050919 BUDGET WORK SESSION MAY 9
City of Darlington · Darlington County · meeting of May 6, 2020 · Budget documents
Open the original document More from City of Darlington
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
CITY OF DARLINGTON
BUDGET WORK SESSION
THURSDAY MAY 9, 2019 AT 6:00 PM
The City of Darlington held a Budget Work Session in the Old Council
Chambers on Thursday, May 9, 2019 at 6:00 PM. Present at the meeting:
Mayor Gloria C. Hines, City Manager Howard Garland; Council Members:
John Segars, Elaine Reed, and Sheila Baccus. Others in attendance
included: City Attorney Kevin Etheridge, Police Chief Kelvin Washington,
Fire Chief Pat Cavanaugh, Mrs. Anna DeWitt and Mr. Bobby from the News
& Press.
Mayor Hines called the meeting to order and chief Kelvin Washington did
the invocation.
MR GARLAND – OVERVIEW OF 2019-2020 BUDGET PROCESS
Mr. Garland said we have a surplus for the 2018-2019 budget year due to all
the hurricane money we received. He said revenues are down this year in
some areas. He said we still don’t know what we can do as far as a millage
increase because we don’t have the numbers yet on the census data. Mr.
Garland said the local government fund has gone up about $7,000 but it’s
still only funded about 79% of what we should receive. Mr. Garland said
building permits are extremely high, but Mr. Gainey will address that when
he gives his budget overview. Mr. Garland said Ms. Karen Carroll has
worked understaff most of the year but has done an outstanding job despite
that. He said he wanted to compliment Ms. Pridgen and her staff for
working with Webster Rogers to help get them out of here, so we can start
working with next year’s audit. He said the Brittingham Group out of
Columbia, SC has been engaged to be our next audit firm and they have
been working to get information together for our 2017-2018 audit.
Councilman Segars asked, “If hurricane money has come in is there any
chance it could go into the reserve fund rather than the general fund”?
Councilman Segars asked, “Didn’t most of it come out of the reserve fund”?
Mr. Garland said, “It did, but there’s only been very few years where the
reserve fund has been static”. He said the reserve fund is our “operating
fund” and we take from it and most of the year there’s not much in it except
maybe in June. He said that’s one of the things they talked about with the
cash flow issue that we have in December and January and that’s why we
wanted the money from Duke Energy on a quarterly basis to help with our
2
cash flow problem. Mr. Garland said he’s not been able to address the
reserve fund properly in a way that he feels good about. He said based on
the plan submitted in 2002, we’re supposed to set aside $100,000 for the
general fund and $50,000 for the water & sewer fund, but we haven’t done
that this year. Councilwoman Reed said, “So, the reserve fund is truly
supposed to be a reserve fund”? Mr. Garland said, “Yes, that’s correct”.
Councilman Segars said it was designed so that we wouldn’t have to borrow
money to finish up the budget year and we could borrow from ourselves and
pay ourselves back.
FIRE DEPARTMENT BUDGET OVERVIEW – FIRE CHIEF PAT
CAVANAUGH
Fire Chief Pat Cavanaugh said the biggest thing this year is to purchase an
additional pickup. Chief Cavanaugh said they talked about trying to get two
vehicles, but he, Mr. Garland and Chief Washington looked at the numbers
and it’s not possible to do it right now, so they’ll put an additional one on
and as soon as the new budget comes, they will work on getting a third one.
Chief Cavanaugh said line item 217 (auto operating expense) is the fund
used for fuel or when vehicles break down. He said they had a rough year
because they had some vehicles to break down. Chief Cavanaugh said they
had a trailer parked out back and for the first time in 10-12 years they had an
outside company come and go over those things head to toe. And they also
received a federal inspection to make sure those things were up to par. He
said that gives them a list of problems that we may have and that we can
start working in as budgetary concerns and handle all the big things first.
Chief Cavanaugh said it costs a little more on the budget, but it covers them
in case something does happen. He said on line item 226 (maintenance and
service contracts), they usually budget about $4,500 but they are on the
Palmetto 800 system with Motorola and they have a VHS system that they
must maintain. To be in the federal system and state mutual aid, we must be
in the Palmetto 800 system. Chief Cavanaugh said everything else is close
to what it was last year, and he usually tries to keep it that way.
