RecordWell Data

DRB Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Jul 6, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON DESIGN REVIEW BOARD PUBLIC COMMENT JULY 6, 2026 A meeting of the Design Review Board (DRB) will be held on Monday, July 6, 2026 at 4:30 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street. The following written comments will be provided to the board members on the deadline date and also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/drb. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 A. APPLICATIONS 1. 1798 Ashley River Rd. West Ashley | Council District 9 | TMS# 351-07-00-002 | DRB2026-000355 Requesting approval of staff denial of a sign package that uses gradient colors for their signage. Owner: Jupiter Holdings Applicant: Kimberly Hunt/Supreme Sign Services. No Comments Submitted 2. 3041, 3025, 3015 Reva Ridge Dr. Johns Island | Council District 3 | TMS# 313-00-00-584, 585 | DRB2026-000357 Requesting conceptual approval for three new 3-story multi-family buildings. Owner: Crowne at Live Oak Sq. Phase 2 Applicant: Spencer Plowden 1 Comment Submitted: • Michelle Robbins, 1508 Roustabout Way, Charleston, SC 29414 Submitted to Innovate Site on July 5, 2026 11:24 AM We strongly oppose further approvals for multifamily apartments, housing developments, drive-through fast food, storage units, car washes, gas stations, and similar high-impact projects in West Ashley. Our roads are already overwhelmed, and thousands of apartments and homes have recently been built, approved, or are planned near Bees Ferry and Glenn McConnell. Residents have repeatedly voiced concerns, yet development continues to move forward despite clear community opposition. West Ashley needs a moratorium on additional multifamily housing until traffic infrastructure, drainage, public safety, and quality-of-life impacts are properly addressed. Continued overdevelopment is destroying the wooded landscape, displacing wildlife, and pushing animals into neighborhoods where they increasingly pose risks to pets and residents. Instead of more apartments and low-value commercial development, the community needs thoughtful restaurants, local retail, Design Review Board Public Comment | July 6, 2026 Page 2 outdoor gathering spaces, and entertainment that enhance West Ashley without erasing the natural character that makes it special. Protect what remains before it is gone. 3. 3930 West Ashley Circle West Ashley | Council District 5 | TMS# 301-00-00-819, 469 | DRB2026-000356 Requesting preliminary approval for a single-story shell retail building. Owner: Bees Wedge, LLC Applicant: LFK Architects, LLC 1 Comment Submitted: • Michelle Robbins, 1508 Roustabout Way, Charleston, SC 29414 Submitted to Innovate Site on July 5, 2026 11:27 AM We strongly oppose further approvals for storage units, car washes, gas stations, and similar high-impact projects in West Ashley. Residents have repeatedly voiced concerns, yet development continues to move forward despite clear community opposition. West Ashley needs a moratorium on additional multifamily housing until traffic infrastructure, drainage, public safety, and quality-of-life impacts are properly addressed. Continued overdevelopment is destroying the wooded landscape, displacing wildlife, and pushing animals into neighborhoods where they increasingly pose risks to pets and residents. Instead of more apartments and low-value commercial development, the community needs thoughtful restaurants, local retail, outdoor gathering spaces, and entertainment that enhance West Ashley without erasing the natural character that makes it special. Protect what remains before it is gone. 4. 2110 Ashepoo Ln. UP | Council District 4 | TMS# 464-06-00-011 | DRB2026-000362 Requesting Preliminary approval for a new 4-story storage building. Owner: JEAL-K Associates LLC Applicant: SeamonWhiteside and Assoc 1 Comment Submitted: • Michelle Robbins, 1508 Roustabout Way, Charleston, SC 29414 Submitted to Innovate Site on July 5, 2026 11:29 AM We strongly oppose further approvals for multifamily apartments, housing developments, drive-through fast food, storage units, car washes, gas stations, and similar high-impact projects in West Ashley. Instead of low-value commercial development, the community needs thoughtful restaurants, local retail, outdoor gathering spaces, and entertainment that enhance West Ashley without erasing the natural character that makes it special. Protect what remains before it is gone. Design Review Board Public Comment | July 6, 2026 Page 3 5. 3943 West Ashley Circle West Ashley | Council District 5 | TMS# 301-00-00-469 | DRB2026-000360 Requesting preliminary approval for a new 1-story McDonalds. Owner: Whitefield Construction Co Applicant: McDonalds USA LLC 2 Comments Submitted: • Michelle Robbins, 1508 Roustabout Way, Charleston, SC 29414 Submitted to Innovate Site on July 5, 2026 11:33 AM We strongly oppose further approvals for drive-through fast food, storage units, car washes, gas stations, and similar high-impact projects in West Ashley. Instead of low- value commercial development, the community needs thoughtful restaurants, local retail, outdoor gathering spaces, and entertainment that enhance West Ashley without erasing the natural character that makes it special. Protect what remains before it is gone. • Loretta Silecchia, 402 Blue Jasmine Ln, Charleston 29414 Submitted to Innovate Site on July 5, 2026 3:50 PM our neighborhood does not need another McDonalds restaurant.There is a McDonalds across the street in Walmart.There is too much traffic in the area because of all the apartments that were built nearby. Fast food such as McDonalds will lower our quality of life.We need small franchise or mom and pop restaurants 6. Grand Oaks, just NW of W. Ashley Circle West Ashley | Council District 10 | TMS# 301-00-00-052 | DRB2026-000361 Requesting conceptual approval for a new multi-family community with seven 4-story buildings containing 348 units, 33 townhomes, 6 detached garages and a clubhouse. Owner: Middleburg Communities Applicant: Mark Ward First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted Pamela Wike 793 Bent