RecordWell Data

BZA-Z Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Jun 16, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING PUBLIC COMMENT JUNE 16, 2026 A meeting of the Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning (BZA-Z) will be held on Tuesday, June 16, 2026 at 5:15 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street. The following comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the meeting and also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/bza-z. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 194 Cannon St. Crosstown| Council District 6 | TMS# 460-10-04-011/13 Zoned: PUD, Accommodations Overlay District | BZA2026-002381 Request Special Exception under Sec. 54-220 to build a 175-unit accommodations use. Owner: 194 Cannon Street, LLC Applicant: Dylan Towe, LS3P 1 Comment Submitted: • Preservation Society of Charleston Submitted to Staff See attached statement. Position Statement Board of Zoning Appeals - Zoning June 16, 2026 194 Cannon Street Dear Board Members: The Preservation Society of Charleston (PSC) respectfully submits that the materials currently before the Board do not provide an adequate basis for evaluating this special exception request. The Preservation Society of Charleston (PSC) respectfully submits that the materials currently before the Board The application relies on materials submitted nearly a decade ago, under an outdated version of the Accommodations Overlay (Sec. 54-220). Since that time, the city has implemented substantial amendments to the ordinance out of concern for the changing character of the city’s residential neighborhoods and historically mixed-use districts. This intent was furthered in the 2021 City Plan, which recommends supporting “sustainable tourism through policies and programs that promote the unique character and sense of place of each area of Charleston” (p. 61). Of particular importance in the amended ordinance is the requirement that the Board make a finding that “the location of the accommodations use will contribute to the maintenance or creation of a diverse mixed-use district” (Sec. 54-220 (e)). Without updated materials responsive to this criterion, the Board cannot fully evaluate the proposal’s compatibility with its surrounding context. A Planned Unit Development (PUD) should be considered a base zoning that is subject to overlay provisions. The PUD contains no explicit language giving the applicant the right to apply an outdated version of the Accommodations Overlay. Instead, the PUD references compliance with the Zoning Ordinance generally and further acknowledges that projects within the PUD are subject to review and approval by both the Board of Zoning Appeals. Accordingly, the current version of Section 54-220 should apply. For these reasons, PSC asks the Board to defer consideration of this item until the applicant submits updated materials that fully address the criteria set forth in the current version of the Accommodations Overlay. Thank you for considering our position in this matter. Sincerely, Anna-Catherine Alexander Director of Advocacy Initiatives CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 221 Grove St. Wagener Terrace | Council District 6 | TMS# 463-14-02-006 Zoned: SR-2 | BZA2026-002387 Request Variance from Sec. 54-301 to build a 2-story rear addition with a 21’ rear setback (25’ required). Owners: Owen Meislin Applicant: Michael Fisher 4 Comments Submitted: • Letters of Support Submitted to Staff See attached letters. • Nat and Lily Gunter, 219 Grove St. • Brittany Stickland, 223 Grove St. • Renee Wickes Poser, 56 Dunnemann Ave. • Wagener Terrace Neighborhood Association Submitted to Staff See attached letter. Wagener Terrace Neighborhood Association Charleston, SC 29403 June 10th, 2026 Re: 221 Grove Street, TMS# 463-14-02-006 Robert Summerfield BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS 2 George Street, Suite 3100 Charleston, SC 29401 Dear Mr. Summerfield, I am writing to you on behalf of the Wagener Terrace Neighborhood Association (WTNA) to express our support for the recent zoning variance request submitted by Owen Meislin for the property located at 221 Grove Street. Mr.Meislin presented his plans at our WTNA meeting and the WTNA felt the plans were respectful to the neighborhood architecture and were a practical use of space. A motion was made and carried to write a letter of support for the variance request and all were in favor. We kindly ask the Board of Zoning Appeals to consider this letter as a formal expression of our support for Meislin’s variance request. We believe that granting this variance will contribute positively to his well-being and to our neighborhood's cohesiveness. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Jarett Nicholson President, Wagener Terrace Neighborhood Association CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 330 W Confederate Cir. South Windemere | Council District 11 | TMS# 460-07-04-141 Zoned: SR-1 | BZA2026-002389 Request Variance from Sec. 54-301 to build a 2-story rear addition with a 5’ north side setback (9’ required) and a 17’ rear setback (25’ required). Owner: Phil & Acacia Braun Applicant: Amber Aument 2 Comments Submitted: • Letters of Support Submitted to Staff See attached letters. • Frank J. Ritter, 324 Confederate Circle • Resident, 336 Confederate Circle CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 2 Allgood Rd. Wappoo Heights | Council District 11 | TMS# 421-13-00-031 Zoned: SR-1 | BZA2026-002394 Appeal of Zoning Administrator determination requiring the property owner to apply for a Special Exception under Sec. 54-501 to construct a detached single-family home on a lot of insufficient size. Owner: John Dean Yarborough Applicant: Andrew Gowder, Jr. 51 Comments and 1 Petition Submitted: • 20 Comments Submitted on Innovate Site See attached comments. Note: Some residents submitted comments both in letter format and on the Innovate site. • Neighborhood Statement and Survey See attached petition with 70 signatures. • Charlotte Nash Taylor Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • M. Ross Armstrong, 134 Folly Rd. Blvd. Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Megan and Hunter Louis, 36 Formosa Drive Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Claire duPont, 16 Tranquil Drive Submitted to Staff I oppose the application for special exception for 2 Allgood Rd., and I also signed the Wappoo Heights neighborhood petition. • Chantal Byrne, Wappoo Heights Resident Submitted to Staff My name is Chantal Byrne and I am a resident of Wappoo Heights. Although I cannot attend the meeting on the evening of June 16, 2026 I am writing to let you know I oppose the application for special exception for 2 Allgood Rd, and I also signed the neighborhood petition. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | 2 Allgood Rd. Page 2 • Lindsey Stang, 28 Formosa Drive Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Heather Davidson, 12 Tranquil Drive Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Lea Clement, 9 Palmetto Road Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Patricia McGuinn, 9 Allgood Road Submitted to Staff I oppose the application for special exception for 2 Allgood Rd, and I also signed the neighborhood petition. • Ellen Lucas, 19 Formosa Drive Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Jennifer Ferrell Submitted to Staff I am writing to strongly oppose the application for special exception requested for 2 Allgood Road. I signed the neighborhood petition and plan to attend the meeting tomorrow night as well. My family has been in residence in Wappoo Heights since the 1950s, and I can confidently state that this special exception request is not absolutely consistent with the character or spirit of our neighborhood. • Nancy Youngblood Jordan, 0 Devil’s Elbow Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Jody Smith, 16 Formosa Dr. Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Mary Barrineau, 6 Formosa Drive Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Dr. Erica Anderson Submitted to Staff I strongly oppose the application for special exception for 2 Allgood Rd, and I also signed the neighborhood petition. This land is a very small patch of dirt overlooking the marsh where neighbors historically have visited, small children learn about marsh wildlife, and watch the sunset. I hope we can do the right thing and not destroy this space with another huge home. Thanks for your work and attention to this matter. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | 2 Allgood Rd. Page 3 • Meredith and Cooper Coker, 8 Formosa Dr. Submitted to Staff Please let this email serve as our letter in objection to the above-referenced appeal, to be heard June 16, 2026. My husband and I reside in the Wappoo Heights neighborhood (Cooper and Meredith Coker, 8 Formosa Dr.) and would request that the Board deny the appeal for the myriad reasons set forth in the neighborhood petition and any accompanying letters of objection. We were unavailable to sign the petition and will be unable to attend the hearing due to prior commitments, but we do wish to lodge our objection to the proposed project. • Bill and Donna Nichols, 138 Folly Road Blvd. Submitted to Staff We oppose the application for special exception for 2 Allgood Rd, and we also signed the neighborhood petition. • Walker Ferrell Submitted to Staff I oppose the application for special exception for 2 Allgood Rd, and I also signed the neighborhood petition. • Alex Betros Submitted to Staff I oppose the application for special exception for 2 Allgood Rd, and I also signed the neighborhood petition. • Christopher Stang, 28 Formosa Drive Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Jennifer Latimer Wildstein, 7 Palmetto Road Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Chris K. Smith, 16 Formosa Drive Submitted to Staff This is to advise the board that I very much oppose the application for special exception for 2 Allgood Rd, and I also signed the neighborhood petition. • JP Byrne, Wappoo Heights Resident Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • John F. Hassell, III Submitted to Staff I oppose the application for special exception for 2 Allgood Rd., and I also signed the neighborhood petition. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | 2 Allgood Rd. Page 4 • Charlie McCrary Submitted to Staff I oppose the application for special exception for 2 Allgood Rd. I also signed the neighborhood petition. Thank you. • Sharon McCrary, 17 Palmetto Rd. Submitted to Staff I oppose the application for special exception for 2 Allgood Road, and I also signed the neighborhood petition. • Lynn Crymes, Wappoo Heights Resident Submitted to Staff I am writing to OPPOSE the application for special exception for 2 Allgood Rd, Sincerely, Lynn Grymes (resident of Wappoo Heights Neighborhood) • Constantine P. Copses, 5 Nashmor Road Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Sallie Bennett Robinson, 108 Folly Road Blvd. Submitted to Staff I am opposed to the requested change to the zoning for 2 Allgood Road in Wappoo Heights. If this property had been intended to be built upon originally, it would have be built on many years prior to now as part of the original plan for the neighborhood. Please do not change the zoning as requested since it is not in keeping with the original design of Wappoo Heights and sets a presidence for future development on property never intended for that use. • Allison Kinder, 3 Formosa Drive Submitted to Staff I oppose the application for special exception for 2 Allgood Rd, and I also signed the neighborhood petition. The proposed build absolutely does not fit within the character of the Wappoo Heights neighbourhood and the lot size is not sufficient for any build whatsoever. Thank you for your consideration. • Merrie Koester, 11 Allgood Road Submitted to Staff See attached letter. 6/15/26, 12:45 PM lnbox - Swalhah, Christopher - Outlook Outlook 2 Allgood Rd PID 421-13-00-031 Hearing June 16, 2026 From Jody Smith Date Mon 6/1 5/2026 11 :34 AM To Cc bza-z Swalhah, Christopher @ 1 attachment (429 KB) Charlotte Nash Taylor letter.pdf; ATTENTION: This email originated from outside the City of Charleston's systems. Do not click links or open attachments unl ess you are expecting them from the sender and/or have confirmed the content is safe. Forward any suspicious emails by clicking the Phish Alert Button. To: City of Charleston, SC Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning Meeting June 16, 2026 Re: 2 Allgood Rd, Charleston, SC PID 421-13-00-031 Dear Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals, I've been requested to forward a letter from Ms Charlotte Nash Taylor, one of the sellers of the subject property to Mr. Dean Yarborough. She has limited mobility but plans to attend the meeting in person a speak if able. Her letter is attached. Given the extraordinary nature of this letter, we request to board give it due consideration. Thank you , Jody Smith 16 Formosa Dr, Chas, SC 29407 https://outlook.office.com/mail/inbox/id/ MQkADFIM2VIOTYxLWFjYjltNGU 1 NS05MGRkL TUyYzFkMjgwMjg5YwAQAGdm%2FvgXiOJHqf65ExeBKUA... 