RecordWell Data

BAR-L Meeting Results

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Jun 10, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

DRAFT CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – LARGE MEETING RE SULTS JUNE 10, 2026 4:30 P.M. 2 GEORGE STREET BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT: Trey Watkins (Chair), James Meadors, Joel Trantham, Jay White STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT: Lawrence Courtney, Brad Thomas A. MINUTES 1. Review of Minutes from the May 13, 2026 Meeting DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Approval as submitted. MADE BY: Meadors SECOND: Trantham VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 B. APPLICATIONS 1. 174 King Street BAR2026-002651 | TMS #4570804003 | Downtown | Council District 8 Category 3 | c. 1876 | Height Districts 3, 6 | Old and Historic District Requesting a Revision to Conceptual Approval for alterations of an existing building. Owner: American Gardens CHS LLC Applicant: Keith Simmel DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Approval of Revisions to Conceptual Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions with further study by Applicant with Final Review by Staff of For-Permit Drawings. MADE BY: Trantham SECOND: White VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 1 Meadors against. STAFF COMMENTS: • This project previous received Conceptual Approval 28 August 2024 with Final Details to Staff. The Final Review by Staff was Approved on 8 January 2025 and the Certificate of Construction Completion was issued on 19 November 2025. • The Applicant is requesting a revision to Conceptual Approval to make modifications to the existing building to include, but not limited to, new windows and doors, a painted wood storefront, exterior lighting, awnings, and copper downspout. • The King Street (west) elevation has no proposed changes. DRAFT Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | June 10, 2026 Page 2 • The entire south façade is visible from King Street. The proposal removes the previously approved awnings and substitutes with a different design, changes the design of the pass-through window, changes the paint color for the trim on the windows and doors, turns the door closest to King Street into a window. Staff support all these changes. The submittal also proposes a painted wood storefront at the eastern end of the building. The design of the storefront takes its cues from storefronts on King Street, and its design direction is appropriate as a storefront type. What is unusual here is the placement of the storefront on what would have originally been understood as the rear of the building. Staff understand that the development of American Gardens has changed the traditional front/back relationship of the structure. Staff also note that the King Street façade historically has had no entrance on that elevation. So, given those unusual circumstances and the desire to offer public access to the building, staf f support this unusual configuration to allow the historic King Street elevation to remain as is. • The east façade is minimally visible from the public right of way on Meeting Street, which is a full city block to the east. The elevation proposes the addition of the ground floor storefront with associated revisions to windows and doors. Staff considerat ion of the storefront is primarily on the more visible South and North facades. If those are approved, then it would follow that the east would be approved as well given visibility issues as it relates to purview. • The entire north elevation is visible from King Street as well. The Applicant proposes the replacement of the single ground floor door with two new doors due to floor plan reconfigurations. The proposed door on the NW corner (on the right side of the elevation) lines up with the window above. Staff would like the proposed door on the NE corner of the elevation (on the left side of the elevation) to likewise line up with the window above it. Staff understand this will necessitate the shortening of the storef ront as it wraps around to the North and asks for the associated changes to be studied. Staff also note that the allée of trees currently extends all the way to the gate on King Street. The changing of the doors will necessitate the removal of trees that w ould block these doors. The proposed site plan (p. 9) does not make it clear if the trees will return (as the canopies are still shown in same place as previous. The first-floor plan (pp. 31-32) shows no trees. Staff would like to see the allée completed to King Street in some configuration. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. Line up doors on North elevation with the windows on the second floor and modify the storefront accordingly. 2. Complete the allée of trees all the way to King Street along the north side of the structure. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of Revision s to Conceptual Approval with Board and staff Comments and conditions with Final Review By Staff of For-Permit drawings. BOARD COMMENT AND CONDITIONS: • Changes are really pretty benign but vegetation is not under Board jurisdiction and therefore Staff Condition #2. really cannot be compelled. • Really love the park . Precedent images are great but t he switch of front to back is a path we might not want to go down as it may relate to future elements of the park. Cannot support the current design which is driven by interior design. • Appreciate Staffs detailed analysis and perspective . The new context does mak e one re-evaluate the orientation of the building – the storefront typically faces the public realm and here the public realm is toward the park which seems appropriate. This also DRAFT Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | June 10, 2026 Page 3 allows the King St. façade to remain as is. The building sits in a new life and therefore this feels appropriate. For further Board discussion see the City of Charleston YouTube channel. 