Hickory Road I am opposed to the site design and architecture of the buildings. The site design has "future city roadway" and "future Long Savannah Pkwy", when are these roadways being constructed? I'm assuming after the construction is done and the contractor is long gone. So, then residents will pressure the Mayor and City Council to do something in reverse, just doesn't make sense. Infrastructure first then development. The design also has two ponds to send all the flooding/stormwater too. Why can't nature based solutions be used by the engineering firm to save more trees in/around the pond and beyond? Take a look at the pond right down the street that has a couple trees that have thrived for years growing in the ponds. The 25' landscape buffer along Grand Oaks Boulevard doesn't make sense. Why not put the Long Savannah Road 50' landscape buffer on the Grand Oaks Boulevard side? Push the whole plan slightly and the residents get 25 more feet of wooded scenery. The Long Savannah Road stretch has Jul 1 2026 3:23PM Design Review Board Public Comment | July 6, 2026 Page 4 no people living there, the buffers just don't make sense. The 15' landscape buffer for the "future city road" will not provide adequate shade for Building #4 when the sun is setting. Finally, on the plan there's the tree preserve areas, I think the engineering firm could design this better to save more "already there" trees. Kathryn Wilson 225 Brambling Lane, Charleston, SC 29414 Dear DR Board: I’d like to express my strong disapproval of the proposed height for the apartments of the planned development at Grand Oaks. The current design calls for seven (!), four- story apartment buildings. This new development sits at the entrance to Grand Oaks setting the first impression of our neighborhood! All of the existing apartment buildings in Grand Oaks – Proximity, The Atlantic, The Enclave and Bees Ferry – have no more than three stories. Please – as you do for the downtown peninsula - have some respect for the existing neighborhood of Grand Oaks and keep with what is already here. Go view the other apartments here to see how they blend with the single family home sub-divisions. To approve the developers’ current design would show that the DRB has complete disregard for the character and beauty of ALL our neighborhoods. Do not allow the new apartments to be more than three stories tall! I hope the Board will agree and deny approval of the current design. Thank you. Jul 4 2026 5:21PM Loretta Silecchia 402 Blue Jasmine Ln,Charleston 29414 There are too many apartments and townhomes already in my neighborhood. Our quality of life has already been affected by all the extra population and traffic. my neighborhood is already being impacted by all the fumes from the traffic. it takes several lights to get out of grand oaks blvd during non rush hours. we time our trips in the community to try to avoid traffic but there is always traffic. I moved down here to escape traffic and the concrete jungle. Apartments eventually will destabilize our neighborhood. Build homes that young people can afford not apartments, we have more than enough here. Jul 5 2026 4:06PM Erin Lawhorn 1500 parklawn drive Dear Members of the Design Review Board,As a concerned cofounder of the Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance regarding the upcoming multi-family and townhome development at Grand Oaks Boulevard, I request that the Board mandate stringent architectural, site layout, and landscaping conditions to protect our historic canopy and combat localized flooding.I respectfully ask the DRB to incorporate the following requirements into any conceptual or preliminary approvals:1. Resilient & Native Canopy Planting SpecificationsNative Live Oaks (Quercus virginiana): Request that all mitigation canopy trees along the streetscape and key buffers prioritize native Live Oaks to maintain the historic character of the West Ashley canopy.Flood-Tolerant Species: Given the region's intense stormwater challenges, require the integration of highly flood-tolerant native and adapted species, specifically Jul 5 2026 10:59PM Design Review Board Public Comment | July 6, 2026 Page 5 requesting the inclusion of Dawn Redwood (Metasequoia glyptostroboides) in low-lying bio-retention cells and drainage buffers.2. Best Industry Standard Specs for Grand Tree ProtectionTo ensure that retained grand trees survive construction stressors, the developer must adhere to strict, enforceable tree protection standards before, during, and after construction:Critical Root Zone (CRZ) / Drip Line Protection: Erect rigid, chain-link tree protection barricades at the full radius of the tree’s drip line (or 1 foot of radius per 1 inch of tree diameter, whichever is greater) before any equipment arrives on site. Barricades must remain completely undisturbed through final inspection.Mandatory Hand Digging: Prohibit heavy machinery within the drip line or CRZ. Any mandatory utility trenching or grading within these zones must be executed exclusively via hand-digging or pneumatic air- spading to prevent root shearing.Color-Sensitive Plan Zones: Require all civil, architectural, and grading plans to utilize specialized, highly visible color-coded "Tree Protection Zones" (TPZs) so contractors can easily identify zero-tolerance boundaries.3. Tree-Forward Site Layout and Architectural DesignClustered & Grouped Parking: Reject standard, monolithic grid parking layouts that force the clear-cutting of grand trees. Require clustered or grouped parking configurations that pocket vehicles around existing root systems.Curved Infrastructure: Mandate the use of curved parking lot drives, meandering sidewalks, and curved building footprints. Aligning the architecture to bend naturally around grand trees dynamically minimizes root impacts and enhances the aesthetic value of the development.Thank you for your rigorous review and continued dedication to protecting West Ashley's environmental assets. Michelle Robbins 1508 Roustabout Way, Charleston, SC 29414 We strongly oppose further approvals for multifamily apartments, housing developments, drive-through fast food, storage units, car washes, gas