1 /1 6/15/26, 9:30 AM Mail - Swalhah, Christopher - Outlook Outlook Objection to Application No. 15 (2 Allgood Rd) - Board of Zoning Appeals PID 421-13-00-031 From M Ross Armstrong Date Mon 6/15/2026 7:40 AM To Swalhah, Christopher ATTENTION: This email originated from outside the City of Charleston's systems. Do not click links or open attachments unless you are expecting them from the sender and/or have confirmed the content is safe. Forward any suspicious emails by clicking the Phish Alert Button. Christopher, I am a resident of the Wappoo Heights neighborhood and respectfully object to Application No. 15. I urge the Board to uphold the Zoning Administrator's decision denying the requested Special Exception. The subject property has historically been considered undevelopable and has never functioned as a buildable residential lot. Since the time of the Nash family, the original developers of Wappoo Heights, the property was used as a neighborhood waterfront access point known as "The Landing," which served as a community dock prior to Hurricane Hugo. The Applicant purchased the property for approximately $20,000, consisting of marshland and two separate areas of upland. As correctly determined by the City of Charleston Department of Planning, Preservation & Sustainability, neither upland area independently satisfies the requirements for a Special Exception. The purchase price reflects the nature of the property being conveyed: undevelopable marshland and two isolated parcels of high ground. The fact that these areas share a single TMS number or appear on a single plat should not control the outcome. The upland areas are physically separated by marshland and do not constitute a contiguous buildable lot. Administrative designation alone cannot create development rights where the zoning requirements have not been met. The City of Charleston Zoning Administrator properly applied the ordinance and did not abuse his discretion. The proposed building site does not contain the required 9,000 square feet of contiguous high ground upon which development may occur, a deficiency that has been communicated to the Applicant for the past two years. Approving this application would effectively grant development rights to a property that has historically been recognized as undevelopable and would undermine the consistent application of the City's zoning regulations. For these reasons, I respectfully request that the Board affirm the Zoning Administrator's decision and deny Application No. 15. Respectfully submitted, M. Ross Armstrong Wappoo Heights Resident 134 Folly Rd. Blvd. https://outlook.office.com/mail/inbox/id/MQkADFIM2VIOTYxLWFjYjltNGU1 NS05MGRkLTUyYzFkMjgwMj g5YwAQAPO3Wj96nYpOtyQkAOcGl8c%3D... 1 /2 6/15/26, 9:30 AM Charleston, SC 29407 M Ross Armstrong Armstrong Commercial Real Estate, LLC Licensed Real Estate Broker in SC and GA Mail - Swalhah, Christopher - Outlook https://outlook.office.com/mail/inbox/id/MQkADFIM2VIOTYxLWFjYjltNGU1NS05M GRkLTUyYzFkMjgwMjg5YwAQAPO3Wj96nYpOtyQkAOcGl8c%3D... 2/2 June 13, 2026 Board of Zoning City of Charleston Clarification Regarding Property at 36 Formosa Drive, Wappoo Heights, Charleston, SC Dear Members of the Board of Zoning, We are writing to provide important context concerning the property located at 36 Formosa Drive in the Wappoo Heights neighborhood. This letter addresses a likely misunderstanding that has arisen in the community regarding the size of the residence currently situated on this lot. In October 2019, our family home, which exceeded 3,000 square feet, was severely damaged by fire. The blaze left only a single living room intact, which became the foundation for our subsequent renovation. Rather than sell the property—a location of deep personal significance where we raised our children and formed lasting ties to the neighborhood—we chose to rebuild upon the remaining structure. This decision required substantial modifications to bring the building into compliance with current building codes, including elevating the structure, as it was no longer eligible for grandfathered status following the loss of the primary residence. The resulting home is approximately 740 square feet. It represents a careful renovation and adaptive reuse of the surviving portion of our original family home, rather than new construction of a small dwelling. We undertook this project with full adherence to all applicable regulations and with profound respect for the character of the Wappoo Heights neighborhood. It has come to our attention that our renovated residence is being cited by a neighbor as an example of smaller new construction homes in the area. We wish to respectfully clarify that this characterization is inaccurate, as the current structure is the preserved and upgraded remnant of a much larger pre-fire home, not a newly built small residence. Thank you for your service to the Charleston community. We are available to provide any additional documentation or clarification that may assist the Board. Sincerely, Megan and Hunter Louis 36 Formosa Drive Wappoo Heights June 15, 2026 RE: Agenda Item B-15 – 2 Allgood Road (TMS 421-13-00-031) Dear Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals, My name is Lindsey Stang, and I am a resident of Wappoo Heights. I am writing to respectfully request that the Board uphold the Zoning Administrator’s decision and deny the applicant’s request for a Special Exception under Section 54-501. In reviewing both the application and the intent of Section 54-501, I do not believe the applicant has demonstrated that the proposed site plan is consistent with the purpose and intent of Charleston’s zoning regulations. While Section 54-501 allows the Board to consider development on a lot that does not meet minimum lot size requirements, approval is discretionary and should only occur when the proposal does not conflict with the broader objectives of the ordinance. One of my primary concerns is that this property is not comparable to a typical residential lot in Wappoo Heights. Although the parcel contains approximately 10.43 acres, nearly all of that acreage consists of marshland. The proposed home would be confined to a small isolated upland area whose development characteristics are substantially different from surrounding properties. The buildable area is significantly smaller than neighboring lots and, in my opinion, requires a development approach that is inconsistent with the established character of the neighborhood. I am also concerned by the applicant’s reliance on the recently assigned Allgood Road address as support for the proposal. The GIS 911 Addressing Coordinator’s assignment of an address is an administrative function and does not determine zoning compliance or development rights. The parcel has extensive frontage along Tranquil Drive and only minimal frontage along Allgood Road. Consistent with the Zoning Administrator’s determination, I believe the property should be evaluated based on its frontage along Tranquil Drive and the corresponding setback requirements contained within the zoning ordinance. Environmental conditions on the property further distinguish this parcel from other residential lots. The site is adjacent to sensitive marshland resources and is subject to critical line and buffer requirements intended to protect Charleston’s coastal environment. These regulations exist for an important reason and should not be minimized when evaluating whether a site plan is consistent with the intent of the ordinance. Additionally, residents have observed flooding in this area on multiple occasions, including recent events. Photographs submitted as part of the public record demonstrate the site’s vulnerability to tidal and stormwater impacts. The history of this property is also relevant. Historical documents associated with the original Wappoo Heights subdivision identify this upland area as “The Landing,” a waterfront recreational space intended for use by neighborhood residents and their guests. For generations, the property remained undeveloped and served as a community amenity. The applicant has not demonstrated that this area was ever intended to function as an independent residential lot. Another important consideration is that the applicant purchased the property with full knowledge of its limitations. Public records classified the parcel as undevelopable, and the purchase price reflected those constraints. The conditions that make the site difficult or impossible to develop are not new. They existed long before the current owner acquired the property and were readily apparent at the time of purchase. Finally, I encourage the Board to consider the precedent that approval of this application could establish. This case extends well beyond a single property. Future applicants, City staff, and future Boards will inevitably look to this decision when evaluating similar requests. If a predominantly marsh parcel with fragmented upland areas, environmental constraints, and a long history of non-development is determined to satisfy the intent and purpose requirements of Section 54-501, it becomes increasingly difficult to distinguish this property from other similarly situated parcels throughout Charleston. The City has spent decades developing regulations that balance private property rights with the protection of Charleston’s marshes, waterways, environmental resources, and historic neighborhood character. Approving this request risks significantly expanding the circumstances under which Section 54-501 may be applied and could weaken the effectiveness of the City’s minimum lot size standards and environmental protections. For these reasons, I respectfully request that the Board uphold the Zoning Administrator’s determination and deny the application. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Lindsey Stang Wappoo Heights Resident 28 Formosa Drive Heather Davidson 12 Tranquil Drive Charleston, SC 29407 June 16, 2026 City of Charleston Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Department of Planning & Preservation 2 George Street, Suite 3100 Charleston, SC 29401 Attn: Christopher Swalhah, Senior Zoning Planner Re: Opposition to Appeal – July 16, 2026 meeting, Agenda Item B-15 | 2 Allgood Road, Charleston, SC 29407 | TMS No. 421-13-00-031 Dear Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals and Mr. Swalhah: I am writing as a long-time resident of Wappoo Heights, residing at 12 Tranquil Drive, to formally oppose the appeal filed by Dean Yarborough (Agenda Item B-15) regarding the property at 2 Allgood Road, TMS No. 421-13-00-031. Mr. Yarborough is asking this Board to overturn the May 1, 2026 determination of the Zoning Administrator, which correctly required him to obtain a Special Exception under Section 54-501 before constructing a single-family home on a lot of insufficient contiguous high ground. Rather than bypassing that process through this appeal, Mr. Yarborough should be required to proceed through the Special Exception pathway, which would allow the Board to review the proposed development in its entirety – including site-specific conditions, access, environmental review status, neighbor impacts, and compatibility with the surrounding neighborhood – before any authorization is granted. The appellant’s argument that the City’s 60-day inaction constitutes deemed approval under S.C. Code § 6-29-1150(A) is a legal matter for the Board to assess carefully; however, even if that argument had merit as a procedural matter, it should not substitute for the substantive review that the Special Exception process is designed to provide. I respectfully urge the Board to uphold that determination and deny the appeal. In the alternative, if the Board elects to treat this matter as a Special Exception application, I submit that the applicant has not provided sufficient evidence for the Board to make the required findings, and that the request should be denied on that basis as well. I. The Applicant Has Not Demonstrated Compliance with Applicable Zoning Requirements The SR-1 zoning district requires a minimum lot area of 9,000 square feet of high ground. The subject parcel, while totaling 10.427 acres overall, contains only approximately 0.357 acres (15,589 sq. ft.) of upland, scattered across multiple disconnected high-ground areas. The primary proposed building site, Upland 1, contains only 6,064 square feet – well below the 9,000 square foot minimum. A second upland area, Upland 6, contains 8,310 square feet but is separated from Upland 1 by marsh and open water. The applicant contends that these disconnected upland areas may be aggregated to satisfy the SR-1 minimum. That argument is not supported by the ordinance. The Zoning Administrator and Planning Director have both correctly concluded that the minimum lot area standard requires contiguous high ground sufficient to provide adequate area for development. Allowing an applicant to stitch together isolated marsh islands to meet a dimensional standard would render the SR-1 lot area requirement meaningless for parcels in tidal and wetland environments. The applicant has also not demonstrated compliance with front setback requirements in a straightforward manner. The address and front-of-lot designation were only recently assigned by the City’s GIS Division, and the setback analysis in the preliminary site plan depends entirely on that assignment. The Board should scrutinize whether the setback configuration presented truly satisfies SR-1 dimensional standards as written, not as reinterpreted to accommodate a favorable address assignment. II. The Proposed Site Plan Is Not Consistent with the Intent and Purposes of Section 54-501 or the Zoning Ordinance Section 54-501 authorizes the Board to permit development on a lot of record of insufficient size – but only upon approval of a site plan deemed consistent with the intent and purposes of the zoning ordinance. That standard is not automatically satisfied simply because a building can be placed on a parcel without exceeding dimensional limits. The Board must affirmatively find that the proposed development is consistent with the ordinance’s broader purposes. The zoning ordinance’s SR-1 district is designed to protect low-density residential neighborhoods and to ensure that development occurs on lots with adequate buildable area. Placing a two-story, 34-foot structure on a 6,064-square-foot island of high ground surrounded almost entirely by tidal marsh does not serve those purposes. The proposed development would occupy 19.1% of the only upland area on which it would be built, with virtually no buffer from the surrounding marsh. This is not the type of residential infill development that Section 54-501 was designed to accommodate; it is an attempt to develop a parcel that is, for practical purposes, a marsh lot. III. The Request Is Not Consistent with the Character and Development Pattern of Wappoo Heights Wappoo Heights is one of the oldest residential neighborhoods in West Ashley, established in 1924 by George Albert Nash from land that was once part of the Crescent Plantation. The neighborhood was built around its relationship to the marshes of Wappoo Creek – residents crabbed, shrimped, and swam from a dock on the creek, built tree houses in the grand live oaks, and formed bonds that became, as one community historian wrote, “part of the mortar of Wappoo Heights.” That character endures today in the tree-canopied streets, the marsh views, and the quiet, low-density residential fabric of the neighborhood. The parcel at 2 Allgood Road has never had a home on it. It is over 96% tidal marsh and sits directly on the Wappoo Cut/Intracoastal Waterway. The surrounding residential lots on Palmetto Road, Tranquil Drive, and Allgood Road are established homes on conventionally sized, primarily upland lots. Constructing a new residence on what