052819 BUDGET WORK SESSION
City of Darlington · Darlington County · meeting of May 6, 2020 · Budget documents
Open the original document More from City of Darlington
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
CITY OF DARLINGTON
BUDGET WORK SESSION
TUESDAY MAY 28, 2019 AT 6:00 PM
The City of Darlington held a Budget Work Session in the Old Council
Chambers on Tuesday, May 28, 2019 at 6:00 PM. Present at the meeting:
Mayor Gloria C. Hines, City Manager Howard Garland; Council Members:
Mayor Pro-Tem Carolyn Bruce, John Segars, Elaine Reed, John Milling,
Sheila Baccus and Bryant Gardner. Others in attendance included: City
Attorney Kevin Etheridge, Police Chief Kelvin Washington.
Mayor Hines called the meeting to order at 6:07 PM.
MR GARLAND
Mr. Garland said he got news of an RIA Grant Award for the lift stations.
Mr. Garland said this is the RIA Grant and this is the match for the EDA
Grant for the four lift stations. Part of the match is $268,130. Mr. Garland
said they are waiting on word in the next week or two from EDA. Mayor
Hines said, “This is not what Pee Dee COG did, this is what Ms. Lathan
did”.
WATER & SEWER BUDGET – MR. KINSAUL
Mr. Kinsaul went over his schedule of revenues for the water & sewer
department noting any significant changes. He said the biggest change is
line item 4615. Mr. Garland added $1,500,000 for the EDA/RIA grants with
the assumption we’ll get them. Mr. Kinsaul said also in the revenues there
will be a $60,000 increase from the 3% rate increase in the budget. He said
that’s the basic changes for the revenue side. He went over each of his 912
(Water Department) budget line items. Mr. Kinsaul went over 914C budget.
He said there’s an increase in his sewer line repair line item. Mr. Garland
said we had so many sewer line collapses but we’re going to get reimbursed
from Hurricane Florence for sewer line repair that was done on S. Main
Street. He said it should be somewhere around $75,000. Mr. Kinsaul said in
capital outlay, they have a vehicle purchase of $30,000. Councilwoman
Baccus asked, “What vehicle are they purchasing”? Mr. Kinsaul said his
plan is to buy a truck, but they haven’t purchased it yet. Mr. Kinsaul said
Franklin will probably get the new truck because the one he’s driving is a
2010. Councilwoman asked what will happen to Frankie’s old truck? Mr.
Kinsaul said they will probably pass it down. Mr. Garland said sometimes
2
they transfer old vehicles to the Street Department or the Recreation
Department. Councilwoman Elaine Reed said, “I don’t know what that van
was that we rode to Sumter in”. Mr. Garland told Council if they want to get
a van, he’ll get some quotes on one. Mayor Hines asked Mr. Kinsaul if we
ever did a drainage study? Mr. Kinsaul said, “Not complete, but they’ve
done part here and part there”. Mayor Hines asked if they have the maps on
it? Mr. Garland said, “We’ve done smoke tests on different parts of the
line”. Councilwoman Reed asked if that is considered drainage with the
smoke or whatever we’re talking about”? Mr. Garland said, “Are we talking
storm or drainage”? Mayor Hines said, “The drains going in pipes and
checking them out to see, you know”. Mr. Garland said, “We did a storm
drainage study in 2011. Councilman Gardner said, “Just so I’m clear on
what ya’ll asking about; you talking about mapping out our storm water
system”? Mayor Hines said, “Yes, it needs to be mapped out because with
the storm water project, they hit a whole lot of lines that were not mapped
out. They didn’t know where they were, so it cost the City an extra amount
of money, so where is that showing on here”? Mr. Kinsaul said it shows in
expenses in 912-227 (machines & equipment) expense. Mr. Garland said it
also shows up in 914-278C. Councilwoman Bruce said, “So the work that
they’re doing now on the new storm water system in Southwest Darlington,
you say they ran into a lot of busted pipes”? Councilwoman Bruce asked,
“There’s no new map that mapped out this stuff since they did the new
project”? Mr. Kinsaul said, “The one line they hit three times, they said
there use to be a junk yard down there”. Councilwoman Bruce said, “Are
there records of that knowing now if we have to go back……Mr. Kinsaul
started talking and said, “Everybody’s got it, but nobody”….Councilwoman
Bruce said in the past, there was nothing mapped out; now that we did this
new project, do we have something mapped out going forward”? Mr.