stations, and similar high-impact projects in West Ashley. Our roads are already overwhelmed, and thousands of apartments and homes have recently been built, approved, or are planned near Bees Ferry and Glenn McConnell. Residents have repeatedly voiced concerns, yet development continues to move forward despite clear community opposition. West Ashley needs a moratorium on additional multifamily housing until traffic infrastructure, drainage, public safety, and quality-of-life impacts are properly addressed. Continued overdevelopment is destroying the wooded landscape, displacing wildlife, and pushing animals into neighborhoods where they increasingly pose risks to pets and residents. Instead of more apartments and low-value commercial development, the community needs thoughtful restaurants, local retail, outdoor gathering spaces, and entertainment that enhance West Ashley without erasing Jul 5 2026 11:34AM Design Review Board Public Comment | July 6, 2026 Page 6 the natural character that makes it special. Protect what remains before it is gone. Nancy Huber 337 Weeping Willow Way How in the world can you all approve this design? Our beautiful entrance will be taken away. All the wild life will be removed of tgeir habitat. No way do we need 7 - 4 story apartments much less any apartments. The traffic now is ridiculous much less adding 1000s of more cars. I beg you to vote no on this construction. Jul 5 2026 11:39AM Pamela Ingram 1036 Tyron Circle, Charleston, SC 29414 The scale is still too large. Not only do we not have any 4- story buildings in the neighborhood, this is at the front of the neighborhood, where we have just 1 and 2-story single family residences. The building height should be no more than 2-stories. Trees-any removed trees should be replaced with trees that have more storm resistance and flood control features (grand oaks, bald cypress, weeping willow, etc NOT crepe myrtles, etc). Also, they need to provide more understory vegetation. Close the entrance/exit onto Grand Oaks Blvd. They claim this is needed as an emergency exit and that they do not know for certain that Long Savanna Pkwy will be built so they can’t count that as an exit. Long Savanna Pkwy is a definite. They have already clear cut behind Grand Oaks and neighborhood roads for Long Savanna. I have seen crews out at the site of the future parkway many times. Certainly this can be confirmed for them. Make sure the views of backs of buildings/utilities/garages that back up to Grand Oaks Blvd. are masked as much as possible with vegetation Jul 5 2026 12:19PM David Quick 1502 Village Square Dear Members of the Design Review Board, As a concerned member of the Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance regarding the upcoming multi-family and townhome development at Grand Oaks Boulevard, I request that the Board mandate stringent architectural, site layout, and landscaping conditions to protect our historic canopy and combat localized flooding. I respectfully ask the DRB to incorporate the following requirements into any conceptual or preliminary approvals: 1. Resilient & Native Canopy Planting Specifications •Native Live Oaks (Quercus virginiana): Request that all mitigation canopy trees along the streetscape and key buffers prioritize native Live Oaks to maintain the historic character of the West Ashley canopy. •Flood-Tolerant Species: Given the region's intense stormwater challenges, require the integration of highly flood-tolerant native and adapted species, specifically requesting the inclusion of Dawn Redwood (Metasequoia glyptostroboides) in low-lying bio- retention cells and drainage buffers. 2. Best Industry Standard Specs for Grand Tree Protection To ensure that retained grand trees survive construction stressors, the developer must adhere to strict, enforceable tree protection standards before, during, and after construction: [1] •Critical Root Zone (CRZ) / Drip Line Protection: Erect Jul 6 2026 8:15AM Design Review Board Public Comment | July 6, 2026 Page 7 rigid, chain-link tree protection barricades at the full radius of the tree’s drip line (or 1 foot of radius per 1 inch of tree diameter, whichever is greater) before any equipment arrives on site. Barricades must remain completely undisturbed through final inspection. [1, 2, 3, 4] •Mandatory Hand Digging: Prohibit heavy machinery within the drip line or CRZ. Any mandatory utility trenching or grading within these zones must be executed exclusively via hand-digging or pneumatic air-spading to prevent root shearing. [1] •Color-Sensitive Plan Zones: Require all civil, architectural, and grading plans to utilize specialized, highly visible color-coded "Tree Protection Zones" (TPZs) so contractors can easily identify zero-tolerance boundaries. 3. Tree-Forward Site Layout and Architectural Design •Clustered & Grouped Parking: Reject standard, monolithic grid parking layouts that force the clear-cutting of grand trees. Require clustered or grouped parking configurations that pocket vehicles around existing root systems. [1] •Curved Infrastructure: Mandate the use of curved parking lot drives, meandering sidewalks, and curved building footprints. Aligning the architecture to bend naturally around grand trees dynamically minimizes root impacts and enhances the aesthetic value of the development. Thank you for your rigorous review and continued dedication to protecting West Ashley's environmental assets. Sincerely, David Quick Leah Low 2753 garden creek rd chas sc 29414 Why are we approving more apartments and more of our grand live oaks to be cut down We have enough apartments currently being built and that we’re just built on beesferry. With long savanna coming yall are going to make this side of west Ashley an absolute nightmare. 