is effectively a marsh island – accessible only via a narrow, unpaved, single-lane road – is not consistent with that development pattern. The nearest home at 1 Allgood Road is approximately 120 feet away; the nearest home at 12 Palmetto Road is approximately 300 feet away. Those distances reflect not proximity of neighbors but the extent of intervening marsh. The proposed development would introduce a new structure into a setting that has remained undeveloped for exactly the reasons the zoning ordinance is designed to protect. IV . The Applicant Has Not Provided Sufficient Evidence for the Board to Make the Required Findings To the extent the Board considers this matter as a Special Exception application, Section 54-501 requires that the Board approve a site plan it deems consistent with the intent and purposes of the ordinance before authorizing any use. The applicant has submitted only a preliminary site plan, and significant required information remains absent from the record. Specifically, the record before the Board does not include: a completed environmental review or OCRM permitting determination (the applicant’s own materials list “OCRM consultation” as an outstanding task); final civil engineering, utility permitting, or stormwater management documentation; confirmation of adequate water and sewer service to Upland 1; a traffic or access analysis for Tranquil Drive; or an independent assessment of the critical line location on Upland 1. The applicant has acknowledged that architectural refinement, soil testing, builder selection, and landscape design are all still outstanding. A board cannot make findings required by the ordinance on the basis of incomplete preliminary materials. Approving a Special Exception for a marsh-front parcel of this sensitivity without a complete record would be an abuse of the discretion Section 54-501 is meant to channel, not eliminate. The Board should require a complete application before making any determination. V . Environmental, Critical Line, Marsh Buffer, and Other Regulatory Requirements Have Not Been Adequately Addressed The subject parcel is one of the most environmentally sensitive parcels in this part of the City. It is located within FEMA Flood Zone AE-10 and surrounded by the tidal marshes and open water of Wappoo Creek and the Atlantic Intracoastal Waterway. The OCRM Critical Line runs through Upland 1 – the very area where the proposed structure would be sited. The applicant’s own preliminary site plan identifies this critical line but does not resolve it; OCRM consultation is listed as a future task. Section 54-347.1 of the City’s Zoning Ordinance establishes critical line buffer requirements that apply to development near tidal wetlands. While the applicant has cited the parcel’s status as a platted lot of record as grounds for exemption from those buffer requirements under Section 54-344, that exemption does not eliminate the need for OCRM approval, Army Corps of Engineers review, or compliance with all applicable state and federal coastal resource regulations. None of those reviews have been completed. The Board should not grant any relief that would accelerate development of this parcel ahead of the environmental review process. Additionally, the water and sewer infrastructure shown in the City’s mapping does not appear to extend to Upland 1. The applicant has not explained how potable water, sanitary sewer, or stormwater management would be provided to and from the proposed building site in a manner consistent with applicable regulations. These are not minor details – they are foundational to any determination that a site plan is adequate for development approval. VI. Access via Tranquil Drive Is Inadequate and Presents a Public Safety Concern As the resident of 12 Tranquil Drive, I can personally attest that Tranquil Drive is a narrow, unpaved, single-lane road. Its effective width is reduced to approximately 12 feet in places. It cannot safely accommodate two-way residential traffic or multiple construction vehicles. The applicant has provided no access analysis, no proposed road improvements and no plan for storage of materials during construction. Approving development on this parcel without resolving the access deficiency would create an ongoing public safety hazard for existing residents. Conclusion The Zoning Administrator’s May 1, 2026 determination was correct, and this Board should uphold it. The applicant has not demonstrated compliance with applicable zoning requirements, has not shown that the proposed development is consistent with the intent and purposes of the ordinance, has not demonstrated compatibility with the established character and development pattern of Wappoo Heights, has not provided sufficient evidence for the Board to make required findings, and has not addressed critical environmental, regulatory, and access concerns. Wappoo Heights is a historically significant neighborhood whose character is defined in large part by its relationship to the surrounding marsh. That character deserves the protection that the zoning ordinance provides. I respectfully urge the Board to deny Mr. Yarborough’s appeal and to require that any future application for development of this parcel proceed through the full Special Exception review process with a complete record, including all required environmental approvals, a final site plan, and a demonstrated solution to the access deficiency on Tranquil Drive. Thank you for your consideration. I am prepared to speak at the June 16, 2026 hearing and to answer any questions the Board may have. Respectfully submitted, Heather Davidson 12 Tranquil Drive Charleston, SC 29407 6/15/26, 10:50 AM Mail - Swalhah, Christopher - Outlook Outlook 2 Allgood Wappoo Heights - BZA Meeting June 16, 2026 From Lea Clement Date Mon 6/15/2026 9:37 AM To bza-z; Swalhah, Christopher ATTENTION: This email originated from outside the City of Charleston's systems. Do not click links or open attachments unless you are expecting them from the sender and/or have confirmed the content is safe. Forward any suspicious emails by clicking the Phish Alert Button. Dear Members of the Zoning Board, I am writing to respectfully oppose the request for rezoning and residential approval for 2 Allgood Road in Wappoo Heights. My husband and I have called Wappoo Heights home for nearly 30 years, and over that time we have come to deeply appreciate the special character of this neighborhood. It is not just where we live, it is part of our daily lives. We have spent years walking this area, enjoying its quiet, park-like setting. Children have played here, built treehouses, and experienced a sense of openness and connection to nature that is increasingly rare. Once this space is developed, that character is permanently lost. This parcel itself is undersized, nonconforming, and not zoned for residential use. The proposed development is not consistent with the established pattern of Wappoo Heights, which is defined by larger lots, open spacing, and thoughtfully placed homes that respect the surrounding marsh. The applicant has not demonstrated a true hardship; rather, this appears to be an effort to develop a parcel that was simply not intended for residential construction. While we value helping neighbors, zoning relief should not be granted when the hardship is effectively self-created. Beyond these zoning concerns, this land holds real meaning for the neighborhood. The area around Tranquil and Allgood has long functioned as a shared, open space that contributes to the feel and identity of Wappoo Heights. It is my understanding that the original developer family intended this parcel for neighborhood enjoyment, and years ago there was a dock here that residents used. That history speaks to the purpose of this land; as an open, communal space connected to the marsh, not as the site of a private home. There are also important practical considerations. The lot's proximity to the marsh raises concerns about flooding and stormwater management. This space currently serves as a natural buffer, helping to absorb water and protect nearby homes. Development could disrupt these patterns and increase flood risks for surrounding properties. Finally, the proposed structure appears out of scale with nearby homes and would impact the views and overall enjoyment of adjacent properties. Approval of this request would also set a concerning precedent for further nonconforming development, which could gradually change the character of this neighborhood in ways that cannot be undone. For all of these reasons, I respectfully ask that you deny this application and help preserve the character, history, and integrity of Wappoo Heights. Thank you for your time and thoughtful consideration. https://outlook.office.com/mail/inbox/id/MQkADFIM2VIOTYxLWFjYjltNGU1NS05MGRkLTUyYzFkMjgwMjg5YwAQAPmUUuzWaS1BtZU4%2FiOyl80%... 1/2 6/15/26, 10:55 AM Mail - Swalhah, Christopher - Outlook Outlook Formal Opposition to Special Exception Request - 2 Allgood Road From Ellen Lucas Date Mon 6/1 5/2026 10:09 AM To Swalhah, Christopher ATTENTION: This email originated from outside the City of Charleston's systems. Do not click links or open attachments unless you are expecting them from the sender and/or have confirmed the content is safe. Forward any suspicious emails by clicking the Phish Alert Button. Date: June 15, 2026 To: City of Charleston Board of Zoning Appeals - Zoning (BZA-Z) Department of Planning, Preservation, and Sustainability 2 George Street, 1st Floor Charleston, SC 29401 Subject: Formal Opposition to Special Exception Request (Section 54-501) - 2 Allgood Road Applicant / Property Address: 2 Allgood Road, Charleston, SC 29407 Respected Members of the Board, I am writing as a resident of the immediate neighborhood to formally request that the Board DENY the applicant's request for a Special Exception under Section 54-501. The applicant has failed to meet the heavy burden of proof required by the City of Charleston Zoning Ordinance. Specifically, building on a lot of only 6,034 square feet directly conflicts with the explicit intent of Section 54-501 and will permanently alter the character, development pattern, and environmental safety of our neighborhood. Per Section 54-501, a Special Exception for an insufficient lot of record may only be granted if the site plan is "not in conflict with the intent and purposes of this ordinance" and respects local neighborhood patterns. The application fails on the following counts: • Failure to Match Neighborhood Character: There are absolutely no other lots in this neighborhood even close to 6,000 square feet. The vast majority of our surrounding parcels are at least one-third (1/3) acre up to full 1-acre lots. Forcing a micro-lot into a neighborhood built entirely on large acreage creates a severe, jarring density anomaly that shatters the established community fabric. • Severe Environmental and Flooding Risks: This specific property is a critical marshfront lot that actively experiences tidal flooding during King Tides and heavy West Ashley rain events. Forcing a building footprint and impervious surfaces onto an undersized 6,000 square-foot parcel severely reduces the natural absorbent marsh buffer. See attached photo from a https://outlook.office.com/mail/inbox/id/MQkADFIM2VIOTYxLWFjYjltNGU1NS05MGRkLTUyYzFkMjgwMjg5YwAQABKZA1o2KHVDphlBYYss%2BY0... 1/5 6/15/26, 11 :26 AM Outlook Wappoo Heights Zoning From Nancy Jordan Date Mon 6/15/2026 8:33 AM To bza-z lnbox - Swalhah, Christopher - Outlook ATTENTION: This email originated from outside the City of Charleston's systems. Do not click links or open attachments unless you are expecting them from the sender and/or have confirmed the content is safe. Forward any suspicious emails by clicking the Phish Alert Button. Good morning! My family and I have lived in Wappoo Heights for over 30 years. At this point, we have seen many of the long term residents, who we knew when we first moved here, pass away. They would have been shocked at the present situation of the person trying to build on a sliver of land that has remained a favorite spot for anyone in the neighborhood to walk and enjoy the marsh view. Our family would be directly affected because our house at O Devil's Elbow is directly adjacent to the small parcel that is under consideration. We bought directly from the Nash family who had established the subdivision. Our driveway is our street and exiting the driveway to Tranquil Drive would be impacted by having a house in our path! This is not a case of NIMBY~~it is more a case of Not In My Front Yard! The petitioner's dwelling would impact the peaceful, collaborative, attraction of Wappoo Heights and has already caused anxiety and chagrin among us. We are not new neighbor averse. We live peacefully and collaboratively and are fond of our different styles of architecture and our different personalities and lifestyles. But this attempt by the petitioner is just so unfair to the rest of us. Looking forward to Tuesday evening when you will review the appeal of the petitioner re: 2 Allgood. Nancy Youngblood Jordan 0 Devil's Elbow https://outlook.office.com/mail/none/id/AAQk AGRINjhlODYyLWJmNWEtNDZjYS05ZWUyLTc4N2VhMWlwOTBjZgAQAD6XX7NWkSRFqAu3R3ETfuM... 1/1 To: City of Charleston, SC Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning Meeting June 16, 2026 Re: 2 Allgood Rd, Charleston, SC PID 421-13-00-031 We oppose the current application for a special exception. We support the Zoning Administrator's determination in the April 5, 2024 review. 1. The application (under the Precedents section), contains two important inaccuracies:  That 1 Allgood Rd avoids a front setback variance. This is not true. The setback for this property along Allgood road is actually 25' and did not require a variance.  That the 714 square foot structure at 36 Formosa Dr is recently built. Actually, 36 Formosa Dr is the renovated remains of a much larger structure that was destroyed by fire in October 2019. 2. The application (in the Background panel) infers that the Zoning Administrator’s previous denial was based on a flawed application of existing ordinances. However:  Article 3 Sec. 54-301, Table 3.1 of the Zoning Ordinance clearly specifies regulations for District SR-1 as 25 feet front and rear setbacks; 9 feet side setbacks; 9,000 square feet minimum lot size; and 35% maximum lot coverage by buildings.  The survey by Thomas & Hutton, approved by the City Plan Review Committee, indicates the high ground area of the proposed lot is 6,064 square feet – a significant difference.  