Kinsaul said, “All that would be is mapping on that new project is what
they’re doing”. Councilwoman Reed asked, “The City Water Department
because the problems we encountered was because we didn’t have an outline
of where the other lines were. Are we now drawing an outline of all of our
lines (Water & Sewer)”? Mr. Kinsaul said, we’ve got the majority of lines.
Councilwoman Reed asked, “Are you identifying those things now, so we
won’t have to question it if anybody else come with a project we’ll know
what lines and where they are”? Mr. Garland said Mr. Milling put this
question before Council sometime in the past. He asked about a GIS System
and we got a quote on this. Mr. Garland said Ms. Lathan handed him copies
of a quote for a GIS System with license fee for users. Councilman Gardner
said, “We would purchase this and then we would have to get someone to go
3
out and smoke test our lines to identify where they are”? Mr. Kinsaul said
you do a smoke test to see if there’s a cross connection or a leak.
Councilman Gardner said, “Isn’t there some organization we can use from
the State that we can hire to come in and help us with the mapping and
they’ll do it in chunks”? Mr. Kinsaul said, “Rural Water Association does
some of this and the Ervin Group does some as a contractor”. Councilman
Gardner said he asked about this previously and he thinks he was told we
should go through this in chunks and allocate $15,000 per year and
systematically go across the City and map out our infrastructure instead of
doing it one time. Mayor Hines asked if we can get somebody from
Clemson or some place to come in and do that for us”? Mr. Garland said, “I
don’t know if Clemson does something like that”. Mr. Garland said, “I’m
sure we can find someone to do that. It’s something you’d have to bid out,
but I think what we’re looking at here is a software system for that”. He
said what we would do is take the input that we have from Davis & Brown
and Hanna Engineering and then put that in there, then we’d see what we
have filled in and then we would put that out to have work to be done. Mr.
Gardner asked if this has a yearly fee that goes along with it? Ms. Lathan
said the $10,000 includes the licensing. Ms. Lathan said, “At one of the
budget meetings last year, Councilman Milling asked her to come up with a
cost estimate”. Ms. Lathan said, “What would be required would be a
computer with software, GIS software license (up to 3 users), a 44” plotter
(with power filter). She said the scanner is very critical. She said when the
construction company is finished installing any infrastructure, they are
required per their contract to provide to the City “as built drawings”. The
scanner will be able to take the blue prints as built, scan it and digitize it so
that the City can start building a digital database of all their underground
lines. Ms. Lathan said she thinks Darlington county has this GIS software,
but she didn’t have time to touch base with them, but she did benchmark
Sumter County and what they’re using. She said county-wide is costing
them about $27,000. Ms. Lathan said they allow different users from
different counties to tie in to that and get their license, so it’s less expensive.
She said she is almost 100% confident that Darlington County has a GIS and
we should be able to get with them to see if we can just pick up a license,
which will be approximately $3,000 - $4,000. Councilman Gardner asked,
“Is it an annual fee of $10,000 or $3,000 that you just said”? Ms. Lathan
said it’s going to be an annual fee and she put $10,000 which is a good
figure to use for budgeting. She said we can then get with Darlington
County and see if there’s some way we can leverage off of that. Councilman
Gardner asked about the scanner and who would run the GIS software. He
4
said, “Wouldn’t that be another employee”? Ms. Lathan said, “Yes, more
than likely”. Councilwoman Reed said we need this system because of the
problems we’re encountering now. She said along with this system we’re
going to need somebody that knows how to do all of that. Councilwoman
Reed said, “With $22,840 for the system, we’ve got to think of personnel”.
Mr. Garland said we can add another $40,000 to that for the person that’s
going to be doing the job. Councilman Gardner said it’s got to be more than
that. Mr. Garland said it could be more. Councilman Segars said, “We
would be better served if we contracted that out to somebody like Ervin
Engineering who has the software and have the people that’s smart enough
to use it, run it, and digitize it”. Mr. Garland said, “Unlike the general fund,
we have some cushion in the water & sewer fund, so if they want to do this
and do it inhouse, we could do it”. Mayor Hines asked Mr. Garland if he
could talk to Ervin Engineering. Councilman Gardner said, “I completely
agree on this and would love to do it, but I think this is a little like putting
the cart before the horse”. He said, “We could take the $22,000 and study
our infrastructure and find out where all of our pipes are and use this fund
for a couple of years to map everything and once we have a good map of
everything, then we can figure out how to utilize it best”. Councilman
Gardner said, “But to purchase a system that’s going to cost us ten grand a
year potentially, I’m going to say seventy-five grand because there’s going
to be retirement and all that stuff, plus the software licensing fees”. He said,
“You’re spending $50,000 that we can spend in getting a full comprehensive
storm water plan and getting a full understanding of where all of our pipes
are”. Mr. Garland told Council he doesn’t mean to be rude, but we have an
executive session and other departments to cover. Council agreed they need
to revisit this because this needs to be discussed. Councilwoman Reed said,
“Even if we contracted somebody else, we would be paying about this
amount of money, right”? Councilman Gardner said, “You’re right, but we
would have $75,000 a year plus paying somebody to go out and map the
system”. Councilwoman Baccus said, “Not if it’s done in house”.