Councilwoman Reed asked Chief Cavanaugh what line item shows the truck
purchase and he said line item 293. He said they will continue paying for
the one and add the second one on. Councilman Segars asked Chief
Cavanaugh if he was purchasing a new truck and he said, “Yes, they are
purchasing”. Chief Cavanaugh said they’ve got a 4% interest rate and the
first truck will be theirs in roughly three more years. He said they are
buying the truck turn key and will get the radios and get it striped locally
which saves them money. He said instead of ordering the truck and if it
3
costs $30,00 and will cost $15,000-$20,000 to get it outfitted, you will be
paying interest on $50,000 instead of on $30,000. Chief Cavanaugh said
they got Raceway Chevrolet to come in and they have agreed to work with
them. Councilwoman Baccus said, “So, technically now, you only got two
vehicles that’s old”? Chief Cavanaugh said, “Yes”. Mr. Garland told
Council when they look at revenues in a few weeks, they will see that the
fire district revenues are up a good bit. Councilwoman Baccus asked Chief
Cavanaugh about the Cost Recovery Program he mentioned last year. Chief
Cavanaugh said he, Police Chief Washington and Mr. Garland have been
working with the City Attorney on this. He said they have given the City
Attorney (Kevin) some ordinances to look at and choose the one that best
fits the City. Chief Washington said that’s the biggest thing now, getting the
ordinance written up so they can present it to Council and have something
that will past the test the first time as opposed to submitting it and then
having to go back and rewrite it and bring it back again. Chief Washington
said he wanted to add a couple more things to the Fire budget. He said one
of the things he recognized early on in January when he started working with
the Fire Department was that there was a couple of areas in their budget
where there were deficiencies as it relates to operating procedures. Chief
Washington said he, Chief Cavanaugh and Mr. Garland sat down and looked
at it and there have been increases in operations. He said he told the
firemen at their meeting that Mr. Garland found some money and there were
some increases put in place.
POLICE DEPARTMENT BUDGET – CHIEF KELVIN
WASHINGTON
Chief Washington said, for the most part, his budget is pretty much the
same. He said there’s a 25% increase in travel and training because at some
point and time, all his staff will receive training including the administrative
staff. He said training helps with morale. Chief Washington said line item
279 (other operating expense) was increased a little. He said his goal was to
keep what he had and help Chief Cavanaugh with the Fire Department as
best he could. Mr. Garland asked Chief Washington to give Council an
overview of the lease program and how it’s going. Chief said the lease
program with the narcotics vehicles is going really well. The whole process
with Enterprise was an easy process to get involved in, but it hasn’t been and
easy process to manage. He said their billing is some of the worse billing in
a corporate company that he’s ever worked with. Chief Washington said we
would mail payments to Enterprise long before the due date, but the account
would never show a payment being made. Chief Washington said, “The
4
company would call us saying they haven’t received our payment, so I
would get Ms. Pridgen to check the bank account to see if the check cleared
and sure enough the check would have cleared the bank”. He said he would
go through this almost every month. Chief Washington said he met with a
representative from Enterprise yesterday and expressed his displeasure and
our concerns and told him it’s doubtful we will continue in this partnership
with them because of that. Chief Washington said the narcotics vehicles and
how we have that set up is a win-win for the City because we’re purchasing
the vehicles at such a low price and reselling them at a higher price, so they
are paying for themselves. He said at this point tonight he would not
recommend to Council for us to continue that partnership. Councilman
Segars asked Chief Washington where was the guy that sold us the plan and
wanted to know if he is involved in any of the conversations. Chief said he
is in Columbia and he has not spoken with him. He said he thinks his boss
and the young lady from Hartsville that manages this area sent emails to him
and Mr. Garland requesting a meeting. Mr. Garland said what Chief
Washington is not telling them is Enterprise would have someone call from
the collections department call him and say, “You owe this money, why
haven’t you paid it yet”? Mr. Garland said they did this for five months in a
row. Mayor Hines asked how much longer do we have? Chief said that
would be up to Council. He said the question would be, do you want to
finish out just these cars that we have, which would be the recommendation
that he would make and then we won’t do it anymore. Councilwoman
Baccus asked Chief Washington to give an update on traffic tickets. Chief
Washington said he’s been here now about sixteen months, so coming in, the
guidance he got from Council was that they wanted the Police Department to
be a little bit more involved in the community, which is what they have
done. He said because of that, they are not writing as many traffic tickets.