The minimum setbacks and lot size have been in force and clearly defined in the Zoning Ordinance since May 15, 1996. It is apparent that the Zoning Administrator rightfully exercised the duty to conclude (in the April 5, 2024 review) that the proposal did not meet the requirements of the Ordinance and is thus not flawed as stated in the application. 3. Also in the Background panel, the application infers that a right to construct a single-family dwelling exists pursuant to the South Carolina Vested Rights Act. However, under South Carolina law, a Vested Right is established for two years and five annual renewals upon approval of a site specific development plan. No such approved plan has been submitted. 4. The Charleston County GIS lists the entire parcel containing the portion subject to the application as Class Code: 990 – UNDEVELOPABLE and recorded 08 Aug 2023. Given the length of time from purchase, to project review and to application for special exception, we don’t believe that the applicant should be entitled special consideration for hardship. Jody Smith 16 Formosa Dr, Charleston, SC 29407 6/15/26, 12:45 PM lnbox - Swalhah, Christopher - Outlook Outlook "I oppose the application for special exception for 2 Allgood Rd, and I also signed the neighborhood petition." From Mary T. Barrineau Date Mon 6/15/2026 11 :25 AM To bza-z; Swalhah, Christopher ATTENTION: This email originated from outside the City of Charleston's systems. Do not click links or open attachments unless you are expecting them from the sender and/or have confirmed the content is safe. Forward any suspicious emails by clicking the Phish Alert Button. To: City of Charleston Board of Zoning Appeals - Zoning (BZA-Z) Department of Planning, Preservation, and Sustainability 2 George Street, 1 st Floor Charleston, SC 29401 Respected Members of the Board, I am writing as a resident of the immediate neighborhood to formally request that the Board DENY the applicant's request for a Special Exception under Section 54-501. The applicant has failed to meet the heavy burden of proof required by the City of Charleston Zoning Ordinance. Specifically, building on a lot of only 6,064 square feet directly conflicts with the explicit intent of Section 54-501 and will permanently alter the character, development pattern, and environmental safety of our neighborhood. Per Section 54-501, a Special Exception for an insufficient lot of record may only be granted if the site plan is "not in conflict with the intent and purposes of this ordinance" and respects local neighborhood patterns. The application fails on the following counts: • Failure to Match Neighborhood Character: There are absolutely no other lots in this neighborhood even close to 6,000 square feet. The vast majority of our surrounding parcels are at least one-third (1/3) acre up to full 1-acre lots. Forcing a micro-lot into a neighborhood built entirely on large acreage creates a severe, jarring density anomaly that shatters the established community fabric. • Severe Environmental and Flooding Risks: This specific property is a critical marshfront lot that actively experiences tidal flooding during King Tides and heavy West Ashley rain events. Forcing a building footprint and impervious surfaces onto an undersized 6,000 square-foot parcel severely reduces the natural absorbent marsh buffer. The photo from a December storm that shows the entire lot under water-Not from a hurricane or a predicted weather event. https://outlook.office.com/mail/inbox/id/MQkADFIM2VIOTYxLWFjYjltNGU1NS05MGRkLTUyYzFkMjgwMjg5YwAQAlbsXNVdActEv5Bv30z7GEc%3D?... 1/4 June 15, 2026 RE: Agenda Item B-15 – 2 Allgood Road (TMS 421-13-00-031) Dear Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals, I respectfully request that the Board uphold the Zoning Administrator's determination and deny the applicant's request under Section 54-501 of the Charleston Zoning Ordinance. Section 54-501 does not create an automatic right to build on a lot of insufficient size. Rather, it provides that the Board may authorize a permitted use only when the proposed site plan is deemed not to conflict with the intent and purposes of the Charleston Zoning Ordinance. The burden rests with the applicant to demonstrate that this standard has been met. The applicant has not met that burden. First, this property is fundamentally different from a conventional residential lot in Wappoo Heights. While the parcel encompasses approximately 10.43 acres, the overwhelming majority consists of marshland. Development is proposed on a limited, isolated upland area within a largely marsh- dominated site. The practical development characteristics of this property are substantially different from those in the neighborhood. The proposed buildable area is 30% the size of lots in the neighborhood, 20% the size of the adjoining parcel at 1 Algood and 6% the size of the adjoining parcel at 12 Palmetto. The small footprint necessitates the construction of a home which is completely out of character for the neighborhood. Second, creating an address with the GIS 911 Addressing Coordinator does not give you right to build a house on the lot despite not meeting the zoning requirements. The GIS 911 Addressing Coordinator only gave the applicant an Allgood Road address rather than a Tranquil Drive address because “of the front door location” the applicant himself submitted. The 10+ acre lot fronts Tranquil drive. If the applicant wants to make the claim that he can combine non-contiguous upland areas over 600 feet apart, he should also have to uphold that the parcel fronts Tranquil drive for more than 800 feet and only touches approximately 10 feet of Allgood. For this reason, and in agreement with the City of Charleston Zoning Administrator’s decision, the parcel fronts Tranquil Drive and should be subject to those setbacks listed in 54-301 table 3.1 Third, the property is subject to significant environmental considerations. The parcel abuts a salt marsh and is affected by critical line and buffer requirements intended to protect Charleston's coastal resources. The City has adopted these regulations specifically to preserve environmentally sensitive areas and protect water quality, marsh habitat, and shoreline character. Approval of residential development on this site would be inconsistent with those purposes unless full compliance with all applicable critical line, buffer, and environmental protection requirements has been clearly demonstrated. This area of “high-ground” has flooded on at least two occasions, including 2019 and 2024. Additionally, a relatively nominal 6.4 foot tide was experienced this past Saturday show water up to the edge of the “high ground”. (See attached photographs) Fourth, historical documents associated with the original Wappoo Heights subdivision identify the high- ground in question as "The Landing," a waterfront recreational area established by George Nash for the use and enjoyment of neighborhood residents and their guests. For approximately one hundred years, the property remained undeveloped and functioned as a community waterfront amenity. The applicant has not demonstrated that this area was ever intended to serve as an individual residential lot. Finally, the applicant purchased this property with full knowledge of its physical characteristics, development limitations, marsh conditions, and regulatory constraints. The parcel was purchased for $20,000 in Aug 2023. According to the County’s Register of Deeds, the parcel has a Class Code of “990 – UNDEVELOPABLE”. The applicant knew, or should have known, this property could not be built upon. Despite its large 10.43-acre footprint, its market value is heavily discounted due to the unbuildable classification. The inability to construct a residence on the property is not an economic hardship created by a recent change in law or circumstance; it is a condition that has existed for generations and was readily apparent at the time of purchase. The Board should also carefully consider the broad implications of approving this application under Section 54-501. This case will inevitably guide future applicants, property owners, City staff, and future Boards when evaluating similar requests. If a predominantly marsh parcel with fragmented upland areas, environmental constraints, and a century-long history of non-development is found to be consistent with the intent and purposes of the ordinance, it becomes difficult to distinguish this property from other similarly situated marsh-edge parcels throughout Charleston. The City has spent decades developing regulations intended to balance private property rights with the protection of Charleston's unique marshes, waterways, natural resources, and historic neighborhood character. Approval of this application would significantly expand the circumstances under which Section 54-501 may be used and risks weakening the effectiveness of the City's minimum lot size standards, critical line protections, and longstanding environmental policies. For all of these reasons, I respectfully request that the Board determine that the proposed site plan conflicts with the intent and purposes of the Charleston Zoning Ordinance and deny the application. Thank you for your consideration. Christopher Stang 28 Formosa Drive 6-13-26 6.4’ high tide December 17, 2023 September 11, 2017 Speaking Points (2–3 Minutes) total Strategic Advice for the Hearing If multiple neighbors speak, avoid repeating the same points. Divide the topics: 1. Speaker 1: §54-501 and ordinance intent. 2. Speaker 2: Historical use of The Landing and community history. 3. Speaker 3: Critical line, marsh buffer, and environmental protections. 4. Speaker 4: Future implications for Charleston and interpretation of §54-501. 5. Speaker 5: Neighborhood character and consistency with the original purpose of the property. That approach gives the Board a complete record and is generally more effective than having ten people deliver the same statement. Talking Points Good evening. My name is [Name], and I respectfully ask the Board to uphold the Zoning Administrator's determination and deny this request. The most important point in this case is Section 54-501 itself. The question before the Board is not whether this parcel appears on a historic plat, has a tax map number, or whether a house can physically fit on a portion of the property. Section 54-501 allows the Board to approve development on a lot of insufficient size only if the proposed site plan is not in conflict with the intent and purposes of the Charleston Zoning Ordinance. The applicant has not demonstrated that standard has been met. First, this is not a conventional residential lot. Although the parcel contains approximately 10.5 acres, the overwhelming majority of the property is marshland, with only limited upland areas available for development. Second, the property is directly affected by critical line and buffer protections that exist to protect Charleston's marshes and waterways. The Board should not conclude that this proposal is consistent with the intent of the ordinance until those issues are fully resolved. Third, the historical record indicates that this area was known as "The Landing," a community waterfront recreation area established for the use of Wappoo Heights residents and their guests. The property remained undeveloped for approximately one hundred years. That history strongly suggests that this property was never intended to function as a conventional residential homesite. I would also ask the Board to consider the significance of its interpretation of Section 54-501. I understand that every case is unique. However, if a predominantly marsh parcel with fragmented upland areas, environmental constraints, and a century-long history of non-development is found to be consistent with the intent and purposes of the ordinance, it becomes difficult to explain why similar parcels throughout Charleston should not receive the same treatment. This case is bigger than a single house. It involves how Section 54-501 will be interpreted for future marsh-edge properties throughout the City. The City has adopted minimum lot size requirements, critical line protections, and environmental safeguards for a reason. Those protections should not be weakened through an overly broad application of Section 54-501. Finally, the applicant purchased this property with knowledge of its existing conditions and limitations. The inability to develop the property is not a newly created hardship. It is a condition that has existed for decades. For these reasons, I respectfully request that the Board find that the proposed site plan conflicts with the intent and purposes of the Charleston Zoning Ordinance and deny the application. Thank you. 6/15/26, 1:27 PM lnbox - Swalhah, Christopher - Outlook Outlook Objection to Application No. 15 (2 Allgood Rd) - Board of Zoning Appeals PID 421-13-00-031 From Jennifer Latimer Date Mon 6/1 5/2026 10:04 AM To bza-z ATTENTION: This email originated from outside the City of Charleston's systems. Do not click links or open attachments unless you are expecting them from the sender and/or have confirmed the content is safe. Forward any suspicious emails by clicking the Phish Alert Button. Good Morning, I am a resident of the Wappoo Heights neighborhood and respectfully oppose the application for special exception for 2 Allgood Rd. I urge the Board to uphold the Zoning Administrator's decision denying the requested Special Exception. The City of Charleston Zoning Administrator properly applied the ordinance and did not abuse his discretion. The proposed building site does not contain the required 9,000 square feet of contiguous high ground upon which development may occur, a deficiency that has been communicated to the Applicant for the past two years. Approving this application would effectively grant development rights to a property that has historically been recognized as undevelopable and would undermine the consistent application of the City's zoning regulations. Thank you, Jennifer Latimer Wildstein 7 Palmetto Road Charleston, SC 29407 https://outlook.office.com/mail/none/id/AAQkAGRINjhlODYyLWJmNWEtNDZjYS05ZWUyLTc4N2VhMWlwOTBjZgAQAKYkVhyJr8IGh7wCBgkVUVk%3... 