2. 649 Meeting Street BAR2026-002655 | TMS #4631602060 | East Central | Council District 4 Category 1 | c. 1897 | Height District 4 | Historic Corridor District/Landmark Overlay Requesting Conceptual Approval of an addition to a Category 1 building. Owner: American College of the Building Arts (ACBA) Applicant: Sacha Rosen (Architect) DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions and a requirement for ongoing drawings to be clear and in agreement as to how the addition intersects the historic structure. MADE BY: White SECOND: Trantham VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 1 Meadors against. STAFF COMMENTS: • The Applicant was previously deferred for restudy and identification of a single pathway option with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions on 11 March 2026. • In addition to being a Category 1 structure, the Trolly Barn is also in the Landmark Overlay. This submittal is for an addition to the rear north portion of the Trolley Barn and site and thus the visibility is somewhat limited from Meeting Street. • Relevant to this discussion of an addition to a Category 1 building is Charleston Standard #7: “Additions or exterior alterations to historic properties should be sympathetic to historic materials, features, and spatial relationships that characterize the property. The new work should be compatible with the historic materials, features, size, scale, proportion, and massing to protect the integrity of the property and its setting. To respect the authenticity of the historic structure and its context and setting, the new alteration s or addition should be clearly discernable from the old. The differentiation may or may not be stylistic, and may be as subtle as a change in building footprint, material or other means.” • Also relevant is Ordinance Sec. 54 -306.13. “Additional buildings and additions to buildings that are subject to the jurisdiction of the BAR shall be subordinate in height, scale and mass to the primary building […]” • Previous Staff and Board Comments and Conditions included the following: o The direction to pick a specific style to pursue for the addition with the notation that the Board does not have stylistic agendas but did have c oncern about the type of Classicism being deployed. o Concern that the façade was being built as a veneer. o Support of height, scale and mass of the proposed addition as it is subordinate to the Trolley Barn. o Concern that the ornamented classical approach calls attention to itself and away from the Category 1 structure and therefore is not subordinate. o Requiring a more articulated joint or small hyphen between the addition and the historic brick wall. DRAFT Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | June 10, 2026 Page 4 o Discussion of whether the façade should be rebuilt over time by various cohorts of students. • In response to Board and Staff Comments and Conditions, the Applicant has: o Chosen to pursue a Classical Approach with references to turn -of-the-20th century Classicism deployed in buildings with ornamented facades (e.g. railroad stations of Daniel Burnham). o Proposed bearing masonry for the façade and all exterior walls and is no longer proposing veneer construction. o Retained the subordinate height, scale and mass of the proposal. o Used the mission and programming of the ACBA as their context for the choosing of the material palette and asserted that the place ment on the site away from the street in a courtyard setting supports the subordination of the addition. o Has not depicted an articulated joint or small hyphen between the addition and the historic wall. o Is now proposing a single student-involved build of the design submitted. • Based on the revised proposal, Staff: o Appreciate the depiction of well composed classicism (particularly the removal of the partial, asymmetrical broken pediment). o Support the use of bearing masonry for the construction of the addition. o Affirm the appropriateness of the H/S/M of the submittal. o Understand the mission of the BAR to be that of considering the physical context of the proposal (Standard 7) as well as the mission of the ACBA to include classical architecture as a key context for their programming. As regards previous Board comments re lated to the potential for classicism to be subordinate and/or appropriate for the context of the Landmark structure, Staff refer to both the Board statement that the BAR “does not have stylistic agendas” which is applied consistently (and not just in this application) and to Ordinance Sec. 54 -306.13. which clearly states that “… additions to buildings that are subject to the jurisdiction of the BAR shall be subordinate in height, scale and mass to the primary building […]” and does not reference architectural direction. If the Board believed classicism to be inappropriate for the context and subordination, then the motion