He said there’s a lot of factors involved in this. Chief said back in 2018 and
years prior, his understanding was that this department was heavy, heavy
handed writing tickets. Back in 2017 the General Assembly changed how
cities could do careless operation. He said prior to July 2017, if a person got
a ticket, they could pay a higher fine with no points and the City would keep
100% of the fine and they could do because it was a City ordinance. He said
the State changed the law and said any ticket, whether a state traffic ticket or
a city ordinance ticket, was going to be subjected to the same assessments,
fines and fees as State tickets and our revenues went down and never
recovered. Chief Washington said there were a lot of different things that
went on that year. In July 2017 was when they had the break-in; there were
some issues in the Clerk’s office and we got a new Judge around the same
5
time. Chief Washington said the previous Judge was a little heavier handed
than the current Judge. Chief said he and Mr. Garland talked in detail about
this. He said the previous administration, the projection they had for a city
this size was just too high. He said there were a lot of things that went on in
2017 that were motivating factors. He said when things happen in a
department it affects the morale. Councilwoman Reed said, “From what I
am hearing you respond, we can conclude that a lot of the revenue…we’re
probably still writing the same number of tickets, but because of the change
in legislation as how the funding is done, would automatically cause a
decrease in our revenue”. Chief Washington said we’re not writing as many
tickets and the ability to use careless operation. Mr. Garland said we’re able
to keep 100% of parking tickets and seatbelt tickets. Chief Washington said
it’s been a bit of a struggle and the way they’re handling it tonight with
being open and transparent is the way to go about handling it. Chief
Washington said, “I don’t think Mr. Garland got the very best advice in the
past as it relates to traffic enforcement in this community; it was just not
sustainable”. Mayor Hines and Councilwomen Reed and Baccus said it’s
good that training is being offered to the administrative staff.
Councilwoman Baccus said she’s hearing there’s supposed to be a police
substation on Avenue D and S. Main Street. She asked Chief Washington if
this was so. Chief Washington said, “No ma’am, I’ve had no formal request
about anything of that nature. He said if something like this were to be
requested or suggested, he would have to bring it before Council. Mr.
Garland said we have had a substation in Bowen Manor and when Chief
Washington came on they talked about putting one in another complex.
Chief Washington said he and Jamie Steen talked about a substation, but
nothing has come of that. Chief thanked Council for giving him an
opportunity to serve as Police Chief. Chief said they are trying to partner
with the State to update their camera system.
BUILDING & CODES BUDGET– MR. ALEX GAINEY
Mr. Gainey said they increased office supply line item because his
department has taken on the Zoning Board of Appeals, so his postage line
items has increased because of the mailings. He said his training line item
has increased because both he and Sheila will be taking more classes.
Mayor Hines said line item 271 (specialized departmental supplies) has
increased to $5,000 and wanted to know what they purchase from this
particular line item. Mr. Garland said suits, codes books, etc. Mr. Gainey
said so far, to date they have collected $123,439.23 in permitting fees. He
said they were expecting to collect around $140,000 but it will probably be
6
closer to $150,000. Mr. Gainey said for the 2019-2020 budget they are
projecting to bring in $170,000. He increased his demolition budget because
he said it costs around $1,900 to take a house down. Mr. Garland said he
has news about 375 W. Broad Street (The Lawrence Reese House). Mr.
Garland said he called one of his friends from Palmetto Trust for Historic
Preservation and they preserve old residential structures. Mr. Garland said
he is coming to visit next week and see what they can do for that structure.
Mr. Gainey said he and Mr. Garland talked about the house the other day.
He said if he tried to tackle that house it would cost him $20,000 to tear it
down. Mr. Garland said what they do is come in and stabilize a structure
and then advertise it nationally for someone to come in and restore it. They
act as a holding agent for someone to come in and invest in that property.
Councilwoman Baccus said we need to revisit the lots being cleaned up
because some of them are not being cleaned well. Councilman Segars asked
how does the homeowner get involved in that? Councilwoman Baccus said
the owner is not involved. Councilman Segars asked, “Why shouldn’t they
be”? Mr. Gainey said they send the homeowner a letter telling them the
house has been condemned and they have thirty (30) days to either come
pull permits or tear the house down. If they don’t pull permits or tear the
house down, then it’s on their list. Mr. Gainey said once we tear the house
down, we then send the owner a bill for whatever it costs to tear the house
down plus 15% administrative costs. If they don’t respond to them or try to
make payment arrangements or pay it, then they’ll assess it to their taxes and
it will show up on their tax notice. (Mr. Gainey used the example of the
demolition bill being $2,000 plus the 15% administrative costs)
Councilwoman Baccus said, “If we are going to be sending a homeowner a
$2,000 bill, then we should be cleaning up the lot. Mr. Garland told
Councilwoman Baccus that he and Mr. Gainey has had conversations about
this and her standard of clean may not be his standard of clean.
Councilwoman Baccus said that’s why Council needs to revisit this. She
said the way some of those lots are left, it doesn’t look good for the City.
