RecordWell Data

BZA-SD Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Jun 3, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – SITE DESIGN PUBLIC COMMENT JUNE 3, 2026 A meeting of the BZA-SD will be held on Wednesday, June 3, 2026 at 5:00 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street. The following written comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the meeting and also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/bza-sd. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 A. Review of Minutes and Deferred Applications from Previously Advertised BZA-SD Agendas 3. Grand Oaks Boulevard West Ashley | Council District 10 | TMS #301-00-00-052 | Zoned: GB/LB Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 19 grand trees. Request a special exception from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 3 grand trees. Request a variance from Sec 54-330 to allow a reduction in the impervious construction setback near the bases of 6 grand trees. Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 10 protected trees. Owner: Bees Resources Applicant: Thomas and Hutton 50 Comments in Opposition and 1 other comment: • See attached comments submitted on the Innovate site and to staff. B. New Applications 1. 4 Jenkins Ave Citadel | Council District 6 | TMS# 460-00-00-004 | Zoned: DR-1F & SR-2 Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of one grand tree. Owner: The Citadel Applicant: ADC Engineering No Comments Submitted 2. Hollydale Court Johns Island | Council District 3 | TMS# 313-00-00-021, 023, 328 & 329 Zoned: GB & BP Request a special exception from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of four grand trees. Owner: TBLB LLC Applicant: Windmill Engineering No Comments Submitted Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 2 A-3: Grand Oaks Boulevard 1 Other Comment: • Suzanne Stinson, Resident Submitted to Staff See attached letter. 50 Comments Submitted in Opposition: First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted Zac Viscidi 59 Cypress St The headline of the city’s public participation website is “Your Opinion Is Important” but it seems that this is continually ignored when it relates to the removal of grand trees. On an almost monthly basis, there are pockets of concern over our tree canopy from across the city. Developers propose removal and the individuals who see these changes firsthand participate, speak up, and ask the city to stop destroying the green spaces that truly define the area we love. However, the bar seems to never be met, and the burden of the developers continually wins. These 32 trees may be a small portion of the overall canopy, but this is not the first time, nor will it be the last that a small pocket of citizens has stood up in vain in opposition to the removal of grand trees. The bar to denial should not require mustering thousands of voices in unison over one project. The cacophony is already there, but it comes in waves as informed citizens see the impact in their area. The city tree removal laws were created to allow for the city officials to justify denial of these developments without needing a chorus of citizens backing them. Please, listen not just to the few concerned constituents who speak up in this instance; look to the constant trend and think about the overall damage that is repeatedly occurring across our city. Jun 1 2026 1:27AM Devin Moore 1028 Tyron Circle, Charleston, SC 29414 I am STRONGLY OPPOSED to the Variances and Special Exceptions being requested to remove or impinge on Grand Trees and Protected Trees for the unwanted and unnecessary development of this natural area. This is the last and only wooded forest section of the Grand Oaks PUD and the last safe haven for the wildlife in our community. It also serves the very important purpose of helping to cope with flooding in our neighborhood, providing capacity for rainwater that would otherwise flood our streets and homes. I do not agree with any variances or exceptions that would allow for even a single Grand Oak or Protected Tree to be removed. If this multi-family housing development is allowed to move forward, it would be a far better option to Jun 1 2026 1:33PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 3 reduce the unit count & population density of the development by removing two or three buildings from the proposed development instead of removing any of the outlined trees. The proposed buffer along Grand Oaks should be required to be at least twice as deep. The citizens of West Ashley implore you to hear our voices and represent us instead of bowing to the developers. Help us save our neighborhood and protect our environment! Eric Wilhelm 1706 N Elgin Ct I do not consent to the removal of protected trees. They are needed to mitigate flooding. In addition, infrastructure in the area is struggling to accommodate more housing/traffic. I object to any protected trees being removed at any time Jun 1 2026 2:44PM David Scott 511 Carters Grove Road I am strongly against this project. I believe it will have substantial negative impacts on the communities and neighborhoods around the site, as was brought up countless times in the previous BZA-SD meeting. In addition to the Grand Trees they are requesting to remove, they also propose removing 867 Protected Trees, which is in excess of the 25% allowed under 54- 327B (by approximately 500 trees). They have not requested a variance to 54-327B, which I believe needs to be addressed. I am aware a variance can be granted for that section, but I would urge the board to reject their current proposal and consider an alternate site design where the parking garages (30 of them) are removed. SKIM READING INFO: If you look on pages 22, 24, and 26, I believe the removal of the parking garages will save around eight (8) of the protected trees they want to remove near the property line (of the ten in their current variance request), as well as countless other trees they didn't request a variance for. This has no impact on the number of apartments they are asking to build, and is a minor impact on overall site design. (the 30 parking garages are excess spaces above the number required by the city). Shifting some parking into those sites shown as garage spaces would allow more trees to be protected, and give a better buffer against the edge of the lot. Unrelated to the above request to remove the parking garages to make the site complaint and reduce the number of trees removed, I still believe the overall site design fails the tests allowing a variance to be granted. Jun 1 2026 4:13PM Richard Kazzi 862 Rue Drive Charleston Please do not let them move forward with the removal of these protected trees. Why do we have protected trees, if someone can lobby to remove them. There is no hardship here. And, I'm also not in favor of the reduction in the setback near the bases of 6 protected trees. Thank you for your consideration in this matter. Jun 1 2026 5:31PM Cindy Kazzi 862 Rue As a resident of Grand Oaks plantation i travel Grand Jun 1 2026 Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 4 Drive Oaks Boulevard daily. I understand that the project was approved decades ago so overcrowding the already crowded area is all about money, however that should not include destroying protected trees so that extra structures can be crowded into the project Even one extra tree destroyed is invading the wildlife and environmental status in that area This appears to me to be a sleezy way of still trying to make more money by getting around the system Please don’t let this happen 5:45PM Patrick Boyle 434 Blue Jasmine Lane, Charleston 29414 I wish to voice my strong objection to removing any trees along Grand Oaks Boulevard. These trees are in good health, protect the area from flooding, and are an important part of our community. They do not been to be cut down for this development and should not be removed. Jun 1 2026 7:09PM Shawn Finch 190 Gazania Way, Charleston SC 29414 I have lived in West Ashley since 2016 and in Grand Bees since 2020. The area was perfect back in 2016 without the over building. The greed of these developers is over the top and needs to stop. We don't need more apartments, townhomes, grocery stores and entire neighborhoods by the landfill. You are taking away the beauty of West Ashley by killing trees and not to mention taking away the wildlife habitat and then blaming them for being in your yard. The Grand Bees project needs to be stopped because it will just look like a concrete jungle and has anyone thought of the traffic issues that will get worse Just look at it this way, basically two cars per house hold added and that's just the minimum. If Council members won't step up to developers then you should be voted out. I'm sure I have wasted my time with this and to add it's a crap move setting the meeting when people are just getting off work. It's gotten to the point we might sell and move because West Ashley is turning into a shithole. Jun 1 2026 8:04PM Stephanie Brooks 220 hampton Bluff Rd Charleston SC 29414 As a resident of the Grand Oaks neighborhood (Autumn Chase), I ask that the council reject this developer's request to remove these grand/protected trees. When we look at the actual legal standards for granting a variance or special exception under the tree protection ordinance, this application simply doesn't qualify — and approving something that doesn't qualify undermines the entire point of having that protection in place. As I mentioned in my last comment regarding this situation: "These..trees are not incidental landscaping. They are the living foundation of an entryway that our neighborhood was named for. They represent decades — in some cases, generations — of natural growth that cannot be replicated within any reasonable timeframe. Their removal would not Jun 1 2026 