1 live oak holds up to 100,000 gallons of water 1 acre of wet lands hold up to 1 million gallons of water, so respectfully why do yall keep prioritizing new comers and developers over what makes Charleston beautiful and the locals who have been here our entire lives? Most decisions yall make are in areas where NONE OF YOU even travel through. Quit failing true Charlestonians & quit over developing our home. Do yall sit in this traffic?? It’s absolutely miserable every damn day!! Yall need to start thinking about people who have been here for generations being taxed out and pushed out!! Please STOP CUTTING DOWN OUR LIVE OAKS!! It tooks hundreds of years for them to get the size they are, your saplings u have developers plant will never EVER amount to the live oaks we have today and it won’t ever come back not in our lifetime Quit destroying Charleston Blood is on yalls hands. Jul 6 2026 8:50AM Anna Skerkavich 220 WATER LOTUS DR CHARLESTON SC 29414 Dear Members of the Design Review Board, As a concerned member of the Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance regarding the upcoming multi-family and townhome development at Grand Oaks Boulevard, I request that the Board mandate stringent architectural, site Jul 6 2026 9:56AM Design Review Board Public Comment | July 6, 2026 Page 8 layout, and landscaping conditions to protect our historic canopy and combat localized flooding. I respectfully ask the DRB to incorporate the following requirements into any conceptual or preliminary approvals: Specifications •Native Live Oaks (Quercus virginiana): Request that all mitigation canopy trees along the streetscape and key buffers prioritize native Live Oaks to maintain the historic character of the West Ashley canopy. •Flood-Tolerant Species: Given the region's intense stormwater challenges, require the integration of highly flood-tolerant native and adapted species, specifically requesting the inclusion of Dawn Redwood (Metasequoia glyptostroboides) in low- lying bio-retention cells and drainage buffers. 2. Best Industry Standard Specs for Grand Tree Protection To ensure that retained grand trees survive construction stressors, the developer must adhere to strict, enforceable tree protection standards before, during, and after construction: [1] •Critical Root Zone (CRZ) / Drip Line Protection: Erect rigid, chain-link tree protection barricades at the full radius of the tree’s drip line (or 1 foot of radius per 1 inch of tree diameter, whichever is greater) before any equipment arrives on site. Barricades must remain completely undisturbed through final inspection. [1, 2, 3, 4] •Mandatory Hand Digging: Prohibit heavy machinery within the drip line or CRZ. Any mandatory utility trenching or grading within these zones must be executed exclusively via hand-digging or pneumatic air-spading to prevent root shearing. [1] •Color-Sensitive Plan Zones: Require all civil, architectural, and grading plans to utilize specialized, highly visible color-coded "Tree Protection Zones" (TPZs) so contractors can easily identify zero-tolerance boundaries. 3. Tree-Forward Site Layout and Architectural Design •Clustered & Grouped Parking: Reject standard, monolithic grid parking layouts that force the clear-cutting of grand trees. Require clustered or grouped parking configurations that pocket vehicles around existing root systems. [1] •Curved Infrastructure: Mandate the use of curved parking lot drives, meandering sidewalks, and curved building footprints. Aligning the architecture to bend naturally around grand trees dynamically minimizes root impacts and enhances the aesthetic value of the development. Thank you for your rigorous review and continued dedication to protecting West Ashley's environmental assets. Sincerely, Anna M Skerkavich David Skerkavich 220 WATER LOTUS DR CHARLESTON SC 29414 Dear Members of the Design Review Board, As a concerned member of the Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance regarding the upcoming multi-family and townhome development at Grand Oaks Boulevard, I request that the Board mandate stringent architectural, site layout, and landscaping conditions to protect our historic canopy and combat localized flooding. I respectfully ask the DRB to incorporate the following requirements into any Jul 6 2026 10:00AM Design Review Board Public Comment | July 6, 2026 Page 9 conceptual or preliminary approvals: Specifications •Native Live Oaks (Quercus virginiana): Request that all mitigation canopy trees along the streetscape and key buffers prioritize native Live Oaks to maintain the historic character of the West Ashley canopy. •Flood-Tolerant Species: Given the region's intense stormwater challenges, require the integration of highly flood-tolerant native and adapted species, specifically requesting the inclusion of Dawn Redwood (Metasequoia glyptostroboides) in low- lying bio-retention cells and drainage buffers. 2. Best Industry Standard Specs for Grand Tree Protection To ensure that retained grand trees survive construction stressors, the developer must adhere to strict, enforceable tree protection standards before, during, and after construction: [1] •Critical Root Zone (CRZ) / Drip Line Protection: Erect rigid, chain-link tree protection barricades at the full radius of the tree’s drip line (or 1 foot of radius per 1 inch of tree diameter, whichever is greater) before any equipment arrives on site. Barricades must remain completely undisturbed through final inspection. [1, 2, 3, 4] •Mandatory Hand Digging: Prohibit heavy machinery within the drip line or CRZ. Any mandatory utility trenching or grading within these zones must be executed exclusively via hand-digging or pneumatic air-spading to prevent root shearing. [1] •Color-Sensitive Plan Zones: Require all civil, architectural, and grading plans to utilize specialized, highly visible color-coded "Tree Protection Zones" (TPZs) so contractors can easily identify zero-tolerance boundaries. 