1/1 To: City of Charleston, SC Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning Meeting June 16, 2026 Re: Objection to Application No. 15 (2 Allgood Rd) – Board of Zoning Appeals PID 421-13-00-031 Good evening. My name is JP Byrne, and I am a resident of Wappoo Heights. Although I cannot be here tonight, I respectfully ask that these comments be entered into the record. I respectfully urge the Board to deny this appeal and preserve this unique property. Charleston has experienced tremendous growth over the last several decades. New homes, new development, and increasing demand have changed the character of many neighborhoods throughout our city. Growth is inevitable, but preserving what makes Charleston special requires intentional decisions. This property represents one of those decisions. I moved away from this neighborhood for a period of time and later chose to return because of what makes this area unique. The mature trees, the marsh views, the open space, and the feeling that nature still has a meaningful presence here are increasingly rare in Charleston. I have watched other neighborhoods change over time as development has continued. While growth has brought many benefits, it has also diminished some of the natural beauty and character that originally attracted people to those communities. Throughout the materials submitted to the Board, the applicant emphasizes the marsh views, open space, waterfront setting, and unique natural character of this property. I agree that these qualities make this a special place. But those qualities are not necessarily a reason to develop it. They may be the very reason it deserves to remain preserved. In many cases, the things that make a property most desirable for development are the same things that make it most worthy of protection. In fact, the reason this applicant wants to build here is the same reason many of us believe it should remain undeveloped. The value of this property is not simply that a house can be placed on it. Its value comes from the open waterfront landscape, the natural setting, the wildlife habitat, and the sense of place it provides to everyone who experiences it. Those qualities benefit the entire neighborhood every day. Once a home is built, those qualities can never be fully restored. This Board has an opportunity to think beyond what can be built and consider what should be preserved. Not every open space in Charleston must become a building site simply because a building can fit there. 1 Growth should occur in appropriate places, but we also have a responsibility to protect the landscapes that define our community and distinguish Charleston from every other growing city. We do not have many opportunities left to choose conservation over construction. This Board cannot reverse decades of growth across Charleston, but tonight it can decide whether one more unique waterfront landscape remains open or becomes another house. Future generations will never criticize us for preserving too much natural beauty. They may, however , wonder why we failed to protect it when we still had the chance. I respectfully ask you to choose preservation and deny this appeal. Thank you for your time and consideration. Respectfully submitted, JP Byrne Wappoo Heights Resident 2 To: City of Charleston, SC Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning Meeting June 16, 2026 Re: Objection to Application No. 15 (2 Allgood Rd ) – Board of Zoning Appeals PID 421-13-00-031 To the Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals: I am a resident of the Wappoo Heights neighborhood and respectfully object to Application No. 15. I urge the Board to uphold the Zoning Administrator's decision denying the requested Special Exception. The subject property has historically been considered undevelopable and has never functioned as a buildable residential lot. Since the time of the Nash family, the original developers of Wappoo Heights, the property was used as a neighborhood waterfront access point known as "The Landing, " which served as a community dock prior to Hurricane Hugo. The Applicant purchased the property for approximately $20,000, consisting of marshland and two separate areas of upland. As correctly determined by the City of Charleston Department of Planning, Preservation & Sustainability, neither upland area independently satisfies the requirements for a Special Exception. The purchase price reflects the nature of the property being conveyed: undevelopable marshland and two isolated parcels of high ground. The fact that these areas share a single TMS number or appear on a single plat should not control the outcome. The upland areas are physically separated by marshland and do not constitute a contiguous buildable lot. Administrative designation alone cannot create development rights where the zoning requirements have not been met. The City of Charleston Zoning Administrator properly applied the ordinance and did not abuse his discretion. The proposed building site does not contain the required 9,000 square feet of contiguous high ground upon which development may occur, a deficiency that has been communicated to the Applicant for the past two years. Approving this application would effectively grant development rights to a property that has historically been recognized as undevelopable and would undermine the consistent application of the City's zoning regulations. For these reasons, I respectfully request that the Board affirm the Zoning Administrator's decision and deny Application No. 15. Respectfully submitted, Constantine P . Copses Wappoo Heights Resident 5 Nashmor Road Charleston, SC 29407 To: City of Charleston, SC Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning Meeting June 16, 2026 Re: Objection to Application No. 15 (2 Allgood Rd ) – Board of Zoning Appeals PID 421 -13- 00-031 To the Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals: I have lived on Allgood Road in Wappoo Heights for over 30 years and also spent countless hours here as a child, especially at the Landing, the waterfront recreational commons set aside for that purpose by the original owner and developer, Mr. George Nash in 1924. For over one hundred years, Wappoo Heights residents have been afforded free and unimpeded access to this pristine marsh upland, now suddenly the site of the proposed siting of a single family home by the applicant. The beauty and character of the neighborhood has been defined by the Landing’s presence as well as the marsh land along Tranquil drive, property which, though it appears on tax maps, has never been subdivided or platted for single family home siting. I write this comment from my perspective as an environmental scientist, with specific training and expertise on salt marsh ecosystem services, especially the degree to which they must be protected to most fully attenuate storm surge energy and mitigate loss of both lives and property. Even with a fully intact, undeveloped marsh and upland at the end of Allgood, homes along this street have experienced significant storm surge flooding in both Hurricane Irma (Sept. 11, 2017) and the December 17, 2023 Nor’Easter. I have a duty and a responsibility to implore that the zoning regulations—established at the City, County, and State levels that would prohibit development like that proposed on this marsh upland so as to protect public health, wellness, and safety—be enforced. Significantly, this property, including all of its marsh uplands, has been assessed as a Class 990 vacant, UNDEVELOPABLE land in a FEMA Special Flood Hazard Zone AE-10. It is situated in the riparian zone of jurisdictional wetland and below the elevation recommended by the City Comprehensive Water Plan for development as a flood hazard risk prevention measure. Since 1978, The City of Charleston has mandated a Type L Buffer under Section 54-347.1 and Section 54-348 of the City of Charleston Zoning Ordinance to protect SCDHEC-OCRM critical lines: The width of a Type L Buffer for a Neighborhood District zone is a 40 foot minimum. Charleston County actually requires a 50-foot setback of undisturbed natural vegetative buffer (Riparian Zone) along coastal marshes for many reasons: To protect wetland ecology, stabilize the soil, protect from erosion, filter stormwater runoff, and attenuate dangerous storm surge energy, thus mitigating flood hazard risk to the nearby community. Prohibited Activities and Restrictions under Section 54-347.1 and Section 54-348 include the addition of impervious surfaces or the construction of any permanent structures within the buffer zone. Please note Tranquil Drive, which fronts the property and which lies in this required riparian buffer zone, is itself unpaved. In summary, this variance request in no way meets the test for its approval: • The permit application has already been denied by a City zoning administrator with decades of experience, based on the fact that the lot is of insufficient size for a single family home in a neighborhood long zoned as SR-1. • The proposed development could jeopardize the health, wellness, and safety of residents along Allgood by amplifying their flood hazard risk and cutting off cooling sea breezes from Wappoo Cut • The proposed development would cause substantial detriment to the character of our neighborhood and restrict or prohibit the utilization of the property as a neighborhood recreational commons, an affordance enjoyed by residents for over 100 years. I respectfully urge the board to uphold the Zoning Administrator's decision denying the requested Special Exception With regard, 11 Allgood Road Wappoo Heights Neighborhood Resident Since 1992 Charleston, SC, 20407 B-15: 2 Allgood Rd. 20 Comments Submitted on Innovate Site First Name Last Name Address Comment Submitted: Robert Newman 20 Formosa Dr. Charleston, SC 29407 To: City of Charleston, SC Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning Meeting June 16, 2026 Re:Objection to Application No. 15 (2 Allgood Rd ) – Board of Zoning Appeals PID 421-13-00- 031 To the Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals: I have been a resident of Wappoo Heights for 41 years, and respectfully object to Application No. 15. I urge the Board to uphold the Zoning Administrator's decision denying the requested Special Exception. I personally knew Miss. Lorena Nash, Mrs. Fortunato, Mrs. McCrae, and Mrs. Junie Polk, what the present residents call the original residents. The subject property has historically been considered a playground for our children. This property known as “Devil’s Elbow” dock was used as a neighborhood waterfront access point, which had a community dock. All the local children, including my two kids, would use the dock for crabbing. I was Present of the “Devil’s Elbow Dock Club “prior to Hurricane Hugo which took it out. The City of Charleston Zoning Administrator properly applied the ordinance. The proposed building site does not contain the required footage upon which development may occur. Approving this application would effectively grant development rights to a property that has historically been recognized as undevelopable and would undermine the idea of a community development. In which Wappoo Heights is one of the best in Charleston. For these reasons, I respectfully request that the Board affirm the Zoning Administrator's decision and deny Application No. 15. Respectfully submitted, Robert N. Newman 41-year resident of Wappoo HeightsHouse Phone: 843-571-2011 20 Formosa Drive Charleston, SC 29407 Jun 13 2026 1:28PM Ellen Durrence 1 Formosa Dr.., Charleston, SC The Wappoo Heights neighborhood was established about 80 years ago with specific criteria for the lot sizes, home sizes to establish a pleasant small neighborhood. It was NOT established for tiny houses on slivers of land and it was definitely NOT established to fill in the marsh in order to create land on which to build. The small home referenced in the application is what was salvaged from a disastrous home fire. This project DEFINITELY NEEDS TO BE DENIED! Jun 13 2026 5:42PM Dr. Hugh Durrence 1 Formosa Dr.., Charleston, SC To: City of Charleston, SC Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning Meeting June 16, 2026 Re:Objection to Application No. 15 (2 Allgood Rd ) – Board of Zoning Appeals PID 421-13-00- 031 To the Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals: I am a resident of the Wappoo Heights neighborhood and respectfully object to Application No. 15. I urge the Board to uphold the Zoning Administrator's decision denying the requested Special Exception. The subject property has Jun 13 2026 6:00PM historically been considered undevelopable and has never functioned as a buildable residential lot. Since the time of the Nash family, the original developers of Wappoo Heights, the property was used as a neighborhood waterfront access point known as "The Landing," which served as a community dock prior to Hurricane Hugo. The Applicant purchased the property for approximately $20,000, consisting of marshland and two separate areas of upland. As correctly determined by the City of Charleston Department of Planning, Preservation & Sustainability, neither upland area independently satisfies the requirements for a Special Exception. The purchase price reflects the nature of the property being conveyed: undevelopable marshland and two isolated parcels of high ground. The fact that these areas share a single TMS number or appear on a single plat should not control the outcome. The upland areas are physically separated by marshland and do not constitute a contiguous buildable lot. Administrative designation alone cannot create development rights where the zoning requirements have not been met. The City of Charleston Zoning Administrator properly applied the ordinance and did not abuse his discretion. The proposed building site does not contain the required 9,000 square feet of contiguous high ground upon which development may occur, a deficiency that has been communicated to the Applicant for the past two years. Approving this application would effectively grant development rights to a property that has historically been recognized as undevelopable and would undermine the consistent application of the City's zoning regulations. For these reasons, I respectfully request that the Board affirm the Zoning Administrator's decision and deny Application No. 15. Respectfully submitted, Hugh D. Durrence, MD Wappoo Heights Resident 1 Formosa Drive Ann H Wappoo Heights I am opposed to the precedence that this exemption to our current zoning regulations would set. This is an old neighborhood with homes originally required to be set on a half an acre NOT 25 ft of dirt next to a neighborhood road. The only small structure that this project