BAR-S Public Comment
City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Jun 11, 2026 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Charleston
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY OF CHARLESTON
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL
PUBLIC COMMENT
JUNE 11, 2026
A meeting of the Board of Architectural Review – Small (BAR -S) will be held on Thursday,
June 11, 2026 at 4:30 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street.
The following written comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of
the meeting. The comments will also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public
is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard.
Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/bar. Please check the website on
the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items.
For additional information, please contact:
Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781
B. APPLICATIONS
1. 32 Dunnemann Street
BAR2026-002599 | TMS# 463-14-02-017 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6
Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1947 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Requesting approval for the after-the-fact partial demolition of exterior elements visible
from the public right-of-way.
Owner: 32 DUNN HOLDINGS LLC
Applicant: Nicholas Grossman
Site visit on 06/11/2026 at 8:30 a.m.
No Comments Submitted
2. 399 Sumter Street
BAR2026-002605 | TMS# 460-07-02-086 | Westside | Council District 6
Category 4 (Group 1) | c. 1915 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Requesting appeal of staff decision for replacement of six (6) windows with Renewal by
Anderson.
Owner: Tom Zavada
Applicant: Brian Pine
Site visit on 06/11/2026 at 8:50 a.m.
No Comments Submitted
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Public Comment | June 11, 2026 Page 2
3. 443 Huger Street
BAR2026-002635 | TMS#460-03-03-081 | Hampton Park Terrace | Council District 6
Category 4 (Group 1) | c. 1915 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Requesting approval for partial demolition of exterior elements visible from the public
right-of-way.
Owner: Carlee Clark & Brett Carron
Applicant: Old City Builders – Griffin Burts
Site visit on 06/11/2026 at 9:10 a.m.
No Comments Submitted
4. 30 F Street
BAR2026-002596 | TMS# 463-16-03-049 | Westside | Council District 4
Not Surveyed | c. 1974 | Historic Corridor District
Requesting full demolition of existing dwelling.
Owner: ELP Properties LLC
Applicant: ELP Properties – Kyle Long
Site visit on 06/11/2026 at 9:30 a.m.
No Comments Submitted
5. 2 Larnes Street
BAR2026-002640 | TMS# 460-07-02-246 | Westside | Council District 6
Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1905 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Requesting approval for partial demolition of exterior elements visible from the public
right-of-way.
Owner: Larry & Alison Padget
Applicant: Scott MacCargar
Site visit on 06/11/2026 at 9:50 a.m.
No Comments Submitted
6. 8 Sheppard Street
BAR2026-002623 | TMS# 459-05-04-065 | East Side | Council District 4
Category 4 | c. 1920 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Requesting full demolition of existing dwelling.
Owner: Austen F. Kroll
Applicant: Robert Chipley
Site visit on 06/11/2026 at 10:10 a.m.
41 Comments Submitted:
• 40 Comments Submitted to Innovate Site
See attached comments.
• Julie O’Connor, SOS-CHS (Save Our Structures – Charleston)
Submitted to Staff
I am writing on behalf of SOS-CHS. The house at 8 Sheppard Street is an important
vernacular cottage, contributing to the streetscape and historic by virtue of its age.
There is no reason to allow the demolition of this house and the application should be
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Public Comment | June 11, 2026 Page 3
denied. This property is in great condition and is not on our survey of neglected
structures. Many houses that are on our survey were in terrible condition, were saved
and are being utilized to their fullest potential today. The applicant needs to use their
resources to maintain and improve this beautiful house instead of seeking to destroy it.
7. 872 Ashley Avenue
BAR2026-002604 | TMS# 463-11-03-015 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6
Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1940 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Requesting OPT-IN REVIEW for demolition of existing exterior elements visible from the
public right-of-way AND conceptual approval for proposed addition.
Owner: Joe & Rebecca Miller
Applicant: Abigail WR Brennan
Previous site visit on 4/23/2026 at 8:50 a.m.
5 Comments Submitted:
• Letters of Support
Submitted to Staff
See attached letters.
• Resident, 870 Ashley Ave.
• Michael Houck, 874 Ashley Ave.
• Andrea Grabman, 875 Ashley Ave.
• Wes Thaller, 1 Darlington Ave.
• Donna Storrow, 9 Darlington Ave.