3. Tree-Forward Site Layout and Architectural Design •Clustered & Grouped Parking: Reject standard, monolithic grid parking layouts that force the clear-cutting of grand trees. Require clustered or grouped parking configurations that pocket vehicles around existing root systems. [1] •Curved Infrastructure: Mandate the use of curved parking lot drives, meandering sidewalks, and curved building footprints. Aligning the architecture to bend naturally around grand trees dynamically minimizes root impacts and enhances the aesthetic value of the development. Thank you for your rigorous review and continued dedication to protecting West Ashley's environmental assets. Sincerely, DAVID P SKERKAVICH Tyler Skerkavich 180 RESIDENCES LANE; unit 301, CHARLESTON SC 29414 Dear Members of the Design Review Board, As a concerned member of the Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance regarding the upcoming multi-family and townhome development at Grand Oaks Boulevard, I request that the Board mandate stringent architectural, site layout, and landscaping conditions to protect our historic canopy and combat localized flooding. I respectfully ask the DRB to incorporate the following requirements into any conceptual or preliminary approvals: Specifications •Native Live Oaks (Quercus virginiana): Request that all mitigation canopy trees along the streetscape and key Jul 6 2026 10:02AM Design Review Board Public Comment | July 6, 2026 Page 10 buffers prioritize native Live Oaks to maintain the historic character of the West Ashley canopy. •Flood-Tolerant Species: Given the region's intense stormwater challenges, require the integration of highly flood-tolerant native and adapted species, specifically requesting the inclusion of Dawn Redwood (Metasequoia glyptostroboides) in low- lying bio-retention cells and drainage buffers. 2. Best Industry Standard Specs for Grand Tree Protection To ensure that retained grand trees survive construction stressors, the developer must adhere to strict, enforceable tree protection standards before, during, and after construction: [1] •Critical Root Zone (CRZ) / Drip Line Protection: Erect rigid, chain-link tree protection barricades at the full radius of the tree’s drip line (or 1 foot of radius per 1 inch of tree diameter, whichever is greater) before any equipment arrives on site. Barricades must remain completely undisturbed through final inspection. [1, 2, 3, 4] •Mandatory Hand Digging: Prohibit heavy machinery within the drip line or CRZ. Any mandatory utility trenching or grading within these zones must be executed exclusively via hand-digging or pneumatic air-spading to prevent root shearing. [1] •Color-Sensitive Plan Zones: Require all civil, architectural, and grading plans to utilize specialized, highly visible color-coded "Tree Protection Zones" (TPZs) so contractors can easily identify zero-tolerance boundaries. 3. Tree-Forward Site Layout and Architectural Design •Clustered & Grouped Parking: Reject standard, monolithic grid parking layouts that force the clear-cutting of grand trees. Require clustered or grouped parking configurations that pocket vehicles around existing root systems. [1] •Curved Infrastructure: Mandate the use of curved parking lot drives, meandering sidewalks, and curved building footprints. Aligning the architecture to bend naturally around grand trees dynamically minimizes root impacts and enhances the aesthetic value of the development. Thank you for your rigorous review and continued dedication to protecting West Ashley's environmental assets. Sincerely, TYLER D SKERKAVICH Robert Frederick 110 Sugar Magnolia Way Four stories for apartment buildings in this neighborhood is unacceptable. The apartments in the back of the neighborhood top out at three and so should these to keep with the aesthetic of the overall neighborhood plan. Jun 26 2026 7:12PM Eric Wilhelm 1706 N Elgin Ct This is another project that is not needed in this area, and will only lead to more problems for current residents. Infrastructure continues to be years behind developments in the area. Bees Ferry, 17 and many other areas are oversaturated with new or proposed developments. In an already flood-prone area, removing more forestry/wetlands vital to countering flooding. Church Creek's historic flood 10 years ago proved overdeveloping the Shadowmoss area was foolish. A large area there has since been reverted to address flooding. Jun 27 2026 1:20PM Design Review Board Public Comment | July 6, 2026 Page 11 Why are developers being given an opportunity to repeat the same mistakes? Christine Horne 249 Larissa Dr, Charleston, SC 29414 To the Design Review Board, I respectfully urge the Board to deny or postpone approval of the proposed Grand Oaks development. The West Ashley area has experienced significant growth over the past several years, and the pace of development has exceeded the capacity of the surrounding infrastructure. Adding another large residential development will only worsen existing problems that residents deal with every day. First, the road network in this area is already overwhelmed. Traffic congestion on West Ashley Circle and the surrounding roads continues to increase, particularly during peak commuting hours. Residents experience long delays, difficulty entering and exiting neighborhoods, and increased safety concerns. The existing transportation infrastructure simply cannot support hundreds of additional residential units without substantial roadway improvements. Second, this project will further reduce wildlife habitat. The undeveloped land in this area provides an important refuge for native wildlife, and continued development fragments these habitats, displaces animals, and permanently alters the natural character of West Ashley. Finally, I am deeply concerned about flooding. The proposed development is located in an area that already experiences drainage challenges during heavy rainfall. Replacing natural land with buildings, roads, and other impervious surfaces will increase stormwater runoff and has the potential to worsen flooding for surrounding neighborhoods. Before any approval is considered, there should be clear evidence that the project will not negatively impact existing residents or downstream properties. Growth should be balanced with responsible planning. Until transportation improvements, environmental impacts, and flooding concerns are adequately addressed, approving another high-density development is not in the best interest of the community. Thank you for your consideration. Respectfully, Christine Horne Jun 27 2026 4:21PM Melissa Muse 637 Halstead St, Charleston 29414 We cannot support more residents Jun 27 2026 9:17PM Careen Jensen 904 Lansfaire Dr., Charleston, SC 29414 The design of this project is not within scale of