is being compared to is what remains of a horrible house fire that destroyed the rest of the original, much larger home on Formosa Drive. This property will not remain as it is in the future. We oppose the precedence of what this exemption would set , and it would destroy our historic neighborhood and its long standing regulations already in place. Also, this proposed development would highly impact the marsh that it is a part of considering any run off or proposed underground infrastructure would have no buffer at all between its existence and the current marsh line. The current water line has already shown that this small piece of dirt is quickly eroding compared to what it was during the development of the neighborhood. This was NEVER meant to be a structured property. It was originally used as Jun 13 2026 7:35PM a platform to the dock that this neighborhood once used before a hurricane took that away. I have lived in this neighborhood my entire life. I was born in Charleston, and I simply ask that you please keep this neighborhood as it was historically intended just as you would consider doing for the neighboring Crescent. We do not want to see our neighborhood destroyed by this precedence, and it would set a bad precedence for any neighborhood near it. Please do not let this marshland be destroyed either. Jane N Hughes 10 Formosa Dr. To: City of Charleston, SC Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning Meeting June 16, 2026 Re:Objection to Application No. 15 (2 Allgood Rd ) – Board of Zoning Appeals PID 421-13-00- 031 To the Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals: I am a resident of the Wappoo Heights neighborhood and respectfully object to Application No. 15. I urge the Board to uphold the Zoning Administrator's decision denying the requested Special Exception. The subject property has historically been considered undevelopable and has never functioned as a buildable residential lot. Since the time of the Nash family, the original developers of Wappoo Heights, the property was used as a neighborhood waterfront access point known as "The Landing," which served as a community dock prior to Hurricane Hugo. The Applicant purchased the property for approximately $20,000, consisting of marshland and two separate areas of upland. As correctly determined by the City of Charleston Department of Planning, Preservation & Sustainability, neither upland area independently satisfies the requirements for a Special Exception. The purchase price reflects the nature of the property being conveyed: undevelopable marshland and two isolated parcels of high ground. The fact that these areas share a single TMS number or appear on a single plat should not control the outcome. The upland areas are physically separated by marshland and do not constitute a contiguous buildable lot. Administrative designation alone cannot create development rights where the zoning requirements have not been met. The City of Charleston Zoning Administrator properly applied the ordinance and did not abuse his discretion. The proposed building site does not contain the required 9,000 square feet of contiguous high ground upon which development may occur, a deficiency that has been communicated to the Applicant for the past two years. Approving this application would effectively grant development rights to a property that has historically been recognized as undevelopable and would undermine the consistent application of the City's zoning regulations. For these reasons, I respectfully request that the Board affirm the Zoning Administrator's decision and deny Application No. 15. Respectfully submitted, Jane N Hughes (Jane Bryant Neill, FKA) Wappoo Heights Resident 10 Formosa Dr. Charleston SC 29407 Jun 14 2026 1:18PM Elizabeth Smith 32 Formosa Drive Charleston, SC 29407 To: City of Charleston, SC Board of Zoning Appeals-Zoning Meeting June 16, 2026 Re:Objection to Application No. 15 (2 Allgood Rd ) – Board of Zoning Appeals PID 421-13-00- 031 To the Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals: I am a resident of the Wappoo Heights neighborhood and respectfully object to Application No. 15. I urge the Board to uphold the Zoning Administrator's decision denying the requested Special Exception. The subject property has historically been considered undevelopable and has never functioned as a buildable residential lot. Since the time of the Nash family, the original developers of Wappoo Heights, the property was used as a neighborhood waterfront access point known as "The Landing," which served as a community dock prior to Hurricane Hugo. The Applicant purchased the property for approximately $20,000, consisting of marshland and two separate areas of upland. As correctly determined by the City of Charleston Department of Planning, Preservation & Sustainability, neither upland area independently satisfies the requirements for a Special Exception. The purchase price reflects the nature of the property being conveyed: undevelopable marshland and two isolated parcels of high ground. The fact that these areas share a single TMS number or appear on a single plat should not control the outcome. The upland areas are physically separated by marshland and do not constitute a contiguous buildable lot. Administrative designation alone cannot create development rights where the zoning requirements have not been met. The City of Charleston Zoning Administrator properly applied the ordinance and did not abuse his discretion. The proposed building site does not contain the required 9,000 square feet of contiguous high ground upon which development may occur, a deficiency that has been communicated to the Applicant for the past two years. Approving this application would effectively grant development rights to a property that has historically been recognized as undevelopable and would undermine the consistent application of the City's zoning regulations. For these reasons, I respectfully request that the Board affirm the Zoning Administrator's decision and deny Application No. 15. Respectfully submitted, Elizabeth Smith,
 Wappoo Heights Resident
: 32 Formosa Drive Jun 14 2026 4:13PM Christopher Betros 7 Nashmor Road - Charleston, SC 29407 The applicant purchased this property with full knowledge of its development limitations. The parcel does not meet the City's minimum lot size requirements, fails to satisfy required setbacks—particularly those associated with the critical line—and is therefore unsuitable for development under existing regulations. Approving this request would establish an unfortunate precedent within the City of Charleston by allowing development that disregards longstanding protections for environmentally sensitive wetlands. Such a decision could encourage similar requests in the future and undermine the integrity of the City's land- Jun 14 2026 5:37PM use and environmental standards. Additionally, several examples cited in support of the applicant's appeal appear to be materially different from the subject property and do not provide an appropriate basis for comparison. For these reasons, I respectfully and firmly oppose this project and request that the appeal be denied. Thank you for your consideration. Respectfully, Chris Betros 7 Nashmor Road M. Ross Armstrong 134 Folly Rd Blvd To the Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals: I am a resident of the Wappoo Heights neighborhood and respectfully object to Application No. 15. I urge the Board to uphold the Zoning Administrator's decision denying the requested Special Exception. The subject property has historically been considered undevelopable and has never functioned as a buildable residential lot. Since the time of the Nash family, the original developers of Wappoo Heights, the property was used as a neighborhood waterfront access point known as "The Landing," which served as a community dock prior to Hurricane Hugo. The Applicant purchased the property for approximately $20,000, consisting of marshland and two separate areas of upland. As correctly determined by the City of Charleston Department of Planning, Preservation & Sustainability, neither upland area independently satisfies the requirements for a Special Exception. The purchase price reflects the nature of the property being conveyed: undevelopable marshland and two isolated parcels of high ground. The fact that these areas share a single TMS number or appear on a single plat should not control the outcome. The upland areas are physically separated by marshland and do not constitute a contiguous buildable lot. Administrative designation alone cannot create development rights where the zoning requirements have not been met. The City of Charleston Zoning Administrator properly applied the ordinance and did not abuse his discretion. The proposed building site does not contain the required 9,000 square feet of contiguous high ground upon which development may occur, a deficiency that has been communicated to the Applicant for the past two years. Approving this application would effectively grant development rights to a property that has historically been recognized as undevelopable and would undermine the consistent application of the City's zoning regulations. For these reasons, I respectfully request that the Board affirm the Zoning Administrator's decision and deny Application No. 15. Respectfully submitted, M Ross Armstrong Jun 15 2026 7:44AM Heather Davidson 12 Tranquil Drive, Charleston, SC 29407 I am a resident of Wappoo Heights and I oppose the application for special exception for 2 Allgood Rd, I signed the neighborhood petition and have provided more detailed comments below: Dear Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals and Mr. Swalhah: I am writing as a long- time resident of Wappoo Heights, residing at 12 Tranquil Drive, to formally oppose the appeal filed by Dean Yarborough (Agenda Item B-15) regarding the property at Jun 15 2026 9:26AM 2 Allgood Road, TMS No. 421-13-00-031. Mr. Yarborough is asking this Board to overturn the May 1, 2026 determination of the Zoning Administrator, which correctly required him to obtain a Special Exception under Section 54-501 before constructing a single-family home on a lot of insufficient contiguous high ground. Rather than bypassing that process through this appeal, Mr. Yarborough should be required to proceed through the Special Exception pathway, which would allow the Board to review the proposed development in its entirety – including site-specific conditions, access, environmental review status, neighbor impacts, and compatibility with the surrounding neighborhood – before any authorization is granted. The appellant’s argument that the City’s 60-day inaction constitutes deemed approval under S.C. Code § 6- 29-1150(A) is a legal matter for the Board to assess carefully; however, even if that argument had merit as a procedural matter, it should not substitute for the substantive review that the Special Exception process is designed to provide. I respectfully urge the Board to uphold that determination and deny the appeal. In the alternative, if the Board elects to treat this matter as a Special Exception application, I submit that the applicant has not provided sufficient evidence for the Board to make the required findings, and that the request should be denied on that basis as well. I. The Applicant Has Not Demonstrated Compliance with Applicable Zoning Requirements The SR-1 zoning district requires a minimum lot area of 9,000 square feet of high ground. The subject parcel, while totaling 10.427 acres overall, contains only approximately 0.357 acres (15,589 sq. ft.) of upland, scattered across multiple disconnected high-ground areas. The primary proposed building site, Upland 1, contains only 6,064 square feet – well below the 9,000 square foot minimum. A second upland area, Upland 6, contains 8,310 square feet but is separated from Upland 1 by marsh and open water. The applicant contends that these disconnected upland areas may be aggregated to satisfy the SR-1 minimum. That argument is not supported by the ordinance. The Zoning Administrator and Planning Director have both correctly concluded that the minimum lot area standard requires contiguous high ground sufficient to provide adequate area for development. Allowing an applicant to stitch together isolated marsh islands to meet a dimensional standard would render the SR-1 lot area requirement meaningless for parcels in tidal and wetland environments. The applicant has also not demonstrated compliance with front setback requirements in a straightforward manner. The address and front-of-lot designation were only recently assigned by the City’s GIS Division, and the setback analysis in the preliminary site plan depends entirely on that assignment. The Board should scrutinize whether the setback configuration presented truly satisfies SR-1 dimensional standards as written, not as reinterpreted to accommodate a favorable address assignment. II. The Proposed Site Plan Is Not Consistent with the Intent and Purposes of Section 54-501 or the Zoning Ordinance Section 54-501 authorizes the Board to permit development on a lot of record of insufficient size – but only upon approval of a site plan deemed consistent with the intent and purposes of the zoning ordinance. That standard is not automatically satisfied simply because a building can be placed on a parcel without exceeding dimensional limits. The Board must affirmatively find that the proposed development is consistent with the ordinance’s broader purposes. The zoning ordinance’s SR-1 district is designed to protect low- density residential neighborhoods and to ensure that development occurs on lots with adequate buildable area. Placing a two-story, 34-foot structure on a 6,064-square- foot island of high ground surrounded almost entirely by tidal marsh does not serve those purposes. The proposed development would occupy 19.1% of the only upland area on which it would be built, with virtually no buffer from the surrounding marsh. This is not the type of residential infill development that Section 54-501 was designed to accommodate; it is an attempt to develop a parcel that is, for practical purposes, a marsh lot. III. The Request Is Not Consistent with the Character and Development Pattern of Wappoo Heights Wappoo Heights is one of the oldest residential neighborhoods in West Ashley, established in 1924 by George Albert Nash from land that was once part of the Crescent Plantation. The neighborhood was built around its relationship