8. 4 Henrietta Street
BAR2026-002563 | TMS# 459-13-03-078 | Garden District | Council District 4
New Construction | Old & Historic District
Requesting conceptual approval for a new single-family dwelling.
Owner: SC Reno Partners LLC
Applicant: Coastal Creek Design – Joel Adrian
6 Comments Submitted:
• Fred L. Willis, III, 99 ½ Alexander St.
Submitted to Staff
See attached letter and elevations.
• Susan Flaster, 42 Chapel St. Charleston, SC
Submitted to Innovate Site on June 8, 2026 12:27 PM
While most of us in the Garden District agree that a new house would be more
attractive and appropriate than the current vacant lot, we think that this project as
proposed is simply out of scale with the rest of the street, and too large for the
available lot. It seems that we neighobrs are constantly defending the Board itself
against the eroding of its own rules in defense of livalble neighborhoods, as well as
fighting back against protestations of "hardship" when hardship simply seems to mean
less profit from a project where space limitation rules were publically available in
advance of their purchase of the property.
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Public Comment | June 11, 2026 Page 4
• Helen Mitternight, 47 Chapel Street, Charleston
Submitted to Innovate Site on June 9, 2026 7:59 PM
This property is #8 on the June 11, 2026 Board of Architectural Review for conceptual
approval of a new single-family dwelling. Please reject the plan as submitted, which
continues to offer a house that dwarfs the lot it will be built upon and, because of its
size compared to the lot, encroaches on its immediate neighbors’ views and privacy. I
am hoping the board continues to uphold its own regulations and doesn’t bow to
continued pleadings for exceptions; the size of the lot hasn’t changed since it was
purchased, and the purchaser’s poor planning shouldn’t be considered a hardship that
requires an exception to regulations put in place to make the city livable for those
already in residence, all of whom had to abide by the same rules when making their
own purchases. Thank you!
• Todd Magro, 11 Elizabeth Street
Submitted to Innovate Site on June 9, 2026 10:51 PM
Dear Members of the Board, I reside at 11 Elizabeth Street, which directly abuts the
eastern property line of the proposed development at 4 Henrietta Street. I am writing
to respectfully request that the Board deny conceptual approval for this project in its
current iteration. While I fully support my neighbors' concerns regarding the project's
overall density, my opposition is specifically rooted in how the proposed height, scale,
and massing create severe, adverse conditions for the adjacent properties.
DISPROPORTIONATE MASSING AND SCALE The current design appears to maximize
square footage at the expense of architectural proportion. The proposed structure's
massing is awkward and unbalanced, particularly because the roofline on the rear
half of the building sits noticeably higher than the front. This creates a top-heavy,
disproportionate appearance that is entirely out of scale for a narrow 24-foot-wide
lot. Furthermore, this awkward, mismatched massing will be directly and unavoidably
visible from my rear porch, aggressively dominating the sightlines and failing to
respect the contextual harmony of the surrounding properties. CONTEXTUAL DENSITY
AND OVERBUILDING While the footprint may technically meet minimum zoning
setbacks, the sheer three-dimensional volume being forced into this constrained space
is fundamentally inappropriate. Attempting to squeeze a structure of this immense
mass onto such a narrow parcel ignores the historic spatial rhythms of the block and
overwhelms the adjacent parcels. PROXIMITY, PRIVACY, AND SAFETY IMPACTS The
scale and placement of the structure create severe negative impacts on the abutting
Elizabeth Street properties. The current design introduces a significant number of
windows on the east elevation that will directly overlook the private spaces of 11, 13,
and 15 Elizabeth Street, with the center of this massive east-facing wall sitting a mere
15 feet from my rear porch. Furthermore, the proposed plan places this new structure
a mere 5 feet away from the existing historic wood-frame structure on the east side.