the existing neighborhood. The proposed buildings are 4 story high. Within the Grand Oaks neighborhood, we have two and three story buildings along with single family homes. As I drive by all the new construction of apartments in the Bees Ferry/Glen McConnell area, the 4 story apartments are on the highway and next to retail. The proposed development does not fit within this neighborhood. Please consider moving this development to another area or significantly reduce the size and scale of this housing. As Jun 27 2026 12:19PM Design Review Board Public Comment | July 6, 2026 Page 12 proposed, it will bring much more traffic and we already have backups getting out of Grand Oaks Blvd and onto Bees Ferry. Please hear the voice of the people who live in the neighborhood. There have been many residents who have commented on this development who don't think we are being heard. Malorie Igo 439 minim street It’s clear the developer does not care about keeping the beauty of grand oaks. We shouldn’t look at the landscape and see a 4story building. We shouldn’t look see grand oaks, which you are chopping down just as much as you please. Building heights should be limited to as tall as the houses 2 stories. We moved to this part of west Ashley for more nature not buildings and you are destroying that. Jun 28 2026 3:13PM Daniel Gracie 260 Gazania Way, Charleston, SC 29414 Dan Gracie 260 Gazania Way Charleston, SC 29424 July 6, 2026 City of Charleston Design Review Board 2 George Street, First Floor Meeting Room Charleston, SC 29403 RE: Opposition to Conceptual Approval—Design Character and Aesthetic Compatibility 350 Grand Oaks Boulevard Development MS# 301-00-00-052 | DRB2026-000361 Dear Design Review Board Members, I submit this letter in opposition to conceptual approval of the proposed development at 350 Grand Oaks Boulevard. The project fails to meet the Design Review Board's core mandate: "to establish a review process that will protect and improve the visual and aesthetic character and economic value" of development within Charleston. The project's scale, massing, architectural treatment, and extensive forest clearing are fundamentally incompatible with Grand Oaks' established aesthetic character. Approval would diminish both the visual character and economic value of the neighborhood for existing residents. I. Grand Oaks' Established Aesthetic Character Grand Oaks is defined by a distinctive, cohesive visual character that residents chose deliberately. The neighborhood consists primarily of one- and two-story homes arranged along winding roads with preserved wetlands, ponds, and mature forest canopy. This character is not accidental—it reflects the original site planning and has endured for decades as the neighborhood's defining aesthetic. Dr. Frank Ricker, a longtime Grand Oaks resident, testified to this before the board in January: "What concerns me is what happens to Charleston. Developers come in and they just dump these big buildings on us." His statement captures what residents understand about their neighborhood's visual identity: it is modest in scale, residential in character, and dependent on preserved natural elements. Charlie Strickland, another resident of 20 years, made this point directly to the board: the design "does not match the rest of the community" and asked the board to "consider the residents who have to view the project daily, not the developers." This is precisely the DRB's mandate—to protect the visual character that residents and neighbors Jun 28 2026 9:38PM Design Review Board Public Comment | July 6, 2026 Page 13 experience. II. Scale and Massing: Incompatible with Neighborhood Character The proposed development includes four- to six-story apartment buildings. These heights are fundamentally out of proportion to Grand Oaks' existing architecture. In January, board member David Meeks articulated this concern directly: "I think even at a height scale and massing, I struggle to support it." The board's own initial response flagged that the scale does not fit the neighborhood. A four- to six-story apartment building next to one- and two-story homes creates visual jarring. The scale relationship is not gradual or transitional—it is abrupt. Residents living on adjacent streets will look out their windows at structures 2–3 times the height of their own homes. This is not a matter of accepting development. It is a matter of ensuring that development respects the scale context of its surroundings. The neighborhood is not asking for no change. It is asking for change that fits. III. Architectural Incompatibility and Design Quality The architect described the project as "meant to feel as residential as possible" and said it would "echo some kind of Lowcountry vernacular." This framing reveals a design problem: the project needs to claim to be residential and Lowcountry because it actually is not either. A genuine Lowcountry vernacular—which characterizes existing Grand Oaks homes—features modest pitched roofs, deep porches, natural materials, and integration with landscape. A four- to six-story apartment complex cannot honestly claim that vernacular regardless of surface details. Applying Lowcountry color palettes to a building of fundamentally incompatible scale does not create compatibility. It creates a costume. The board should not accept design strategies that attempt to mask incompatibility. The project's design should demonstrate genuine fit with the neighborhood, not simulate it. IV. Forest Clearing and Loss of Visual Amenity In June 2026, the Board of Zoning Appeals approved removal of 22 historic oak trees from this site. Originally the developer requested removal of 50 trees. The fact that the developer had to request removal of 50 trees and negotiate down to 22 signals the extent and significance of the existing forest. This forest is not incidental to the neighborhood's visual character—it defines it. Grand Oaks residents chose to live among preserved trees and natural vegetation. The forest provides visual screening, seasonal interest, and the sense of being in a landscape rather than an urban development. Removing 22 historic oaks and clearing significant