should not have been to ask the applicant to make a choice but to clearly state that Option 2 (as defined in March 2026 submittal), be the only appropriate architectural direction for the applicant to pursue. Applicant has followed 5 of the 6 Standard 7 directives related to compatibility (with features perhaps relating to architectural direction and therefore up for debate) and the Standard 7 directive for the addition to be discernable from the historic structure. Staff also note that the proposal is set back on the site and does not sit directly on Meeting Street. Given this assessment, Staff affirm that the classical architectural directi on is an acceptable choice to achieve subordination. o Have concerns about how the addition will touch the historic wall. The column closest to the addition is not a flat plane. How will the applicant negotiate that variability? The current conceptual plan detail shows the base of the column touching the historic wall. As previously mentioned, this is not an acceptable approach, there needs to be some type of articulated joint or small hyphen between the addition and the historic wall. o Is comfortable with a single proposal, built once by students. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. The next review submittal must include details showing how the new additional will connect to the historic wall as previously requested by Board and Staff. 2. The scale of the proposed addition has been noted to be different between what is shown in elevations and in renderings. As this difference directly impacts how Board and DRAFT Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | June 10, 2026 Page 5 Staff view the issues related to subordination, we need to see these drawings in agreement as to actual scale in relation to the historic structure. 3. Staff has spoken with Sacha Rosen advising him of Board and Staff concerns regarding the apparent differences in scale shown in the elevations and renderings. He checked on these and said that they indeed were in agreement and on the renderings a tonal shift at the eave line was possibly causing some confusion. 4. To Staff, the question is whether these apparent graphic inconsistencies rise to the level of Deferral for this Conceptual level of review. The formulaic nature of Classical Design will largely govern the scale and it will not be significantly different than what is shown with any adjustment. Thus, Height, Scale and Mass and General Architectural Direction are clearly enough defined. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions and a requirement for ongoing drawings to be clear and in agreement as to how the addition intersects the Historic structure. BOARD COMMENT AND CONDITIONS: • Were there any elements on the existing building which helped inform the design as to elements or where they occur on the addition? • There are concerns regarding the scale of the addition which is shown in different relationships with up to what appears to be about a 4’ difference. Can you help in resolving this? • How is water from the two roofs being handled between the two structures and how will it affect existing elements on the historic structure? We need to better understand this due to it being such an important condition. • We’ve discussed details before, is this critical juncture a matter for concern now as it relates to scale? • Conceptual Review relates to height, scale and mass and general architectural direction and the applicant has clarified what this detail might be and it is not going to affect the height, scale and mass. In this case we would be deferring a Conceptual design for lack of a Preliminary level detail. If the applicant had not been able to describe what they intend, it might be a different matter. We could require that this be shown at Preliminary, and if not, well… • Agreed think it is covered under staff conditions …. the record is covered on that and that it can be addressed at Preliminary. • The compatibility of the addition in its features, scale, style and materiality to the historic structure and as all of these are in such contrast – at what point is does it begin to tip, in its architectural direction, in terms of being subordinate to another structure? Are the attributes of this design overriding the idea of this being subordinate in nature? The separation between the two is important but I do thin k that is something we could look at at a preliminary level. I do think the north façade is more successful now as it turns the corner and shifts back towards the existing . So I’m curious as to how you all feel about the amount architectural elements on the meeting St. façade and how it relates to the existing. • If you go back to the ordinance, it does define subordination extraordinarily well, with style not being included. It’s obviously a higher style than the building its adjoining, which might feel a little strange, but the ordinance really does not define a hierarchy to style in terms of subordination. Another thing that staff did not draw from in the ordinance is the latitude that it gives to civic structures. I think that the fact that this is a n institution teaching students a traditional craft is something we should consider too. Another thing is that if this is to be built by students or graduates to demonstrate their capacity then DRAFT Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | June 10, 2026 Page 6 we should not restrain them. The fact that it is back from the street and partially concealed helps I am comfortable with applicant’s response to comments from last time and think that staff has been detailed and explicit in their recommendation, so I’m okay with conceptual approval. • I do think that as this moves towar d Preliminary there are a few details will warrant restudy but in separating the structure, it having a didactic purpose and is something that the public will get to experience, it is appropriate. • I would also echo this thinking and add that, as staff points out, we did give the directive to pursue one pathway for design and we need to hold to that. For further Board discussion see the City of Charleston YouTube channel. 