Councilman Gardner said, “But we don’t have the person in house that could
do the engineering”. Mr. Garland said, “We can rejigger the budget with
some work to do that; it’s just that it would have to be done either next year
or we could go ahead and have first and second readings on this and then we
can amend the budget to include it, but it will have to be amended later on”.
Councilman Gardner said, “You’re cutting us off from being able to discuss
the issue and then trying to add it to the budget”. Mr. Garland said, “I’m
just giving you your choices, that’s all”. Councilwoman Baccus said her
question concerning all of the water leaks in the City. She said, “Explain to
5
me how much money we’ve lost as far as the water leaks we’ve had in the
City because of the time frame it takes to fix the water leaks”?
Councilwoman Baccus said there was a water leak on Jordan Street and she
let Mr. Kinsaul know and she told Howard, but in three days the County
fixed the water leak. She said they have water leaks on Farm Street and fifty
other places and it’s two or three months before a water leak gets fixed.
Councilwoman Baccus asked how they prioritize fixing these water leaks.
Mr. Kinsaul said, “They try to fix the one that’s the worst -the larger lines,
where it’s at and what it’s doing. Mr. Kinsaul said it looks like a lot of
water, but it’s not. He said they had six on Carol Drive at one time. He said
it takes a week to get a locate unless you do an emergency, but you can’t do
them all on “emergency” because 811 is going to scream that you’re playing
with the system. Mr. Kinsaul said that’s probably what the County did that
day; they probably did an “emergency” locate. Mr. Kinsaul said the last
time he talked to the County they had seventy-five leaks in one day.
Councilwoman Baccus said, “Let me understand this. We pay to have this
water clean to run through our lines for the citizens, right”? She said we pay
to have this water treated to come through our lines, so then we’re going to
let it run three months on the ground? Mr. Kinsaul said most of them don’t
go three months. He said, “When they have to work two months on a sewer,
a lot of leaks backed up because we had the whole crew working on the
sewer”. Councilwoman Bruce said, “The bottom line is that there is a
problem and it was a problem long before many of them got on Council”.
Councilwoman Bruce said, I am sure these discussions are the same
discussions from twenty years ago. At some point the discussions have got
to stop and we’ve got to make a decision on what we’re going to do to fix
it”. She said, “We can look at this (she told Ms. Lathan she did an excellent
job explaining it) the comparison between what would be more feasible
because it needs to happen; how it happens is the question”. Mr. Kinsaul
said, “That don’t fix one water leak”. Councilwoman Bruce said, “It doesn’t
fix a water leak, but it gives them something to look at to see where the
problems are”. Mr. Kinsaul said until you dig it up, you don’t know it’s
there. Councilwoman Reed said, “But I thought this system help identify”.
Mr. Kinsaul said, “Oh no, you’ve got to tell that system where that water
line is at”. Councilman Gardner said, “First off this isn’t for water lines,
we’re talking about doing this for storm water. He said, “But your sewer we
can put it all in this system per se”. Councilwoman Reed asked about the
scanner…. Councilwoman Baccus said, “Didn’t Mr. Gardner table this and
we went on to something else, now you’re going backwards”. She said we
tabled that conversation for later. Mayor Hines said we have something else
6
at 7:00 and we need to move on. Mr. Kinsaul said nothing changed in his
914T budget. Councilwoman Baccus asked if 912 (water distribution &
maintenance) is where the expenses for where we pay to have the water
…Mr. Kinsaul said department 912 pertains to everything related to water.
He said 914C is the sewer pipes. Councilwoman Baccus wanted to know
why the operating expenses go up. She wanted to know why it increased
from $482,000 & $536,000. Councilwoman Baccus said she is assuming the
$482,000 includes those hundreds of gallons of water we wasted on the
ground. Mr. Garland said $482,00 is the current budget year and $536,000
is the estimated expenditures for next year. Councilwoman Baccus wanted
to know why they raised the amount. Mr. Garland said because they expect
the expenses to go up some. Councilwoman Baccus asked Mr. Garland if
that was where they are seeing the expenses for the water leaks. Mr. Kinsaul
said that would be anything pertaining to water. Mayor Hines asked, “Mr.