to the marshes of Wappoo Creek – residents crabbed, shrimped, and swam from a dock on the creek, built tree houses in the grand live oaks, and formed bonds that became, as one community historian wrote, “part of the mortar of Wappoo Heights.” That character endures today in the tree-canopied streets, the marsh views, and the quiet, low-density residential fabric of the neighborhood. The parcel at 2 Allgood Road has never had a home on it. It is over 96% tidal marsh and sits directly on the Wappoo Cut/Intracoastal Waterway. The surrounding residential lots on Palmetto Road, Tranquil Drive, and Allgood Road are established homes on conventionally sized, primarily upland lots. Constructing a new residence on what is effectively a marsh island – accessible only via a narrow, unpaved, single-lane road – is not consistent with that development pattern. The nearest home at 1 Allgood Road is approximately 120 feet away; the nearest home at 12 Palmetto Road is approximately 300 feet away. Those distances reflect not proximity of neighbors but the extent of intervening marsh. The proposed development would introduce a new structure into a setting that has remained undeveloped for exactly the reasons the zoning ordinance is designed to protect. IV. The Applicant Has Not Provided Sufficient Evidence for the Board to Make the Required Findings To the extent the Board considers this matter as a Special Exception application, Section 54-501 requires that the Board approve a site plan it deems consistent with the intent and purposes of the ordinance before authorizing any use. The applicant has submitted only a preliminary site plan, and significant required information remains absent from the record. Specifically, the record before the Board does not include: a completed environmental review or OCRM permitting determination (the applicant’s own materials list “OCRM consultation” as an outstanding task); final civil engineering, utility permitting, or stormwater management documentation; confirmation of adequate water and sewer service to Upland 1; a traffic or access analysis for Tranquil Drive; or an independent assessment of the critical line location on Upland 1. The applicant has acknowledged that architectural refinement, soil testing, builder selection, and landscape design are all still outstanding. A board cannot make findings required by the ordinance on the basis of incomplete preliminary materials. Approving a Special Exception for a marsh-front parcel of this sensitivity without a complete record would be an abuse of the discretion Section 54-501 is meant to channel, not eliminate. The Board should require a complete application before making any determination. V. Environmental, Critical Line, Marsh Buffer, and Other Regulatory Requirements Have Not Been Adequately Addressed The subject parcel is one of the most environmentally sensitive parcels in this part of the City. It is located within FEMA Flood Zone AE-10 and surrounded by the tidal marshes and open water of Wappoo Creek and the Atlantic Intracoastal Waterway. The OCRM Critical Line runs through Upland 1 – the very area where the proposed structure would be sited. The applicant’s own preliminary site plan identifies this critical line but does not resolve it; OCRM consultation is listed as a future task. Section 54- 347.1 of the City’s Zoning Ordinance establishes critical line buffer requirements that apply to development near tidal wetlands. While the applicant has cited the parcel’s status as a platted lot of record as grounds for exemption from those buffer requirements under Section 54-344, that exemption does not eliminate the need for OCRM approval, Army Corps of Engineers review, or compliance with all applicable state and federal coastal resource regulations. None of those reviews have been completed. The Board should not grant any relief that would accelerate development of this parcel ahead of the environmental review process. Additionally, the water and sewer infrastructure shown in the City’s mapping does not appear to extend to Upland 1. The applicant has not explained how potable water, sanitary sewer, or stormwater management would be provided to and from the proposed building site in a manner consistent with applicable regulations. These are not minor details – they are foundational to any determination that a site plan is adequate for development approval. VI. Access via Tranquil Drive Is Inadequate and Presents a Public Safety Concern As the resident of 12 Tranquil Drive, I can personally attest that Tranquil Drive is a narrow, unpaved, single-lane road. Its effective width is reduced to approximately 12 feet in places. It cannot safely accommodate two-way residential traffic or multiple construction vehicles. The applicant has provided no access analysis, no proposed road improvements and no plan for storage of materials during construction. Approving development on this parcel without resolving the access deficiency would create an ongoing public safety hazard for existing residents. Conclusion The Zoning Administrator’s May 1, 2026 determination was correct, and this Board should uphold it. The applicant has not demonstrated compliance with applicable zoning requirements, has not shown that the proposed development is consistent with the intent and purposes of the ordinance, has not demonstrated compatibility with the established character and development pattern of Wappoo Heights, has not provided sufficient evidence for the Board to make required findings, and has not addressed critical environmental, regulatory, and access concerns. Wappoo Heights is a historically significant neighborhood whose character is defined in large part by its relationship to the surrounding marsh. That character deserves the protection that the zoning ordinance provides. I respectfully urge the Board to deny Mr. Yarborough’s appeal and to require that any future application for development of this parcel proceed through the full Special Exception review process with a complete record, including all required environmental approvals, a final site plan, and a demonstrated solution to the access deficiency on Tranquil Drive. Thank you for your consideration. I am prepared to speak at the June 16, 2026 hearing and to answer any questions the Board may have. Respectfully submitted, Heather Davidson 12 Tranquil Drive Charleston, SC 29407 Lindsey Stang 28 Formosa Drive, Charleston, SC 29407 June 15, 2026 RE: Agenda Item B-15 – 2 Allgood Road (TMS 421-13-00-031) Dear Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals, My name is Lindsey Stang, and I am a resident of Wappoo Heights. I am writing to respectfully request that the Board uphold the Zoning Administrator's decision and deny the applicant's request for a Special Exception under Section 54-501. In reviewing both the application and the intent of Section 54-501, I do not believe the applicant has demonstrated that the proposed site plan is consistent with the purpose and intent of Charleston's zoning regulations. While Section 54-501 allows the Board to consider development on a lot that Jun 15 2026 9:36AM does not meet minimum lot size requirements, approval is discretionary and should only occur when the proposal does not conflict with the broader objectives of the ordinance. One of my primary concerns is that this property is not comparable to a typical residential lot in Wappoo Heights. Although the parcel contains approximately 10.43 acres, nearly all of that acreage consists of marshland. The proposed home would be confined to a small isolated upland area whose development characteristics are substantially different from surrounding properties. The buildable area is significantly smaller than neighboring lots and, in my opinion, requires a development approach that is inconsistent with the established character of the neighborhood. I am also concerned by the applicant's reliance on the recently assigned Allgood Road address as support for the proposal. The GIS 911 Addressing Coordinator's assignment of an address is an administrative function and does not determine zoning compliance or development rights. The parcel has extensive frontage along Tranquil Drive and only minimal frontage along Allgood Road. Consistent with the Zoning Administrator's determination, I believe the property should be evaluated based on its frontage along Tranquil Drive and the corresponding setback requirements contained within the zoning ordinance. Environmental conditions on the property further distinguish this parcel from other residential lots. The site is adjacent to sensitive marshland resources and is subject to critical line and buffer requirements intended to protect Charleston's coastal environment. These regulations exist for an important reason and should not be minimized when evaluating whether a site plan is consistent with the intent of the ordinance. Additionally, residents have observed flooding in this area on multiple occasions, including recent events. Photographs submitted as part of the public record demonstrate the site's vulnerability to tidal and stormwater impacts. The history of this property is also relevant. Historical documents associated with the original Wappoo Heights subdivision identify this upland area as "The Landing," a waterfront recreational space intended for use by neighborhood residents and their guests. For generations, the property remained undeveloped and served as a community amenity. The applicant has not demonstrated that this area was ever intended to function as an independent residential lot. Another important consideration is that the applicant purchased the property with full knowledge of its limitations. Public records classified the parcel as undevelopable, and the purchase price reflected those constraints. The conditions that make the site difficult or impossible to develop are not new. They existed long before the current owner acquired the property and were readily apparent at the time of purchase. Finally, I encourage the Board to consider the precedent that approval of this application could establish. This case extends well beyond a single property. Future applicants, City staff, and future Boards will inevitably look to this decision when evaluating similar requests. If a predominantly marsh parcel with fragmented upland areas, environmental constraints, and a long history of non-development is determined to satisfy the intent and purpose requirements of Section 54-501, it becomes increasingly difficult to distinguish this property from other similarly situated parcels throughout Charleston. The City has spent decades developing regulations that balance private property rights with the protection of Charleston's marshes, waterways, environmental resources, and historic neighborhood character. Approving this request risks significantly expanding the circumstances under which Section 54-501 may be applied and could weaken the effectiveness of the City's minimum lot size standards and environmental protections. For these reasons, I respectfully request that the Board uphold the Zoning Administrator's determination and deny the application. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Lindsey Stang Wappoo Heights Resident 28 Formosa Drive Hunter Louis 36 Formosa Drive June 13, 2026 Board of Zoning City of Charleston Clarification Regarding Property at 36 Formosa Drive, Wappoo Heights, Charleston, SC Dear Members of the Board of Zoning, We are writing to provide important context concerning the property located at 36 Formosa Drive in the Wappoo Heights neighborhood. This letter addresses a likely misunderstanding that has arisen in the community regarding the size of the residence currently situated on this lot. In October 2019, our family home, which exceeded 3,000 square feet, was severely damaged by fire. The blaze left only a single living room intact, which became the foundation for our subsequent renovation. Rather than sell the property—a location of deep personal significance where we raised our children and formed lasting ties to the neighborhood—we chose to rebuild upon the remaining structure. This decision required substantial modifications to bring the building into compliance with current building codes, including elevating the structure, as it was no longer eligible for grandfathered status following the loss of the primary residence. The resulting home is approximately 740 square feet. It represents a careful renovation and adaptive reuse of the surviving portion of our original family home, rather than new construction of a small dwelling. We undertook this project with full adherence to all applicable regulations and with profound respect for the character of the Wappoo Heights neighborhood. It has come to our attention that our renovated residence is being cited by a neighbor as an example of smaller new construction homes in the area. We wish to respectfully Jun 15 2026 9:41AM clarify that this characterization is inaccurate, as the current structure is the preserved and upgraded remnant of a much larger pre-fire home, not a newly built small residence. Thank you for your service to the Charleston community. We are available to provide any additional documentation or clarification that may assist the Board. Sincerely, Megan and Hunter Louis 36 Formosa Drive Wappoo Heights Christopher Stang 28 Formosa Drive, Charleston, SC 29407 June 15, 2026 RE: Agenda Item B-15 – 2 Allgood Road (TMS 421-13-00-031) Dear Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals, I respectfully request that the Board uphold the Zoning Administrator's determination and deny the applicant's request under Section 54-501 of the Charleston Zoning Ordinance. Section 54-501 does not create an automatic right to build on a lot of insufficient size. Rather, it provides that the Board may authorize a permitted use only when the proposed site plan is deemed not to conflict with the intent and purposes of the Charleston Zoning Ordinance. The burden rests with the applicant to demonstrate that this standard has been met. The applicant has not met that burden. First, this property is fundamentally different from a conventional residential lot in Wappoo Heights. While the parcel encompasses approximately 10.43 acres, the overwhelming majority consists of marshland. Development is proposed on a limited, isolated upland area within a largely marsh- dominated site. The practical development characteristics of this property are substantially different from those in the