9:24PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 5 simply alter the appearance of this corridor; it would permanently and irreversibly eliminate the green canopy that residents of Autumn Chase, Magnolia Lakes, and the broader Grand Oaks Plantation community have come to treasure as a defining feature of where we live." There are many good reasons to deny this request and a huge number of residents that will be impacted by your decision. Mark Brooks 220 Hampton Bluff Dr Charleston SC 29414 The Authorization of These Variances Would Be of Substantial Detriment to the Public Good. The BZA variance process is the mechanism through which that protection is enforced. Here, the applicant has submitted an application that relies on an unverified factual predicate, fails to demonstrate hardship as to the healthy trees on the removal list, and provides no legally sufficient basis for the special exception request. For once listen to what the people who actually live there think. Jun 1 2026 9:33PM Jena Wirth 434 Blue Jasmine Lane I am writing to strongly oppose the variance and special exception requests submitted by Thomas & Hutton for the proposed Bees Resource Apartments on Grand Oaks Boulevard. As a Grand Oaks resident, I urge the Board to deny these requests based on the following critical points, aligning with objections raised by the Coastal Conservation League (CCL) during the previous meeting: 1. Unsubstantiated Hardship Claims: The applicant’s primary justification for a variance relies on an unverified claim that previous phosphate mining created site constraints. As CCL noted, no historical maps, environmental reports, or survey data have been provided to legally prove this unique property hardship. 2. Design Choices vs. Hardship: Many of the grand trees slated for destruction are healthy, high-quality trees (rated "B" condition). They are being removed simply to accommodate surface parking and drive aisles. This is a voluntary site design choice, not an environmental hardship that justifies bypassing our tree protection ordinances. 3. Compounded Stormwater and Flooding Risks: This tract is vital for local water retention. Removing mature hardwoods (up to 44 inches DBH) will severely compromise stormwater interception. Furthermore, the upcoming Long Savannah road extension bordering this property will drastically increase impervious surfaces in the immediate area. Losing this canopy alongside the road expansion will compound local runoff issues, heavily stressing our already vulnerable stormwater infrastructure. 4. Procedural Deficiencies: The applicant has failed to provide the necessary documentation or specific tree identifications required under Section 54-329.b to legally grant a special exception. The Board's variance process exists to Jun 2 2026 8:29AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 6 protect our canopy from unnecessary clear-cutting. The developer has failed to demonstrate a true hardship and should reconfigure their site plan to design around these irreplaceable community assets. Please deny all requested variances and special exceptions. Thank you for your time. Erin Nichols 120 Fulmar Place, Charleston, SC 29414 I live in Grand Oaks and we are named that for a reason. No trees should be removed that are protected. They are protected for a reason. We need the sound buffer and they provide oxygen and home for the native wildlife. Too many trees are being removed in this Bees Ferry Corridor. I have over 10 species of small birds that rely on the trees for shelter. We need to be good natives and build around the trees. It is possible. It is what makes us the Lowcountry that people travel too. Jun 2 2026 9:35AM Heather Moore 1028 Tyron Circle I am writing to again express my opposition to the proposed removal of grand trees as part of this development. During the last meeting, it was clear that the developer did not demonstrate that all of the required criteria for a special exception had been met. Granting a special exception should require a compelling showing that the standards have been satisfied, yet significant concerns remain unanswered. What specific hardship prevents the developer from redesigning the project to preserve more trees? It is also important to remember that nothing has been built! The site is still in the planning stage, which means there is still an opportunity to make meaningful changes. Relocating buildings, adjusting the site layout, reducing the footprint of the project, or even decreasing the number of proposed buildings would come at little to no cost compared to the irreversible loss of mature trees and valuable green space. Once these trees are removed, they are gone forever. The preservation of these trees is not simply an aesthetic issue. The existing tree canopy and green space help absorb stormwater, reduce flooding, improve air quality, provide wildlife habitat, and maintain the character of our community. In an area that continues to experience flooding concerns, removing so much established vegetation is contrary to the long-term interests of both existing and future residents. I would also ask the board to consider the extraordinary level of public interest and concern surrounding this proposal. The volume of comments received should make it abundantly clear that residents care deeply about preserving the natural features that make Grand Oaks a desirable place to live. The community is not asking that development be prohibited. Rather, residents are asking the developer to be a better neighbor by making reasonable efforts to preserve Jun 2 2026 9:55AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 7 more of the existing trees, landscaping, and open space. The current and updated proposal appears to prioritize clearing the site to the greatest extent possible instead of working with the existing landscape. It is difficult to understand why the removal of grand trees is necessary when there are still opportunities to modify the project before construction begins. A development can be successful while also respecting the community and the environment. I respectfully urge you to deny the special exception request or require substantial revisions to the plan that preserve more trees, protect green space, and better reflect the concerns of the residents who will be most affected by this project. Thank you for your consideration. Emily Vogelgesang 584 Hainsworth Dr These are trees in good health. There is no reason to provide the variance. These ordinances have been put in place to protect the character and environmental health of Charleston and variances should not be allowed. Additionally, reducing the impervious setback will likely kill the trees impacted so should not be allowed. This will impact flooding as well. Jun 2 2026 9:57AM Kyle Boggs 718 Bent Hickory Rd I urge the Board to deny the request to remove these protected trees on Grand Oaks Boulevard. While the developer has reduced the number of trees proposed for removal, 32 mature trees are still a significant loss to our community. According to the applicant’s own arborist, many of these trees are not in poor health, making their removal difficult to justify. Mature trees provide benefits that cannot be quickly replaced, including shade, stormwater management, wildlife habitat, and the character that makes Charleston unique. Development should be designed around healthy protected trees whenever possible, not the other way around. Please prioritize preservation and require alternatives that retain these valuable community assets. Jun 2 2026 10:25AM Christine Horne 249 Larissa Dr, Charleston, SC 29414 I strongly oppose the proposed Grand Oaks Boulevard development and the request to remove dozens of grand and protected trees. Our area is already experiencing increased traffic congestion, flooding concerns, and the loss of the natural character that makes West Ashley a desirable place to live. Removing mature trees will only worsen these problems. Large trees absorb stormwater, reduce runoff, and help mitigate flooding during heavy rains. Once they are removed, newly planted saplings cannot provide the same benefits for decades. This development appears to prioritize maximizing construction over preserving the environmental resources that protect surrounding neighborhoods. The loss of so many mature trees will Jun 2 2026 10:54AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 8 permanently alter the character of the area, reduce green space, and diminish the beauty that contributes to local property values and quality of life. Residents should not be asked to accept more traffic, more flooding risk, and the destruction of our tree canopy for a project that requires extensive variances to move forward. I urge the Board of Zoning Appeals to deny these requests and require a plan that protects our existing trees and respects the surrounding community. Pamela Wike 793 Bent Hickory Road I am writing again to oppose the variance requests and the special exception for the residential development. There is no hard ship that would require the removal of grand trees, protected trees, nor the reduction of setbacks. I am not opposed to smart development, but filling in our wetlands and killing and displacing wildlife is not the answer to line pockets with money for that one more unit. Has a traffic study been completed yet? And, do not do the traffic study during the summer, do it during the school year to get an accurate study. Bees Ferry Road, Glenn McConnell and Highway 17 are over crowded and can't handle any additional traffic. In 2025/early 2026, during the school year, it took 35min to go 6miles on Bees Ferry and Glenn McConnell. With the number of residential units, storage facilities, car washes, fire training facility, restaurants being added around this project it will become impossible nor fun to leave home. Fix the