Pushing a building of this tremendous height and volume so perilously close to an older
wood-framed home not only strips the abutting neighbors of their privacy, but it also
raises profound fire-spread and life-safety concerns. The applicant should be
required to return with a design that fundamentally respects the limitations of this lot,
rather than attempting to maximize rentable floor space with an oversized,
disproportionate structure. For these reasons, I urge the Board to deny conceptual
approval for 4 Henrietta Street. Sincerely, Todd Magro, MD
• Hugo Hanham-Gross, 6 Henrietta Street, Charleston, SC, 29403
Submitted to Innovate Site on June 10, 2026 9:07 AM
Dear Board Members, We are the owners and residents of 6 Henrietta Street, the
property immediately adjacent to the proposed project at 4 Henrietta Street, and we
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Public Comment | June 11, 2026 Page 5
have reviewed the plans submitted for consideration. We respectfully submit the
following concerns. At this stage, we believe the proposed building remains
significantly too tall and too large for the lot to warrant approval. While the structure
appears to have been moved closer to the street, the overall massing, height, and
distinctive “rocket ship” design remain substantially unchanged. In our view, these
revisions do not adequately address the concerns previously raised regarding scale,
compatibility, and neighborhood context. We are also concerned about the fence
shown along the shared property line. As part of the original Board of Zoning Appeals
variance approval, a CMU wall was required between the two properties in the area
where the driveway is now proposed. That wall was an important component of the
variance approval and was part of our basis for supporting the request at that time.
The current plans appear to remove this required CMU wall. Given the width and
proximity of the proposed driveway to our property at 6 Henrietta Street, we
respectfully request that the Board require the CMU wall to be reinstated as a
condition of any approval. Finally, we agree with the intent of the letter submitted by
Fred Willis and support the modifications he has suggested. We believe those changes
would substantially improve the project’s height, scale, and massing and make it more
compatible with the character of the surrounding neighborhood. Thank you for your
consideration of these comments. Sincerely, David Gross Victoria Hanham Hugo
Hanham-Gross Owners and Residents of 6 Henrietta Street
• John Ferrell, 5 Henrietta
Submitted to Innovate Site on June 10, 2026 11:16 AM
The proposed house is 1813sf, 3 Bedrooms and 4 full baths. It is 4 bedrooms if you
count the office. This house is designed for student housing so I’m sure it will be used as
a bedroom. The proposed house should be not larger than the previous uses. The
house at 3 Henrietta which is comparable to this house is 2 bedrooms with 2-1/2 baths
. The 1955 Sanbourn map shows a house that is 14’x36’ or 576sf per floor or 1008sf
total The 1888 map shows a house that is 16’x42’ or 672sf per floor or 1344sf The
proposed house should not be any larger than the 1344sf with 2 bedrooms and 2-
1/2 baths
9. 3 Savage Street
BAR2026-002606 | TMS# 457-12-03-060 | Charlestowne | Council District 8
Not Surveyed | c. 1890 | Old & Historic District
Requesting conceptual approval to elevate building and shift on site, and fenestration
alterations.
Owner: H. Chapman McKay
Applicant: Sebastian von Marschall
No Comments Submitted
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Public Comment | June 11, 2026 Page 6
10. 190 Line Street
BAR2026-002624 | TMS# 460-07-04-141 | Westside | Council District 6
Not Surveyed | Historic Materials Demolition District
Requesting approval for reconstruction of previous structure per Board motion.
Owner: MFI
Applicant: Amber Aument
2 Comments Submitted:
• Julie O’Connor, SOS-CHS (Save Our Structures – Charleston)
Submitted to Staff
I am writing on behalf of SOS-CHS. We applaud the applicant for rebuilding the
house at 190 Line Street. Thank you for your commitment to restoring the streetscape
of Line Street and honoring the history of this vernacular cottage.
• Kalen McNabb, 191 Line Street
Submitted to Innovate Site on June 10, 2026 9:43 AM
To the BAR members and BAR Staff - As a neighbor and preservationist, I am writing
in support of the design for the reconstruction of 190 Line Street. I have been in
contact with the Architect, Aument Design Studio, and I appreciate being included in
the design process. I believe this is a well-researched and faithful reconstruction of the
original cottage, and I fully support the proposed design.
11. 6 Atlantic Street
BAR2026-002609 | TMS# 457-16-04-074 | Charlestowne | Council District 8
Category 3 | c. 1830 | Old & Historic District
Requesting conceptual approval for renovation and addition to rear structure.
Owner: Emily W. Whipple
Applicant: Alexey Grigorieff
No Comments Submitted
12. 89 ½ Ashley Avenue
BAR2026-002608 | TMS# 457-03-03-059 | Harleston Village | Council District 8
Category 2 | c. 1838 | Old & Historic District
Requesting conceptual/ preliminary / final approval for material change to second floor
balcony of rear carriage house.