forest canopy to accommodate apartment construction diminishes the neighborhood's most valued aesthetic feature. The replacement planting of 495.25 caliper inches of new trees is arithmetic compensation, not functional replacement. A mature oak tree provides 15+ years of growth and character. New plantings do not Design Review Board Public Comment | July 6, 2026 Page 14 replicate that value. The DRB should recognize that forest clearing for high-density development is an aesthetic loss that cannot be fully mitigated through replanting requirements. V. Economic Value and Neighborhood Investment Residents of Grand Oaks have invested in their homes with expectations shaped by neighborhood character. Home values in residential neighborhoods depend on visual stability and character preservation. When a developer introduces a major multifamily project with incompatible scale and design, existing homeowners absorb an aesthetic loss they did not choose and cannot easily remediate. A neighbor cannot renovate away a four-story apartment building next to their property. They cannot improve their home's visual context. They experience a permanent diminishment of their investment's setting. The DRB's mandate includes protecting "economic value." That mandate applies to existing residents as much as to developers. Approving developments that degrade neighborhood character—and therefore neighborhood property values—contradicts the board's core responsibility. VI. The Board's Own January Concerns In January, the Design Review Board itself expressed concerns about this project's compatibility: - Board member David Meeks struggled with the height and massing. - The board requested design adjustments, including color modification of the pool house. - Residents testified repeatedly that the design does not fit the neighborhood. - The board was unable to reach consensus on conceptual approval—a clear signal of design concerns. These concerns have not been resolved. The developer's presentation framed the project as "meant to feel as residential as possible" and "Lowcountry vernacular"—language that reveals the design team understands the fundamental incompatibility and is attempting to manage it through framing rather than redesign. The board should not grant conceptual approval to a project it already identified as having significant design compatibility concerns. VII. Recommendations 1. Deny conceptual approval in its current form. The scale, massing, and architectural treatment are fundamentally incompatible with Grand Oaks' established aesthetic character. 2. Require substantial redesign for height, massing, and scale. If the site is to be developed, it should be developed at a scale consistent with the surrounding neighborhood—primarily one- to two-story residential structures. This is not a request to prevent development. It is a request that development respect the scale context of its setting. 3. Require preservation of significant forest canopy. The existing forest is a defining element of Grand Oaks' visual character. Require the developer to modify site planning to preserve existing forest where feasible and to avoid wholesale clearing for parking and Design Review Board Public Comment | July 6, 2026 Page 15 hardscape. 4. Require authentic architectural compatibility, not simulated vernacular. The project should demonstrate genuine architectural fit with Lowcountry residential character, not apply surface details to incompatible forms. 5. Require visual impact analysis. Before reconsidering this project, require a professional visual impact assessment showing sightlines from nearby residences, seasonal views, and cumulative visual impact of the development on the neighborhood streetscape and residence views. VIII. Conclusion The Design Review Board's mandate is to protect and improve the visual and aesthetic character and economic value of development within Charleston. Grand Oaks residents have built a neighborhood defined by modest scale, preserved forest, and residential character. They have invested in that neighborhood with expectations shaped by its visual identity. The proposed development contradicts that character at every scale: height incompatible with surrounding homes, massing that creates visual jarring, forest clearing that removes defining landscape features, and design that requires "Lowcountry vernacular" language to mask its fundamental incompatibility. The board's own January discussion flagged these exact concerns. The board should honor those concerns and require redesign that respects the visual character and economic value of the existing neighborhood. I urge you to deny conceptual approval and require substantial redesign on scale, massing, forest preservation, and architectural authenticity before reconsidering this project. Respectfully, Dan Gracie 260 Gazania Way Charleston, SC 29424 (843) 278-0256 dangracie@gmail.com — Sources and References City of Charleston (2021). Design Review Board Guidelines and Standards. City of Charleston Design Review Board (January 6, 2026). Meeting Minutes and Board Discussion—350 Grand Oaks Boulevard Development. Live5News (June 3, 2026). Charleston board approves removal of 22 historic oak trees for apartment complex. Post and Courier (January 6, 2026). Another 400 apartments, townhomes proposed behind West Ashley grocery store. Professional visual impact assessment standards and best practices for neighborhood design compatibility analysis. Liz Munn 3631 Morse Avenue, Johns Island, SC 29455 This project has obtained approval for removal of grand trees with the variance granted with conditions regarding the circumstances. The current packet shows replacement canopy trees that are not appropriate for hurricane survival, will not be considered protected in the future, and meet aesthetic needs only. Shumard Oak, Nuttal Oak, and Pin Oaks are described as being wind sails. A more resilient choice would be Bald Cypress for wet areas and Live Oaks. The removal of so much should result in the Jun 29 2026 3:25PM Design Review Board Public Comment | July 6, 2026 Page 16 responsibile replacement of trees which will stand up to the