infrastructure and require property owners and builders to do more for infrastructure! We need flooding issues resolved and not by cutting down trees for detention ponds, roadways, public transportation, schools for all the homes being built. The residents of Grand Oaks all know this will pass then the developer and engineering firm will move on to the next big thing for money and leave the city to fix the traffic and flooding. So, please have more of a wooded buffer off Grand Oaks Blvd. and save all the grand and protected trees. Jun 2 2026 11:10AM Steven Giorno 174 Cabrill Dr CHS, SC 29414 I have watched as more and more development has changed not just the physical appeal of the Glen McConnell- Bees Ferry area of West Ashley but also the esthetics' of life in the greatest city in the state and the south. We moved here from CLT, NC in 2015. We moved to be closer to our children and grand children and the quality of life that we were looking for. Charlotte had grown into a mini metropolis trying to become another Atlanta. In the 11 years that we have lived in Grand Oaks we have seen more homes, condos, apartments and commercial development in such a small area and at a rate that can not be sustained. The environmental impact of flooding and pollution and loss of wetlands effects all of us. The Jun 2 2026 11:24AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 9 impact of out of control growth has out paced the road and utility capacity of the area. We are paying for this "GROWTH" by increased property taxes, sales taxes, utility rate increases, insurance costs and most importantly a loss of the quality of life the Charleston area once offered. This proposal to further develop Grand Oaks Plantation into more multi family development is WRONG. For all the reasons I have already mentioned. As I read the reason for the rezoning variance it is to remove more trees and change the road construction in this proposed multi family development at the entrance to Grand Oaks. With new development already planned for West Ashley Circle including more multi family and commercial development and the future extension of Glen McConnell Parkway through Grand Oaks I say IT'S TIME TO PERMENENTLY STOP DEVLOPMENT IN GRAND OAKS. This project does nothing to improve our quality of life, provide additional infrastructure, or provide additional financial gain. Except to the developer and the politicians that benefit from their support of over development. DEVELOPERS AND POLITICIANS BENEFIT AND CONSTITUENTS ARE TOLD EXCEPT IT. THIS IS THE FUTURE. WE DON'T HAVE TO ACCEPT THIS ANY LONGER. THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION TO THIS MATTER AND YOUR RESPONSE IS EXPECTED. Kathryn Wilson 225 Brambling Lane I am a Landing at Grand Oaks resident and strongly oppose the removal of protected and Grand trees for the Bees Resources project ! West Ashley has become a dumping ground to provide tax revenue for the peninsula with no attempt to improve WA. I say NO to removal of 19 grand trees, NO to special exception to remove 3 grand trees, NO to reduce any construction setbacks and NO removal of 10 protected trees! Let the developer figure out how to deal with it as they purchased the land. It’s hot to syop / these developers assume Charleston will now to their demands. SAY NO !!! Jun 2 2026 11:50AM Summer Elcock 511 Carters Grove Road This is far too many grand and protected trees being removed, on top of the removal of hundreds of trees that are also being removed to develop on this wetland. These trees and this land help with water retention, air quality, and provide a safe haven for dozens of different types of species. This is not being developed with longevity to the community and the environment in mind. Variances should be for smaller issues, not blatant disregard for the rules. Jun 2 2026 11:51AM Maria Hoffman 261 Larissa Drive, Charleston, SC 29414 I strongly oppose the requested variances and special exceptions for the proposed 382-unit apartment complex on Grand Oaks Boulevard. Grand Oaks is known for its beautiful mature trees, natural Jun 2 2026 11:52AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 10 landscape, and family-friendly environment. The tree canopy is one of the primary reasons residents choose to live here and raise their children and grandchildren. Removing dozens of protected grand trees would permanently damage the character and beauty of our community. The proposed development would also create additional traffic congestion and safety concerns on roads that are already heavily traveled. Increased traffic puts pedestrians, cyclists, children, and families at greater risk and negatively impacts the quality of life for existing residents. In addition, removing these mature trees would disrupt local wildlife habitats and harm the natural ecosystem that makes this area unique. These trees provide environmental benefits that cannot simply be replaced by smaller new plantings. They help with stormwater management, shade, air quality, and preserving the natural character of West Ashley. I am also concerned by the serious issues raised in the Coastal Conservation League’s comments regarding the developer’s failure to meet the legal standards required for these variances and special exceptions. According to the League, the applicant has not provided sufficient evidence to justify the hardship claims, including unsupported assertions regarding prior phosphate mining and site limitations. The application also appears to rely on removing many healthy trees simply to accommodate design choices such as parking areas and drive aisles. The City’s tree protection ordinance exists to preserve irreplaceable community assets like the grand trees in Grand Oaks. Granting these requests would undermine the purpose of those protections and set a damaging precedent for future development. I respectfully urge the Board to deny these variance and special exception requests and protect the trees, safety, wildlife, and character of the Grand Oaks community for current and future generations Joy Geter 252 Gazania Way I oppose the removal of additional trees for overdevelopment in this environmentally sensitive wetland area. Mature trees are essential for stormwater absorption, flood prevention, erosion control, and protecting Charlestons's already strained infrastructure. Removing them will only worsen flooding, heat, traffic, and environmental damage. Once these trees and wetlands are gone, they cannot realistically be replaced. Charleston needs responsible growth - not unchecked development at the expense of its natural protections. May 28 2026 1:01PM Linh Smith 556 Ivy cir I Oppose to remove grand trees May 28 2026 1:09PM Laura Thompson 2136 I oppose the destruction of more trees on Bees Ferry. May 28 2026 Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 11 Military Way, Charleston SC The roads around the Grand Oaks neighborhood are already overloaded with traffic, and additional apartments will only make the situation worse. These trees are part of the swamplands and destroying more of them will continue to destroy the habitats of many animals. People wonder why we have an issue with alligators coming into people's yards, well this is the reason why. Please do not continue to build in this area and tear down the beautiful Oak trees that have been in this area for years. 1:19PM CYNTHIA SMART 301 Steele Magnolia These trees need to remain. Arborist says they are healthy. Grand oaks take a long time to grow and are not replaceable. The benefits trees provide are numerous and can’t be overstated. We have already lost 100s of trees with the raping if the land for Long Savannah. ENOUGH!!!!! May 28 2026 1:22PM Jennifer Powell 156 Evening Shade Drive; Charleston, SC 29414 Please do not remove the 32 trees alongside Grand Oaks Boulevard! 1. Environmental and Ecological Impacts Air Quality: Trees filter pollutants from the air, improving air quality by reducing particulate matter and absorbing harmful gases, such as nitrogen oxides, ozone, and sulfur dioxide. Removal of trees would exacerbate air pollution in the area. Soil Erosion and Flooding: Tree roots stabilize soil, reducing erosion, and help manage water runoff. Deforestation increases the risk of soil degradation, landslides, and flooding in adjacent areas. We have enough issues with flooding, and cutting down these trees will contribute to that issue. Biodiversity Loss: Trees provide habitats for plants, birds, and animals. Cutting them down disrupts ecosystems, leading to species displacement or extinction. 2. Economic Consequences Ecosystem Services Value: Trees provide crucial ecosystem services, such as water filtration, pollination, and climate moderation, which often hold significant economic value. Removing trees jeopardizes these services and may lead to higher costs for artificial replacements. Cost of Mitigation: The consequences of tree removal, such as erosion, flooding, and poor air quality, often lead to substantial costs for remediation and infrastructure repair. 3. Human Health and Well- being Improved Health Outcomes: Trees reduce urban heat island effects, providing cooling and minimizing heat-related illnesses. Urban areas without trees often experience higher temperatures, leading to increased health risks. Stress Reduction and Mental Health: Tree- lined spaces and forests promote psychological well- being, reduce stress, and encourage outdoor physical activity. Removing these natural spaces diminishes the quality of life for nearby residents. Noise Reduction: Trees act as natural sound barriers, reducing noise May 28 2026 1:40PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 12 pollution in urban and suburban environments. Their removal can lead to increased noise levels, adversely affecting nearby communities. 