_06152026-10975
City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Jun 15, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Charleston
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Committee on Real Estate
June 15, 2026
A meeting of the Committee on Real Estate was held on this date at 3:02 p.m. via Zoom .
Notice of this meeting was sent to all local news media.
PRESENT
Committee M embers : Councilmember William Tinkler (Chair), Councilmember Boyd Gregg,
Councilmember Ross Appel, Councilmember Keith Waring (3:07) , and Mayor William Cogswell
City Staff and Others : Malena Dinwoodie, Shannon Elliot, Magalie Creech, Melissa Cruthirds,
Robert Summerfield, Michael Mathis, Julia Copeland, Mollie Conner, Philip Clapper, and Donna
Constance
Chair Tinkler called the meeting to order.
Invocation
The meeting was opened with a moment of silence led by Councilmember Tinkler
Approval of Minutes
On a motion by Mayor Cogswell , seconded by Councilmember Gregg , the Committee voted
unanimously to approve the May 21, 2026 , Real Estate meeting minutes.
a) Authorization for the Mayor to execute First Amendment to SCDOT Lease Agreement
to extend term to 12/18/2085 and restate that the City has not abandoned the area to
address section 13(a). (SCDOT I-26 Underpass). The property is owned by SCDOT.
Ms. Dinwoodie said the City leased a property from the DOT. Next to it was City-owned property,
where they will build affordable housing units. Part of this involved the Charleston Housing
Authority, which would allow easements for road improvements to pass through its property and
provide access to the DOT area. For this development to proceed, the developer ’s lender required
that the lease term for the DOT area match the loan term, which is why they extended the lease
agreement only for the portion of the leased area through 2085 to match that note.
On a motion by Mayor Cogswell, seconded by Councilmember Gregg, the Committee voted
unanimously to approve Item A.
b) Authorization for the Mayor to sign Memorandum of Understanding with the County of
Charleston to provide parking enforcement services within garage located at 85 Queen
Street. (85 Queen Street, TMS# 457-12-02-003). The property is owned by Charleston
County.
Ms. Creech said this was an MOU with the county to handle parking enforcement at their parking
facility at 85 Queen Street.
2
This did not require them to add that location to their routine enforcement route or to hire
personnel. If they saw something, they would call it in and handle it as needed. The City would
retain all revenue from those violations. This was a one-year term that could be terminated at any
time for any reason, with annual renewals thereafter.
On a motion by Mayor Cogswell, seconded by Councilmember Appel, the Committee voted
unanimously to approve Item B.
c) Authorization for the Mayor to execute license agreement with Belle Terre
Homeowners Association to allow pair of brick columns on City right-of-way. (Parrot
Point Drive, TMS# 452-06-00-139). The property is owned by the City of Charleston.
Ms. Copeland said that in 2012 , the City allowed a temporary encroachment for this neighborhood
to install brick columns and a lockable gate. The condition of this encroachment was that the 21st
CO in that neighborhood would have to remove the gates. Instead, they asked the 21st CO
whether they could leave the brick pillars and gates and weld the hinges so the gates could not
be permanently closed. This was a license agreement reflecting that arrangement.
Councilmember Waring said the last gated community in the City of Charleston was Ashley Hawk.
They were supposed to put up a temporary gate, but it was not temporary. It was a public street
that received public services. When police were needed or trash was collected there, they needed
permission to go through the gates. Those gates needed to come down. Whoever bought those
lots and based their purchase on the community being gated sold falsehoods. The compromise
was that when that lot was sold, the gates would come down, and that had not happened.
Ms. Copeland said they would be issuing the 21 st CF.
Councilmember Waring said the gate needed to come down because it was supposed to be
temporary, not a brick entrance. When they updated the tourism plan several years ago, the
subcommittee moved to install a gate at Meeting and Broad that would open at 7:00 a.m. and
7:00 p.m., but that did not make it into the tourism management plan.
Mayor Cogswell said they did not want the expense of tearing it down. The y welded it open so it
could not be taken down, and it was more of a decorative item. If they did close it , they should be
able to enforce their rights to have them taken out. The proposal was to have the gates welded
open.