Owner: Mary Howell
Applicant: LFA Architecture - Laura F. Altman
No Comments Submitted
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Public Comment | June 11, 2026 Page 7
13. 241 Coming Street
BAR2026-002620 | TMS# 460-08-03-168 | Cannonborough/Elliottoborough
Council District 6 | Category 4 | c. 1890 | Old City District
Requesting appeal of staff decision for fiberglass columns.
Owner: Myril L. Primus-Brown
Applicant: Myril L. Primus-Brown
2 Comments Submitted:
• Preservation Society of Charleston
Submitted to Staff
See attached statement.
• Historic Charleston Foundation
Submitted to Staff
See attached statement.
14. 152 Coming Street, Unit A
BAR2026-002603 | TMS# 460-16-01-022 | Radcliffeborough | Council District 4
Category 4 | c. 1840 | Old & Historic District
Requesting conceptual approval for metal roof replacement.
Owner: Gina Kennedy
Applicant: Hopestar Roofing – Richard Kerr
Previous site visit on 03/26/2026 at 8:50 a.m.
No Comments Submitted
15. 394 Meeting Street
BAR2026-002615 | TMS# 459-09-03-105 | East Side | Council District 4
Not Surveyed | c. 2000 | Old & Historic District
Requesting approval for illuminated signage.
Owner: Veracept, LLC
Applicant: LINGEO Sign – Lindsay Wine
No Comments Submitted
CITY OF CHARLESTON
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL
8 Sheppard Street
BAR2026-002623 | TMS# 459-05-04-065 | East Side | Council District 4
Category 4 | c. 1920 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Requesting full demolition of existing dwelling.
Owner: Austen F. Kroll
Applicant: Robert Chipley
Site visit on 06/11/2026 at 10:10 a.m.
8 Sheppard Street
Public Comments Submitted to Innovate Site
First Name Last Name Address Comment Submitted
J Leeser 320 King Street DENY Jun 8 2026
10:17PM
John . America St. In full support Jun 9 2026
1:19PM
Megan Knowlan 3558 Clambank
Dr
No demo Jun 9 2026
1:34PM
Kelly Doyle 6158 bears bluff
rd
The building notes indicate it is structurally
sound. It has historic relevance to the
neighborhood and city and should not be
demolished
Jun 9 2026
2:40PM
Char Glatley 1 Rutledge Blvd,
CHARleston
29401
There is no reason to demo a structurally fine
home just to rebuild. It ruins the integrity of the
neighborhood and the fabric of this City. I vote
for denial of this item.
Jun 9 2026
3:03PM
Emily Storrow 40 Saint
Margaret St.
I urge you to deny this request for demolition.
This is a historic East Side cottage with many
vernacular features and no structural issues,
and it contributes vital and distinct context to
one of the peninsula’s most historic (and under
threat) neighborhoods. Demoing it and
replacing with a modern build is effectively
erasing East Side’s unique character at a time
when it should be preserved the most.
Jun 9 2026
3:04PM
Jamila Anderson 8704 Jenny Lind
st
NO DEMO Jun 9 2026
3:06PM
Ahpahmeh Firoozi 322 Westminster No Demo!! Do not demo a sound historic
structure.
Jun 9 2026
3:19PM
Shellie Horgan 2251 N Marsh
Dr. Mount
Pleasant, SC
29466
Please please please do not demo this 1940’s
cottage. This cottage is a lasting impression on
what the east side once was…vibrant, a story
to tell, and what makes Charleston, Charleston.
If we take this down what are we to gain? No
story, no history, just a has been dirt lot for
someone to make a cookie cutter structure.
Jun 9 2026
3:55PM
M Voorhees Trumbo Street Request no demo approval for this historic
structure.
Jun 9 2026
4:28AM
Sarah Tamsberg 1132 Yorktown
Court
Deny demo! Jun 9 2026
4:37PM
Amy Hirsch 3 elmwood st No demo!!! Jun 9 2026
4:54PM
Melissa Funk 2039 Parkway
Drive
Vote No and preserve this historic home for
generations to come. Charleston needs to keep
the heartbeat of the city alive and
preservation is the answer. Do the right thing.