4. Community and Aesthetic Value Enhanced Property Values: Properties near green spaces or tree canopies typically have higher market values. Tree removal can decrease property appeal and lead to economic decline in neighborhoods. Denise Gann 188 Larissa Dr Please reject the destruction of this space and these trees on Grand Oaks Boulevard. We need these pockets of nature in our area. And please do not build more apartments - our infrastructure cannot handle this. May 28 2026 2:08PM Meagan Labriola 1578 Dowden Court, Charleston, SC 29407 I am a long time resident of West Ashley and I am writing to appeal to the Board of Zoning to please protect the remaining natural environment of West Ashley and reject the plan to cut down 38 grand trees in West Ashley. These trees are what make the Lowcountry special and unique and what make the region a profitable attraction for tourists and visitors. I believe it is short-sighted to cut down the Lowcountry's natural and historic heritage for short-term profits for just a few people. We will lose something invaluable that will be lost forever to line the pockets of a few. Thank you for your time. May 28 2026 2:40PM Hope Sanders 562 Merrywood dr Traffic is already a nightmare here. It barely resembles Charleston anymore. The wild life have absolutely nowhere to go. It already takes about 45 mins at times just to get through the traffic from bees ferry/glen mcconnell. This place is being ruined by developers. May 28 2026 3:45PM Lou Friscoe 373 weeping Willow way, Charleston, 29414 The proposed removal of 32 protected trees within the Grand Oaks community in West Ashley represents a serious environmental, legal, and community concern. These trees are not dead, diseased, hazardous, or structurally compromised. They are healthy, mature components of the ecosystem that provide critical environmental services and contribute directly to the character and identity of the Grand Oaks development. Protected trees exist under local ordinances for a reason. Mature trees absorb and slow stormwater runoff, reduce flooding, stabilize soil, filter pollutants, lower surrounding temperatures, improve air quality, and provide vital wildlife habitat. In a coastal region such as Charleston County, where stormwater management and flooding continue to be major public concerns, the preservation of large mature trees is not optional — it is a necessary environmental safeguard. The trees targeted for removal currently serve as natural stormwater infrastructure. Their root systems absorb substantial amounts of water during heavy rains, reducing erosion and helping prevent excessive May 28 2026 6:19PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 13 runoff into streets, drainage systems, wetlands, and nearby properties. Removing 32 mature trees would significantly reduce the land’s natural water absorption capacity and could worsen localized flooding conditions within surrounding neighborhoods. In addition to environmental impacts, these trees support birds, squirrels, pollinators, and other native wildlife that rely on mature canopy systems for shelter, nesting, and food sources. Once removed, it takes decades for replacement trees to provide the same ecological benefits. Saplings and mitigation plantings cannot immediately replace the environmental function of established mature hardwoods. The name “Grand Oaks” itself reflects the community’s historic tree canopy and natural landscape. These mature trees are part of the neighborhood’s identity, aesthetics, and property value. Their removal would permanently alter the visual character of the development and diminish the quality of life for residents who chose to live in a community known for its trees and green space. Most importantly, these trees are legally protected. Tree protection ordinances are designed specifically to prevent unnecessary clearing for development convenience or profit when no legitimate hazard or public safety issue exists. Allowing the removal of healthy protected trees undermines the purpose of those ordinances and sets a dangerous precedent for future development throughout West Ashley and Charleston County. Development and growth should not come at the expense of environmental protections that were established to preserve the health, safety, and sustainability of the community. Responsible development must work around protected natural resources whenever possible rather than eliminating them for ease of construction. For these reasons, the removal permits for these 32 protected trees should be denied unless the developer can clearly demonstrate unavoidable necessity, compliance with all applicable environmental regulations, and the absence of reasonable alternatives. The preservation of these trees is in the best interest of the residents, wildlife, stormwater management systems, environmental health, and the long-term integrity of the Grand Oaks community. BRYAN EVANS 2522 Rutherford Way, Charleston, SC 29414- 6666, USA Why are you guys even contemplating cutting down a bunch of oxygen producing Grand trees to put up a bunch of shitty townhouse apartments whatever the hell they are. That are all cookie cutter, poorly made, crappily designed, and ugly. Why do you like to make Charleston more ugly? We already have long Savannah about ready to lay waste to a bunch of fucking natural May 28 2026 8:41PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 14 area and you want to add this pestilent boil into an area that's already pretty difficult to get in and out of the neighborhood with traffic no you want to add some crap ass townhouses as well. Respectfully guys really need to retire if you're allowing this type of crap to continue all the dang time. Karen Melamed 756 Certificate Ct. Charleston 29414 I did not move to this neighborhood to be surrounded by ugly apartment buildings. I moved to this neighborhood because of the beautiful woods, the wildlife, and and the quiet. You are proposing to cut down oak trees that have been here before there was a West Ashley. . And for what? More apartment buildings? You are compromising our livability by proposing this development. Our neighborhood is already over-crowded and the last thing we need is to add more apartments that will increase traffic, drive away the what little wildlife we have left and cause more stress on our already stressed power grid. Nobody needs this or wants this save some builders who probably live in Mt. Pleasant. Hey, that's an idea. Why don't you build in Mt. Pleasant near the homes of Thomas and Hutton. I'm sure they would love that. May 28 2026 8:54PM Gretchen Rowe 160 Ivy Green Way Why have tree protection at all if that protection can be so easily removed? More housing in West Ashley is only going to lower the overall satisfaction of everyone living in West Ashley. Charleston is bursting already; you must know and see this. You must put a stop to this over development that is only going to congest the area more, make people want to move out rather than move in, and disrupt nature (removing trees, animal habitat, and flood protection). Nothing about this is a good idea. Please, if you know what is good, put residents before money. May 28 2026 9:34AM Beverly Hiott 1007 Ashley Gardens Boulevard Absolutely NO more tree removal!!!! May 28 2026 9:42AM Ann Skerkavich Grand Terrace I oppose the destruction of the GRAND OAKS section of our beautiful city! Please cease the trashing of this area. Residents need to be heard! Let’s vote yay or Nay. May 28 2026 10:00AM Darby Brass 1035 Ashley Gardens Blvd Charleston 29414 Please do not allow the tree removal of any kind. We have laws and standards in place for a reason……to protect our trees! To me it is backwards for developers to come up with their building plans and then after the fact ask about going against Charleston’s tree ordinance. I believe they must run the idea that is is easier to ask for forgiveness than permission. In this case they tweak so that since they have hopped through all these hoops of planning, that work will over ride any laws that stand in their way of the May 28 2026 10:14AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 15 development. We humans need trees and our wildlife is in dire straights without necessary habits. I as a private citizen had to build a home around a tree’s location, it was a grand tree. Period…no recourse, the law is the law, and we knew that going in. Let them stop this development and regroup to work within what nature has laid out! Robert Frederick 110 Sugar Magnolia Way 32 Grand oak trees are still slated for removal. This is absurd. It will take upwards of 100 years to replace them. Not to mention the damage to surrounding wildlife and water mitigation. Retention ponds are poor substitutes for these trees and the surrounding area. This entire area was a swamp! It will turn into another flooding situation just like 2 Loch in Shadowmoss. Are you going to condemn and bulldoze Autumn Chase or Magnolia Lakes across the street from all of the run-off from every storm that hits the area? If they're removed; go ahead and change the name to the entire boulevard because there will not be enough oaks left to justify the name. May 28 2026 10:28AM Sandy Traeger 458 Hainsworth Drive When I first moved here there were oaks and they were Grand. It seems as soon as someone (with money) sees a group of trees or a flat piece of land they think how many structures can I build to make more money. I oppose the idea of development that destroys the very thing that supports the beauty of Lowcountry Charleston and attracts new neighbors . The “planning” is not very thoughtful. Fewer trees, less marshland both which contribute to the health of the city; more cars on the already crowded roads negatively impact people’s lives—even the new people you are recruiting. The bigger, the better? Not always. Addressing all of the issues involved in a development should be a