 | New Construction Height District 8 | Old and Historic District Requesting Revision to Conceptual Approval and Preliminary Approval of two (2) mixed-use buildings. Owner: LL East LLC Applicant: Kevin Smith (Robert A.M. Stern Architects) CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – LARGE 48 & 52 Line Street 7 Comments Submitted First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted Stephen Ziff 8 Legare St The redesign is cheapened and should be rejected. Developer just wants to turn a getter profit at citizens' expense. Jul 2 2026 1:44PM Isabel Warner Wagener Terrace Deny the request. Put in a park considering the building just went up at the top of king and line which is going to create incredible congestion issues but there have been no road infrastructure ideas made to make sure the area is moving as smooth as it should. Keep the historical charm of Charleston…. Our charm is disappearing. Jul 2 2026 2:54PM Jennifer B. 55419 Reduced architectural detailing across both buildings diminishes overall quality and compatibility with the surrounding district. Revised massing is more boxy and less responsive to its context. These changes represent a step backward; strong design standards should be upheld given the project’s impact on the streetscape and skyline. Jul 2 2026 12:55PM MEREDITH HOFFORD 1 LAURENS ST, CHARLESTON 29401 Please do not approve these proposed changes. The original design is MUCH better. Stick with it. Do not reward or encourage this "bait and switch" tactic. Jul 3 2026 1:10PM Larry Musetti 98 Logan St, Charleston This project should not allow the delays any longer. Please do not approve changes now after so many years of mistakes that diminishes overall quality of these historic buildings. It’s backward and will harm this the character of this historic Charleston neighborhood. Jul 6 2026 9:02AM Lynn Hanlin 67 Meeting , Charleston SC 29401 Reject this new plan as it significantly departs from the approved plan from 2018, a plan which included significant input from steak holders, preservation groups . Jul 6 2026 10:18PM Carol Jackson 1461 Patterson Ave Charleston 29412 Please do not approve the submissions you will rule on for any of these 3 scene changing projects- -huge in scope, location and purpose. I know there will be plenty of commentators who have the expertise and experience I don't claim. My collective descriptions for each of these inappropriate projects and sites are dishonoring, disruptive and deconstructive to the longstanding architectural values and objectives your Board is pledged to uphold. Thank you. Jul 6 2026 3:50PM CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – LARGE 251 King Street BAR2026-002690 | TMS #4570801052 | Downtown | Council District 4 Category 2 | c. 1880’s | Height Districts 3, 6 | Old and Historic District Requesting Conceptual Approval of exterior alterations and illuminated signage. Owner: Peter Demetre Applicant: Bill Marshall Gt?attv Ervix fie Co. Classic Clothiers To Gentlemen June 12, 2026 To: Cityof Charleston BAR RE: M.P.Demetre Improvements to 251 King St. To Whom it may concern: My name is Chip Ervln. I am the business and building owner at 313 King St./Grady Ervin & Company for over 30 years. I am writing in support of M.R Demetre Improvements to 251 King St. This is a huge win for the City of Charleston and the Historic King Street shopping district! This local building owner is doing great things with the preservation and improvement to this property! The plans for a Future Rolex High End Boutique built to a very high finish and standard! Good for all retail on King St. with the fact that the owner is Peter Demetre along with the Gold standard of Retailer's and world class watch maker. The repairs to the building interior and facade will be second to none based on the stewardship of the other Demetre buildings that front King St. this too is very exciting for the city and the most Historic Street in SC. Not many property owners are willing to make such a large financial investment to pass on to future generations. Many thanks in advance for your consideration. Chip Ervin 313 King Street Charleston, SC 29401 4- Ph: 843-722-1776 4> Fax: 843-722-1708 BEEMOK HOSPITALITY COLLECTION 200 Meeting Street, Ste 11 Charleston, SO 29401 BHC.COM 30 June 2026 Dear B.A.R. Members, We are pleased to offer our support for Demetre Jewelers' proposed plans for the 251 King Street Rolex Project. Having reviewed the images of the boutique, we believe the exterior and interior elements are compatible with the historic district's guidelines and would be a welcome improvement to the streetscape we share. As a neighboring business, we welcome this common investment to the city's namesake street and encourage the Board's favorable consideration. Sincerely, Casey Lavin President Beemok Hospitality Collection 7/1/26, 4:47 PM Fw: 251 King - Bill Marshall - Outlook about:blank Outlook Fw: 251 King From Bill Marshall Date Wed 7/1/2026 4:46 PM To Bill Marshall From: Kate Dutilly Sent: Thursday, June 18, 2026 5:30 PM To: Bill Marshall Subject: Re: 251 King Hi Bill, April forwarded me the drawings you sent over regarding 251 King. I just took a closer look and as I think we discussed when we met, we do not have any concerns/questions at the moment. We look forward to seeing the project move forward! Thanks, Kate Dutilly Preservation Planner Historic Charleston Foundation 40 East Bay Street, Charleston, SC 29401 1/4 7/1/26, 4:49 PM lnbox - Bill Marshall - Outlook Outlook Re: Rolex BAR_S set From Flannery Antinoro Date Wed 6/17/2026 4:54 PM To Bill Marshall; Laurel Fay Hi Bill, We took another look at the plans and have no questions or concerns about the project. Thank you again for taking the time to meet with us. Please let me know if you have any questions. Best, Flannery Antinoro Preservation Specialist PRESERVATION SOCIETY OF CHARLESTON 14 7 King Street Charleston, South Carolina 29401 0: 843. 722.4630 ext. 125 12reservationsocie(Y..org From: Flannery Antinoro Date: Wednesday, June 10, 2026 at 5:00 PM https://outlook.cloud .microsoft/mail/id/AAQkADU0Yzl2ZDU0L TkzZWMtNDIIMS04MmJmL Tk5YjU 1 ZmQ 1 ODExYQAQAJcsWpLGqBplleaEYIQVikw%3D 1 /3 CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – LARGE 134 Saint Philip Street BAR2026-002672 | TMS #4601202038 | Radcliffeborough | Council District 4 Category 3 | c. 1887 | Height Districts 2.5-3, 4 | Old City District Requesting Final Approval of an exterior lighting package. Owner: Father Johnbosco Ikemeh (St. Patrick Catholic Church) Applicant: David Hill (Innova Architecture) Position Statement Board of Architectural Review - Large July 8, 2026 134 St. Philip Street Dear Board Members: The Preservation Society of Charleston commends the St. Patrick's congregation for its dedicated stewardship of this important historic church. We were honored to highlight their preservation efforts during Preservation Month and look forward to seeing the broader restoration project come to fruition. While we are not opposed to uplighting this building, we encourage the applicant to minimize the proposal’s visual and physical impact on the historic exterior to the greatest extent possible. Specifically, we recommend reducing the amount of visible conduit as well as the scale and prominence of the proposed light fixtures. We encourage the applicant to work with staff to pursue a simpler, more discreet lighting design that achieves the project goals while remaining sensitive to the character of the historic building. Sincerely, Anna-Catherine Alexander Director of Advocacy Initiatives

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.