conditions of the lowcountry. Charles Stricklin Sr 330 Cabrill Dr. Charleston, SC 29414. This purposed development of 4 story, 348 units, 33 townhomes, 6 garages and clubhouse is very much opposed by my neighbors and myself. The addition traffic from this complex will just be a big mess! No only will there be additional congestion but emergency vehicles will have a terrible time getting to anyone or locations during rush hours. Flooding conditions will surely be elevated with all the additional concrete and asphalt. This is a flood prone area as it is. The loss of large trees will cause the ground to become saturated very quickly during heavy rain events. I have talked with District 10 Rep. Stephen Bowden and the mayor’s aide Hampton Logan IV. They both argue that this is in the master plan for this area call; Long Savannah. This plan is a old plan they say. Plans can be changed, they are all the time. There are enough apartments available now and others are being built as of this writing. If you haven’t visited this area in the past year or so please do. This complex is just not needed, it’s all about money. The powerful families like the Rivers and others just want more money. They don’t live where this will be built so they don’t care one iota. Please stop this madness! The traffic that will be created will be a nightmare. This is not a job creator or good for economic development as developers and politicians like to say. It all about money!!! Jun 29 2026 7:11PM Carlos Bright 310 Grouse Park, Charleston SC 29414 I am opposed to the project due to it's negative impact on the community and surrounding areas. This project does not have a site plan that offers a buffer to nearby neighborhoods. Our neighborhood in particular will be directly backed up to tall multi-family building with no buffer whatsoever. The development consists of large 4 story buildings with only a few townhomes along the street. This should be rethought / redesigned to swap that and provide more single family homes rather than apartments. The neighborhood is currently 100% single family homes and townhomes. Placing a massive amount of rental properties in the area will change the demographics relating in more noise, crime, etc. There will also be an influx of cars on an already over-burdened street (Grand Oaks Blvd). This street at the Bees Ferry intersection already backs up all day. This traffic light, and the lack of enough turning lanes etc in the immediate area causes a lot of traffic and quite a bit of road rage. This area is a nice, quiet neighborhood and this development will only be detrimental to that peace. No one wants it here, and there is certainly no reason for it to be here. There are too many new apartments in the area already. I would guess there have been more than 1500 units built in the last 5 years and absolutely NO new roads to handle them. The added lane to Glenn McConnell is not enough to help especially Jun 30 2026 8:25AM Design Review Board Public Comment | July 6, 2026 Page 17 since there was no improvement to Bees Ferry. This is just a bad idea no matter how you look at it. It only helps the developer, no one else. Maybe consider whether the other apartments are at full capacity before allowing this to happen. Nicole Heugel 217 Brambling Lane Charleston SC 29414 Before granting conceptual approval, I believe the Planning Commission should take a closer look at the project's density, infrastructure demands, environmental impacts, and compatibility with existing neighborhoods. Although this development has been discussed for years, the surrounding community has changed significantly, and the project should be evaluated based on current conditions rather than assumptions made decades ago. Many nearby residents were not directly notified of the proposal or informed of opportunities to provide feedback. Given the size and potential impact of this development, meaningful community engagement should occur before any conceptual approval is granted. My primary concern is the proposed density, particularly the apartment units planned adjacent to existing neighborhoods. A lower-density design with more townhomes, greater setbacks from existing homes, and the preservation of additional green space and mature trees would be more compatible with the surrounding community. The proposal also raises concerns regarding traffic, road safety, stormwater management, flooding, wildlife habitat, wetlands, and overall environmental impacts. These issues deserve careful evaluation before moving forward. In addition, the area is already experiencing growing pressure on roads, utilities, schools, healthcare facilities, emergency services, and other public infrastructure. It is unclear whether these systems can adequately support the additional population this development would bring. Growth should be planned responsibly and in a manner that protects both current and future residents. For these reasons, I encourage the Commission to reconsider the scale and density of the proposal and require modifications that better address infrastructure, environmental preservation, and compatibility with the surrounding community before granting conceptual approval. Jun 30 2026 9:24AM Design Review Board Public Comment | July 6, 2026 Page 18 Other Comments: 2 Comments Submitted: • Shannon Wolcott, 139 Toura lane Submitted to Innovate Site on June 28, 2026 12:34 PM No more housing. Too much traffic. Use that land to make a road going from Glen Mc Connell to Summerville to ease up traffic on 61 where they cannot add more lanes . So many acccidents on the black hole of 61 from bees ferry to Dorchester rd. Many deaths • Donna McClain, 2475 Wensley Drive Submitted to Innovate Site on June 28, 2026 1:31 PM West Ashley is currently a complete nightmare with regards to traffic. One minor fender locks up Hwy 17 and 61. Each new subdivision will cause more devastating flooding which we are already suffering due to over development. Please do not allow any further building until our infrastructure can properly support it. At present our infrastructure is about 20 years behind.

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.