Jun 9 2026
5:18PM
Emily Hendrix 4310 cotton flat
rd
no demo Jun 9 2026
5:27PM
Emily Shelley 101 Saint
Margaret Street
Charleston, SC
29403
No Demo! Jun 9 2026
6:38PM
Emily Barron 84 Bull St No demo. Preserve Charleston’s history. Jun 9 2026
7:26AM
Public Comment | 8 Sheppard Street Page 2 of 5
Eliza Bettke 18 Bogard
Street
No demo! This is the only city like this in the
country! Stop tearing down the houses that
make Charleston unique.
Jun 9 2026
7:45PM
Abigail Newton 7 Sycamore
Avenue
No Demo Jun 9 2026
7:47AM
Elizabeth Nolin Pickett Post Office Box
175, Paeonian
Springs, VA
20129
No Demo! This building is structurally sound,
and is a contributing piece of architecture to
this neighborhood. There is absolutely no
reason to allow demolition of this building.
Jun 9 2026
7:56PM
Alison Neely 1507 Greenbay
Drive
Destroying a historic home without structural
issues does not support the historic preservation
approach to development that Charleston has
promised its residents to uphold. The Eastside
neighborhood is a beautiful historic community
that deserves to uphold its unique character.
Turning a 1920 cottage into a multi-home
property is greedy and does not fit in with the
soul of the neighborhood.
Jun 9 2026
8:04AM
Nicole Morsilli 1158 N Shadow
Drive
This building should not be demoed. It is
structurally sound (a fact the requester has
stated). Why demo a structurally sound
building that has historical significance to the
east side of our peninsula? Rather, the
petitioner should thoughtfully renovate and
restore the building in its glory to be an
example of the history our city is known for.
Jun 9 2026
8:06AM
Brittany Nailon 292 Terry Rd
Bostic NC 28018
NO DEMO Jun 9 2026
8:10AM
Christy Siegling 820 Armsway
Street
A concerning precedent for folks to buy lots
relating to them as though they’re vacant.
(They’re not!) It’s tough bc I support property
rights but this is essentially ppl just making our
town whatever they see fit - ignoring the
history, context, & shared vision of the town.
Sincerely, a fatigued local
Jun 9 2026
8:17AM
Lucille Fine 90 Hanover
Street
Do not demolish this historic home. There are no
structural issues, we must maintain the cities
character. NO DEMO
Jun 9 2026
8:20PM
Robert McKinney 333 king No demo! This is a classic structure and could
easily be remodeled. So tired of people
moving here and destroying history
Jun 9 2026
8:28PM
Lucille Houting 0 s battery This demolition request should be denied due
to the structure being in good condition. There
is no need for this home to be demolished so
that a new larger home can be built.
Charleston is know for many things and be
important thing that makes it so unique is the
historic homes. The old rich history is vital to our
charm, we do not need new builds in downtown
Charleston. If the owner wants a new build
they can go to another area of
Charleston…maybe they should consider
goose creek or Summerville. Please deny this
request as the owner is simply looking to make
more money and fill their pockets and not keep
the charm of historic Charleston.
Jun 9 2026
8:39AM
Sydney Derrick 1166
Montgomery
To demo a house that so embodies an aspect
of Charleston history, and which is still
Jun 9 2026
8:50AM
Public Comment | 8 Sheppard Street Page 3 of 5
Road,
Charleston, SC
29412
structurally sound, is ludicrous. Having these
places around us today is an interactive history
lesson every day, and an experience that
should not be denied to present and future
residents/visitors.
English Burch 655 east Bay
Street apt 208
No demo Jun 9 2026
9:18AM
Amanda Metze 321 Sumter St I urge the BAR to DENY demolition for 8
Sheppard St. This 1920s cottage is not only
structurally sound, but is an important and
intact contributor to the character of the historic
East Side neighborhood.
Jun 9 2026
9:36AM
Leah S. 69 Bogard
Street, Unit B
Please don’t demolish this building. Once a
historic structure is destroyed, that piece of our
city's story is lost forever and can never be
truly replaced. As a city whose identity is
rooted in history, Charleston should continue to
protect and celebrate its historic resources
rather than demolish them. Every effort needs
to be made to preserve this building and
explore alternatives to demolition that honor its
historical integrity and significance to our
community.
Jun 9 2026
9:38PM
Emilie Crossan Summerville The 1920s cottage has no structural damage
and remains a significant example of the
historic architectural character of Charleston’s
East Side neighborhood. There is no justifiable
reason to demolish this structure beyond the
applicant’s personal and financial interests. The
BAR should deny the application and protect
this important piece of Charleston’s
architectural heritage.