requirement. But as we know, time is money. Please don’t insult me by reminding me that without development I wouldn’t have a place to live or shop. If so, you’ve missed the point, May 28 2026 10:31AM Amanda Gross 1235 Ashley Gardens Blvd. Throughout my time of living off of Grand Oak Blvd it has become over developed leaving wildlife with no where to go. An excessive amount of deer, raccoons, snakes, geese that I have seen hit by cars or displaced in areas they shouldn’t be is shocking for an area that prides itself on its beauty of the land. We have already removed enough. What is the point of protecting the grand oaks if you are willing to let them be cut down?! Aside from the wildlife we are stealing from that development cannot take over 400 more apartments with the current state of the roads. There is ultimately one main entrance in and out. Unless we are tearing down further land to develop roads that are equip for the ongoing development in this subdivision. Thomas May 28 2026 10:38AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 16 & Hutton is based out of and developed in Mt. Pleasant until they passed protecting their land. Now we are pursuing for developments within West Ashley. It’s not fair for our citizens who reside here. Protect the Oaks the way we were promised. Sam Briggs 732 Bent Hickory Road, Charleston, SC 29414 We strongly urge the decision makers involved in this project to vote against the removal of the grand oak trees within our neighborhood. These trees are a defining part of our community and are meant to be protected for a reason. They provide beauty, history, shade, environmental benefits, and an irreplaceable character that cannot simply be replanted or recreated. Beyond the loss of the trees themselves, many residents are deeply concerned about the impact this additional clearing will have on the wildlife that depends on this area for habitat and shelter. The development already includes the removal of a significant amount of natural habitat, making further tree removal feel both unnecessary and excessive. The residents who already live here chose this neighborhood because of its natural beauty and established landscape. These grand oaks are part of what makes our community special. Their removal is not wanted by many of the established residents, and we ask that every possible effort be made to preserve them. Protecting these trees means protecting the character of our neighborhood, the surrounding ecosystem, and the quality of life for the families who call this area home. May 28 2026 10:56AM B. B. Grand oaks Repeated redesigns and changing figures regarding protected tree removal undermine confidence in the applicant’s planning process. When critical elements of a proposal continue to shift during zoning review, it raises legitimate concerns about transparency, accuracy, and whether the full environmental impact has been adequately disclosed. This should have been known from the beginning why all of the sudden the change in number of tree removal? If we keep changing the number why remove any of them zero transparency, zero consistency. This whole project needs to be stopped. May 28 2026 11:06AM Careen Jensen 904 Lansfaire Dr., Charleston, SC 29414 I appose the removal of the grand trees from the property on Grand Oaks Blvd. The grand oaks trees are protected trees and should not be allowed to be removed. I was at the last BZA meeting at heard how just one homeowner had to jump through hoops to get one tree removed so they could add an addition to their home. They had to pay over $500 and had to remove another tree and add two additional. How is this fair to allow a developer to just come in and expect to remove over 30 grand oak trees so they can put in May 28 2026 11:43AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 17 condensed housing in an area that is already overdeveloped with apartments? Please do not approve of this application for tree removal. Rachel Braddock 421 Sycamore Shade St. The removal of 47 grand trees is an abomination and an offense against Charleston, its ecosystem and its local beauty. The neighborhood is even called "Grand Oaks". What will it be called once they are all removed? Removing them because the tree is "forked"? Grand oaks are commonly forked. We cannot continue to be a City that is focused on protecting our history, cultural, and ecosystem while constantly destroying it to the highest bidder or the wealthiest developer. And after the trees are removed and the apartments built, who will be the ones to pay for the improvement of infrastructure and for the stormwater management? Will it be the developer or the tax payers? May 28 2026 12:46PM Lisa Bradley 6448 Pepper Grass Trail Ravenel, SC 29470 I’m writing to ask the Board to DENY the requested variance for removal of 30 Grand Oaks. Grand Oaks are hundreds of years old and are irreplaceable. Ordinances are in place to protect these Grand trees as they are a staple of the Lowcountry landscape and history. Developers have destroyed enough of the Lowcountry with the destruction of the landscape and environment for the sake of the almighty dollar. It is time to protect these Grand trees and make developers conform to our standards! Please reject the petition for a variance and protect these Grand Oaks. Thank you. May 28 2026 12:56PM Erin Lawhorn 1500 parklawn drive SUBJECT: URGENT: DENY Variances (Sec 54-327 & 54- 330) for Bees Resources/Thomas & Hutton – 32 Grand Trees on Grand Oaks Blvd, West Ashley TO: Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA-SD), City of Charleston Planning Commission, Mayor John Tecklenburg, City Council DATE: May 29, 2026 PROJECT LOCATION: Grand Oaks Blvd, West Ashley, SC APPLICANT: Bees Resources (represented by Thomas & Hutton) I am a resident of West Ashley and a concerned stakeholder in the future of Charleston’s flood resilience. I am writing to formally and vehemently OPPOSE the variance requests filed under Section 54-327 and Section 54-330 regarding the proposed development by Bees Resources on Grand Oaks Blvd. This application seeks to remove 32 Grand Trees (24+ inches DBH) and provides inadequate protection for 6 additional specimens. This totals 38 irreplaceable Grand Trees slated for destruction. The applicant, represented by Thomas & Hutton, is asking the Board to grant variances that would strip West Ashley of its most critical natural infrastructure. This request fails every legal test for a variance and imposes a multi-million dollar liability on the City and its May 29 2026 7:21AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 18 taxpayers. I. LEGAL BASIS FOR DENIAL: FAILURE TO MEET VARANCE STANDARDS Under City of Charleston Zoning Ordinance Sections 54-327 and 54-330, variances are strictly limited to cases where "extraordinary and exceptional conditions" exist. The applicant has failed to demonstrate this. No Unique Hardship: The property does not possess conditions unique to it that are not shared by neighboring properties in West Ashley. The desire to maximize density or profit is explicitly not a legal hardship under South Carolina law. Reasonable Use Exists: The applicant has not proven that strict adherence to the tree ordinance prohibits reasonable use of the land. Viable alternatives exist, including site redesign, clustering, and adjusted density, which would allow development without destroying the canopy. Substantial Detriment to Public Good: Granting these variances would cause a direct, substantial detriment to the public good. The removal of 32 Grand Trees will: Exacerbate neighborhood flooding in West Ashley. Increase stormwater runoff into local estuaries. Force the City to incur massive infrastructure costs. Set a dangerous precedent for future development in the district. Therefore, the Board must DENY these variances. II. FULL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT: THE COST OF LOSS The removal of 32 Grand Trees is not merely an aesthetic loss; it is a catastrophic failure of natural stormwater management. A. Stormwater Interception & Flood Mitigation Mature live oaks are the most effective natural stormwater systems available. Capacity: A single Grand Tree intercepts and processes between 1,000 and 11,000+ gallons of rain annually, with exceptional specimens handling up to 40,000 gallons. The Math of Loss: Removing 32 trees eliminates the capacity to manage hundreds of thousands to millions of gallons of runoff annually. In a city like Charleston, where sea-level rise and intense rainfall are already overwhelming our drainage systems, this loss is unacceptable. Consequences: This removal will directly increase peak flow rates, worsen localized flooding in West Ashley, accelerate soil erosion, and carry pollutants into our waterways. B. Irreversible Ecological Damage Canopy Recovery: Replacing these trees is impossible on a human timescale. It will take 50 to 100+ years to regrow a canopy of this magnitude. Urban Heat Island Effect: The loss of this shade will significantly raise local temperatures, increasing energy costs for residents and degrading air quality. Habitat Destruction: These trees provide essential habitat for local wildlife, the loss of which disrupts the ecological Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 19 balance of the Grand Oaks corridor. III. FINANCIAL LIABILITY: THE TAXPAYER BURDEN The applicant is attempting to privatize the profits of development while socializing the costs of infrastructure failure. Estimated Replacement Cost: Regional engineering data indicates that replacing the stormwater capacity of 32 Grand Trees with "grey infrastructure" (pipes, pumps, retention ponds) would cost between $500,000 and over $2,000,000. This figure excludes ongoing maintenance, energy costs, and future upgrades necessitated by worsening climate conditions. Current Resident Burden: West Ashley