Kinsaul is there any way to tell how much it costs extra when all of these
things happen, the water leaks, etc.”? Mr. Kinsaul said, “Not to calculate
how much water, because nothing is measured”. Mr. Garland said, “I guess
the question would be how much water do we use a day, and then what is
used in a house a day multiplied by the number of customers to come up
with a number. Councilwoman Baccus said, “At the end of the day, the
point is, it shouldn’t take two months to fix a water line”. Mayor Hines
asked, “Are we understaffed the reason why it took so long”? Mr. Kinsaul
said, “They had the Lee Street cave-in and the S. Main Street cave-in, and
the entire crew worked there for a couple of months”. Mr. Kinsaul said,
“So, yes, they are understaffed”.
MS. LATHAN
Ms. Lathan said some of the residents in the neighborhood that the Joe Louis
pump station supports are concerned and wanted to have full assurance that
there’s maintenance dollars in the City budget that would ensure that J.L.
pump station is properly maintained, and any repairs would be made until
the new pump station is put in. Mr. Kinsaul said it’s been maintained and
one of the workers checks it every day. Ms. Lathan said, “So the short
answer is yes there’s money in the maintenance budget for repairs” and Mr.
Kinsaul said, “Yes”.
MR. GARLAND
Mr. Garland went over the consumer price index figures which is 2.44% so
if council wanted to raise millage they could by this amount. Mr. Garland
said some councilmembers have been upset that we’re not paving streets so
7
he’s going to give them this option – If they want to raise millage this year,
they can because we have 2.44% consumer price index increase. He said
our current millage is 131.4125; the millage increase is 3.2; a mill in the city
of Darlington is worth $17,929 so if you wanted to raise this just for paving
the streets, you could raise 3.2 mils and it would bring in about $57,370.
The new millage would 134.6125 if council chooses to do the increase. Mr.
Garland asked Council if they want to consider doing this or want him to
forget it and move on? Mr. Garland said he would also have to update our
City street listing because DOT has added another street therefore we have
43 streets now. Mr. Garland said Keith Evans did some work on Columbian
Street without getting an encroachment permit, so DOT gave us that street
saying he didn’t follow proper procedure. Mr. Garland said the first block of
Columbian Street between E. Hampton and E. Broad Street, we own now,
because of that. Councilwoman Baccus asked, “So, what did he do to it”?
Mr. Garland said he put in seven apartments. Councilwoman Baccus said”
Didn’t he have to get a permit”? Mr. Garland said he got a permit from the
City to put in the buildings, but he went ahead and built too close to the
road. Councilwoman Baccus asked who the inspector was at that time and
Mr. Garland was said he thinks it was Henry Chapman. Mayor Hines said,
“Didn’t Mr. Chapman come in on the end of that, and it had already started
or something”? Mr. Garland said Mr. Chapman was building inspector at
that time. Mr. Garland went over the total property tax collection total
which includes the property taxes. local option sales tax, homestead
exemption, & manufacture’s exemption. Mr. Garland said he broke this
down because a few years ago councilmembers didn’t understand how the
property taxes were broken out, you thought that the property tax was the
first line in our revenues. Mr. Garland said councilmembers also asked for a
sanitation service survey and he called around to several difference
towns/cities in our area, so he provided them with his findings. Councilman
Gardner asked, “Wasn’t that $1.00 for the roads”? Mr. Garland said, “No,
the $1.00 is used just for the sanitation”. He said we just started getting
where we have a reserve fund for the street & sanitation, but we set aside
approximately $43,000 of that for the cutter and camera. Mr. Garland said
another idea for the future. He said we currently have inhouse garbage
collection, but we could farm that out and let somebody do our residential
garbage service pickup. He said out of the seven towns/cities that he got
sanitation rates on, three of them have companies that do their residential
sanitation pickup. Mr. Garland told Council if they are serious about doing
this they can bid it out and look at it. He said we can also bid out the
commercial garbage pickup which is currently handled by Waste
8
Management. Mayor Hines said, “We just got that new truck; we don’t need
to bid it out just yet, we’ve got to get the use out that new garbage truck we
brought”. Mr. Garland said you’d be surprised how quick a truck breaks
down. Mr. Garland said the reason he is bringing this up is that the conveyer
belt at the County broke down again so the last three weeks we’ve had to
drive to Bishopville everyday (Monday, Tuesday & Thursday). On Friday
they take recyclables to Sonoco. He said it’s a concern because if the
County decides not to do this anymore, we would have to drive to
Bishopville every day. Mr. Garland told Council it’s just for consideration.