3. 261 Calhoun Street BAR2026-002636 | TMS #4570301097 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 Not Rated | c. 1998 | Height District 5 | Old and Historic District Requesting Final Approval of two (2) illuminated façade signs. Owner: Medical University of South Carolina (MUSC) Applicant: Jake Back (Greenberg Farrow) WITHDRAWN BY APPLICANT NOTES: Withdrawn by applicant prior to meeting. 4. 83 Mary Street BAR2026-002628 | TMS #4601202024 | Mazyck-Wraggborough | Council District 4 Not Rated | c. 2019 | Height District 8 | Old and Historic District Requesting Final Approval of an illuminated hanging sign. Owner: 83 Mary, LLC Applicant: Lindsay Wine (LINGEO Sign) DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Final approval with Board and staff comments and Conditions with Final Review of Details to Staff and associated field Reviews and the Condition that the sign is illuminated only during business hours. MADE BY: White SECOND: Trantham VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 STAFF COMMENTS: The following BAR Policy Statements are relevant to this application. • BAR Signage Policy: o (1) Design : Signage shall respect, complement, and reflect the architectural character of a building, its context, and surroundings through appropriate size, scale, materials, color, and design. Signs shall be non -intrusive, pedestrian -oriented, balanced to the facade, and reflect a human scale. Signs shall not obscure significant architectural features and appear dominant or visually overwhelming, both on the building it is applied to and neighboring buildings. o (4) Brands: There is no presumption of approval for corporate logos or branding. Private agreements regarding tenant signage, to which the City is not a party, are irrelevant to the review process and will not be considered. DRAFT Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | June 10, 2026 Page 7 o (7) Location: Signage is only permitted on first -floor façades that directly front a public right-of-way. o (9) Illumination: All signage that is directly or indirectly illuminated, or has the potential to be illuminated, shall be reviewed and approved by either the City Architect or the Board before receiving approval within a sign permit. Illumination shall be permitted only for businesses operating after dark and of a muted tone and brightness. o (11)(iv) Unpermitted Signage Types and Attributes include Cabinet/Boxstyles. • While the primary component of this application is the proposed illumination, the Applicant is also proposing a sign type that is not specifically addressed in either the BAR Sign Policy Statement or the Zoning Ordinance. Essentially, it is a suspended façade sign with a cloud cabinet. • Staff find that a suspended façade sign is the most appropriate sign type for this location because of the following factors: o The absence of a traditional sign band. o The height of the canopy. o The large amount of storefront glazing. o The contemporary architectural direction of the building. • Staff also support the proposed font, color, and overall size of the suspended façade sign. • Concerning illumination, Staff acknowledges and agrees with the Applicant's statement that lighting is necessary due to the business's proposed operating hours, which begin at 5:00 a.m. • The Applicant proposes to illuminate the sign using white LEDs. • The application does not specify the illumination levels or the mounting method for the sign. • Although some technical details remain unresolved, Staff is confident that these items can be addressed during the permitting process and do not affect the Board's ability to evaluate the appropriateness of the sign concept. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. Provide details regarding mounting and illumination level and color temperature to Staff within the permit drawings. 2. Provide a nighttime Staff field inspection of the illumination and adjust levels if requested by Staff following inspection, recording them and providing a program for monitoring and maintaining them. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Final Approval with Board and Staff Conditions with Final Review of Details to Staff in the Permit and associated field reviews. BOARD COMMENTS AND CONDITIONS: • The board has typically had issues with illuminated signs on historic buildings. This is a contemporary building and therefore it seems appropriate. • Can we simply condition an approval on the sign being illuminated during hours of operation? That condition would help prevent the illumination when the business is not open, say at 10 o’clock at night. For further Board discussion see the City of Charleston YouTube channel.

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.