neighborhood. The proposed buildable area is 30% the size of lots in the neighborhood, 20% the size of the adjoining parcel at 1 Algood and 6% the size of the adjoining parcel at 12 Palmetto. The small footprint necessitates the construction of a home which is completely out of character for the neighborhood. Second, creating an address with the GIS 911 Addressing Coordinator does not give you right to build a house on the lot despite not meeting the zoning requirements. The GIS 911 Addressing Coordinator only gave the applicant an Allgood Road address rather than a Tranquil Drive address because “of the front door location” the applicant himself submitted. The 10+ acre lot fronts Tranquil drive. If the applicant wants to make the claim that he can combine non-contiguous upland areas over 600 feet apart, he should also have to uphold that the parcel fronts Tranquil drive for more than 800 feet and only touches approximately 10 feet of Allgood. For this reason, and in agreement with the City of Charleston Zoning Administrator’s decision, the parcel fronts Tranquil Drive and should be subject to those setbacks listed in 54-301 table 3.1 Third, the property is subject to significant environmental considerations. The parcel abuts a salt marsh and is affected by critical line and buffer requirements intended to protect Charleston's coastal Jun 15 2026 9:50AM resources. The City has adopted these regulations specifically to preserve environmentally sensitive areas and protect water quality, marsh habitat, and shoreline character. Approval of residential development on this site would be inconsistent with those purposes unless full compliance with all applicable critical line, buffer, and environmental protection requirements has been clearly demonstrated. This area of “high-ground” has flooded on at least two occasions, including 2019 and 2024. Additionally, a relatively nominal 6.4 foot tide was experienced this past Saturday show water up to the edge of the “high ground”. (See attached photographs) Fourth, historical documents associated with the original Wappoo Heights subdivision identify the high-ground in question as "The Landing," a waterfront recreational area established by George Nash for the use and enjoyment of neighborhood residents and their guests. For approximately one hundred years, the property remained undeveloped and functioned as a community waterfront amenity. The applicant has not demonstrated that this area was ever intended to serve as an individual residential lot. Finally, the applicant purchased this property with full knowledge of its physical characteristics, development limitations, marsh conditions, and regulatory constraints. The parcel was purchased for $20,000 in Aug 2023. According to the County’s Register of Deeds, the parcel has a Class Code of “990 – UNDEVELOPABLE”. The applicant knew, or should have known, this property could not be built upon. Despite its large 10.43-acre footprint, its market value is heavily discounted due to the unbuildable classification. The inability to construct a residence on the property is not an economic hardship created by a recent change in law or circumstance; it is a condition that has existed for generations and was readily apparent at the time of purchase. The Board should also carefully consider the broad implications of approving this application under Section 54-501. This case will inevitably guide future applicants, property owners, City staff, and future Boards when evaluating similar requests. If a predominantly marsh parcel with fragmented upland areas, environmental constraints, and a century-long history of non- development is found to be consistent with the intent and purposes of the ordinance, it becomes difficult to distinguish this property from other similarly situated marsh-edge parcels throughout Charleston. The City has spent decades developing regulations intended to balance private property rights with the protection of Charleston's unique marshes, waterways, natural resources, and historic neighborhood character. Approval of this application would significantly expand the circumstances under which Section 54-501 may be used and risks weakening the effectiveness of the City's minimum lot size standards, critical line protections, and longstanding environmental policies. For all of these reasons, I respectfully request that the Board determine that the proposed site plan conflicts with the intent and purposes of the Charleston Zoning Ordinance and deny the application. Thank you for your consideration. Christopher Stang 28 Formosa Drive Photo attachments and letter will also be sent to bza-z@charleston-sc.gov Patricia McGuinn 9 Allgood Road, Charleston 29407 I oppose the application for special exception for 2 Allgood Rd, and I also signed the neighborhood petition. Jun 15 2026 9:52AM Joseph Cheshire Rhett 13 Formosa Drive Applicant's request would require the violation of several setback requirements ,not to mention lot size regulations. I will not belabor you with the specifics, as they will be addressed by fellow neighbors who will be present at the meeting. This is a prime example for which such zoning codes have been established. I ask that the board does open our neighborhood to blatant violation of those rules and regulations. Jun 15 2026 9:53AM Alexandra Betros 7 Nashmor Road I oppose the application for special exception for 2 Allgood Rd, and I also signed the neighborhood petition. Jun 15 2026 9:58AM John Robinson 108 Folly Road Blvd, Charleston, 29407 Dear members of BZAZ: My wife Sallie and I live at 108 Folly Road Blvd., in the Wappoo Heights neighborhood, where the applicant's property is located. I have thoroughly reviewed the application and wish to point out that the topography of this lot, together with the split areas of highland, create an issue with interpretation of the applicable zoning ordinances to this property. Because of the very limited high land on this parcel and the fact that it is physically split, together with the access issues to the property, I respectfully request that BZAZ deny the application as presented. Jun 15 2026 10:11AM Jennifer Latimer Wildstein 7 Palmetto Road Charleston SC 29407 I am a resident of the Wappoo Heights neighborhood and respectfully object to Application No. 15. I urge the Board to uphold the Zoning Administrator's decision denying the requested Special Exception. The Applicant purchased the property for approximately $20,000, consisting of marshland and two separate areas of upland. As correctly determined by the City of Charleston Department of Planning, Preservation & Sustainability, neither upland area independently satisfies the requirements for a Special Exception. The purchase price reflects the nature of the property being conveyed: undevelopable marshland and two isolated parcels of high ground. The fact that these areas share a single TMS number or appear on a single plat should not control the outcome. The upland areas are physically separated by marshland and do not constitute a contiguous buildable lot. Administrative designation alone cannot create development rights where the zoning requirements have not been met. The City of Charleston Zoning Administrator properly applied the ordinance and did not abuse his discretion. The proposed building site Jun 15 2026 10:14AM does not contain the required 9,000 square feet of contiguous high ground upon which development may occur, a deficiency that has been communicated to the Applicant for the past two years. Approving this application would effectively grant development rights to a property that has historically been recognized as undevelopable and would undermine the consistent application of the City's zoning regulations. For these reasons, I respectfully request that the Board affirm the Zoning Administrator's decision and deny Application No. 15. Bert Utsey 1 Allgood Rd. My wife Judy and I are diagonally across Allgood Road from the subject property. For the following reasons, we believe our property and the neighborhood as a whole will be negatively affected if the proposed project is approved. •The proposed project is inconsistent with the letter and the spirit of the SR-1 requirements of the zoning ordinance (9,000 sq. ft. lot size). A property owner should not be able to combine small undevelopable pieces of high ground to claim that, in aggregate, they constitute a lot. The applicant is attempting to take advantage of the fact that his property was never subdivided and is considered only one parcel. That was because no one ever considered that property to be developable (see below). •If the BZA were to approve the application, it would set a dangerous precedent for owners of other small high ground parcels to build on lots smaller than intended for SR-1 zoning by cobbling together small pieces of undevelopable property. •The proposed dwelling would be out of character for the Wappoo Heights neighborhood in size and lot density. It would eliminate a view that the public has enjoyed for generations. •The subject property has always been considered undevelopable. It is listed as such on county records. oThe family that developed the neighborhood intended for the subject property to set aside as a landing and open greenspace for residents of Wappoo Heights. They have acquiesced in that use for over 100 years with no effort to develop the property or suggestion that it was developable. oProperty owners (like us) who bought in the neighborhood did so in reliance on the fact that the property was not developable and that we would continue to benefit from having this open greenspace, which enhances property values throughout the neighborhood. oThe applicant recently purchased the subject property for a relatively small sum of money and certainly knew at that time that the property was considered undevelopable. •The application contains a misrepresentation regarding the front setback for 1 Allgood Road (our property). We oriented our house based on our architect's recommendation that we take full advantage of the marsh view. We did not change the driveway entrance for the property. Most importantly, we maintained a 25' setback from the street as required by applicable zoning. Jun 15 2026 10:31AM Ellen Lucas 19 Formosa Drive City of Charleston Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning (BZA- Z) Department of Planning, Preservation, and Sustainability 2 George Street, 1st Floor Charleston, SC 29401 Subject: Formal Opposition to Special Exception Request (Section 54-501) – 2 Allgood Road Applicant / Property Address: 2 Allgood Road, Charleston, SC 29407 Respected Members of the Board, I am writing as a resident of the immediate neighborhood to formally request that the Board DENY the applicant’s request for a Special Exception under Section 54-501. The applicant has failed to meet the heavy burden of proof required by the City of Charleston Zoning Ordinance. Specifically, building on a lot of only 6,064 square feet directly conflicts with the explicit intent of Section 54-501 and will permanently alter the character, development pattern, and environmental safety of our neighborhood. Per Section 54-501, a Special Exception for an insufficient lot of record may only be granted if the site plan is "not in conflict with the intent and purposes of this ordinance" and respects local neighborhood patterns. The application fails on the following counts: Failure to Match Neighborhood Character: There are absolutely no other lots in this neighborhood even close to 6,064 square feet. The vast majority of our surrounding parcels are at least one-third (1/3) acre up to full 1-acre lots. Forcing a micro- lot into a neighborhood built entirely on large acreage creates a severe, jarring density anomaly that shatters the established community fabric. Severe Environmental and Flooding Risks: This specific property is a critical marshfront lot that actively experiences tidal flooding during King Tides and heavy West Ashley rain events. Forcing a building footprint and impervious surfaces onto an undersized 6,064-square-foot parcel severely reduces the natural absorbent marsh buffer. We have several photos from a December storm that shows the entire lot under water—Not from a hurricane or a predicted weather event. Conflict with Zoning Ordinance Intent: The primary purpose of the ordinance is to preserve safety from flooding, safeguard drainage, and protect critical ecologies. Squeezing a structure onto this miniature scale will inevitably displace stormwater and tidal surge onto adjacent, established properties, worsening localized flooding on Allgood Road. Disruption of the Development Pattern: The surrounding homes feature expansive front setbacks, wide side-yard buffers, and open green spaces that allow the coastal terrain to naturally manage water. Forcing a layout onto a substandard lot will result in over- occupancy of the land and a dangerous reduction in the open-space ratio. My across the street neighbor was used as an example of a small house—arounbd 900 square feet. This is a false claim. 36 Formosa Drive is a small house because of a tragic fire event and this is all that remained after the fire. They have building plans for a full size house on the lot. Insufficient Evidence of Harmony: The applicant Jun 15 2026 10:38AM has provided no evidence demonstrating how a high- density, sub-standard lot configuration can harmoniously blend into a historically large-acreage streetscape without violating the city's strict stormwater and marshland protection principles. A Special Exception is a privilege, not an automatic right. The Board is legally bound to protect the existing neighborhood and our critical marsh environments from incompatible, hazardous infill development. Because this request fails to satisfy the criteria of Section 54-501, we respectfully ask the Board to uphold the integrity of our zoning laws and deny the application. Sincerely, Ellen, David, Jack, Kathryn and Dorothy Lucas 19 Formosa Drive Charleston, SC 29407 Lavinia Thaxton 12 Palmetto Dr. I am strongly opposed granting Mr. Yarbrough a special exception under Section 54-501 for several reasons. The primary one is due insufficient size of the site noted in his application. The other concerns will be voiced tomorrow night at the meeting. I respectful request the board affirm the zoning administrators decision and deny application 15. Sincerely, Lavinia Thaxton 12 Palmetto Dr. Jun 15 2026 11:35AM

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.