residents already pay a flat $132/year stormwater fee. Every time the City approves a project that removes trees and increases impervious surface, the burden on residents grows. Charleston County has lost over 10,000 acres of tree cover since 1992. Approving this project accelerates the cycle of overdevelopment, forcing taxpayers to subsidize developer-driven impacts through higher fees, property taxes, and emergency flood repairs. DEMAND: If the Board were to consider any form of approval (which we strongly advise against), the following conditions must be met before any permit is issued: Full Developer Funding: The applicant (Bees Resources) must fund 100% of the stormwater offset costs ($500k–$2M+) via an escrow account. Independent Verification: An ISA-certified arborist and civil engineer must verify the stormwater impact and offset plan. Performance Bonds: 5–10 year bonds must be posted to ensure long-term maintenance of any replacement infrastructure. Taxpayer Protection: A written guarantee that zero costs will be passed to the City or residents. IV. RECOMMENDED ACTIONS & LONG-TERM REFORM Immediate Action for June 3 BZA Meeting: DENY the variances under Sec 54-327 and 54-330. Require a full site redesign by Thomas & Hutton to preserve all viable Grand Trees. If any limited approval is granted (against all advice), enforce a 5:1 mitigation ratio with native species and strict Critical Root Zone protection. Establishment of the Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance: We are formally establishing the Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance to advocate for stricter tree ordinances, higher mitigation ratios, and citizen oversight. Request: The City Council and BZA must formally recognize the Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance as the designated entity to be notified of all future variance hearings involving Grand Trees. Goal: We will pursue a citizen-initiated petition to update the tree ordinance, ensuring that no future development can bypass the protections of Sections 54-327 and 54-330 without Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 20 rigorous public review. CONCLUSION The proposal by Bees Resources to remove 32 Grand Trees on Grand Oaks Blvd is a short-sighted decision that threatens the flood resilience of West Ashley and the financial stability of its residents. The legal requirements for a variance are not met. The environmental impact is severe. The financial cost to the public is unjustifiable. We urge the Board to DENY this request in its entirety. Respectfully, [Erin Lawhorn] [1500 parklawn drive, West Ashley] [erinlawhorn@icloud.com] [PRESIDENT, Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance Hung Vo 763 Certificate Ct SUBJECT: URGENT: DENY Variances (Sec 54-327 & 54- 330) for Bees Resources/Thomas & Hutton – 32 Grand Trees on Grand Oaks Blvd, West Ashley TO: Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA-SD), City of Charleston Planning Commission, Mayor William Cogswell, City Council DATE: May 29, 2026 PROJECT LOCATION: Grand Oaks Blvd, West Ashley, SC APPLICANT: Bees Resources (represented by Thomas & Hutton) I am a resident of West Ashley and a concerned stakeholder in the future of Charleston’s flood resilience. I am writing to formally and vehemently OPPOSE the variance requests filed under Section 54-327 and Section 54-330 regarding the proposed development by Bees Resources on Grand Oaks Blvd. This application seeks to remove 32 Grand Trees (24+ inches DBH) and provides inadequate protection for 6 additional specimens. This totals 38 irreplaceable Grand Trees slated for destruction. The applicant, represented by Thomas & Hutton, is asking the Board to grant variances that would strip West Ashley of its most critical natural infrastructure. This request fails every legal test for a variance and imposes a multi-million dollar liability on the City and its taxpayers. I. LEGAL BASIS FOR DENIAL: FAILURE TO MEET VARANCE STANDARDS Under City of Charleston Zoning Ordinance Sections 54-327 and 54-330, variances are strictly limited to cases where "extraordinary and exceptional conditions" exist. The applicant has failed to demonstrate this. 1.No Unique Hardship: The property does not possess conditions unique to it that are not shared by neighboring properties in West Ashley. The desire to maximize density or profit is explicitly not a legal hardship under South Carolina law. 2.Reasonable Use Exists: The applicant has not proven that strict adherence to the tree ordinance prohibits reasonable use of the land. Viable alternatives exist, including site redesign, clustering, and adjusted density, which would allow development without destroying the canopy. 3.Substantial Detriment to Public Good: Granting these variances would cause a direct, substantial detriment May 29 2026 7:47PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 21 to the public good. The removal of 32 Grand Trees will: ◦Exacerbate neighborhood flooding in West Ashley. ◦Increase stormwater runoff into local estuaries. ◦Force the City to incur massive infrastructure costs. ◦Set a dangerous precedent for future development in the district. Therefore, the Board must DENY these variances. II. FULL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT: THE COST OF LOSS The removal of 32 Grand Trees is not merely an aesthetic loss; it is a catastrophic failure of natural stormwater management. A. Stormwater Interception & Flood Mitigation Mature live oaks are the most effective natural stormwater systems available. •Capacity: A single Grand Tree intercepts and processes between 1,000 and 11,000+ gallons of rain annually, with exceptional specimens handling up to 40,000 gallons. •The Math of Loss: Removing 32 trees eliminates the capacity to manage hundreds of thousands to millions of gallons of runoff annually. In a city like Charleston, where sea-level rise and intense rainfall are already overwhelming our drainage systems, this loss is unacceptable. •Consequences: This removal will directly increase peak flow rates, worsen localized flooding in West Ashley, accelerate soil erosion, and carry pollutants into our waterways. B. Irreversible Ecological Damage •Canopy Recovery: Replacing these trees is impossible on a human timescale. It will take 50 to 100+ years to regrow a canopy of this magnitude. •Urban Heat Island Effect: The loss of this shade will significantly raise local temperatures, increasing energy costs for residents and degrading air quality. •Habitat Destruction: These trees provide essential habitat for local wildlife, the loss of which disrupts the ecological balance of the Grand Oaks corridor. III. FINANCIAL LIABILITY: THE TAXPAYER BURDEN The applicant is attempting to privatize the profits of development while socializing the costs of infrastructure failure. Estimated Replacement Cost: Regional engineering data indicates that replacing the stormwater capacity of 32 Grand Trees with "grey infrastructure" (pipes, pumps, retention ponds) would cost between $500,000 and over $2,000,000. This figure excludes ongoing maintenance, energy costs, and future upgrades necessitated by worsening climate conditions. Current Resident Burden: West Ashley residents already pay a flat $132/year stormwater fee. Every time the City approves a project that removes trees and increases impervious surface, the burden on residents grows. •Charleston County has lost over 10,000 acres of tree cover since 1992. •Approving this project accelerates the cycle of overdevelopment, forcing taxpayers to Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 22 subsidize developer-driven impacts through higher fees, property taxes, and emergency flood repairs. DEMAND: If the Board were to consider any form of approval (which we strongly advise against), the following conditions must be met before any permit is issued: 1.Full Developer Funding: The applicant (Bees Resources) must fund 100% of the stormwater offset costs ($500k–$2M+) via an escrow account. 2.Independent Verification: An ISA-certified arborist and civil engineer must verify the stormwater impact and offset plan. 3.Performance Bonds: 5–10 year bonds must be posted to ensure long-term maintenance of any replacement infrastructure. 4.Taxpayer Protection: A written guarantee that zero costs will be passed to the City or residents. IV. RECOMMENDED ACTIONS & LONG-TERM REFORM Immediate Action for June 3 BZA Meeting: •DENY the variances under Sec 54-327 and 54-330. •Require a full site redesign by Thomas & Hutton to preserve all viable Grand Trees. •If any limited approval is granted (against all advice), enforce a 5:1 mitigation ratio with native species and strict Critical Root Zone protection. Establishment of the Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance: We are formally establishing the Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance to advocate for stricter tree ordinances, higher mitigation ratios, and citizen oversight. •Request: The City Council and BZA must formally recognize the Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance as the designated entity to be notified of all future variance hearings involving Grand Trees. •Goal: We will pursue a citizen-initiated petition to update the tree ordinance, ensuring that no future development can bypass the protections of Sections 54-327 and 54-330 without rigorous public review. CONCLUSION The proposal by Bees Resources to remove 32 Grand Trees on Grand Oaks Blvd is a short-sighted decision that threatens the flood resilience of West Ashley and the financial stability of its residents. The legal requirements for a variance are not met. The environmental impact is severe. The financial cost to the public is unjustifiable. We urge the Board to DENY this request in its entirety. Respectfully, Hung Vo margureitta moroney 169 larissa dr charleston SC29414 No way