Councilwoman Baccus said if a contractor was tearing this house down and
Alex went out to monitor it, they would be held to a certain standard. Mr.
Gainey said, “Yes and no. I’ve seen houses that contractors have gone in
and torn down. Typically, they don’t haul dirt in and level a lot off”. Mr.
Gainey said whenever they start looking at houses that we’re tearing down
there are two things he takes into consideration- being an eyesore and being
a hazard. Mayor Hines said, “With all that being said, but with the house on
Chestnut Street that you took down, it is leveled off. You’re not doing all of
them like that”. Mr. Gainey said, “Whenever they took that one down, the
7
way it was built and the footers and stuff, they had a hole there, so they
brought dirt in and leveled it off”. He said if they have a house that has a
big hole, then they will bring dirt in and level it off. Mayor Hines told Mr.
Gainey how he did the one on Chestnut Street is how all of them should be
done. Councilwoman Baccus said, “I’m not talking about bringing in a lot
of dirt, I’m saying get the tires up, the limbs up, the debris up”. She said if
we’re sending some guy that we paid $7,950 last year to clean up the lots
then when they leave there shouldn’t be tires left, there shouldn’t be sticks
and paper left, tons of cans and trash, it doesn’t look good. Mr. Gainey said
we don’t tear a house down and then send the contractor out there to clean
the lot up. He only goes out there if a lot looks really bad and I tell him to
go out there. Mr. Gainey said Mike has only been doing this a couple of
months and before him it was Bleep’s Lawn Care. He said they haven’t
cleaned every one of them, and they can, but you’re talking about another
$1,000 per lot. Councilwoman Reed said, “What I call cleaning up like on
Tallulah Street the house down there is so much debris with tree limbs”. She
said you really don’t have so much trash, but it still looks bad because it’s
got to be cleaned off. Councilwoman Reed said she understand what its
going to cost to clean it, not just picking up the trash. Councilwoman
Baccus said, “I’m concerned with the trash”. Councilwoman Reed said she
is looking at how smooth, even and clear Chestnut Street is, and she is going
to try to see if we can’t get that done for Tallulah Street or some of the other
lots. Mr. Gainey said whenever you’re talking about clearing a lot of tires, I
don’t know what we’ll do with the tires because can’t take them to the
landfill. Mayor Hines said, “Mr. Garland said one time on Council there
was something they had once a year where you put your tires out and they
would pick them up”. She asked, “Is this no longer in place”? Mr. Garland
said it was done last month. Mayor Hines asked was it advertised because
she didn’t hear or know anything about it. Mr. Garland said the County does
this now. He said we do the cleanup on the Square instead of that. Mr.
Gainey said, “Getting back to Chestnut Street, they hauled in two loads of
dirt at the request of the family. He said the family called and asked them to
bring the dirt in and level it off since they were tearing the house down. Mr.
Gainey said they paid for them to do this. Councilwoman Baccus said she
thinks Council needs to revisit the cleaning of the lots and make it clear to
Alex what they expect the lots to look like when they are done. Mr. Gainey
said, “We can do it, but $70,000 isn’t going to do it”. Mr. Gainey said if
we’re going to tear down 10 houses and clean 10 lots, then $70,000 will do
it, but if we’re going to try and clean the City of Darlington up and tear
houses down that are a potential hazard, then we’ve got to figure out exactly
8
what they need to do. Councilman Segars said they just have to reduce the
number of houses we can tear down and level them off like she’s talking
about. Councilwoman Baccus said, “I didn’t say bring in dirt, I’m not
saying none of that; all I’m asking is for you to pick up the trash”. Mr.
Garland said it’s a matter of a difference of opinion over esthetics over how
a lot should look. Councilwoman Baccus said, “That’s why Council should
discuss it and put down the ground rules of how we want it to look once it’s
done”. Mayor Hines said they will discuss this at a later date.
Mr. Garland said he wanted to thank Sheila in the Codes Department for all
of the work she’s done with FEMA related to Hurricane Florence. Mr.
Garland said she was able to streamline everything and get it done during
her normal work hours. He said she’s an invaluable resource to have there.
Mr. Garland went over the Department 500-Legislative Department,
Department 510-Municipal Court, Department 520-Elections, Department
530-Legal, Department 550-Community Promotions & Department 560 -
Accommodations Tax. There were no significant changes in these
departments.
Mr. Garland said he wants to meet again a week from today (May 16, 2019
at 6:00 PM)
Upon motion of Council woman Segars, seconded by Council woman Reed,
the meeting adjourned at 7:45 PM.
Mayor
ATTEST:
Clerk & Treasurer
Source: City of Darlington website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.