Councilmember Waring asked what they agreed to in this agreement.
Ms. Copeland said the pillars and the gate would stay, but they would weld the hinges so the gate
could not close.
Councilmember Waring asked if they were compliant with the agreement.
Ms. Copeland said yes.
Councilmember Waring asked how old the agreement was.
Ms. Copeland said the encroachment occurred in 2012.
Councilmember Waring asked if they had an attorney handling this.
Ms. Copeland said there was no attorney, but she was dealing directly with the HOA president
and secretary.
Councilmember Appel said he wanted to confirm that they were not making this a permanent
gated situation . T hey did not want to tear down the brick gate, but the public right-of-way would
be maintained.
On a motion by Mayor Cogswell, seconded by Councilmember Gregg, the Committee voted
unanimously to approve Item C.
3
d) Authorization for the Mayor to execute a Memorandum of Understanding with Berkeley
County and Clouter Creek Reserve, LLC regarding a marina development on Clements
Ferry Road. (Clements Ferry Road). The property is owned by Berkeley County.
Ms. Copeland said the MOU was the culmination of an agreement among three parties. Clouter
Creek has a marina plan currently with the TRC , which was on hold. That was because of an
encroachment by Berkeley County over Clements Road to access the site. Berkeley County asked
that the City annex this parcel; in exchange, they would issue an encroachment permit allowing
construction of the marina to begin. The City would take up the permit on Berkeley County ’s
behalf . Construction could begin; however, the marina would not be entitled to any COS, and the
residential portion would not be entitled to any permits until Clouter Creek and any other
developers working back there could resolve the road issue. Under this agreement, Berkeley
County agreed to issue the permit while it worked through the process. An application for the
annexation was submitted. Part of the MOU, for the City ’s benefit, was that once they got through
this, fixed the road, and built out the residential, there would be a dedication of public space and
a boat slip in the marina for the City upon completion.
Councilmember Waring asked how they would work out the encroachment.
Councilmember Gregg said they had not worked it out yet.
Councilmember Waring said this had been an issue for a while.
Ms. Copeland said Berkeley County was going to start initiating an encroachment clearing
process through its own municipal court process, which was one of the stipulations of the MOU.
They started this process a few years ago, and one of the landowners arrived at court and said it
had been worked out, so it had been dismissed when, in fact, it had not been worked out.
On a motion by Councilmember Gregg, seconded by Mayor Cogswell, the Committee voted
unanimously to approve Item D.
e) Authorization for the Mayor to execute a License Agreement with 131 Columbus NPV
MCZ SPE LLC to use area of lowline for construction laydown during hotel
construction. (Lowcountry Lowline). The property is owned by the City of Charleston.
Ms. Dinwoodie said they were discussing a portion of the lowline, unlike the DOT portions of the
lowline that were being leased from DOT. These were fee-simple-owned portions of the lowline
that they purchased from Norfolk Southern. Currently, they are trying to utilize these to help with
project construction in the area and to put them to use for the City. The section they were speaking
of was between Columbus and Spring Street. The property located at 131 Columbus would be
developed as a hotel. The City currently leases 25 parking spaces to the Hyatt for staff and
employee parking. As part of the license agreement with 131 Columbus, they would be required
to improve that section so that these parkers would be moved over without any loss of revenue.
Once it has been improved and the parkers have been moved over, the license agreement with
131 Columbus would begin. This is a month-to-month agreement until the project is complete.
There is a license fee of $2,000 each month. Either party could terminate the agreement at any
time for convenience.
Councilmember Waring asked if this was going to be a hotel.
Mayor Cogswell said this was approved five years ago to be a hotel.
Chair Tinkler asked if they knew how long they anticipated that construction would last.
Ms. Dinwoodie said six months, then would continue on a month-to-month basis.
On a motion by Mayor Cogswell, seconded by Councilmember Waring, the Committee voted
unanimously to approve Item E.