May 29 2026 10:09PM Nancy Huber 337 Weeping Willow way Please please please do not approve the removal of any trees on GO. Almost 6 years ago when I first looked at my place, the entrance to GO just took my breath away and now they want to remove then? The May 30 2026 2:04PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 23 project needs to go away. Our roads cannot handle any more cars. Our wild life have no where to go. Please disapprove this project. Laura Black 2345 f tallsail dr SUBJECT: URGENT: DENY Variances (Sec 54-327 & 54- 330) for Bees Resources/Thomas & Hutton – 32 Grand Trees on Grand Oaks Blvd, West Ashley TO: Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA-SD), City of Charleston Planning Commission, Mayor William Cogswell, City Council DATE: May 29, 2026 PROJECT LOCATION: Grand Oaks Blvd, West Ashley, SC APPLICANT: Bees Resources (represented by Thomas & Hutton) I am a resident of West Ashley and a concerned stakeholder in the future of Charleston’s flood resilience. I am writing to formally and vehemently OPPOSE the variance requests filed under Section 54-327 and Section 54-330 regarding the proposed development by Bees Resources on Grand Oaks Blvd. This application seeks to remove 32 Grand Trees (24+ inches DBH) and provides inadequate protection for 6 additional specimens. This totals 38 irreplaceable Grand Trees slated for destruction. The applicant, represented by Thomas & Hutton, is asking the Board to grant variances that would strip West Ashley of its most critical natural infrastructure. This request fails every legal test for a variance and imposes a multi-million dollar liability on the City and its taxpayers. I. LEGAL BASIS FOR DENIAL: FAILURE TO MEET VARANCE STANDARDS Under City of Charleston Zoning Ordinance Sections 54-327 and 54-330, variances are strictly limited to cases where "extraordinary and exceptional conditions" exist. The applicant has failed to demonstrate this. 1.No Unique Hardship: The property does not possess conditions unique to it that are not shared by neighboring properties in West Ashley. The desire to maximize density or profit is explicitly not a legal hardship under South Carolina law. 2.Reasonable Use Exists: The applicant has not proven that strict adherence to the tree ordinance prohibits reasonable use of the land. Viable alternatives exist, including site redesign, clustering, and adjusted density, which would allow development without destroying the canopy. 3.Substantial Detriment to Public Good: Granting these variances would cause a direct, substantial detriment to the public good. The removal of 32 Grand Trees will: ◦Exacerbate neighborhood flooding in West Ashley. ◦Increase stormwater runoff into local estuaries. ◦Force the City to incur massive infrastructure costs. ◦Set a dangerous precedent for future development in the district. Therefore, the Board must DENY these variances. II. FULL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT: THE COST OF LOSS The removal of 32 May 30 2026 9:38AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 24 Grand Trees is not merely an aesthetic loss; it is a catastrophic failure of natural stormwater management. A. Stormwater Interception & Flood Mitigation Mature live oaks are the most effective natural stormwater systems available. •Capacity: A single Grand Tree intercepts and processes between 1,000 and 11,000+ gallons of rain annually, with exceptional specimens handling up to 40,000 gallons. •The Math of Loss: Removing 32 trees eliminates the capacity to manage hundreds of thousands to millions of gallons of runoff annually. In a city like Charleston, where sea-level rise and intense rainfall are already overwhelming our drainage systems, this loss is unacceptable. •Consequences: This removal will directly increase peak flow rates, worsen localized flooding in West Ashley, accelerate soil erosion, and carry pollutants into our waterways. B. Irreversible Ecological Damage •Canopy Recovery: Replacing these trees is impossible on a human timescale. It will take 50 to 100+ years to regrow a canopy of this magnitude. •Urban Heat Island Effect: The loss of this shade will significantly raise local temperatures, increasing energy costs for residents and degrading air quality. •Habitat Destruction: These trees provide essential habitat for local wildlife, the loss of which disrupts the ecological balance of the Grand Oaks corridor. III. FINANCIAL LIABILITY: THE TAXPAYER BURDEN The applicant is attempting to privatize the profits of development while socializing the costs of infrastructure failure. Estimated Replacement Cost: Regional engineering data indicates that replacing the stormwater capacity of 32 Grand Trees with "grey infrastructure" (pipes, pumps, retention ponds) would cost between $500,000 and over $2,000,000. This figure excludes ongoing maintenance, energy costs, and future upgrades necessitated by worsening climate conditions. Current Resident Burden: West Ashley residents already pay a flat $132/year stormwater fee. Every time the City approves a project that removes trees and increases impervious surface, the burden on residents grows. •Charleston County has lost over 10,000 acres of tree cover since 1992. •Approving this project accelerates the cycle of overdevelopment, forcing taxpayers to subsidize developer-driven impacts through higher fees, property taxes, and emergency flood repairs. DEMAND: If the Board were to consider any form of approval (which we strongly advise against), the following conditions must be met before any permit is issued: 1.Full Developer Funding: The applicant (Bees Resources) must fund 100% of the stormwater offset costs ($500k–$2M+) via an escrow account. Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 25 2.Independent Verification: An ISA-certified arborist and civil engineer must verify the stormwater impact and offset plan. 3.Performance Bonds: 5–10 year bonds must be posted to ensure long-term maintenance of any replacement infrastructure. 4.Taxpayer Protection: A written guarantee that zero costs will be passed to the City or residents. IV. RECOMMENDED ACTIONS & LONG-TERM REFORM Immediate Action for June 3 BZA Meeting: •DENY the variances under Sec 54-327 and 54-330. •Require a full site redesign by Thomas & Hutton to preserve all viable Grand Trees. •If any limited approval is granted (against all advice), enforce a 5:1 mitigation ratio with native species and strict Critical Root Zone protection. Establishment of the Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance: We are formally establishing the Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance to advocate for stricter tree ordinances, higher mitigation ratios, and citizen oversight. •Request: The City Council and BZA must formally recognize the Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance as the designated entity to be notified of all future variance hearings involving Grand Trees. •Goal: We will pursue a citizen-initiated petition to update the tree ordinance, ensuring that no future development can bypass the protections of Sections 54-327 and 54-330 without rigorous public review. CONCLUSION The proposal by Bees Resources to remove 32 Grand Trees on Grand Oaks Blvd is a short-sighted decision that threatens the flood resilience of West Ashley and the financial stability of its residents. The legal requirements for a variance are not met. The environmental impact is severe. The financial cost to the public is unjustifiable. We urge the Board to DENY this request in its entirety. Rachel Turbow 7088 Windmill Creek Road SUBJECT: URGENT: DENY Variances (Sec 54-327 & 54- 330) for Bees Resources/Thomas & Hutton – 32 Grand Trees on Grand Oaks Blvd, West Ashley TO: Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA-SD), City of Charleston Planning Commission, Mayor William Cogswell, City Council DATE: May 29, 2026 PROJECT LOCATION: Grand Oaks Blvd, West Ashley, SC APPLICANT: Bees Resources (represented by Thomas & Hutton) I am a resident of West Ashley and a concerned stakeholder in the future of Charleston’s flood resilience. I am writing to formally and vehemently OPPOSE the variance requests filed under Section 54-327 and Section 54-330 regarding the proposed development by Bees Resources on Grand Oaks Blvd. This application seeks to remove 32 Grand Trees (24+ inches DBH) and provides inadequate protection for 6 additional specimens. This totals 38 May 31 2026 3:46PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 26 irreplaceable Grand Trees slated for destruction. The applicant, represented by Thomas & Hutton, is asking the Board to grant variances that would strip West Ashley of its most critical natural infrastructure. This request fails every legal test for a variance and imposes a multi-million dollar liability on the City and its taxpayers. I. LEGAL BASIS FOR DENIAL: FAILURE TO MEET VARANCE STANDARDS Under City of Charleston Zoning Ordinance Sections 54-327 and 54-330, variances are strictly limited to cases where "extraordinary and exceptional conditions" exist. The applicant has failed to demonstrate this. 1.No Unique Hardship: The property does not possess conditions unique to it that are not shared by neighboring properties in West Ashley. The desire to maximize density or profit is explicitly not a legal hardship under South Carolina law. 2.Reasonable Use Exists: The applicant has not proven that strict adherence to the tree ordinance prohibits reasonable use of the land. Viable alternatives exist, including site redesign, clustering, and adjusted density, which would allow development without destroying the canopy. 