Jun 9 2026
9:48AM
Chris Kronzer 88 Hanover
Street
I strongly support preserving 8 Sheppard
Street. This home isn’t an architectural
showpiece and that’s exactly the point. It’s a
honest representation of the Eastside’s history
and it should NOT be demolished. It's small
cottages like 8 Sheppard St that tell the real
story of the neighborhood and the people who
lived here. Once these significant homes are
demolished, that history is gone forever. We've
proven time and again that these homes can
be saved, much like 88 Hanover was
preserved. I hope we choose preservation over
demolition for this application.
Jun 9 2026
10:21PM
Dylan Prucker Mount Pleasant No demo Jun 9 2026
10:53AM
Jillian Sebelist 126 Cannon St
Apt A Charleston
SC 29403
This would be an unnecessary demolition that
damages the historical integrity of the
neighborhood. The application itself clarifies
that there is no structural reason for this. But if
gentrification is your goal, then go right ahead,
I guess.
Jun 9 2026
11:14AM
Emily Chandler 1306 Gilmore
Rd
Do not demo! Please do not demolish a 100+
year old cottage in Charleston’s historic
neighborhood, especially when it is structurally
sound. We have a responsibility to keep
Charleston historic where and when we can.
This is one of those times!
Jun 9 2026
11:18AM
Public Comment | 8 Sheppard Street Page 4 of 5
Caroline Parker 1463 Brookbank
Avenue, CHS, SC
This home is one of our city's most historic
neighborhood. It is an important example of a
1920's cottage, and is structurally sound. If this
home were allowed to be demolished, a very
dangerous precedent will be set. The height
and scale of the peninsula is increasing
dramatically, permanently changing the way
people experience our city. This cottage is an
important part of preservation.
Jun 9 2026
12:22AM
Kate Shannon Mount Pleasant No demo. Preserve the charm and history! Jun 9 2026
12:29PM
Holly Rhett
Hayden
1750 Atlantic
Ave
No Demo! Please do not permit demolition of
this property. Preservation of architectural
history and the rich cultural heritage of these
historic neighborhoods and properties is a part
of Charleston’s legacy. It is our responsibility
to protect this property from demolition. Deny
Demo!!
Jun 9 2026
12:47PM
Erin Minnigan
Mehard
1640 Canty
Lane
The 1940s cottage at 8 Sheppard Street is a
well-preserved, contributing resource to the
East Side neighborhood, retaining a high
degree of integrity including its form, historic
fabric, and character-defining features. There
is no compelling reason for demolition, as the
structure is sound and rehabilitation for
continued use is entirely feasible. I request the
Board to deny this request for demolition and
urge the exploration of alternatives to retain
this irreplaceable piece of the neighborhood's
history.
Jun 10 2026
10:33AM
Brittany Lavelle Tulla
(BVL HPR)
231 King Street I respectfully urge the Board to deny the
proposed demolition application. The cottage
at 8 Sheppard retains character-defining
features that powerfully reflect its contribution
to the historic East Side neighborhood,
including its vernacular cottage form and
profile. Not only does the cottage and its
features, such as its massing, front gable
orientation and the facade’s tripartite window
configuration, represent the neighborhood's
development as a working- and middle-class
residential community, but the addition of a
front porch supported by its decorative metal
columns is a common feature that defined most
cottages as the area evolved. The applicant
has stated that structural instability is not the
basis for the demolition request - therefore, the
request does not appear to be dependent on
the inability to reuse the cottage. The successful
rehabilitation of numerous Charleston cottages
in substantially worse condition proves that
preservation is possible and deserving.
Demolition would permanently eliminate a
building type that continues to convey its
historic character and association with the East
Side's cultural landscape, and has been lost on
a large scale in decades past. As
redevelopment has increased throughout this
section of the East Side, as seen in the buildings
Jun 10 2026
11:58AM
Public Comment | 8 Sheppard Street Page 5 of 5
directly adjacent to 8 Sheppard, surviving
cottages of this type have become increasingly
rare.