4
f) Authorizing the Mayor to execute an Agreement for Purchase and Sale in Lieu of
Condemnation with The Most Reverend Paul J. Hallinan, as The Bishop of Charleston,
and his successors in the Episcopal See of Charleston according to the discipline and
government of the Roman Catholic Church, and his and their assigns, now and more
commonly known as the Roman Catholic Diocese of Charleston regarding the
purchase of property identified as Charleston County TMS#: 418-14-00-181 for
$445,000.00 to facilitate Charleston County ’s road realignment project. This is funded
with General Reserve Funds and will be included in a future budget amendment.
g) Authorizing the Mayor to execute an Agreement for Purchase and Sale in Lieu of
Condemnation with Avondale Holding Company, LLC regarding the purchase of
property identified as Charleston County TMS# 418-14-00-056 for $3,020,000.00 to
facilitate Charleston County ’s road realignment project. This is funded with General
Fund Reserves and will be included in a future budget amendment.
Ms. Copeland said this was a 2018 IGA that was amended in 2020 with the county to improve the
Avondale intersection. This would require them to purchase property from Avondale Holding
Company, which owns the building and a triangular-shaped parking lot owned by the Diocese.
The first agreement was with Avondale Holdings, and they came down to $3,020,000.00. They
were going to terminate the leases, and the City and the county would jointly begin the demolition
process within the next 10 days. The county had submitted its plans to the DOT but was waiting
for the City to complete the deal. They would also be purchasing 12 acres from the Diocese's
parking lot for $445,000. As part of that deal, they would get a curb cut further up Nicholson.
Avondale Holdings and the Diocese would also be swapping two parcels as part of this deal. Once
these are approved, they will begin the intersection improvement.
Councilmember Gregg said he did not understand why they were spending $3.5 million to
purchase this property for a county road project. He thought the county should be funding this
because it was a lot of money, and they did not collect taxes for road improvements in the City. It
would be one thing if they were facilitating the transaction and being reimbursed; that was why
they had the half-penny sales tax to pay for things like this. They did not have a half-penny sales
tax to pay for this.
Mayor Cogswell said this would have to be passed on to someone who had been here from the
beginning, when the original deal was struck. This was a deal that had been six or seven years in
the making, in which the county agreed to make the intersection improvement, subject to the
county obtaining control of those properties.
Ms. Copeland said that was correct. They conducted a DOT study, or a traffic study facilitated by
the county. This intersection had generated many accidents and was a public safety issue that
concerned both the City and the county. The county reached out to them with the IGA, on the
premise that they would build this project at the intersection, a massive undertaking in itself, if the
City would help with condemnation to acquire those parcels and hand them over. At that time, the
council was open to facilitating this improvement.
Councilmember Gregg asked whether they knew how much the county was spending on the
intersection improvement.
Ms. Copeland said she did not have them , but could get those numbers quickly.
Mr. Summerfield said this project was part of Plan West Ashley due to safety concerns related to
traffic accidents and the number of intersections in the Avondale area. Plan West Ashley was part
of the redevelopment and revitalization of the Avondale corridor. Because this was part of a larger
plan, the City Council had endorsed it. The City Council had planned several initiatives for West
5
Ashley, including those for Avondale and this portion of the boulevard. This was part of the
rationale for the City's willingness to invest in a collaborative project with the County.
Chair Tinkler said the county project, which included the Savannah Highway corridor project,
addressed several other intersections, including Wappoo, where the City was also contributing
significant resources and partnering with the county to make that intersection safer and more
connected.
Mr. Mathis said this was one of the three intersections that would be improved as part of this
project.
Chair Tinkler said that this just happened to be the most resource-intensive.
Mayor Cogswell asked whether they knew the projected cost .
Mr. Mathis said he did not know the exact cost of this one, but the three together were $50 million.
Councilmember Appel said he recalls receiving a county presentation about this specific project,
which showed the before-and-after conditions and the level of service at this intersection. This
project would take it from an F to an A and would be a significant bang-for-the-buck improvement
for the county had as part of their half-cent sales tax program. This was more than the Wappoo
and Stinson intersections, which were an important part of this project. But the dog-legged current
condition there created a need for multiple lights in proximity. When there was a mass of cars
coming into town in the morning and a mass of cars coming up Savannah Highway in the
afternoon, this created a horrible bottleneck. So, by aligning those streets, they would make the
area safer and assist with traffic flow on Savannah Highway. This was an important project that
they would help to facilitate through a partnership with the county.