Mr. Garland continued to go over the schedule of revenues, summary of
expenses for the General Fund (Personnel) which gives a breakdown per
department. Mr. Garland called council’s attention to personnel cost for the
police department which is over $2 million. He said that’s the cost of doing
business when you have 31 employees in one department. He said the
police department is our largest department. Mr. Garland went over the
operating expenses for each department; Capital Outlay for each department
and the general fund recap. Mayor Hines said, “The loft apartments, the 30-
year phase one, the second year-18years how much time d we have on each
one and where is it located in the line item”? Mr. Garland said, “For phase
1, you’re not going to have a line item for that until 2037. Phase 2 is line
item 4260. Mr. Garland said they haven’t made a payment in three years.
Councilman Gardner said, “Hold on, downtown loft apartments haven’t
made a payment in three years”? Mr. Garland said, “Let me explain that.
They based that on the number of apartments that they rent, and it’s written
into the agreement that was signed in 2007 or 2008 that if they rent the
apartments full, we’ll get some money back, if they don’t we don’t get
anything”. Mayor Hines said, “I didn’t vote for it ya’ll, to let ya’ll know”.
Mr. Garland said out of 10 years, they have probably paid us three years.
Mayor Hines said, “With all of the mildew and with all of the mold that’s in
those buildings when they finish with them, they revert back to us, right”?
Mayor Hines said, “We can’t do nothing with them, they’ll be so rotten”. Mr.
Garland said, “We held payment from them for two years because they
weren’t addressing code issues”. He said we finally paid them within the last
2-3 months approximately $60,000-$62,000 for revenue from the retail rents
and money for the water bill ($10,800 a year). Mr. Garland said since they
have not been good corporate citizen s, they’ve sent them letters saying they
are breaking the City’s building code and they’ve been given a certain amount
of time to fix the deficiencies in the apartments and the retail spaces. He said
if the y don’t do that, then we’ll take them to court. Councilman Gardner
asked, “What if it’s not done”? Mr. Garland said, “Then we’ll start fin ing
9
them”. Councilman Gardner asked, “Can we take them over, can we condemn
it”. Mr. Garland said, “No, we don’t want to take them over, then we’ll be
responsible for fixing them”. Councilwoman Bruce asked, “when was the last
time we communicated with them on this”? Mr. Garland said within the last
six weeks we have sent them letters. Mr. Garland said he has talked with
some of the regional managers and they said in March and in April that
somebody was coming down to look. He said he has called the te nants and
the lady at the Chamber and she said someone showed up but all they did was
put Clorox on the wall to wipe some of the mold away. Mayor Hines asked
if we were having this problem before the previous owner passed away and
Mr. Garland said, “No”. Mayor Hines said, “When we did this long time ago,
I spoke out against it, Annette Thomas and myself. We didn’t vote for it
because we felt it was a bad situation and it has turned into something really
bad now and it never should have been done. Those buildings were
dilapidated then; I mean it turned out to be a pretty good thing, but now we’re
suffering for it and after we get money from the five or six retail spaces and
we’re having problems now and we’ve got so many more years to deal with
this, that’s just a loss”. Mr. Garland said, “We asked several years ago, I think
starting in 2012, to put this as a note in the audit because if I’m alive I would
come to Council in 2037 and say, “Hey these things are due you now, but
there’s a reversion clause in there that those buildings go back to the City”.
Councilwoman Reed said, “We must have an avenue of some kind of way to
revisit the contract because they are already out of compliance on some
things”. Mr. Garland said, “We are doing what we can based on the law”.
5 Minute Break
Councilwoman Baccus made a motion to go into Executive Session at 7:12
PM to discuss the Municipal Court Judge. Darlington City Council will
not vote after executive session. Councilman Gardner seconded the
motion.
Councilwoman Reed made a motion, seconded by Councilwoman Baccus
to go out of Executive Session at 7:35 PM.
Mayor Hines said there was a discussion in executive session, but there will
not be a vote tonight.
Upon motion of Councilman Gardner, seconded by Council woman, the
meeting adjourned at 7:36 PM.
10
Mayor
ATTEST:
Clerk & Treasurer
Source: City of Darlington website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.