CITY OF CHARLESTON
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL
872 Ashley Avenue
BAR2026-002604 | TMS# 463-11-03-015 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6
Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1940 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Requesting OPT-IN REVIEW for demolition of existing exterior elements visible from the public
right-of-way AND conceptual approval for proposed addition.
Owner: Joe & Rebecca Miller
Applicant: Abigail WR Brennan
Previous site visit on 4/23/2026 at 8:50 a.m.
CITY OF CHARLESTON
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL
4 Henrietta Street
BAR2026-002563 | TMS# 459-13-03-078 | Garden District | Council District 4
New Construction | Old & Historic District
Requesting conceptual approval for a new single-family dwelling.
Owner: SC Reno Partners LLC
Applicant: Coastal Creek Design – Joel Adrian
Fred L. Willis, III | 99-1/2 Alexander Street | Charleston, SC 29403
Board of Architectural Review
City of Charleston
2 George Street
Charleston, SC 29401
Re: 4 Henrietta Street
This property is #8 on the June 11, 2026 Board of Architectural Review for conceptual approval
of a new single-family dwelling. Conceptual approval requires examination of the Height,
Scale, and Mass of the submitted project’s plans.
Due to the conditions imposed by the lot size of 4 Henrietta, Height, Scale, and Mass becomes
a challenge for the owner to meet the parameters that these conditions imply. In reviewing the
plans submitted for a single-family home on this property, I believe that the house plan as
drawn fails to meet the tests. However, the applicant has shown a willingness to revisit
previously submitted plans for this site, and I suggest that there are several ways in which the
plans can be modified to meet conceptual requirements.
The height as shown on the plans can be reduced by changing the roof pitch from 12/10 to
12/6. The south and north elevations should both have 12/6 roof pitch. The intersection of the
gable can be the same height as south elevation, or lower if that would improve the south
elevation. The east and west elevations will not be noticeable due to the proximity of the
adjacent properties.
As for the mass and scale of the project, although it meets the lot coverage requirement, I think
it violates the intent of mass and scale due to the narrowness of the lot and its ratio of width to
length. This issue is easily solved by reducing the volume of the single-family home as
presented by 1) lowering the height as addressed, and 2) by reducing the square footage of the
home. A two bedroom, two and 1/2 bath home would be much more appropriate for a 2,367
SF lot that is only 24-feet in width.
Your consideration of my comments is appreciated.
Sincerely,
Fred L. Willis, III
Fred L. Willis, III
4 Henrietta: south elevation
4 Henrietta: proposed 12/6 roof pitch
CITY OF CHARLESTON
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL
241 Coming Street
BAR2026-002620 | TMS# 460-08-03-168 | Cannonborough/Elliottoborough
Council District 6 | Category 4 | c. 1890 | Old City District
Requesting appeal of staff decision for fiberglass columns.
Owner: Myril L. Primus-Brown
Applicant: Myril L. Primus-Brown
Position Statement Board of Architectural Review – Small June 11, 2026 Agenda Item #13 241 Coming Street Dear Board Members, The Preservation Society of Charleston (PSC) commends the ongoing preservation work that has been undertaken by this legacy homeowner to steward this historic property. After reviewing the limited application materials provided, the PSC requests clarity regarding the existing piazza columns, including their material, age, current condition, and the number proposed for replacement to guide the Board in their decision-making. If repairing the existing columns is feasible, PSC recommends this as the best course of action to retain the historic integrity of this house and the longevity of the columns themselves. The PSC team welcomes the chance to discuss this project with the applicant and help establish connections with experienced professionals who can evaluate the condition of the columns and offer guidance for lasting repair methods. I can be reached at the phone number and email address below. Thank you for taking our feedback into consideration. We appreciate the Board taking our position on this matter into account. Sincerely,
Laurel M. Fay lfay@preservationsociety.org 843.722.4630 ext. 127 Manager of Preservation & Research Preservation Society of Charleston
Post Office Box 1120 ∙ Charleston, SC 29402 ∙ (843) 723-1623 ∙ Fax (843) 577-2067 ∙ www.historiccharleston.org
To: Members of the Board of Architectural Review-Small
From: Kate Dutilly, Preservation Planner
Date: June 11, 2026
Re: 241 Coming
HCF requests that the Board uphold Staff’s decision and deny the appeal for fiberglass columns
at 241 Coming Street. Additional documentation is needed to fully understand the scope and
details of the request. Thank you.
Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.