Councilmember Gregg said he understood the need but did not think they should be in the
business of funding projects that the county should pay for with their general fund.
Councilmember Waring said when the realignment was worked out , the hope was that it would
create a small parcel for additional parking for Avondale. It appeared that they would get the
alignment, but the extra parking seemed too much to ask for.
Chair Tinkler said this was an opportunity to address the stormwater that flowed to the south and
went underneath Savannah Highway, whose capacity was currently limited. The Stormwater
Department was presently studying this as part of the 2026 small project allocation budget.
On a motion by Mayor Cogswell, seconded by Councilmember Appel, the Committee voted on
Items F and G . It was not unanimous. Councilmember Waring recused him self from voting on
th ese item s and completed a Conflict-of-Interest Form , which is on file in the Office of the Clerk of
Council . Councilmember Gregg voted Nay.
h) Authorization to enter into Purchase and Sale Agreement by and between the City as
Seller and 37254 Rivers, LLC as Buyer for the sale of approximately 0.44 acres of
property located in North Charleston for the appraised value of $20,000.00. The final
form of the PSA will incorporate the terms of the executed LOI and be subject to
approval of Corporation Counsel. (McMillan Ave., North Charleston, SC TMS# 469-
02-00-231). The property is owned by the City of Charleston. [Ordinance]
Ms. Dinwoodie said the property was a portion of an abandoned right-of-way adjacent to McMillan.
This was part of the Kids on Point after-school program, which provided tutoring and other
activities. The property was undeveloped , City-owned property with access and utility easements.
The property was appraised at $20,000. They had an LOI outlining the terms of the sale of this
property, with the sale at the appraised value. There was a 90-day due diligence period followed
by a 30-day closing. They were requesting permission to enter into a PSA that would incorporate
all of the terms, subject to the Corporation Council ’s approval.
6
Councilmember Waring asked if that property was an old railroad bed.
Ms. Dinwoodie said it looked like it was a railway.
On a motion by Mayor Cogswell, seconded by Councilmember Waring, the Committee voted
unanimously to approve Item H.
i) Authorization to enter into a Memorandum of Understanding between the City,
Charleston Housing Authority, and The Grace Hotel, Inc. for the construction of a public
use alleyway connecting Lee Street to Cooper Street. (524, 520, 516, 512 Meeting,
114 Cooper, Hanover St., and Cooper St. TMS#s 459-05-04-217, -078, -079, -216, &
-214 (City owned) 459-05-03-077 & 459-05-04-222 (Grace owned) 459-05-04-207
(CHA owned)). The properties are owned by the City of Charleston, Charleston
Housing Authority, and The Grace Hotel, LLC.
Ms. Dinwoodie said this was a three-party MOU, and if approved by the council within 30 days,
they would complete a detailed PSA agreement for the transactions contemplated in the MOU.
The City-owned properties that were part of the Cooper River mitigation parcels were acquired
with the right-of-way abandonments. Several parcels owned by the Charleston Housing Authority
and Mr. Patel are to be developed into a hotel. Years ago, before the acquisition of these parcels,
there was a discussion about an easement that would run from Lee Street and connect to Cooper
Street. To make that happen, both the Charleston Housing Authority and the Grace Hotel would
need to contribute 10 feet of their property. Another parcel would be transferred to the Grace Hotel
properties, creating a southbound one-way alleyway from Lee to Cooper. They would install
sidewalks and provide pedestrian access for Charleston Housing Authority residents. The City
would contribute its portion of the property, and the Grace Hotel would be responsible for all
design, permitting, and construction costs, so the City pays nothing. Once that is completed, they
will have an as-built survey completed and proceed with the dedication process. After that, the
City will maintain the surface right-of-way, and Mr. Patel will be permitted to use a portion of the
adjacent section of his property for stormwater storage, for which he will be responsible for
maintenance and improvements for the stormwater storage section of the agreement.