3.Substantial Detriment to Public Good: Granting these variances would cause a direct, substantial detriment to the public good. The removal of 32 Grand Trees will: ◦Exacerbate neighborhood flooding in West Ashley. ◦Increase stormwater runoff into local estuaries. ◦Force the City to incur massive infrastructure costs. ◦Set a dangerous precedent for future development in the district. Therefore, the Board must DENY these variances. II. FULL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT: THE COST OF LOSS The removal of 32 Grand Trees is not merely an aesthetic loss; it is a catastrophic failure of natural stormwater management. A. Stormwater Interception & Flood Mitigation Mature live oaks are the most effective natural stormwater systems available. •Capacity: A single Grand Tree intercepts and processes between 1,000 and 11,000+ gallons of rain annually, with exceptional specimens handling up to 40,000 gallons. •The Math of Loss: Removing 32 trees eliminates the capacity to manage hundreds of thousands to millions of gallons of runoff annually. In a city like Charleston, where sea-level rise and intense rainfall are already overwhelming our drainage systems, this loss is unacceptable. •Consequences: This removal will directly increase peak flow rates, worsen localized flooding in West Ashley, accelerate soil erosion, and carry pollutants into our waterways. B. Irreversible Ecological Damage •Canopy Recovery: Replacing these trees is impossible on a human timescale. It will take Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 27 50 to 100+ years to regrow a canopy of this magnitude. •Urban Heat Island Effect: The loss of this shade will significantly raise local temperatures, increasing energy costs for residents and degrading air quality. •Habitat Destruction: These trees provide essential habitat for local wildlife, the loss of which disrupts the ecological balance of the Grand Oaks corridor. III. FINANCIAL LIABILITY: THE TAXPAYER BURDEN The applicant is attempting to privatize the profits of development while socializing the costs of infrastructure failure. Estimated Replacement Cost: Regional engineering data indicates that replacing the stormwater capacity of 32 Grand Trees with "grey infrastructure" (pipes, pumps, retention ponds) would cost between $500,000 and over $2,000,000. This figure excludes ongoing maintenance, energy costs, and future upgrades necessitated by worsening climate conditions. Current Resident Burden: West Ashley residents already pay a flat $132/year stormwater fee. Every time the City approves a project that removes trees and increases impervious surface, the burden on residents grows. •Charleston County has lost over 10,000 acres of tree cover since 1992. •Approving this project accelerates the cycle of overdevelopment, forcing taxpayers to subsidize developer-driven impacts through higher fees, property taxes, and emergency flood repairs. DEMAND: If the Board were to consider any form of approval (which we strongly advise against), the following conditions must be met before any permit is issued: 1.Full Developer Funding: The applicant (Bees Resources) must fund 100% of the stormwater offset costs ($500k–$2M+) via an escrow account. 2.Independent Verification: An ISA-certified arborist and civil engineer must verify the stormwater impact and offset plan. 3.Performance Bonds: 5–10 year bonds must be posted to ensure long-term maintenance of any replacement infrastructure. 4.Taxpayer Protection: A written guarantee that zero costs will be passed to the City or residents. IV. RECOMMENDED ACTIONS & LONG-TERM REFORM Immediate Action for June 3 BZA Meeting: •DENY the variances under Sec 54-327 and 54-330. •Require a full site redesign by Thomas & Hutton to preserve all viable Grand Trees. •If any limited approval is granted (against all advice), enforce a 5:1 mitigation ratio with native species and strict Critical Root Zone protection. Establishment of the Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance: We are formally establishing the Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance to advocate for stricter tree ordinances, higher mitigation ratios, and citizen oversight. •Request: The City Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | June 3, 2026 Page 28 Council and BZA must formally recognize the Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance as the designated entity to be notified of all future variance hearings involving Grand Trees. •Goal: We will pursue a citizen-initiated petition to update the tree ordinance, ensuring that no future development can bypass the protections of Sections 54-327 and 54-330 without rigorous public review. CONCLUSION The proposal by Bees Resources to remove 32 Grand Trees on Grand Oaks Blvd is a short-sighted decision that threatens the flood resilience of West Ashley and the financial stability of its residents. The legal requirements for a variance are not met. The environmental impact is severe. The financial cost to the public is unjustifiable. We urge the Board to DENY this request in its entirety. Respectfully, Rachel Turbow 7088 Windmill Creek Rd Village Green, West Ashley Member, Charleston County Tree Preservation Alliance 1 Walsh, Christina From: Schultz, Eric Sent: Tuesday, May 19, 2026 3:48 PM To: Summerfield, Robert; Lewis, Alicia; Walsh, Christina Cc: Harp, Ana; Toppercer, Elianna Subject: RE: Proposed Grand Oaks Development located behind Harris Teeter off Bees Ferry Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Thanks Robert. Christina, Please log the letter for the upcoming BZA-SD and include in packets. The applicant has requested to be placed on the June 3 meeting. ERIC SCHULTZ, TRC ADMINISTRATOR Principal Planner 2 George St, Suite 3100, Charleston SC 29401 843.724.3790|www.charleston-sc.gov From: Summerfield, Robert <Summerfieldr@charleston-sc.gov> Sent: Tuesday, May 19, 2026 3:41 PM To: Schultz, Eric <SCHULTZE@charleston-sc.gov>; Lewis, Alicia <lewisa@charleston-sc.gov> Subject: FW: Proposed Grand Oaks Development located behind Harris Teeter off Bees Ferry Please include this email with your future TRC reviews related to this site, if any for the TH/Apt. project on Grand Oaks. Thanks – Robert Robert Summerfield, AICP This message sent from mobile 깳깶깷깴깵깸, please forgive any typos or grammar mistakes. From: Earthlink Sent: Tuesday, May 19, 2026 1:37 PM To: Summerfield, Robert <Summerfieldr@charleston-sc.gov> Subject: Proposed Grand Oaks Development located behind Harris Teeter off Bees Ferry ATTENTION: This email originated from outside the City of Charleston's systems. Do not click links or open attachments unless you are expecting them from the sender and/or have confirmed the content is safe. Forward any suspicious emails by clicking the Phish Alert Button. 2 To: Robert Summerfield, director of preservation and planning for the City of Charleston Dear Mr. Summerfield, RE: https://abcnews4.com/news/local/2005-zoning-could-spur-400-plus-home-project-near-grand- oaks-as-area-grows As a resident of the Landing at Grande Oaks located next door to the proposed development I have some concerns which I would like to bring to your organization’s attention. 1. A development planned and zoned back in 2005 needs to have the zoning reconsidered based on the current existing state of the immediate area. 2. At the first recent open house to make the community aware of the planned development the organizers presented the development plan as one that is a done deal, to discourage push back. 3. The HOA and residents of the Landing located adjacent to the property have received no direct notification of the proposed project or where comments can be submitted. 4. The number of apartments especially as located directly on property right directly next to the Landing is worrisome. It is preferable that townhouses be built in that location instead and any apartment buildings be built closer to the shopping center. More: The most recent plan of 400 units based on 2 car households puts 800 more vehicles on the road. 5. This area is already overdeveloped. More high density housing is not needed. If they were building only townhouses and protecting more green space and trees all around the development, that would be a much improved compromise. 6. There will be a huge negative impact on this relatively compact section off Grand Oaks and individuals who will profit from tearing up this plot of land will not have to live with the myriad of negative consequences to the existing surrounding community. 7. Issues include damage to existing wildlife, flora and fauna, environment and swamp land destruction, destruction of the existing historic phosphorus mines that could lead to unstable land, more automobile and other pollution, and new flooding patterns developing from gross overdevelopment. 8. There is also concern around the increase in crime and violation of noise ordinances that unfortunately are found frequently around rental apartment complexes. 9. There are obvious overall insufficient infrastructure in the area, already being experienced from all the recent growth in the past 24 months, which is resulting in tremendous traffic jams, exacerbating already unsafe roads that cannot handle the current traffic, which is to the detriment and safety of the overall quality of life for the surrounding existing communities. 10. More Importantly, insufficient infrastructure encompasses not only road design and traffic, but: Utilities including clean water; Waste management; 3 School and day care capacity; And critically, the capacity of the local hospital; urgent care and other medical care facilities to provide services to a rapid population explosion; The ability of the police force; firefighters; and other public services to provide services pursuant to this rapid increase in population growth. I thank you for the consideration of my comments as you decide the future of our already overburdened community and the surrounding environment. Best, Suzanne Stinson Reference: https://www.facebook.com/share/p/14fgrVLc2FZ/? Sent from my iPhone

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.