Mayor Cogswell asked if the J parcel had been appraised.
Ms. Dinwoodie said yes.
Mayor Cogswell asked if this was a net even construction.
Ms. Dinwoodie said yes because of the construction cost, had put it in the net even point.
A COC drainage easement would run through the area. They had a collaboration with stormwater
and parks for any park or linear park improvements that may be made in that area.
Mayor Cogswell asked whether that would help with drainage, since they would have to improve
stormwater.
Ms. Dinwoodie said yes.
On a motion by Mayor Cogswell, seconded by Councilmember Appel, the Committee voted
unanimously to approve Item I.
j) Authorization to enter into Temporary Access and Use Agreement with JJR
Development, LLC for the use of a portion of City owned property located at 212 Spring
Street for use of a tower crane in relation to project construction on Developer ’s
adjacent property. (212 Spring Street, TMS# 460-11-01-015). The property is owned
by the City of Charleston. [Ordinance]
7
Ms. Dinwoodie said 212 Spring Street was part of their stormwater division ’s inventory because
the deep tunnel access occupied the first quarter of that property. The owner of the adjacent
property is developing a workforce apartment complex. They requested a license for a 25 x 25-
foot section for a tower crane. They would maintain a security fence at all times, so no one could
access the area, and the crane would be locked within a 180-degree radius so it would not be
permitted to go over any City property. Stormwater would have trailers there in association with
their spring Fishburn pump station upfit project. The license fee would be $1,000 per month for
the use of the 25 x 25-foot area. This was a month-to-month agreement until the project was
completed, or either party had the option to terminate the agreement with 30 days ’ advance notice.
Councilmember Waring asked how they determined the lay-down feed rates.
Ms. Dinwoodie said she researched what other lay-down rates were on the peninsula. Generally , it
was $18 to$20 per square foot for a lay-down area. They thought $1,000 would be fair for this
space.
Mayor Cogswell said h is recommendation is to , instead of a month-to-month lease , do a six-month
lease and pay upfront if they keep the crane up and are not using it.
Ms. Dinwoodie said she would make that suggestion and amend the agreement before this went
to Ways and Means.
Councilmember Waring said they should do six-month intervals and have two checks.
Ms. Dinwoodie said she would bring this to the developer , and if there were any objections to
those suggestions, she would inform the committee.
On a motion by Councilmember Waring, seconded by Mayor Cogswell, the Committee voted
unanimously to approve Item J.
k) 74 Stuart Street – Request to increase amount authorized for purchase/condemnation
to $475,000 to add to inventory for Project 3500.
Ms. Copeland sai d 74 Stuart was presently boarded up and was adjacent to 899 Morison, where
they planned to build out Project 3500. Several months ago, the council gave them the authority
to have discussions with 74 and 76 to purchase them, including condemnation, to add these
properties to Project 3500. The owner of the home demanded $940,000, which was based on his
appraisal ; they were at $378,000. They agreed to $475,000 with the council ’s approval.
Mayor Cogswell said this was a nuisance property. This address was known for police reports,
and he thought this would be a blessing not to have this anymore.
On a motion by Mayor Cogswell, seconded by Councilmember Waring, the Committee voted
unanimously to approve Item K.
l) Please consider the following annexations:
i. 1627 Wappoo Drive (0.20 acre) (TMS# 351-12-00-106), (District 7). The
property is owned by Terrence Renk.
ii. 2792 Garden Creek Road (0.33 acre) (TMS# 355-08-00-066), (District 2). The
property is owned by Christine Murakami.
iii. 2788 Garden Creek Road (0.34 acre) (TMS# 355-08-00-065), (District 2). The
property is owned by Vincent Ferrante.
iv. A portion of Clements Ferry Road Right-of-Way (0.92 acre) (TMS# Right-of-
Way, See Exhibit), (District 1). The property is owned by Berkeley County .
8
On a motion by Councilmember Waring, seconded by Mayor Cogswell, the Committee voted
unanimously to approve all four annexations.
With there being no further business, the Committee adjourned the meeting at 3:56 p.m.
Clerk of Council ’s Office
Donna Constance
Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.